06.08.2018 Views

[James_H._Harlow]_Electric_Power_Transformer_Engin(BookSee.org)

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

FIGURE 3.8.30 DC content of the differential current for Case 3.<br />

TABLE 3.8.3 Inrush Detection Methods Performance during Inrush Conditions<br />

Method Case 1 Case 2 Case 3<br />

<br />

<br />

Low even-harmonic Second-harmonic setting<br />

content<br />

6%<br />

8%<br />

Second- and fourthharmonic<br />

blocking<br />

All-harmonic restraint<br />

Low-current detection<br />

Even-harmonic restraint<br />

DC-ratio blocking<br />

4. An improved approach for transformer protection that combines harmonic-restraint and -blocking<br />

methods with a waveshape-recognition technique provides added security to the independent<br />

harmonic-restraint element without sacrificing dependability. This new method uses even harmonics<br />

for restraint, plus dc component and fifth harmonic for blocking.<br />

5. Using even-harmonic restraint ensures security for inrush currents with low second-harmonic<br />

content and maintains dependability for internal faults with CT saturation. The use of fifthharmonic<br />

blocking guarantees an invariant relay response to overexcitation. Using dc-offset blocking<br />

ensures security for inrush conditions with very low total harmonic distortion.<br />

References<br />

Percentage<br />

100<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

Cycles<br />

<br />

High third-harmonic<br />

content<br />

<br />

Low-current interval = 1 / 4<br />

cycle<br />

<br />

Low even-harmonic<br />

content<br />

<br />

DC ratio = zero<br />

Note: = Correct operation; = Misoperation.<br />

<br />

Even-harmonic content<br />

<br />

Low-current interval > 1 / 4<br />

cycle<br />

<br />

Even-harmonic content<br />

<br />

DC ratio > 0.1 after 1 cycle<br />

<br />

Second-harmonic setting<br />

<br />

Harmonic content<br />

<br />

Low-current interval < 1 / 4<br />

cycle<br />

<br />

Even-harmonic content<br />

<br />

DC ratio = zero<br />

1. Klingshirn, E.A., Moore, H.R., and Wentz, E.C., Detection of faults in power transformers, AIEE<br />

Trans., 76, 87–95, 1957.<br />

2. Madill, J.T., Typical transformer faults and gas detector relay protection, AIEE Trans., 66,<br />

1052–1060, 1947.<br />

3. Bean, R.L. and Cole, H.L., A sudden gas pressure relay for transformer protection, AIEE Trans.,<br />

72, 480–483, 1953.<br />

4. Monseth, I.T. and Robinson, P.H., Relay Systems: Theory and Applications, McGraw Hill, New York,<br />

1935.<br />

5. Sleeper, H.P., Ratio differential relay protection, <strong>Electric</strong>al World, 827831, October 1927.<br />

6. Cordray, R.E., Percentage differential transformer protection, <strong>Electric</strong>al Eng., 50, 361–363, 1931.<br />

7. Cordray, R.E., Preventing false operation of differential relays, <strong>Electric</strong>al World, 160–161, July 25,<br />

1931.<br />

8. Harder, E.L. and Marter, W.E., Principles and practices of relaying in the United States, AIEE Trans.,<br />

67, 1005–1023, 1948.<br />

9. Kennedy, L.F., and Hayward, C.D., Harmonic-current-restrained relays for differential protection,<br />

AIEE Trans., 57, 262–266, 1938.<br />

10. Hayward, C.D., Harmonic-current-restrained relays for transformer differential protection, AIEE<br />

Trans., 60, 377–382, 1941.<br />

11. Mathews, C.A., An improved transformer differential relay, AIEE Trans., 73, 645–650, 1954.<br />

12. Sharp, R.L. and Glassburn, W.E., A transformer differential relay with second-harmonic restraint,<br />

AIEE Trans., 77, 913–918, 1958.<br />

13. Einval, C.H. and Linders, J.R., A three-phase differential relay for transformer protection, IEEE<br />

Trans., PAS-94, 1971–1980, 1975.<br />

14. Dmitrenko, A.M., Semiconductor pulse-duration differential restraint relay, Izv. Vysshikh Uchebnykh<br />

Zavedenii, Elektromekhanika, No. 3, 335–339, March 1970 (in Russian).<br />

15. Atabekov, G.I., The Relay Protection of High Voltage Networks, Pergamon Press, London, 1960.<br />

16. Rockefeller, G.D., Fault protection with a digital computer, IEEE Trans., PAS-98, 438464, 1969.<br />

17. Wilkinson, S.B., <strong>Transformer</strong> Differential Relay, U.S. Patent 5,627,712, May 6, 1997.<br />

18. Hayward, C.D., Prolonged inrush currents with parallel transformers affect differential relaying,<br />

AIEE Trans., 60, 10961101, 1941.<br />

19. Blume, L.F., Camilli, G., Farnham, S.B., and Peterson, H.A., <strong>Transformer</strong> magnetizing inrush<br />

currents and influence on system operation, AIEE Trans., 63, 366375, 1944.<br />

20. Specht, T.R., <strong>Transformer</strong> magnetizing inrush current, AIEE Trans., 70, 323328, 1951.<br />

21. AIEE Committee Report, Report on transformer magnetizing current and its effect on relaying<br />

and air switch operation, AIEE Trans., 70, 17331740, 1951.<br />

22. Sonnemann, W.K., Wagner, C.L., and Rockefeller, G.D., Magnetizing inrush phenomena in transformer<br />

banks, AIEE Trans., 77, 884892, 1958.<br />

23. Berdy, J., Kaufman, W., and Winick, K., A Dissertation on <strong>Power</strong> <strong>Transformer</strong> Excitation and<br />

Inrush Characteristics, presented at Symposium on <strong>Transformer</strong> Excitation and Inrush Characteristics<br />

and Their Relationship to <strong>Transformer</strong> Protective Relaying, Houston, TX, 1976.<br />

24. Zocholl, S.E., Guzmán, A., and Hou, D., <strong>Transformer</strong> Modeling as Applied to Differential Protection,<br />

presented at 22nd Annual Western Protective Relay Conference, Spokane, WA, 1995.<br />

25. Cooper <strong>Power</strong> Systems, <strong>Electric</strong> <strong>Power</strong> System Harmonics: Design Guide, Cooper <strong>Power</strong> Systems,<br />

Bulletin 87011, Franksville, WI, 1990.<br />

26. Waldron, J.E. and Zocholl, S.E., Design Considerations for a New Solid-State <strong>Transformer</strong> Differential<br />

Relay with Harmonic Restraint, presented at Fifth Annual Western Protective Relay Conference,<br />

Sacramento, CA, 1978.<br />

27. Marshall, D.E. and Langguth, P.O., Current transformer excitation under transient conditions,<br />

AIEE Trans., 48, 14641474, 1929.<br />

28. Wentz, E.C. and Sonnemann, W.K., Current transformers and relays for high-speed differential<br />

protection with particular reference to offset transient currents, AIEE Trans., 59, 481488, 1940.<br />

© 2004 by CRC Press LLC<br />

© 2004 by CRC Press LLC

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!