36_ENG
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
JUNE 12, 2018 ISSUE No. <strong>36</strong> (1168)<br />
Tel.: +38(044) 303-96-19,<br />
fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
е-mail: time@day.kiev.ua;<br />
http://www.day.kiev.ua<br />
Artist Andrii<br />
Yermolenko<br />
drew a series<br />
of placards on<br />
the 2018 FIFA<br />
World Cup<br />
in Russia and<br />
explained why<br />
it must be<br />
boycotted<br />
Continued on page 6<br />
“IN ORDER TO BRING<br />
THE WORLD TO ITS SENSES…”
2<br />
No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018<br />
DAY AFTER DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Volodymyr KOSTYRIN<br />
Photos by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
This is only the first part of the<br />
project, which has already<br />
found a broad response among<br />
viewers, particularly on<br />
YouTube. Although the subject<br />
the author broaches is rather<br />
complicated, the audience reacted<br />
approvingly. The film’s author<br />
himself, who was born and raised in<br />
Luhansk, stayed behind in his native<br />
city until September 2, 2014, and<br />
saw the dramatic events of Russian<br />
aggression against Ukraine. Later<br />
on, Valentyn Torba wrote a book, I, an<br />
Eyewitness. Notes from the Occupied<br />
Luhansk, on the basis of his reminiscences<br />
and diary. The film is sort of<br />
the author’s video reproduction of<br />
his reflections on those events.<br />
“My book, published by the newspaper<br />
Den, must only be viewed in the<br />
reference frame of two other books in<br />
the ‘Contemporary History for Dummies’<br />
series,” Den’s journalist Valentyn<br />
TORBA says. “A prolog of<br />
sorts to it is Ivan Kapsamun’s book<br />
‘The Trap,’ or A Case without a Statute<br />
The harsh reality of war<br />
Last week Den’s journalist Valentyn Torba<br />
presented his film Luhansk:<br />
Occupation at the Kyiv House of Cinema<br />
Indeed, it is impossible to find<br />
the causes and effects of the current<br />
war without sinking into history –<br />
both the domestic history and the<br />
history of our country’s relationships<br />
with the neighbor that eventually became<br />
the enemy.<br />
“The main conclusion for me is<br />
that this film has a cause-and-effect<br />
relation,” says Ivan KAPSAMUN,<br />
controlled the city. Let me tell you<br />
how he began cooperating with Den.<br />
As early as during the so-called ‘Russian<br />
spring’ in the spring and summer<br />
of 2014, Valentyn’s biting and meaningful<br />
posts and blogs in Facebook,<br />
where he described what was going on<br />
in his city and region, drew the attention<br />
of Den’s editor-in-chief Larysa<br />
IVSHYNA who invited him to contribute<br />
to our newspaper. He agreed,<br />
sk: Occupation is a very serious work.<br />
Valentyn in fact adapted to the screen<br />
what Den had been writing about for<br />
many years. I wish my colleague success<br />
and want as many people as possible<br />
to watch it because, before occupying<br />
our territories, the Kremlin<br />
‘occupied’ people’s brains. To ward<br />
this off, one must know contemporary<br />
history on the basis of the Den’s Library<br />
and the presented film.”<br />
300 years ago and even earlier. The<br />
war is permanent, and it did not begin<br />
in 2014. We were being exterminated<br />
and manipulated in 1933 and well before<br />
that. And, instead of forming<br />
state institutions, the authorities<br />
palmed off certain individuals upon<br />
us, who were just ruining these institutions,<br />
ruining the groundwork<br />
for the restoration of our statehood.<br />
And why are governmental officials<br />
indifferent? Let me say an objectionable<br />
thing: I am convinced for some<br />
reason that the political elite seems to<br />
be feeling good even without Luhansk,<br />
Donetsk, and Crimea.”<br />
“It was about the Ukraine-Russia<br />
border,” civic activist, journalist,<br />
and political scientist Oleksii PODOL-<br />
SKY said after watching the film.<br />
“The first negotiations on this matter,<br />
in which I took part, began in 1995.<br />
Before that, we and Russia had never<br />
negotiated the border question. I was<br />
a diplomat at the time and first came<br />
to Luhansk, when we were trying to<br />
persuade the leadership to follow the<br />
Estonian way. I took part in the<br />
closed-door negotiations about the<br />
Black Sea Fleet, as well as in the talks<br />
about gas with participation of<br />
AT THE SCREENING OF THE FILM LUHANSK: OCCUPATION, THE FUTURE OFFICERS WERE DEEPLY MOVED NOT ONLY BY THE FOOTAGE AND CONTACTS WITH GUESTS, BUT ALSO BY BEING GIVEN THE<br />
BOOK “THE TRAP,” OR A CASE WITHOUT A STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS, A TEXTBOOK ON UKRAINE’S TRUE CONTEMPORARY HISTORY<br />
of Limitations which tells the prehistory<br />
of the political ‘trap’ into<br />
which this country fell. My film is sort<br />
of a video illustration to the trilogy<br />
Den published as far back as 2015.”<br />
Torba said after the screening:<br />
“I’ve brought some books and would<br />
like to gift them to the military present<br />
here. Here is the book ‘The Trap,’<br />
or A Case without a Statute of Limitations<br />
by Ivan Kapsamun, editor of<br />
Den’s politics section. Note the phrase<br />
‘without a statute of limitations.’<br />
Our current problem is that we think<br />
in the terms that call us for artificial<br />
reconciliation. We think: well, OK,<br />
let’s forgive, forget, make friends,<br />
hug, and things will be all right. Do<br />
you remember, by the way, the fake<br />
photograph in the internet about how<br />
the Ukrainian-Russian border must<br />
look like? It shows people drinking,<br />
eating, etc., at the table. The killing<br />
of us begins with this illusory reconciliation.<br />
Nobody wants to ‘fraternize’<br />
with us. They want to exterminate<br />
us, Ukrainians, wipe off our<br />
memory, and turn us into an eternal<br />
second-rate satellite. The aggressor is<br />
taking advantage of our weaknesses to<br />
this end. Therefore, we must not forget<br />
both the foreign and the domestic<br />
enemy.”<br />
editor of Den’s politics section. “This<br />
is the most important point. For what<br />
we have in the information space today<br />
is just a picture, sometimes a<br />
conclusion, with no explanation of<br />
what caused one problem or another.<br />
And many fall for this. This film<br />
practically shows the contemporary<br />
history of Ukraine, including the way<br />
the occupation of the Luhansk region<br />
was prepared and finally carried out.<br />
The film also recalls the Holodomor<br />
period and emphasizes that our country<br />
found itself in a very difficult situation<br />
in the early 1990s because it<br />
had a postcolonial and post-genocidal<br />
society. Such difficult times require<br />
very strong efforts to build the state.<br />
But, we saw in the film that, instead<br />
of building state institutions, the<br />
leadership of this country formed a<br />
clannish oligarchic system, in which<br />
we are in fact still living. The revolutions<br />
we had can hardly be called<br />
revolutions. Society was doing very<br />
much to break this system but, unfortunately,<br />
failed to do so. For society<br />
itself is sick and was unable to organize<br />
– neither after the first nor after<br />
the second Maidan.”<br />
Kapsamun also added: “Valentyn<br />
stayed in Luhansk to the last moment,<br />
when Russian troops in fact<br />
and then, on the chief editor’s instructions,<br />
I came into direct contact,<br />
as I edited many of his texts. We<br />
thus began to receive on-the-spot information<br />
and analyses of events.<br />
Later, when it became dangerous to<br />
stay on in Luhansk, Valentyn had to<br />
leave the native city. He moved to<br />
Kyiv, and the newspaper offered him<br />
a job on the staff.<br />
“In 2015 Den prepared a trilogy of<br />
books compiled by me (‘The Trap’),<br />
Torba (I, an Eyewitness), and Maria<br />
Semenchenko (Catastrophe and Triumph).<br />
The first is about why this<br />
country got into a ‘political trap’ on<br />
the example of high-profile murders of<br />
Yevhen Shcherban, Borys Derevianko,<br />
Vadym Hetman, and, as the apotheosis<br />
of the system, the attempt on the<br />
life of Oleksandr Yeliashkevych, the<br />
attack on and kidnapping of Oleksii<br />
Podolsky, and murder of Georgy<br />
Gongadze. Consequentially, the second<br />
book is about the living and dead heroes<br />
who went to war in the east and<br />
covered with their bodies the mistakes<br />
politicians had made.<br />
“To launch Den’s books, we in<br />
fact traveled all over Ukraine, doing<br />
the educational work the state is normally<br />
supposed to do. The film Luhan-<br />
“This is really a story that touches<br />
one on the raw, and I would like the<br />
people who have nothing to do personally<br />
with our Luhansk region to<br />
watch the first and the next parts of<br />
the film,” civic activist Maryna ZOLK-<br />
INA said during the film presentation.<br />
“I am often asked, because of my<br />
work, why certain decisions are not<br />
made. All I can do is give a not-soprofessional<br />
explanation of why we<br />
show this kind of reaction to this procrastination.<br />
In my view, this happens<br />
because those who must, by force of<br />
our choice, make decisions are indifferent.<br />
You, Valentyn, are not indifferent.<br />
You, as a journalist, a writer,<br />
and a person who makes no decisions,<br />
are not indifferent. So where should<br />
the central authorities draw strength<br />
to regain the temporarily occupied territories?<br />
Where is the source of the<br />
strength that will help us achieve<br />
this?”<br />
“In my opinion, our first source of<br />
strength is to be able to understand<br />
that the war will never end,” Torba answered<br />
this question. “Terrible words<br />
indeed, but we are now in the state of<br />
a permanent war. And if we try to persuade<br />
ourselves that things will be different,<br />
we will be wrong. Things won’t<br />
be different. They were not different<br />
Lazarenko and Turkmenistan. I finally<br />
saw that our leadership was the<br />
No. 1 traitor, that the agent of Russia,<br />
who was selling our state out, was<br />
the head of our state. So I, chief of the<br />
Russia department of our Foreign<br />
Ministry, deliberately joined the opposition<br />
to Kuchma. I was busy writing,<br />
running around, keeping a secret<br />
print shop, and so on. All this resulted<br />
in the Gongadze case. You should<br />
know that Gongadze and other likeminded<br />
people also participated in<br />
this. Do you remember<br />
Yeliashkevych? And Yurii Orobets?<br />
Many of them have already passed<br />
away. I am a person who took part in<br />
all of this and saw everything with my<br />
own eyes. Do you remember the Black<br />
Sea Fleet negotiations, when Crimea<br />
was being surrendered for a gas bribe?<br />
Such entities as RosUkrEnergo were<br />
a feeding trough for the families of<br />
our presidents. Torba was right to say<br />
that the war will go on. The film is<br />
about this, about how cynically<br />
Crimea and the Donbas were surrendered.”<br />
The author also plans to show the<br />
film in Sievierodonetsk, Luhansk<br />
oblast, which was lucky enough to be<br />
liberated as far back as the summer<br />
of 2014.
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
DAY AFTER DAY No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018 3<br />
By Andreas UMLAND<br />
The new German study “Die<br />
Ukraine in den Augen Deutschlands.<br />
Bilder und Wahrnehmungen<br />
eines Landes im<br />
Umbruch” (Kyiv: Buero fuer<br />
politische Kommunikation, GIZ<br />
GmbH, 2018. 111 pp.) carefully<br />
reflects a wide range of opinions<br />
held by German experts on the state<br />
of affairs in Ukraine and issues of its<br />
description, perception, understanding<br />
and misunderstanding in<br />
today’s Germany.<br />
Population and economy-wise,<br />
Germany is the most significant<br />
country in Central and Western Europe,<br />
while Ukraine, which has the<br />
largest area among exclusively European<br />
countries (some parts of<br />
Russia and Turkey lie in Europe,<br />
but most of them are in Asia), has<br />
turned into a geopolitically key<br />
state of East-Central Europe in the<br />
post-Soviet period. The Ukrainians<br />
and Germans have deep-rooted historical<br />
connections. One of such<br />
connections was the adoption of the<br />
famed Magdeburg Law by several<br />
Ukrainian cities in the 15th-19thcentury<br />
period. One of these cities,<br />
namely Kyiv, hosts a monument to<br />
the Magdeburg Law. In the post-Soviet<br />
period, Ukrainian-German cooperation<br />
in various fields of business,<br />
science, education, and culture<br />
has developed and continues to<br />
develop in a great variety of forms.<br />
In view of these and many other circumstances,<br />
it is surprising how little<br />
attention has been paid so far to<br />
the study of the relations and connections<br />
between the two major European<br />
peoples in the context of the<br />
study of European history and international<br />
relations.<br />
While the interest of Ukrainians<br />
in Germany has always been high,<br />
Germans have only recently begun<br />
to exhibit growing interest in<br />
Ukraine and information about it.<br />
In 2006, the Research Center for<br />
East European Studies at the University<br />
of Bremen began publishing<br />
a periodic electronic bulletin called<br />
Ukraine-Analysen, which has had<br />
201 issues so far. At present, two<br />
specialized German-language websites<br />
– Ukraine-Nachrichten (News<br />
about Ukraine, founded in Dresden<br />
in 2007) and Ukraine verstehen<br />
(Understanding Ukraine, launched<br />
in Berlin in 2017) – are also improving<br />
the understanding of Ukraine in<br />
Germany. The work on systematic<br />
interpretation of the history of German-Ukrainian<br />
relations is progressing<br />
as well, albeit at a slower<br />
pace. In 2010, Hamburg-based historian<br />
Frank Golczewski published<br />
a major work on German-Ukrainian<br />
relations in the interwar period<br />
(Deutsche und Ukrainer 1914-1939,<br />
Paderborn: Schoeningh, 1,058 p.).<br />
Since then, there have been several<br />
studies and papers on the presentation<br />
of Ukraine in the German media<br />
(including distortions in it), as<br />
well as Germany’s participation in<br />
the transformations in post-Soviet<br />
Ukraine.<br />
The Ukrainian program of the<br />
German Agency for International<br />
Cooperation (GIZ) offers an extremely<br />
informative and illuminating<br />
description of the German perspectives<br />
on today’s Ukraine in<br />
their new study “Ukraine through<br />
the German Eyes: Representations<br />
and Perceptions of a Country in the<br />
Transition Period.” The study is<br />
based on the methodology of the<br />
GIZ’s previous project of studying<br />
the perception of Germany in the<br />
world, during which international<br />
experts on Germany were asked to<br />
Krieg, Krise, Krim vs.<br />
Dynamo Kyiv and the Klitschkos<br />
A German study tries to determine which perception<br />
of Ukraine is prevailing in German society<br />
answer the question of how the German<br />
state was perceived in their<br />
homeland. The study of Ukraine<br />
conducted by the GIZ in 2017 is also<br />
not a statistical study of the Germans’<br />
attitude towards Ukraine,<br />
but a deep qualitative exploration<br />
of the impressions, interpretations,<br />
opinions, perspectives, assessments,<br />
stereotypes, knowledge and<br />
expectations that exist in Germany<br />
regarding Ukraine. This analysis is<br />
based on 1,014 statements by<br />
44 German citizens who are more or<br />
less familiar with Ukraine or are<br />
interested in it for various professional<br />
reasons. The respondents include<br />
researchers, businesspeople,<br />
civic activists, journalists as well<br />
as cultural and political figures.<br />
The latter category encompasses<br />
some well-known individuals, such<br />
as the Green Party’s Member of the<br />
European Parliament Rebecca<br />
Harms or former Prime Minister of<br />
Saxony and serving Ambassador of<br />
the G7 in Ukraine, Professor Georg<br />
Milbradt.<br />
As initiator and immediate<br />
leader of the project Andreas von<br />
Schumann clearly points out in his<br />
opening remarks, the objective of<br />
the study was not “to search for<br />
[objective] truth” about Ukraine.<br />
Rather, “[we] wanted to isolate the<br />
similarities that can be revealed in<br />
different views [on Ukraine] of different<br />
people [from Germany], to<br />
discover the outlines of these perceptions<br />
[and] recognizable features<br />
of both the real and distorted<br />
portrait of the country.” Von Schumann<br />
points out two fundamental<br />
trends in the assessments given by<br />
44 German participants in specialized<br />
interviews: firstly, the German<br />
experts questioned believe<br />
that the German “perspective on<br />
Ukraine is too narrow, the knowledge<br />
[of Ukraine in Germany] is too<br />
unsystematic, the attention of [the<br />
Germans] [to events in Ukraine] is<br />
too fickle, and assessments [of<br />
Ukrainian topics] are built on too<br />
shallow foundations.” Secondly,<br />
the German experts interviewed,<br />
according to von Schumann, expressed<br />
“a deep desire that Germany<br />
and the Germans find a common<br />
language with Ukraine more<br />
often and more actively.” This desire<br />
is based on several motives:<br />
the historical responsibility of the<br />
German people, the cultural diversity<br />
of Ukraine, the economic potential<br />
of the country, the need to<br />
ensure stability in eastern Europe<br />
and the possible incentives [flowing<br />
from such involvement] for the<br />
further development of the EU.<br />
And yet, as the respondents noted,<br />
the most obvious incentive for<br />
them was admiration brought by<br />
their own closer encounter with<br />
Ukraine. Regardless of the specific<br />
reason that put Ukraine forward as<br />
their principal interest, most [of<br />
the interviewees] stressed that the<br />
“clean sheet” of perception that<br />
had existed at first had quickly<br />
turned into a “colorful canvas”<br />
(page 7).<br />
As shown by the study, three<br />
negative ‘K’s have dominated the<br />
German perception of Ukraine since<br />
2014: Krieg, Krise, Krim – i.e., the<br />
[military] conflict, crisis, Crimea.<br />
Two other ‘K’s with positive connotations,<br />
which are the once famous<br />
soccer team Dynamo Kyiv and the<br />
The Queen’s record achievements<br />
How America and Canada were able<br />
to watch the coronation of Her Majesty<br />
which took place 65 years ago<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
name Klitschko, borne by Vladimir<br />
and Vitalii, two famous world boxing<br />
champions who lived in Germany<br />
for a long time and are still<br />
popular in that country, have only<br />
slightly improved this image. The<br />
GIZ study not only presents widespread<br />
German stereotypes about<br />
Ukraine, similar to those described<br />
above, but also offers numerous indepth<br />
assessments of the scope of<br />
various perceptions in Germany of<br />
such Ukrainian topics as the 2014<br />
regime change, reforms, corruption,<br />
nationalism, external relations,<br />
European aspirations, cultural<br />
differences, relations with Russia,<br />
and the nation’s significance for<br />
Germany.<br />
The value of this study is not<br />
only in illustrating well the various<br />
German interpretations of these<br />
topics. Besides presenting the<br />
views of many leading German experts<br />
on Ukraine and their perspectives<br />
on the country they take interest<br />
in, the brochure also offers<br />
an in-depth presentation of how the<br />
German public should be informed<br />
in the future about the history and<br />
events in and around Ukraine.<br />
From the point of view of Germany’s<br />
importance for the EU’s<br />
foreign policy in general and for<br />
the Union’s policy towards Ukraine<br />
in particular, this study of the German<br />
thinking on various Ukrainian<br />
issues, which is now being translated<br />
into English and Ukrainian, will<br />
become mandatory reading for all<br />
those interested in the present and<br />
future of international relations of<br />
Ukraine, as well as its gradual European<br />
integration.<br />
Andreas UMLAND is an expert<br />
at the Institute for Euro-Atlantic<br />
Cooperation (Kyiv)<br />
By Natalia PUSHKARUK, The Day<br />
On June 2, Queen<br />
Elizabeth II celebrated<br />
65 years since her<br />
coronation, held at the<br />
Westminster Abbey on<br />
the same day in 1953. Then, thousands<br />
of guests witnessed the<br />
historic ascension of the 27-year-old<br />
Elizabeth to the throne, while<br />
11 million Britons listened to the<br />
event on radio, and 27 million<br />
watched it on TV. The CBS News<br />
writes that journalist Walter<br />
Cronkite was the first to broadcast<br />
the event in America, using an<br />
improvised studio in a hangar in<br />
Boston’s Logan Airport. Meanwhile,<br />
the Royal Central web<br />
resource reports that the Canadians<br />
and Americans were able to watch<br />
Elizabeth’s coronation on the same<br />
day as the British only because the<br />
BBC’s records of the events were<br />
transported across the Atlantic by<br />
Royal Air Force aircraft. Formally,<br />
Elizabeth assumed her duties as<br />
Queen on February 6, 1952, when<br />
she learned, while visiting Kenya,<br />
that her father, King George VI,<br />
had died. That is why the Sapphire<br />
Jubilee of Elizabeth II, marking<br />
65 years of her reign, was<br />
celebrated last year. The Express<br />
publication notes that there were no<br />
official celebrations for the<br />
coronation anniversary in Britain<br />
this year, and Elizabeth spent<br />
June 2 attending one of her favorite<br />
entertainments, the Epsom Derby.<br />
Pictured: Queen Elizabeth II<br />
with John Warren, Her Majesty’s<br />
horse caretaker.
4<br />
No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
In the first part of the<br />
interview (see No. 34,<br />
June 5, 2018), the<br />
well-known Estonian<br />
philosopher and statesman<br />
Ulo Vooglaid reflects<br />
on the formation of elites,<br />
the preconditions for successful<br />
reforms, and the<br />
importance of service, spirituality,<br />
and planning in<br />
the context of societal<br />
changes. Read below about<br />
the place of upbringing and<br />
patriotism in the system of<br />
education, drawbacks of<br />
the Bologna Agreement,<br />
and the nature of democracy.<br />
● “EDUCATION DOES<br />
NOT BEGIN<br />
IN THE KINDERGARTEN<br />
OR SCHOOL”<br />
In the past few years, Ukraine’s<br />
education officials have been endlessly<br />
trying to reduce the number and<br />
volume of compulsory liberal-arts<br />
disciplines in non-core curriculums<br />
on the grounds that a narrower specialization<br />
is needed. What do you<br />
think of this viewpoint?<br />
“Society is in need of educated<br />
people in all the spheres of life, including,<br />
naturally, industrial production,<br />
agriculture, and trade. If somebody really<br />
intends to withdraw liberal arts<br />
from the system of education, it is<br />
sheer horror. In these conditions, a<br />
generalist cannot emerge in principle.<br />
“Research shows that the fundamental<br />
phases of education, which fall<br />
on the earliest age and even the prenatal<br />
period, are of paramount importance<br />
for the formation of a personality.<br />
We call it ‘education in the<br />
womb.’ What is from the moment of<br />
birth until the age of three is ‘education<br />
in the nest.’ At this stage an individual<br />
acquires the idea of himself as<br />
well as ethic and esthetic notions,<br />
forms the sensation of ‘I,’ ‘we,’ and<br />
‘they,’ and learns the native language.<br />
“We should understand that education<br />
does not begin in the kindergarten<br />
or school. A human begins to<br />
receive education the moment parents<br />
‘send a letter to the stork.’ It is very<br />
important for him or her to feel warm<br />
and cozy, without any fear or alarm.<br />
The likelihood of neuroses and psychoses<br />
depends on this period to a considerable<br />
extent. The question is<br />
whether one will grow into a subject or<br />
an object of manipulations. At a very<br />
early age, in the kindergarten, it is a<br />
conscious person who has rights, duties,<br />
and freedom of actions. He or she<br />
must know why it is necessary to observe<br />
certain rules, do something one<br />
way, not another. This lays the foundation<br />
of a personality.<br />
“As for the next phases, we<br />
should know that the ultimate goal of<br />
an elementary school leaver is not confined<br />
to being promoted to secondary<br />
and then higher school. Life is multifaceted,<br />
and we are speaking of a person<br />
who receives the passport of a citizen<br />
and will soon take part in social<br />
and cultural life. He or she is fully responsible<br />
for what they are doing as<br />
well as for what they are not doing, although<br />
they should do. The graduate<br />
should be prepared for work, and<br />
know how to defend not only himself,<br />
but also others as well as nature, culture,<br />
the native language, the honor<br />
and dignity of the state – with<br />
weapons in hand, if necessary. Work,<br />
creation, cognition – one must be prepared<br />
for all the spheres of public life.<br />
“In the higher school, what really<br />
matters is not specialty but personality<br />
– as a subject, an active beginning<br />
of certain processes for which one<br />
How to change a country<br />
by means of education?–2<br />
Ulo VOOGLAID: “Democracy is a function of culture –<br />
otherwise it turns into a set of public deception ploys”<br />
must be responsible. What is important<br />
here is experience in terms of not<br />
only the specialty, but also the profession<br />
and the office held.”<br />
There is a widespread opinion in<br />
Ukraine’s educational circles that upbringing<br />
is only good at the school<br />
stage. The idea is that school should<br />
inculcate civil patriotism, certain<br />
moral guidelines, etc., in children<br />
(which is far from always the case in<br />
reality, unfortunately), whereas the<br />
university should remain “neutral” in<br />
this matter. But it is hardly achievable<br />
in reality, for every teacher also<br />
has values and persuasions of their<br />
own which they convey, deliberately<br />
or not, to students. Do you agree to<br />
this interpretation of the place of upbringing<br />
in the system of education?<br />
“No, in my view, it is a terrible approach.<br />
I am convinced that upbringing<br />
takes precedence over education.<br />
Knowledge, skills, and experience are<br />
only some of the prerequisites, but human<br />
life centers around the personality,<br />
subjectness, soul, world-view, the<br />
human being and his position in public<br />
and cultural life. This is what really<br />
matters.<br />
“An individual is brought up and<br />
educated not only in school and university<br />
– experts estimate that it is a<br />
question of not more than 10 percent<br />
here. Ninety percent is accounted for<br />
by all the other civic institutions:<br />
above all, the family, and the system<br />
of mass communication and information,<br />
sport organizations, and any other<br />
nongovernmental initiatives.<br />
“It is worthwhile to define what<br />
education and learnedness is. There are<br />
at least 10 viewpoints on this. To get a<br />
full picture, we must take all them into<br />
account. For example, we can regard<br />
education as a lifelong process. It is a<br />
process of forming preparedness for<br />
various situations at different stages<br />
of life, which culture and society offer.<br />
It is impossible to evaluate education<br />
by inspecting schools. You can only<br />
evaluate the result of this activity –<br />
whether or not it meets the expectations<br />
of public and cultural life.<br />
“It is very important that an individual<br />
should grow into a patriot who<br />
wants to serve his country and nation<br />
and is preparing for this at every moment<br />
of his life.”<br />
● “TO LOVE YOUR COUNTRY<br />
IS A NATURAL NEED<br />
FOR MAN”<br />
I think the fear that upbringing is<br />
part of the system of education may<br />
be the result of a totalitarian legacy.<br />
For both the USSR and the Third Reich<br />
were trying hard to “bring up a<br />
new man.”<br />
“Maybe. It is important to note<br />
that the effects of upbringing are not<br />
produced in a game situation – the<br />
process requires a serious attitude. Is<br />
it shameful to love your country culture,<br />
nature? Of course not! It is an<br />
honor, a natural need for man. We<br />
should in no way give in to enemy<br />
propaganda in this matter. Are we really<br />
striving to produce an individual<br />
who will learn all subjects but end up<br />
as a rascal? There’s nothing to argue<br />
about here. Bringing up a soundminded<br />
and adequate patriot is the<br />
primary task.”<br />
After all, one is happier when<br />
these contexts are present in his life,<br />
when this life is not confined to his<br />
purely personal interests and has<br />
broader public and cultural horizons.<br />
“Exactly! Ideals (both personal<br />
and national) are an important quality<br />
of any personality. Serving the ideals<br />
makes life meaningful.”<br />
I know that you are critical of the<br />
Bologna Process in education. Why?<br />
“I remember everybody saying in<br />
1999, when the Bologna Agreement<br />
was signed, that, while earlier it took<br />
Photo by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
four years to gain higher education,<br />
now it will take five (three years of the<br />
bachelor’s course and two years of the<br />
master’s course). But, as we can see,<br />
the majority of students confine<br />
themselves to the bachelor’s degree. It<br />
is very difficult to call three years of<br />
study a university education. Pardon<br />
my harsh words, but I can only offer<br />
my condolences to those who think so.<br />
If one who has only a bachelor’s degree<br />
is allowed to work in a university, it is<br />
abnormal, to say the least.<br />
“The objective of the higher education<br />
system is to train, above all, an<br />
educated person, not a degree-bearing<br />
specialist, and increase the number of<br />
intellectuals in all the required fields.<br />
It is not a question of choice but a prerequisite<br />
for the existence and development<br />
of society. In addition to giving<br />
a specialty, the university provides<br />
training with due account of the<br />
profession, position, and ability to<br />
cognize and create. The graduate must<br />
be able to begin practical activity in a<br />
certain field. If the objective is only to<br />
prepare for the next stage of education,<br />
as the Bologna Process suggests,<br />
what one is going to do after gaining a<br />
doctoral degree?<br />
“The Bologna Process calls for<br />
students to draw up programs on their<br />
own, but most of them are not prepared<br />
to do so. If doctors were also<br />
trained on these principles, this would<br />
have a deleterious effect on patients’<br />
life expectancy.”<br />
● “TO ASK THE PEOPLE FOR<br />
THE RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE<br />
IN PARLIAMENTARY<br />
ACTIVITY, YOU MUST<br />
PREPARE YOURSELF VERY<br />
SERIOUSLY”<br />
There is an opinion that modernday<br />
democracy is more and more<br />
turning into sort of “democracy of minorities.”<br />
Major efforts are being<br />
made to preserve local identities,<br />
while universal values are being either<br />
ignored or, on the contrary, so<br />
emasculated and “worn out” due to<br />
constant use that they are in fact<br />
turning into empty words bereft of<br />
any sense. For example, everybody<br />
talks of “human rights,” but do people<br />
know where this concept came<br />
from and what it means? Do you<br />
agree that this problem exists?<br />
“Yes, of course. You are asking<br />
about ‘modern-day democracy.’ But<br />
who developed this modern-day idea<br />
of democracy? Who decided that the<br />
so-called minority has all the rights,<br />
while all the other people must observe<br />
them? Unfortunately, this improper<br />
idea is very common. I think<br />
we must ‘straighten our back.’<br />
Democracy is a function of culture.<br />
Democracy is people who know and respect<br />
one another, have a feeling of<br />
shame, and strive to behave normally,<br />
in accordance with the expectations of<br />
others. Only in these conditions is<br />
democracy possible. Otherwise,<br />
democracy turns into a set of public<br />
deception ploys. We have seen these<br />
sad changes take place in the past few<br />
years.<br />
“Winston Churchill once said that<br />
if something depended on elections,<br />
they would have been banned long<br />
ago. Certain figures have always been<br />
trying to use elections for consolidating<br />
and preserving their power even<br />
after their own death. Democracy is<br />
impossible when people are uneducated,<br />
uninformed, and inexperienced.<br />
What’s the use of elections if you<br />
know nothing?<br />
“Ballots should bear the names of<br />
the people who really know what to do<br />
if they are elected. If you’ve been<br />
elected to parliament, you must know<br />
what legislation is and how the law<br />
works as a regulatory mechanism. To<br />
be still more exact, mechanisms of impact<br />
must be brought into play. You<br />
must know this, and only then you will<br />
have a moral right to push multicolored<br />
buttons.<br />
“Another enormous task is to exercise<br />
top control over the activity of<br />
all civic constitutional institutions.<br />
One must understand their purpose,<br />
goals, rights, and duties, and know<br />
the prerequisites that allow one to<br />
govern, manage, and conduct other<br />
target-oriented processes. One must<br />
know society, people, the laws and<br />
regularities of the formation of various<br />
relationships – in other words,<br />
you must be an educated person or, to<br />
be more exact, a generalist. To ask the<br />
people for the right to participate in<br />
parliamentary activity, you must first<br />
prepare yourself very seriously. It is a<br />
tremendous honor, but, first of all, it<br />
is a very important task to serve your<br />
nation – not to simulate service but to<br />
serve indeed. Only this kind of ruler<br />
will earn society’s respect.<br />
“It is primitive to identify democracy<br />
with elections only. Under normal<br />
circumstances, the people, as the<br />
highest power-forming body, has the<br />
right to show legislative initiatives,<br />
hold referendums on various issues,<br />
and take part in shaping the organizational<br />
mechanisms of public and cultural<br />
life. For, as it was said above, an<br />
individual asserts his activity and responsibility<br />
by way of real participation<br />
in decision-making. Once he withdraws<br />
from this process, he sinks into<br />
passivity, apathy, and alienation (in<br />
the psychic and sociological senses).<br />
You cannot order a person to be active.<br />
Activity forms by itself, but this<br />
requires the creation of relevant preconditions.<br />
“We have discussed all this at our<br />
meetings in Ukraine, and I can assure<br />
you that there are a lot of people here<br />
who understand the essence of these<br />
fundamental societal issues.”<br />
By Roman GRYVINSKYI, The Day
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018 5<br />
Who outplayed whom?<br />
Lawyer: “Although the law on the Anticorruption Court<br />
has been passed, the leadership got the upper hand”<br />
By Ivan KAPSAMUN,<br />
photos by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
Let us recall how many calls<br />
there have been in the past<br />
few years to establish the<br />
Anticorruption Court.<br />
Many. But, to start with, it<br />
was, of course, necessary to pass<br />
a law to this effect. This brought<br />
about a long standoff. On one<br />
side, it is the leadership which<br />
proposed its bill and wanted to<br />
form the Anticorruption Court in<br />
accordance with its rules; on the<br />
other, it is a part of the Ukrainian<br />
public, international partners,<br />
and representatives of the<br />
democratic opposition. There is<br />
also a third side – those who<br />
oppose the establishment of this<br />
court on the grounds that this<br />
will in any case boil down to<br />
window dressing in the current<br />
conditions and it is better to<br />
reform the existing courts so they<br />
could try corruptionists. But, as<br />
the law was finally passed, let us<br />
focus on it.<br />
After a long standoff, MPs<br />
cast 315 votes for establishing<br />
the High Anticorruption Court<br />
(constitutional majority). But,<br />
before doing so, they had examined<br />
1,927 amendments to the<br />
law. This vividly illustrates the<br />
quality of the document submitted<br />
by the Presidential Administration.<br />
One of the main points MPs<br />
failed to come to terms about for<br />
a long time was powers of the<br />
Nongovernmental Board of International<br />
Experts. The question<br />
was whether or not international<br />
partners will be authorized to debar<br />
from competition the candidates<br />
that raise their doubts. Parliament<br />
Speaker Andrii PARU-<br />
BII said “a formula we found”<br />
fully complies with recommendations<br />
of the Venice Commission.<br />
The Chairman of the Parliamentary<br />
Committee on Legal Policies<br />
and Justice, Ruslan Kniazevych,<br />
explained the law’s most<br />
controversial clause on the selection<br />
of Anticorruption Court<br />
judges as follows: “The Nongovernmental<br />
Board consists of<br />
six members appointed by the High<br />
Qualification Commission of<br />
Judges (VKKS) exclusively on the<br />
basis of proposals from international<br />
organizations with which<br />
Ukraine cooperates in the field of<br />
preventing and countering corruption<br />
in accordance with international<br />
agreements. On the initiative<br />
of at least three members of<br />
the Nongovernmental Board of International<br />
Experts, the question<br />
of whether a candidate for the office<br />
of a High Anticorruption<br />
Court judge meets the necessary<br />
criteria is to be discussed at a joint<br />
meeting of the VKKS and the Nongovernmental<br />
Board of International<br />
Experts. The decision on<br />
whether this candidate meets these<br />
criteria is to be made by the majority<br />
of VKKS and Nongovernmental<br />
Board members on condition<br />
that at least a half of Nongovernmental<br />
Board members have<br />
voted for it. Should this decision<br />
not be made, the candidate shall be<br />
considered as rejected.” (unian.us)<br />
The Anticorruption Court is<br />
to be formed within 12 months<br />
from the day this law came into<br />
force.<br />
President Petro Poroshenko,<br />
the bill’s initiator, who was present<br />
in the session hall during the<br />
vote, called on MPs to muster<br />
their strength and approve this<br />
document. After the vote, the<br />
head of state repeatedly pronounced<br />
the word “victory” in his<br />
traditional manner: “It is a victory,<br />
a victory of Ukraine, a victory<br />
of the Ukrainian people, the<br />
victory of me as president of<br />
Ukraine, a victory of the Ukrainian<br />
parliament with Speaker Andrii<br />
Parubii at the head, a victory<br />
of the Ukrainian government with<br />
Prime Minister Volodymyr Hroisman<br />
at the head.”<br />
With due account of a long<br />
history and all the peripeteia, the<br />
“victory” looks at least indecent in<br />
this case. Too much pomp and anguish<br />
in the conditions, when the<br />
state needs a strong remedy and<br />
radical surgery, rather than<br />
shamans or antipyretic pills. It<br />
will be recalled that the law on the<br />
State Bureau of Investigations<br />
was passed as long as two and a<br />
half years ago, but this body has<br />
not yet been formed. The country<br />
has long needed serious reforms,<br />
all the more so that war is still going<br />
on at our territory. Instead, we<br />
can the ante endlessly upped in the<br />
inter-clannish struggle, protection<br />
of personal interests, in playing<br />
down to society, and in promises<br />
to international partners.<br />
All right, let us put aside criticism<br />
for a while and accept the<br />
logic of those who say that passing<br />
the law on the Anticorruption<br />
Court in the present conditions is<br />
at least a kind of a step. What does<br />
it mean? “It seems at first glance<br />
that compromises were reached<br />
and satisfy the Venice Commission<br />
and the IMF,” lawyer Ruslan RI-<br />
ABOSHAPKA comments to The<br />
Day. “In all probability, the leadership<br />
will be delaying the implementation<br />
of this law. On the<br />
whole, I do not think this court is<br />
a panacea and will solve the problem<br />
of corruption.”<br />
“What simply stuns me is<br />
weakness and non-professionalism<br />
of our experts and civic activists<br />
because they have shown a<br />
children’s level,” lawyer Vitalii<br />
TYTYCH told The Day. “In the<br />
past three months, I’ve been in<br />
contact with all stakeholders,<br />
Ukrainian activists, the US ambassador<br />
to Ukraine, and the head<br />
of the IMF mission, but, as a result,<br />
I failed to see that we have<br />
outplayed the current leadership.<br />
In reality, the latter, including<br />
President Poroshenko; Filatov,<br />
in charge of legal affairs in the<br />
Presidential Administration; Kniazevych<br />
in parliament; and Koziakov,<br />
chairman of the High Qualification<br />
Commission of Judges,<br />
have outplayed everybody. The<br />
vast majority of amendments<br />
were aimed at blocking the passage<br />
of the law and creating<br />
chaos. All these amendments are<br />
not the first victory of Bankova<br />
St. And when it is said that the<br />
establishment of this court is a<br />
step forward, I disagree. It is not<br />
clear how six members of the Nongovernmental<br />
Board will be able<br />
to prove that a certain individual<br />
is not competent enough. And<br />
who will they be vetoing? To be<br />
able to choose somebody, one must<br />
have a choice, and there will only<br />
be a choice if professionals and<br />
honest people, who can sacrifice<br />
themselves (such is the work in a<br />
true anticorruption court), accept<br />
offer to work there. But normal<br />
people are unlikely to go there<br />
because no conditions have been<br />
created. Maybe, our Western<br />
partners’ plans included a strategy<br />
– to force us to pass this law<br />
for the time being, leaving the<br />
VKKS free to apply its methods<br />
afterwards.”
6<br />
No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018<br />
CLOSE UP<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
The ideal FIFA World<br />
Cup, to kick off in<br />
Russia on June 14,<br />
should look as<br />
follows: a boycott on<br />
the part of world leaders<br />
and ordinary soccer fans<br />
and the release of about<br />
70 Ukrainian political<br />
prisoners. The example is<br />
being set by members of the<br />
British royal family and<br />
British ministers who will<br />
not go to see the tournament<br />
because of Russia’s likely<br />
complicity in poisoning exintelligence<br />
officer Sergei<br />
Skripal. For the same<br />
reason, Iceland announced<br />
boycotting the World Cup.<br />
At the same time, 5,000<br />
Ukrainians are going to the<br />
country that annexed<br />
Crimea and unleashed a war<br />
in the Donbas, enslaves and<br />
tortures thousands of their<br />
compatriots.<br />
To bring the world to<br />
its senses at least a little,<br />
artist Andrii Yermolenko<br />
has drawn a series of posters<br />
about the world soccer<br />
championship. Instead of<br />
idyllic pictures, we can see<br />
the military in the goal,<br />
bombings, and a downed<br />
airplane against the suffocating<br />
red background. Andrii<br />
can be said to have<br />
struck a chord – his drawings<br />
went viral in the internet,<br />
and Facebook even<br />
blocked him. Andrii YER-<br />
MOLENKO told The Day<br />
why, in spite of a wide response,<br />
he considers this a<br />
“one-man picket.”<br />
● “I APPEAL MORE TO<br />
<strong>ENG</strong>LISH-SPEAKING<br />
EUROPEANS”<br />
“You see, very many serious things<br />
have occurred in the past month. Firstly,<br />
it is the hunger strike of Sentsov and<br />
Kolchenko. This is one of the factors that<br />
catalyzed the creation of these posters,”<br />
Yermolenko begins the conversation.<br />
“At first I joined the campaign of drawing<br />
posters in support of Sentsov. When<br />
you look at the Ukrainian information<br />
“In order to bring the world to its senses…”<br />
field, you can see that our Ministry of Information<br />
Politics is falling short of its<br />
targets. This kind of posters about the<br />
FIFA World Cup in Russia should have<br />
appeared long ago. I understood there<br />
would be none of them until the championship<br />
opening. And then we would be<br />
lifting our hands in dismay and saying<br />
that all those Europeans, Germans, or<br />
whoever it is, are bastards because they<br />
went to the championship instead of<br />
boycotting it. But all is very simple – nobody<br />
shaped a right information policy<br />
in Ukraine about this championship.<br />
And this was my small one-man picket<br />
against the tournament. I wanted more<br />
people to pay attention to this. I appeal<br />
more to English-speaking Europeans<br />
rather than to Ukrainians.<br />
“To tell the truth, it is terrible that<br />
things have very noticeably changed for<br />
the worse in comparison with the 1980<br />
Olympics in the Soviet Union, when a lot<br />
of countries boycotted it. Now, owing<br />
to various commercial and business interests,<br />
everybody is shutting their<br />
eyes to such obvious things as the war<br />
Artist Andrii<br />
Yermolenko<br />
drew a series<br />
of placards on<br />
the 2018 FIFA World<br />
Cup in Russia and<br />
explained why<br />
it must be boycotted<br />
in Ukraine and Syria, acts of terror in<br />
London with a Russian trace, Russia’s<br />
interference into elections in a number<br />
of countries. The impression is that<br />
when civilized people – you know, all<br />
wearing neckties – are sitting at the<br />
table, and a barefaced ruffian suddenly<br />
climbs up and dirties the table, they<br />
are all saying to him: ‘Tut-tut, you<br />
shouldn’t do so, we are warning you for<br />
the last time.’ Then this ruffian says:<br />
‘And now let’s go to my home place and<br />
hold a cool soccer championship.’ And<br />
they say: ‘Let’s go. Maybe, this will salvage<br />
him. Maybe, he will become better<br />
if we come.’ He won’t – that’s the<br />
point. This silence prompts him to go on<br />
behaving brazenly and disgustingly.”<br />
● “SUCH SIMPLE THINGS AS<br />
PROBITY AND THE FEELING<br />
OF DIGNITY GO AWRY”<br />
At the same time, 5,000 Ukrainians<br />
have bought tickets to the World<br />
Cup.<br />
“It is a shock to me. I know that<br />
very many Ukrainians are saying it is<br />
not their war. This disgusts me. In the<br />
first days of the war, very may soccer<br />
fans joined the army. They took up<br />
arms for our Ukraine, while very many<br />
Ukrainians ‘in the chips’ bought tickets<br />
(which cost a pretty penny) and are<br />
traveling to the aggressor country that<br />
is killing your country. They are traveling<br />
there to watch this championship.<br />
In addition, I am sure that, what is still<br />
more disgusting, they will be saying to<br />
Russians: ‘It’s not our or your fault, it<br />
is politics. We know that you are good<br />
and Ukrainians are not fighting against<br />
Russians. It’s politicians…’ This is also<br />
a catalyst of my posters.<br />
“Some people are doing something,<br />
but… My posters are really a<br />
one-man picket against all this. Such<br />
simple things as probity and the feeling<br />
of dignity – your own and of your<br />
country – go awry. They are trampled<br />
upon and killed day after day. I am<br />
sure still more of the Ukrainian establishment<br />
and politicians will push forward<br />
to this championship, which infuriates<br />
me still more.<br />
“We are living at a moment when<br />
things regain their proper places.<br />
Black is black, and white is white. We<br />
must not be afraid to call things by<br />
their proper names.”<br />
● “WE HAVE A BOYCOTTED<br />
BOYCOTT”<br />
Did Facebook block you over the<br />
posters?<br />
“It not only blocked me. Before<br />
that, I began to receive on Facebook<br />
various messages from the unknown<br />
people with all kinds of embeddings. I<br />
knew that those were viruses and did<br />
not accept them. The next day Facebook<br />
blocked me. I asked some people<br />
to hand out the posters, for I’d like as<br />
many people as possible to understand<br />
that it is a blood-stained soccer. I was<br />
unblocked, but not on the account,<br />
where I posted these posters, then<br />
they began to add some unclear files.<br />
I cleaned up my page the other day.<br />
“To block means to be afraid. I was<br />
prepared for this and opened one more<br />
account to post messages from there<br />
in case they don’t unblock me.<br />
“We are living in an era of information<br />
warfare, when participants<br />
are still to lean how to handle it. I<br />
can’t say we are losing. We are not losing.<br />
We just don’t know so far how to<br />
wage this war. I’d like more people,<br />
who know how to do this, to get engaged<br />
in this war. I am one of these<br />
fighters. I know there are very many<br />
fighters of this kind. The state is not<br />
exactly paying attention to us, but<br />
that’s all right – we must do our job.”<br />
How do the foreigners you address<br />
by way of posters react to them?<br />
“It is some French and Belgian<br />
publishers and a Dane who asked me<br />
permission to use these posters. I also<br />
commented for Radio Liberty in the<br />
Czech Republic. A lot of people have<br />
been turning to me. The British asked<br />
to write about this. I allow using and<br />
spreading these posters free of charge.<br />
“We have a boycotted boycott. We,<br />
Ukrainians and Europe as a whole are<br />
boycotting the boycott that was to have<br />
taken place. Schizophrenia pure and<br />
simple. I’d like to draw your attention<br />
to this not because I am so good and polite.<br />
I am just scared. At this very moment,<br />
some of my friends are fighting<br />
at the front, and other friends have<br />
died. I know that I must also do something.<br />
Oleh Sentsov is on a hunger<br />
strike in the country which hosts this<br />
championship and to which politicians<br />
from various countries will travel.<br />
They will travel to celebrate the ‘feast<br />
of soccer,’ while very many Ukrainian<br />
political prisoners are simply dying<br />
there. And should anything happen to<br />
Sentsov (I hope he will be freed anyway)<br />
or any other political prisoner,<br />
the concerned Europe will say: ‘Tuttut,<br />
how vexing and bad!’ It’s the most<br />
terrible thing, double standards, when<br />
a rapist is told not to rape, but he goes<br />
on doing so, the same people who say<br />
‘don’t rape’ visit his home to drink tea<br />
or cognac and talk about soccer. In my<br />
view, it is the same thing.”<br />
By Maria PROKOPENKO, The Day
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
CULT URE No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018 7<br />
By Dmytro DESIATERYK, The Day<br />
The drama Touch Me Not (Nu Ma Atinge-<br />
Ma, Romania – Germany – Czech Republic<br />
– Bulgaria – France, 2018) became a<br />
real sensation of the last Berlinale,<br />
winning there both the Golden Bear<br />
for the best feature film and the award for the<br />
best debut.<br />
This work, done as a peculiar combination of<br />
live-action and documentary cinema, tells the<br />
story of three heroes – Laura, Tudor, and Christian.<br />
The first two are played by well-known actors<br />
Laura Benson (Dangerous Liaisons (1988),<br />
Ready to Wear (1994)) and Tomas Lemarquis<br />
(3 Days to Kill (2014), X Men: Apocalypse<br />
(2016), Blade Runner 2049 (2017)). Like many<br />
supporting characters, they share the same problem<br />
as they strive and at the same time acutely<br />
fear intimacy, corporeal and emotional alike.<br />
Christian practically plays himself: crippled by<br />
spinal muscular atrophy, he is completely free<br />
from prejudice and lives with the girl he loves.<br />
The film itself is a kind of story about liberation,<br />
about overcoming of protective mechanisms and<br />
taboos, sometimes in quite unusual ways.<br />
In the non-competitive program of the<br />
Molodist Festival, which ended in Kyiv on<br />
June 3, Touch Me Not was personally presented<br />
by the film’s director Adina Pintilie and the<br />
leading actress Laura Benson.<br />
Adina-Elena Pintilie was born in Bucharest<br />
on January 12, 1980. She debuted in 2003 as a<br />
documentary filmmaker. Her non-live-action<br />
works participated in the competition programs<br />
of the festivals in Locarno, Rotterdam, Leipzig,<br />
and Warsaw. Pintilie serves as artistic director<br />
and curator of the International Experimental<br />
Film Festival in Bucharest. Touch Me Not is her<br />
first live-action film.<br />
After the Kyiv premiere, Pintilie answered<br />
questions of The Day’s correspondent.<br />
How did it occur to you to make Touch Me<br />
Not?<br />
“When I was twenty, I thought I knew everything<br />
about how relationship should function,<br />
intimacy, our desire mechanism, and also what<br />
means beauty. But in the past years of life, I realized<br />
that actually I don’t know anything. Once<br />
clear ideas get destabilized when I enter in contact<br />
with real people and with real life. So, we set<br />
out on this journey to just question our own preconceived<br />
ideas about how intimacy functions,<br />
and to discover how people actually can access<br />
intimacy in the most unexpected ways. And back<br />
in 2013, we started an extensive casting process,<br />
which was more like in documentaries, but this<br />
film is not a documentary. We try to avoid all<br />
these labels, because the film is mainly a research<br />
one, it is a process film, a research film.<br />
“So, in 2013 we started this extending casting<br />
period. It was not like looking for actors, it<br />
was more like looking for like-minded people.<br />
And after finding them, we worked with video<br />
diaries, with a lot of filmed exercises – it was before<br />
the official shooting, where we could get accustomed<br />
with the camera being, like, a witness<br />
of some of our very personal, intimate stories.<br />
So, this kind of a long process helped to grow the<br />
trust between the participants in the project.”<br />
It looks like creating a commune of sorts.<br />
“It was like fiction functioning like more a<br />
sort of laboratory, like a safe place which allowed<br />
us to explore really sensitive areas. Because<br />
when you are protecting yourself under, let’s<br />
say, fictional character, in that convention you<br />
can go everywhere, because you don’t need to<br />
know what is real, what is invented, what is<br />
imagined, what is memory. Many of them came<br />
as themselves in the film. So, they were not playing<br />
with this mixture of fictional and real elements,<br />
they brought their own.”<br />
Did you have the help of professional psychologists?<br />
“Yes. For example, the emotional anatomy<br />
workshop: it’s designed by this very distinguished<br />
German performance artist and therapist<br />
Julia Sparmann. I found this very inspiring.<br />
So I proposed to collaborate and to create a workshop<br />
for the film, and within this structure,<br />
reenactment of the real workshop, we cast real<br />
people that wanted to work with this intimacy<br />
area in front of the camera, to share their experiences.<br />
And they were already entering this, I<br />
would call it, conventional laboratory. And<br />
everything that happens in this created structure,<br />
or a lot of what is happening there, it’s really<br />
authentic encounters between people. So,<br />
this is a very good example of how the mixture<br />
between staging and reality functions.”<br />
THE DRAMA TOUCH ME NOT BECAME A REAL SENSATION OF THE LAST BERLINALE<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
“We set out on this journey to just<br />
questionourownpreconceivedideas”<br />
Can your directorial approach be called anthropological?<br />
“I would not call it, because anthropologizing<br />
claims sort of objectivity. But this film is a very<br />
subjective emotional exploration that each of us<br />
went through. And by being highly subjective, I<br />
don’t think you can call it a scientific approach.<br />
I mean, in the end, if you look at psychotherapy,<br />
it is both sort of science, but it also involves high<br />
doses of subjectivity, intuition, and non-rational<br />
thinking, because they work a lot with the unconscious<br />
mind, with early memories, with a lot<br />
of emotions. So, that’s why I’m hesitating to put<br />
it in the area of science, but I would put it in the<br />
area of research. Research about human nature,<br />
in that sense it is connected to anthropology.”<br />
One of the protagonists is played by an actor<br />
with a disability. What was special about<br />
working with such an actor?<br />
The Golden Bear winner of the Berlin Film<br />
Festival Adina Pintilie discusses the intimacy<br />
and phenomenon of the Romanian cinema<br />
“For me it was very important in the casting<br />
process. And when trying to find these people,<br />
it was very important to feel that they have<br />
a strong motivation, emotional motivation to be<br />
part of the project. And Christian, it’s a very<br />
particular example of this, because he wanted<br />
to communicate with the audience. And actually,<br />
I think this film functioned like sort of a dialog,<br />
like many of the characters have their<br />
own, very specific views of the world, very progressive,<br />
and they would like to share it with<br />
the audience. And Christian said it from the beginning:<br />
‘I’m not afraid that this film is going<br />
to be attacked for me, for doing it. Because you<br />
know, the people who are going to attack the<br />
film are people who just actually have no idea<br />
about disability and about the relationship between<br />
disability and intimacy. They think that<br />
we, people who have different label on body, we<br />
just need to be taken care of, we are asexual, we<br />
don’t have any intimate life.’ And for him it<br />
was very important to enter into this communication<br />
with the audience and to share with them<br />
that people with the different label on bodies<br />
have the same desire, the same needs, and the<br />
same right to exist as sexual beings as any other<br />
person. He is also an activist for the rights of<br />
people with disabilities. And it was really an inspiring<br />
experience for all of us in the film to<br />
have Christian and Grit. They are a real couple,<br />
they are really passionate explorers of intimacy.<br />
Earlier only Christian was able to verbalize,<br />
to speak about this, but now Grit started to explain,<br />
and her voice is growing in this whole<br />
thing.”<br />
Do you see a difference between documentary<br />
and live-action cinema?<br />
“The border between the two is actually so<br />
fluid, because in the end, it’s about cinema,<br />
which is a very subjective experience of reality.<br />
It’s an illusion that you can capture the reality<br />
in a sort of an objective way. You cannot do<br />
something like that from the moment you choose<br />
to put the camera and to make a frame, and<br />
everything becomes a matter of subjective perception.<br />
I had the privilege to witness a master<br />
class that Werner Herzog [a German screenwriter,<br />
film director, author, actor, and opera<br />
director. – Author] gave some years ago in Salonica,<br />
and he was criticizing, debating with this<br />
view of documentary as being sort of fly-on-thewall<br />
approach, where you don’t interfere, you<br />
don’t alter reality. And he was saying, ‘I don’t<br />
want to be a fly on the wall, I want to be the bee<br />
that stings.’ Because you can’t have access to the<br />
truth of the human being by just putting the<br />
camera and watching that thing, that is happening<br />
in front of you. I have to be able to create situation,<br />
to provoke, to create the environment<br />
that can bring that truth to the surface. So, the<br />
reality is not what it is, it’s transformed by the<br />
subjective perception. And in that sense, I really<br />
don’t think there’s a distinction.”<br />
Now, when there are many different kinds<br />
of technologies that let one change one’s body,<br />
what do you think, how has the attitude to corporeality<br />
changed?<br />
“I basically can talk about my very subjective<br />
experience. I notice that in the past years<br />
at least, there is a strong interest for these selfexploration<br />
activities, like for workshops in<br />
different areas. And I think this happens everywhere<br />
in the world. Everywhere I traveled,<br />
there is growing interest in this process of getting<br />
to know your own body, and to be friends<br />
and accepting your body as it is. But luckily,<br />
more and more people start to look at that as<br />
something very normal, as something which is<br />
naturally part of your life and is worth exploring,<br />
because it helps you. If you know yourself<br />
better, you can solve also the other stuff. Actually,<br />
psychoanalysts have for a hundred years<br />
talked about how intimacy and sexuality are<br />
such natural parts of your life and your development.<br />
This all is so natural in psychotherapy,<br />
but for many other areas of discussion in our<br />
life, this is a difficult topic to approach. Psychoanalyst<br />
Michael Bader was explaining that<br />
your sexual behavior and your sexual fantasy<br />
can be key to read aspects of yourself also in<br />
other domains. So, you can judge yourself and<br />
say, ‘I’m wrong, I’m sick, I have to go to hospital<br />
to repair myself’ – or you can look with honesty<br />
at yourself and you say, ‘OK, I am like this,<br />
let’s try to understand what’s behind this behavior,<br />
why I am actually doing that.” There<br />
are ways of experiencing intimacy different<br />
from the norm, if you try to understand them<br />
and not put a label that they are wrong, first of<br />
all, you will have a better understanding of<br />
yourself, and then you will have a different relationship<br />
with the other person in front of you.<br />
So, you will not so easy become an extremist, or<br />
judgmental, or right-wing, the degree of aggressiveness<br />
has high chances to decrease.<br />
That’s why a film like this is important, because<br />
it’s offering a sort of mirror about how<br />
people can be different than what you think<br />
they are, how you think they should be.”<br />
In conclusion, a question asked from our<br />
Ukrainian perspective this time. It can be said<br />
that we here in Ukraine envy you, Romanian<br />
filmmakers, greatly, because you have just<br />
suddenly, after a prolonged period of communism<br />
and troubles, created an incredibly flourishing<br />
cinematic school. How have you managed<br />
to do it?<br />
“I don’t know. “I don’t know. I mean, the<br />
Romanian cinematic community was all the<br />
time clashing with political system, with the<br />
state system. So, you have this situation which<br />
is not so nice and cozy, it’s not so comfortable,<br />
so then you need to put extra energy to make<br />
things happen. Maybe this is energy which<br />
comes from having an enemy, having an antagonist.<br />
There are a lot of talented people, but not<br />
all of them functioning.”
8<br />
No.<strong>36</strong> JUNE 12, 2018<br />
TIMEO U T<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
Take care of bees!<br />
There are 16 entomological<br />
sanctuaries in the Rivne region<br />
By Liudmyla STUPCHUK, Rivne<br />
The prominent physicist Albert<br />
Einstein is said to have<br />
predicted: if bees ever die off,<br />
humans will go extinct four<br />
years later or so. Maybe he<br />
really said that, but it is likelier that<br />
these words were misattributed to<br />
him; still, humanity ought to give<br />
them a thought. It is because the list<br />
of plants that do not yield fruit<br />
without insect pollinators is quite<br />
long. Moreover, 80 percent of the<br />
pollination work is carried out<br />
precisely by bees, because butterflies,<br />
flies or wasps, of course, cannot work<br />
the huge areas that are needed by<br />
humans. Thus, scientists, beekeepers,<br />
and farmers are increasingly<br />
frequently sounding the alarm and<br />
calling for bees to be protected,<br />
considering that the main cause of<br />
their extinction is poisoning with<br />
pesticides and pathogenic microorganisms.<br />
Many plants are pollinated by<br />
wild bees as well, which still manage<br />
to survive under natural conditions,<br />
making nests in the hollows of trees,<br />
at the entrances to caves or even under<br />
rocky protrusions. They almost<br />
never get sick and can survive a severe<br />
winter with the ambient temperature<br />
falling to 50 degrees Celsius<br />
below zero. But wild bees are<br />
special not only in their higher working<br />
capacity and endurance, but also<br />
in low levels of anger, as they rarely<br />
bite and chase after those who disturb<br />
them, so that such scenes can be<br />
seen in cartoons alone. Do you remember<br />
how Winnie the Pooh tried<br />
to escape from such bees? But, just<br />
as “domestic” bees (and maybe more<br />
so), they also face extinction under<br />
the current conditions. Therefore,<br />
some species of wild bees are protected<br />
in Ukraine and elsewhere. The<br />
Red List of Ukraine includes eight<br />
species of bumblebees and several<br />
species of wild bees (mason bee,<br />
Dasypoda).<br />
“The fact is that for healthy existence<br />
of wild bees and preservation<br />
of their ability to harvest wild honey,<br />
special conditions are needed<br />
which are very difficult to preserve<br />
Photo by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
in the modern world. In order to save<br />
the wild bee gene pool and prevent it<br />
from hybridization with domestic<br />
bees, the protected habitat (pristine<br />
forests with hollow trees and sufficient<br />
tree cover to provide a rich forage<br />
base) should be enormous. After<br />
all, male bees sometimes overcome<br />
distances up to 17 kilometers in<br />
search of a partner,” biologist Anatolii<br />
Vlaskin told us. “It is primarily<br />
‘human factor’ that facilitates the<br />
disappearance of wild bees. Because<br />
of the excessive use of pesticides,<br />
high share of arable land, and the<br />
burning of grass, they irreversibly<br />
reduce their range and perish.”<br />
To preserve the populations of<br />
disappearing insects, including wild<br />
bees, people create entomological<br />
sanctuaries. In particular, there are<br />
16 such sanctuaries in the Rivne region.<br />
The entomological fauna of<br />
these territories is represented by<br />
many species, among them the regionally<br />
rare species of insects included<br />
in the Red List of Ukraine.<br />
For example, such species include<br />
stag beetle, musk beetle, and Old<br />
World swallowtail in Riasnyky and<br />
Miatnyky sanctuaries.<br />
Hrushvytsia and Kolodenka<br />
sanctuaries host populations of gray<br />
forest grasshopper and gray click<br />
beetle, green grasshopper, violet<br />
ground beetle, and red campion. Not<br />
all adults are likely to know how<br />
these insects look, and children have<br />
seen them mostly in books alone.<br />
This is despite their parents probably<br />
having done a lot during their<br />
own childhood to reduce the population<br />
of deer beetles, grasshoppers,<br />
and even swallowtail butterflies – do<br />
you remember how many of them<br />
you caught and put into little boxes<br />
to admire and show to friends?<br />
However, most entomological<br />
sanctuaries in the Rivne region were<br />
created specifically to preserve the<br />
breeding places of wild bees and<br />
bumblebees. They are protected in<br />
Syniv, Moshchanytsia, Stupno, Buderazh,<br />
Korshiv, Steblivka, and Ozeriany<br />
sanctuaries. Logging, grazing,<br />
and mowing are restricted in these<br />
“zoos” for insects, and the use of any<br />
chemicals is prohibited as well.<br />
By Larysa MYRHORODSKA, Ternopil<br />
The “Ukrainian Soul” exhibition<br />
of young creative artist Olesia<br />
Hudyma’s paintings, which<br />
opened at the Ternopil Regional<br />
Art Museum on June 1, can be<br />
termed a positive explosion. Colorful,<br />
fascinating paintings from the series<br />
“Flowers,” “Ukrainian Madonna,”<br />
“Angels of Peace for Ukraine”<br />
‘sounded’ especially atmospheric<br />
when accompanied by Wolfgang<br />
Amadeus Mozart’s music. As Hudyma<br />
told The Day, she painted a lot of<br />
works while listening to his tunes.<br />
Hence, there is also a painting named<br />
Flowers for Mozart among more than<br />
40 works on display.<br />
Hudyma is a journalist by profession.<br />
She started painting in 2007<br />
and has created a thousand paintings<br />
since then. The artist has to paint<br />
even at night sometimes, because her<br />
four children need attention too. She<br />
says that without her husband, she<br />
would have never been able to cope<br />
with the domestic chores. Photographer<br />
Liubomyr Kit is now her art<br />
manager as well. Hudyma started<br />
with the “Sleepwalker” series, and<br />
continued with “Steps” as well as already<br />
mentioned “Angels of Peace for<br />
Ukraine,” “Ukrainian Madonna,” and<br />
“Flowers.” Her works are in private<br />
collections almost all over the world,<br />
except for Australia and Argentina.<br />
They were exhibited in Kyiv’s Mystetsky<br />
Arsenal this May. Soon, the<br />
talented Ternopil artist’s series<br />
“Ukrainian Madonna” will appear on<br />
stamps of Ukrposhta, while the<br />
painting The Tree of Life will be made<br />
into a greeting postcard. Well-known<br />
British company Wraptious has already<br />
reproduced Hudyma’s “Flowers”<br />
on cushions made out of vegan<br />
suede. Last winter, the artist’s works<br />
appeared on the covers of the Canon<br />
periodical, published in the American<br />
city of Portland, and in the Kyiv<br />
magazine Slovo Zhinky. Hudyma’s<br />
A romantic mode of transport has<br />
appeared in the city on the Buh River<br />
By Olesia SHUTKEVYCH, Vinnytsia<br />
Recently, pub owner Vitalii<br />
Humeniuk, who leases a barge<br />
on the riverfront, started<br />
offering this attraction to his<br />
patrons. A romantic boat was<br />
designed by his grandpa to confess his<br />
love to his future wife. Many years<br />
later, Humeniuk decided to give the<br />
A positive explosion<br />
Ternopil artist Olesia Hudyma’s paintings<br />
will appear on stamps of Ukrposhta<br />
paintings reflect an eclectic mix of<br />
artistic styles, including impressionism,<br />
expressionism, abstractionism,<br />
symbolism, naive art, mathematism,<br />
magical realism, and postmodernism.<br />
The artist emphasizes: her paintings<br />
are intuitive, heart-created spontaneously,<br />
not based on traditional<br />
rules of the art. “However, in order<br />
to paint like this, one needs to develop<br />
technically for many years beforehand,”<br />
Hudyma believes. Her personal<br />
techniques include impatto and<br />
sfumato, done using masticks, brushes,<br />
and combs. The painter admits<br />
that she is impressed by the art of<br />
positivism. “Now it is the purity of<br />
the colors in the picture that I need,<br />
and it is very difficult to achieve,”<br />
the artist told us.<br />
Hudyma’s works will be exhibited<br />
at the Ternopil Regional Art Museum<br />
until June 18. This is the third solo<br />
exhibition of the young artist in her<br />
hometown.<br />
“Is Vinnytsia really any worse than Venice?”<br />
gondola a second life, restored it,<br />
modernized, and launched into water.<br />
“My grandpa and grandma had an<br />
incredible love story that deserves a<br />
novel-length treatment. The grandpa<br />
built this gondola for her, but christened<br />
it Juliet, probably in honor of the<br />
character of the famous Shakespearean<br />
play,” the pub owner told us. “I worked<br />
abroad for a long time. When asked<br />
Photo courtesy of the author<br />
Photo by Mykhailo URBANSKYI<br />
where I came from, I replied: ‘From Vinnytsia.’<br />
And everybody thought that I<br />
was from Venice. After all, is Vinnytsia<br />
really any worse than Venice? When<br />
I opened my restaurant, I remembered<br />
the gondola and my Vinnytsia Venice.<br />
After a long reconstruction and testing,<br />
I launched the first tourist season and<br />
became the first gondolier in the city.<br />
Now I am carrying couples of lovers who<br />
admire the sunset or sunrise. People are<br />
pleased, while my establishment gets<br />
tourists entertained.”<br />
Juliet differs from the original<br />
gondolas in that it is a bit narrower and<br />
longer. There is an iron crest on the<br />
boat’s bow which acts as a counterbalance<br />
to the gondolier. The boat has a<br />
comfortable seat and a table. Since nobody<br />
teaches the gondola sculling art in<br />
Ukraine, Humeniuk had to master this<br />
skill on his own: he watched video tutorials,<br />
read books and perused dozens<br />
of films. He admits that gondola is<br />
harder to steer than an ordinary boat.<br />
Moreover, in addition to the skill, one<br />
needs to have permission for boat rowing<br />
on the Southern Buh River.<br />
A gondola ride along the Southern<br />
Buh River costs 250 hryvnias. In this<br />
way, Humeniuk tries to raise funds for<br />
his dream: to open a school of Ukrainian<br />
gondoliers, because the number of<br />
clients willing to ride in the gondola increases<br />
all the time, so he is becoming<br />
unable to serve them all.<br />
UKRAINIAN NEWS IN <strong>ENG</strong>LISH<br />
www.day.kiev.ua incognita.day.kiev.ua<br />
FOUNDER AND PUBLISHER:<br />
UKRAINIAN PRESS GROUP LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY<br />
Published since May 27, 1998.<br />
Свiдоцтво про перереєстрацiю КВ № 21448-11248 ПР<br />
вiд 27 липня 2015 року<br />
Larysa Ivshyna, Editor-in-Chief, Den<br />
e-mail: chedit@day.kiev.ua<br />
Hanna Sheremet, Deputy Editor-in-Chief<br />
Anna Mazurenko, Director,<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Anna Motoziuk, Editor,<br />
English Language Bureau<br />
Olha Pavliei, Technical Editor<br />
Borys Honcharov, George Skliar, Taras Shulha,<br />
Nadia Sysiuk, Translators<br />
Maryna Khyzhniakova, Proofreader<br />
Marharyta Motoziuk, Designer<br />
Alla Bober, Responsible Secretary<br />
Mykola Tymchenko, Photography Editor<br />
Mailing address: prosp. Peremohy, 121d, Kyiv 03115, Ukraine<br />
Telephone: +38(044) 303-96-19<br />
Fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
Advertising: +38(044) 303-96-20; e-mail: ra@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscriptions: +38(044) 303-96-23; e-mail: amir@day.kiev.ua<br />
E-mail: time@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscription index: 40032<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Code 24249388<br />
Raiffeisen Bank joint-stock company<br />
MFO 380805<br />
A/С 26007478064<br />
Responsibility for the accuracy of facts, quotations, personal names, and other information is borne by the authors of publications and in advertising<br />
materials by the advertiser. The views expressed in signed articles do not necessarily reflect those of the editors. Submitted materials are not returned<br />
and not reviewed. The editors retain the right to edit materials. When citing Day materials, reference to The Day is mandatory. ©Den.