white_paper_on_data_protection_in_india_171127_final_v2

9.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 129
(i) The right to object to processing............................................................................................... 129
(ii) The right to object to processing for the purpose of direct marketing ...................................... 129
(iii) Right to not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing ........................ 130
(iv) Right to Restrict Processing ...................................................................................................... 130
(v) Right to Data Portability ........................................................................................................... 131
9.2 Issues ........................................................................................................................................ 131
(i) Costly implementation .............................................................................................................. 131
(ii) Inchoate nature of rights ........................................................................................................... 132
(iii) Unsuitability for India............................................................................................................... 132
(iv) Overlap with sector-specific regulations .................................................................................. 133
(v) Automated Decision Making .................................................................................................... 133
9.3 International Practices .............................................................................................................. 133
9.4 Provisional Views ..................................................................................................................... 135
9.5 Questions .................................................................................................................................. 136
Chapter 10: Individual Participation Rights 3- Right to be forgotten ......................................... 137
10.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 137
10.2 Issues ........................................................................................................................................ 138
(i) Conflict with freedom of speech ............................................................................................... 138
(ii) Compliance of Third Parties ..................................................................................................... 139
10.3 International Practices .............................................................................................................. 139
10.4 Provisional Views ..................................................................................................................... 141
10.5 Questions .................................................................................................................................. 141
PART IV ............................................................................................................................................ 143
Regulation And Enforcement .......................................................................................................... 143
Chapter 1: Enforcement Models ..................................................................................................... 143
1.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 143
1.2 Types of Enforcement Models .................................................................................................. 144
(i) ‗Command and control‘ regulation ........................................................................................... 144
(ii) Self-regulation .......................................................................................................................... 144
(iii) Co-regulation ............................................................................................................................ 145
1.3 Provisional Views ..................................................................................................................... 146
1.4 Questions .................................................................................................................................. 146
Chapter 2: Accountability and Enforcement Tools ....................................................................... 147
Accountability ..................................................................................................................................... 147
2.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 147
2.2 Issues ........................................................................................................................................ 149
2.3 International Practices .............................................................................................................. 151
2.4 Provisional Views ..................................................................................................................... 155
2.5 Questions .................................................................................................................................. 155
Enforcement Tools .............................................................................................................................. 157
2.6 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 157
A. Codes Of Practice ................................................................................................................... 157
2.7 Issues ........................................................................................................................................ 157
2.8 International Practices .............................................................................................................. 158
2.9 Provisional Views ..................................................................................................................... 159
2.10 Questions .................................................................................................................................. 159
B. Personal Data Breach Notification ........................................................................................ 161
viii