Pausanias_Travel_Writing_in_Ancient Greece [Maria_Pretzler]

MACEDONIA is Greek and will always be Greek- (if they are desperate to steal a name Monkeydonkeys suits them just fine) ΦΕΚ, ΚΚΕ,ΚΟΜΜΟΥΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΣΥΡΙΖΑ, ΠΑΣΟΚ, ΝΕΑ ΔΗΜΟΚΡΑΤΙΑ, ΕΓΚΛΗΜΑΤΑ, MACEDONIA,ΣΥΜΜΟΡΙΤΟΠΟΛΕΜΟΣ, ΑΝΘΕΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΥΠΟΥΡΓΕΙΟ,ΕΝΟΠΛΕΣ ΔΥΝΑΜΕΙΣ, ΣΤΡΑΤΟΣ, ΑΕΡΟΠΟΡΙΑ, ΑΣΤΥΝΟΜΙΑ, ΔΗΜΑΡΧΕΙΟ, ΝΟΜΑΡΧΙΑ, ΠΑΝΕΠΙΣΤΗΜΙΟ, ΛΟΓΟΤΕΧΝΙΑ, ΔΗΜΟΣ, LIFO, ΠΕΡΙΦΕΡΕΙΑ,ΕΚΚΛΗΣΙΑ, ΜΟΝΗ, ΠΑΤΡΙΑΡΧΕΙΟ,ΜΕΣΗ ΕΚΠΑΙΔΕΥΣΗ, ΙΑΤΡΙΚΗ, ΟΛΜΕ, ΦΙΛΟΛΟΓΙΚΑ, ΝΟΜΟΘΕΣΙΑ, ΔΙΚΗΓΟΡΙΚΟΣ, ΣΥΜΒΟΛΑΙΟΓΡΑΦΙΚΟΣ, ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΑ, ΜΑΘΗΜΑΤΙΚΑ,ΝΕΟΛΑΙΑ, ΟΙΚΟΝΟΜΙΚΑ,ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑ,ΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΑ, ΑΥΓΗ, ΤΑ ΝΕΑ, ΕΘΝΟΣ, ΣΟΣΙΑΛΙΣΜΟΣ, LEFT, ΚΟΚΚΙΝΟ,ATHENS VOICE, ΡΑΤΣΙΣΜΟΣ,ΠΡΟΣΦΥΓΕΣ,GREECE,ΚΟΣΜΟΣ, ΜΑΓΕΙΡΙΚΗ, ΣΥΝΤΑΓΕΣ,ΕΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΕΛΛΑΔΑ, ΕΜΦΥΛΙΟΣ, ΤΗΛΕΟΡΑΣΗ, ΕΓΚΥΚΛΙΟΣ, ΡΑΔΙΟΦΩΝΟ, ΓΥΜΝΑΣΤΙΚΗ,ΠΟΛΙΤΙΚΑΝΤΗΔΕΣ, ΠΑΤΡΙΔΑ, ΒΙΒΛΙΟ, ΕΡΕΥΝΑ, ΠΟΛΙΤΙΚΗ, ΚΥΝΗΓΕΤΙΚΑ, ΚΥΝΗΓΙ, ΘΡΙΛΕΡ, ΠΕΡΙΟΔΙΚΟ, ΤΕΥΧΟΣ, ΜΥΘΙΣΤΟΡΗΜΑ, ΑΔΩΝΙΣ ΓΕΩΡΓΙΑΔΗΣ, ADONIS GEORGIADIS, ΦΑΝΤΑΣΤΙΚΕΣ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΕΣ, ΑΣΤΥΝΟΜΙΚΑ,ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΚΗ, ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΚΑ,ΙΚΕΑ, ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΑ, ΑΤΤΙΚΗ, ΘΡΑΚΗ,ΘΕΣΣΑΛΟΝΙΚΗ, ΙΟΝΙΟ, ΧΡΗΜΑ, ΚΩΣ, ΡΟΔΟΣ, ΚΑΒΑΛΑ, ΜΟΔΑ, ΔΡΑΜΑ, ΣΕΡΡΕΣ, ΕΥΡΥΤΑΝΙΑ, ΠΑΡΓΑ, ΚΕΦΑΛΟΝΙΑ, ΠΑΞΟΙ, ΙΩΑΝΝΙΝΑ, ΛΕΥΚΑΔΑ, ΠΑΤΡΑ, ΣΠΑΡΤΗ, ΧΙΟΣ, ΜΥΤΙΛΗΝΗ MACEDONIA is Greek and will always be Greek- (if they are desperate to steal a name Monkeydonkeys suits them just fine)
ΦΕΚ, ΚΚΕ,ΚΟΜΜΟΥΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΣΥΡΙΖΑ, ΠΑΣΟΚ, ΝΕΑ ΔΗΜΟΚΡΑΤΙΑ, ΕΓΚΛΗΜΑΤΑ, MACEDONIA,ΣΥΜΜΟΡΙΤΟΠΟΛΕΜΟΣ, ΑΝΘΕΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΥΠΟΥΡΓΕΙΟ,ΕΝΟΠΛΕΣ ΔΥΝΑΜΕΙΣ, ΣΤΡΑΤΟΣ, ΑΕΡΟΠΟΡΙΑ, ΑΣΤΥΝΟΜΙΑ, ΔΗΜΑΡΧΕΙΟ, ΝΟΜΑΡΧΙΑ, ΠΑΝΕΠΙΣΤΗΜΙΟ, ΛΟΓΟΤΕΧΝΙΑ, ΔΗΜΟΣ, LIFO, ΠΕΡΙΦΕΡΕΙΑ,ΕΚΚΛΗΣΙΑ, ΜΟΝΗ, ΠΑΤΡΙΑΡΧΕΙΟ,ΜΕΣΗ ΕΚΠΑΙΔΕΥΣΗ, ΙΑΤΡΙΚΗ, ΟΛΜΕ, ΦΙΛΟΛΟΓΙΚΑ, ΝΟΜΟΘΕΣΙΑ, ΔΙΚΗΓΟΡΙΚΟΣ, ΣΥΜΒΟΛΑΙΟΓΡΑΦΙΚΟΣ, ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΑ, ΜΑΘΗΜΑΤΙΚΑ,ΝΕΟΛΑΙΑ, ΟΙΚΟΝΟΜΙΚΑ,ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑ,ΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΑ, ΑΥΓΗ, ΤΑ ΝΕΑ, ΕΘΝΟΣ, ΣΟΣΙΑΛΙΣΜΟΣ, LEFT, ΚΟΚΚΙΝΟ,ATHENS VOICE, ΡΑΤΣΙΣΜΟΣ,ΠΡΟΣΦΥΓΕΣ,GREECE,ΚΟΣΜΟΣ, ΜΑΓΕΙΡΙΚΗ, ΣΥΝΤΑΓΕΣ,ΕΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ, ΕΛΛΑΔΑ, ΕΜΦΥΛΙΟΣ, ΤΗΛΕΟΡΑΣΗ, ΕΓΚΥΚΛΙΟΣ, ΡΑΔΙΟΦΩΝΟ, ΓΥΜΝΑΣΤΙΚΗ,ΠΟΛΙΤΙΚΑΝΤΗΔΕΣ, ΠΑΤΡΙΔΑ, ΒΙΒΛΙΟ, ΕΡΕΥΝΑ, ΠΟΛΙΤΙΚΗ, ΚΥΝΗΓΕΤΙΚΑ, ΚΥΝΗΓΙ, ΘΡΙΛΕΡ, ΠΕΡΙΟΔΙΚΟ, ΤΕΥΧΟΣ, ΜΥΘΙΣΤΟΡΗΜΑ, ΑΔΩΝΙΣ ΓΕΩΡΓΙΑΔΗΣ, ADONIS GEORGIADIS, ΦΑΝΤΑΣΤΙΚΕΣ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΕΣ, ΑΣΤΥΝΟΜΙΚΑ,ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΚΗ, ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΚΑ,ΙΚΕΑ, ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΑ, ΑΤΤΙΚΗ, ΘΡΑΚΗ,ΘΕΣΣΑΛΟΝΙΚΗ, ΙΟΝΙΟ, ΧΡΗΜΑ, ΚΩΣ, ΡΟΔΟΣ, ΚΑΒΑΛΑ, ΜΟΔΑ, ΔΡΑΜΑ, ΣΕΡΡΕΣ, ΕΥΡΥΤΑΝΙΑ, ΠΑΡΓΑ, ΚΕΦΑΛΟΝΙΑ, ΠΑΞΟΙ, ΙΩΑΝΝΙΝΑ, ΛΕΥΚΑΔΑ, ΠΑΤΡΑ, ΣΠΑΡΤΗ, ΧΙΟΣ, ΜΥΤΙΛΗΝΗ

16.01.2018 Views

7. Describing a City can be a matter of scholarly dispute. 19 Most ancient cities pose a much more complex problem: very few settlement sites have been investigated in sufficient detail to allow a study of urban topography beyond the most prominent public spaces. Moreover, Pausanias’ imprecise directions, combined with his habit of ignoring residential quarters, often do not offer enough guidance to warrant a systematic search for the remains of monuments he is describing. Apart from Athens, which is altogether exceptional, there are only a few cities where the urban topography described in the Periegesis can be reconstructed with some confidence, and Corinth is the best example. 20 Hutton’s meticulous analysis demonstrates that Pausanias’ description there follows a plan which echoes his way of organising the countryside, and it is likely that he treated other cities in a similar way. The tour usually starts in the agora and then follows radial routes as far as the city walls, describing everything that is worth noting along the way. 21 This system was not rigid, but could be adapted to local circumstances. In Tegea the starting point is the temple of Athena Alea rather than the market-place, which emphasises its status as a prominent ancient sanctuary and the city’s most famous attraction. Pausanias does not indicate its location south-west of the city, just outside the walls. 22 The description continues with a few sights ‘not far from the temple’, namely the stadium, a spring ‘north of the temple’ and a temple of Hermes three stadia from the spring. This is followed by a discussion of the temple of Athena Poliatis (‘of the City’) which one would expect to find inside the city walls. 23 The remark that the spring was north of the sanctuary of Athena Alea suggests that Pausanias is on his way towards the agora. The subsequent description of the town begins with the monuments around the market-place and then moves on to the theatre, which is ‘not far from the agora’. Here the description halts for four chapters to accommodate the biography of Philopoimen. 24 After this, further notable monuments are listed, apparently in other parts of the town, but the text offers no more than a very vague idea of their locations. The following extract contains all the topographical information provided in this final part of the description of the city. The Tegeans have four images of Agyieus, one set up by each tribe. … There is also at Tegea a temple of Demeter and Kore, whom they call Fruitbringers, and close by is one of Paphian Aphrodite. … Not far from it are two sanctuaries of Dionysos, an altar of Kore, and a temple of Apollo with a gilded image. … Next to Apollo stands a stone statue of Cheirisophos. The Tegeans also have what they call the Common Hearth of the Arkadians. In this place there is an image of Herakles. … The high place with most of the altars of the Tegeans is called the place of Zeus Klarios. … I also saw the following things in Tegea: the house of Aleos, the tomb of Echemos, and, engraved on a stele, the fight between Echemos and Hyllos. As you go from Tegea towards Lakonia, there is on the left of the road an altar of Pan, and another of Zeus Lykaios. 25 (Paus. 8.53.6-11) 95

Pausanias: Travel Writing in Ancient Greece Some sights are presented without any information about their location, but at first Pausanias seems to follow a route, describing monuments in relation to each other. The elevated place (chôrion hypsêlon) with the altars has not been identified, since there are no notable hills within the territory of the ancient city, but Pausanias’ usual mode of city descriptions suggests that he is still inside the town. The point where he moves on to the countryside is reached suddenly, but it is clearly marked by indicating the road to Lakonia. This description provides only a very vague notion of the layout of Tegea, and we get no sense of what the city looked like. 26 Pausanias’ mental site maps become far more structured and distinct once their historical component is taken into account. The noteworthy objects described at a site may not be well located in space, but usually they are linked to a particular point in time. An object does not itself need to date to the correct period to represent a specific aspect of the past: it is usually enough if it evokes a relevant memory, as may a work of art that is much later than the period in question but that depicts an important character or aspect of the story. These chronological links are rarely explicit and they may not always be immediately apparent to a modern reader. Almost every monument comes with a story or at least a reference to a prominent figure or event, which would allow an ancient pepaideumenos to connect it with a particular generation or period. In addition, Pausanias’ genealogies and historical accounts provide a chronological framework which accommodates most of the events or characters he mentions in his site descriptions. This combination of theôrêmata and logoi, description and comments, is characteristic for the Periegesis, and in order to understand the structure of Pausanias’ Greek landscape it is important to consider them together, as the author intended. Monuments or stories are not just fixed in the local topography: they are also assigned their place in time. In the larger cities this produces a mental map with historical layers which surface in different locations in the town or the surrounding countryside wherever a place is in some way connected with a particular period or story. I return to Tegea to illustrate how Pausanias’ text reflects the historical topography. The description starts with a typical historical introduction which summarises a few highlights of the city’s past without attempting a continuous narrative. The Tegeans say that under Tegeates, son of Lykaon, only the region was named after him, and the inhabitants lived in villages (dêmoi) … In the reign of Apheidas a ninth deme, called Apheidantes, was added. Aleos was the founder of the modern city. Apart from the events in which they participated together with the Arkadians, which include the Trojan War, the Persian Wars and the battle at Dipaia against the Spartans, and, apart from what has already been mentioned, the Tegeans have the following famous deeds of their own: in spite of his wounds Ankaios, the son of Lykourgos, stood up to the Kalydonian Boar. … When the Herakleidai returned to the Pelopon- 96

7. Describ<strong>in</strong>g a City<br />

can be a matter of scholarly dispute. 19<br />

Most ancient cities pose a much<br />

more complex problem: very few settlement sites have been <strong>in</strong>vestigated<br />

<strong>in</strong> sufficient detail to allow a study of urban topography beyond the most<br />

prom<strong>in</strong>ent public spaces. Moreover, <strong>Pausanias</strong>’ imprecise directions, comb<strong>in</strong>ed<br />

with his habit of ignor<strong>in</strong>g residential quarters, often do not offer<br />

enough guidance to warrant a systematic search for the rema<strong>in</strong>s of monuments<br />

he is describ<strong>in</strong>g. Apart from Athens, which is altogether<br />

exceptional, there are only a few cities where the urban topography<br />

described <strong>in</strong> the Periegesis can be reconstructed with some confidence, and<br />

Cor<strong>in</strong>th is the best example. 20 Hutton’s meticulous analysis demonstrates<br />

that <strong>Pausanias</strong>’ description there follows a plan which echoes his way of<br />

organis<strong>in</strong>g the countryside, and it is likely that he treated other cities <strong>in</strong><br />

a similar way. The tour usually starts <strong>in</strong> the agora and then follows radial<br />

routes as far as the city walls, describ<strong>in</strong>g everyth<strong>in</strong>g that is worth not<strong>in</strong>g<br />

along the way. 21 This system was not rigid, but could be adapted to local<br />

circumstances.<br />

In Tegea the start<strong>in</strong>g po<strong>in</strong>t is the temple of Athena Alea rather than the<br />

market-place, which emphasises its status as a prom<strong>in</strong>ent ancient sanctuary<br />

and the city’s most famous attraction. <strong>Pausanias</strong> does not <strong>in</strong>dicate its<br />

location south-west of the city, just outside the walls. 22<br />

The description<br />

cont<strong>in</strong>ues with a few sights ‘not far from the temple’, namely the stadium,<br />

a spr<strong>in</strong>g ‘north of the temple’ and a temple of Hermes three stadia from<br />

the spr<strong>in</strong>g. This is followed by a discussion of the temple of Athena Poliatis<br />

(‘of the City’) which one would expect to f<strong>in</strong>d <strong>in</strong>side the city walls. 23 The<br />

remark that the spr<strong>in</strong>g was north of the sanctuary of Athena Alea suggests<br />

that <strong>Pausanias</strong> is on his way towards the agora. The subsequent description<br />

of the town beg<strong>in</strong>s with the monuments around the market-place and<br />

then moves on to the theatre, which is ‘not far from the agora’. Here the<br />

description halts for four chapters to accommodate the biography of Philopoimen.<br />

24 After this, further notable monuments are listed, apparently<br />

<strong>in</strong> other parts of the town, but the text offers no more than a very vague<br />

idea of their locations. The follow<strong>in</strong>g extract conta<strong>in</strong>s all the topographical<br />

<strong>in</strong>formation provided <strong>in</strong> this f<strong>in</strong>al part of the description of the city.<br />

The Tegeans have four images of Agyieus, one set up by each tribe. … There<br />

is also at Tegea a temple of Demeter and Kore, whom they call Fruitbr<strong>in</strong>gers,<br />

and close by is one of Paphian Aphrodite. … Not far from it are two<br />

sanctuaries of Dionysos, an altar of Kore, and a temple of Apollo with a gilded<br />

image. … Next to Apollo stands a stone statue of Cheirisophos.<br />

The Tegeans also have what they call the Common Hearth of the Arkadians.<br />

In this place there is an image of Herakles. … The high place with most<br />

of the altars of the Tegeans is called the place of Zeus Klarios. … I also saw<br />

the follow<strong>in</strong>g th<strong>in</strong>gs <strong>in</strong> Tegea: the house of Aleos, the tomb of Echemos, and,<br />

engraved on a stele, the fight between Echemos and Hyllos.<br />

As you go from Tegea towards Lakonia, there is on the left of the road an<br />

altar of Pan, and another of Zeus Lykaios. 25 (Paus. 8.53.6-11)<br />

95

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!