Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church

Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church

13.12.2012 Views

C D 1412A B DIFFICULTY 71 163 weakness and play are privations, of wisdom, power and prudence, respectively, but when they are attributed to God they clearly mean excess of wisdom, power and prudence. What with us counts as privation, with God is certainly rightly taken to mean possession; while what with us counts as possession, with God is most fittingly taken to mean privation by excess. For the transcendent attributes of the divine, spoken of by us in a contrary sense as privations, fall a long way short of their true meaning. If this in its normal sense is true (for the divine never agrees with the human), then the mystery of the divine Incarnation is called the foolishness and weakness of God according to the holy Apostle Paul, and God’s play according to the wonderful and great teacher Gregory, since it oversteps in a way that transcends being every order and harmony of all nature and power and energy. This the most divine David beheld from afar and in this he was initiated at the level of mind through the divine Spirit, so that he expressed beforehand the apostolic interpretation of the transcendent possession of God through privation, calling out (I think with reference to the Jews), In the multitude of your power your enemies will lie about you (Psa. 65:3). For every human being is certainly an enemy of God and clearly established as a liar who ignorantly and irreverently includes God in the law of nature and has not begun to believe that he who is serenely beyond nature in reality came among those who are subject to nature and is able to fill with power the whole of nature. Thus from one point of view reason dares in a conjectural way 5 to behold the foolishness, the weakness and the play of God, by a digression in which it seeks a provisional interpretation of the difficulty before us, and reason takes the abyss calling to abyss in the noise of the divine cataracts to be the mind that reaches after knowledge and calls upon wisdom, and thus discerns a tiny reflection of the mysteries of the divine and ineffable descent among us. For the abyss and the place of the abyss are called by the same name, and thus the pure mind is established as the place of divine wisdom. Thus the mind is called abyss because of its capacity, and again wisdom is given the same name because of its nature. Another contemplation of the same With the help of divine grace, looking in another way at the difficulty before us—by way of conjecture6 rather than categorical assertion (for the one is modest, the other reckless)

164 TEXTS C D 1413A —we dare to take the Word before us and say that the play of God spoken of by the great teacher is a kind of keeping to the middle, staying equidistant from the extremes, by weaving about and quickly changing one’s position, or, to put it better, by a flowing that remains still. And this is the paradox: to behold stillness eternally flowing and being carried away, a flowing, eternally-moving, divinely contrived to contribute providentially to the improvement of the whole divine economy, capable of making wise those who are taught by it to hope always for change, and to believe that the end of this mystery for them is that by an inclination towards God they might be securely deified by grace. By the middle I mean the totality of things visible which now surround the human being or in which the human is; by the extremes I mean the reality of everything not manifest and which is going unfailingly to surround humanity, things that have properly and truly been made and come into being in accordance with the ineffable and preeminent purpose and reason of the divine goodness. 7 Just as the wise Preacher with the great and clear eye of the soul caught a glimpse of the coming into being of visible and flowing things and, as in a vision, of their being made and coming into being, and said, What is this that has been? It is the same as that which is going to be. And what is this that has been made? It is the same as that which is going to be made (Eccles. 1:9). Clearly he has in mind the first and the last things, as those which are themselves and truly are, and also the middle things, that pass away and are never in the same place. For when the teacher has come to an end of speaking grandiosely of a certain kind of living things and of stones, and of simply speaking boundlessly of the many things that can been seen in beings, 8 he adds ‘The high Word plays in every kind of form, mixing, as he wills, with his world here and there.’ Is it not therefore the same as what he says in his sermon on Holy Pentecost about divinity and created nature? ‘As long as each nature remains on its own, the one in its majesty, the other in its lowliness, his goodness remains unmixed and his love for human kind unshared, and there is a great gulf in the middle that cannot be crossed, which not only separates the rich man from Lazarus and the longed-for bosom of Abraham, 9 but also every nature that has come to be and is in a state of flux from that nature which has not come to be and is immutable.’ 10 Somewhat similar to this is what the great divine preacher Denys the Areopagite says: ‘We must dare to add this as being no less true: that the source of all

C<br />

D<br />

1412A<br />

B<br />

DIFFICULTY 71 163<br />

weakness and play are privations, of wisdom, power and<br />

prudence, respectively, but when they are attributed to God<br />

they clearly mean excess of wisdom, power and prudence. What<br />

with us counts as privation, with God is certainly rightly taken<br />

to mean possession; while what with us counts as possession,<br />

with God is most fittingly taken to mean privation by excess.<br />

For the transcendent attributes of the divine, spoken of by us<br />

in a contrary sense as privations, fall a long way short of their<br />

true meaning. If this in its normal sense is true (for the divine<br />

never agrees with the human), then the mystery of the divine<br />

Incarnation is called the foolishness and weakness of God<br />

according to the holy Apostle Paul, and God’s play according<br />

to the wonderful and great teacher Gregory, since it oversteps<br />

in a way that transcends being every order and harmony of all<br />

nature and power and energy. This the most divine David<br />

beheld from afar and in this he was initiated at the level of<br />

mind through the divine Spirit, so that he expressed<br />

beforehand the apostolic interpretation of the transcendent<br />

possession of God through privation, calling out (I think with<br />

reference to the Jews), In the multitude of your power your<br />

enemies will lie about you (Psa. 65:3). For every human being<br />

is certainly an enemy of God and clearly established as a liar<br />

who ignorantly and irreverently includes God in the law of<br />

nature and has not begun to believe that he who is serenely<br />

beyond nature in reality came among those who are subject to<br />

nature and is able to fill with power the whole of nature. Thus<br />

from one point of view reason dares in a conjectural way 5 to<br />

behold the foolishness, the weakness and the play of God, by a<br />

digression in which it seeks a provisional interpretation of the<br />

difficulty before us, and reason takes the abyss calling to abyss<br />

in the noise of the divine cataracts to be the mind that reaches<br />

after knowledge and calls upon wisdom, and thus discerns a<br />

tiny reflection of the mysteries of the divine and ineffable<br />

descent among us. For the abyss and the place of the abyss are<br />

called by the same name, and thus the pure mind is<br />

established as the place of divine wisdom. Thus the mind is<br />

called abyss because of its capacity, and again wisdom is given<br />

the same name because of its nature.<br />

Another contemplation of the same<br />

With the help of divine grace, looking in another way at the<br />

difficulty before us—by way of conjecture6 rather than<br />

categorical assertion (for the one is modest, the other reckless)

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!