Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church

Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church Andrew Louth - Syriac Christian Church

13.12.2012 Views

1177A B C TEXTS 135 behind all these things. For though he cannot accomplish the complete transition with his mind, or receive without intermediary the object of his desires which he knows through the mediation of its effects, he can readily put away the error that the world is without beginning, as he reasons truly that everything that moves must certainly begin to move. No motion is without beginning, since it is not without cause. For motion has a beginning, and a cause from which it is called and an end to which it is drawn. If the beginning of the movement of every moving thing is its motion, and its end the cause to which what is moved is borne (for nothing is moved without cause), then none of the beings is unmoved, except that which moves first (for that which moves first is completely unmoved, because it is without beginning), and none of the beings then is without beginning, because none is unmoved. 96 For every kind of being is moved, except for the sole cause which is unmoved and transcends all things, those beings that are intelligent and rational in a way in accordance with knowledge and understanding, because they are not knowledge itself or understanding itself. For neither is their knowledge or understanding their being, but something they acquire as they consider their being with correct judgment in accordance with mind and reason (what I call their constituent powers 97 ). 37 Contemplation of being, quantity and quality But that which is simply called being itself is not only the being of those things subject to change and corruption, moved in accordance with change and corruption, but also the being of all beings whatever that have been moved and are moved in accord ance with the reason and mode of expansion and contraction. For it is moved from the most universal kind through the more universal kinds to the forms, by which and in which everything is naturally divided, proceeding as far as the most specific forms, by a process of expansion [diastolê], circumscribing its being towards what is below, and again it is gathered together from the most specific forms, retreating through the more universal, up to the most universal kind, by a process of contraction [systolê], defining its being towards what is above. 98 Thus it can be described either way, either from above or from below, and is shown as possessing both beginning and end, not at all capable of being defined by

D 1180A 136 DIFFICULTY 10 B limitlessness. So it has quantity, not just the quantity of those things subject to change and corruption which are perceived to increase and decrease in every way naturally, but also every kind of quantity that can be circumscribed when it is moved by tightening and loosening and given form according to expansion by partial differences, without however flowing out into limitlessness, and again gathered together as it retreats in accordance with its kind, without however losing its natural form. Similarly with quality which is not just that moved by change in beings subject to change and corruption, but every kind of quality, moved according to difference in what is changeable and soluble, and receptive of expansion and contraction. For no-one can say that anything that can naturally be scattered and gathered together again either by reason or force can reasonably be thought to be completely unmoved. If it is not unmoved, it is not without beginning. If it is not without beginning, then clearly it is not ingenerate, but just as everyone knows that the motion of what is moved must have had a beginning, so anything that has come into being must have begun to come into being, receiving its being and movement from the sole One who has not come into being and is unmoved. That which has begun to come into being could not in any way be without beginning. 38 Proof that everything apart from God exists in a place 99 I should say, too, that the fact that beings exist in a certain way and not simply—that this, indeed, is the first form of circumscription—is a powerful factor in proving that beings have a beginning in respect of being and generation. Who is ignorant of the fact that every kind of being whatever, apart from the divine and unique being, which properly speaking exists beyond being itself, is already thought of as being somewhere, and that, together with this, it is necessarily thought of as certainly existing at some time? For space cannot be thought of, separate from and deprived of time (for they go together and one cannot be without the other), C nor can time be separated from and deprived of space, for they are naturally thought of together. By space, we mean that everything is shown as being in a place. For the totality of everything is not beyond the universe (for it is irrational and impossible to conceive of the universe itself as being beyond

1177A<br />

B<br />

C<br />

TEXTS 135<br />

behind all these things. For though he cannot accomplish the<br />

complete transition with his mind, or receive without<br />

intermediary the object of his desires which he knows through<br />

the mediation of its effects, he can readily put away the error<br />

that the world is without beginning, as he reasons truly that<br />

everything that moves must certainly begin to move. No<br />

motion is without beginning, since it is not without cause. For<br />

motion has a beginning, and a cause from which it is called<br />

and an end to which it is drawn. If the beginning of the<br />

movement of every moving thing is its motion, and its end the<br />

cause to which what is moved is borne (for nothing is moved<br />

without cause), then none of the beings is unmoved, except that<br />

which moves first (for that which moves first is completely<br />

unmoved, because it is without beginning), and none of the<br />

beings then is without beginning, because none is unmoved. 96<br />

For every kind of being is moved, except for the sole cause<br />

which is unmoved and transcends all things, those beings that<br />

are intelligent and rational in a way in accordance with<br />

knowledge and understanding, because they are not<br />

knowledge itself or understanding itself. For neither is their<br />

knowledge or understanding their being, but something they<br />

acquire as they consider their being with correct judgment in<br />

accordance with mind and reason (what I call their constituent<br />

powers 97 ).<br />

37<br />

Contemplation of being, quantity and quality<br />

But that which is simply called being itself is not only the<br />

being of those things subject to change and corruption, moved<br />

in accordance with change and corruption, but also the being<br />

of all beings whatever that have been moved and are moved in<br />

accord ance with the reason and mode of expansion and<br />

contraction. For it is moved from the most universal kind<br />

through the more universal kinds to the forms, by which and<br />

in which everything is naturally divided, proceeding as far as<br />

the most specific forms, by a process of expansion [diastolê],<br />

circumscribing its being towards what is below, and again it is<br />

gathered together from the most specific forms, retreating<br />

through the more universal, up to the most universal kind, by<br />

a process of contraction [systolê], defining its being towards<br />

what is above. 98 Thus it can be described either way, either<br />

from above or from below, and is shown as possessing both<br />

beginning and end, not at all capable of being defined by

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!