e_Paper, Sunday, July 23, 2017
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
24<br />
SUNDAY, JULY <strong>23</strong>, <strong>2017</strong><br />
DT<br />
Back Page<br />
INDO-BANGLA BORDER CHANGES DUE<br />
TO CONTINUOUS RIVER EROSION › 10<br />
<strong>2017</strong> MCC PLAYERS’<br />
DRAFT HELD › 19<br />
FILMS COMING OUT<br />
THIS EID › <strong>23</strong><br />
How did Hungama Ltd’s Tk2lakh investment<br />
make Tk13cr in profit?<br />
• Hitler A Halim<br />
SPECIAL <br />
Hungama Bangladesh Private Limited<br />
– an Indian digital media company<br />
– invested Tk2lakh in Bangladesh<br />
and has sent back nearly<br />
Tk13cr in profits to India.<br />
The profit is a whooping 320 times<br />
its original investment. Bangladesh<br />
Bank is treating the subject as an<br />
“unusual business activity.” As such,<br />
the central bank has twice asked the<br />
chairman of Bangladesh Telecommunication<br />
Regulatory Commission<br />
(BTRC) via letters on their opinion<br />
on “Hungama Bangladesh Private<br />
Limited sending excessive dividend<br />
to non-residential shareholders.”<br />
Bangladesh Bank alleges that<br />
Hungama invested only Tk2lakh in<br />
Bangladesh and has sent back profits<br />
in crores. In 2015, it sent back<br />
Tk6.74cr as dividend and in 2014 it<br />
was Tk6.07cr. The total dividend of<br />
the past two years is 320 times the<br />
original investment in Bangladesh.<br />
The central bank, in its investigation,<br />
found that Hungama Bangladesh<br />
has just one employee. It<br />
has no fixed assets in Bangladesh.<br />
The fact that a “small-capital”<br />
managed to raise profit 320 times<br />
its original investment has given<br />
Bangladesh Bank a cause for concern.<br />
In the letters to BTRC, Hungama<br />
is referred to as a “disreputable<br />
company with 100% foreign ownership”<br />
by Bangladesh Bank.<br />
Hungama Bangladesh is a subsidiary<br />
of India’s Hungama Digital<br />
Media Entertainment Private Limited.<br />
The company is helmed by<br />
Neeraj Roy, who serves as both the<br />
managing director and the chief executive<br />
officer. Hungama provides<br />
a diverse array of mobile services<br />
ranging from WAP, CRBT (Caller<br />
Ring Back Tone), IVR (Interactive<br />
Voice Recognition) and music<br />
streaming.<br />
Bangladesh Bank analysed the<br />
financial reports of Hungama and<br />
found that the majority of its income<br />
came from selling various services<br />
to different mobile operators.<br />
Bangladesh Bank Deputy General<br />
Manager (Foreign Exchange<br />
Investment Department) Md Ali<br />
Akbar Farazi signed the letter that<br />
was conveyed to the BTRC. In the<br />
letter, Bangladesh Bank asked if<br />
the provision of any such services<br />
required taking permission from<br />
the BTRC, and asked if there was<br />
any justification in permitting a<br />
“disreputable company which is<br />
fully owned by foreigners” and<br />
whether there should be any regulation<br />
in mobile phone operators<br />
charging such exorbitant prices in<br />
providing WAP, CRBT, IVR and music<br />
streaming services.<br />
Recently, Hungama applied to<br />
the BRRC for a shortcode service.<br />
The shortcode has been requested<br />
for e-entertainment services (music,<br />
wallpaper, animation, games,<br />
videos). Hungama paid the BTRC<br />
Tk1.15lakh (VAT inclusive) through<br />
a cheque. The shortcode application<br />
bears the authorisation of<br />
CEO-MD Neeraj Roy, followed by<br />
his phone number in India. The<br />
pad bears a Gulshan address, but<br />
no Bangladesh contact number or<br />
e-mail address.<br />
The BTRC has said that they will<br />
look into the matter after Bangladesh<br />
Bank expressed its concerns.<br />
The office of Hungama Bangladesh<br />
is located on Road 126 in Gulshan.<br />
They share an office with an<br />
accounting firm. A visit to the office<br />
on Thursday revealed that the digital<br />
media company occupies just<br />
one room, which often remains<br />
closed, even on weekdays. A CIMA<br />
employee said that the Hungama<br />
office has just one employee, who<br />
only shows up from time to time.<br />
Hungma is registered with the<br />
Bangladesh Office of the Registrat<br />
of Joint Stock Companies and<br />
Firms with the number C-86484.<br />
The contact number on the application<br />
was called and the receiver<br />
said it was the Mumbai office of<br />
Hungama. The received said Neeraj<br />
Roy was not in the office and his<br />
contact number was not permitted<br />
to be given out. After persisting,<br />
the call was transferred to a woman<br />
who identified herself as Priyanka,<br />
overseeing the Mumbai operations<br />
of Hungama.<br />
She said that Hungama operates<br />
out of their Gulshan office in Bangladesh.<br />
She failed to provide a reason<br />
when asked why the office was<br />
closed on weekdays.<br />
Priyanka also said that mobile<br />
phone users in Bangladesh purchase<br />
content from them. When<br />
asked for details, she could not provide<br />
any further insight.<br />
She took the caller’s number<br />
and said that the legal department<br />
of Hungama Digital Media will contact<br />
them with the details. But as<br />
of this report was written, nobody<br />
from Hungama reached out.<br />
Officials at several mobile<br />
phone operators in Bangladesh<br />
have revealed that their users often<br />
download songs, wallpapers,<br />
ringtones or welcome tunes from<br />
various content providers. The users<br />
are charged from their account<br />
balance. Businesses like Hungama<br />
share the profits with the mobile<br />
phone operators. Said profit has<br />
amounted to Tk13cr, which has<br />
been transferred back to India as<br />
dividend for the shareholders.<br />
BTRC Secretary Md Sarwar Alam<br />
said the central bank has informed<br />
that this firm has no fixed asset in the<br />
country and has only one employee.<br />
He said: “We have asked all the<br />
mobile phone operators to provide<br />
us with information to help with<br />
our investigation. Afterwards, we<br />
will decide on our next course of<br />
action.” •<br />
This story was first published on the<br />
Bangla Tribune.<br />
International Math Olympiad: Bangladesh best in South Asia<br />
• Tribune Desk<br />
FEATURE <br />
Bangladeshi students have won four<br />
medals, including two silver and two<br />
bronze, in the 58th International<br />
Mathematical Olympiad held in Rio de<br />
Janeiro, Brazil.<br />
Though one of the students missed out<br />
on a gold medal by one point, Bangladesh<br />
ranked 26th, while India finished 52nd, Sri<br />
Lanka 62nd, Pakistan 81st and Nepal 110th<br />
among 111 countries. Bangladesh was<br />
ranked in the 35th position last year.<br />
The silver medal winners are Asif-e-<br />
Elahi of MC College, Sylhet and Ahmed<br />
Jawad Chowdhury of Cantonment<br />
English School and College of Chittagong.<br />
The bronze winners are Tamjid<br />
Morshed Rubab of Notre Dame College<br />
and Rahul Saha of Dhaka College.<br />
Sabbir Rahman of Notre Dame<br />
College and AM Naimul Islam of Amrita<br />
The Hungama office has just one employee,<br />
who only shows up from time to time<br />
Lal Dey Mohabiddyaloy were given<br />
Honourable Mentions for their scores in<br />
the competition.<br />
Muhammad Zafar Iqbal, vice president<br />
of Bangladesh Mathematical Olympiad<br />
committee, said: “Missing gold for<br />
one point is heart breaking but I will not<br />
let this to ruin my joy. I am proud of our<br />
BdMO team and congratulate everyone.<br />
“It must be fun to beat every country<br />
in our region and climb 8 steps up in<br />
world ranking,” he added.<br />
The 58th International Mathematical<br />
Olympiad (IMO <strong>2017</strong>) was held in Rio de<br />
Janeiro of Brazil from <strong>July</strong> 12 to <strong>23</strong>.<br />
This was the first IMO to be held in<br />
Brazil. However, the history of the IMO<br />
goes back to 1959 when its first edition<br />
was held in Romania.<br />
Since then, the competition has<br />
provided a stimulus to mathematics,<br />
offering a great opportunity for the creative<br />
exchange of ideas and experiences<br />
among students from various cultures. • The Bangladesh team poses for a photo after the announcement PHOTO: COLLECTED<br />
Editor: Zafar Sobhan, Published and Printed by Kazi Anis Ahmed on behalf of 2A Media Limited at Dainik Shakaler Khabar Publications Limited, 153/7, Tejgaon Industrial Area, Dhaka-1208. Editorial, News & Commercial Office: FR Tower,<br />
8/C Panthapath, Shukrabad, Dhaka 1207. Phone: 9132093-94, Advertising: 9132155, Circulation: 9132282, Fax: News-9132192, e-mail: news@dhakatribune.com, info@dhakatribune.com, Website: www.dhakatribune.com