March - April 2012
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
MARCH - APRIL <strong>2012</strong><br />
ART - ARCHITECTURE - INTERIORS - ACCESSORIES<br />
www.spacesnepal.com<br />
RENOVATION<br />
for adaptive reuse<br />
The Story of Swotha<br />
Aluminium Composite Panels (ACP)<br />
Style or<br />
Sensi sibility<br />
Rustic<br />
radiance<br />
To<br />
HOUSE<br />
or not to house<br />
Price NRs. 100/- IRs. 65/-<br />
A HOME with a HABITATION<br />
AMA GHAR
JK cement
Jorpati,Kathmandu,Nepal<br />
Tel: 4911701, 4426554<br />
Fax:977-1-912868<br />
Email: info@topwinsys.com<br />
topwinsys@yahoo.com<br />
Website:www.topwinsys.com
Price NRs. 100/- IRs. 65/-<br />
20 HERITAGE<br />
The Story of Swotha<br />
by Ar. Swati Pujari<br />
The value of preservation and the preservation<br />
of values go hand in hand. A one year series<br />
on change and preservation begins with the<br />
renovation of two buildings at Swotha, Patan.<br />
Volume 8 Issue 3 <strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
46 ARCHITECTURE<br />
A Home with a Habitation - Ama Ghar<br />
by Ar. Kalpana Bhandari<br />
“Ama Ghar” or “Motherly Home” a home<br />
for orphans and underprivileged children, in<br />
Godavari, showcases minimalism in design;<br />
passive and active solar energy management;<br />
and waste and rain water management.<br />
46 ARCHITECTURE<br />
Aluminium Composite Panels (ACP)<br />
- Style or Sensibility<br />
by Ar. Shristi Shrestha<br />
Following the ongoing trend of using ACP or<br />
Aluminium Composite Panels, a comprehensive<br />
analysis of the material, its installation, its<br />
benefits and disadvantages<br />
42 ARCHITECTURE<br />
House or Not to House<br />
by Ar. Yatra Sharma<br />
A common sight along the river corridors of<br />
Kathmandu - the Sukumbasi or squatters, and the<br />
dilemma of eviction versus distributing land titles<br />
is discussed and analyzed here.<br />
20 ARCHITECTURE<br />
Rainwater Harvesting, a smart way<br />
of life!<br />
by Ar. Diskhya Poudyal<br />
“The term ‘GREEN’ is contextual. The concept<br />
of ‘Green Architecture’ means different in<br />
different places. For Nepal, Green Building is the<br />
building which is energy efficient, cost effective,<br />
structurally stable and sustainable.”<br />
-B. L. Shrestha<br />
MARCH - APRIL <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.spacesnepal.com<br />
www.spacesnepal.com<br />
ART - ARCHITECTURE - INTERIORS - ACCESSORIES<br />
16<br />
Interior<br />
Rustic Radiance<br />
by Artex Pvt. Ltd.<br />
‘Those who want to make it find a way, those<br />
who don’t, find a reason’ and interior designer<br />
Rishi Shroff has definitely found a way. Once a<br />
residence, the eatery - Grill me is now a challenge<br />
turned into an opportunity.<br />
COVER PHOTO : Ashesh Rajbansh<br />
50 ADVERTORIAL<br />
Just a Click Away<br />
by Ar. Swati Pujari<br />
Bipassana International - the up and coming<br />
name, buzzing in the field of home automation<br />
brings to you custom designed solutions in<br />
security and convenience - a Smart Home.<br />
RENOVATION<br />
for adaptive reuse<br />
The Story of Swotha<br />
Aluminium Composite Panels (ACP)<br />
Style or<br />
Sensi sibility<br />
ToHOUSE<br />
or not to house<br />
Rustic<br />
radiance<br />
A HOME with a HABITATION<br />
AMA GHAR<br />
50 BOOK RELEASE<br />
Architecture of the Newars<br />
Dr. Niels Gutschow presents a tribute to the<br />
heritage of Nepal - his three volume book<br />
‘Architecture of the Newars: A History of<br />
Building Typologies and Details in Nepal’ - a<br />
comprehensive compilation of 40 years of<br />
research.
Volume 8 Issue 3<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
Regd. No 30657/061-62 CDO No. 41<br />
Contributors<br />
Madan Chitrakar, a regular<br />
contributor to SPACES, is an<br />
artist, art critic, writer, and holds<br />
a masters degree in History and<br />
Culture besides a degree in Applied<br />
Art from J. J. School of Arts in<br />
Mumbai, India and Iconographic<br />
Design from the Netherlands. His<br />
writings on art include the book<br />
on his late father Tej B. Chitrakar, ‘Icon of a Transition’,<br />
published in 2004. He is presently associated as visiting<br />
faculty in the KU Centre for Art & Design. (madanc@ntc.<br />
net.np)<br />
Dikshya Poudyal received her<br />
B.Arch degree from IOE Pulchowk<br />
campus in 2010. She carries a<br />
passion for writing and believes<br />
that architecture has always been<br />
something that carries with it the<br />
essence of time and culture.<br />
Managing Editor<br />
Editor at Large<br />
Editors<br />
Public Relations<br />
Marketing<br />
Marketing /Correspondence<br />
Subscription/Marketing Ass.<br />
Contributing Art Editor<br />
Contributing Editors<br />
Contributors<br />
Accounts / Admin<br />
Senior Correspondent<br />
Photographers<br />
Design / Colour Separation<br />
Printed at<br />
Published by<br />
Ashesh Rajbansh<br />
Siddhartha Lama<br />
Ar. Swati Pujari<br />
Ar. Sushmita Ranjit Shrestha<br />
Prakash Bahadur Amatya<br />
Kripa Shrestha<br />
Kajal Pradhanang<br />
Anish Shrestha<br />
Madan Chitrakar<br />
Kasthamandap Art Studio<br />
Ar. Sworup G. Koney<br />
(President - Society of Nepalese Architects)<br />
Ar. Debesh Raj Bhattarai<br />
(General Secretary - Society of Nepalese Architects)<br />
Ar. Jinisha Jain (Delhi)<br />
Ar. Chetan Raj Shrestha (Sikkim)<br />
Barun Roy (Darjeeling Hills)<br />
Madan Chitrakar<br />
Ar. Dikshya Poudyal<br />
Dipa Shrestha<br />
Ar. Bansri Pandey<br />
Ar. Kalpana Bhandari<br />
Ashesh Rajbansh<br />
Pradip Ratna Tuladhar<br />
Digiscan Pre-Press<br />
Naxal, Kathmandu. Phone: 4436817<br />
Format Printing Press<br />
Hadigaon, Kathmandu. Phone: 4010160<br />
IMPRESSIONS Publishing Pvt.Ltd.<br />
Kupondole, Lalitpur<br />
Post Box No. 227, DPO Lalitpur<br />
Phone: 5544606<br />
Ar. Yatra Sharma, is a post<br />
graduate in Urban Management<br />
and Development studies from<br />
the Netherlands, Institute of<br />
Housing Studies. After graduating<br />
in Architecture from Pulchowk<br />
Engineering College, she was<br />
involved in various architectural<br />
projects in both government and<br />
private sector. Currently, she is teaching at Khwopa<br />
Engineering College and is involved in a range of<br />
architectural and urban research works.<br />
(yatrasharma@gmail.com)<br />
DISTRIBUTION<br />
Kathmandu<br />
Mid & West Nepal<br />
Darjeeling<br />
Kalimpong, Gangtok<br />
R.B. Newspaper Traders, Kathmandu<br />
Ph: 4232784 / 4215652 / 4216658<br />
Allied Newspaper Distributor Pvt. Ltd., Kathmandu<br />
Ph: 4261948 / 4419466<br />
Sanjana Limbu<br />
The Digital Den<br />
Top Floor, New Super Market, Darjeeling - 734101<br />
Cell: 99323 - 85772 eMail:subbaangel@yahoo.com<br />
ADVERTISING & SUBSCRIPTIONS<br />
Kathmandu IMPRESSIONS Publishing Pvt.Ltd.<br />
Ph: 5544606<br />
email: market@spacesnepal.com<br />
Birgunj Kishore Shrestha, Hotel Kailash, Adarsha Nagar.<br />
Ph: 522384, 529984. email: hotelkailash@wlink.com.np<br />
Itahari Naya Bazar, Dharan - 05<br />
Biratnagar Ph: 025-5-21164/025-525118, Cell: 9842054110<br />
Shristi Shrestha is a final year<br />
architecture student at Nepal<br />
Engineering College, Bhaktapur.<br />
She has worked as a trainee<br />
architect with John Sanday<br />
Associates in Kathmandu, and<br />
along with architecture journalism<br />
Shristi is also interested in<br />
interior design and energy<br />
efficient design.<br />
SPACES is published six times a year at the<br />
address above. All rights are reserved in<br />
respect of articles, illustrations, photographs,<br />
etc. published in SPACES. The contents<br />
of this publication may not be reproduced<br />
in whole or in part in any form without the<br />
written consent of the publisher. The opinions<br />
expressed by contributors are not necessarily<br />
those of the publisher and the publisher<br />
cannot accept responsiblility for any errors<br />
or omissions.<br />
Those submitting manuscripts, photographs,<br />
artwork or other materials to SPACES for<br />
consideration should not send originals<br />
unless specifically requested to do so by<br />
SPACES in writing. Unsolicited manuscripts,<br />
photographs and other submitted material<br />
must be accompanied by a self addressed<br />
return envelope, postage prepaid. However,<br />
SPACES is not responsible for unsolicited<br />
submissions. All editorial inquiries and<br />
submissions to SPACES must be addressed<br />
to editor@spacesnepal.com or sent to the<br />
address mentioned above.
from the editor<br />
What is building green? It’s not just another overly used phrase but in recent<br />
times, green buildings, sustainable architecture and energy conservation<br />
have become social, or rather existential, responsibilities. Gone are the days<br />
of low fuel efficiency - it is neither affordable nor appropriate. And it is not just<br />
about mechanics either. In this issue of SPACES, we focus on the matter of<br />
green buildings. Our writers mention how 40% of the total energy consumed<br />
in the world is used by buildings, thus highlighting the responsibility of the<br />
building sector towards sustainability, energy consumption - and about green<br />
architecture.<br />
The term ‘Green’ and its multiple façades were discussed in a recent seminar<br />
‘Towards Green Building’, organized by the Department of Architecture,<br />
Institute of Engineering, Pulchowk Campus and VSBK/ CESEF program<br />
Nepal. SPACES Magazine participated in this four day seminar and shares<br />
the experience in this issue. So what is Building Green? Is it about the<br />
use of materials, technology or energy? Is it even affordable to build a<br />
green building, or is the price of saving the planet too high for the limited<br />
budgets of the general public? The key points made at the seminar try to<br />
answer these questions, and their answer is that a green building can have<br />
different meanings in different places, and different contexts. To quote Ar. B.L.<br />
Shrestha of Shelter and Local Technology Development Center, “The term<br />
‘GREEN’ is contextual. The concept of ‘Green Architecture’ means different<br />
things in different places. For Nepal, Green Building is a building which is<br />
energy efficient, cost effective, structurally stable and sustainable.” One must<br />
understand that bigger is not always better- the bigger your building, the<br />
more energy it uses in lighting, heating, cooling etc. Also, more expensive<br />
is not always better. If the materials you use are very expensive, they either<br />
consumed a lot of labour, time, and energy in their production, or they were<br />
transported from a distance, increasing their energy consumption during<br />
transportation. Our writers bring to you issues, features and ramifications of<br />
building (and also not building), green.<br />
In this issue we also focus on building technologies, both old and new. We<br />
explore a once popular building trend using lime mortar/plaster called Bajra,<br />
, highlight entrepreneurs producing quality cement products for tiles and<br />
pavements, and feature how building materials are expanding the horizon<br />
for architects and designers enabling them to create innovative interiors and<br />
exteriors.. And for all our readers who love flipping through SPACES to see the<br />
architectural beauty of our buildings, outdoor spaces, palaces and courtyards,<br />
we bring to you ‘Traditional Homes, Swotha’. This primarily photographic<br />
feature of a recently opened Bed and Breakfast at Swotha, Patan, shows us<br />
the conversion and renovation of an old residence into a contemporary, well<br />
equipped building - a place where the old blends with the new.<br />
It is interesting to note how in architecture, like in many other fields, things<br />
come full circle. Our traditional buildings, which are already energy efficient,<br />
are renovated and reused by adding modern features. Meanwhile, our<br />
modern builders borrow the ideas of traditional construction to make new<br />
buildings ‘Green’. What goes around, comes aound it seems!
I AM<br />
SLEEK’S<br />
KITCHEN<br />
SPECIALIST<br />
Master Chef Sanjeev Kapoor<br />
As a specialist chef, Sanjeev Kapoor knows what it takes<br />
to make a great kitchen. So when he saw a Sleek<br />
Kitchen, he knew it is the best there can be. No wonder,<br />
he chose to be Sleek's Kitchen Specialist.<br />
“Sleek has everything that the modern homemaker<br />
needs. Aesthetic designs, efficient functionality and<br />
smart storage ideas… all of it at an affordable price.<br />
Kitchen solutions for every need and budget.<br />
KITCHEN CONCEPTS PVT. LTD.<br />
GPO Box N. 8975, EPC 2700, Teku Road, Kathmandu (Next to Bakery Café),<br />
Tel.: (01) 422 1858, 421 2097 Fax: (01) 421 6112.<br />
Email : nepalkitchen@wlink.com.np, Visit : wwwsleekworld.com<br />
Sleek Kitchen Concepts : Srijan Chowk, Pokhara, Tel: (061) 62 1863<br />
"Opening shortly at Koteswor, Kumaripati & Chitwan".
PRODUCTS<br />
1<br />
• A console, a lamp and 3 candle holders<br />
• Locally manufactured wooden console with custom designed inlays<br />
of Onyx ( Italian Marble), a ceramic base lamp and 3 lamp holders<br />
• Price: At request<br />
2<br />
• Dining Table with 6 chairs, a wooden console and attached mirror<br />
board, a lamp, a vase and a pair or urns<br />
• Veneer finished wooden furniture, Wooden Urns from Thailand<br />
• Price: at request<br />
3<br />
• Sofa with2 center tables, 1 circular side table, 1 side table, two lamps<br />
and a mirror<br />
• Teak veneer on wooden furniture, band of Egyptian Marble on<br />
centre wooden table, Egyptian marble top on side table with custom<br />
designed Onyx (Italian Marble) and glass inlays, a circular mirror<br />
with glass mosaic floral outline, 2 wooden base lamps from Thailand.<br />
• Price: at request<br />
2<br />
URBAN<br />
Design<br />
1<br />
3<br />
spacesnepal.com 16<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
PRODUCTS<br />
1<br />
MAC<br />
Decor<br />
2<br />
3<br />
1<br />
• A dining table with 6 chairs<br />
• Made of compressed wood, product of China<br />
• Price: NRs 71, 500.<br />
2<br />
• Lobby Console with Mirror<br />
• Material specific: Made of compressed<br />
wooden board, product of China<br />
• Price: NRs. 26,800.<br />
3<br />
• Bar Rack<br />
• Made of compressed wood and glass,<br />
product of China<br />
• Price: NRs 42,600.<br />
spacesnepal.com 18<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
19<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Ama Ghar - A Home<br />
with a Habitation, at<br />
Godawari amidst its<br />
serene surrounding<br />
MASTER PLAN<br />
spacesnepal.com 20<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
A HOME with a HABITATION<br />
AMA GHAR<br />
Text: Ar. Kalpana Bhandari<br />
Nepal, a developing country, still has an<br />
underdeveloped education and health system,<br />
especially with regard to children. According<br />
to UNICEF, 4.8% of children under the age of 5<br />
died in 2010; 650,000 children were orphaned in<br />
2009, and 39% of children under 5 years of age<br />
were underweight (according to World Health<br />
Organization). Statistics like this, and numerous<br />
other related issues like child marriage, child<br />
labour, urbanization etc, highlight the necessity to<br />
provide children with basic rights.<br />
With these very feelings, Mr. Shrawan Nepali,<br />
along with co-founders Ama Tika Basnet and<br />
Shekhar Silwal, initiated the Ama Foundation in<br />
2001. The word ‘Ama’ (literally meaning Mother)<br />
represents love, faith, affection and belonging<br />
in our culture. Ama Ghar was started under this<br />
foundation by Mr. Nepali to commemorate his<br />
upbringing by his godmother Ama Tika Basnet.<br />
“Ama Ghar” or “Motherly Home” is a home for<br />
orphans and underprivileged children, 20 kms<br />
south of Kathmandu, in Godavari. In <strong>2012</strong>, Ama<br />
Ghar moved from an abode for 14 children in a<br />
rented house, to its own building that houses as<br />
many as 46 children and 7 staff members.<br />
A passage in Ama Ghar with exposed brick<br />
walls and exposed concrete slabs/ lintels etc.<br />
decreasing the need for finishing material<br />
The DESIGN<br />
Besides being a home for children,<br />
Ama Ghar also features exemplary<br />
Green Architecture. The requirement<br />
for the building was to accommodate<br />
70 children and 30 staff members.<br />
The client also wanted the building<br />
to have a ‘home like’ environment<br />
instead of a ‘hostel’. The architect,<br />
Prabal Thapa, has designed the<br />
building with a minimalist approach,<br />
and whilst meeting the requirements,<br />
has also managed to keep the<br />
dependence on non- renewable<br />
sources of energy to a minimum.<br />
Ama Ghar is built on 13-ropanis of<br />
land (1 Ropani = 5476 Sq. Ft.). Since<br />
the area is contoured, sloping from<br />
east to west, the building is oriented<br />
towards the west to harmonize with<br />
the hills. Active and passive solar<br />
techniques have been incorporated<br />
for maximum usage of solar energy<br />
to meet heating and lighting needs.<br />
The building has open plumbing<br />
and electrical system which makes<br />
repair and maintenance hassle-free.<br />
In addition, the problem of water<br />
supply has been carefully tackled<br />
with wastewater management and<br />
rainwater harvesting. Ama Ghar<br />
is located on moist grounds so<br />
the French Drain foundation 1 was<br />
built to keep the building dry, and<br />
avoid any kind of seepage/leakage<br />
through floors.<br />
1<br />
French Drain is a trench covered with gravel or rock that redirects surface and groundwater away from an area. French drains are common drainage<br />
systems, primarily used to prevent ground and surface water from penetrating or damaging building foundations, Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/<br />
French_drain<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
21<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
PASSIVE SOLAR ENERGY<br />
Courtyard Planning<br />
The building of Ama Ghar is U-shaped,<br />
opening to the west. The northern wing<br />
is longer than the southern wing so that<br />
the rooms in the Northern and Eastern<br />
wing get the afternoon sun all year round.<br />
Since the kitchen and toilets are mostly<br />
occupied in the mornings, these rooms<br />
have been planned to receive the early<br />
morning sun, thus minimizing artificial<br />
lighting requirements. All rooms have<br />
cross ventilation to provide cooling<br />
requirements for summer.<br />
Planning and layout<br />
All the walls of Ama Ghar are 14” thick,<br />
in order to insulate the heat inside the<br />
building. The U-shaped building has<br />
common activity areas, and rooms for<br />
boys, girls, and staff or visitors. The ground<br />
floor of the northern wing has rooms for<br />
a children needing mobility assistance, a<br />
study/library, and access staircase to the<br />
boys’ rooms on the first floor. The eastern<br />
wing has a common activity room, office<br />
room for staff, and a staircase to the girls’<br />
rooms in upper floors. The southern wing<br />
houses the kitchen and the dining area –<br />
as well as covered sit-out spaces.<br />
Drainage pipes reveled in the building<br />
facade for easy access in maintenance<br />
A section of the building<br />
showing gutters in the<br />
multiple levels of the roof<br />
for rainwater harvesting<br />
The concrete block paved courtyard is<br />
used for games. The building as well<br />
as the courtyard faces the garden, and<br />
open fields to the west. The courtyard<br />
has raised platforms for plantations that<br />
are also used for seating. Since the site<br />
has contours, the amphitheatre space is<br />
designed in steps facing a gazebo that<br />
acts as a performing stage. The curved<br />
ramp is designed for ease of access for<br />
wheelchair users.<br />
Solar Path - the movement of<br />
sun and its apparent impact<br />
on the building and its active<br />
and passive solar techniques<br />
ACTIVE SOLAR TECHNIQUES<br />
PhotoVoltaic Cells (PV Cells) are<br />
positioned on the southern slope of the<br />
building. The electrical energy from PV<br />
Cells is adequate to light the rooms and<br />
cook rice in the kitchen of Ama Ghar.<br />
spacesnepal.com 22<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
THE MINIMALIST APPROACH<br />
Ama Ghar is minimalist in design<br />
and cost. The building has an<br />
exposed brick façade which<br />
eliminates the need of plaster<br />
and paint. The concrete surfaces<br />
are also exposed in ceilings and<br />
walls, without plaster or paint,<br />
which appears raw yet finished.<br />
The openings and balconies/<br />
verandahs are supported and<br />
covered by light metal sections. A<br />
traditional essence is maintained<br />
through the slope roof, facilitating<br />
rain water collection as well. The<br />
wooden rafters in the roof are visible,<br />
and so is the jhingati roof in some<br />
places. The rooms of children are<br />
open (i.e. no doors), thus reducing<br />
the cost of wooden fixtures. The<br />
aluminium windows further enhance<br />
the heating system in the building<br />
and avoid the problems caused by<br />
wooden windows such as sagging of<br />
sections, dust accumulation, termites<br />
attack, etc. The open plumbing and<br />
electrical systems reduce the cost<br />
of concealing these features. In<br />
addition, the lobby in the first floor<br />
has a skylight, thus reducing artificial<br />
lighting requirement.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
23<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
The kitchen of Ama Ghar, showing reveled electric<br />
wiring decreasing the need for concealing/ false<br />
ceiling as well as for easy maintenance<br />
GROUND FLOOR PLAN<br />
FIRST FLOOR PLAN<br />
spacesnepal.com 24<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
WATER TREATEMENT SYSTEM<br />
WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT<br />
Ama Ghar incorporates decentralized wastewater<br />
treatment system (DEWATS), along with organic waste<br />
management. The treatment system, designed for 100<br />
people, has treatment capacity of 8 cubic meters of waste<br />
water per day.<br />
The DEWATS here has three stages of wastewater<br />
treatment.<br />
The Primary Unit: The primary unit involves the<br />
sedimentation of wastewater and sludge, and their<br />
primary treatment in septic tanks. This unit treats black<br />
water and organic solids to produce 5m3 of bio gas per<br />
day, which fulfills one-third of fuel requirement for cooking.<br />
The Secondary Unit: In this unit, both black and grey<br />
water is treated in a chambered Anaerobic Baffled<br />
Reactor (ABR). The ABR reduces biological and chemical<br />
oxygen demand by anaerobic digestion inside the<br />
chambers.<br />
The Tertiary Unit: The final unit involves aerobic/anaerobic<br />
treatment inside Horizontally Planted Gravel Filters<br />
(HPGF) that reduces colours and odours.<br />
TOP FLOOR PLAN<br />
After tertiary treatment, the vegetables/garden plants<br />
absorb phosphorus and nitrogen. The treated water is<br />
used for flushing of toilets and gardening, thus, decreasing<br />
the use/ requirement of fresh water. The byproduct,<br />
biological and chemical oxygen demand (BOD and COD,<br />
or the biological and chemical remnants), are discharged<br />
into the nearby Godavari River.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
25<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
RAINWATER HARVESTING<br />
In maintaining a traditional Nepali homes<br />
essence, the sloped roofs of Ama Ghar drain<br />
the rain water to gutters and pipes for rain water<br />
harvesting. After adequate treatment, the water<br />
is collected in a separate tank. This harvested<br />
rainwater is adequate for household purposes for<br />
5-6 months every year.<br />
Ama Ghar has synchronized architecture with<br />
energy sustaining methods, thus, making it an<br />
example of sustainable architecture. The Ama<br />
Ghar building not only reflects traditional Nepali<br />
Architecture in its exterior, it also demonstrates a<br />
practical approach to environmentally sustainable<br />
technology as a whole. While the city faces<br />
drought and power shortage most of the time,<br />
these aspects of water supply and electricity<br />
are well tackled at Ama Ghar. Architectural<br />
aestheticism, structural stability, ecological<br />
sustainability and cost effectiveness are assets<br />
of Ama Ghar. It is also an exemplary building<br />
that highlights the importance of non-renewable<br />
energy, and advantages of renewable sources of<br />
energy. It is obvious that the current power cuts,<br />
inadequate water supply, and gas shortage can<br />
be tackled with careful investment in environment<br />
friendly and ecologically sustainable technologies<br />
in the construction of a building. •<br />
spacesnepal.com 26<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
27<br />
spacesnepal.com
ADVERTORIAL<br />
Control via i-Phone, i-Pad and Android devices<br />
JUST A<br />
Click away...<br />
Text: Ar. Swati Pujari<br />
YYou open your eyes in the morning to your favourite tune, walk into the<br />
shower and your geyser is already turned on, by the time you step out,<br />
your coffee machine is brewing your favourite coffee. Sipping on the freshly<br />
brewed coffee you turn on the television and catch up on the morning news.<br />
When you leave for work, you don’t have to worry if the lights are still on or if<br />
you forgot to turn off the television, you can check the lights (and just about<br />
anything else) from your computer or your phone and turn them off or on as<br />
you like, or have a customized setting that turns off all selected fixtures and<br />
appliances when the clock says it’s your office time. When you come back<br />
home, your house greets you with a warm flood of lights and music, so you<br />
don’t enter a cold dark building. When you go to sleep, you can turn off all<br />
the lights, or keep the night lights on as per your convenience, and activate<br />
a security field in and around your house, with just a click of a button, while<br />
comfortably wrapping up in your blanket.<br />
This is precisely what Bipassana International strives to bring to you, a house<br />
that is customized to fit your needs and choices, providing you the comfort<br />
spacesnepal.com 28<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ADVERTORIAL<br />
2<br />
1<br />
1. Entrance Scenario Switch to control customized<br />
lights, all at once<br />
2. Access Control to activate the lock as well as<br />
other automation features like curtains, lights,<br />
security sensors, etc.<br />
3. Video Door Phone to view and talk to visitors<br />
from inside your home, then let them inside with<br />
the press of a button.<br />
3<br />
and security you would expect at a<br />
place you call home. The design of<br />
a residence comes from its users;<br />
your home should fit your needs<br />
and nobody else’s. That is why you<br />
employ a designer - to understand<br />
your needs as a user or as an owner<br />
and put to paper and then to the site<br />
what is most appropriate for you,<br />
considering your lifestyle and your<br />
budget. Home automation systems<br />
are basically the next frontier in this<br />
process. Just as the placement of<br />
your windows bring in natural light<br />
and ventilation where you need it,<br />
and the placement of your furniture<br />
allows you to use your space as per<br />
your wish and needs, similarly, a well<br />
designed automation system helps<br />
you safeguard and use your home<br />
and all its aspects the way you need.<br />
It also brings control of your entire<br />
house to your fingertips.<br />
Bipassana International is an up<br />
and coming name in the field of<br />
home automation in Nepal, and<br />
a conversation with Mr. Keyur K.<br />
Shrestha, its Managing Director,<br />
lets you know why. Bipassana<br />
International is not just a supplier of<br />
products related to home automation,<br />
neither is it a company that simply<br />
installs foreign products in your<br />
home. Rather it customizes its<br />
products and services, gives you<br />
consultations, and helps you make<br />
the right choice that suits your<br />
requirements - while keeping in<br />
mind your budget.<br />
A project at Bipassana starts with<br />
site visits and/ or requirement<br />
studies; understanding the client’s<br />
needs is vital. The next step is the<br />
actual design and consultations.<br />
There are a variety of products and<br />
features available and according to<br />
your requirements and budget, a<br />
custom design of your automation<br />
system is provided to you. At the<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
29<br />
spacesnepal.com
ADVERTORIAL<br />
Wireless door sensor.<br />
Gas leak sensors, Motion sensors,<br />
Glass break sensors are also available<br />
Upload your floor plans to control your<br />
features with an extra level of convenience<br />
Curtain control switch and multi room<br />
audio keypad<br />
Lighting automation switches and 5.7 inches<br />
touch screen interface<br />
core of this design are the features<br />
of Security, Surveillance, Lighting,<br />
Energy Management, Access<br />
Control, Entertainment, Interfaces &<br />
Software and, Video Intercom. Once<br />
you are satisfied with the design of<br />
your system, installation drawings<br />
are prepared and Bipassana<br />
International provides you with the<br />
budgeting, bills of quantities, and<br />
recommendations regarding any<br />
issue in the design and installation.<br />
After installation, these techniques<br />
help you predefine customized<br />
settings for time of the day or your<br />
events and moods, thus identifying<br />
lights, music and security as per<br />
the occasion. For example, let’s<br />
say you are having a party. You can<br />
customize a setting called PARTY<br />
(for example), and just by clicking<br />
that option the system automatically<br />
dims the lights, turns on the<br />
fountains in your garden, plays<br />
your selected playlist, and maybe<br />
even throws laser beams to the sky<br />
and activates your security gate.<br />
Bipassana International actually<br />
provides a service not just in<br />
installing and design of the system,<br />
but customizing system settings as<br />
well, helping you set environments<br />
that makes you feel at home, no<br />
matter what your mood.<br />
So what exactly are the kinds of<br />
things home automation systems<br />
can control? Well firstly, you can<br />
have a video door phone at the<br />
entrance to your home, so when a<br />
visitor arrives and buzzes in, you<br />
can see who it is in your screen and<br />
talk to them via this door phone,<br />
and then decide whether to let<br />
the visitor in or not. You can install<br />
sensors in your driveway where, as<br />
you drive in after dark, the lights<br />
are automatically switched on, and<br />
a certain time after the driveway<br />
is cleared, they are switched off<br />
again. These sensors can detect<br />
occupancy and control the lights<br />
accordingly, thus ensuring there<br />
is no waste of energy. You can<br />
install smoke detectors that signal<br />
the system to turn off the air<br />
conditioning if smoke is detected<br />
in the house to avoid the spread<br />
of smoke. You can also select<br />
entertainment systems like movie<br />
rooms and home theatres, and<br />
have them custom designed and<br />
fully automated. You can install a<br />
music system that gives you the<br />
option of using a single music<br />
source, yet controlling it locally so it<br />
spacesnepal.com 30<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ADVERTORIAL<br />
Lighting is one of the most powerful methods interior designers use to change<br />
moods, add elegance and intimacy. Create scenes for different tasks in a room<br />
such as dining, reading a book or the entire family to celebrate a birthday party.<br />
can play different music in different<br />
parts of the house, all originating<br />
from the same source. You can<br />
install sensors in your doors and<br />
windows and check which of these<br />
are left open and which are closed,<br />
you can even check and control<br />
the operation of lights as well as<br />
curtains and blinds. You can install<br />
a security field in and around your<br />
house that, if breached, sends out<br />
eight different pre-recorded phone<br />
calls. You can install all this in either<br />
a wired connection concealed in<br />
the ceiling, walls etc, or select the<br />
wireless options. And all this you<br />
can control either from the system’s<br />
remote control or touch screen, or<br />
from your computer, laptop, i-pad,<br />
i-phones, android phones etc. via<br />
internet/ LAN.<br />
Understanding the current<br />
requirements of its clients,<br />
Bipassana International is also<br />
launching a compact automation<br />
system package called Milan that is<br />
focused on the semi private spaces<br />
in a house, primarily the living and<br />
dining area. This system offers<br />
security and affordability, whereby<br />
the entire system can be installed<br />
in an amount up to (not starting<br />
from) NRs. 3.5 Lakhs or NRs. Three<br />
Hundred and Fifty Thousand.<br />
In order to install just about any of<br />
these features, there is one very<br />
important requirement. You will<br />
need a stabilized voltage for the<br />
motherboard that controls the<br />
entire system. This mother board<br />
is something that looks like the<br />
CPU of a computer, and basically<br />
connects and controls the entire<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
system while occupying minimal<br />
space. So whether you live in a<br />
small compact apartment, or a<br />
large palatial mansion, as long as<br />
you can spare space equivalent to<br />
a small drawer, you can install this<br />
system.<br />
Bipassana International redefines<br />
living experiences and with just<br />
some small changes, gives you the<br />
option of making your life safer,<br />
more convenient, and enjoyable,<br />
by designing and installing an<br />
automation system that serves<br />
your lifestyle and also ensures the<br />
security of your family and your<br />
home, no matter where you are,<br />
with just a click. .•<br />
31<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Aluminium Composite Panels (ACP)<br />
Style or<br />
Sensibility<br />
Text: Ar. Shristi Shrestha<br />
Aluminium skin coating<br />
Protective film<br />
Plastic core<br />
Adhesive<br />
Aluminium skin<br />
Constructed mainly for dry construction and fast erection, the trend of ACP<br />
cladding has been followed widely in the past few years in the city. It has been<br />
employed mostly in commercial buildings and has been the rage these days for<br />
its aesthetics, durability, variety and workability. Used frequently for external<br />
cladding of building façade, its usage also includes any other form of cladding<br />
such as partitions, false ceilings, interior wall etc. So is it merely a fashion trend<br />
or intelligent engineering? What is its correct installation process? This article<br />
focuses on ACP –its structure, installation, its pros and cons.<br />
WHAT IS AN ACP?<br />
Aluminium Composite Panel<br />
(ACP) or Aluminium Composite<br />
Material (ACM) is a type of flat<br />
sandwiched panel that consist<br />
of a non-aluminium core (fire<br />
proof or plastic) bonded between<br />
two aluminium sheets coated with<br />
Polyvinylidene Fluoride Coating<br />
(PVDF) or polyester paint (PE) by<br />
an adhesive. Number of these ACPs<br />
are fixed within an aluminium section<br />
(spacer system) resulting in a cladding<br />
which basically is a typical metal<br />
curtain wall.<br />
Although these panels are used<br />
extensively in building exterior<br />
curtain walls, it has also been used as<br />
decorative materials of interior walls,<br />
bathroom, doors, ceilings, kitchens,<br />
balconies of home and hotel and so<br />
forth. It is also used as decorative<br />
materials in shops as column covers,<br />
fascias and canopy equipment<br />
enclosures and beam wraps, signage<br />
etc.<br />
TYPES AND VARIETIES<br />
Thickness of aluminium section<br />
The recommended thickness for ACP<br />
use largely depends upon the height<br />
at which it will be installed owing<br />
to the wind velocity experienced at<br />
that altitude. Panels are available at<br />
thicknesses of 1mm, 2.5mm, 3mm,<br />
4mm, 5mm and 6mm. Mr. Saurav<br />
Bahety, C.E.O of Aalutuff, one of the<br />
leading brands in manufacture and<br />
supply of ACP, recommends using<br />
panels of 2.5mm thick aluminium<br />
sections for buildings that are up to 10<br />
storey high and 5mm thick aluminium<br />
sections if the buildings are higher than<br />
that but lower than 25 storey.<br />
Area<br />
According to Mr. Bahety, 4ft X 12ft<br />
panels are mostly used for exterior<br />
works, whereas, 4ft X 8ft and 3ft X 12ft<br />
panels are mostly used for works like<br />
ducting, false ceiling, partition, etc.<br />
Though the panels are manufactured<br />
as straight and flat panels, they can be<br />
bended to a certain degree if needed.<br />
Colors and texture<br />
The panels are available in different<br />
colors and texture like silver, flash<br />
silver, gold, flash gold, white, red, black,<br />
marble design, wooden design, golden<br />
mirror, silver mirror, brushed panel etc.<br />
(as required).<br />
FEATURES OF<br />
ALUMINIUM PANELS:<br />
Efficiency:<br />
1) Fire resistance of ACP can be<br />
highly improved by using a<br />
fireproof core (but this option is<br />
not easily affordable and thus not<br />
available in Nepal).<br />
2) Aluminium has high resistance to<br />
corrosion. It reacts with air to form<br />
aluminium oxide, an extremely<br />
hard coating that seals the<br />
aluminium surface from further<br />
degradation.<br />
3) Compared to steel, aluminium<br />
is extremely lightweight,<br />
approximately one third the density,<br />
resulting in low loads on buildings,<br />
which is particularly important<br />
where large spans are involved.<br />
4) The durability of ACP largely<br />
depends upon the quality of the<br />
material. Aalutuf, one of the leading<br />
brands offers 15- 20 yrs of warranty.<br />
5) It has good corrosion, pollutant and<br />
moisture resistant (Aalutuf adopts<br />
the protocol of ASTM B-117, IS<br />
13781-1993, and IS 101 (PT6/Sec<br />
1)-1998).<br />
6) Available in a variety of colors and<br />
textures.<br />
7) Is lightweight and easy to process.<br />
8) It can be re-used and is easy to<br />
maintain.<br />
9) These panels require careful<br />
attention to waterproofing, as lack<br />
of sufficient waterproofing may<br />
allow moisture to enter the seams<br />
around or above the panels.<br />
10) Some panels are self cleaning and<br />
also clean the air around them.<br />
Such panels use titanium dioxidebased<br />
technology .Titanium oxide<br />
spacesnepal.com 32<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
The structure of an ACP is composed<br />
of the following layers:<br />
1) Protective film<br />
2) Coating-basic level( PVDF or<br />
polyester)<br />
3) Aluminum Alloy sheet (of varying<br />
thickness)<br />
5) Adhesive<br />
6) Polyethylene core<br />
7) Adhesive<br />
8) Aluminum Alloy sheet<br />
9) Ground coating<br />
1<br />
on exposure to sunlight, acts as a<br />
catalyst in breaking down organic<br />
substances. At the same time, it<br />
forms a water-attracting surface<br />
(as explained by Ar. Manjushree<br />
Sthapit, (Asst. professor, NEC).<br />
Impact resistance<br />
Although aluminium has higher impact<br />
resistance than other metals, it is still<br />
lower than the impact resistance of a<br />
concrete structure. Hence sometimes,<br />
dents are observed in the buildings.<br />
This is observed especially if thickness<br />
of aluminium is less than required.<br />
It is also susceptible to storms or<br />
hurricanes as the composite strength<br />
is not high and easy to break when the<br />
surface bends.<br />
2 5<br />
3 6<br />
Thermal insulation and protection:<br />
1) Aluminium is one of the best<br />
reflectors of UV rays and<br />
electromagnetic waves. Hence<br />
the color stays for long. But, the<br />
fading of color of the panels largely<br />
depends upon the quality of PVDF<br />
coating.<br />
2) Insulation can also be installed<br />
between the partition board and<br />
the ACP hence improving energy<br />
efficiency of the building.<br />
3) If installed in tray binding system,<br />
the insulation provided increases<br />
dramatically.<br />
4) Some ACP products are also<br />
helpful in reducing internal building<br />
temperatures by achieving a high<br />
SRI (Solar Reflectivity Index). Such<br />
ACP can reduce internal building<br />
temperatures (reducing AC loads in<br />
warm climates) and also potentially<br />
reduce heat island effects which can<br />
be detrimental to natural habitats.<br />
4 7<br />
Stage 1: The RCC frame structure is completed.<br />
Stage 2: Installation of the aluminium section is carried out.<br />
Stage 3: Aluminium composite panel (ACP) is installed.<br />
Stage 4: Installation of insulation (extruded polystyrene foam).<br />
Stage 5: Installation a of internal partition board (calcium silicate board/ fiber cement board).<br />
Stage 6: All external works is completed.<br />
Stage 7: Aluminium glazing is fixed. ((photo courtesy: Innovative Creators)<br />
Stage 8: Weather proof silicon filling is done between the panels.<br />
Removal of protective film is recommended soon after installation (within 45 days) since<br />
residual glue may be left from protective film and stick onto lacquered coated surface of<br />
panels.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
33<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Environmental aspects and carbon<br />
emission<br />
1) Recycling the aluminium uses<br />
only up to 5% of the total energy<br />
required for extraction and can be<br />
recycled for generations without<br />
limitations.<br />
2) The core is made up of<br />
polyethylene i.e. plastic hence is<br />
non-biodegradable.<br />
3) Inspite of being one of the most<br />
abundant metal, aluminium is<br />
the most carbons emitting metal<br />
during extraction. However, eco<br />
friendly ACP is also available that<br />
focus on minimizing building’s<br />
carbon footprint and making<br />
significant contributions to the<br />
sustainability of a building. The<br />
reduced carbon footprint may be<br />
achieved by<br />
* Maximum utilization of Post<br />
Consumer Recycle Content<br />
(PCR) in the raw materials<br />
resulting in no harmful effect on<br />
the environment.<br />
* Energy Efficiency measures<br />
during its product’s life cycle.<br />
INSTALLATION PROCESS:<br />
WALL CLADDING V/S TRAY<br />
BENDING SYSTEM<br />
Wall cladding, the more popular<br />
installation practice among the two, is<br />
where the panels are simply placed<br />
among the aluminum section erected<br />
taking support on a curtain brick<br />
wall. Whereas, tray bending system<br />
is where the ACP is folded to a match<br />
box like structure and placed amongst<br />
the aluminium section. The difference<br />
is that in this system, brick curtain<br />
walls are omitted and internal partition<br />
board and insulation is used.<br />
“ACP is the need of time. But in this<br />
country, it has been abused. These<br />
panels have been developed for dry<br />
construction and fast erection. Hence,<br />
inspite of the popular practice of<br />
cladding the ACP to a brick curtain<br />
wall in a RCC frame structure, it<br />
isn’t the correct installation method<br />
and not the way ACP cladding is<br />
done in developed countries. In<br />
fact, construction of a brick curtain<br />
spacesnepal.com 34<br />
wall is not even advised since it<br />
results in unnecessary increment<br />
of construction cost, decreases the<br />
insulation property of the building<br />
as well as increases the dead load of<br />
the building.” states Ar. Ujjwal Maan<br />
Shakya, one of the pioneer users<br />
of ACP in Kathmandu who strongly<br />
encourages tray bending system.<br />
The pictures below show stepwise<br />
installation of ACP in tray bending<br />
system to be followed in Nepal<br />
Airlines Co-operation Office,<br />
Sinamangal.<br />
BENEFITS AND DIFFICULTIES<br />
WHILE WORKING IN TRAY<br />
BENDING SYSTEM<br />
Benefits:<br />
Better earthquake resistance<br />
Since the weight of aluminium panels<br />
and the partition board is very less as<br />
compared to the brick walls, i.e. less<br />
total dead load of the building, the<br />
performance of the building during an<br />
earthquake is better.<br />
Decrease in the total<br />
construction cost<br />
Although the cost price of ACP<br />
installation is high, (NRs. 300-500/-<br />
per square feet depending upon<br />
its strength), the total construction<br />
price becomes comparative low if<br />
the curtain brick walls are replaced<br />
by a smooth surfaced partition board<br />
like calcium silicate board (this<br />
omits the need for plastering) and<br />
insulation. Along with the deduction of<br />
construction price of the brick walls,<br />
here, price for plastering and coloring<br />
is also omitted resulting in significant<br />
saving. Moreover, lighter building<br />
equals to thinner columns and beams<br />
and less reinforcement bars.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
Better insulation<br />
Placement of insulation materials<br />
between the board and the panel<br />
will aid in thermal efficiency of the<br />
building resulting in less energy<br />
consumption.<br />
Faster construction<br />
This feature comes handy especially<br />
in commercial buildings where time is<br />
actually money; faster construction will<br />
result in maximum profit for the owner.<br />
Difficulties:<br />
Lack of skilled workmanship<br />
One of the main difficulties in<br />
practicing tray bending installation<br />
system is difficulty in finding the<br />
required skilled manpower. Since the<br />
skilled labor is not available locally,<br />
mostly it has to be imported from<br />
India.<br />
The selective use of ACP<br />
An important aspect to discuss here is<br />
the haphazard use of ACP, a trend for<br />
which the user is responsible and not<br />
the material. One can witness the use<br />
of ACP in newly constructed buildings<br />
in areas of historic importance<br />
without any regard to the built<br />
environment of the place thus ruining<br />
the architectural, historic and cultural<br />
fabric of the place.<br />
It can be argued that ACP is a stylish<br />
and sensible innovation, which can<br />
prove to be a blessing for commercial<br />
as well as decorative purposes. Yet<br />
one should be aware of its benefits<br />
as well as demerits, and also realize<br />
its installation process and features.<br />
This would result in the proper use of<br />
the material instead of the haphazard<br />
nature of its current introduction into<br />
the buildings in the city. •<br />
REFERENCES:<br />
1) http://www.archclad.com.au<br />
2) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandwich_panel<br />
3) http://www.blazelead.com/ALUMINIUM-COMPOSITE-PANEL--ACP/UNIVERSAL-METAL/<br />
NP/2655415-26348-4/<br />
4) http://www.architectandbuilder.com.au<br />
5) Interview with Ar.Ujjwal Man Shakya, Managing Director and Senior Architect, Innovative Creaters<br />
6) Interview with Ar. Manjushree Sthapit, Asst. Professor, N.E.C.<br />
7) Interview with Mr Saurav Bahety, C.E.O, Aalutuf
ARCHITECTURE<br />
spacesnepal.com 36<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
To<br />
HOUSE<br />
or not to house<br />
The dilemma of Eviction Vs Land<br />
Titles in Kathmandu<br />
Text: Ar. Yatra Sharma<br />
While hauling across the heavy-trafficridden<br />
Kupondole Bridge, the sight of<br />
squatter settlement in a squalid setting<br />
outlining the Bagmati River strongly<br />
imprints in the mind of the general<br />
passerby. Such blighted settlements<br />
have remained along rivers of<br />
Kathmandu for so long that it is almost<br />
impossible to visualize the mainstream<br />
waterline without them-as if to say<br />
squatter settlements are a component<br />
of riverbanks in the valley.<br />
Such plight often makes the public<br />
wonder why these inhabitants chose<br />
to live in such degraded environment<br />
and why they are tolerated here?<br />
One instant reaction towards the<br />
situation is the perception that squatter<br />
settlements devaluate the image of a<br />
city and should be directly removed.<br />
While some feel that these dwellers<br />
have no alternatives and therefore<br />
the government should create<br />
housing prospects before removing<br />
them. But both these option- one of<br />
evicting and the other of providing<br />
alternative housing- are remarkably<br />
controversial to implement.<br />
On one hand forced eviction involves<br />
clearance through violent force<br />
and large scale housing demolition<br />
when individuals, families and<br />
entire communities are displaced<br />
temporarily or permanently against<br />
their will, from their homes, land<br />
and businesses in the pretext of<br />
city beautification or environmental<br />
hazard. This approach leaves them<br />
homeless and hopeless aggravating<br />
the circle of poverty, discrimination<br />
and social exclusion; and therefore<br />
considered against human rights.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
37<br />
Below the Kupondole Bridge<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
On the other hand, alternative housing<br />
is more often a financially, legally,<br />
technically, socially and politically<br />
controversial approach. It involves<br />
excruciatingly difficult and time<br />
consuming processes of accurate<br />
selection of beneficiaries; community<br />
cohesion, participation and<br />
consensus; land selection and plotting;<br />
infrastructure development, housing<br />
design and construction; temporary<br />
or permanent resettlements; housing<br />
to new buildings and adaptation;<br />
regulations and monitoring over<br />
informal property transaction- all<br />
these based on pre-formulated policy<br />
framework and support from various<br />
stakeholders including the general<br />
public. Even then, the consequences<br />
of this course of action remain<br />
indecisive and unpredictable over the<br />
period of time it gets accomplished.<br />
Either way, both approaches present<br />
a dilemma so deep and the probable<br />
solution so indecisive that they trigger<br />
a perplexing question- whether to<br />
house or not to house the urban<br />
landless mass unable to afford a<br />
respectable shelter in this thriving city<br />
of Kathmandu?<br />
SO MANY! OR HOW FEW!<br />
Kathmandu, being the primate city<br />
in the country with disproportionate<br />
concentration of all major facilities<br />
within its region, thousands of people<br />
migrate to the city in search for<br />
better opportunities of employment,<br />
education, economic activities and<br />
other amenities. Many of them are also<br />
internally displaced, pushed out from<br />
their villages due to political conflict,<br />
that have chosen to settle permanently<br />
within the safer periphery of the city.<br />
Most of these are poor and unskilled<br />
migrants unable to afford a proper<br />
shelter in this growing urban area with<br />
soaring real estate prices. Due to lack<br />
of an alternate, most migrants have<br />
resorted to so-called unauthorized<br />
or informal housing in the absence<br />
of developed land within their reach.<br />
As a result, Kathmandu has been<br />
experiencing increased number of<br />
squatter settlements over the last few<br />
decades.<br />
In 1985, it was estimated that there<br />
were only 17 squatter communities in<br />
Kathmandu valley, but now the number<br />
has grown to 71 (DUDBC, 2011) 1 with<br />
further emerging settlements. These<br />
settlements are communities in the<br />
city squatting illegally on public land<br />
that are environmentally sensitive<br />
areas such as river banks or flood<br />
plains, steep slopes and vacant<br />
spaces under high voltage electrical<br />
transmission line. Characterized<br />
by vulnerability and poverty, these<br />
settlements are growing each day and<br />
their physical existence getting more<br />
and more visible in the city.<br />
The approximate population of<br />
25,000 squatter 2 in Kathmandu<br />
amounts to a mere 1% of its total<br />
population. Although the number is<br />
still on a minor scale the issue is not<br />
insignificant. Towards the end of 2011<br />
we have seen more of these “illegal”<br />
buildings sprouting frequently with a<br />
much solid stance. What used to be<br />
sacks are now concrete structures<br />
claiming their place proudly amidst<br />
all the raging controversies. Ignorance<br />
is definitely not bliss in this contextwithout<br />
a quick resolution, these<br />
issues shall only escalate and become<br />
more complex to solve if lingered too<br />
long.<br />
INITIATIVES SO FAR<br />
Despite much inaction, the<br />
government of Nepal has initiated<br />
some efforts in providing secure<br />
housing to the squatters with support<br />
from Lumanti 3 in the recent past.<br />
These efforts have been aimed<br />
at squatter issues both within and<br />
beyond the valley. But the nature of<br />
the problem within the valley is rather<br />
unique and sensitive due to relatively<br />
high land rates, than the rest of the<br />
country. Most of the engagements<br />
in land development such as site<br />
and services or land pooling in the<br />
Valley have been targeted to general<br />
public or government officers who<br />
can afford it and not specifically the<br />
urban poor. Attempts to utilize the<br />
expensive land for social causes<br />
such as providing them at subsidized<br />
rates are extremely controversial and<br />
unsupported by policies. Therefore<br />
the initiations made towards these<br />
issues have not fully resolved into an<br />
adequate solution.<br />
Kirtipur Resettlement Housing<br />
Program, for instance, was conducted<br />
for housing squatters who were<br />
evicted for construction of Bishnumati<br />
Link Road in 2005. With support from<br />
Lumanti, Kathmandu Metropolitan City<br />
and other national and international<br />
NGOs, the program re-housed the<br />
evictees from Bishnumati area to<br />
a parcel of 6 ropanis (1 ropani=<br />
5476 sq.ft.) land in Kirtipur upon<br />
construction of individual housing<br />
units. Due to scarcity of land in the<br />
nearby area and high land prices<br />
close to it, the resettlement area was<br />
selected 10km away from city centre at<br />
a location with comparably lower land<br />
rates (3million rupees 4 per ropani, in<br />
2003) (Sengupta and Sharma, 2009).<br />
During site visits most inhabitants<br />
express the location factor has made<br />
them compromise their economic<br />
opportunities since increased distance<br />
from prior location has created<br />
difficulty in access to employment. On<br />
the other hand, urban experts argue<br />
that with growing road network and<br />
increasing transportation facilities,<br />
Kirtipur should be not be considered<br />
a “distant” location from the previous<br />
locality. Although the project is<br />
considered much successful, the<br />
bitter reality is that four out of the<br />
forty houses remain empty today. This<br />
presents a question to the replication<br />
of similar resettlement projects that<br />
remains uncertain to the livelihood<br />
of settlers that need to move far away<br />
from their preferred location.<br />
Another breakthrough initiation was<br />
made by the government in 2009 by<br />
assigning a budget of 15 crore (2007-<br />
2008 fiscal year) for upgrading any<br />
one of riverbank squatter settlement<br />
in the city. In order to aptly utilize the<br />
amount, Lumanti together with ACHR 5<br />
worked together with the government<br />
and proposed a land sharing project<br />
in Sankhamul squatter settlement<br />
that would also include residents of<br />
Bansighat and Kuriagaon squatter<br />
spacesnepal.com 38<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
settlements. The idea was to divide the<br />
land into two parts and share – one for<br />
accommodation of existing squatters<br />
in an apartment building with tenure<br />
security and the other for public use<br />
i.e. commercial development and<br />
green space. This would not only<br />
provide formal housing and eliminate<br />
the possibilities of forced evictions but<br />
also improve the surrounding river<br />
area. The commercial buildings would<br />
provide cross subsidy for construction<br />
of housing, making the project<br />
financially self-sustainable. However<br />
the concept of apartment housing was<br />
not appreciated by the community<br />
who wanted to own their own piece of<br />
land parcel and also the government<br />
river-setback regulations caused legal<br />
hindrances. Thus the first, government<br />
led on-site squatter upgrading effort in<br />
Kathmandu was rejected.<br />
After rejection of the land sharing<br />
project, the government of Nepal<br />
focused its attention outside<br />
Kathmandu Valley towards housing the<br />
deprived and marginal communities<br />
including squatters through a project<br />
called “Janta Awas”. As for within the<br />
valley, the government has bought a<br />
piece of 4 Ropanies of land in Ichangu<br />
Narayan (approximately 10km away<br />
from city centre) as part of 2008-<br />
2009 fiscal year’s budget for future<br />
resettlement of squatters residing<br />
in vulnerable conditions. Currently<br />
the government in collaboration with<br />
Lumanti is trying to identify settlements<br />
that need to be resettled immediately<br />
and designing apartments on the<br />
newly bought site for the purpose.<br />
MAJOR CONSTRAINTS<br />
Throughout the process of implementing<br />
these initiations, three major constraints<br />
were brought into light.<br />
Firstly, the institutional flaw in<br />
successful execution of the project<br />
lies in the lack of a policy framework.<br />
Such policy is to be the guideline for<br />
step-wise execution for transfer of land<br />
ownership, construction procedure,<br />
payments, form of tenure, transfer of<br />
use right and other legal aspects that<br />
is extremely important for carrying<br />
out the project- all of which need to be<br />
Below Sankhamul Bridge<br />
Pathivara Squatter along Dhobikhola Corridor, north of Chabahil Chowk<br />
approved by the Cabinet of Ministers<br />
of government of Nepal. Without such<br />
a policy no form of upgrading project<br />
can be executed in a systematic<br />
order. In realization of this drawback<br />
the government of Nepal has recently<br />
formulated a policy which, waiting<br />
in the desk of cabinet ministers for<br />
approval for more than a year, only<br />
reveals the hesitation of the related<br />
bodies in resolving the issue.<br />
Secondly, a critical technical problem<br />
lies in demarcation of land occupied<br />
by riverfront of squatter settlements<br />
(80% of squatter settlements in<br />
Kathmandu valley are along Bagmati<br />
River or its tributaries) created by the<br />
duality of records in current satellite<br />
maps Vs legal survey records. As<br />
per regulations, the official cadastral<br />
maps have to be referred for any<br />
construction works. The cadastral<br />
map of Kathmandu Metropolitan<br />
prepared by the Survey Department<br />
in the year 1965 indicates a wider<br />
course of Bagmati River and its<br />
tributaries which have substantially<br />
narrowed down today. Much of the<br />
river flow in the past was over the<br />
area that is now dry land occupied<br />
by the settlements today (Cadstral<br />
map 1965). So, most portion of land<br />
occupied by riverfront squatters at<br />
present does not legally exist in the<br />
survey records made in the past!<br />
Due to lack of updated data, the<br />
government is forced to overlook<br />
existing conditions. However, NGOs<br />
like Lumanti and squatter federations<br />
demand for on-site upgrading based<br />
on the argument that government<br />
has revised rules according to<br />
requirements as per changing times<br />
and conditions many times in the<br />
history, and similar should be the<br />
case for squatters in order to allow<br />
occupation of riverside land for<br />
housing instead of evicting them<br />
based on records that are no longer<br />
relevant. This duality of records<br />
also creates a dilemma whether<br />
to allow on-site upgrading or to<br />
resettle the squatters elsewhere.<br />
However, considering the limited<br />
government budget for social<br />
housing, scarce land in Kathmandu<br />
and the loss of livelihood created by<br />
resettlement, the second option is not<br />
preferable to majority of squatters<br />
who are sensitively attached to their<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
39<br />
spacesnepal.com
ARCHITECTURE<br />
existing localities. As such the<br />
government has neither been able<br />
to satisfactorily resettle the squatters<br />
nor to legalize on-site upgrading.<br />
Thirdly and most importantly is<br />
the political and legal crisis of<br />
issuing land titles or “lalpurja”<br />
to the squatters as put forward<br />
by squatter federations as their<br />
foremost demand. Although time<br />
and again, political bodies such as<br />
the “Nepal Sukumbashi Samashya<br />
Samadhan Ayog” have distributed<br />
land titles over various parts of the<br />
country, the general public often<br />
questions the validity and legality of<br />
such actions. There are two doubtful<br />
aspects to issuing land titles- one<br />
is in true identification of squatters,<br />
since there are many land and<br />
property owners who claim to be<br />
landless and it is extremely difficult<br />
to assure that the most deserving<br />
candidate has received the benefits<br />
rather than a fake candidate with<br />
intentions of capitalizing the land<br />
value; second is in gentrificationwhereby<br />
issuing of land titles<br />
opens windows for transaction of<br />
property in a formal basis and, in<br />
doing so, the market forces will<br />
push the deserving urban poor<br />
out of their land and pull middle<br />
income citizens in. Through such<br />
transactions squatters will again<br />
remain landless and move into<br />
another informal settlement creating<br />
a vicious circle of landlessness and<br />
aggravating irregularity.<br />
THE RIGHT ATTITUDE<br />
Amidst all the constraints, in the<br />
last two years, the government has<br />
approached the squatter issue in<br />
Kathmandu with a positive outlook.<br />
It has taken a constructive step in<br />
formulating policies and initiating<br />
projects to address the situation in<br />
a participatory method by working<br />
through a coordination committee<br />
that includes not only political<br />
representatives, governmental,<br />
non-governmental and international<br />
bodies but also representatives from<br />
squatter federations, namely NBBSS 6<br />
and NMES 7 so as to resolve issues<br />
through mutual understanding and<br />
collaboration (Draft Working Policy<br />
2010, pp. 6-7). However, these initial<br />
efforts are yet to materialize.<br />
From the standpoint of squatters<br />
their demands for right to housing<br />
without forced eviction and access to<br />
alternative affordable housing seem<br />
valid and necessary but pressuring<br />
legal bodies to provide land titles<br />
puts a deadlock to negotiations.<br />
There are definite legal boundaries<br />
that the government has to abide<br />
by and there is little flexibility it can<br />
adopt at current times. Possibly, the<br />
matters of land titles can be settled<br />
through a strong political movement<br />
as seen in cases of Thailand 8<br />
where squatter communities have<br />
been upgraded in large scale in<br />
the past years based on ad-hoc<br />
practice rather than systematic legal<br />
procedures. As of now, the squatter<br />
federations in Nepal, like in Thailand,<br />
are well empowered and possess<br />
a good knowledge base such that<br />
they can revolt politically. NBBSS and<br />
NMES are well associated with NGOs<br />
such as Lumanti, Action Aid Nepal,<br />
Water Aid Nepal and international<br />
organizations like Asian Coalition for<br />
Housing Rights (ACHR) and Slum<br />
Dwellers International (SDI), through<br />
REFERENCES<br />
which they attain international<br />
exposure and trainings. So it seems<br />
important to recognize the capacity<br />
of squatters in retaining their<br />
occupied land.<br />
At the same time, there is a<br />
chance that if the government of<br />
Nepal becomes a federal state as<br />
intended, the squatters may need<br />
to lower down their demands and<br />
succumb to any housing solution<br />
put before them or else the next<br />
strong government may not hesitate<br />
in evicting the settlements in the<br />
course of revitalizing the city.<br />
There is definitely no correct<br />
solution or the best approach to<br />
solve this multi-faced problem.<br />
The key lies in case to case<br />
analysis, participative planning<br />
and mutual agreements of all the<br />
stakeholders involved. Flexibility<br />
and compromise from both demand<br />
and supply sides is necessary;<br />
and cooperative attitude of both<br />
parties seems essential in resolving<br />
how to house the squatters of<br />
Kathmandu. The issue here is the<br />
dilemma between evictions as<br />
opposed to provision of legal titles.<br />
Both extremes are not possible, the<br />
solution should be mid way. •<br />
CODI 2008, 50 Community upgrading projects, CODI Update, Vol. 5, Community<br />
Organizations Development Institute: Bangkok.<br />
DUDBC 2010, National Shelter Policy, [unpublished draft proposal], DUDBC, Ministry of<br />
Physical Planning and Works, Government of Nepal<br />
Sengupta U. and Sharma S. 2009, ‘No longer Sukumbasis: Challenges in grassroots-led<br />
squatter resettlement program in Kathmandu with special reference to Kirtipur Housing<br />
Project’ , Habitat International, Vol. 33, p. 34-44.<br />
Sharma, Y, 2010, Land Sharing Experience in Kathmandu: Case In Sankhamul Squatter<br />
Settlement “ Institute of housing Studies, Rotterdam<br />
Interview and draft article feed-back from Prafulla Man Pradhan , Advisor at Lumanti,<br />
Regional Capacity Development Advisor at UN Habitat.<br />
END NOTES<br />
1 Interview on 10 th Jan, 2011 with DDG Dr. Mahendra Subba in Department of Urban Development and Building<br />
Construction (DUDBC). Interview with NEST staffs that were a part of a survey conducted in 2011 on “Physical<br />
Mapping of the Squaer Selements in Kathmandu Valley”.<br />
2 This population does not include the total slum population or other informal settlements in the city. According to the<br />
report “State of Asian Cities 2010/11 “ by UN habitat the slum population in Nepal in 2007 was 59.4%.<br />
3 LUMANTI support group is a non-government organization dedicated to the alleviation of urban poverty in Nepal<br />
through the improvement of shelter conditions.<br />
4 Interview with Prafulla Man Singh, Advisor of Lumanti states the price was only 500,000 per Ropani.<br />
5 The Asian Coalition for Housing Rights (ACHR) is a regional network of grassroots community organizations, NGO’s<br />
and professionals actively involved with urban poor development processes in Asian cities based in Thailand.<br />
6 Nepal Basti Basobas Samrakchan Samiti, formulated in 2000; also known as SPOSH<br />
7 Nepal Mahila Ekta Samaj, formulated in 2000<br />
8 Community Organisation Development Institute (CODI), an independent body in Thailand has support various<br />
community-led development activities in providing secure tenure to urban poor in a large scale over the last<br />
decade.
each house with 100 square meter<br />
of roof area collects rainwater,<br />
then a volume of 160,000 liters<br />
can be collected 1 . This is the<br />
theoretical aspects of rainwater<br />
collection but the practical aspects<br />
also need to be addressed side<br />
by side.<br />
Rainwater<br />
Harvesting<br />
A SMART WAY OF LIFE!<br />
Text: Ar. Diskhya Poudyal<br />
Aaaa! Paani Aayo! Paani Aayo!<br />
Its 4 a.m. in the morning and Maili didi shouts as if she has hit gold mine. Well,<br />
precious than gold, and very rare in Kathmandu valley, is nothing but drinking water.<br />
Be it for the purpose of drinking or other use, we are forced to confront the problems<br />
which seem eternal. Also important, is the fact that we doubt the quality of water and<br />
usually boil it for drinking. This definitely questions the purity of the ‘drinking’ water<br />
supplied in the municipal grid or even extracted from deep boring wells. From quality<br />
to the quantity of water, rainwater harvesting can give relief to many, if not all!<br />
WHAT IS RAINWATER<br />
HARVESTING?<br />
Rainwater Harvesting is the process<br />
of collecting and storing rainwater<br />
before it reaches the aquifer. It<br />
can be used for drinking, after<br />
filtration, various other household<br />
purposes and for irrigation in large<br />
scale. The roof of our houses can<br />
make considerable contribution<br />
for collecting water during rainy<br />
seasons. The main idea is to collect<br />
water in containers before it reaches<br />
the stratum level of the earth.<br />
Kathmandu Valley receives 1,600<br />
milliliters of rainfall annually and if<br />
USEFULNESS:<br />
Successfully collecting rainwater<br />
can ease the users from water<br />
scarcity during dry seasons. Also,<br />
the water stored can be made<br />
free from impurities and hence<br />
assures purity. But this condition is<br />
for those who have enough space<br />
in their house for the installation<br />
of such systems. But what about<br />
those who lack space, those who<br />
cannot install an extra tank in their<br />
house? Can they also have the<br />
facility of rainwater harvesting?<br />
Well, now it seems possible, and<br />
hopefully the water woes will ebb<br />
soon in the valley.<br />
A bid to harvest 5 million liters<br />
of rainwater was announced on<br />
<strong>March</strong> 1, <strong>2012</strong>. A campaign has<br />
been launched by Kathmandu<br />
Valley Water Supply Management<br />
Board (KVWSMB) with the support<br />
of Center of Integrated Urban<br />
Development (CIUD). As ground<br />
work for this campaign, 10 ponds<br />
are currently being recharged<br />
through rainwater harvesting<br />
system in Kathmandu Valley. Dallu<br />
area and Trichandra College<br />
currently serves as demonstration<br />
areas 2 .This is a positive initiation,<br />
firstly to make people aware of the<br />
usefulness of rain water, secondly<br />
to minimize water scarcity during<br />
dry seasons, and, thirdly to help<br />
people understand the effort made<br />
in the community level to integrate<br />
those who cannot individually start<br />
a rainwater harvesting project at<br />
their small premises.<br />
spacesnepal.com 42<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Image source http://www.mppcb.nic.in/rwh.htm<br />
HOW DOES RAINWATER<br />
HARVESTING SYSTEM HELP?<br />
The installation cost to set up<br />
the rainwater harvesting system<br />
depends primarily on the volume<br />
of water collection desired by the<br />
users. However, a simple installation<br />
costs around Rs. 45,000 3 . The long<br />
term advantages of this system<br />
are considerable, as the cost for<br />
its maintenance is low and the<br />
purity of water can be relied on.<br />
A smart decision is to design and<br />
provide provisions for a rainwater<br />
harvesting system early in the<br />
design of the building. This will not<br />
only save the cost of retrofitting<br />
in a completed building, but the<br />
owners/users of the building can also<br />
enjoy the 10% subsidy in the total<br />
installation cost provided by DUDBC<br />
(Department of Urban Design and<br />
Building Construction). For this<br />
a comprehensive design should<br />
presented in the building permit<br />
drawings. The noteworthy thing is<br />
that it has been 10 years since the<br />
implementation of this campaign in<br />
order to make everyone, especially<br />
the city dwellers, aware of the value<br />
of rain water, yet the popularity of<br />
this campaign is meek.<br />
HOW DOES RAINWATER<br />
HARVESTING WORK?<br />
Collecting rain water is easy but a<br />
smart technique makes it easier,<br />
practical and feasible. If you would<br />
like to make it an integrated part of<br />
your building water supply system,<br />
then it is a onetime investment<br />
only, which is an extra cost to be<br />
more specific, but can prove to be<br />
a lifelong solution. Installation of a<br />
rainwater harvesting system can free<br />
the users from activities like finding<br />
the perfect location for deep boring<br />
(in case of availability of land), calling<br />
tankers to refill the underground<br />
containers, or sleepless nights just to<br />
wait for water to pour down your tap!<br />
There are various methods to install<br />
rain water harvesting system. Some<br />
are easy enough and do not require<br />
expensive equipments. Some of the<br />
useful tips for collecting rain water at<br />
your premises are as follows:<br />
• Decide a part of your roof as<br />
catchment area. Then make a<br />
gully system along the edge of<br />
your roof (concrete slab sloped<br />
roof or CGI). A proper drainage<br />
pipe from the flat roof terrace<br />
would make the system more<br />
viable.<br />
• Connect these pipes to a<br />
container having sand filtration to<br />
trap impurities.<br />
• Also to get rid of contaminants<br />
the water from the first rain can<br />
be drained off from a separate<br />
valve. Later on, this valve can be<br />
closed to divert the rain water into<br />
the filtration container. However,<br />
sweeping your terrace regularly<br />
can also minimize the hassle from<br />
impurities to some extent.<br />
• Clean water is then collected in<br />
an underground water tank.<br />
• The overflow from the tank is then<br />
sent to a recharge pit which helps<br />
maintain the ground water table.<br />
The water that is replenished<br />
through such a system can be<br />
useful for various activities; from<br />
drinking to washing by easily<br />
extracting from a tube well, in the<br />
long run.<br />
• Simple filtration and chlorination<br />
can make rainwater drinkable.<br />
REALITY AND REFLECTION:<br />
Rainwater harvesting helps recharge<br />
the depleting ground water and<br />
maintains a balance in the natural<br />
system of earth strata. The ever<br />
increasing populationm and their<br />
demand for drinking water, is not fulfilled<br />
by Kathmandu Upatyaka Khanepani<br />
Limited (KUKL). This has led to rampant<br />
extraction from deep boring wells,<br />
such actions are neither monitored by<br />
the government nor can they be called<br />
illegal. But more importantly, without<br />
denying the fact that the water table<br />
in Kathmandu valley is drying up due<br />
to the lack of a source to recharge<br />
itself, most of the rainwater mixes with<br />
the gutter system of our city. Also, the<br />
misconception that rainwater harvesting<br />
is expensive is widespread. But if the<br />
cost of annual water demand and its<br />
scarcity are compared to the calculations<br />
of installing a deep boring system or<br />
some tankers fetching gallons of water<br />
to our houses, then one wouldn’t find<br />
rainwater harvesting an expensive option<br />
if adapted wisely. •<br />
REFERENCES:<br />
One Planet Solution Pvt. Ltd., Smart Pani (water<br />
related product brand)<br />
Bid to harvest 5 million of rainwater, KATHMANDU<br />
POST, <strong>March</strong> 1st <strong>2012</strong><br />
Image source: (http://www.mppcb.nic.in/rwh.htm,<br />
Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control Board<br />
1<br />
Source - One Planet Solution Pvt. Ltd., Smart Pani<br />
(water related product brand)<br />
2<br />
Bid to harvest 5 million of rainwater, KATHMANDU<br />
POST, <strong>March</strong> 1st <strong>2012</strong><br />
3<br />
Ibid, One Planet Solution Pvt. Ltd., Smart Pani<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
43<br />
spacesnepal.com
BOOK RELEASE<br />
ARCHITECTURE<br />
OF THE NEWARS<br />
I<br />
In 1962 Niels Gutschow first<br />
visited Nepal during a trekking<br />
expedition. In 1970, after<br />
graduating architecture, he<br />
returned to the country with his<br />
team to renovate the Pujahari Math,<br />
Bhaktapur, as a wedding gift to<br />
the then crown prince Birendra Bir<br />
Bikram Shah Dev. Today, 40 years<br />
later, Dr. Niels Gutschow presents<br />
a tribute to the heritage of this<br />
country, which has been a second<br />
home to him, in the form of his<br />
three volume book ‘Architecture of<br />
the Newars: A History of Building<br />
Typologies and Details in Nepal’.<br />
This book presents a complete<br />
history of the architecture<br />
of Kathmandu valley and its<br />
neighbors over a period of 1500<br />
years. The three volumes of<br />
the book include, Volume I - The<br />
Early Period, from 200 A.D. to 1350<br />
A.D. showcasing the architectural<br />
development before the Malla times;<br />
Volume II - The Malla Period from<br />
1350 A.D. to 1769 A.D. and; Volume III<br />
- The Modern Period from 1769 A.D.<br />
until present.<br />
‘Architecture of the Newars’<br />
documents the research done by Dr.<br />
Niels and his team over the last 40<br />
years. The book includes documents<br />
in the form of photographs and<br />
drawings, both hand-drawn and<br />
digital. A total of 862 photos and<br />
939 drawings are published in the<br />
book, depicting the architecture<br />
of Kathmandu and its neighbors.<br />
The book identifies and defines the<br />
typology of the buildings and their<br />
different parts and elements.<br />
The first part of the book includes<br />
five sections, beginning with a section<br />
titled ‘About the waning skills of<br />
measured drawings’. In this section<br />
he writes “The trembling line of<br />
the free hand suggests a sense of<br />
life, while the straight line seems<br />
to be dead”. This note describing<br />
the process of documentation<br />
for the book, which includes<br />
making hand-drawn as well<br />
as digital measured drawings,<br />
exemplifying the beliefs of Dr.<br />
Niels that creating and publishing<br />
records is a way of preserving<br />
history and architecture.<br />
‘Architecture of the Newars’<br />
was first published by Serindia<br />
Publications Inc., Chicago, Illinois<br />
in 2011, and printed at Vögeli<br />
AG, Langnau, Switzerland. The<br />
book was available at Vajra<br />
Book Shop, Jyatha, Kathmandu,<br />
in limited volumes. Although the<br />
initial volumes of the book are<br />
now sold out, readers may still<br />
purchase the book from Serindia<br />
Gallery, Bangkok. The listed<br />
price of the book is US $ 450,<br />
with a further shipping charge of<br />
US $ 25 in the United States and<br />
US $ 50 in Asia, which can be<br />
ordered from Vajra Book Shop,<br />
either at the outlet or online at<br />
www.vajrabookshop.com. The<br />
equivalent cost, inclusive of<br />
shipping charge, in Nepal is NRs.<br />
38,000/-. •<br />
spacesnepal.com 44<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
45<br />
spacesnepal.com
INTERIOR<br />
Rustic<br />
radiance<br />
Text-Ar. Shristi Shrestha<br />
spacesnepal.com 46<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
INTERIOR<br />
A circular black and red signage opposite St. Mary’s School in<br />
Jhamsikhel directs you to a narrow lane leading to one of the<br />
best continental cuisine places in town- Grill me. Previously<br />
a residential building, the restaurant now hosts outdoor and<br />
indoor seating areas with an open bar, and a private lounge.<br />
Owners Ninesh Tiwari and Anudan Rana, and interior designer<br />
Rishi Shroff, deserve applause for converting it into such a<br />
Atrendy eatery.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
47<br />
spacesnepal.com
INTERIOR<br />
“We didn’t want anything too prim and proper” says<br />
Mr. Rana, so they have opted for a rustic look. One<br />
can feel the amount of work that has been put in to<br />
retain its raw simplicity - and yet maintain interesting<br />
detailing. Stone, wood, and iron, are the three basic<br />
elements used to create a rustic ambiance, and the<br />
entire place is united with a ‘hide and seek’ of circles.<br />
Sculptures by Meena Kayastha, called ‘Lyrics from<br />
the Junkyard’, made of discarded materials, adorn the<br />
premises. They blend well with the rustic ambiance<br />
of the place.<br />
The main entrance, with parking to the right, leads<br />
up to the outdoor eating area and the lounge and<br />
bar. A stonewall barrier cuts off visual connection<br />
from the road, providing diners with privacy. The first<br />
thing that catches the eye is the open bar. This in<br />
fact was the only requirement of the clients. Looking<br />
the way it does now, it’s hard to believe that this was<br />
once a garage! The side and the front walls of the<br />
garage have been removed giving the bar a breezy<br />
feel. Walls have been left bare, staying true to the<br />
raw theme, and blue neon lights decorate the walls.<br />
Here, one can’t help but notice the circles. A signature<br />
element of the design, compositions of circles have<br />
spacesnepal.com 48<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
INTERIOR<br />
been used on the walls, bar table, behind the<br />
liquor stand, and as a cut off in the angle beams.<br />
The luminosity of the lights behind these circles<br />
adds a different dimension to the bar. Another<br />
thing that one can’t help notice is the use of wood.<br />
Though new, the wooden tables and bar stools<br />
have been designed to look old, worn out, and put<br />
back together.<br />
The outdoor spaces tempt the guests even in<br />
the winter months with its stone fireplaces. In<br />
summer, these fireplaces are decked with stones<br />
and candles. A lounge with blue cushions is<br />
right at the entrance, followed by wooden sitting<br />
areas. A junkyard sculpture, ‘Lyrics of the Last<br />
Era’ is displayed next to the sitting. Pendent lights<br />
hanging from the ceiling, along with the radiance<br />
of blue lights from behind the walls and beneath<br />
the sitting areas, give the place a magical feel<br />
during the evening.<br />
Two doors open up into the indoor eating area<br />
and two sculptures are displayed on the doorway.<br />
The plaster of the existing building was chipped<br />
off for a rugged look and embellished with circles.<br />
Tables are arranged on either side of the walls<br />
with a gleams of light from behind decorative<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
49<br />
spacesnepal.com
INTERIOR<br />
wooden beams are used in the false ceiling. A kitchen,<br />
cold kitchen, and a washroom co-exist on the ground<br />
floor, next to the indoor sitting. A separate circulation area<br />
for the staff is provided along with a stairway that leads to<br />
the offices and lounge.<br />
A metal stairway decorated with circular cut offs<br />
leads to a private lounge that can serve 15 people.<br />
Accompanied by a balcony sitting area, the lounge<br />
has its own restroom and service entrance and hosts<br />
karaoke. The walls here are particularly interesting.<br />
Intended to be different from the lower floor, the paint<br />
on the wall seems like chipping off mud paint. This<br />
adds to the worn out look of the space. The orange<br />
cushions complement the mud-brown walls and the<br />
radiance of lights from behind the sitting areas and the<br />
false wooden beams gives an electric feel to the space.<br />
The balcony seating area adjacent to the lounge has a<br />
captivating ceiling which Mr. Shroff refers to as “stars<br />
on the ceiling”. Designed as if the pieces were sewed<br />
back together, light shining through random circles on<br />
the ceiling gives an illusion of distant stars.<br />
One can say that this restaurant is not just one of the<br />
many places with a popular “rustic” themes. Ingenious<br />
use of metal, wood and light has made the place<br />
different from others. Especially during evenings,<br />
the blue lights from least expected places renders a<br />
vivacious feel. ‘Grill me’ is successful in distinguishing<br />
itself from other restaurants around town and it<br />
certainly delivers a one of its kind eating experience. •
HERITAGE<br />
RENOVATION<br />
for adaptive reuse<br />
Text: Ar. Swati Pujari<br />
The Story of Swotha
HERIETAGE<br />
The value of preservation and the<br />
preservation of values go hand<br />
in hand. A one year series on<br />
change and preservation begins<br />
with renovation of two residential<br />
buildings at Swotha, Patan.<br />
In a country fascinated by the new, why would anyone<br />
want to preserve something old? This is a question<br />
conservationists in our country have been asking for years.<br />
A house is a symbol of status, building a new house is a<br />
symbol of achievement. It is the dream of every Nepali<br />
to have a house in Kathmandu. It is the dream of every<br />
homeowner in Kathmandu to rebuild a new structure, which<br />
is by far bigger and hence better than the other buildings in<br />
their neighbourhood. Haven’t we all heard the expression,<br />
“I couldn’t do much in life, but I’ve built a new house” or,<br />
“I’ve added a floor to the house built by my parents”, thus<br />
emphasizing their achievement as people who have built<br />
something new?<br />
So in effect, people who come into money end up<br />
showcasing their wealth and status by building something<br />
new. It is not a new trend; remember how the kings of<br />
the past built new monuments, palaces and temples to<br />
symbolize their status? And remember how even then it was<br />
a competition between neighbouring kingdoms? After all<br />
that is how the palace complexes of Kathmandu, Patan and<br />
Bhaktapur were built. So why not let the same trend continue<br />
with the rest of the population and let them compete with<br />
their neighbours in respect to their buildings, and thus their<br />
statuses?<br />
So in a scenario like this, what are the values that we strive to<br />
preserve? Why do we showcase our tradition and traditional<br />
values to the world, but fail to preserve them in our own<br />
lives? Why is it that tourists pay a certain fee to enter our<br />
monument zones, temples, and palaces, but the private<br />
buildings adjacent to these are demolished to make way for<br />
newer and apparently ‘better’ construction?
HERITAGE<br />
Heritage conservation and preservation of monuments have<br />
always been critical issues; everyone talks about the values<br />
of these buildings or artefacts. But the question is, what are<br />
these values? According to our law, anything more than a<br />
hundred years old is given the status of a monument and<br />
thus should be preserved, but is that the only definition of<br />
a monument? Can a building not be important due to its<br />
uniqueness or its aesthetic appeal? Can a building designed<br />
by a famous architect, or built using a rare technology not<br />
be a monument? Also, do these values remain the same?<br />
Can values, like people and societies, change with time? We<br />
all understand that change is inevitable, so is it not possible<br />
that the reason old buildings are not preserved is because<br />
the values of society have changed over time, and what was<br />
essential then has become, perhaps, a burden now?<br />
So what are the ‘values’ of today and shouldn’t conservationists<br />
try to understand these new social values and guide<br />
conservation trends accordingly, instead of stating that because<br />
it is a monument it has to be preserved? A large population in<br />
Kathmandu is educated and aware of our cultural wealth and<br />
importance, but has that awareness been enough? Is it the lack<br />
of awareness or interest amongst house owners that is causing<br />
the trend of demolishing old private buildings?<br />
spacesnepal.com 54<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
HERIETAGE<br />
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Back façade of the<br />
building showcasing the<br />
mud plaster which will be<br />
preserved<br />
<br />
It is perhaps a mixture of both. Many homeowners are<br />
not aware about how to preserve their buildings, and find<br />
erecting a new building a much simpler and hassle free<br />
process. But it is also true that many homeowners suffer from<br />
a lack of interest. They find building a new building more<br />
profitable both in terms of investment as well as returns.<br />
Yet there are some buildings and spaces that are, in recent<br />
times, renovated in an avant-garde fashion, with ideas and<br />
inspirations that address the issues of conservation as well<br />
as current values. This series on heritage and conservation<br />
features is dedicated to find such projects where old<br />
buildings are renovated, and new profitable activities are<br />
created for them, thus meeting the needs of preservation as<br />
well as profit. This series will continue for one year and will<br />
feature multiple projects where conservation has lead to the<br />
adaptive reuse of spaces, and will also study the issues and<br />
problems faced by the owners and conservationists during<br />
the process. The series will culminate with an analysis of<br />
the issues related to modern conservation, addressing<br />
conservation principals as well as the changed social values.<br />
The projects featured in this series are a mixture of<br />
conservation and entrepreneurship, and the parties<br />
involved have tried to find a balance between the two,<br />
without sacrificing the ideals of either. Yet in some cases, the<br />
objectives of these projects may not strictly follow the text<br />
book definition of either conservation or entrepreneurship,<br />
or both. But these projects are an attempt at fulfilling the<br />
current needs of society, and not necessarily the ideas of<br />
imported or borrowed theories - thus they demand flexibility<br />
in part from all their stakeholders. The realization of these<br />
projects is not by an objective guidance or text book<br />
theory, but by subjective involvement between the owners,<br />
conservationists, stakeholders and most importantly, the<br />
neighbouring society.<br />
This journey begins with a feature of the ongoing renovation<br />
of two private houses at Swotha, Patan, adjacent to<br />
‘Traditional Homes-Swotha’ (previously featured in Jan-Feb<br />
<strong>2012</strong> issue of SPACES). The renovation, started in November<br />
2011, is carried out as a process by which the external<br />
facade of the buildings was conserved but the cement<br />
plaster over the front outer wall was removed. This is done in<br />
order to showcase the brick facade, indigenous to the mud<br />
based architecture of the buildings. The mud plaster over the<br />
back wall of the building is preserved as is and the structure<br />
of all the outer walls, including the doors and windows. The<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
55<br />
spacesnepal.com
HERITAGE<br />
The old and the new, a<br />
section of new timber<br />
added to an old tham<br />
(traditional pillar)<br />
internal walls however are removed to make way for a new<br />
partition to accommodate new activities. These new walls<br />
are constructed with cement mortar, to decrease the wall<br />
sections, but will be plastered using mud based plaster,<br />
therefore creating a traditional allure.<br />
According to Dr. Rohit Ranjitkar, who is heading this<br />
renovation, the two buildings, previously owned by a single<br />
family, showcases the input of multiple generations. The<br />
proportions of the ground floors suggest that this section<br />
of the building was built prior to the 1934 earthquake, but<br />
the proportions and details on the top floors of one section<br />
suggest the development of a much later period. The roof<br />
of the other section has been converted to a flat roof - as<br />
opposed to the traditional slope - and one of the outer walls<br />
was plastered using cement. Yet the inner walls as well<br />
as the outer wall in the back section are finished in mud<br />
plaster. Thus the building has been constantly adapted as<br />
per the needs of the family.<br />
The current intervention in the buildings will convert it to<br />
a guest house, which operationally will merge with the<br />
adjacent Traditional Homes - Swotha. Although the three<br />
buildings will act as one entity in its function, the ownership<br />
of these two buildings will be different from that of the<br />
building currently housing Traditional Homes. Combined,<br />
the three buildings will have a common courtyard (achieved<br />
by demolishing the boundary walls) and common facilities,<br />
thus reducing the overhead and operation cost, but acting as<br />
a larger unit and serving a larger number of clients.<br />
The facility thus created will be converted into a boutique<br />
apartment hotel that although commercial, will maintain<br />
the prestige of being a privately owned heritage property.<br />
The east wing of the hotel, currently under renovation, will<br />
accommodate three rooms per floor with a suite at the top<br />
floor which will have access to an added private balcony,<br />
amongst other facilities. This section will maintain its flat<br />
roof and necessary waterproofing will be done using<br />
modern materials, although not visibly, and the space will<br />
accommodate a water tank, solar water heaters etc. This<br />
section is approximately 450 square meters in area, and<br />
the expected cost of this renovation/ conversion is close to<br />
NRs. 9 million, which includes renovation, finishing, furniture<br />
and all other required services. The commercialization of<br />
these facilities will be encouraged but controlled, keeping<br />
in mind the targeted clients. In this way these three privately<br />
owned buildings will be preserved with the help of their<br />
spacesnepal.com 56<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
HERIETAGE<br />
A section of the front façade of<br />
the building where the cement<br />
plaster was removed<br />
owners, who are more interested in adapting their buildings<br />
according to their needs rather than demolishing and rebuilding.<br />
Thus the economic motive of the entrepreneurs, as well as the<br />
preservation motive of conservationists and of society is fulfilled.<br />
This complex is located near Patan Durbar Square, on the way to<br />
Bangalamukhi, at a historic location called Swotha. The society at<br />
this area has been able to maintain its traditional fabric to a large<br />
extent, although not entirely. Initiatives like these are appropriate<br />
and should be encouraged to preserve the traditional aesthetics<br />
of these areas, without sacrificing the current economic needs of<br />
the owners and other stakeholders. The project is expected to be<br />
complete in early November <strong>2012</strong>.<br />
But this project is not without its share of troubles. The issue of<br />
whether the government views this as a renovation, remodelling,<br />
maintenance or rebuilding project is unclear. The legal permits<br />
required for each of these endeavours are vague, thus neither<br />
the conservationists involved, nor the government officials, are<br />
certain about what kind of permits are to be issued here. It is no<br />
wonder that many homeowners find it easier to demolish an old<br />
building and build a new one, since the official procedure for<br />
such endeavours are easy to understand - unlike the procedure<br />
for conservation or adaptive reuse projects.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
57<br />
spacesnepal.com
HERITAGE<br />
The front façade of the buildings where the<br />
cement plaster was removed and a balcony at<br />
the top floor was added.<br />
Traditional Homes-Swotha, the existing guest house facility,<br />
with the buildings under renovation in the backdrop. All<br />
these facilities will merge together operationally to create a<br />
boutique heritage hotel<br />
As mentioned earlier, change is inevitable. Projects like<br />
these where old buildings are neither used in old ways<br />
nor demolished and reconstructed into new structures<br />
but adapted according to present need are examples of<br />
change, in both the social values as well as the society’s<br />
approach towards these buildings. This change needs to<br />
be accommodated not only in society but also in the legal<br />
processes, so that these projects are not only made hassle<br />
free and easily accessible, but are actually encouraged by all<br />
parties involved, be it the government, society, professionals<br />
of conservation or homeowners. •<br />
spacesnepal.com 58<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
HERIETAGE<br />
Sipradi<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
59<br />
spacesnepal.com
spacesnepal.com 60<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
PRESS<br />
RELEASE<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
61<br />
spacesnepal.com
Graaha or<br />
Text: Madan Chitrakar<br />
Makar<br />
Crocodiles in Nepali Art<br />
Man’s fascination to draw animals is as old as man’s history. It begins with<br />
when men still dwelt in caves: and animals were drawn or created in cave<br />
ceilings in Altamira or Lascaux. May be in those days they had a reason for<br />
drawing bulls for their own survival – the animals as a rich source of food.<br />
So are in the civilizations of Mohenjo-Daro or Harappa where bulls or cows<br />
– useful for multiple reasons, made strong appearances in clay seals. So are<br />
the horses or other wild animals in ancient Egyptian and Mesopotamian<br />
civilizations.<br />
But what one finds astonishing is the imagination of creatures beyond the<br />
forms found in reality. As the available evidences go, an earliest example<br />
is found in Assyrian Art – a winged-bull created in some 700 B.C. circa. An<br />
imagination of a four footed mammal with wings at that early stage of history<br />
is unthinkable and perplexing! Since then presence of mythical beings - birds<br />
or animals in art has always been common in many of the ancient or medieval<br />
art. Flying dragons, unicorns or phoenix or monsters or genies are some<br />
common examples and it continued to remain regular features in the many of<br />
the art and architectures in both East and West. But more often than not, it had<br />
always been inspired or derived from a native animal or a bird found around<br />
the place where it was been created. That is to say artists usually create forms<br />
with which they are reasonably familiar.<br />
spacesnepal.com 62<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
NEPALI ART: A PROLIFIC<br />
PRESENCE OF ‘GRAAHA OR<br />
MAKARS’<br />
In this context, Nepali art tradition<br />
too has remained very interesting.<br />
It has its rich share of mythical<br />
creatures. The examples are aplenty<br />
and most of them are still very well<br />
in public view – right up to this<br />
moment as medieval architectural<br />
contents. Some famous examples<br />
include– a hybrid man- an upper<br />
half of a man with lower body of a<br />
serpent –described as ‘Nagaraja’-<br />
the king of serpents or a half-bird<br />
half man described as ‘Garuda’- the<br />
legendary mount of Lord Vishnu.<br />
But they remain only in selected<br />
places.<br />
But a strange and an amazing<br />
creature which has made<br />
unbelievably an omni - presence<br />
in various contexts of Nepali art<br />
and architecture- other than the<br />
mythical lions, is an image of a<br />
hybrid creature – a crocodile in<br />
the upper half and the body of a<br />
bird- replete with two bird-like<br />
legs and decorative wings. As the<br />
important upper half –the head is<br />
of a crocodile, it primarily retains<br />
the character of the aquatic animal.<br />
Described as ‘Graaha orMakar or<br />
Hiti-Manga’ in local Newari dialect,<br />
since the time immemorial, it has<br />
come down in the Nepali religious<br />
and art tradition as a giver of holy<br />
water – so essentially needed in<br />
every sacred act of worship. As a<br />
result, ‘Makar’ has made strong<br />
appearances whenever or wherever<br />
there is a context of natural flow of<br />
holy waters - that is in water spouts<br />
- manifested in stone gargoyle<br />
sculptures. In addition, it has a wide<br />
spread and more regular presence<br />
as an integral part of medieval<br />
architectural embellishment –<br />
as wood carving or as metal<br />
repousse works. Not to mention the<br />
presence of crocodile ‘the Makar’<br />
in the painting tradition as well in<br />
various roles and manifestations.<br />
An attempt is made here to make a<br />
brief observation on this interesting<br />
phenomenon.<br />
IN PAINTING<br />
Let’s begin with the tradition of<br />
painting wherever crocodile are<br />
seen or depicted in the stated weird<br />
form of ‘Graaha or Makar’- with<br />
reference to few available examples.<br />
Its manifestation in Nepali painting is<br />
astonishingly diverse and is amazing.<br />
It has continued to appear since the<br />
medieval times to right up to this<br />
moment in various manifestations.<br />
One of the most prolific and regular<br />
appearances are when it is seen in<br />
two sides of the outer rectangular<br />
extensions in all the four sides of a<br />
Buddhist Mandalas – a geometric<br />
diagram designed to assist in an act<br />
of meditation - essentially included<br />
as all important guardian deities.<br />
Two evidences cited here span<br />
some four hundred years from one<br />
another. Yet they serve the same<br />
purpose and are found almost in<br />
similar positions. The ‘Mandala of<br />
Sambhara’ – a Paubha dating 16th<br />
century circa – remains one of the<br />
earliest examples when a ‘Makar’ is<br />
seen in a Nepali painting. The next<br />
evidence cited here is a Mandala<br />
painting dated 1021 Nepal Era<br />
corresponding to late 19th century<br />
circa has too has a very close<br />
continuity in drawing the shape and<br />
its placement. The visible difference<br />
between the two can and is noted<br />
only in the artists’ changing taste for<br />
more details as a result of growing<br />
external influences creeping in the<br />
then local trend. Yet more amazing<br />
is the inclusion of Makar as part of<br />
decorative elements in the paintings<br />
painted for the Tibetan clientele as<br />
late as 18th century circa. Unlike<br />
the paintings meant for local clients,<br />
an example cited here has two<br />
Tibetan holy men – monks of the<br />
red cap sect (Nying Ma-Pa) as the<br />
central figures in the Paubha. Here,<br />
two diminutive Makars are found<br />
flanking outside the halos of the holy<br />
men. Such presentations are hardly<br />
found repeated in the works painted<br />
for local devotees. Interestingly,<br />
here the creatures are painted green<br />
than the usual red in other Mandalas.<br />
An image of a powerful head of a<br />
Makar is also found included along<br />
with the heads of other strong and<br />
powerful animals like elephant<br />
or lions in the medieval paintings<br />
whenever there was a need to<br />
attribute or demonstrate a display<br />
of an extra energy to a particular<br />
deity. Inclusion of crocodile as one<br />
of the extra heads in the depiction<br />
of multi- headed- all powerful Hindu<br />
or Shakta deity like ‘Guheswori or<br />
Guhyakali is one good example.<br />
It leads us to believe that in the<br />
medieval times, the notion of<br />
crocodile as a source of great<br />
energy was apparently very strong.<br />
So in the image we’ve included<br />
here the goddess Guheswori, in<br />
addition to many other heads, also<br />
has a head of a Makar. It visually<br />
describes the deity also possesses<br />
the aquatic power and strength like<br />
that of a crocodile. Similarly, in the<br />
narrative scrolls from the Nepali<br />
medieval art, crocodile are found<br />
depicted as normal aquatic creature<br />
– residing in a pool and has an<br />
encounter with a cursed elephant.<br />
As illustrations, Makars are painted<br />
based in the narratives of Hindu<br />
mythological story of ‘Gajendramoksya’-<br />
the salvation of the cursed<br />
elephant. The example given here<br />
is a folio from a prayer book used<br />
by Gen. Ranbir Singh Thapa- the<br />
youngest brother of Gen. Bhimsen<br />
Thapa in early 19th century circa.<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
63<br />
spacesnepal.com
IN SCULPTURAL TRADITION:<br />
AN INTEGRAL ELEMENT<br />
More surprising than in the painting,<br />
Nepali medieval architecture is<br />
obsessively replete with the image of<br />
‘Graaha or Makar.’ In the medieval<br />
tradition, an inclusion of this mythical<br />
creature had remained so prolific<br />
that it had virtually become an<br />
integral part of the architectural<br />
tradition. The most strong and visible<br />
example is the globally acclaimed<br />
tradition of stone water spout. All<br />
the popular stone water spouts<br />
found in the Kathmandu Valley<br />
narrate the extent of wide spread<br />
popularity of the tradition nurtured<br />
since near two thousand years.<br />
And till today it continues to remain<br />
all visible examples of its past<br />
glory. Virtually with no exception,<br />
all the stone spouts have the head<br />
of the carved head of Makar or a<br />
crocodile gargoyle – releasing water<br />
from its mouth. The most important<br />
feature of this unique tradition is its<br />
unmistakable continuity in its form<br />
and the style of presentation – since<br />
the earliest to the late nineteenth<br />
century after which the tradition went<br />
in decline. The front part has always<br />
a head of the mythical creature<br />
whereas the body is carved has<br />
floral motifs – derived mostly from<br />
the similar tradition found in the<br />
northern Gangetic plains. Stylistically,<br />
there may remain a little variation<br />
in the minor details as a result of<br />
local improvisations or the passage<br />
of time. But in essence, beginning<br />
from the Licchavi times to late Malla<br />
period, the tradition of stone spouts<br />
remained intact, vibrant and alive.<br />
More astonishing is how the Makar<br />
has a place in metal and wood<br />
works of medieval architecture. An<br />
interesting example is the tradition<br />
of placing a tympanum in each and<br />
every important door way – be it a<br />
place of worship – irrespective of<br />
Buddhist or Hindu shrine or a main<br />
entrance of a palace. Also in addition,<br />
whenever there is a need to provide<br />
an arch-like niche to a deity, the basic<br />
paraphernalia remains the same.<br />
The tradition has a rigid standard<br />
that the contents of such decorative<br />
arch should invariably remains same<br />
and unchanged. The normal contents<br />
include other than the central figures<br />
of Chhepu- or the ‘Kirti- mukha’the<br />
all powerful protective monster, the<br />
sides must by flanked or protected<br />
by the two mythical crocodiles -<br />
looking in two opposite directions. So<br />
a careful observer would note that<br />
from all important palace entrance<br />
like the Golden gate of Bhaktapur<br />
Durbar to Patan Durbar or to every<br />
entrance of a Buddhist Vihar, the<br />
composition and the elements remain<br />
unaltered except in some rare cases.<br />
In addition, even in a stone Buddhist<br />
stupa wherever there is a niche<br />
created for the deity is created the<br />
upper arch is always embellished<br />
with the same contents- that is both<br />
the ends flanked by ‘Graaha or<br />
Makar or Hiti-manga’.<br />
Origins: a Sub-continental Culture<br />
A popular belief held by many here<br />
that many of the contents or the<br />
motifs mentioned above including<br />
the ‘Makar’ have its origins here. To<br />
think otherwise it may not be easily<br />
acceptable. And it is partly true. But<br />
it is also true that in the hoary past<br />
many of these weird motifs forms had<br />
had interesting origins elsewhere but<br />
had passed through many gradual<br />
phases of transformation before it<br />
came to be established as a very<br />
important and integral part of Nepali<br />
Art.<br />
The entry of a hybrid-crocodile<br />
as we find in the local art tradition<br />
as ‘Makar’ is one of such glaring<br />
examples. First and foremost is a<br />
fact that the art tradition of Nepal has<br />
always remained concentrated in the<br />
Valley of Kathmandu and the Valley<br />
has never remained a natural habitat<br />
for this aquatic anima. So there is<br />
very likelihood of local artists were<br />
familiar or got inspired by this weird<br />
animal to enter into their imagination.<br />
Going by an early example,<br />
depiction of crocodile in a stone<br />
water spout is found in Handigaon<br />
as early as early Licchavi period of<br />
4th or 5th AD circa. It means by the<br />
time the artists had well knew the<br />
need to depict form of crocodile or<br />
‘Makar’ in a stone spout – meant for<br />
the flow of holy water. And here it<br />
becomes natural to conjure a fact that<br />
the tradition made the entry along<br />
with the art-forms from the Gangetic<br />
plains in the South where the rulers<br />
from both the sides had had close<br />
blood relations.<br />
And it is widely believed the<br />
tradition to sculpt a decorative head<br />
of crocodile or a ‘Graaha’ had a<br />
beginning with a religious belief to<br />
provide a lofty or sacred status to<br />
a natural flow of water- specifically<br />
meant to lustrate the deities every<br />
morning during the Vedic times.<br />
Also apparently to the early men, a<br />
presence of an image of a crocodile<br />
may have provided them a notion of<br />
the animal as a perennial source of<br />
holy water. And as time passed by,<br />
the tradition gained a widespread<br />
acceptance not only throughout<br />
the Indian sub- continent including<br />
spacesnepal.com 64<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
the Valley of Kathmandu but also<br />
spread far and wide in South Eastern<br />
civilization of Java, Sumatra as well.<br />
And in other word, this amazing<br />
phenomenon although so popular<br />
and has remained so integral part of<br />
our visual culture, is a result and an<br />
extension of a wider Sub- continental<br />
heritage.<br />
Madan Chitrakar<br />
<strong>April</strong> 17, <strong>2012</strong><br />
madanc@ntc.net.np<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
65<br />
spacesnepal.com
spacesnepal.com 66<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Nepa Marble<br />
<strong>March</strong> - <strong>April</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
67<br />
spacesnepal.com