Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ...

Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ... Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ...

kosovo.undp.org
from kosovo.undp.org More from this publisher
12.12.2012 Views

The overlap between those excluded from factor markets and those excluded from basic goods and services is surprisingly small: of the total 7.6 percent of households excluded from all factor markets, more than half (about 60 percent) are able to meet their critical needs. This discrepancy can be explained by the fact that around 20 percent of households receive remittances 43 and around 8 percent of households receive social protection transfers. FIGURe 2.2 4.6% Proportion of households excluded only from factor markets In Kosovo, the role of social protection transfers is limited to improving the welfare of the population 44 because the current social protection system 45 is characterised by very limited benefits 46 and low coverage of the poor. 47 However, studies have shown that migration and remittances have been the most effective mechanism for reducing the poverty of recipient families. 48 (iii) Drivers of exclusion: the three primary drivers of the exclusion mecha- 38 | KOSOVO HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2010 3% nism in Kosovo are joblessness, low productivity in agriculture sector and the weak social protection sysem. Joblessness: in the previous sub sections we have seen how a lack of jobs leads to exclusion from essential and mainstream economic processes. Joblessness may also lead to weakening of motivation and make the long-term unemployed even more passive. Youth unemployment can take a particularly high toll, leading to the long-run loss of Intersection between those that are excluded from factor markets and those excluded from basic goods and services 18.2% Proportion of households excluded only from basic goods and services self-esteem. Unemployment can weaken family harmony and coherence and increase gender divisions. In the previous sections we have also seen that employment alone does If you are over 40, it is very difficult to get a steady job therefore I have to take more seasonal and temporary jobs. An unemployed participant of a focus group

not protect from exclusion from goods and services. 49 This confirms that there are many workers engaged in low-paid and low-productivity jobs who do not earn enough to move out of poverty. Unfortunately, Kosovo has not succeeded in raising the share of the population that is gainfully employed and job opportunities remain scarce. Employmentto-population ratios have stayed nearly steady during the period of 2003-2008 (see Figure 2.3), when Kosovo experienced an almost “jobless” GDP growth outside of the capital Prishtinë/Priština. While the growing population and the low skill level of job-seekers are some factors contributing to this disappointing outcome, the inadequate level of labour demand remains the key constraint. Labour demand has been insufficient to absorb new labour force entries and reduce the pool of the unemployed. Inadequate labour demand is also main cause for poorly remunerated and low productivity jobs. There are two possible causes of the slow growth in labour demand (employment): first, the low growth rate of per capita real GDP and secondly, the ‘pattern of growth’. Economic growth during the period 2003-2005 was only slightly higher than the population growth meaning that the GDP per capita remained essentially stagnant. For the period of 2003-2009, GDP per capita growth rate averaged barely 1.8 percent. An average annual growth in per capita income of less than 2 percent is simply not high enough to induce strong labour demand and poverty reduction – particularly without institutional mechanisms for equitable and povertyfocused distribution of revenues. Experiences of other countries show that 2 percent growth in per capita GDP translates into a minimum of 1 percent an- FIGURe 0% 2.3 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% Employment rate (percentage of working age population) 30% 35% 25% 28% Source: SOK, Labour Force Surveys (2003- 2008) nual growth in per capita personal consumption. 50 A consumption increase of 1 percent would barely prevent an increase in poverty when the inequality in the country is increasing. 51 In addition, growth has been dominated by only two sectors: construction and trade (imports), in response to increased consumption financed by foreign aid and remittances. Kosovo’s agriculture and manufacturing sectors - essential engines of private sector growth, job creation and foreign direct investment (FDI) - failed to recover. 52 This growth pattern which is characterised by low private sector investments in productive sectors and is based on private consumption (fuelled by remittances) limits the capacity of the economy to generate additional jobs and leads to lower increases in employment. Extractive industries such as mining and minerals are another potential source of growth that remain underutilized mainly due to problems with property rights and lack of sound and transparent legal and institutional frameworks for investment. Problems 29% 29% 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 27% 24% ECONOMIC AND LABOUR MARKET EXCLUSION | 39

not protect from exclusion from goods<br />

and services. 49 This confirms that there<br />

are many workers engaged in low-paid<br />

and low-productivity jobs who do not<br />

earn enough to move out of poverty.<br />

Unfortunately, <strong>Kosovo</strong> has not succeeded<br />

in raising the share of the population<br />

that is gainfully employed and job opportunities<br />

remain scarce. Employmentto-population<br />

ratios have stayed nearly<br />

steady during the period of 2003-2008<br />

(see Figure 2.3), when <strong>Kosovo</strong> experienced<br />

an almost “jobless” GDP growth<br />

outside of the capital Prishtinë/Priština.<br />

While the growing population and the<br />

low skill level of job-seekers are some<br />

factors contributing to this disappointing<br />

outcome, the inadequate level of<br />

labour demand remains the key constraint.<br />

Labour demand has been insufficient<br />

to absorb new labour force entries<br />

and reduce the pool of the unemployed.<br />

Inadequate labour demand is<br />

also main cause for poorly remunerated<br />

and low productivity jobs.<br />

There are two possible causes of the<br />

slow growth in labour demand (employment):<br />

first, the low growth rate of<br />

per capita real GDP and secondly, the<br />

‘pattern of growth’. Economic growth<br />

during the period 2003-2005 was only<br />

slightly higher than the population<br />

growth meaning that the GDP per capita<br />

remained essentially stagnant. For<br />

the period of 2003-2009, GDP per capita<br />

growth rate averaged barely 1.8 percent.<br />

An average annual growth in per capita<br />

income of less than 2 percent is simply<br />

not high enough to induce strong<br />

labour demand and poverty reduction<br />

– particularly without institutional<br />

mechanisms for equitable and povertyfocused<br />

distribution of revenues. Experiences<br />

of other countries show that 2<br />

percent growth in per capita GDP translates<br />

into a minimum of 1 percent an-<br />

FIGURe<br />

0%<br />

2.3<br />

5%<br />

10%<br />

15%<br />

20%<br />

25%<br />

Employment rate (percentage of working age<br />

population)<br />

30%<br />

35%<br />

25%<br />

28%<br />

Source: SOK, Labour Force Surveys (2003- 2008)<br />

nual growth in per capita personal consumption.<br />

50 A consumption increase<br />

of 1 percent would barely prevent an<br />

increase in poverty when the inequality<br />

in the country is increasing. 51<br />

In addition, growth has been dominated<br />

by only two sectors: construction<br />

and trade (imports), in response<br />

to increased consumption financed by<br />

foreign aid and remittances. <strong>Kosovo</strong>’s<br />

agriculture and manufacturing sectors<br />

- essential engines of private sector<br />

growth, job creation and foreign<br />

direct investment (FDI) - failed to recover.<br />

52 This growth pattern which is<br />

characterised by low private sector investments<br />

in productive sectors and is<br />

based on private consumption (fuelled<br />

by remittances) limits the capacity of<br />

the economy to generate additional<br />

jobs and leads to lower increases in<br />

employment.<br />

Extractive industries such as mining<br />

and minerals are another potential<br />

source of growth that remain underutilized<br />

mainly due to problems with<br />

property rights and lack of sound and<br />

transparent legal and institutional<br />

frameworks for investment. Problems<br />

29% 29%<br />

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

27% 24%<br />

ECONOMIC AND LABOUR MARKET EXCLUSION<br />

| 39

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!