Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ...

Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ... Kosovo Human Development Report 2010 - UNDP Kosovo - United ...

kosovo.undp.org
from kosovo.undp.org More from this publisher
12.12.2012 Views

entated basis for examination of social inequities. It extends beyond the issues of employment or income and addresses other factors and reasons why people are excluded socially. Kosovo has complex multi-dimensional mechanisms and cycles that exclude individuals and groups from taking part in the critical process of socio-economic and political exchange. Moreover, the approach shifts the focus from “vulnerability” as an individual or group characteristic to societal barriers preventing full participation, thus leaving excluded people at the margins. For example, a young woman or man without sufficient education and skills may easily end up in a cycle of poverty and dependency on social assistance. Since most unemployment in Kosovo is long-term, they are easily convinced that finding a job will be impossible. Their children may then accept the idea that being unemployed is socially acceptable. Without recourse to opportunity, feelings of inadequacy and lack of social influence come to dominate the family’s interaction with the community. Marginalization swiftly follows. Social contacts are reduced with all except immediate family or other long-term unemployed. Lifting families out of this cycle, once it is well established, becomes extremely challenging. It is even harder to address exclusion when it comes packaged as social rejection. This is the unfortunate reality for many of Kosovo’s ethnic minorities – in particular Kosovo-RAE communities. Their lack of integration into Kosovo’s society manifests itself as higher than average unemployment, much lower levels of education and extremely low housing standards compared to the rest of the population. This in turn 20 | KOSOVO HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2010 prevents them from seeking greater integration, and reinforces the strong internal bonds that keep them separate from their mainly Kosovo-Albanian neighbours. Fear of the unknown and unwillingness to accommodate differences also underlies exclusion of other minority groups (not necessarily ethnic minorities), such as people with disabilities or young people from poorer backgrounds. They may be dissuaded from continuing beyond compulsory education by inaccessibility of university buildings, high charges and an absence of institutional and family support. Not only minorities are excluded in Kosovo. Women – nearly 50 percent of the population – are denied their full right to contribute socio-economically and politically – for a range of cultural reasons which this KHDR seeks to examine. Young people, particularly the poor, have also demonstrated an increased disaffection with a political process they feel does not represent them – threatening to de-link Kosovo’s democracy with the generation it was developed to serve. Governments are responsible and accountable for setting adequate legislative, administrative and budgetary measures to put in place a system which prevents social exclusion. Kosovo’s authorities have taken some important steps in this direction. The constitution incorporates The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW); addresses the rights of minorities by incorporating the Framework Convention on the Protection of National Minorities of the Council of Europe and includes the Convention on the Rights of the Child. 11 The Kosovo Action Plan for People with Disabilities 2009-2011 was developed and adopted through

an inclusive process. Home care services for those suffering from mental and psychiatric disorders are provided for in legislation. Some community mental health centers and residential housing have also been established under the authority of the Ministry of Health. 12 Yet despite the legislative progress, many of these laws and regulations often remain “paper promises” – merely statements of good intent. Implementation is almost universally weak, monitoring extremely uneven and proper reporting limited. Announcement of a policy is often equated with its implementation. This is one effect of the desire to align technically with EU standards as quickly as possible. Real impact on people’s lives is a secondary consideration – not often duly prioritized and budgeted for. This KHDR provides recommendations and identifies priorities to move towards the implementation of existing laws, along with the development and effective implementation of new policies to further eliminate barriers to social inclusion. The report also points at the importance of selecting targets and indicators for regular measuring and reporting on progress in the area of social inclusion. Although the onus of implementation of laws and policies is on Kosovo’s administration, this KHDR also emphasizes the critical role of civil society and the media to promote and realize true social inclusion. Finally, it explores the necessary changes needed to create a participatory approach to policymaking. A range of international analytical tools and Kosovo statistical sources are drawn on for this report; however, a significant share of analysis is based on data the 2009 Kosovo Mosaic Survey: Public Services and Local Authorities in Focus, published by UNDP. The Mosaic Survey collected data from 6,400 respondents across the full spectrum of Kosovan society. It measures perception and awareness on a variety of factors affecting daily life and individual interactions with local government. Through this survey, significant inequalities across social groups, age and between the genders can be both quantitatively and qualitatively defined. 3. Report structure and chapter outline Chapter 1 - Social inclusion and human development - conceptual background: this chapter introduces the concept of social exclusion, its dimensions, and manifestations. It establishes the conceptual linkages between human development and social inclusion. It analyzes social exclusion as a process and state of being excluded from the life of a community, municipality, society and the world. It explores the potential of a social inclusion-based analysis to better understand the social dynamics of deprivation from public services, poverty and equality in Kosovo. By combining both objective and subjective measures of exclusion, it identifies the multiple and many-layered drivers of exclusion in Kosovo – as well as opportunities for interventions that promote inclusion. Chapter 2 - Economic and labour market exclusion: this chapter develops an innovative approach towards a concept of economic exclusion. Rather than resting on traditional poverty definitions, it lays out a definition of economic exclusion based on factor markets and factors of production such as labour, land, capital, and the ability to purchase the necessary goods and INTRODUCTION | 21

an inclusive process. Home care services<br />

for those suffering from mental<br />

and psychiatric disorders are provided<br />

for in legislation. Some community<br />

mental health centers and residential<br />

housing have also been established<br />

under the authority of the Ministry of<br />

Health. 12<br />

Yet despite the legislative progress,<br />

many of these laws and regulations often<br />

remain “paper promises” – merely<br />

statements of good intent. Implementation<br />

is almost universally weak,<br />

monitoring extremely uneven and<br />

proper reporting limited. Announcement<br />

of a policy is often equated with<br />

its implementation. This is one effect of<br />

the desire to align technically with EU<br />

standards as quickly as possible. Real<br />

impact on people’s lives is a secondary<br />

consideration – not often duly prioritized<br />

and budgeted for.<br />

This KHDR provides recommendations<br />

and identifies priorities to move<br />

towards the implementation of existing<br />

laws, along with the development<br />

and effective implementation of new<br />

policies to further eliminate barriers to<br />

social inclusion. The report also points<br />

at the importance of selecting targets<br />

and indicators for regular measuring<br />

and reporting on progress in the<br />

area of social inclusion. Although the<br />

onus of implementation of laws and<br />

policies is on <strong>Kosovo</strong>’s administration,<br />

this KHDR also emphasizes the critical<br />

role of civil society and the media to<br />

promote and realize true social inclusion.<br />

Finally, it explores the necessary<br />

changes needed to create a participatory<br />

approach to policymaking.<br />

A range of international analytical<br />

tools and <strong>Kosovo</strong> statistical sources<br />

are drawn on for this report; however,<br />

a significant share of analysis is based<br />

on data the 2009 <strong>Kosovo</strong> Mosaic Survey:<br />

Public Services and Local Authorities<br />

in Focus, published by <strong>UNDP</strong>. The Mosaic<br />

Survey collected data from 6,400<br />

respondents across the full spectrum<br />

of Kosovan society. It measures perception<br />

and awareness on a variety<br />

of factors affecting daily life and individual<br />

interactions with local government.<br />

Through this survey, significant<br />

inequalities across social groups, age<br />

and between the genders can be both<br />

quantitatively and qualitatively defined.<br />

3. <strong>Report</strong> structure and chapter<br />

outline<br />

Chapter 1 - Social inclusion and<br />

human development - conceptual<br />

background: this chapter introduces<br />

the concept of social exclusion, its<br />

dimensions, and manifestations. It<br />

establishes the conceptual linkages<br />

between human development and<br />

social inclusion. It analyzes social exclusion<br />

as a process and state of being<br />

excluded from the life of a community,<br />

municipality, society and the world. It<br />

explores the potential of a social inclusion-based<br />

analysis to better understand<br />

the social dynamics of deprivation<br />

from public services, poverty and<br />

equality in <strong>Kosovo</strong>. By combining both<br />

objective and subjective measures of<br />

exclusion, it identifies the multiple and<br />

many-layered drivers of exclusion in<br />

<strong>Kosovo</strong> – as well as opportunities for<br />

interventions that promote inclusion.<br />

Chapter 2 - Economic and labour<br />

market exclusion: this chapter develops<br />

an innovative approach towards a<br />

concept of economic exclusion. Rather<br />

than resting on traditional poverty definitions,<br />

it lays out a definition of economic<br />

exclusion based on factor markets<br />

and factors of production such<br />

as labour, land, capital, and the ability<br />

to purchase the necessary goods and<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

| 21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!