11.12.2012 Views

October 2010 - The Bulletin Magazine

October 2010 - The Bulletin Magazine

October 2010 - The Bulletin Magazine

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

WHY WARDS?<br />

submitted by James Sullivan<br />

A ward system in East Gwillimbury can provide more<br />

fair representation than the current at large system.<br />

<strong>The</strong> present system offers virtually no accountability.<br />

All issues are presented to a five-member council; but<br />

no single councillor is directly responsible for fielding<br />

constituents’ concerns or following through with a<br />

response. Issues raised by residents are routinely<br />

passed from council to various staff departments for a<br />

reply; issues that are perceived as controversial or<br />

politically sensitive can be easily sidestepped. So the<br />

buck wanders aimlessly, but never stops.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Ontario Municipal Act enables electors to petition<br />

council for a by-law dividing the municipality into<br />

wards. Canvassing for signatures, we encountered<br />

overwhelming support for a ward proposal because<br />

people want accountability in local government. A<br />

petition with over 200 signatures was delivered to<br />

council in December 2009.<br />

A staff report to council in February <strong>2010</strong><br />

recommended they hold a workshop on electoral<br />

systems, to be conducted by Dr. Robert Williams,<br />

professor emeritus University of Waterloo. <strong>The</strong> report<br />

further suggested that an electoral review be<br />

conducted to determine the merits of a ward system,<br />

and the criteria for establishing ward boundaries.<br />

<strong>The</strong> report recommended against a referendum<br />

question stating it is not an appropriate way to<br />

obtain public input, plus a ward review is<br />

needed for voters to make an informed<br />

decision.<br />

<strong>The</strong> petitioners supported the staff report. A full<br />

review seemed reasonable and appropriate, and<br />

in the best interest of the public. However, some<br />

councillors voted against the status quo,<br />

supporting a referendum question instead.<br />

Ambiguous and biased toward the status quo,<br />

the question relieved council of acting on the<br />

ward petition.<br />

Had council opted for an electoral review, there<br />

would have been no need for an OMB hearing.<br />

<strong>The</strong> referendum question as worded is meaningless<br />

without an electoral review to define alternatives to<br />

the current system. Our officials have left voters to<br />

ponder an obscure question. Further, council flatly<br />

stated, “it is not council’s job to educate the public” on<br />

the issue.<br />

My response to the referendum question?<br />

Vote No! Not the status quo.<br />

A ward system would benefit East Gwillimbury<br />

because:<br />

• Each area of town is afforded fair<br />

representation.<br />

• Ward councillors become more<br />

knowledgeable about the areas they represent.<br />

• Ward councillors are directly accountable to<br />

their constituents.<br />

• Each vote carries more weight in ward<br />

elections.<br />

• Wards reduce redundancies and council<br />

workloads.<br />

• Ward elections enable candidates to personally<br />

visit with each constituent household.<br />

• In at large systems, councillors compete<br />

against each other, hindering collaboration; it’s<br />

nearly impossible for new candidates to<br />

compete against incumbents.<br />

• We are far above the 10,000 population<br />

considered by the OMB to be the threshold for<br />

a ward system. 0<br />

MOUNT<br />

ALBERT<br />

VETERINARY<br />

HOSPITAL<br />

Dr. “Bob” Prendergast<br />

Full Service Animal Hospital<br />

Mon, Wed, Thurs & Fri 8am-6pm<br />

Tues 8am-7pm<br />

Grooming by Denise<br />

905-473-2400<br />

19144 Highway 48, Mount Albert<br />

(Across from Home Hardware<br />

Building Centre)<br />

www.thebulletinmagazine.com <strong>October</strong> <strong>2010</strong> | <strong>The</strong> <strong>Bulletin</strong> 35

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!