MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ...

MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ... MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ...

10.12.2012 Views

586 Infrastructure and environment for microinsurance Free look periods Recourse options can be reinforced by regulation requiring “free look” periods for longer-term or more complex products (particularly if they contain exclusions) where, once a policy is purchased, consumers have a defined period in which to change their mind, cancel the policy for any reason whatsoever and receive an equitable refund. This approach is gaining ground, 15 and in some countries the free look is being built into the policy wording, which also helps to advance the fairness objective. 26.3 Designing and implementing special consumer protection regimes for microinsurance The previous section discussed typical consumer protection issues in microinsurance and regulatory options to address them, including some reference to how these differ from those in more conventional insurance markets. The mandate, authority and structure of the insurance authority or other entity responsible for designing and implementing such rules is likely to vary from country to country. This has implications for implementation of a consumer protection regime for microinsurance. Where policymakers decide to create an alternative regulatory regime for microinsurance, a number of legal and practical issues need to be considered. 26.3.1 Consumer protection implications of microinsurance definitions and regulation Once the policy decision for adapted or specialized rules has been taken, there are a number of options for embodying this in law and regulation and achieving the appropriate access/protection balance in market conduct rules. One is to explicitly exempt microinsurance from certain requirements of the mainstream law and regulations. Another is to promulgate a special law or regulation, as in India and Peru. The special treatment of microinsurance may then be framed as broad principles or specific rules. Though a principles-based approach allows for maximum flexibility, in practice a rules-based approach is probably preferable while the microinsurance sector is in its development stage. Specific rules are likely to be applied more effectively by developing country supervisors facing capacity constraints, particularly where their actions may be challenged by politically connected special interests or the judicial system is still developing. 15 The requirement in South Africa is 30 days and this appears to be workable.

Protecting consumers while promoting microinsurance Peru’s special regulation (Resolution 14283-2009) addresses consumer protection concerns by specifying qualitative product characteristics, recourse mechanisms and reporting requirements. However, the consumer protection rules cover only registered insurers. India and the Philippines have issued tailored regulations. In the case of India, the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) issued the “MicroInsurance regulations” in 2009 entirely concerned with insurance market conduct rather than prudential matters, which rely on the main insurance law. As in Peru, it covered only registered insurers. In the Philippines, the rules introduced in early 2010 are part of a national effort to strengthen supervision and market conduct of a range of microinsurance institutions, including formally licensed insurers, mutual benefit associations and cooperatives. Informal insurance schemes have been given the choice of working through a licensed insurer or converting to one of three approved structures (see Box 25.5). In both India and the Philippines, microinsurance agents have to be licensed through the insurance supervisor. In India, a code of conduct also applies to all agents, including microinsurance agents, and insurers are required to ensure that it is observed. The code has the force of law (being included in the agency regulations) and any breaches result in termination of the agency licence. As long as a code’s market conduct requirements are reasonable and a capable institution is in a position to oversee the agents, this “delegated self-regulation” approach to codes of conduct is more likely to succeed than purely voluntary codes in the case of microinsurance. Purely voluntary codes tend to be found more often in industrialized countries (e.g. Canada), where strong supervisors and industry associations are in a position to apply moral suasion; it should be noted, however, that they do not always work perfectly, even in those settings. 26.3.2 Regulatory scope, coverage and arbitrage A related policy issue is whether consumer protection regulation effectively covers all formal entities that provide risk products to the economically active poor. If special regulation is developed under the powers of the insurance law only, the coverage is likely to be limited and there will be scope for regulatory arbitrage between licensed and unlicensed entities. For this reason, it is desirable for microinsurance consumer protection regulation to be supported by law that applies to all relevant institutions under a single supervisor, as in the Philippines and Australia. 16 As a rule, if an institution is considered to be important enough 16 In Australia, for historical reasons, a separate law exists for Friendly Societies, but they were brought under the same Federal supervisors as insurance companies when the Australian Prudential Regulatory Authority (APRA) was established. 587

586 Infrastructure and environment for microinsurance<br />

Free look periods<br />

Recourse options can be reinforced by regulation requiring “free look” periods<br />

for longer-term or more complex products (particularly if they contain exclusions)<br />

where, once a policy is purchased, consumers have a defined period in<br />

which to change their mind, cancel the policy for any reason whatsoever and<br />

receive an equitable refund. This approach is gaining ground, 15 and in some<br />

countries the free look is being built into the policy wording, which also helps to<br />

advance the fairness objective.<br />

26.3 Designing and implementing special consumer protection regimes for<br />

microinsurance<br />

The previous section discussed typical consumer protection issues in microinsurance<br />

and regulatory options to address them, including some reference to how<br />

these differ from those in more conventional insurance markets. The mandate,<br />

authority and structure of the insurance authority or other entity responsible for<br />

designing and implementing such rules is likely to vary from country to country.<br />

This has implications for implementation of a consumer protection regime for<br />

microinsurance. Where policymakers decide to create an alternative regulatory<br />

regime for microinsurance, a number of legal and practical issues need to be considered.<br />

26.3.1 Consumer protection implications of microinsurance definitions<br />

and regulation<br />

Once the policy decision for adapted or specialized rules has been taken, there<br />

are a number of options for embodying this in law and regulation and achieving<br />

the appropriate access/protection balance in market conduct rules. One is to<br />

explicitly exempt microinsurance from certain requirements of the mainstream<br />

law and regulations. Another is to promulgate a special law or regulation, as in<br />

India and Peru. The special treatment of microinsurance may then be framed as<br />

broad principles or specific rules. Though a principles-based approach allows for<br />

maximum flexibility, in practice a rules-based approach is probably preferable<br />

while the microinsurance sector is in its development stage. Specific rules are<br />

likely to be applied more effectively by developing country supervisors facing<br />

capacity constraints, particularly where their actions may be challenged by politically<br />

connected special interests or the judicial system is still developing.<br />

15 The requirement in South Africa is 30 days and this appears to be workable.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!