MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ...
MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ... MR Microinsurance_2012_03_29.indd - International Labour ...
22 Emerging issues social and fi nancial impact by saying, “Microinsurance is a double bottom-line business: it has an immediate social impact and, importantly from our perspective, also has a long-term fi nancial impact. With microinsurance, we tap a huge market of low-income households at the bottom of the economic pyramid” (Allianz Group, 2011). Insurers can fi nd easier ways to make money than microinsurance. Th e pull of profi tability helps to keep them focused on effi ciency and market satisfaction, while the CSR angle provides some space for experimentation. Chapter 19 explores this tension between being good corporate citizens and expanding market share, while Box 1.3 highlights the reputation risk to which insurers are exposed as they pursue BoP profi ts. Box 1.3 Critique of the BoP approach Th e fi rst volume of Protecting the poor applied Prahalad’s “bottom of the pyrapyra- mid” (BoP) business strategy to the insurance industry, suggesting that it might be an eff ective means to provide cover to low-income markets that could benefi t both the insured and the insurer. In the following years, Prahalad’s treatise has also attracted some criticism, warranting a closer investigation. Some critics challenge the motivations of corporations, and do not believe that they really can achieve a double bottom-line result. Others are concerned that sellsell- ing consumer goods to the poor may do little to eradicate poverty, and could even harm small businesses and threaten local jobs, for example if they buy from multi- nationals instead of from local producers. Another line of questioning relates to the target group, where perhaps Prahalad’s business model may apply to the upwardly mobile poor poor and emerging consumers, but but not to the poorest of the poor. One of of the most vocal critics, Aneel Karnani Karnani from from the University University of Michigan (2009), believes believes the BoP approach approach does not recognize that poor people people often act against against their own self-interests and and leads leads to to a romanticized view of BoP people people as value- conscious consumers and resilient entrepreneurs (which) are not only false, false, but but also harmful. harmful. Th e assumption that all the poor need is an opportunity to improve their livelihood is dangerous, according to Karnani, because it leads states to build too few legal, regulatory, and social mechanisms mechanisms to protect the poor, as well as to to rely too heavily on market solutions to to poverty. Th e e failure of this approach was evident in the Andhra Andhra Pradesh microfi nance crisis, where where the lack of supervision supervision of lending institutions enabled borrowers borrowers to take take multiple loans that they did not have have the the capacity to understand or repay. Criticism of the BoP approach, and the microfi nance crisis, certainly raise alarm bells for microinsurance. Given the complex nature of insurance, it is diffi - cult for consumers to understand, and they are vulnerable to mis-selling by agents
Current trends in microinsurance and to being misled by disreputable fi rms. Th ese observations highlight the importance for insurers going down-market of carefully considering whether they are providing client value value (Chapter 15), for policymakers and insurance asso- ciations of promoting eff ective consumer protection (Chapter 26), and for regula- tors of cracking down on illegal insurers that could undermine the fl fl edgling insurance culture in low-income markets (Chapter 25). Insurers need to be aware of the BoP criticisms, and respond accordingly. Few insurers would claim that they had any intention of reaching the very bottom of the pyramid, but were more interested in expanding the insurance market by including under-served segments. In addition, the provision of insurance should not replace local risk-management strategies, but rather enhance their eff ectiveness. In fact, insurance is fundamentally diff erent from shampoo or salt, the con- sumer goods often highlighted in BoP business models, because it provides an essential risk-management service that really can enable low-income families to stave off destitution. Th e emerging focus on the profi tability of microinsurance, analysed in Chapter 18, has spawned eff orts to reduce operational costs and have eff ective processes to serve masses of clients. To support scale, insurers recognize the need to effi ciently process huge volumes of data, while securely linking into delivery channels’ systems to facilitate data transfer. At the same time, front-offi ce technology, from handheld and point-of-sale devices to mobile phones, are beginning to improve sales, premium collection and even claims settlement. Th e role of technology in microinsurance is explored in Chapter 24. Some reinsurers have been interested in fi nding a role in microinsurance for years. With supply dominated by simple life covers, most commercial schemes had little need for reinsurance. However, as client demand has been better understood, and insurers have been interested in addressing those needs, reinsurers have become more important to the equation. Insurers in many cases have needed not only the reinsurers’ fi nancial safety net, but also their expertise in navigating the risks of more complex products. As noted by a senior person at Swiss Re, “Insurance is a cornerstone of economic growth and stability, and [we] … are proud to contribute our expertise so that even the poorest farmers and their families can cope when crops are ruined by drought, fl ood or other climate-related impacts” (Swiss Re, 2011). Reinsurers have contributed to developing more complex products, such as health and index-based insurance, and enabling disaster covers to be written. Indeed, with index insurance, most if not all of the risk is ceded to the reinsurer (see Chapters 4 and 11, and section 20.2). 23
- Page 1: Protecting the poor A microinsuranc
- Page 4 and 5: Publications of the International L
- Page 6 and 7: vi Contents Part ii Health insuranc
- Page 8 and 9: viii Contents 19 Teaching elephants
- Page 10 and 11: x Contents 15.4 Products included i
- Page 12 and 13: xii Contents 10.3 Alternative distr
- Page 14 and 15: xiv Acknowledgements Th is publicat
- Page 16 and 17: xvi Table of acronyms AABY Aam Admi
- Page 18 and 19: xviii Table of acronyms FMD foot an
- Page 20 and 21: xx Table of acronyms NCMSL National
- Page 22 and 23: xxii Table of acronyms UMSGF Union
- Page 24 and 25: 2 Introduction Benefits for the wor
- Page 26 and 27: 4 Introduction in many emerging and
- Page 29 and 30: I Emerging issues 7
- Page 31 and 32: Current trends in microinsurance Wh
- Page 33 and 34: Current trends in microinsurance As
- Page 35 and 36: Current trends in microinsurance Si
- Page 37 and 38: Current trends in microinsurance vo
- Page 39 and 40: Current trends in microinsurance A
- Page 41 and 42: Current trends in microinsurance (s
- Page 43: Current trends in microinsurance th
- Page 47 and 48: Current trends in microinsurance Fi
- Page 49 and 50: Current trends in microinsurance Co
- Page 51 and 52: Current trends in microinsurance sc
- Page 53 and 54: Current trends in microinsurance In
- Page 55 and 56: Current trends in microinsurance th
- Page 57 and 58: Current trends in microinsurance in
- Page 59 and 60: Current trends in microinsurance sh
- Page 61 and 62: Current trends in microinsurance cl
- Page 63 and 64: Th e potential of microinsurance fo
- Page 65 and 66: Th e potential of microinsurance fo
- Page 67 and 68: The potential of microinsurance for
- Page 69 and 70: Th e potential of microinsurance fo
- Page 71 and 72: The potential of microinsurance for
- Page 73 and 74: The potential of microinsurance for
- Page 75: The potential of microinsurance for
- Page 78 and 79: 56 Emerging issues Th ese funds and
- Page 80 and 81: 58 Emerging issues year precipitati
- Page 82 and 83: 60 Emerging issues pre-emptively en
- Page 84 and 85: 62 Emerging issues 3.2 The current
- Page 86 and 87: 64 Emerging issues Hence, this chap
- Page 88 and 89: 66 Emerging issues Table 3.1 Impact
- Page 90 and 91: 68 Emerging issues Expenditure Indi
- Page 92 and 93: 70 Emerging issues Box 3.2 Impact o
Current trends in microinsurance<br />
and to being misled by disreputable fi rms. Th ese observations highlight the<br />
importance for insurers going down-market of carefully considering whether<br />
they are providing client value value (Chapter 15), for policymakers and insurance asso-<br />
ciations of promoting eff ective consumer protection (Chapter 26), and for regula-<br />
tors of cracking down on illegal insurers that could undermine the fl fl edgling<br />
insurance culture in low-income markets (Chapter 25).<br />
Insurers need to be aware of the BoP criticisms, and respond accordingly. Few<br />
insurers would claim that they had any intention of reaching the very bottom of<br />
the pyramid, but were more interested in expanding the insurance market by<br />
including under-served segments. In addition, the provision of insurance should<br />
not replace local risk-management strategies, but rather enhance their eff ectiveness.<br />
In fact, insurance is fundamentally diff erent from shampoo or salt, the con-<br />
sumer goods often highlighted in BoP business models, because it provides an<br />
essential risk-management service that really can enable low-income families to<br />
stave off destitution.<br />
Th e emerging focus on the profi tability of microinsurance, analysed in<br />
Chapter 18, has spawned eff orts to reduce operational costs and have eff ective<br />
processes to serve masses of clients. To support scale, insurers recognize the need<br />
to effi ciently process huge volumes of data, while securely linking into delivery<br />
channels’ systems to facilitate data transfer. At the same time, front-offi ce<br />
technology, from handheld and point-of-sale devices to mobile phones, are<br />
beginning to improve sales, premium collection and even claims settlement. Th e<br />
role of technology in microinsurance is explored in Chapter 24.<br />
Some reinsurers have been interested in fi nding a role in microinsurance for<br />
years. With supply dominated by simple life covers, most commercial schemes<br />
had little need for reinsurance. However, as client demand has been better<br />
understood, and insurers have been interested in addressing those needs,<br />
reinsurers have become more important to the equation. Insurers in many cases<br />
have needed not only the reinsurers’ fi nancial safety net, but also their expertise<br />
in navigating the risks of more complex products. As noted by a senior person<br />
at Swiss Re, “Insurance is a cornerstone of economic growth and stability,<br />
and [we] … are proud to contribute our expertise so that even the poorest<br />
farmers and their families can cope when crops are ruined by drought, fl ood or<br />
other climate-related impacts” (Swiss Re, 2011). Reinsurers have contributed to<br />
developing more complex products, such as health and index-based insurance,<br />
and enabling disaster covers to be written. Indeed, with index insurance, most<br />
if not all of the risk is ceded to the reinsurer (see Chapters 4 and 11, and section<br />
20.2).<br />
23