Inspiration
2dteG8h
2dteG8h
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Inspiration</strong> #2<br />
INSIDE<br />
• Give IPF ‘the same attention as cancer’<br />
• The route to first-class care<br />
• Patient and carer perspectives<br />
The production of this document has been wholly funded by Boehringer Ingelheim. pharmaphorum media limited was contracted by Boehringer Ingelheim to conduct<br />
and write up the interviews that are featured. The interviews were completed either over the telephone or face-to-face. None of the contributors have received any<br />
payment for providing their interview and the views expressed are their own.<br />
UK/TIS-161000a – Date of preparation: September 2016
<strong>Inspiration</strong> #2<br />
Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis (IPF)<br />
Report September 2016<br />
www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org www.blf.org.uk www.boehringer-ingelheim.co.uk<br />
Editorial contributors<br />
Claire Bowie has a background in biological<br />
sciences, and extensive experience in<br />
pharmaceutical and biotech journalism, editing,<br />
PR and healthcare communications.<br />
Much of Claire’s career has been spent in<br />
publishing, giving her an in-depth understanding<br />
of the healthcare and life sciences sectors.<br />
Jenny Hone is a freelance journalist with many<br />
years’ experience in pharmaceutical and biotech<br />
journalism/editing and med comms. She was<br />
a freelance consulting editor on PharmaTimes<br />
Magazine; editor of Scrip Magazine; and has<br />
written for the Sunday Telegraph, IMS, Quintiles<br />
and Pharmaceutical Marketing.<br />
Marco Ricci has extensive experience writing<br />
online content, ranging from patient-friendly<br />
information to pharmaceutical journalism. He has<br />
a postgraduate degree in oncology, as well as a<br />
degree in the biological sciences, and currently<br />
reports for the pharmaphorum website on all<br />
matters digital health.<br />
Design & Production<br />
Mike Smith<br />
pharmaphorum media<br />
www.pharmaphorum.com
Foreword<br />
“Provide high quality care for people with IPF”<br />
It is a pleasure to provide a foreword for this issue of <strong>Inspiration</strong> which<br />
focuses on care pathways and service provision for patients with the rare<br />
lung disease idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.<br />
As the Battle for Breath 1 report from the British Lung Foundation points out,<br />
there appears to be an increase in the number of people being diagnosed<br />
with and dying from IPF. Although the reasons for this are not obvious, it<br />
could be due to enhanced detection as well as a genuine increase in the<br />
prevalence of the condition.<br />
As a consequence, recent years have seen the development of a multidisciplinary<br />
approach to the management of this devastating illness.<br />
In England, supervision of this treatment comes under the specialised<br />
commissioning system because of the relatively rare nature of the condition,<br />
the availability of clinical expertise and the potential high costs of therapy.<br />
This system also seeks to provide a standardised and high level of service<br />
specification, as well as equity of access for patients across the country. To<br />
this end, centres and networks treating IPF are being developed and – while<br />
for the moment there is some geographical variability – we expect that the<br />
recent reconfiguration of clinical reference groups and greater investment<br />
in specialised commissioning will improve the situation still further.<br />
This issue of <strong>Inspiration</strong> contains a stark view of the realities of IPF and<br />
the challenges that we face to provide high quality care and support for all<br />
those who are affected. It would be nice to think that in England we can<br />
develop a system of care for such patients that will become the envy of<br />
the world.<br />
Professor Mike Morgan<br />
Chair NHS England Respiratory Clinical Reference Group and<br />
National Clinical Director Respiratory NHS England<br />
Reference<br />
1<br />
British Lung Foundation (2016) The Battle for Breath https://www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/our-research/<br />
the-battle-for-breath-2016 (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
3
Introduction<br />
Where is the<br />
treatment and<br />
care for IPF?<br />
IPF is one of<br />
200 orphan lung<br />
diseases and,<br />
perhaps surprisingly<br />
for such a littleknown<br />
condition,<br />
the prognosis is<br />
often worse than<br />
for lung cancer<br />
The facts about respiratory diseases in the UK – and idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) in particular<br />
– make for stark reading.<br />
IPF – a little-recognised terminal condition characterised by the build-up of scar tissue in the<br />
lungs leading to shortness of breath and eventual respiratory failure – is now thought to affect twice as<br />
many people in the UK as previously thought. Recent data from the British Lung Foundation’s three-year<br />
Respiratory Health of the Nation project reveals that more than 32,000 people in the UK are living with<br />
the disease, compared with the 10,000 to 15,000 estimated by NICE in 2015 – in other words, as many<br />
as 50 per 100,000 people. 1<br />
This large increase in the number of known sufferers is believed to be down to changes in the way the<br />
condition is coded by healthcare practitioners, with up to eight different codes being used to describe<br />
the disease that have taken time to have an effect. Certainly what these new data show is that there are<br />
nearly 9,000 hospital admissions a year for IPF, accounting for 86,000 hospital bed days – so the impact<br />
on NHS services is greater than its prevalence suggests. 2<br />
But just where does IPF fit with other respiratory diseases?<br />
IPF is one of 200 orphan lung diseases and, perhaps surprisingly for such a little-known condition,<br />
the prognosis is often worse than for lung cancer: it can take up to two years for patients with this<br />
condition to be diagnosed following their first symptoms, and as many as half of patients die within<br />
three years of diagnosis. 3, 4<br />
Decades of neglect<br />
Part of the reason for this is that IPF, and respiratory disease in general, has not had the attention that<br />
some of the other major diseases have received in the UK. According to the British Lung Foundation’s<br />
Battle for Breath report, 2 published in June 2016, the impact lung disease has on the nation’s health<br />
and health services is broadly the same as non-respiratory cancer or cardiovascular disease. But while<br />
decades of prioritisations have seen significant improvements in cancer and cardiovascular disease<br />
outcomes, lung disease has not received the same level of attention and investment.<br />
For example, in the UK, if a GP suspects a malignant cancer they must refer that individual to a<br />
specialist within two weeks of presentation, and treatment should start within two months of that<br />
referral 2 . Excluding lung cancer, no such targets exist for respiratory diseases.<br />
This means that while mortality rates are falling for the UK’s two biggest disease areas, there has been<br />
no improvement in the past 10 years in the number of deaths from the third biggest killer – lung disease. 2<br />
One in five people in the UK die from it each year – higher than the European and EU average. 5<br />
So what is being done?<br />
Leading patient organisations Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis and the British Lung Foundation are at the<br />
forefront of campaigns to improve the clinical pathway for IPF and, in two landmark reports 2, 6 recently,<br />
4
Introduction<br />
“In a recent<br />
survey of IPF<br />
patients, only<br />
43% of patients<br />
reported discussing<br />
oxygen therapy<br />
with a healthcare<br />
professional, and<br />
36% reported<br />
having no access to<br />
an ILD specialist<br />
nurse.” 15<br />
outline the crucial steps they believe are required to achieve this, including establishing taskforces in<br />
England and Scotland to produce new five-year strategies for tackling lung disease (Northern Ireland has<br />
a taskforce equivalent in the Regional Respiratory Forum, while Wales has already published Together<br />
for health – a respiratory delivery plan).<br />
Other key suggestions include making respiratory a priority area for strategic clinical networks in<br />
England to better integrate care and tackle regional variations; improving data recording, collection and<br />
analysis across the UK; improving the level of research funding for respiratory diseases; and investing in<br />
awareness campaigns, evidence-based screening and diagnosis, as well as prevention. 2<br />
Treatment and care<br />
Currently, however, service provision for lung disease, and IPF in particular, varies considerably across<br />
the UK. IPF has a higher mortality rate than many common cancers, including leukaemia, stomach, liver<br />
and skin. But the treatment pathway for this condition falls considerably short of that for cancer. 7, 8<br />
NHS England has asked commissioners in each region to decide on which centres should lead on<br />
services for interstitial lung diseases (ILDs) – the group of conditions to which IPF belongs – but the<br />
regions are at different stages of identifying these specialist ILD hospitals. At present, there are only 20<br />
key specialist centres in England, three in Scotland, one in Wales, and as yet no service in Northern<br />
Ireland (patients have to travel to Newcastle for lung transplant services). 9<br />
NICE quality standards and the NHS England service specifications for ILD services set out the<br />
stages and standards of care that patients with lung disease and IPF can expect 10, 11 citing, in particular,<br />
the importance of a multidisciplinary team of expert healthcare professionals to diagnose IPF. In the<br />
meantime, and in practice, early diagnosis remains a challenge. As detailed in our first <strong>Inspiration</strong> report,<br />
published in February 2016, awareness of IPF among the general public and healthcare practitioners is<br />
low, leading to high rates of both mis-, and late, diagnosis. 12<br />
With the European IPF patient charter 13 calling for IPF training to be embedded in healthcare<br />
professionals’ curricula and accreditation systems – as well as the use of standardised protocols and<br />
gold standard diagnostic methods to facilitate rapid and accurate diagnosis – it will be vital to have fully<br />
functioning ILD centres across the country.<br />
NICE also recommends the availability of an ILD specialist nurse to provide information and support<br />
to people with IPF, their families and carers. 14 Currently, however, there is a recognised shortage of ILD<br />
15, 16<br />
specialist nurses to help patients navigate their care.<br />
It also recommends appointments with a healthcare professional six and 12 months after diagnosis;<br />
assessment for pulmonary rehabilitation; and discussions with a healthcare professional about the<br />
option of a lung transplant within six months of diagnosis. In reality, however, few patients with IPF<br />
qualify for a transplant.<br />
As Dr Toby Maher, consultant respiratory physician at the Royal<br />
Brompton Hospital, comments: “NICE has clear standards on<br />
service provision and treatment access for IPF patients,<br />
but despite guidelines setting out what the best care<br />
looks like, they are not always followed.<br />
In a recent survey of IPF patients, only 43%<br />
of patients reported discussing oxygen<br />
therapy with a healthcare professional, and<br />
36% reported having no access to an ILD<br />
specialist nurse.” 15<br />
This mirrors the findings of a similar<br />
patient survey conducted last year,<br />
which found that less than half of the<br />
300-plus respondents had been offered<br />
pulmonary rehabilitation and almost onethird<br />
of patients did not have access to<br />
a specialist nurse for ongoing support<br />
and information. On top of this, one in<br />
three said they did not feel clear about the<br />
treatment options available to them when<br />
they were diagnosed. 16
Variable access to medicines<br />
In Germany and the USA every pulmonologist is able to prescribe either of the two available treatments<br />
for this condition. In the UK, however, this decision to prescribe can only be made by the specialist<br />
centre and only those patients who fall between the parameters of 50% to 80% lung function (measured<br />
by forced vital capacity) will be eligible to receive medication.<br />
Not surprisingly, access to treatment is another focus of the European IPF patient charter, urging all<br />
relevant parties to include the patient perspective in decision-making related to product approval and<br />
regulation. 13<br />
With European IPF Week taking place on 17-25 September, many believe if serious progress is to be<br />
made in providing appropriate levels of service and care to IPF and lung disease patients, prioritisation<br />
and investment must be brought into line with cancer and cardiovascular disease.<br />
In the meantime, things are starting to look brighter for people living with lung disease. In the words of<br />
Professor Mike Morgan, respiratory National Clinical Director:<br />
“In England, the NHS faces a difficult future as a result of increasing demand and limited resources. We<br />
therefore have to seek more efficient ways to deliver the high quality care that is now available to people<br />
with lung disease.<br />
“In the past, people with IPF have had very little support. As described here, things have improved with<br />
the introduction of evidence-based treatment, including new drugs and rehabilitation, but it is important<br />
these are correctly delivered to all those who would benefit.<br />
“This is why the care of people with ILD is now being directed through the specialised commissioning<br />
system that ensures that regional networks and centres can provide equality of access and standardised<br />
decision-making through a specialist multi-disciplinary team for each patient. This is still a system in<br />
evolution but the latest reforms should ensure that the highest standards are finally introduced across<br />
the country.”<br />
References<br />
1<br />
British Lung Foundation, Health of the Nation project https://statistics.blf.org.uk/pulmonary-fibrosis (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
2<br />
British Lung Foundation, The Battle for Breath report (www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/our-research/the-battle-for-breath-2016) (Last<br />
accessed September 2016)<br />
3<br />
NHS Choices Pulmonary Fibrosis (Idiopathic) http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/pulmonary-fibrosis/Pages/Diagnosis.aspx (Last accessed<br />
September 2016)<br />
4<br />
Richeldi L (2015) Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: moving forward. BMC Medicine 13:231 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-<br />
7015/13/231 [Last accessed September 2016)<br />
5<br />
Age standardised mortality rates for all respiratory conditions in Europe. European Respiratory Society, The White Book<br />
www.erswhitebook.org/chapters/the-burden-of-lung-disease (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
6<br />
Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (2016) Fit for the Future: Future-proofing care for patients with IPF http://www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.<br />
org/research/fit-for-the-future-future-proofing-care-for-patients-with-ipf/ (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
7<br />
British Lung Foundation (2016) https://www.blf.org.uk/support-for-you/idiopathic-pulmonary-fibrosis-ipf/statistics/what-you-need-toknow<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
8<br />
Making More Health/Boehringer Ingelheim (2016) Calls for urgent focus on IPF as cases double https://blog.boehringer-ingelheim.<br />
co.uk/2016/05/17/calls-for-urgent-focus-on-ipf-as-cases-double/ (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
9<br />
British Lung Foundation list of IPF services in the UK www.blf.org.uk/sites/default/files/pulmonary-fibrosis-services-list--9-9-15.pdf<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
10<br />
NICE (2015) Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis in adults https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs79 (Last accessed September 2016).<br />
11<br />
NHS Commissioning Board (2013) NHS standard Contract for Respiratory: ILD https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/<br />
uploads/2013/06/a14-respiratory-inters-lung.pdf (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
12<br />
Boehringer Ingelheim (2016) <strong>Inspiration</strong> report on IPF. www.boehringer-ingelheim.co.uk/content/dam/internet/opu/uk_EN/images/<br />
IPFreport.pdf (Last accessed September 2016).<br />
13<br />
European IPF Patient Charter (2016) Call to action www.ipfcharter.org/call-to-action (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
14<br />
NICE (June 2013) Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis in adults: diagnosis and management www.nice.org.uk/guidance/CG163/chapter/Keypriorities-for-implementation<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
15<br />
British Lung Foundation (2015) Lost in the system: the patient experience in England https://www.blf.org.uk/sites/default/files/BLF-IPF-<br />
Report-2015---Lost-in-the-System---250215.pdf (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
16<br />
Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (September 2015) IPF Patient Survey Report http://www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org/wp-content/<br />
uploads/2015/10/APF-IPF-Patient-Survey-Report-full.pdf (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
6
Patient View<br />
A patient’s journey<br />
to diagnosis<br />
Fiona Ballantyne is a 49-year-old IPF patient who received her diagnosis after years of<br />
breathing difficulties. Here, she describes her journey to an accurate diagnosis, her current life<br />
and her worries for the future.<br />
How long had you experienced<br />
breathing problems before being<br />
diagnosed with IPF?<br />
My breathing had deteriorated over a number<br />
of years and I had a range of tests to try and<br />
understand why, but to no avail.<br />
Then, in August 2014, I contracted pneumonia<br />
and by May the following year my breathing still<br />
had not improved so I was referred for further tests.<br />
The results, received in September, revealed<br />
my breathing was abnormal and I was given<br />
steroid treatment for 10 days, which didn’t<br />
improve things.<br />
Then in November my left lung went into spasm<br />
from coughing and a few days later an out-ofhours<br />
doctor referred me to hospital.<br />
How long did it take you to receive an accurate<br />
diagnosis?<br />
From referral to the hospital, it took a further<br />
three months to be diagnosed with IPF. I saw<br />
a consultant the morning after my referral who<br />
asked me to walk to the end of the ward and back.<br />
When I returned, my lips were blue and my oxygen<br />
levels were below 80%. I had an electrocardiogram,<br />
an echocardiogram, lung function tests and blood<br />
tests, but I still didn’t get a diagnosis and was sent<br />
home with ambulatory oxygen.<br />
My consultant referred me for a lung biopsy in<br />
December 2015 and I was finally diagnosed in<br />
February this year.<br />
What treatment do you receive for your IPF?<br />
I’m currently treated with oxygen. I’ve also had<br />
six weeks of pulmonary rehabilitation and my<br />
local council has a great programme for people<br />
with lung conditions. I have a personal trainer and<br />
also get half price gym membership and classes.<br />
I had my first appointment to discuss the<br />
possibility of being placed on the lung transplant<br />
“If I can stay the<br />
way I am on oxygen<br />
for the next 10 years<br />
without having a<br />
lung transplant then<br />
I’m happy!”<br />
Fiona Ballantyne<br />
list in August but discovered I am too healthy to<br />
receive one at the moment, which is a good thing.<br />
To be honest, if I can stay the way I am on<br />
oxygen for the next 10 years without having a<br />
lung transplant then I’m happy!<br />
Do you receive adequate support and<br />
communication from the healthcare<br />
professionals involved in your care?<br />
I cannot fault my consultant – he is very<br />
approachable but I’m not always sure what to<br />
ask him. In my view, the information supplied to<br />
IPF patients could be improved as most of my<br />
knowledge and understanding comes from my<br />
own research. I also think there should be more<br />
pulmonary rehabilitation courses available.<br />
However, there are support groups out there if<br />
you look for them. For example, I found out about<br />
the West of Scotland support group through<br />
the British Lung Foundation website, which is<br />
meeting in the autumn. I can’t wait to attend<br />
because it will give me a chance to talk to people<br />
going through similar experiences to mine.<br />
What is life like living with IPF?<br />
When I was first diagnosed, I felt numb and<br />
scared – because of my age I have no prognosis<br />
as my consultant has never had a patient as<br />
young as me before.<br />
So I do worry for the future but having a<br />
condition like IPF has cemented who my friends<br />
really are and my family are here for me whenever<br />
I need them.<br />
Of course, there are some days when I want to<br />
climb back into bed and never get out, but I know<br />
that I have to. IPF is definitely a disease where<br />
you have to take every day as it comes.<br />
For more information go to<br />
www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org<br />
www.blf.org.uk<br />
7
BLF Interview<br />
The<br />
battle for<br />
breath<br />
With 20% of the UK population receiving a diagnosis of lung<br />
disease in their lifetime – equivalent to 550,000 people every year or<br />
at least one person every minute of every day – Steven Wibberley,<br />
chief operating officer at the British Lung Foundation outlines why<br />
healthcare professionals and policymakers should place more<br />
emphasis on our respiratory health – and IPF in particular<br />
In comparison to other diseases, how<br />
well (or otherwise) is respiratory health<br />
positioned in terms of the attention paid by<br />
policymakers and investment in research?<br />
As one of the UK’s three biggest killer disease<br />
areas, alongside non-respiratory cancer and<br />
cardiovascular disease, lung disease kills around<br />
115,000 people every year in the UK 1 – or one<br />
person every five minutes – and is responsible<br />
for more than 700,000 hospital admissions and<br />
6.1 million hospital bed days per annum. That’s<br />
equivalent to a staggering 8% of all admissions<br />
and 10% of all bed days. 2<br />
However, while the number of people dying<br />
from cardiovascular disease in the UK has fallen<br />
in the 10 year period since the last extensive<br />
epidemiological study, mortality rates from lung<br />
disease have barely changed.<br />
In recent years there has been a concerted<br />
effort to tackle cancer and cardiovascular<br />
disease, which has yielded real progress, but<br />
this same level of attention has not been given<br />
to investment in research or treatments for lung<br />
conditions. Lung disease needs to receive equal<br />
priority to these other therapy areas if we are to<br />
see improvements in outcomes. 1<br />
“IPF kills more<br />
people than many<br />
other better known<br />
conditions, such<br />
as leukaemia,<br />
yet funding into<br />
researching the<br />
condition is not at<br />
the same level”<br />
Can you put IPF in context of the broader<br />
picture for respiratory health in the UK?<br />
Our study found that some lung diseases are<br />
more common than UK public health bodies<br />
had previously suggested, and IPF was one<br />
of these, with around 32,500 people in the UK<br />
living with the condition – more than double the<br />
level 2 previously thought.<br />
IPF kills more people than many other better<br />
known conditions, such as leukaemia, yet funding<br />
for research into the condition is not at the same<br />
level. This is reflective of the lack of resource and<br />
prioritisation that has been given to lung research<br />
across the UK. In 2014, UK government spend<br />
on respiratory disease research was around £28<br />
million. 3 Twice as much (£56 million) was spent on<br />
cardiovascular disease research, and more than<br />
three and a half times as much (£103 million) was<br />
spent on cancer research.<br />
To what do you attribute the almost doubling<br />
of people living with IPF since the last official<br />
figures were released 10 years ago?<br />
It is unclear whether the stark difference between<br />
the two figures indicate IPF rates are rising or<br />
whether our study is more accurate than others.<br />
There are also considerable challenges with the<br />
way IPF is coded by healthcare professionals<br />
8
BLF Interview<br />
found that 30% had to wait six months or more<br />
for referral to a specialist and, even then, 39% of<br />
patients reported waiting three months or longer<br />
to be told they had IPF.<br />
It is disappointing that 26% also said they had<br />
been initially misdiagnosed with an alternative<br />
respiratory condition. 5<br />
In comparison, early diagnosis has been<br />
prioritised in the new National Cancer Strategy,<br />
which outlines an ambition for 95% of cancers<br />
to be diagnosed within four weeks by 2020. 6 Yet<br />
while deaths from IPF are equal to and greater<br />
than some types of cancer, we haven’t seen the<br />
same ambitious targets set for early diagnosis of<br />
this condition.<br />
For people with IPF, a referral to a specialist<br />
within four weeks, let alone a diagnosis, would<br />
be a major improvement.<br />
and a number of caveats in terms of how the<br />
base data were interpreted but, despite this, our<br />
clinical and epidemiological experts believe the<br />
figures provide a more accurate picture of IPF<br />
in the UK. In short, the number of people may<br />
be the same, but recording of the condition may<br />
have become more accurate.<br />
What is IPF’s impact from an NHS point of<br />
view, and what is its likely effect in the next<br />
five to 10 years?<br />
There are 9,000 hospital admissions that can be<br />
attributed to IPF each year and 86,000 hospital<br />
bed days accounted for by interstitial lung<br />
disease, 4 the category of conditions that IPF falls<br />
under. Although the total impact on health services<br />
is relatively low, it’s greater for each person living<br />
with pulmonary fibrosis than for most other lung<br />
diseases. To reduce the burden of this disease<br />
over the next five to 10 years, policymakers need<br />
to develop a wider strategy to improve healthcare<br />
for all lung patients and IPF service provision<br />
should form a critical part of this strategy.<br />
What is the situation for people living with IPF<br />
in terms of the path to diagnosis, and access<br />
to care and treatment?<br />
Our survey of people living with IPF in 2015<br />
“To reduce the<br />
burden of this<br />
disease over the<br />
next five to 10<br />
years, policymakers<br />
need to develop a<br />
wider strategy to<br />
improve the health<br />
for all lung patients<br />
and IPF service<br />
provision should<br />
form a critical part<br />
of this strategy.”<br />
What does a patient journey look like in<br />
2016? And what do you hope it will look like<br />
10 years from now?<br />
ILD pathways are extremely complex and involve<br />
primary, secondary and tertiary care alongside<br />
local community services such as pulmonary<br />
rehabilitation, oxygen and palliative care.<br />
Patients have told us that services can be<br />
fragmented, complex and difficult to navigate.<br />
In 10 years from now, our hope is that<br />
respiratory has been prioritised throughout<br />
the healthcare system, with access to new<br />
treatments, truly integrated care, and more<br />
specialist ILD nurses.<br />
We hope that diagnosis will have radically<br />
improved and will be prompt and accurate as<br />
more people start to take early action.<br />
If you could change one thing in the care<br />
pathway for IPF patients, what would it be<br />
and why?<br />
Now is an ideal time for NHS England to integrate<br />
ILD services to ensure the delivery of excellent<br />
care. A long-term and sustainable commissioning<br />
model for ILDs and clear service pathway would<br />
help improve delivery for IPF patients.<br />
Are there variations of care and service<br />
provision in the UK? Are there learnings that<br />
could be applied elsewhere?<br />
The BLF’s 2015 report, Lost in the system –<br />
IPF: the patient experience in England, found<br />
considerable differences in patient experience<br />
across the UK. Of the 122 patients that<br />
responded to our survey just 39% reported<br />
frequent contact with an ILD specialist nurse,<br />
and 36% said they had no access at all, yet<br />
NICE guidelines state that all patients should<br />
have access to a specialist nurse. 7<br />
9
BLF Interview<br />
This is just one example where ILD service<br />
provision could do more for patients. One<br />
person explained: “I was told my life expectancy<br />
was two to five years and then I was scheduled<br />
for a check-up six months later. I was referred to<br />
a physiotherapist to learn breathing exercises.<br />
That was it – no other information or support<br />
was given.”<br />
What commitment is required from<br />
government and policymakers to reshape<br />
care for people living with IPF?<br />
We believe the fragmentation of data capture,<br />
access to services, quality of support given,<br />
and information and expertise provided to<br />
patients is not equitable or sustainable in the<br />
current ILD service model, and welcome the<br />
inclusion of specialised services as a priority<br />
in NHS England’s 2016 business plan. 8 But<br />
transparency will need to be at the core of the<br />
ILD service framework, so it would be very<br />
useful for NHS England to establish agreed<br />
and published pathways that demonstrate the<br />
seamless integration of primary, secondary,<br />
tertiary and community services.<br />
People who eventually receive an IPF<br />
diagnosis should be focusing on how best to<br />
manage their condition and make the most<br />
of their lives, rather than trying to navigate a<br />
fragmented health service. Both patients and<br />
carers have told us this can be extremely time<br />
consuming and exhausting. A transparent<br />
network of ILD services that is clearly<br />
communicated to patients would enable NHS<br />
England to deliver a world class service for<br />
people with IPF.<br />
IPF: FACTS AND FIGURES 1<br />
32,500<br />
live with<br />
IPF in<br />
the UK<br />
1,300<br />
3,300<br />
5,300<br />
die each year<br />
from IPF<br />
4,500<br />
What are the key issues and challenges in<br />
ensuring more awareness for respiratory<br />
health among government and healthcare<br />
professionals?<br />
The lack of improvement in lung health<br />
outcomes over the past 10 years can largely be<br />
attributed to a systemic neglect of respiratory<br />
conditions. For instance, respiratory health isn’t<br />
one of the mandated priority areas for strategic<br />
clinical networks in England.<br />
We want to ensure that healthcare<br />
professionals are made aware of the<br />
importance of respiratory health and to make<br />
it a priority and are calling for policymakers<br />
to establish a taskforce for lung health in<br />
England and Scotland that will ensure people<br />
are better empowered to self-manage their<br />
condition, avoiding preventable admissions<br />
while improving patient outcomes, experience<br />
and saving the NHS money.<br />
IPF Prevalence<br />
is highest in*:<br />
3,300<br />
1,300<br />
Scotland<br />
Northern<br />
Ireland<br />
2,100<br />
2,100<br />
4,500<br />
Wales<br />
North-West<br />
England<br />
*(figures are lifetime prevalence as a raw figure) – the reasons for this are not known<br />
10
BLF Interview<br />
Finally, as a condition with a relatively low<br />
incidence compared to major killers such as<br />
lung cancer or cardiovascular disease, why<br />
should HCPs and policymakers sit up and<br />
pay attention to IPF?<br />
Although the total impact on health services is<br />
relatively low, the effect on each person living<br />
with IPF is higher than for most other lung<br />
diseases. Despite accounting for less than<br />
0.25% of people who have had a diagnosis of<br />
lung disease, IPF represents around 1.4% of all<br />
hospital bed days and 1.3% of all admissions<br />
due to lung disease. 9<br />
Across the board, the burden that lung<br />
disease places on our nation’s health and<br />
health services is immense – yet the money<br />
and attention invested in tackling lung disease<br />
trails behind other disease areas. Given that<br />
resources are becoming even more stretched<br />
across healthcare, we urgently need to make sure<br />
prioritisation is given to respiratory or we could<br />
be looking back in 10 years at a similar or worse<br />
picture for lung disease. Ultimately, if we want to<br />
see improvements in outcomes for people living<br />
with IPF, policymakers are going to need to step<br />
up and prioritise all our respiratory health.<br />
>9,000<br />
admissions a<br />
year for IPF<br />
86,000<br />
hospital bed days<br />
accounted by<br />
ILDs<br />
For more information, go to<br />
www.blf.org.uk<br />
References<br />
1<br />
British Lung Foundation (May 2016) The Battle for Breath – the impact<br />
of lung disease in the UK, pg.4 https://www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/ourresearch/the-battle-for-breath-2016<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
2<br />
British Lung Foundation (May 2016) The Battle for Breath – the impact of<br />
lung disease in the UK, pg. 45, https://www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/ourresearch/the-battle-for-breath-2016<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
3<br />
Parliamentary questions 1 September 2014, Dan Poulter, Minister for Health<br />
4<br />
British Lung Foundation (May 2016) The Battle for Breath – the impact of<br />
lung disease in the UK, pg. 45, https://www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/ourresearch/the-battle-for-breath-2016<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
5<br />
British Lung Foundation (2015) Lost in the System, IPF: the patient<br />
experience in England, https://www.blf.org.uk/sites/default/files/BLF-<br />
IPF-Report-2015---Lost-in-the-System---250215.pdf (Last accessed<br />
September 2016)<br />
6<br />
British Lung Foundation (2015) Lost in the System, IPF: the patient<br />
1.4% 1.3%<br />
experience in England, https://www.blf.org.uk/sites/default/files/BLF-IPF-<br />
Report-2015---Lost-in-the-System---250215.pdf<br />
7<br />
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (June 2013) Idiopathic<br />
pulmonary fibrosis: The diagnosis and management of suspected<br />
idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg163<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
8<br />
NHS England (April 2016) NHS England Business Plan 2016/17, https://<br />
www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/bus-plan-16.pdf<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
9<br />
British Lung Foundation (May 2016) The Battle for Breath – the impact of<br />
lung disease in the UK, pg. 45, https://www.blf.org.uk/what-we-do/ourresearch/the-battle-for-breath-2016<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
IPF accounts for around 1.4% of all hospital bed days<br />
and 1.3% of all admissions due to lung disease<br />
This is despite it accounting for<br />
Carer’s View<br />
Living<br />
with IPF –<br />
A carer’s insight<br />
Much like other chronic diseases, IPF’s impact on quality<br />
of life is felt not only by those with the condition but loved<br />
ones and carers too. Here, Kath Butler, wife of IPF patient<br />
Gordon Butler, describes the impact IPF has on their daily<br />
lives, their journey to care and how their positive attitude has<br />
driven them to try new things.<br />
How long did it take for Gordon to<br />
receive an accurate diagnosis?<br />
Gordon was diagnosed in 2007 following<br />
a comparatively quick diagnostic period of six<br />
weeks. He was initially sent for a chest X-ray<br />
by our GP which, when it came back, led to his<br />
referral to a choice of three hospitals. Thankfully,<br />
we picked the hospital with the shortest waiting<br />
time where Gordon’s consultant sent him for<br />
various tests and, about a fortnight later, we<br />
returned for his diagnosis of IPF.<br />
We understand our case is not representative<br />
of all cases of IPF as I think Gordon’s fast<br />
diagnosis was largely down to the efficiency<br />
of our GP who had known us for years. She<br />
knew that if Gordon was presenting at the<br />
doctors then there must have been something<br />
seriously wrong. We’ve known plenty of people<br />
to be given a number of misdiagnoses before<br />
eventually being told they have IPF.<br />
Did you feel part of the conversation during the<br />
diagnostic and treatment planning process?<br />
From the start, we’ve been lucky enough to<br />
have a good relationship with our doctors<br />
12
Carer’s View<br />
“I think Gordon’s<br />
fast diagnosis was<br />
largely down to<br />
the efficiency of<br />
our GP who had<br />
known us for years.<br />
We’ve known plenty<br />
of people to be<br />
given a number of<br />
misdiagnoses before<br />
eventually being told<br />
they have IPF”<br />
In addition, we have the support and<br />
reassurance of knowing a specialist nurse is at<br />
the end of the phone at any time, and we are<br />
also able to access information to prepare us for<br />
what might be round the corner. There is also<br />
quite a lot of help for carers – I haven’t really<br />
needed it so far but I know it is there if I do.<br />
What are some of your biggest frustrations<br />
in going about your daily life?<br />
As Gordon’s disease has progressed, he needs<br />
oxygen to do almost anything, including getting<br />
dressed in the morning.<br />
I know that his diminishing ability to do<br />
certain things like carry the shopping, lifting<br />
heavy objects or just to pace himself to stop<br />
breathlessness frustrates him as does the<br />
tiredness he experiences.<br />
In terms of public attitude, there have been<br />
several difficult situations where we’ve been<br />
chastised for using a blue badge in our car<br />
because, visually, it doesn’t look like there’s<br />
anything wrong with Gordon. As his carer,<br />
it’s not a nice thing for me to witness. If you<br />
haven’t got crutches, you’re not disabled in<br />
some people’s eyes.<br />
and nurses. Gordon’s diagnosis was delivered<br />
in a very matter-of-fact, straightforward and<br />
down-to-earth fashion which was reassuring.<br />
The consultant told us that Gordon had an<br />
incurable illness but there were no time factors<br />
or life-limiting information given – it was just<br />
“you’ve got it, we’ll see how it goes and we’ll<br />
look after you”. We have been involved at all<br />
stages of Gordon’s care plan. Our doctor<br />
informed us that there is a small window for<br />
treatment between certain stages of disease<br />
development, but thankfully Gordon was within<br />
those parameters for him to receive treatment<br />
immediately following diagnosis.<br />
What other services does Gordon have<br />
access to?<br />
On top of his medicines, Gordon attends<br />
support groups that really help – not only in<br />
managing symptoms but with the social side<br />
of life. He also has pulmonary rehab, attends<br />
specifically-designed exercise classes for<br />
people with respiratory disease, and has<br />
recently been put forward to try a new oxygen<br />
concentrator.<br />
How has IPF impacted your lives?<br />
Initially, we were scared about what to expect<br />
as we didn’t know to what extent it would affect<br />
us. But looking back, I feel very fortunate to still<br />
have Gordon, having just celebrated our 45th<br />
wedding anniversary.<br />
It has taught us to make the most of the life<br />
we still have together and now we’re aiming for<br />
50 years of marriage.<br />
There have also been other positives<br />
following Gordon’s diagnosis. When he first<br />
came out of hospital, he decided to conquer<br />
his fear of flying so we could go travelling.<br />
Although this is more difficult now with all the<br />
paraphernalia we have to take with us, we did<br />
enjoy a number of trips to Canada, Germany,<br />
Italy and Switzerland.<br />
We understand that our experience with IPF<br />
is not reflected by the majority of people living<br />
with it. We know and have known many people<br />
who’ve had issues getting accurate diagnoses<br />
and accessing treatment.<br />
However, we believe that a positive mental<br />
attitude goes a long way to helping you cope<br />
with the condition. After all, we still need to live<br />
our lives.<br />
For more information go to<br />
www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org<br />
www.blf.org.uk<br />
13
APF Interview<br />
Finding<br />
the route<br />
to firstclass<br />
care<br />
Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF), says Mike Bray, a patient<br />
and founding trustee of Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (APF),<br />
is a devastating, terminal lung condition known to affect at<br />
least 15,000 people in the UK, 1 with the most recent data<br />
showing this figure may have more than doubled. 2<br />
T<br />
hese data show that there remains an<br />
inherent lack of clarity in identifying the<br />
true prevalence of IPF – and this, says<br />
Mike, is largely down to difficulties in getting<br />
a confirmed diagnosis. “The first question I<br />
always ask of respiratory consultants is ‘how<br />
many patients do you have with IPF?’ and<br />
the answer is always ‘I don’t know’. This is<br />
because information about the incidence<br />
and prevalence of diseases is often gathered<br />
from death certificates and hospital episode<br />
statistics. However, this only collects diagnostic<br />
coding data on people who are admitted to<br />
hospital and does not capture any information<br />
about patients who attend for outpatient<br />
appointments. The APF is concerned about the<br />
accuracy of these data.”<br />
The issue for APF is how we can get all the<br />
right resources in place for patients with IPF<br />
across primary, secondary and specialist care<br />
without having a true understanding of the<br />
scale of the disease. The group’s report Fit for<br />
the future – Future-proofing care for patients<br />
with IPF, 3 which was launched at a Westminster<br />
event in July 2016, highlights this and urges the<br />
NHS to introduce mandatory collection of data<br />
relating to the number of people diagnosed<br />
Mike<br />
Bray<br />
with IPF by a multi-disciplinary team (MDT).<br />
Without this information, how can the NHS<br />
provide optimum care for people with IPF in<br />
accordance with the NICE IPF quality standard?<br />
The NICE quality standard 4 for IPF says<br />
it’s the responsibility of the MDT to give a<br />
confirmed diagnosis but, Mike adds, there<br />
are key challenges that make it difficult to get<br />
a definitive picture of the number of people<br />
living with IPF. Part of the reason for this, he<br />
notes, is because of the coding system and the<br />
way it is used. “The difficulties are two-fold –<br />
firstly, the diagnostic coding data for outpatient<br />
attendances is not collected and, secondly,<br />
diagnostic criteria for IPF have changed. If<br />
the MDT captured the number of patients<br />
diagnosed with IPF then over time we would<br />
have a more accurate picture of the number<br />
of incidents, as well as prevalent cases of IPF<br />
in the UK.<br />
“In this scenario,” he points out, “we could<br />
then identify how many cases of IPF had been<br />
diagnosed and, as a result, be able to more<br />
accurately determine whether we really are<br />
seeing an upward progression in its incidence.<br />
We believe it’s a disease on the increase, but<br />
unless we get a number we just won’t know.”<br />
Once a patient receives that much needed<br />
diagnosis, the next challenge is often accessing<br />
the services – with significant geographical<br />
variations in both the availability and the<br />
delivery of basic, essential care for people with<br />
this terminal lung disease. 1<br />
APF conducted a UK-wide survey last year,<br />
Mike says, which found that of the 300-plus<br />
responses, less than half were taking part in<br />
a pulmonary rehabilitation programme and<br />
almost one in three said they did not feel<br />
clear about the treatment options available to<br />
them when they were diagnosed. On top of<br />
this, almost one-third of patients did not have<br />
access to a specialist nurse for ongoing support<br />
and information – despite six out of 10 patients<br />
describing specialist nurses as the single best<br />
point of contact for their care. 5 “The level of the<br />
problem becomes clear with the knowledge<br />
there are insufficient specialist interstitial lung<br />
disease (ILD) nurses for the entire IPF patient<br />
population,” Mike stresses.<br />
“Having a true understanding of disease<br />
prevalence would help identify how many<br />
specialist nurses are required, as well as being<br />
able to make effective use of the resources,<br />
including pulmonary rehabilitation, access to<br />
a specialist nurse, oxygen and palliative care<br />
support, to provide the level of care set out in<br />
the quality standards.”<br />
14
APF Interview<br />
“While the NHS provides excellent care, the<br />
problem is that there is significant variation<br />
in the availability and access to healthcare<br />
services across the country,” Mike observes.<br />
“Many more specialist nurses are required<br />
but there is also a huge need for a better<br />
knowledge and understanding of the disease<br />
to be cascaded down from the specialists,<br />
giving the relevant healthcare professionals in<br />
local hospitals and in the community a greater<br />
understanding and awareness of IPF and the<br />
optimum care pathway. This is beginning to<br />
happen but needs to be encouraged further.”<br />
However, importantly, in England, there<br />
has also been a lack of publicly available<br />
information around which hospitals have<br />
been identified as specialist centres by NHS<br />
England. And, central to this, is that only these<br />
hospitals are able to prescribe anti-fibrotic<br />
therapies for IPF.<br />
“Ultimately, the best chance of first-class<br />
care for IPF patients is at specialist centres,”<br />
he argues. “Patients who are lucky enough to<br />
fall within the catchment area of a specialist<br />
hospital are undoubtedly going to get access<br />
to the full range of services more quickly<br />
than someone in a local hospital. So my<br />
recommendation to all patients is to try to get<br />
yourself referred to a specialist hospital.”<br />
As NICE quality standards start to embed<br />
across the nation, the experiences of IPF<br />
patients should improve, he notes. However,<br />
while that progress might be slow, the<br />
“excellent care” Mike alludes to is the ideal that<br />
all NHS providers should strive to deliver. “The<br />
best care pathway begins pre-diagnosis with<br />
early recognition and avoiding misdiagnosis,”<br />
Mike says. “Part of the problem is that<br />
breathlessness and cough are not specific to<br />
IPF and are common to many lung diseases.<br />
The presence of clubbing of the finger nails and<br />
crackles (heard when your GP listens to your<br />
chest) should raise the concern of pulmonary<br />
fibrosis and trigger referral to local hospital or<br />
specialist centre for further evaluation. Getting<br />
this early diagnosis is paramount.”<br />
Following diagnosis, the next step of the<br />
ideal care pathway is having ready access to<br />
the limited medications available which can<br />
help to slow progression of the disease. “In the<br />
case of IPF you can have a patient who is newly<br />
diagnosed with a forced vital capacity (FVC) of<br />
90% who is not eligible for treatment – they<br />
have to get worse first – or in the other extreme<br />
where a series of misdiagnoses means the<br />
patient’s disease rapidly progressed and they<br />
may have missed the window of opportunity<br />
“After diagnosis I<br />
basically discovered<br />
that I was likely to<br />
die within three to<br />
five years, should<br />
expect to slowly<br />
suffocate, that noone<br />
knows what<br />
caused my disease,<br />
that there are no<br />
effective treatments<br />
and no-one is even<br />
near finding a cure.<br />
And I just went to<br />
the doctor with an<br />
annoying cough.”<br />
Tony Gowland,<br />
IPF patient and<br />
ambassador for<br />
Action for Pulmonary<br />
Fibrosis.<br />
for treatment because their FVC has dropped<br />
below the 50% threshold.”<br />
While positive strides are being taken, Mike<br />
adds, work to promote awareness and achieve<br />
consistent levels of quality care and access to<br />
treatment nationwide is ongoing.<br />
On a practical level, people could be made<br />
much more aware of the services that are<br />
available to them and, critically, how to access<br />
these – whether it is contacting your specialist<br />
respiratory nurse, being put forward for<br />
pulmonary rehabilitation or oxygen therapy, or<br />
obtaining information about palliative or respite<br />
care. “I wouldn’t like to guess what proportion<br />
of IPF patients even know about the NICE quality<br />
standards, but it’s their entitlement,” finishes<br />
Mike. “It’s their right to have these services.”<br />
Ultimately it comes back to how can the<br />
NHS be expected to provide the best care<br />
and services possible without knowing the<br />
size of the problem? As Mike says, “we work<br />
on figures of around 15,000 but the number<br />
of patients could be double that. How can<br />
patients expect to get adequate care and how<br />
can the NHS plan funding for IPF services<br />
without this information?<br />
“APF will continue to call on the NHS to<br />
introduce mandatory collection of data relating<br />
to numbers of IPF patients at diagnosis by a<br />
multi-disciplinary team. This will ensure that all<br />
patients are included.”<br />
References<br />
For more information go to<br />
www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org<br />
1<br />
British Lung Foundation (2015). Lost in the System – IPF:<br />
the patient experience in England. https://www.blf.org.<br />
System---250215.pdf (accessed September 2016)<br />
2<br />
British Lung Foundation (2016). Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis<br />
uk/sites/default/files/BLF-IPF-Report-2015---Lost-in-the-<br />
statistics.https://www.blf.org.uk/support-for-you/idiopathicpulmonary-fibrosis-ipf/statistics<br />
(accessed September 2016)<br />
3<br />
Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (2016). Fit for the future:<br />
Future-proofing care for patients with IPF. http://www.<br />
Report.pdf (accessed September 2016)<br />
4<br />
NICE (2015). NICE quality standard [QS79]: Idiopathic<br />
pulmonary fibrosis in adults. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/<br />
qs79 (accessed September 2016)<br />
5<br />
Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (2015). Working together:<br />
delivering a better future for patients with IPF. http://www.<br />
actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/IPF-<br />
actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/APF-<br />
IPF-Patient-Survey-Report-full.pdf (accessed September 2016)<br />
15
A good<br />
IPF patient<br />
pathway 1, 2<br />
Patient presents to GP with breathlessness and persistent cough<br />
GP considers a diagnosis of IPF<br />
Speedy referral to local hospital then specialist centre<br />
Diagnosis confirmed by multidisciplinary team<br />
Clear and accurate information about IPF, treatment options, service<br />
provision and support groups provided<br />
Assessment for and access to treatment for qualifying patients<br />
Coordination of care between specialist centre and local hospital<br />
Provision of a specialist IPF nurse<br />
Assessment for pulmonary rehabilitation and oxygen therapy<br />
Access to palliative support at<br />
end of life<br />
?<br />
Patient presents to GP<br />
with breathlessness and<br />
persistent cough<br />
IPF diagnosis not considered<br />
X<br />
?<br />
Treatment prescribed for COPD or asthma,<br />
breathlessness gets worse<br />
Referred to heart specialist<br />
Further delay in referral to chest physician and<br />
specialist centre<br />
?<br />
Given no or poor information<br />
X<br />
Referral delays mean condition worsens and treatment<br />
criteria not met<br />
Limited ability to access specialist respiratory nurse<br />
and support services<br />
No assessment for pulmonary rehabilitation and oxygen therapy<br />
?<br />
Specialist palliative care not provided at end of life<br />
A bad IPF patient pathway 3<br />
References<br />
1<br />
NICE, Quality Standard 79 for Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis in adults, 2015<br />
2<br />
APF report (http://www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/IPF-Report.pdf)<br />
3<br />
Boehringer Ingelheim data on file: DOF NIN16-12
Inside View<br />
Give IPF<br />
the same<br />
attention<br />
as cancer<br />
With idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) accounting for 5,000<br />
deaths every year - or one in every 100 deaths in the UK -<br />
Dr Toby Maher, Consultant Respiratory Physician at the<br />
Royal Brompton and Harefield NHS Trust, says there is an<br />
urgent need to reshape the provision of care and services for<br />
patients with IPF.<br />
30,000 people are living<br />
with IPF in the UK at any one time,<br />
“Around<br />
more than double the number<br />
stated by NICE,” 1 says Dr Toby Maher, who<br />
was involved in the British Lung Foundation’s<br />
landmark epidemiological study, The<br />
Respiratory Health of the Nation 2 – the first to<br />
look at the extent and impact of lung disease<br />
across the UK in a decade.<br />
But this is just the tip of the iceberg if all<br />
causes of lung fibrosis are taken into account,<br />
he points out, adding, “there are probably half<br />
a dozen relatively common causes of lung<br />
scarring that are likely to account for about<br />
twice as many cases as IPF”.<br />
Yet despite the prevalence of these conditions<br />
– and significant burden on NHS resources 2,3<br />
– “IPF and other fibrosing lung diseases have<br />
been largely neglected by policymakers and<br />
healthcare professionals. First because of the<br />
perception that nothing could be done for these<br />
patients and, second, because the paucity of<br />
treatment meant there was a real nihilism about<br />
diagnosis.”<br />
Having access to treatment has led to an<br />
urgent need to re-evaluate and formalise the<br />
delivery of care to patients with IPF and other<br />
fibrosing lung diseases, says Maher. “Huge<br />
strides have been made in recent years to<br />
improve diagnosis, treatment and services for<br />
cancer patients – now it’s time for IPF to be<br />
prioritised in the same way.” 4<br />
To see what is needed in IPF, you only have<br />
to look at lung cancer where outcomes and<br />
desirable treatment options have been poor<br />
but services have been developed to allow for<br />
better provision of care for patients.<br />
Indeed, Maher observes, unless you have<br />
engaged local physicians who are dedicated to<br />
treating the condition, the entire care pathway<br />
for an IPF patient can be extremely protracted.<br />
“The whole process – from first symptoms to<br />
GP, to local hospital, to CT scan, to specialist<br />
centre, to treatment – can take six to 18 months.<br />
This for a disease that kills more people each<br />
year than better known conditions such as<br />
leukaemia and skin cancer.” 5<br />
People need access to healthcare<br />
professionals who understand IPF, who can<br />
make a reliable diagnosis, who can help them<br />
through their disease journey, who can provide<br />
pulmonary rehabilitation and advice on the role<br />
of exercise, as well as services relating to endof-life<br />
care, he stresses.<br />
However, there have been positive moves<br />
forward, with NHS England believed to be<br />
formally identifying 15-20 specialist centres for<br />
IPF in the near future after a number of delays.<br />
Now, Maher would like to see networks of care<br />
developed between the regional specialist<br />
centre(s) and the referring district general<br />
hospital. “In my view, it will be important for the<br />
majority of IPF care to be delivered as close to<br />
home as possible without patients – who are on<br />
17
Inside View<br />
average in their 60s and 70s – having to travel<br />
to hospital or a specialist centre unnecessarily.”<br />
Diagnosis, for example, is reasonably<br />
straightforward for at least two-thirds of patients<br />
and should be possible to deliver through<br />
telemedicine. “This would ensure diagnosis is<br />
still authenticated by a multi-disciplinary team,<br />
allow a degree of gatekeeping around the use of<br />
anti-fibrotic medicines, but also let the patient<br />
be managed at their local hospital.”<br />
In this scenario, only the more challenging<br />
cases would need to be sent to the specialist<br />
centre, where Maher’s vision is for engagement<br />
between the specialist nurses and local<br />
hospital to coordinate patient care and clinical<br />
management of the condition. There also<br />
needs to be a drive at secondary care level to<br />
ensure patients have access to oxygen therapy,<br />
pulmonary rehabilitation and palliative care, he<br />
adds.<br />
Currently, the majority of patients do not have<br />
access to all the services outlined in NICE’s<br />
quality standards for IPF, 1 Maher points out,<br />
adding that – while all the services are in place<br />
– there is an absence of available information<br />
and no clear signposting for patients and their<br />
families to follow. In fact, in many cases, he<br />
says, people don’t actually realise what their<br />
entitlements are.<br />
There are also a number of other challenges<br />
and artificial barriers that get in the way of<br />
patients receiving better care during the<br />
course of their illness and at end of life. In<br />
many areas, for example, hospitals are only<br />
able to receive CCG (clinical commissioning<br />
group) reimbursement for pulmonary rehab in<br />
patients with COPD. Similarly, Maher points<br />
to the example of IPF patients being given<br />
oxygen therapy that’s appropriate for COPD,<br />
whereas “the two conditions have very distinct<br />
requirements and there is a vast difference<br />
between approaches”.<br />
Despite the variability in care across the UK,<br />
there are pockets of very good practice with<br />
regions that have joined up respiratory services<br />
for pulmonary rehab and a clear understanding<br />
of oxygen services, Maher is quick to stress.<br />
“Ultimately, patients need to be in the driving<br />
seat in terms of accessing the relevant<br />
information, identifying the services available<br />
to them and ensuring they push for what they<br />
are entitled to along the disease management<br />
pathway.”<br />
“Unfortunately it’s very easy to be given bad<br />
information,” he reveals. “I have encountered<br />
a number of patients who have been given<br />
the wrong diagnosis or been given the right<br />
diagnosis and told there’s nothing that can be<br />
done. There have even been cases where the<br />
individual had previously been told they had IPF<br />
but clearly did not.”<br />
Certainly, accurate diagnosis is key –<br />
particularly as the prognosis for an IPF patient<br />
“The whole<br />
process – from first<br />
symptoms to GP, to<br />
local hospital, to CT<br />
scan, to specialist<br />
centre, to treatment<br />
– can take six to<br />
18 months. This<br />
for a disease that<br />
kills more people<br />
each year than better<br />
known conditions<br />
such as leukaemia<br />
and skin cancer”<br />
may be as bad as, or worse than, it is for lung<br />
cancer. Indeed more than half of all people with<br />
the condition will not live more than three years<br />
from diagnosis. 6,7<br />
The unspoken reality, says Maher, is that<br />
with improvements in diagnosis, services and<br />
treatment – alongside an ageing population –<br />
the number of IPF patients is going to increase<br />
further. It’s therefore imperative that we get it<br />
right and put a functioning pathway in place,<br />
particularly with broad variations in care across<br />
the country still in evidence.<br />
“My view is that we should be diagnosing and<br />
treating people much more rapidly because it is<br />
a disease of inevitable progression that causes<br />
irreversible damage to the lungs. The treatments<br />
we have are targeted at slowing down the rate<br />
of damage, so to derive maximum benefit you<br />
need to start therapy early in order to protect as<br />
much lung tissue as possible.<br />
In an ideal world, treatment should be<br />
triggered immediately following diagnosis<br />
and not be dependent on reaching the 80%<br />
FVC threshold for accessing therapy, Maher<br />
argues. And, in this regard, he believes there<br />
are a huge number of people missing out on<br />
treatment. Indeed, recent data from the British<br />
Thoracic Society’s IPF Registry found that 40%<br />
of patients have an FVC of greater than 80% at<br />
first presentation to clinic. 8<br />
As a field we need to find a way of better<br />
defining the impact of treatment on quality of<br />
18
Inside View<br />
“To die from<br />
breathlessness is<br />
a pretty miserable<br />
way out, so the<br />
more effectively we<br />
can treat IPF, the<br />
more effectively we<br />
can alleviate a large<br />
burden of suffering”<br />
to IPF – especially as the UK population gets<br />
proportionally older and the burden of IPF<br />
increases further. As Maher observes: “There<br />
are more people with IPF than we realise, yet it<br />
remains relatively unknown and has received a<br />
trivial amount of research and funding in recent<br />
decades.”<br />
“All this adds more weight than ever to our calls<br />
for IPF care in this country to be improved,” he<br />
says. “We need NICE Guidelines to be followed<br />
in full, for all patients to be given access to a<br />
specialist nurse to help them manage their<br />
disease, and for better signposted pathways of<br />
care with rapid access to specialist centres to<br />
ensure accurate, early diagnosis and treatment<br />
for all patients with this life threatening condition.<br />
“These standards are common for people<br />
with cancer and, as the British Lung Foundation<br />
says, there’s no reason why people with IPF<br />
should get a lesser standard of care.” 9<br />
To die from breathlessness is a pretty<br />
miserable way out, so the more effectively<br />
we can treat IPF, the more effectively we<br />
can alleviate a large burden of suffering. We<br />
underestimate the importance of reshaping the<br />
care pathway for IPF patients at our peril.<br />
life in IPF in order to demonstrate the economic<br />
viability of treatment. “To my mind,” notes<br />
Maher, “the difficulty lies in the fact that patients<br />
involved in clinical trials tend to have early<br />
stage disease and the impact on their quality<br />
of life is relatively small. You can’t identify an<br />
improvement in quality of life in early stage IPF<br />
during the course of a 12 month trial.”<br />
A similar situation is also seen in cancer trials,<br />
says Maher. But, whereas an ‘urgent’ referral for<br />
an IPF patient can take months – for cancer, the<br />
vast majority are seen within two weeks.” 4,9<br />
“However, until we reach such a point where<br />
NICE reappraises the treatment thresholds,<br />
there is no point in talking about implementing<br />
similar two-week referral timelines for IPF – as<br />
with cancer. If you went down this route, you’d<br />
be putting in a lot of effort to identify people<br />
who would then have to wait until their disease<br />
had progressed before receiving therapy.”<br />
But it’s not just changing NICE’s mind, it’s also<br />
getting the message across to physicians that<br />
slowing down fibrosis will ultimately improve<br />
survival, Maher argues. “Ultimately for IPF care<br />
in this country to be improved we need better<br />
networks of care, we need to ensure that NICE<br />
quality standards are met across the board<br />
and we should be initiating therapy as early as<br />
possible to maximise benefit.”<br />
As a disease that causes an unrecognised<br />
burden of suffering, policymakers and healthcare<br />
professionals need to pay particular attention<br />
For more information go to<br />
www.rbht.nhs.uk/healthprofessionals/<br />
clinical-departments/interstitial-lungdisease/<br />
References:<br />
1<br />
NICE (January 2015) Quality Standard: Idiopathic Pulmonary<br />
Fibrosis in Adults https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/<br />
qs79 (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
2<br />
British Lung Foundation (2016) Battle for Breath:<br />
The Impact of Lung Disease in the UK https://cdn.<br />
shopify.com/s/files/1/0221/4446/files/The_Battle_for_<br />
Breath_report_cf62c62d-aeb0-49dc-9da5-e0f57ce44cf6.<br />
pdf?1270881605930435872 (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
3<br />
Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (2016) Fit for the Future:<br />
Future Proofing Care for Patients with IPF http://www.<br />
actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/<br />
IPF-Report.pdf (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
4<br />
BBC News (3 October, 2014) Does cancer get too much<br />
attention? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-29363887<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
5<br />
British Lung Foundation (2016) https://www.blf.org.uk/<br />
support-for-you/idiopathic-pulmonary-fibrosis-ipf/statistics/<br />
what-you-need-to-know (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
6<br />
NHS Choices Pulmonary Fibrosis (Idiopathic) http://www.<br />
nhs.uk/Conditions/pulmonary-fibrosis/Pages/Diagnosis.<br />
aspx (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
7<br />
Richeldi L (2015) Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: moving<br />
forward. BMC Medicine 13:231 http://www.biomedcentral.<br />
com/1741-7015/13/231 (Last accessed September 2016)<br />
8<br />
British Thoracic Society (2016) https://www.brit-thoracic.<br />
org.uk/document-library/audit-and-quality-improvement/<br />
lung-disease-registry/bts-ild-registry-newsletter-june-2016/<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
9<br />
Making More Health/Boehringer Ingelheim (2016) Calls for<br />
urgent focus on IPF as cases double https://blog.boehringeringelheim.co.uk/<br />
(Last accessed September 2016)<br />
19
For more information, contact<br />
Boehringer Ingelheim Communications Department<br />
communications.bra@boehringer-ingelheim.co.uk<br />
www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org www.blf.org.uk www.boehringer-ingelheim.co.uk<br />
A pharmaphorum media publication<br />
www.pharmaphorum.com