22.09.2016 Views

5128_Ch03_pp098-184

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

112 Chapter 3 Derivatives<br />

An Alternative to NDER<br />

Graphing<br />

f(x 0.001) f(x 0.001)<br />

y <br />

0.002<br />

is equivalent to graphing y NDER f x<br />

(useful if NDER is not readily available<br />

on your calculator).<br />

SOLUTION<br />

We saw at the start of this section that x is not differentiable at x 0 since its righthand<br />

and left-hand derivatives at x 0 are not the same. Nonetheless,<br />

0 h 0 h<br />

NDER x, 0 lim<br />

h→0 2h<br />

h h<br />

lim <br />

h→0 2h<br />

0<br />

lim <br />

h→0 2 h<br />

0.<br />

The symmetric difference quotient, which works symmetrically on either side of 0,<br />

never detects the corner! Consequently, most graphing utilities will indicate (wrongly)<br />

that y x is differentiable at x 0, with derivative 0.<br />

Now try Exercise 23.<br />

In light of Example 3, it is worth repeating here that NDER f a actually does approach<br />

f a when f a exists, and in fact approximates it quite well (as in Example 2).<br />

EXPLORATION 2<br />

Looking at the Symmetric Difference Quotient<br />

Analytically<br />

Let f x x 2 and let h 0.01.<br />

1. Find<br />

f 10 h f 10<br />

.<br />

h<br />

How close is it to f 10?<br />

2. Find<br />

f 10 h f 10 h<br />

.<br />

2h<br />

How close is it to f 10?<br />

3. Repeat this comparison for f x x 3 .<br />

.1<br />

.2<br />

.3<br />

.4<br />

.5<br />

.6<br />

.7<br />

X<br />

X = .1<br />

[–2, 4] by [–1, 3]<br />

(a)<br />

Y1<br />

10<br />

5<br />

3.3333<br />

2.5<br />

2<br />

1.6667<br />

1.4286<br />

(b)<br />

Figure 3.17 (a) The graph of NDER<br />

ln x and (b) a table of values. What graph<br />

could this be? (Example 4)<br />

EXAMPLE 4<br />

Graphing a Derivative Using NDER<br />

Let f x ln x. Use NDER to graph y f x. Can you guess what function f x is<br />

by analyzing its graph?<br />

SOLUTION<br />

The graph is shown in Figure 3.17a. The shape of the graph suggests, and the table of<br />

values in Figure 3.17b supports, the conjecture that this is the graph of y 1x. We will<br />

prove in Section 3.9 (using analytic methods) that this is indeed the case.<br />

Now try Exercise 27.<br />

Differentiability Implies Continuity<br />

We began this section with a look at the typical ways that a function could fail to have a<br />

derivative at a point. As one example, we indicated graphically that a discontinuity in the<br />

graph of f would cause one or both of the one-sided derivatives to be nonexistent. It is

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!