31.07.2016 Views

Cause Principle Unity

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Fifth dialogue<br />

status as point, it becomes a line; from its status as line, it becomes a surface;<br />

from its status as surface, it becomes a body. So the point, because it<br />

possesses the potency to become a body, does not differ from the status of<br />

a body, where the potency and the act are one and the same thing.<br />

The undivided does not differ, therefore, from the divided, nor does the<br />

absolutely simple differ from the infinite, nor does the centre differ from<br />

the circumference. Since the infinite is all that it can be, it is immobile;<br />

since in it everything is indifferent, it is one; and since it possesses all the<br />

greatness and perfection that can possibly be possessed, beyond all limit,<br />

it is the maximum and supreme immensity. If the point does not differ from<br />

the body, nor the centre from the circumference, nor the finite from the<br />

infinite, nor the maximum from the minimum, we may certainly affirm that<br />

the universe is entirely centre, or that the centre of the universe is everywhere,<br />

and the circumference nowhere insofar as it is different from the<br />

centre; or else that the circumference is everywhere, but the centre is<br />

nowhere insofar as it differs from the circumference. Here, then, is how it<br />

is not impossible, but rather necessary, that the optimum, the maximum,<br />

the incomprehensible is everything, is everywhere, is in everything, for,<br />

being simple and indivisible, it can be everything, be everywhere and be<br />

in everything. Thus, not for nothing is it said that Jove fills all things,<br />

inhabits all parts of the universe, is the centre of everything which has<br />

being: one in all, and that through which all is one, and is that which, being<br />

all things and comprehending all being in itself, causes everything to be in<br />

everything.<br />

But you will say to me, ‘Then why do things change? Why does particular<br />

matter turn itself into other forms?’ My answer is that mutation is not<br />

striving for another being, but for another mode of being. And this is the<br />

difference between the universe and the things of the universe: for the<br />

universe contains all being and all modes of being, while each thing of the<br />

universe possesses all being but not all modes of being. Each thing cannot<br />

possess, in act, all particularities and accidents, because many forms are<br />

incompatible within the same subject, either because they are contrary or<br />

because they belong to different species – for example, there cannot be the<br />

same individual substance under the accidents of a horse and a human<br />

being, or under the dimensions of a plant or an animal. What is more, the<br />

universe comprehends all being totally, for nothing can exist outside of or<br />

beyond infinite being, because there is no outside or beyond infinity. By<br />

contrast, each of the things of the universe comprehends all being, but not<br />

89

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!