14.06.2016 Views

WORK UP EXERCISE TRI CRAB BATTLE OF JUTLAND REMEMBERED

1UuMbCX

1UuMbCX

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

issue 200 June 2016<br />

TE KAHA<br />

<strong>WORK</strong> <strong>UP</strong><br />

<strong>EXERCISE</strong><br />

<strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong><br />

<strong>BATTLE</strong> <strong>OF</strong> <strong>JUTLAND</strong><br />

<strong>REMEMBERED</strong><br />

1<br />

Celebrating the 75 th anniversary of the Royal New Zealand Navy


contents NAVY TODAY ISSUE 200 2016<br />

DIRECTORY<br />

Published to inform, inspire and entertain<br />

serving and former members of the RNZN,<br />

their families and friends and the wider<br />

Navy community.<br />

Navy Today is the official magazine of the<br />

Royal New Zealand Navy. Published by<br />

Defence Public Affairs, Wellington.<br />

Navy Today is now in its nineteenth year<br />

of publication.<br />

Views expressed in Navy Today are not<br />

necessarily those of the RNZN or the NZDF.<br />

Contributions are welcomed, including<br />

stories, photographs and letters. Please<br />

submit stories and letters by email in<br />

Microsoft Word or the body of an email.<br />

Articles up to 500 words welcomed, longer<br />

if required by the subject. Please consult the<br />

editor about long articles. Digital photos<br />

submitted by email also welcomed, at least<br />

500kb preferred.<br />

COPY DEADLINES FOR NT<br />

5PM AS FOLLOWS:<br />

NT 201 July issue<br />

15 June<br />

NT 202 August issue 15 July<br />

NT 203 September issue 26 August<br />

Subject to change.<br />

EDITOR:<br />

DPA Staff<br />

Defence Public Affairs<br />

HQ NZ Defence Force<br />

Private Bag, Wellington, New Zealand<br />

E: DCG.NAVYTODAY@nzdf.mil.nz<br />

DESIGN & LAYOUT:<br />

Defence Public Affairs<br />

PRINT:<br />

As part of a Government multi-agency<br />

initiative the NZDF has changed to a single<br />

provider for all of its Print Services.<br />

This magazine is now printed by Blue Star.<br />

Feedback to rick.derham@nzdf.mil.nz on<br />

the quality of this publication is welcomed.<br />

INQUIRIES TO:<br />

Defence Public Affairs<br />

P: (04) 496 0270 F: (04) 496 0290<br />

Director Defence Public Affairs<br />

P: (04) 496 0299 F: (04) 496 0290<br />

Defence Careers:<br />

P: 0800 1FORCE (0800 136 723)<br />

www.defencecareers.mil.nz<br />

CHANGING ADDRESS?<br />

To join or leave our mailing list,<br />

please contact:<br />

E: navytoday@nzdf.mil.nz<br />

04<br />

15 31<br />

04 TE KAHA <strong>WORK</strong> <strong>UP</strong><br />

06 <strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong><br />

09 200th issue<br />

12 Battle of Jutland<br />

15 Invictus Games<br />

24 SERVICEMAN <strong>REMEMBERED</strong><br />

29 Unconscious Bias<br />

31 Mainland Island Sanctuary<br />

34 Book reviews<br />

cover image:<br />

TE KAHA CREW TRAINING<br />

DURING <strong>WORK</strong> <strong>UP</strong><br />

2


CHIEF <strong>OF</strong> NAVY<br />

Rear Admiral John Martin<br />

yours aye<br />

As this Navy Today goes to print, I am heading to the United<br />

Kingdom to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the Battle<br />

of Jutland. Our Navy’s links with the battle are largely<br />

symbolic, but our nation’s relationship with the battle is strong.<br />

In 1909, there was growing concern about regional security. In an<br />

empire-wide effort to support the fleet of the Royal Navy, New<br />

Zealand provided funds to build a battlecruiser, or cruisers. The<br />

result was HMS NEW ZEALAND.<br />

HMS NEW ZEALAND toured New Zealand in 1913, and just under<br />

half the population of New Zealand came out to inspect her. In true<br />

Kiwi hospitality, gifts were given to the ship; some can be seen in<br />

the Navy Museum today. One, in particular, a piupiu worn by the<br />

Commanding Officer of NEW ZEALAND, has been loaned to the<br />

National Museum of the Royal Navy, for their exhibition on the<br />

Battle of Jutland.<br />

Within a year of the 1913 visit, NEW ZEALAND would form part of<br />

the Grand Fleet Battle Cruiser squadron. The squadron saw service<br />

throughout the war, participating in the three major sea ‘battles’ –<br />

or, more properly, skirmishes between the British Grand Fleet and<br />

the German High Seas Fleet.<br />

While NEW ZEALAND was a Royal Navy ship with a predominantly<br />

Royal Navy ship’s company, New Zealanders served in her. One was<br />

the commander of X Turret, Lieutenant A D Boyle, RN, from Otaio,<br />

South Canterbury. X Turret suffered a direct hit during the Battle of<br />

Jutland. No-one was killed – testimony, many say, to the spiritual<br />

power of the piupiu, which had been gifted to the ship with the<br />

prophesy that no harm would come to her crew if the captain wore<br />

it in battle. No harm ever did. After the war, NEW ZEALAND visited<br />

New Zealand, with the wartime fleet commander and previous First<br />

Sea Lord, Admiral of the Fleet, Lord Jellicoe. Jellicoe became the<br />

Governor General of New Zealand in 1920, until 1924.<br />

Hundreds of our seafaring men served in the Naval Forces of Great<br />

Britain during World War One and many did not come home.<br />

Instead, many of them served at sea, and they died and were buried<br />

at sea. For their relatives, there are no graveyards to be visited;<br />

seldom are there opportunities to parade with dignitaries and mark<br />

their graves. Instead, they rely on us, just as we rely on those who<br />

follow, to understand the very nature of warfare at sea, and mark<br />

their sacrifice in the waters where they died, a long way from home.<br />

At the Battle of Jutland commemorations, the Warrant Officer<br />

of the Navy and I will have the honour of representing you, and<br />

remembering those New Zealand naval personnel who served in<br />

WWI, in general, and at Jutland, in particular.<br />

For me, serving New Zealand in our Navy is an honour. To serve<br />

with honour is a destination as much as a description of how I will<br />

serve. Serving with honour and living this life as an honourable<br />

person is a key tenet of who I am as a man, a husband and father.<br />

And so, when I meet people who have been treated without honour,<br />

who have been left scarred by those who do not serve honourably<br />

— I ask myself, do I want those who do not act with honour in our<br />

Navy? You see, it’s not about doing things right, it’s about doing<br />

the right things. Recent events suggest that I am right, but it’s not<br />

just founded on a legal basis; it’s all about who we are as people<br />

and as naval personnel. Serving with honour is a hallmark of our<br />

contribution to our nation’s security.<br />

yours aye<br />

3


TE KAHA<br />

achieves<br />

DLOC<br />

4


‘Smashing it’<br />

After an intense seven-week readiness training period (also<br />

known as a ‘work up’), HMNZS TE KAHA successfully<br />

achieved her ‘directed level of capability’ (‘DLOC’) at the<br />

end of May.<br />

“This is a significant achievement for TE KAHA and I congratulate<br />

her crew − not only for the result, but also the attitude with which<br />

they tackled and overcame the challenge. Achieving DLOC means<br />

she is ready and able to deploy for warfare-based operations if<br />

required,” said the Royal New Zealand Navy’s Maritime Component<br />

Commander, Commodore Jim Gilmour.<br />

“One of the requirements of the NZDF is to maintain our combat<br />

capabilities across a range of force elements,” he explained. “In this<br />

case, the workup was for an element of the Naval Combat Force,<br />

and specifically, HMNZS TE KAHA. The crew, under the guidance<br />

and mentoring of the Maritime Operational Evaluation Team<br />

(MOET), demonstrated a thirst for knowledge, a drive for constant<br />

improvement and a warfighting attitude. They are well led at all<br />

levels and are operating as a great team.”<br />

The seven-week workup comprised a series of intense training<br />

periods. These prepared the ship to be able to conduct its core<br />

mission: generic warfare-based operations, and sea-control work.<br />

The ship is tested in areas such as warfare, core maritime skills,<br />

aviation, survivability, defence diplomacy, and C4ISR (command,<br />

control, communications, computers, intelligence, surveillance and<br />

reconnaissance).<br />

The work up culminated in a ‘directed readiness evaluation’. This<br />

was conducted by the MOET, who act as mentors early on and then<br />

‘withdraw’ to become assessors. They put the ship through a ‘mini<br />

war’ on 23 and 24 May, to evaluate its capability.<br />

Now that the ship is ready to operate at her directed level of<br />

capability, her next challenge is to achieve ‘task group certification’.<br />

The certification will allow her to participate in the Anzac task<br />

group deploying to Exercise RIMPAC (Rim of the Pacific) around<br />

Hawaii in July.<br />

By AWT Jesse Maiha<br />

Reflecting on the first three weeks of workup − the<br />

firings, damage control exercises, replenishment at<br />

sea, and everything else that the Maritime Operational<br />

Evaluation Team has thrown our way − we’ve shown that<br />

we’re ready to smash the remaining weeks ahead.<br />

The first week seemed about a month long, with long days<br />

getting the weapons prepped and cleaned to fulfil the<br />

goal of “1,000 rounds out of the barrel of the five”. The<br />

“roar of the war-drum”, so to speak, the thunder of the<br />

biggest gun in New Zealand, has been echoing a lot during<br />

the past couple of weeks. Hearing the empty cartridges<br />

smash against the fo’c’s’le as it was fired has made the early<br />

morning wakeups all that more worth it − no straight guard<br />

rails are left behind!<br />

The damage control teams have been getting a proper<br />

workout, putting every situation to the test. The Standing<br />

Sea Emergency Party definitely get a special mention here,<br />

as, quite simply, they have become better and better as the<br />

days have gone by.<br />

Heading into Defence watches meant a lot more<br />

seamanship evolutions, with the evo team going through<br />

their paces with RAS(L)s, light jackstays, boat transfers,<br />

and the boarding team learning the ropes. These all went<br />

as well as expected; the right people led the way and made<br />

sure everything went the way it should.<br />

The workup period evaluation (W<strong>UP</strong>E) was a good test.<br />

Overall, it was a pretty successful day, and I’m stoked<br />

we got the tick in the box. The Maritime Operational<br />

Evaluation Team fired everything they had at us and we<br />

took it in our stride, ensuring the enthusiasm was at a high,<br />

and leaving everything on the table. I, for one, am looking<br />

forward to learning more during the next few weeks and<br />

smashing everything that comes our way, while still getting<br />

more and more rounds out of the barrels.<br />

TE KAHA <strong>WORK</strong> <strong>UP</strong><br />

5


Multinational<br />

EOD exercise: ‘gold’<br />

Sailors from the RNZN Littoral Warfare<br />

Unit recently trained alongside troops<br />

from the US, Australian, Canadian<br />

and Singaporean defence forces in the<br />

biennial Exercise <strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong>.<br />

Above: ADRs Carlos Mita and Kyran Bennett swimming clear after<br />

placing a disposal charge<br />

The three-week exercise focuses on all aspects of Maritime<br />

Explosive Ordnance Disposal (MEOD) training. It was hosted<br />

by the US Navy’s Explosive Ordnance Disposal Mobile Unit 5,<br />

on the US Naval Base in Guam, during May.<br />

It was a great opportunity to improve ‘interoperability’ amongst a<br />

diverse group of EOD technicians, says Lieutenant Simon Marston.<br />

He led the Clearance Diving Group, of the RNZN’s Littoral Warfare<br />

Unit (LWU). They joined units from the US Navy, US Marine Corps,<br />

US Air Force, US Army, Royal Australian Navy, Royal Australian Air<br />

Force, Royal Canadian Navy, and the Singaporean Navy.<br />

“From an operational and capability perspective, the exercise<br />

was gold,” says LT Marston. “The ability to utilise live, underwater<br />

demolition ranges for both drills and tasks cannot be overstated, and<br />

the chance to work with partner nations who have had considerable<br />

exposure to EOD in a tactical environment allowed us to improve<br />

our techniques and procedures, and take a look at new and<br />

emerging technologies and equipment.”<br />

6 Ex Tri Crab


The aim of <strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong> is to strengthen relationships and<br />

interoperability between the participating nations, and to enhance<br />

the participants’ EOD capability.<br />

To achieve this, it focuses on all aspects of EOD tactics, techniques<br />

and procedures, including: Counter Improvised Explosive Device<br />

Disposal (CIEDD); waterborne IEDs; mine countermeasures;<br />

unexploded ordnance and explosive remnants of war response;<br />

weapons handling; chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear<br />

response; clearance diving; and helicopter and small boat insertion<br />

and extraction.<br />

“The greatest benefit of the exercise to the RNZN was the ability to<br />

access maritime ranges and other diverse training facilities, in which<br />

live maritime EOD and demolitions serials could be executed,” says<br />

LT Marston.<br />

The first week consisted of briefs on intelligence, bomb scene<br />

exploitation and case studies, as well as access training on fast rope,<br />

helicopter casting, small boat insertion, rappelling and parachuting.<br />

The second week was a series of US-run training days, concentrating<br />

on every facet of EOD work, including mounted and dismounted,<br />

Maritime Improvised Explosive Device Disposal (MIEDD), helicopterborne<br />

Mine Counter Measures (Pouncer Operations), underwater<br />

demolition serials, underwater improvised explosive device disposal,<br />

suicide boat attack, suicide diver attack, air insertion port clearance<br />

ops, limpet mine disposal, and high-risk port/jetty/hull clearance.<br />

Week three was ‘free play’, with scenarios developed and overseen<br />

by each nation’s ‘White Cell representatives’.<br />

LT Marston says that the exercise was “hugely successful”.<br />

“The team left New Zealand with a determination to contribute and<br />

interact at all levels and were committed to furthering the good<br />

name and reputation of the NZDF. They accomplished this and<br />

more; they constantly impressed with their ‘give it a go’ attitude, and<br />

won over many new friends.<br />

“From a leadership perspective, I am immensely proud to have<br />

been able to lead such a capable team who embraced every facet of<br />

the exercise and will have left a very favourable impression for the<br />

future.”<br />

The exercise first took place in 1996; the participants then were the<br />

US, Australia and Singapore – hence the name ‘Tri’. Crab is the name<br />

of the US EOD insignia.<br />

The exercise runs every two years. On the ‘off’ years, the RNZN<br />

trains with the exercise’s organising unit, US Navy EOD<br />

Mobile Unit 5.<br />

Top Left & Right: PODR Heaslip liaising with US EOD team on task;<br />

conducting a Render Safe Procedure<br />

<strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong><br />

This scenario was based on Maritime Infrastructure<br />

Protection (MIP) overseas during a period of civil unrest.<br />

A diver was challenged by maritime security forces for<br />

accessing a restricted area area. He failed to surrender and was<br />

subsequently shot on the surface before his body sank to the<br />

sea bed. The team were tasked to investigate and recover the<br />

body. The diver was carrying an improvised limpet device which<br />

needed to be rendered safe prior to being remotely lifted and<br />

moved to a safe disposal area, the body being recovered and<br />

processed through the forensic chain.<br />

The team was working hard as the scenarios ran for around five<br />

hours at time in temperatures ranging between 36–40 degrees C.<br />

They are being constantly monitored for fatigue, and fluid levels<br />

were maintained.<br />

Ex Tri Crab<br />

7


RNZN ready for first<br />

command role in RIMPAC<br />

By SLT Kimberley Williams, Flag Aide to CCTF 176<br />

The Rim of the Pacific Exercise, known as RIMPAC, is the world’s<br />

largest international maritime warfare exercise. This year, the<br />

25th RIMPAC, 26 nations will attend the biennial event.<br />

2016 also marks the first year that the RNZN will take a key leadership<br />

position in the exercise, which is hosted by the United States Navy<br />

(USN) Third Fleet.<br />

The Royal New Zealand Navy’s Maritime Component Commander<br />

(MCC), CDRE Jim Gilmour, supported by predominantly New Zealand<br />

staff, will be the ‘Commander Coalition Taskforce 176’ (CTF 176).<br />

CTF 176 is the largest coalition taskforce. The amphibious assault<br />

taskforce comprises 11 ships from six nations, including HMNZS TE<br />

KAHA. Multiple air and land assets, including the US Marine Corps’<br />

3rd Marine Brigade and 15th Marine Expeditionary Unit, as well as<br />

a company from the New Zealand Army, who will deploy in HMAS<br />

CANBERRA, will also be under command. This taskforce will be capable<br />

of projecting power in the maritime, littoral and inlands environments<br />

of Hawaii and Southern California.<br />

CTF 176 will be the lead from on-board USS AMERICA, which is the first<br />

of the America-class amphibious assault ships and the newest edition<br />

to the USN. USS AMERICA, commanded by Captain Wayne Baze,<br />

USN, has been in service since 2014, but RIMPAC will be her first major<br />

tasking. With a complement of over 2,700 personnel, there are more<br />

people on USS AMERICA than in the RNZN Regular Force!<br />

The Commander and staff of the USN Expeditionary Strike Group<br />

(ESG) Three will mentor the RNZN team, assisting them with<br />

understanding the USN systems and operations, and passing on their<br />

knowledge of the vast capabilities under their command. ESGs are<br />

self-contained composite forces, held at short notice to deliver effect<br />

anywhere in the world that can be reached by sea. They combine the<br />

capabilities of the surface ships, submarines, and patrol and attack<br />

aircraft, as well as the embarked amphibious Landing Force.<br />

The first planning conferences were held in 2015. This year, there have<br />

been several trips to the US and Canada to plan and train with our<br />

coalition partners, and finalise details. In March, CCTF 176 attended the<br />

commanders’ conference in Victoria, Canada.<br />

Another five CTF 176 staff spent two weeks in the US. There, they<br />

trained with the USN and US Marine Corps, adapting their knowledge<br />

of amphibious warfare to the US procedures, which will be used in<br />

RIMPAC 16.<br />

The RIMPAC team’s most recent trip was to the final planning<br />

conference and staff exercise in San Diego, in April. After a hectic week<br />

finalising the day-by-day plans for the entire amphibious taskforce, the<br />

RIMPAC staff undertook a week of scenario-based practical command<br />

training, simulating operational events that are likely to occur during<br />

the exercise, or during real-world operations. During the week, threat<br />

levels increased and the team used the assets on USS AMERICA and<br />

the entire amphibious taskforce to control the developing situation.<br />

The week culminated in air and sea landings, to take back a town from<br />

insurgents, who had gained control and were using it as a base, whilst<br />

at the same time warding off threats from enemy ships, patrol boats<br />

and aircraft. CDRE Gilmour proclaimed New Zealand as the winners of<br />

the exercise!<br />

CTF 176 staff will be deployed in USS AMERICA for the execution<br />

of the exercise, from June until August. After months of planning,<br />

the staffs are eagerly anticipating joining USS AMERICA in San<br />

Diego for the transit to Hawaii in mid-June. Stay tuned for exciting<br />

developments, as we get closer to the execution of RIMPAC 16.<br />

Above: During a visit to San Diego for the final planning conference, the<br />

MCC toured USS AMERICA, escorted by the Commanding Officer, CAPT<br />

Baze. Presented with a USS AMERICA ship’s cap, CCTF 176 is prepared to<br />

take command.<br />

Top of page: USS AMERICA<br />

8 RIMPAC PREP


Navy Today<br />

milestone<br />

200<br />

By former editor, CDR Richard Jackson RNZN (Rtd)<br />

The first issue of Navy Today was printed in June 1996, under the editorship of<br />

Jo Bunce, then the Navy’s corporate relations manager. It was a thin magazine –<br />

just 12 pages, with a limited print run of 5000 – but was an immediate hit.<br />

Twenty years ago, the Ministry of Defence produced a quarterly<br />

magazine aimed at defence commentators and government<br />

officials: Defence Quarterly. The RNZN also had its own<br />

periodical, Navy News, which had originated in the 1970s. Navy News<br />

depended on advertising support, and its commercial publisher<br />

would occasionally delay production until sufficient advertising had<br />

been sold. So it soon developed a reputation for being out of date.<br />

In 1996, the technology of communication had yet to explode into<br />

all the channels that are available today. The then Chief of Navy,<br />

Rear Admiral Jack Welch, saw the need for a reliable, up-to-date and<br />

authoritative magazine that would present the Navy’s wide-ranging<br />

activities to the public and to others in Government. Jo Bunce, with<br />

his extensive marketing credentials, developed the idea into tangible<br />

form, and designer Liz Bridgeman created a lively looking magazine.<br />

Back then, the only digital aspect was word processing; photographs<br />

came as hard-copy prints and the printing process depended on<br />

Navy Today – milestone 200<br />

9


Navy Today – milestone 200<br />

filmwork and plates. While Jo oversaw the editorial process and<br />

inspired the ships and units within the Navy to contribute, Liz<br />

oversaw the production. Jo ensured the magazine covered the recent<br />

activities of our ships, and also reflected the Navy’s interaction with<br />

New Zealand communities, as well as the wider naval profession<br />

– through book reviews, history pieces, and commentary on the<br />

international maritime scene.<br />

Navy Today’s success was reflected in an increasing print run and<br />

many requests to get onto the mailing list. Our sailors’ proud<br />

mums and dads wanted their own copies, as did our naval attachés,<br />

who saw the magazine as a useful entrée to the naval staffs of their<br />

host nations.<br />

The completion and delivery of our new Anzac frigates ensured<br />

a wide public interest in the Navy’s activities; by the turn of the<br />

century, Jo had an increasing workload with wider corporate relations<br />

activities. In 2001, he handed over the editor’s role to me: as a former<br />

naval officer, I have a deep interest in our Navy’s history and culture.<br />

For me, it was the perfect job, allowing me to be in close email<br />

contact with our Navy’s people, in ships, shore bases or overseas.<br />

At the same time, the evolution of digital imagery meant that<br />

photographs could be taken in, for example, the Persian Gulf or the<br />

Ross Sea and be sent to my computer the same day.<br />

In 2002, the talented Sarah Courtney joined Naval Staff and became<br />

the magazine’s designer. Her input was vital to Navy Today’s impact<br />

10<br />

Navy Today – milestone 200


ISSUE 200 JUNE 2016<br />

TE KAHA<br />

<strong>EXERCISE</strong><br />

<strong>BATTLE</strong> <strong>OF</strong> <strong>JUTLAND</strong><br />

<strong>WORK</strong> <strong>UP</strong> <strong>TRI</strong> <strong>CRAB</strong><br />

<strong>REMEMBERED</strong><br />

1<br />

CELEBRATING THE 75 TH ANNIVERSARY <strong>OF</strong> THE ROYAL NEW ZEALAND NAVY<br />

Navy Today – milestone 200<br />

as a professional journal. The Navy itself was fully engaged with<br />

ongoing operational deployments – both at sea and ashore – while<br />

Project Protector meant that the Navy’s management and technical<br />

expertise was in demand. Each Chief of Navy fully supported Navy<br />

Today, seeing it as a valuable leadership tool.<br />

By 2011, the design of Navy Today had been moved ‘inhouse’, within<br />

the Defence public relations organisation, and I moved across to Air<br />

Force News. The experienced journalist David McLoughlin came in as<br />

Navy Today’s third editor; he built on the established structure of the<br />

magazine and strengthened the multi-media approach, taking the<br />

Navy’s Facebook page out to a huge audience.<br />

With Issue 200, Navy Today has reached an important milestone.<br />

A hard-copy printed magazine imposes some key disciplines<br />

on contributors and editors alike. The proliferation of digital<br />

channels may be a key element for contemporary public affairs,<br />

but magazines have a degree of permanence and durability that is<br />

still unrivalled. Navy Today can found in public and school libraries,<br />

as well as foreign embassies and even doctors’ or dentists’ waiting<br />

rooms. It reaches a wide audience and has been a key element<br />

in maintaining public awareness of the many ways our Navy<br />

contributes to New Zealand.<br />

Navy Today – milestone 200<br />

11


Battle of Jutland<br />

It is 100 years since the largest naval battle in history: the Battle of Jutland.<br />

The Battle of Jutland – or, as the Germans called it, The Battle<br />

of Skagerrak – raged for over 12 hours, beginning on the<br />

afternoon of 31 May 1916, 80 miles west off the coast of<br />

Jutland, in Denmark.<br />

Jutland was fought by the fleets of the world’s two largest navies,<br />

those of England and Germany. It was the only time that the Royal<br />

Navy’s Grand Fleet and the German High Seas Fleet met in battle<br />

during World War One, and it was to be the last time a major naval<br />

battle would be contested between only two surface fleets.<br />

There were 249 ships involved in the battle – 150 British and 99<br />

German – and over 100,000 men. Of those, one in 10 were killed<br />

or wounded. For many, death was sudden and was on a huge scale.<br />

HMS QUEEN MARY lost 1,266; INDEFATIGABLE, 1,017; INVINCIBLE,<br />

1,026; DEFENCE, 903; BLACK PRINCE, 857; SMS WIESBADEN, 589;<br />

FRAULENLOB, 320. Many of those who did survive the sinkings died<br />

of exposure in the cold waters.<br />

Debate over the outcome still rages on − 100 years after the fleets<br />

returned to their home ports.<br />

What was the legacy of Jutland?<br />

• It was a decisive, pivotal turning point of naval doctrine,<br />

strategy and technology.<br />

• It was the first battle fought against the unseen: due to<br />

the weather, darkness, the Zeppelin or the new threat of<br />

the submarine.<br />

• After failing to annihilate the Grand Fleet, Germany was left<br />

with only one option: to return to unrestricted submarine<br />

warfare, which Britain was unprepared for. In 1917, this nearly<br />

caused Britain’s defeat, but also brought the United States into<br />

the war.<br />

• At Jutland, the dreadnought was redefined, the torpedo and<br />

mine threat unrealised, and gunnery, munitions, ship design,<br />

intelligence and battlefield communications were re-thought.<br />

Notes on Jutland<br />

• Both the commanders-in-chief accompanied the fleet into<br />

action and risked being killed in action.<br />

• Radio was in use, but it was very poor and subject to<br />

interference and loss of signals; signalling was reduced<br />

to flags.<br />

• There was no GPS; the exact positions of ships were<br />

determined mostly by dead reckoning; although a few, like<br />

NEW ZEALAND, had taken an observed position at noon on<br />

the 31st.<br />

• Unlike a modern ship, Jellicoe and Scheer did not have realtime<br />

information on the progress of the battle, such as radar<br />

and airborne reconnaissance, so they had to make tactical<br />

decisions with the fragmented information passed along to<br />

them during the battle.<br />

• This battle showed that there was a lag between the efficiency<br />

of communications equipment and the complexity of handling<br />

a large fleet in battle.<br />

• The lessons and controversies of the Battle of Jutland directly<br />

influenced how the Royal and Commonwealth navies fought in<br />

World War Two, and shaped the ethos of our Navy today.<br />

For a more detailed account of the Battle of Jutland, visit the Royal<br />

New Zealand Navy Museum website, http://navymuseum.co.nz/<br />

worldwar1/battles-operations/battle-of-jutland/. Or open Navy Today<br />

#110, page 21−28.<br />

Timeline<br />

• First phase of the main fleet action, 4.54−6.15pm:<br />

action between the battleships, battlecruisers and<br />

light forces of each fleet, loss of INVINCIBLE.<br />

• Fourth phase of the main fleet<br />

action, 7.45−9.30 – last action in<br />

daylight.<br />

• Battlecruiser action,<br />

3.48−4.54pm: New Zealand’s<br />

first shots of the battle, loss<br />

of the QUEEN MARY and<br />

INDEFATIGABLE.<br />

• Second phase of<br />

the main fleet<br />

action, 6.15−7pm.<br />

• Third phase of the<br />

main fleet action,<br />

7−7.45pm.<br />

• Night action,<br />

9.30pm−3am,<br />

1 June.<br />

• Return to<br />

ports by both<br />

fleets, 1 June.<br />

12 Battle of Jutland


Captain<br />

Alexander Boyle<br />

Lieutenant Alexander David Boyle is the only known New<br />

Zealander to have served at all three major naval battles of World<br />

War One.<br />

CAPT Boyle, from Canterbury, entered the Royal Navy before<br />

World War One and was serving on HMS NEW ZEALAND when war<br />

broke. He stayed with the ship as it participated in the all the major<br />

naval engagements between 1914 and 1918, including the Battles of<br />

Heligoland Bight, Dogger Bank and Jutland.<br />

During the Battle of Jutland, in May 1916, HMS NEW ZEALAND<br />

suffered a number of hits but no serious damage. NEW ZEALAND<br />

survived a direct hit to X- turret, the gun turret Captain Boyle<br />

was in charge of. He was awarded a Mention in Dispatches for his<br />

subsequent actions.<br />

Boyle wrote to his parents after HMS NEW ZEALAND had returned<br />

to port:<br />

• There is not the smallest doubt in my mind that they lost as<br />

many ships as we did and received considerably more damage.<br />

• I am perfectly convinced they will be defeated one day. They<br />

would have been completely that day had the light lasted.<br />

• Their luck at the beginning, with mist and light, gave them the<br />

first advantage. The destroyers who attacked them in the night<br />

swear they saw some sink.<br />

• I do not think the truth will ever be known. NEW ZEALAND<br />

was in the thick of it and came out with hardly a scratch to<br />

ship or person.<br />

• The other ships in the fleet were hit many more times than<br />

we were.<br />

• The sailors say the Maori face we have painted on the central<br />

top saved the ship. If we painted it out now I am sure they<br />

would mutiny. We are not going to try.<br />

• When the enemy fire, you can see the dull red flash of their<br />

guns and then a cluster of dots getting bigger and bigger as<br />

they tear towards you.<br />

• One knows it is no good ducking or getting behind anything,<br />

as the only thing to do is sit still and hope they do not hit you.<br />

It is like somebody throwing heavy stones at you whilst you sit<br />

still in a chair.<br />

He concluded with, “It is a nice little game this war and I will not be<br />

sorry when it is over.”<br />

After World War One, CAPT Boyle left the Royal Navy and returned<br />

to Canterbury. He was the first Commanding Officer of the Naval<br />

Reserve Division, established in Christchurch between the wars.<br />

He was recalled to active service during World War Two, where he<br />

reached the rank of Captain, then returned to his South Canterbury<br />

farm after the war ended. He died in 1965.<br />

Marking Jutland in 2016<br />

The Orkney Islands served as the main base for the Royal Navy<br />

during the First World War, and was the major focal point for the<br />

anniversary ceremony in the UK on 31 May.<br />

On Orkney, a national service of remembrance was held in St<br />

Magnus’ Cathedral. Then proceedings moved to Lyness Royal Navy<br />

Cemetery, overlooking Scapa Flow. The Chief of Navy, Rear Admiral<br />

John Martin, ONZM, attended the ceremony. He presented the<br />

piupiu and objects from the Battle of Jutland, which are on loan to<br />

the RN Museum’s Jutland Exhibition (see page 32).<br />

Commemorations in New Zealand<br />

Sunday, 29 May 2016: Kaiapoi Returned Services Association<br />

held a Battle of Jutland Service at Kaiapoi Cenotaph, supported<br />

by HMNZS Pegasus. It was followed by a wreath-laying<br />

ceremony.<br />

Tuesday, 31 May: A service was held in Devonport, Auckland,<br />

run by the Auckland Council and the National Museum of the<br />

Royal New Zealand Navy.<br />

Also on the 31 May, the Battle of Jutland Exhibition opened<br />

at South Canterbury Museum, in Timaru. The battle flag from<br />

HMS New Zealand is on display in the exhibition.<br />

Battle of Jutland<br />

13


Operation Neptune:<br />

full steam ahead for November<br />

Following the 75th anniversary events featured in our February<br />

update (Naval Base Veteran’s Day, Formation Entry, and<br />

Government House Garden Party) Operation NEPTUNE has<br />

hosted more events and is ramping up preparations for the Women<br />

at Sea celebrations in June and the International Naval Review in<br />

November.<br />

To mark the Navy’s 75th anniversary, Mr Malcolm Taylor of<br />

Ashburton presented a handcrafted model of HMNZS KIWI (T02),<br />

a Bird-class ‘corvette’ commissioned in 1941 that saw service in the<br />

Solomon Islands in 1943. Together with HMNZS MOA, the KIWI<br />

successfully engaged the Japanese submarine I-1 off the coast of<br />

Guadalcanal, ramming her three times and causing the much bigger<br />

submarine to flee until she ran aground. The well-detailed model<br />

took Mr Taylor around 1,400 hours, during a two-year period, to<br />

complete.<br />

Ceremonies at shore and at sea were held to commemorate the 75th<br />

anniversary of HMS PURIRI’s loss on 14 May 1941. HMS PURIRI was<br />

the only warship sunk by enemy action in New Zealand waters. For<br />

more on the ceremony, see page 22 and 23.<br />

Preparations are well underway for the Women at Sea celebrations<br />

this June. The events will be launched with a sea-riding day in<br />

HMNZS WELLINGTON on 18 June, followed by a conference at the<br />

Spencer on Byron Hotel on 23−24 June and a reception on 23 June at<br />

the Auckland War Memorial Museum. We are proud to acknowledge<br />

the previous service of our former naval women, as well as the great<br />

work of our current sailors.<br />

The International Naval Review in November is shaping up to be<br />

a once-in-a-lifetime, spectacular event. A number of foreign and<br />

Commonwealth navies have said that they will be participating. A<br />

street march, a fleet review by Her Excellency the Governor General,<br />

an all-ranks function and a ‘Champion of the Navy’-style sports<br />

tournament are but a few of the activities that are planned for the<br />

celebration. There is certainly plenty of work to do leading up to the<br />

INR from across the Navy but it will be worth it.<br />

The Operation NEPTUNE team has made a real effort to connect our<br />

people with our history. In doing so, we have made some mistakes<br />

which must be acknowledged. On page 48 of the commemorative<br />

publication “Courage, Commitment, Comradeship: 75 Years of the<br />

Royal New Zealand Navy”, there is a photograph captioned HMS<br />

NEW ZEALAND, which is actually the battleship HMS NEPTUNE.<br />

In the order of service for the PURIRI commemorations there is<br />

a photograph of a vessel captioned MV PURIRI, which is in fact<br />

the vessel built after the war to replace the original. We sincerely<br />

apologise for these mistakes and deeply regret any offence that may<br />

have been caused.<br />

Stand by for more pipes!<br />

Above: Mr Malcolm Taylor with the model of the HMNZS KIWI that he<br />

presented to the RNZN on 24 February<br />

14 Operation Neptune


Our Collective Purpose<br />

Left: HRH Prince Harry with<br />

(left) CPO Amy Baynes, who<br />

received two silver medals,<br />

one for the IRB2 Women’s<br />

Road Bike Time Trial and one<br />

for the IRB2 Women’s Road<br />

Bike Circuit.<br />

The power of potential:<br />

Invictus<br />

By Matthew Boulton, Defence Public Affairs<br />

There’s a growing air of excitement as<br />

the team members take their places on<br />

the court. A whistle blows and the ball is<br />

thrown in. Arms reach to take possession<br />

and simultaneously the crowd erupts over<br />

the crash of metal on metal, as opposing<br />

sides hurl themselves at the person they are<br />

marking. Every attempt is made to stop the<br />

other team from being able to manoeuvre<br />

their well-armoured wheelchairs toward the<br />

touch line. It’s an intense game of hard hits<br />

and incredible athleticism; it’s nicknamed<br />

‘murderball’ for good reason, and it’s only<br />

when you watch a triple-amputee move<br />

like lightning through a heavy New Zealand<br />

defence and score the first try of the game<br />

you realise this is a sporting competition<br />

like no other. This is wheelchair rugby at the<br />

Invictus Games − it’s only one of 10 sports<br />

being competed during the four days of<br />

competition − and it’s spectacular.<br />

In 2014, His Royal Highness Prince Harry, along with the Royal<br />

Foundation of the Duchess of Cambridge and the UK Ministry<br />

of Defence, hosted the inaugural Invictus Games − a five-day<br />

adaptive sporting event that brought together injured, wounded and<br />

ill current and ex-serving men and women from around the world.<br />

Its goals: to harness the power of sport to inspire recovery, support<br />

rehabilitation, and generate a wider understanding of, and respect<br />

for, those who serve their country.<br />

In 2014, the New Zealand Defence Force sent 12 athletes from across<br />

all services: representatives of Regular and Reserve Forces, serving<br />

civilians and retired personnel. The team fought hard in London and<br />

brought back six medals for their efforts.<br />

Toward the end of 2015, the call went out again across the NZDF.<br />

A selection camp was held and over the coming months of training,<br />

18 athletes and a handful of support staff found themselves<br />

marching into Champion Stadium at the ESPN Wide World of<br />

Sports Complex in Orlando, Florida, as part of the NZ Defence Force<br />

Invictus Games team.<br />

It would be easy to think that competing at events like the Invictus<br />

Games is less challenging than in non-adaptive sporting events.<br />

Nothing could be further from the truth. The road to Invictus is not<br />

an easy one. For some it means testing their physicality in ways that<br />

it hasn’t been tested before. For others, it’s a test of their mental<br />

strength: stepping outside of their comfort zone. Each would agree<br />

that the end result was worth it.<br />

CPOPTI Miria Paul, one of the team’s team trainers, says she<br />

learned unexpected lessons through the Games. “Preconceptions<br />

I may have had at the beginning of this journey about the limits<br />

I thought athletes might have due to their illness or injury − not<br />

understanding their true potential or capabilities − has changed so<br />

INVICTUS<br />

15


Our Collective Purpose<br />

much. It’s allowed me to become a better trainer, looking outside<br />

the square to find different training solutions for different athletes,”<br />

she says.<br />

During the games, the playing field is levelled through details such<br />

as competitors being matched against people with similar injury,<br />

or by all players competing in wheelchairs in basketball, tennis and<br />

rugby. But the challenge is as big, if not bigger. There are physical<br />

and emotional differences to overcome; perceived weaknesses that<br />

are refocused as strengths. Imagine learning the skills required to<br />

handle a wheelchair when you have never had to use one, while<br />

simultaneously remembering the particular rules of the sport you’re<br />

playing AND keeping a competitive edge.<br />

Beyond the physical rehabilitation that sport can bring, competing<br />

with people who share a similar circumstance or experience offers<br />

a way to enhance good mental health − a huge focus of the 2016<br />

Invictus Games.<br />

“It’s the people,” says POMED Aaron Gibbs, a competitor at the<br />

games. “Everybody has their own journey, but we’re all on the same<br />

road heading for the same place. We all have our stories to share,<br />

and we did. It made it easier,” he said.<br />

While individual sport makes up six of the events throughout the<br />

Invictus Games, team sports such as wheelchair rugby, wheelchair<br />

basketball and wheelchair tennis brought the team together.<br />

“My highlight was playing wheelchair basketball against the Italian<br />

team,” says CPO Bart Couprie. “I was pleased with the way we<br />

performed − the team on the court worked well. It was good to be<br />

able to put all of our training into practice,” he said.<br />

The next Invictus Games will take place in Toronto, Canada, 26−30<br />

September 2017.<br />

Invictus<br />

Out of the night that covers me,<br />

Black as the pit from pole to pole,<br />

I thank whatever gods may be,<br />

For my unconquerable soul.<br />

In the fell clutch of circumstance<br />

I have not winced or cried aloud.<br />

Under the bludgeonings of change<br />

My head is bloody, but unbowed.<br />

Beyond this place of wrath and tears<br />

Looms but the horrors of the shade,<br />

And yet the menace of the years<br />

Finds, and shall find, me afraid.<br />

It matters not how strait the gate,<br />

How charged with punishments the scroll,<br />

I AM the master of my fate:<br />

I AM the captain of my soul.<br />

The Invictus Games was inspired by the words of William<br />

Ernest Henley’s poem. Henley was an amputee and his poem<br />

is testimony to his refusal to let illness disrupt his life. It is<br />

this ode to the unrelenting human spirit that is at the very heart of<br />

the Invictus Games.<br />

The 2016 Invictus Games were an outstanding success. The host<br />

country, the United States, organised a great event. I have never<br />

been in such a place where the atmosphere has been so powerful,<br />

inspiring and humbling, and with many of the athletes openly<br />

telling their stories.<br />

A total of 500 athletes from 14 countries (Afghanistan, Australia,<br />

Canada, Denmark, Estonia, France, Georgia, Germany, Italy, Jordan,<br />

Netherlands, New Zealand, United Kingdom, US) competed in 10<br />

adaptive sporting events.<br />

Left: POMED Aaron Gibbs, following New Zealand’s resounding win against<br />

Australia in wheelchair basketball<br />

16 INVICTUS


Our Collective Purpose<br />

The NZDF Invictus 2016 Team did well; they should all be proud<br />

of their achievements. What the athletes achieved on their own<br />

journeys to achieving a medal, a personal best or making it to the<br />

start line is nothing short of inspirational.<br />

You may see physical scars of what the athletes have endured, but<br />

not the mental scars. Many of the servicemen and women suffer lifechanging<br />

injuries, visible or otherwise, while serving their country.<br />

How do they find the motivation to move on and not be defined by<br />

their injuries? How can they be recognised for their achievements<br />

and not given sympathy?<br />

Using sport as the medium has helped physically, psychologically<br />

and socially with their recovery, as these mediums are the great<br />

denominators.<br />

Like all good sports teams there are also the management, medical<br />

support, trainers and media teams who all need to be acknowledged<br />

for all their hard work, organisation, commitment and support<br />

shown to help the competitors in their journey.<br />

The Navy component of the team comprised CPO Amy Baynes (who<br />

achieved two silver medals in cycling); CPO Bart Couprie; POSCS<br />

Tana Pungatara; POMED Aaron Gibbs; POEWS Karl Shearsby; A/<br />

LWTR Heather Cook and – not forgetting – the all-important trainer<br />

and support person, CPOPTI Miria Paul.<br />

An important element of the success of the Invictus Games is also<br />

the whanau and friends who support the athletes through their<br />

journey; our families are our rock.<br />

By WO Steve Bourke<br />

Top left: CPO Bart Couprie during indoor rowing<br />

Above left: CPO Amy Baynes takes aim<br />

Above right: POSCS Tana Pungatara lays down the challenge in a pre-match<br />

haka against the host USA Wheelchair Rugby team<br />

The Kiwi Team took home nine medals<br />

at Invictus 2016:<br />

Gold<br />

Glenn Barnes (ex-Army): IR2 Men’s One-Minute Rowing<br />

Silver<br />

NZDF medal tally<br />

CPO Amy Baynes (Navy): IRB2 Women’s Road Bike Time Trial<br />

CPO Amy Baynes (Navy): IRB2 Women’s Road Bike Circuit<br />

Glenn Barnes (ex-Army): Wheelchair Tennis<br />

David Sherriff (ex-Air Force): Wheelchair Tennis<br />

Bronze<br />

SGT Gareth Pratt (Army): Men’s 50-Metre Breaststroke ISD<br />

MAJ (Rtd) Josephine Barrett (Army): Women’s 50-Metre<br />

Breaststroke ISC<br />

CPL Kelly Whittle (Army): Women’s Discus Throw IF4<br />

Nu Filo (ex-Army): IR5 Men’s One-Minute Rowing<br />

INVICTUS<br />

17


18 Celebrating our Women


Celebrating our Women<br />

19


Inspiring next<br />

generation of scientists<br />

By Anna Thomas<br />

Around 40 primary school children from South Auckland<br />

recently spent the day in Devonport with some of the<br />

NZDF’s sharpest scientific minds.<br />

The visit was part of the Rongomai Primary School STEM immersion<br />

class, which draws students from Rongomai, Bairds, Dawson and<br />

Opukeke primary schools. STEM stands for science, technology,<br />

engineering and mathematics.<br />

The pilot programme aims to encourage students to learn through<br />

projects that improve their literacy and numeracy skills.<br />

Some of their projects have already gained national attention,<br />

including a test for kauri dieback disease and the testing of mould in<br />

South Auckland homes.<br />

The group’s visit to the Navy focused on the testing of ‘aquabots’<br />

(underwater robots) that they had made in their classroom. A<br />

group of scientists and engineers from DTA was on hand to answer<br />

questions and share their knowledge with the youngsters.<br />

After testing and running exercises with the aquabots in the Navy<br />

pool, the group were given a tour of TE MANA. For some of the<br />

children, it was their first trip over the Auckland Harbour Bridge and,<br />

for most of them, their first time on a Navy ship.<br />

STEM director, Nick Pattison, says the biggest challenge is getting<br />

the children to believe in themselves. “These kids are from some<br />

of the poorest homes in the country and they have so little<br />

opportunity. But they have so much potential, it is a matter of being<br />

able to tap into it.”<br />

He hopes the visit to the Devonport Naval Base and the tour of TE<br />

MANA will inspire some of them to consider the military as a<br />

career option.<br />

“If they can understand science, they can apply it in a variety of<br />

areas, and the military is a great place.”<br />

Nick Pattison says he is particularly interested in empowering girls.<br />

“I really want to show these kids, especially the girls, that joining the<br />

military doesn’t just mean fighting wars. You can get an education<br />

and see the world, and there are so many different roles within the<br />

military to consider, especially within the RNZN.”<br />

All images on this page: South Auckland primary school children<br />

test their ‘aquabots’<br />

20 Community


Seaworthiness<br />

safe, compliant<br />

& effective<br />

By Dennis Pringle and Helen Wright<br />

The technical outputs of the NZDF Maritime Domain must meet<br />

the three essential requirements of seaworthiness: being safe,<br />

compliant and effective.<br />

The purpose of the Technical Seaworthiness Authority (TSwA) is to<br />

assure the NZDF Seaworthiness Authority (SwA, the Chief of Navy)<br />

that these requirements are met. As the TSwA is independent from<br />

Capability and Operations, the reports and advice given are not<br />

influenced by conflicting objectives.<br />

The TSwA’s core function is to provide the SwA with independent<br />

assurance that NZDF vessels, key equipment, and systems used<br />

by maritime force elements comply with the Maritime Regulatory<br />

Baseline (for more on the MRB, see Navy Today #199, page 21). This<br />

means verifying that all policies, processes, procedures, standards,<br />

instructions and SOPs that make up and support the technical aspects<br />

of the MRB are followed.<br />

Some of the TSwA’s other functions include reporting issues that<br />

might affect seaworthiness to the SwA and the Maritime Regulator<br />

(MARREG), communicating seaworthiness-critical technical<br />

regulations to stakeholders, and assisting MARREG in administrating<br />

technical regulatory deviation requests. Processing deviation<br />

requests (RNZN180s) involves evaluating the operational and safety<br />

risks associated with the deviation and considering the adequacy of<br />

proposed risk mitigation strategies.<br />

To deliver their core function, the TSwA conducts assurance activities.<br />

Inspections, audits and reviews assess the adequacy of technical<br />

policy and procedures for compliance with the MRB, and to assess<br />

unit compliance with these policies and procedures.<br />

All NZDF units that contribute to the technical seaworthiness of force<br />

elements are responsible for ensuring compliance with the MRB.<br />

Individual units retain responsibility for internal audit programmes<br />

used to improve and assure regulatory compliance. TSwA assurance<br />

activities do not replace these internal programmes, but identify areas<br />

of non-compliance where corrective and preventative action plans can<br />

be implemented.<br />

Specific assurance activities are undertaken for various reasons, such<br />

as leading up to or subsequent to Seaworthiness Boards, follow up of<br />

earlier assurance activities, or an assessment of adherence to changes<br />

in policies. There is a focus on critical safety aspects. Assurance<br />

activities have been conducted in a number of areas. Some recent<br />

assurance activities conducted include maintenance management:<br />

working at height; ship stability management; explosives handling and<br />

storage; and aviation fuel management.<br />

TSwA has a strategy of continuous improvement, so sharing results,<br />

forwarding advice and providing feedback to units is a vital part of<br />

conducting an assurance activity. Rather than being just an assessor<br />

or enforcer, TSwA can help units improve their own approach to<br />

safety, compliance and effectiveness by providing an external view of<br />

what they are doing and identifying deficiencies or opportunities for<br />

improvement.<br />

One of the first assurance activities conducted was on ‘height safety’,<br />

and a follow-up activity was since carried out. The review found<br />

that force elements had taken on-board previous TSwA direction.<br />

Processes and training have being aligned with updated policies and<br />

new legislative requirements. The activity showed a positive change in<br />

RNZN height safety culture, which was reinforced by the enthusiasm<br />

of the personnel encountered during the review.<br />

TSwA assurance activities are not just about ticking boxes. They<br />

provide evidence of the health of technical administrative and<br />

management systems in the NZDF maritime domain and facilitate<br />

action plans for improving technical seaworthiness.<br />

NZDF SEaworthiness<br />

21


75 th anniversary<br />

of HMS Puriri sinking commemorated<br />

Ceremonies at shore and sea were held to commemorate the<br />

75th anniversary of the sinking of HMS PURIRI − the only<br />

New Zealand naval ship lost to enemy action in New Zealand<br />

waters.<br />

HMS PURIRI was a merchant vessel commissioned into service as<br />

a minesweeper. She sank after striking a mine about eight nautical<br />

miles northeast of Bream Head, Whangarei, on 14 May 1941.<br />

Five of her crew were killed, including the captain, Lieutenant<br />

Douglas Blacklaws, Royal Naval Reserve (New Zealand).<br />

The ceremony ashore began with a dawn service on 14 May. The<br />

service was facilitated by local iwi and supported by the RNZN<br />

Māori Cultural Group, the Littoral Warfare Unit, Commodore John<br />

Campbell and Captain Andrew Watts.<br />

Following this was a general service, involving the Littoral Warfare<br />

Unit, the Whangarei RSA, and representatives of the New Zealand<br />

Merchant Service. Distinguished guests included the Mayor of<br />

Whangarei, local iwi, former naval men and women, and the family<br />

of the PURIRI casualties.<br />

Simultaneously, the ceremony at sea was held on board HMNZS<br />

ROTOITI, where her commanding officer, Lieutenant Adam Flaws,<br />

laid a wreath above the PURIRI wreck, eight nautical miles northeast<br />

off Bream Head, Whangarei.<br />

Chaplain Peter Olds gave a wonderful address in which he spoke<br />

of the enduring significance of the sacrifice of those lost in PURIRI,<br />

and contrasted that with the superficial preoccupation that we see<br />

reflected in today’s mainstream news media. In 1941, the loss of<br />

the PURIRI was front-page news. In 2016, it’s the aftermath of “The<br />

Bachelor”, he said. It is certainly worth thinking about, as we reflect<br />

on our history and those who have gone before us.<br />

The commemoration was particularly meaningful to the relatives of<br />

the PURIRI casualties, including the family of LT Blacklaws RNR(NZ),<br />

the commanding officer of the ill-fated minesweeper who, together<br />

with four others, perished when their ship struck a German mine.<br />

Mrs Sonya Sage (LT Blacklaws’ niece) and her husband Ian said that<br />

they were “deeply grateful that the personal involvement of people<br />

22 HMS PURIRI


“deeply grateful that the personal involvement<br />

of people involved in setting up the memorial<br />

was recognised”<br />

involved in setting up the memorial was recognised”, adding that<br />

“everyone we spoke to was appreciative of the service”. Another<br />

relative commented that “everything was just superb, even down to<br />

the magnificent weather” and that it was “a very special day for us<br />

that will live long in our memories”.<br />

CAPT Watts, Director of Operation Neptune, said the ceremony was<br />

particularly relevant for the Littoral Warfare Unit, which conducts<br />

mine clearance operations in the Pacific Islands.<br />

“A key role of the Navy’s Littoral Warfare Unit is to identify and clear<br />

mines to ensure waterways are safe for the shipping that carries 98<br />

percent of New Zealand’s imports and exports by volume.<br />

“It’s important also to note the role of the Merchant Navy in<br />

sustaining New Zealand’s national life during World War II. This<br />

commemoration highlights that the relationship between the RNZN<br />

and the Merchant Navy is just as important now as it was 75 years<br />

ago,” said CAPT Watts.<br />

NZDF SEaworthiness<br />

23


Fallen<br />

serviceman<br />

remembered<br />

Nine-year-old Brooklyn Oakley listens intently to the names<br />

of veterans being read at an Anzac service, waiting for one<br />

name in particular – that never came.<br />

The name was ‘Denis Scrimgeour’. The Royal New Zealand Air Force<br />

Warrant officer died in 1942, during the fall of Singapore, aged 21.<br />

Brooklyn’s father, Royal New Zealand Navy Commander Brendon<br />

Oakley, was based in Singapore with his family for the past three<br />

years. The family would regularly lay poppies onto the Kiwi graves<br />

in Singapore’s Kranji War Cemetery, and place their personal poppies<br />

on the grave of Denis Scrimgeour.<br />

The children – Lukas (11), Brooklyn and Ruby (twins, 9) – were<br />

‘looking after’ the buried soldiers.<br />

The Kranji War Cemetery records Denis’s hometown as being<br />

Richmond, in the Nelson region, which is also the hometown of CDR<br />

Oakley and his wife Lisa.<br />

So when the Oakley family attended their first Anzac day service in<br />

Richmond this year, Brooklyn listened intently to the Roll of Honour,<br />

for Denis’s name. When it didn’t come, CDR Oakley had to reassure<br />

Brooklyn that Denis was still being looked after.<br />

And now he can. A story in the Nelson Mail, a letter and a few emails<br />

later – and the mystery was solved.<br />

CDR Oakley received a letter from Denise Scrimgeour, the niece of<br />

Denis, and his namesake.<br />

She said that Denis grew up in Golden Bay, rather than Richmond, so<br />

his name was recorded on the cenotaph at Collingwood.<br />

“Mrs Scrimgeour emailed through photos and a link to a<br />

website, which shows the Collingwood cenotaph with WO Denis<br />

Scrimgeour’s name engraved. Therefore, he’s suitably remembered<br />

in Collingwood in Golden Bay, and still within the Nelson region.<br />

This was great to learn,” says CDR Oakley.<br />

“My kids were delighted to see his name on the cenotaph, to<br />

discover that he is remembered in the town where he grew up.”<br />

They were also very interested to hear that his niece had been<br />

named after him.<br />

“When I was born in 1945, he was still officially ‘missing’,” said Mrs<br />

Scrimgeour. “I was named after him.”<br />

Five years later her mother received a letter from the Air<br />

Department, dated May 26, 1950, informing her of the location of<br />

the graves in Malaya, and the re-internment in Kranji Cemetery. The<br />

records state that he died on 4 February, 1942.<br />

The correspondence didn’t stop there.<br />

American military personnel posted to Singapore saw the Nelson<br />

Mail article online, and they contacted CDR Oakley and Lisa through<br />

social media.<br />

“They essentially said, ‘no worries; we’ll look after him’ and visited<br />

Kranji War Cemetery, placing flowers on his grave. That was quite a<br />

touching statement from the US Forces.”<br />

The US military personnel said they would make a tradition of<br />

looking after the graves.<br />

CDR Oakley is amazed how it all came about, and the positive<br />

reaction from people in New Zealand and offshore – all just from<br />

sitting there, reassuring his daughter on Anzac Day morning.<br />

In Memory of<br />

Warrant Officer<br />

Denis Allan Scrimgeour<br />

401783, Royal New Zealand Air Force who died on 04 February 1942 Age 21<br />

Son of Arthur Raymond Scrimgeour, and of Phyllis Scrimgeour (nee Lewis), of Richmond, Nelson, New<br />

Zealand.<br />

Remembered with Honour<br />

Kranji War Cemetery<br />

Above right: Lukas Oakley lays a poppy on the grave of Denis Scrimgeour,<br />

in Singapore<br />

24 OUR PEOPLE


Sailors get ‘head start’<br />

on Canadian frigate<br />

By Sonya Chwyl of the Royal Canadian Navy, Maritime Forces Pacific Public Affairs<br />

Four Royal New Zealand Navy sailors travelled more than<br />

14,000 kilometres to join Royal Canadian Navy (RCN)<br />

sailors in HMCS Ottawa, as part of the Regulus<br />

exchange programme.<br />

They are part of a 30-person contingent sent to work with<br />

the RCN.<br />

Since January, the sailors have adjusted to life aboard a foreign<br />

navy ship, learning where everything is located in the Canadian<br />

frigate, and finding their place within the ship’s crew and culture.<br />

“Everyone has been very welcoming,” said Able Marine<br />

Technician (AMT) Tomi Fataaiki. “It’s a super-friendly atmosphere<br />

and the culture is very similar to back home, so we clicked<br />

straight away.”<br />

The Kiwi sailors perform the same duties as their Canadian<br />

counterparts, Ordinary Seaman Marine Engineers.<br />

“All four New Zealanders have been working diligently alongside<br />

the Canadian crew,” said Lieutenant (Navy) Jeff Benson. “They’re<br />

all fully integrated, and they’re expected and capable of doing all<br />

the tasks of any other Ordinary Seaman Marine Engineer.”<br />

All four have become qualified Engineering Roundsmen. Ordinary<br />

Marine Technician Damon Dick-Carson has also achieved<br />

certification as an Emergency Response Roundsman and AMT<br />

Fataaiki is now a qualified Canadian Patrol Frigate Damage<br />

Control Roundsman.<br />

AMT Fataaiki says the exchange programme has been an<br />

excellent way to kick-start his naval career.<br />

“It’s been exactly what I was hoping for. The knowledge I’ve<br />

gained here will be really useful, because a lot of the same<br />

“It’s a super-friendly<br />

atmosphere and the<br />

culture is very similar to<br />

back home, so we clicked<br />

straight away.”<br />

equipment will be installed on the RNZN’s ships soon. It’s a great<br />

way to get ahead of the game.”<br />

Before they return home at the end of June, the New Zealand<br />

sailors will be qualified to operate all the auxiliary machinery<br />

systems on board Halifax-class frigates, which means they’ll be<br />

capable of working with the RNZN’s upgraded ships as soon as<br />

they complete their own modernisation process.<br />

The Regulus programme was originally conceived during a time<br />

of reduced sailing opportunities, when many Canadian ships were<br />

undergoing upgrades as part of the Halifax-Class Modernisation/<br />

Frigate Life Extension programme. Through Regulus, RCN sailors<br />

could participate in international exchanges with partner navies,<br />

enabling them to keep their skills sharp by working and training<br />

on board foreign vessels. In addition to helping sailors gain<br />

valuable practical knowledge, exchanges to foreign countries<br />

provide exposure to a wide range of diverse cultures.<br />

Above : L-R: New Zealand sailors AMT Vance Bell, AMT Robert<br />

Jackson, AMT Tomi Fataaiki and OMT Damon Dick-Carson work<br />

onboard HMCS Ottawa<br />

OUR PEOPLE<br />

25


Doing the Navy<br />

proud in Gisborne<br />

By Chris White<br />

A platoon of former and serving<br />

members of the New Zealand Navy<br />

paraded through the streets of<br />

Gisborne for Anzac Day 2016.<br />

26 ANZAC DAY IN GISBORNE


Retired gunnery instructors Jack Donnelly and Tony Lewis<br />

organised the Anzac weekend reunion to honour the<br />

Navy’s 75th year anniversary and support the city’s Anzac<br />

commemorations.<br />

“We were once again a ship’s company of many generations,”<br />

said Jack Donnelly, writing to the Gisborne Herald to thank RSA<br />

president Ben Tahuta and his committee for the trust, support and<br />

encouragement they gave the Navy veterans. “I was born and raised<br />

in Gisborne before joining the Navy, and to come home for this<br />

occasion was something very special. ‘He heramana ahau’.”<br />

The organising committee, including the RNO, Gisborne, LTCDR<br />

Tony Pereia, consulted with the RSA on how best to support the<br />

Anzac Day commemorations. They decided that the contingent<br />

would parade in three of Gisborne’s Anzac services: the Dawn<br />

Service, the 28th Maori Battalion memorial ceremony at Te Poho O<br />

Rawiri Marae, and the Civic Parade through the streets of Gisborne.<br />

More than 40 former and serving members of the Navy mustered<br />

and fell in before dawn on Anzac Day morning. The haunting and<br />

dull sound of the trench whistle, blown by Jack Donnelly, blew out<br />

– recollecting the Battle of the Somme in 1916, where it sounded<br />

before soldiers went ‘over the top’ to face the enemy in battle.<br />

Following on from the Dawn Service, the parade reformed outside<br />

the Te Poho O Rawiri Marae and marched onto the marae, ahead<br />

of the 28th Maori Battalion Memorial Service. After the service, a<br />

lovely hangi was served for breakfast in the meeting house. It was<br />

also a time for many songs and speeches.<br />

At the Civic Parade in Gisborne, the RNZN platoon − many wearing<br />

berets − gave three cheers to acknowledge the Anzacs and all men<br />

and women of every war, campaign and conflict. On 25 April 1915,<br />

as boats were lowered, readied and cast off for Anzac Cove, the<br />

sailors on HMS Prince of Wales ‘manned’ the guardrails and gave the<br />

soldiers in the boats three cheers by raising their caps and rotating<br />

them in a clockwise fashion, uttering a very subdued whisper.<br />

Chief Petty Officer Rawiri Barriball had drawn two beautiful taonga,<br />

which were presented to the Te Poho O Rawiri Marae and the<br />

Gisborne RSA from the RNZN. These were very gratefully received<br />

as a memento of Anzac 2016.<br />

The RNZN contingent was granted special permission by the Chief<br />

of Navy to parade the New Zealand White Ensign in Gisborne. A<br />

colour guard of former RNZN personnel paraded the ensign at the<br />

Dawn Service and later proudly led the Anzac Parade through the<br />

streets of Gisborne during the Civic Parade.<br />

The gathering at Gisborne in 2016 was a reunion for many, and an<br />

opportunity to share our common bond, as we marched together in<br />

the footsteps of our ancestors.<br />

ANZAC DAY IN GISBORNE<br />

27


Fostering<br />

The Anzac Spirit<br />

Online<br />

“<br />

Over recent years, there has been a growing interest from<br />

younger New Zealanders in learning more about their<br />

family military history,” says Rear Admiral (Rtd) Jack<br />

Steer. “This support is evident in the growing numbers attending<br />

services on Anzac Day and among those wearing poppies with<br />

pride. Many young New Zealanders are keen to know more about<br />

our war heritage and be connected with that and, through an RSA<br />

membership, where there will be a focus on engaging with our<br />

members online, they can be. It doesn’t matter if you’re 21 or 71<br />

years old – the new National Association enables you to be part of<br />

a force for good in New Zealand, that champions the Anzac spirit<br />

and everything it stands for.” – RADM Jack Steer is the National<br />

Association’s president. He is not able to visit his RSA Club, in<br />

Papanui, Christchurch, very often. So being part of the National<br />

Association “allows me to stay engaged with what I feel is a very<br />

worthwhile movement”.<br />

What is the new ‘National<br />

Association’ of the RSA?<br />

The National Association is an online RSA. Because it is online, all<br />

New Zealanders can join up and support the RSA, regardless of<br />

whether they live near an RSA Club, or have any family or service<br />

connections to the military. It will also allow service personnel<br />

without a permanent address to join and participate in the RSA.<br />

The National Association provides welfare for war veterans and<br />

their families, and assists with remembrance for New Zealand’s<br />

servicemen and women.<br />

How and why did it<br />

come about?<br />

RSA research showed that many people believed them needed to<br />

have served in the military, or have some service connection to join<br />

the RSA.<br />

Also, not everyone wants to join a local club; people want to be able<br />

to engage with their peers online, and that is what prompted the<br />

RSA to set up a National Association.<br />

New Zealanders from around the world can join the new National<br />

Association, via our website, and connect with our cause on an<br />

international scale.<br />

Why should people join?<br />

Everyone with an interest in the Anzac spirit, and the ideals of the<br />

RNZRSA, should join.<br />

Members also gain advice on support and benefits, discounts<br />

through the RSA network, and access to Returned and Services<br />

League (RSL) clubs in Australia. Members will be provided with an<br />

RSA Club Card, granting them exclusive benefits and deals with a<br />

range of quality, trusted brands. The benefits available through the<br />

Club Card are substantial.<br />

How do people sign up?<br />

Visit https://rsa.org.nz/join<br />

28 RSA


Reduce bias and<br />

make better decisions<br />

What is ‘unconscious bias’?<br />

‘Unconscious bias’ is the prejudice that no-one notices because it’s<br />

present everywhere. We might think we are being fair, yet the actions<br />

we take are based on preconceived beliefs, and have an unfair impact<br />

on certain people.<br />

Shortcut thinking<br />

Bias is ‘heuristic’ thinking: a ‘rough and ready’ way to make a decision,<br />

form a judgement, or solve a problem. When we are in a pressured or<br />

emergency situation, and under stress, we often ‘think fast’. Instead<br />

of using a process, and studying the information available, we use<br />

heuristics. We rely on the ‘status quo’, with a bias against anything<br />

new.<br />

Our brain is highly complicated, and capable of very sophisticated<br />

processing. But very arduous tasks, such as adjusting to change<br />

or understanding brand-new data, require significant cognitive<br />

power. Our brain will take shortcuts (heuristics) to save energy for<br />

really important, unavoidable tasks. Sometimes these shortcuts are<br />

effective and necessary, but sometimes they compromise the quality<br />

of our decisions.<br />

The brain needs to filter data; at any one time, 11 million pieces of data<br />

can be ‘picked up’, and yet our brains can only functionally deal with<br />

around 40 at any one time.<br />

Why are you seeing ‘your’ silver<br />

BMW 7-series car everywhere?<br />

For example, you’ve just decided to buy a new silver BMW 7-series<br />

car. You see this type of car everywhere: on the roads, on the internet,<br />

in advertisements. This is not necessarily because there suddenly<br />

are more BMW 7-series cars on the road, or in ads, but because your<br />

unconscious brain is focused on the car, so you pick it up.<br />

Our brain filters the evidence we collect; in general, it supports<br />

our existing point of view and disproves the point of view that we<br />

disagree with.<br />

As a result of these filters, we see, hear, and interpret things<br />

differently than other people might, or we might not even see them at<br />

all. Of those 11 million pieces of information, we see what we want to<br />

see, and we believe that what we see is reality. Seeing is believing, but<br />

believing is seeing!<br />

Only occasionally do we realise how subjective those determinations<br />

are and how much they are affected not by what is in front of us, but<br />

by what we interpret is front of us, filtered through our own lens on<br />

the world.<br />

Why is it important that we<br />

address unconscious bias in<br />

the NZDF?<br />

Some decisions and actions taken in the NZDF are affected by<br />

unconscious bias. This has a negative effect on people and how they<br />

are treated, and on organisational decisions.<br />

Types of bias:<br />

• Stereotyping is making assumptions or judgments about people,<br />

groups or religions or any other characteristics that have become<br />

‘common knowledge’.<br />

• ‘Like me’ bias is a natural bias in favour of people we know well,<br />

and who are like us. We favour them as we think they are like us,<br />

and we assume that we share common attributes, values or traits.<br />

• Selective bias is searching for and focusing on information that<br />

confirms your own views and opinions.<br />

• Judgmental bias is where minority groups are systematically less<br />

well rated for technical or leadership roles, even when they have<br />

the same performance records and qualifications.<br />

• Filtering bias is when you ‘scrutinise’ everything, ignoring<br />

information that doesn’t fit with your beliefs and expectations.<br />

• Backlash bias is when a person behaves in a way that is not<br />

consistent with the stereotype held by the group and the person is<br />

rated less competent because of it.<br />

What you can do about it<br />

Reduce your bias: discover what your biases are, and be conscious of<br />

how they affect your decisions. Challenge the thinking or behaviour<br />

of others. And test yourself. Go to: https://implicit.harvard.edu and<br />

Google workshops https://library.gv.com/unconscious-bias-at-work-<br />

22e698e9b2d#.8s2lral7b<br />

Also, use these tools to reduce opportunities for unconscious bias:<br />

• slow down your thinking: listen, reflect, take notes<br />

• use checklists/use analytical tools; eg, SWAT/ask questions<br />

• run well-structured, inclusive meetings<br />

• question your own assumptions and conclusions<br />

• take rest breaks<br />

• maintain structured and formalised processes<br />

• build rapport<br />

• diversify your ‘go-to’ people<br />

• be interested in people<br />

• be disciplined in allocating projects<br />

• look for similarities and connections<br />

• watch for overconfidence<br />

• introduce a ‘Devil’s advocate/black-hat thinker’<br />

• drop the ‘un’ in unconscious, to make your actions conscious<br />

• acknowledge your own bias<br />

• check what bias you have using the Harvard Business School<br />

implicit association test<br />

• use ‘round robins’ when looking at situations<br />

• use peer/360 review<br />

• seek contrary data<br />

• encourage different points of views<br />

• as a leader, hold others accountable<br />

• identify and change own habits, and<br />

• develop your knowledge of different cultures, religions, lifestyle<br />

preferences.<br />

unconscious bias<br />

29


Connect through<br />

The Hub<br />

What?<br />

The Hub is a collaboration tool for NZDF personnel. It has<br />

features similar to social media; for example, users can ‘like’,<br />

share and comment on other members’ posts, questions or polls.<br />

How?<br />

The Hub is ‘unclassified’, and is accessible via personal laptops<br />

and smart devices. It provides users with access to Defence<br />

Force news, events, announcements and unit training tailored<br />

for you based on your service and unit. Beyond being able<br />

to post and share content, you can create and join groups of<br />

interest or you can create your own.<br />

Who?<br />

The Hub is for current and released NZDF military members and<br />

civilian employees, as well as ‘trusted partners’ of the NZDF.<br />

Did you say mobile?<br />

Once you have logged in and created your profile on a computer,<br />

you can download the mobile application from the Apple Store<br />

or Google Play, allowing you 24/7 access from anywhere around<br />

the world.<br />

Still confused what ‘The Hub’ is?<br />

It’s cool; search the keyword ‘learn’ and select the topic ‘learn’<br />

to see a number of short video clips, including ‘Getting Started’,<br />

‘Chatter’ or ‘Groups’; there are others too, if you’re super keen.<br />

To signup<br />

Visit ‘http://TheHub’ on DIXS or find us under ‘quicklinks’<br />

on the ILP by looking for ‘The Hub’.<br />

Are you on<br />

The Hub?<br />

Visit http://thehub on DIXS<br />

30 mcc THE HUB log


Whangaparaoa’s<br />

mainland island sanctuary<br />

By Anne Lightfoot, Environmental Officer (Northern), Environmental Services, Defence Property Group<br />

In the five years since the NZDF’s Tamaki Leadership Centre<br />

became part of an ‘open sanctuary’, possums, stoats and rats<br />

have been successfully eradicated, protecting the centre’s rare<br />

and at-risk native species.<br />

In 2011, a 1.7km-long, pest-proof fence across the entire width of the<br />

Whangaparaoa Peninsula, from Army Bay to Okoromai Bay, was<br />

built, creating the ‘Shakespear Open Sanctuary’. Of the 500-hectare<br />

enclosed space, NZDF occupies 130 hectares.<br />

The aim of an open sanctuary is to support New Zealand’s native<br />

and endemic species to make their home and breed on the mainland<br />

in a predator-free environment.<br />

The concept for the sanctuary was first proposed by Auckland<br />

Council in 2006. Its position on the mainland, at the end of a<br />

peninsula and with Tiritiri Matangi Island just across the Tiri<br />

Channel, makes it ideal as a pest-free area.<br />

The NZDF had already identified a number of rare and ‘at-risk’<br />

species inhabiting the centre, including the moko skink, Auckland<br />

green gecko and ornate skink, as well as some rare plants, and rare<br />

sea and land bird species.<br />

In 2010, the NZDF signed a Memorandum of Understanding<br />

with the Auckland Council, making a long-term commitment to<br />

maintaining the sanctuary, and helping it become pest free.<br />

Since then, possums, stoats and rats have all been successfully<br />

eradicated from the sanctuary. (Although you might still spot the<br />

odd cat chasing a mouse!) As a result, many birds have naturally<br />

inhabited the sanctuary. Other bird species have also been<br />

introduced, including the pōpokatea (whitehead) in mid-2015 and<br />

the toutouwai (North Island robin) this year. The pukupuku (little<br />

spotted kiwi) will be released in April 2017.<br />

The 9.2-inch battery is one of most suitable locations for these bird<br />

releases. Behind the 100m range, solar-powered speakers broadcast<br />

night-time calls of grey-faced and diving petrels, as well as fluttering<br />

shearwaters. This successful seabird attraction project has been<br />

underway for the past year.<br />

New Zealand native and endemic species face significant challenges<br />

outside the sanctuary fence. However, it is hoped that species from<br />

the sanctuary will migrate to other inland areas and establish their<br />

home, thereby increasing the biodiversity and habitat connection<br />

within Auckland and beyond.<br />

Since the beginning, the Shakespear Open Sanctuary management<br />

has been a collaborative approach between Auckland Council park<br />

rangers and NZDF personnel. Other project partners include other<br />

landowners (YMCA and Watercare), iwi, and the Shakespear Open<br />

Sanctuary Society.<br />

There have also been a number of planting days and conservation<br />

programmes running at the sanctuary, giving local school groups<br />

and other community groups a chance to get their hands dirty.<br />

Much of the monitoring and pest mammal control work at the<br />

sanctuary is undertaken by volunteers and council staff, facilitated<br />

by either council park rangers or by the Shakespear Open Sanctuary<br />

Society. NZDF personnel, including Navy range managers and the<br />

NZDF Defence Property Group Environmental Services, as well<br />

as the Northern Facilities Management contractor, PAE NZ, also<br />

play their part, in the ‘Shakespear Open Sanctuary Society working<br />

group’. The working group manages comprehensive pest plant<br />

control programmes on NZDF land and supports council staff when<br />

they are on NZDF land. The Navy Base Operations Unit also plays<br />

a significant role in an ongoing wilding pine removal programme at<br />

the Tamaki Leadership Centre.<br />

The Shakespear Open Sanctuary’s success can be attributed to<br />

the strong working relationship between stakeholders, and their<br />

respect for one another’s operational requirements. Given the type<br />

of occupants within the sanctuary, it is quite unique compared with<br />

other open sanctuaries around the country!<br />

But, in many ways, NZDF land is ideal for an open sanctuary, given<br />

the limited number of people and domestic animals that enter<br />

Tamaki Leadership Centre’s extensive bush-clad areas.<br />

If you are interested in getting involved with the sanctuary, please<br />

contact Defence Property Group Environmental Services.<br />

Top Left: First fluttering shearwater (and nesting) identified within SOS,<br />

on NZDF land located at Huroa Point (behind the 100m Range). It is very<br />

rare on the mainland<br />

Top right: Pacific gecko, resides on NZDF land<br />

sanctuary<br />

31


Above: David Grinlinton is pictured with syndicate DS Captain Kenneth<br />

Stewart (RCN Ret.)<br />

Officer<br />

graduates in<br />

Canada<br />

Lieutenant Commander David Grinlinton, RNZNVR, graduated<br />

from the Canadian Forces Joint Command Staff and Staff Program<br />

(JCSP) at the Canadian Forces College in Toronto. The two-year<br />

programme of study and exercises involves distance learning and<br />

two residential exercises in Canada. While primarily for officers in<br />

the Canadian Forces, some officers from other nations, including<br />

the US, Australia, New Zealand and NATO, also attended the<br />

programme. The qualification means officers are professionally<br />

staff-qualified to Canadian Forces’ standards.<br />

Jutland artefacts<br />

arrive in UK<br />

The ‘lucky charm’ of HMS NEW ZEALAND – a traditional<br />

flax piupiu worn by the ship’s captain during the Battle of<br />

Jutland – along with its bell hanger, honours board, and the<br />

HMS QUEEN MARY ring bolt – were welcomed into the National<br />

Museum of the Royal Navy in Portsmouth, England, during May.<br />

The artefacts will form part of the Royal Navy’s exhibition, “36<br />

Hours: Jutland 1916, the battle that won the war”, which opened to<br />

the public on 18 May.<br />

Ngati Ranana welcomed the artefacts to the UK with karakia and<br />

waiata. The National Museum of the Royal Navy staff said they<br />

were “blown away” to see the artefacts first hand. In particular, they<br />

noted the ‘presence’ of the piupiu.<br />

The piupiu was gifted to the Commanding Officer of HMS NEW<br />

ZEALAND, Captain Halsey (Royal Navy) by a Maori chief in 1913.<br />

At the time, the chief made three prophecies: that the ship would<br />

be involved in three sea battles, the ship would be hit only once,<br />

and that no one on board would be killed. The chief requested that<br />

Halsey wear the piupiu in battle to protect the ship and crew.<br />

On 28 August 1914, HMS New Zealand went into action in the battle<br />

of Heligoland Bight. Halsey donned the piupiu over his uniform and,<br />

recalling later: “Officers and men who were in the Conning Tower…<br />

were so startled at seeing me in this extraordinary clothing that<br />

they appeared to be quite incapable of carrying on with their very<br />

important personal duties and I had quickly to explain why I was<br />

thus attired.” The ship was not damaged or hit during this action.<br />

Halsey wore the piupiu again at Dogger Bank on 24 January 1915.<br />

Before the action he “got many messages from all over the ship<br />

hoping that the [piupiu] was again going to be worn”. Once more,<br />

although the ship came under heavy fire, it was never hit.<br />

In May 1915, when Halsey was promoted and appointed to another<br />

ship, he passed the piupiu to his successor on HMS NEW ZEALAND,<br />

Captain J. Green. CAPT Green agreed to wear the piupiu into action,<br />

which he did during the Battle of Jutland on 31 May 1916. Again, the<br />

ship came under heavy fire but was hit only once, sustaining minor<br />

damage and no casualties. The piupiu remained on board the ship<br />

until the surrender of the German fleet in 1918.<br />

The piece of ring bolt from HMS QUEEN MARY landed on the<br />

quarterdeck of HMS NEW ZEALAND when QUEEN MARY blew up<br />

during the Battle of Jutland. The battle honours board was made to<br />

mark HMS NEW ZEALAND’s participation at the Battle of Jutland in<br />

May 1916.<br />

32 mcc NEWSlog


Learning from the<br />

maritime industry<br />

By LT Leander Scott-Donelan<br />

CPOMTO Nigel McFadyen and OMTO Jess McShane boarded<br />

MV SOOCHOW in March for an overnight passage from<br />

Auckland to Tauranga.<br />

The passage gave the Maritime Trade Operation personnel,<br />

from HMNZS Ngapona VR, the chance to learn from the Master<br />

and crew, by participating in and observing all aspects of the<br />

vessel’s operation.<br />

The Maritime Trade Operation provides a link between the<br />

RNZN and the civilian maritime industry.<br />

CPOMTO McFadyen focused on obtaining information on the<br />

technical details of MV SOOCHOW. OMTO McShane was able<br />

to shadow bridge watch keepers and, under supervision, was<br />

involved in tasks such as assisting with passage planning and<br />

updating navigational plots using the ship’s radar. They were<br />

also able to introduce and explain the role of the Maritime<br />

Trade Operation to the ship’s Master and officers.<br />

The ship’s company was welcoming and highly cooperative,<br />

which made for a smooth transition into the ship’s routine,<br />

in a very short period of time. The voyage provided a glimpse<br />

into the numerous areas of expertise required to be proficient<br />

on board this type of vessel; indeed, a high degree of<br />

professionalism, ethics and a strong health and safety culture<br />

was demonstrated at all times. The passage was an excellent<br />

opportunity to build relationships with the civilian maritime<br />

industry, and learn from it.<br />

Gearing up<br />

for Census16<br />

Our first ever NZDF engagement survey, known as ‘the<br />

Census’, was launched a year ago.<br />

This year’s Census is fast approaching. In late July, we will be<br />

asking you to complete the Census16 survey. As this is our<br />

full engagement survey, it is longer than the short Pulse16<br />

survey completed in April.<br />

Engagement scores are important because, among other<br />

things, they measure two things of concern to us: the<br />

performance of our leaders and people, and our people’s<br />

wellbeing. These are paramount for everyone who works in<br />

the NZDF, given that we are proud of ‘punching above our<br />

weight’, and also caring for our people.<br />

Census16<br />

WHAT<br />

WHY<br />

WHO<br />

WHEN<br />

HOW<br />

The Census16 survey measures how we’re<br />

performing as a Defence Force. It takes<br />

around 15−20 minutes to complete.<br />

To gather information that will help NZDF<br />

build an even better workplace, improve<br />

the working lives of personnel, and further<br />

increase our ability to provide a Force for NZ.<br />

Census16 is for ALL who work at the NZDF,<br />

including Reserves and those who are<br />

deployed.<br />

Census16 will run in late July for<br />

TWO weeks.<br />

For Regular Force and civilians the survey<br />

will be online and a link will be emailed to all<br />

members/employees. Hard copies will also<br />

be sent out to camps and bases for people<br />

who may not have access to a Defence<br />

computer, including people on an exercise<br />

or those who are deployed. For Reserves,<br />

the survey will be advertised on The Hub<br />

and completed via direct email.<br />

RESULTS<br />

We expect the reports to be made<br />

available for all NZDF personnel in early<br />

September.<br />

our people NEWS<br />

33


Jutland – the<br />

Unfinished Battle: a<br />

Personal History of a<br />

Naval Controversy<br />

By Nicholas Jellicoe<br />

Seaforth Publishing,<br />

UK, 2016<br />

ISBN: 9781848323216<br />

Voices from Jutland:<br />

A Centenary<br />

Commemoration<br />

By Jim Crossley<br />

Pen & Sword Maritime,<br />

UK, 2016<br />

ISBN: 9781473823716<br />

The Hidden Threat;<br />

The Story of Mines and<br />

Minesweeping by the<br />

Royal Navy in World War 1<br />

By Jim Crossley<br />

Pen & Sword Maritime<br />

South Yorkshire, UK<br />

2011<br />

ISBN: 9781848842724<br />

The Jutland Scandal:<br />

The Truth About the<br />

First World War’s<br />

Greatest Sea Battle<br />

By Admiral Bacon, Vice<br />

Admiral Harper<br />

Frontline Books, UK, 2016<br />

ISBN: 9781848329379<br />

Jutland: The Naval Staff<br />

Appreciation<br />

By William Schleihauf<br />

Seaforth Publishing, UK,<br />

2016<br />

ISBN: 9781848323179<br />

Fighting the Great War at<br />

Sea: Strategy, Tactics and<br />

Technology<br />

By Norman Friedman<br />

Seaforth Publishing, UK,<br />

2014<br />

ISBN: 9781848321892<br />

The Great War at sea<br />

– Battle of Jutland remembered<br />

By CDR Richard Jackson RNZN (Rtd)<br />

After the Battle of Jutland, controversy<br />

arose because the Germans (the High<br />

Seas Fleet was the first to reach home)<br />

won the opening propaganda campaign. Then,<br />

immediately after the War, when Beatty was<br />

appointed First Sea Lord, he suppressed the<br />

Admiralty’s assessment of the battle (written by<br />

then Captain John Ernest Troyte Harper, a New<br />

Zealander in the Royal Navy) because it showed<br />

up mistakes that Beatty had made on the day.<br />

Thus, the Royal Navy became split between<br />

Jellicoe loyalists and Beatty supporters.<br />

That split is evident in some of the many books<br />

subsequently written about the battle. But<br />

now, a century on, authors are able to take a<br />

less biased view of the battle. And note that a<br />

website, Jutland1916.com, is well worth a visit.<br />

Admiral Jellicoe’s grandson Nicholas Jellicoe<br />

has written Jutland – The Unfinished Battle: A<br />

Personal History of a Naval Controversy. His book<br />

tells the story of the battle from both British<br />

and German perspectives, based on the latest<br />

research, and sets the context of Germany’s<br />

inevitable naval clash with Britain.<br />

The author then traces the bitter dispute that<br />

became known as the ‘Jutland Controversy’<br />

which ensued in the years after the war; young<br />

Jellicoe is very even-handed in his account. This<br />

book gives an excellent account of the battle,<br />

overall, and is recommended.<br />

Jim Crossley, in Voices From Jutland: A Centenary<br />

Commemoration, examines the strengths<br />

and weaknesses of both navies and identifies<br />

some of the reasons for the disappointing<br />

performance of the Royal Navy in the battle.<br />

Crossley argues that the building of the High<br />

Seas Fleet was a strategic blunder on the part<br />

of the Germans, who could have forced Britain<br />

out of the war completely if they had instead<br />

concentrated on their submarine fleet and on<br />

mine-laying.<br />

The Jutland Scandal: The Truth About the First<br />

World War’s Greatest Sea Battle by Admirals<br />

Bacon and Harper is a fresh presentation of two<br />

books first published in the 1920s. Vice Admiral<br />

Harper wrote his personal account after his<br />

Admiralty-approved analysis was suppressed;<br />

Admiral Bacon wrote his after various London<br />

newspapers and Winston Churchill had sided<br />

with Beatty. Both accounts include useful maps<br />

to illustrate the tactical questions that arose.<br />

This volume is for the specialist wishing to<br />

read more deeply into the battle.<br />

Jutland: The Naval Staff Appreciation was<br />

originally written after Harper’s objective<br />

record was delayed and heavily censored.<br />

The Appreciation was a more ambitious<br />

scheme to write a no-holds-barred critique<br />

of the fleet’s performance for use in training<br />

future officers at the Naval Staff College.<br />

But it was written by two Beatty supporters<br />

with a now-obvious bias. The Naval Staff<br />

Appreciation was eventually deemed too<br />

damaging, and its publication cancelled with<br />

all proof copies ordered to be destroyed.<br />

However, despite the orders, a few copies<br />

survived and, transcribed from one of them,<br />

this long-hidden work is now published, but<br />

with an expert modern commentary and<br />

explanatory notes to put it in proper context.<br />

Norman Friedman is a recognised authority<br />

on the strategic, technical, and tactical<br />

aspects of the maritime environment, and<br />

in Fighting the Great War at Sea: Strategy,<br />

Tactics and Technology, he presents a fresh<br />

perspective of the naval side of WWI. While<br />

the focal point of the war was in northeastern<br />

France, the global impact of the war<br />

arose from its maritime character. Allied<br />

troops reached France by sea, and were<br />

sustained by allied shipping. Both France<br />

and the British needed access to American<br />

industry; when the Germans could not reach<br />

US resources themselves, they deployed<br />

their U-boats to deny that access to the<br />

British.<br />

Friedman takes a fresh look at the ways each<br />

side tried to gain command of the sea in<br />

what proved to be a four-year campaign. He<br />

describes the rapid wartime changes in ship<br />

and weapon technology: mines, torpedoes<br />

and aircraft – and in the way naval warfare<br />

was fought, the tactical practices and<br />

changes to command and control.<br />

As with many of Friedman’s books, the<br />

extensive and informative captions to the<br />

many well-chosen photos are essential<br />

reading, along with the main narrative. This<br />

book is highly recommended.<br />

34<br />

Book reviews


Wellington Returned and Services Association Needs You<br />

The WRSA was established 100 years ago. Since then it has served the<br />

Wellington region’s returned and service people and their families.<br />

The WRSA is financially very stable and currently served by a lot of<br />

dedicated ex service and associated people. To ensure it continues to<br />

provide both social and other support to all service people and their<br />

families fresh blood is needed on their Executive Committee. If you<br />

are interested in continuing the traditions of the Services and RSAs,<br />

that is support to all service people and their families, why don’t you<br />

join? Please contact Ron Turner QSM JO, President WRSA by email at<br />

rjturner@clear.net.nz or by phone at 04 38511910 or 274 478138<br />

Retrospect, a history conference celebrating RNZN’s 75th Anniversary<br />

Hosted by the Navy League of New Zealand (Wellington branch) and<br />

the Maritime Friends of New Zealand.<br />

Where: HMNZS Olphert, 34 Waione Street, Petone, Wellington<br />

When: 18 June 2016, 09:00–17:00<br />

Topics covered: HMS Neptune; HMNZS Leander; hydrography; women<br />

in the RNZN; Wellington Harbour (1939−45); RNZN in the Korean War;<br />

Dido Class Cruisers<br />

Further details: 027 4459 590 or rob.martin@nz.ey.com<br />

Cost: $55, or $30 concession<br />

All Ships Reunion celebrating HMNZS BLACKPOOL 50th Anniversary<br />

and HMNZS ROYALIST 60th Anniversary<br />

This will be held in New Plymouth on the weekend of Friday 15 to<br />

Monday 18 July 2016. Details still to be finalised but application forms<br />

can be applied for now. They will be sent when full programme is<br />

completed. Contact Trevor Wylde, 146A Ngamotu Road, Spotswood,<br />

New Plymouth 4310. Phone/fax (06) 7515595, mobile 0274 844587, email<br />

trevor.cherryl@xtra.co.nz<br />

MAY 1977 Intake 40 year Reunion<br />

Auckland May 26 to 28 2017, venue TBA<br />

All BCTs, WRNZNs, instructors and divisional officers who enlisted in or<br />

were involved with this 1977 intake 40 years ago. Please contact either<br />

Norm Harding georgenormharding@gmail.com<br />

or John Leefe j_leefe@me.com<br />

MAY 1977 Intake 40 year Reunion Auckland May 26 to 28 2017,<br />

venue TBA<br />

All BCTs, WRNZNs, instructors and divisional officers who enlisted in or<br />

were involved with this 1977 intake 40 years ago. Please contact either<br />

Norm Harding georgenormharding@gmail.com or John Leefe j_leefe@<br />

me.com<br />

Royal Naval Engineers' Benevolent Society 2018 celebration<br />

150th Anniversary of the Introduction of Artificers into the Royal Navy<br />

in 1868<br />

We are organising a UK event to celebrate the Introduction of Artificers<br />

into the Royal Navy in 1868. RNZN Artificers welcome. Contact Cliff<br />

Fiander, 33 Goldfinch Road, Melksham, Wiltshire SN12 7FL UK, email<br />

cliff.fiander@mail.com<br />

New Zealand Defence Industry Association (NZDIA) Annual Forum<br />

Where: Viaduct Events Centre, Auckland, New Zealand<br />

Dates: 16-17 November 2016<br />

Theme: Shaping the next 75 years – Investing in New Zealand’s<br />

Future Security<br />

Attending will be senior members of the NZ Defence Force, Ministry<br />

of Defence, Industry, Government and International Delegations. This<br />

year’s forum is timed to coincide with the 75th Anniversary Celebrations<br />

of the Royal New Zealand Navy. Please plan early to attend and be part<br />

of this important event.<br />

Further details: www.nzdia.co.nz<br />

Email: contact@nzdia.co.nz<br />

Selected RNZN<br />

rank abbreviations<br />

RADM: Rear Admiral<br />

CDRE: Commodore<br />

CAPT: Captain<br />

CDR: Commander<br />

LT CDR: Lieutenant Commander<br />

LT: Lieutenant<br />

SLT: Sub Lieutenant<br />

ENS: Ensign<br />

MID: Midshipman<br />

WOCH: Warrant Officer Chef<br />

WOMED: Warrant Officer Medic<br />

CPOWTR: Chief Petty Officer Writer<br />

CPOEWS: Chief Petty Officer Electronic Warfare Specialist<br />

POPTI: Petty Officer Physical Training Instructor<br />

POCSS: Petty Officer Combat System Specialist<br />

LSCS: Leading Seamanship Combat Specialist<br />

LSA: Leading Stores Accountant<br />

LMT (P): Leading Marine Technician (Propulsion)<br />

AMUS: Able Musician<br />

ADR: Able Diver<br />

AHLM: Able Helicopter Load Master<br />

OSTD: Ordinary Steward<br />

OMT (L): Ordinary Marine Technician (Electrical)<br />

OCWS: Ordinary Communications Warfare Specialist<br />

Jackspeak—Navy slang<br />

Adrift: Late for work<br />

Blubber: Cry, the word originates from the whaling days:<br />

globules of fat dripped down the carcass during flensing,<br />

resembling teardrops<br />

Gardening: The process of aerial mine-laying during<br />

World War Two; the aircraft involved were ‘sowing<br />

cucumbers’ into the sea.<br />

Hardly out of the egg: A very inexperienced<br />

individual.<br />

Jetsam: Cargo, stores, equipment, etc, which has been<br />

deliberately thrown overboard (jettisoned) to lighten the<br />

ship in a survival situation, but remains the property of the<br />

owner.<br />

Oppo: A friend in a ship; they are on watch when you are<br />

off. Derives from “opposite number”.<br />

Poet’s day: An alternative name for Friday, derived from<br />

the first letters of ‘piss off early – tomorrow’s Saturday!’<br />

Space cadet: Young officer who thinks he or she is<br />

captain of the universe.<br />

Toybox: The engine room.<br />

Wrinkle: Shortcut<br />

our notices people<br />

35


JUN–AUG 2016<br />

64 King Edward ParadE<br />

dEvonPort<br />

10am to 5Pm, sEvEn days<br />

FrEE admission<br />

Westpac presents<br />

30 years of<br />

Women at Sea<br />

During June 2016, we celebrate the courage,<br />

commitment and comradeship of our past and<br />

current Naval women.<br />

In 1986<br />

10.1%<br />

Women in the Navy<br />

In 2016<br />

22.2%<br />

Women in the Navy<br />

In 1986, the Royal New Zealand<br />

Navy commenced a trial of<br />

women at sea onboard HMNZS<br />

MONOWAI. There were 14 women<br />

that participated; 13 ratings and<br />

one officer. In posting onboard,<br />

they had the opportunity to work<br />

in each department during the<br />

trial. It was the first time that<br />

women posted to sea as part of<br />

the regular crew, albeit on a noncombatant<br />

ship.<br />

In 1989, Navy Order 35/1989<br />

authorised the permanent<br />

employment of women at sea in<br />

the RNZN. All women entering the<br />

RNZN from January 1989 intake<br />

would be required to serve at sea<br />

except those in a limited number<br />

of shore only trades.<br />

Today, women operate onboard<br />

each of the RNZN’s 11 warships,<br />

performing roles from warfare<br />

officer, to electronics technician,<br />

chef to engineer.<br />

Since women have been integrated<br />

within ships crews they now have<br />

the ability to progress through<br />

all trades and ranks within the<br />

service alongside our servicemen.<br />

With greater career options more<br />

women are joining and staying<br />

longer than ever before and better<br />

reflecting the nation we represent.<br />

presentInG partner, OperatIOn neptUne<br />

www.navymuseum.co.nz www.navy.mil.nz www.nznavy75.co.nz<br />

36

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!