25.03.2016 Views

The Gentile Times Reconsidered Chronology Christ

An historical and biblical refutation of 1914, a favorite year of Jehovah's Witnesses and other Bible Students. By Carl Olof Jonsson.

An historical and biblical refutation of 1914, a favorite year of Jehovah's Witnesses and other Bible Students. By Carl Olof Jonsson.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Furuli’s Second Book 495<br />

Furuli’s date: Addaru 7 = 30 March 587 BCE:<br />

Furuli’s date for Addaru 7 is 30 March 587 BCE. He states that Cancer in that night “was 4 o<br />

above the moon and α Leonis was 13 o below the moon.” However, Cancer was not above<br />

but in front of (west of) the moon, and α Leonis was not below but behind (east of) the moon.<br />

But as this lunar position was nearly the same as on 20/21 March, 567 BCE, both positions<br />

fit.<br />

(13) ´Rev. line 16: “<strong>The</strong> 12 th , one god was seen with the other; sunrise to moonset: 1 o 30´ [6<br />

minutes]; ….”<br />

Addaru 12 = 25/26 March 567 BCE:<br />

In 567 BCE the 12 th of Addaru fell on 25/26 March. According to the tablet sunrise<br />

occurred 1 o 30´ – 6 minutes – before moonset, meaning that one “god” could be “seen with<br />

the other” in the morning for six minutes. My astro-program shows that in the morning of<br />

March 26 the sun rose at c. 06:08 and the moon set c. 06:11, that is, they could both be seen<br />

at the same time above the horizon for about 3 minutes, which is close to the time given on<br />

the tablet.<br />

Furuli’s date: Addaru 12 = 4/5 April 587 BCE:<br />

Furuli has misunderstood the kind of phenomenon referred to by the expression “one god<br />

was seen with the other”. He explains on page 323: “To say that one god (the sun) was seen<br />

with the other god (the moon) was one way to express that the moon was full.”<br />

Although it is true that the moon was nearly full when it was seen with the sun, this is not<br />

exactly what the expression refers to. As explained earlier, it refers to the situation when the<br />

sun and the moon stand in opposition to each other – the sun in the east and the moon in<br />

the west – and both can be seen simultaneously above the horizon for a short period of time. As Furuli<br />

has not understood this, his comments on the text are mistaken and irrelevant.<br />

Furuli’s date for the 12 th of Addaru is 4/5 April 587 BCE. In the morning of April 5 the sun<br />

rose at c. 05:54. But the moon had already set at c. 05:13, i.e., about 41 minutes before<br />

sunrise. Thus one “god” could not be seen “with the other” this morning. Furuli’s date,<br />

then, is wrong. Only the 567 BCE date fits the statement on the tablet.<br />

In summary, at least 10 of the 13 lunar positions examined fit the 568/567 BCE date quite<br />

well, one (no. 10) is acceptable, while two (nos. 2 and 5) are acceptable only if the dates are<br />

moved back one day. Of Furuli’s dates in 588/587 BCE only one (no. 12) fits, while 9 do<br />

not fit at all. <strong>The</strong> fits of the remaining three (9, 10, and 11) are far from good but acceptable.<br />

<strong>The</strong> conclusion is, that the observations were made in 568/567<br />

BCE. <strong>The</strong> year 588/587 BCE is definitely out of the question.<br />

Part II: <strong>The</strong> Saturn Tablet BM 76738 + BM 76813<br />

<strong>The</strong> Saturn Tablet consists of two broken pieces, BM 76738 + BM 76813. It contains a list<br />

of last and first appearances of Saturn for a period of 14 successive years, namely, the first<br />

14 years of the Babylonian king Kandalanu, whose 22 years of reign is generally dated to 647<br />

– 626 BCE. As the examination below will demonstrate, the Saturn Tablet alone is sufficient<br />

for establishing the absolute chronology of the first 14 years of his reign. Every attempt by<br />

the Watchtower Society and its apologists to add 20 years to the Neo-Babylonian<br />

chronology is effectively blocked by this tablet.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Watchtower apologist Rolf Furuli in Oslo, Norway, strains every nerve to get rid of the<br />

evidence provided by this tablet in his new volume on chronology, Assyrian, Babylonian and<br />

Egyptian <strong>Chronology</strong> (Oslo: Awatu Publishers, 2007). <strong>The</strong> Watchtower Society’s chronology,<br />

renamed by Furuli the “Oslo <strong>Chronology</strong>”, requires that Nebuchadnezzar’s 18 th year, in<br />

which he desolated Jerusalem, is dated to 607 instead of 587 BCE. This would also move his<br />

father Nabopolassar’s 21-year reign 20 years backwards in time, from 625-605 to 645-625.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!