15.03.2016 Views

Truckload Authority - Spring 2015

Meet new TCA Chairman Keith Tuttle! Plus, we take an in-depth look at the emergence of the SuperTruck and how technology is changing trucking. Also, get important updates on ELDs, speed limiters, and much more!

Meet new TCA Chairman Keith Tuttle! Plus, we take an in-depth look at the emergence of the SuperTruck and how technology is changing trucking. Also, get important updates on ELDs, speed limiters, and much more!

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

est fleets to drive for winners | safest fleets | drivers of the year<br />

O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N o f t h e T r U C k L O A d C a r r i e r s A s s O C I A T I O N<br />

spring <strong>2015</strong><br />

Happy<br />

Warrior<br />

With Chairman Keith Tuttle


KEEP YOUR BUSINESS IN IT FOR THE LONG<br />

HAUL WITH SHELL LUBRICANTS SERVICES.<br />

Protect your business with the proven performance of Shell Lubricants and our wide portfolio of business and<br />

maintenance services. Maximizing fl eet uptime and minimizing operation costs is key for your success. That’s<br />

why we work with our customers to deliver the products and services that can adapt to the ever-changing<br />

maintenance and lubrication requirements of fl eets.<br />

Shell LubeAnalyst helps you monitor your equipment performance<br />

Shell LubeMatch offers recommendations for optimized lubrication<br />

Shell LubeVideoCheck allows assessment of your internal engine condition<br />

Shell LubeExpert provides on-site application support and inspections<br />

Ask your Shell Lubricants Representative for more information on a customized product-and-service recommendation<br />

for your equipment. Contact us today at 1-800-231-6950 or visit us online at www.rotella.com<br />

THE ENGINE OIL THAT<br />

WORKS AS HARD AS YOU.


<strong>Spring</strong> | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

President’s Purview<br />

New Directions and<br />

New Beginnings<br />

As I write this column, I am happy to report that spring has (almost) sprung in Washington,<br />

DC. Having survived my first winter in the nation’s capital, I will admit it couldn’t get here soon<br />

enough for me.<br />

Those comments aren’t simply because of the extra daylight and warmer temperatures that<br />

spring provides. To me, spring symbolizes the season of new growth and the signs of change all<br />

around. It is also seen more generally as the start of better times — the time of year when we begin<br />

to feel less sluggish and become more open to inviting changes into our lives and businesses.<br />

The symbolism of spring is one most people can appreciate. There are cultural traditions<br />

worldwide that celebrate rebirth and new beginnings. Whether it is Easter or various festivals,<br />

springtime itself is a season that never seems to go unmarked.<br />

For Washingtonians, spring is usually ushered in by the National Cherry Blossom Festival,<br />

which celebrates the gift of cherry blossom trees and the enduring friendship between the people<br />

of the United States and Japan. In the trade association world, spring is also a time for meetings<br />

and conventions for most groups.<br />

The <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association just wrapped up our 77th Annual Convention with a<br />

theme of New Directions: Setting The Course, where we outlined our roadmap for the future.<br />

If you missed the celebration and camaraderie in Orlando last month, you can still access the<br />

content. All of the sessions were recorded and are available on our <strong>Truckload</strong> Academy On Demand.<br />

To download the recordings, simply go to truckoad.org/TAO.<br />

Festivals in general are a call to positive thinking, and TCA’s Annual Convention was certainly<br />

not an exception to that rule. One of the key elements of positive psychology is optimism,<br />

and six months into this position as TCA president I am more optimistic than ever about the<br />

direction of our association.<br />

We have unveiled new image programs, are involved in a negotiated rulemaking on entry-level<br />

driver training, and have resurrected our Young Transportation Executive program to<br />

groom the next generation of TCA leaders.<br />

Many of our efforts are highlighted in this issue of <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> magazine. In the<br />

pages that follow, you can also learn more about our new chairman, Keith Tuttle of Motor Carrier<br />

Service.<br />

Ultimately spring is all about opportunity — a time for strengthening the belief in ourselves<br />

and our powers to achieve and overcome obstacles — and I know Chairman Tuttle is up for the<br />

challenges that TCA faces.<br />

As the days grow longer, I can assure you they will be filled with a newfound commitment<br />

from me and the TCA staff and officers in providing more value for our members to grow the<br />

association. My hope is that these efforts can be built on throughout the year, and I look forward<br />

to writing about them in future issues of <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>.<br />

Brad Bentley<br />

President<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association<br />

bbentley@truckload.org<br />

Brad Bentley<br />

PRESIDENT’S PICKS<br />

®<br />

Capitol Recap<br />

Updates on the 34-hour restart,<br />

ELDs, speed limiters, and more.<br />

Page 8<br />

Trailer Tales, part II<br />

Hearing your trailers speak is getting easier.<br />

Are you listening?<br />

Page 18<br />

And the Winners Are ...<br />

See which fleets took home<br />

top honors this year.<br />

Page 36<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>


<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>2015</strong><br />

555 E. Braddock Road, Alexandria, VA 22314<br />

<br />

www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org<br />

The<br />

Road<br />

Map<br />

rOUTing & nAVigATiOn<br />

prOViDED BY<br />

President’s Purview<br />

New Directions and New Beginnings by Brad Bentley | 3<br />

LegisLative Look-in<br />

Step Right Up | 6<br />

Capitol Recap | 8<br />

Where States Stand | 12<br />

From Where We Sit | 14<br />

tracking the trends sponsored by skybitz<br />

Rise of the SuperTruck | 16<br />

Trailer Tales, Part II | 18<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> Trendlines | 21<br />

Game Changer, Part II - The Case for Cameras | 22<br />

Mind Your Maintenance: Battling the BASICs | 27<br />

MeMber MaiLrooM<br />

Getting Involved in the Regulatory Process | 29<br />

chairMan of the board<br />

Keith Tuttle<br />

Founder & President, Motor Carrier Service, LLC.<br />

President<br />

Brad Bentley<br />

bbentley@truckload.org<br />

vice President – deveLoPMent<br />

Debbie Sparks<br />

dsparks@truckload.org<br />

director of education<br />

Ron Goode<br />

rgoode@truckload.org<br />

second vice chair<br />

Daniel Doran<br />

President<br />

Ace Doran Hauling & Rigging<br />

secretary<br />

Aaron Tennant<br />

CEO & President<br />

Tennant Truck Lines, Inc.<br />

executive vice President<br />

William Giroux<br />

wgiroux@truckload.org<br />

director, safety & PoLicy<br />

Dave Heller<br />

dheller@truckload.org<br />

first vice chair<br />

Russell Stubbs<br />

CEO & President, FFE Holdings Corp.<br />

treasurer<br />

Rob Penner<br />

Executive Vice President & COO<br />

Bison Transport<br />

iMMediate Past chair<br />

Shepard Dunn<br />

CEO & President<br />

Bestway Express, Inc.<br />

The viewpoints and opinions of those quoted in articles in this<br />

publication are not necessarily those of TCA.<br />

In exclusive partnership with:<br />

GET A LOAD<br />

OF THIS...<br />

a chat with the chairMan sponsored by McLeod software<br />

Happy Warrior with Keith Tuttle | 30<br />

taLking tca<br />

TCA Honors | 36<br />

Inside Out with Brad Bentley, Part II | 39<br />

Small Talk | 41<br />

See and Be Seen, 77th Annual Convention | 44<br />

Mark Your Calendar | 46<br />

1123 S. University Ave., Ste 320, Little Rock, AR 72204<br />

<br />

www.TheTrucker.com<br />

PubLisher + generaL Mgr.<br />

Micah Jackson<br />

publisher@thetrucker.com<br />

adMinistrator<br />

Leah M. Birdsong<br />

leahb@thetrucker.com<br />

Production + art director<br />

Rob Nelson<br />

robn@thetrucker.com<br />

Production + art assistant<br />

Christie Arnold<br />

christiea@thetrucker.com<br />

nationaL Marketing consuLtant<br />

Kurtis Denton<br />

kurtisd@thetrucker.com<br />

vice President<br />

Ed Leader<br />

edl@thetrucker.com<br />

editor<br />

Lyndon Finney<br />

editor@thetrucker.com<br />

associate editor<br />

Dorothy Cox<br />

dlcox@thetrucker.com<br />

sPeciaL corresPondent<br />

Cliff Abbott<br />

cliffa@thetrucker.com<br />

advertising and Marketing departMent<br />

saLes + creative director<br />

Raelee Toye Jackson<br />

raeleet@thetrucker.com<br />

nationaL Marketing consuLtant<br />

Kelly Brooke Drier<br />

kellydr@thetrucker.com<br />

© <strong>2015</strong> Trucker Publications Inc., all rights reserved. Reproduction without written permission<br />

prohibited. The publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited material. All advertisements<br />

and editorial materials are accepted and published by <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> and its exclusive partner,<br />

Trucker Publications, on the representation that the advertiser, its advertising company and/<br />

or the supplier of editorial materials are authorized to publish the entire contents and subject<br />

matter thereof. The publisher reserves the right to accept or reject any art from client. Such entities<br />

and/or their agents will defend, indemnify and hold <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>, <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />

Association, Target Media Partners, and its subsidiaries included, by not limited to, Trucker<br />

Publications Inc., harmless from and against any loss, expense, or other liability resulting from<br />

any claims or suits for libel, violations of privacy, plagiarism, copyright or trademark infringement<br />

and any other claims or suits that may rise out of publication of such advertisements and/or<br />

editorial materials. Press releases are expressly covered within the definition of editorial materials.<br />

Cover Photo by Gregg Hart & Stacey Carter<br />

Love is Greater Photography<br />

Additional magazine<br />

photography courtesy of:<br />

Daimler Trucks N. America: p. 16, 17<br />

FotoSearch: p. 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 16,<br />

18, 20, 22, 23, 24, 26, 27, 29, 44, 45<br />

Love is Greater: p. 30, 31, 32, 35<br />

TCA: p. 3, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45<br />

The Trucker News Org.: p. 3, 6, 8, 9,<br />

16, 18, 22, 23, 44<br />

4<br />

<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Truckload</strong><br />

auThoriTy<br />

<strong>Authority</strong><br />

|<br />

| www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org<br />

www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org Tca<br />

TCA<br />

<strong>2015</strong><br />

<strong>2015</strong>


O N T I M E .<br />

AT T E M P E R AT U R E .<br />

A N D E V E N T U A L LY, I N B U T T E R .<br />

Twenty tons of lobster tails are twenty tons of pure gold. And you can’t risk<br />

losing an ounce of it. That’s why Everest Reefers feature the most advanced<br />

void-free foaming process, premium liners and modular panel construction.<br />

And unlike traditional trailer assembly, Great Dane has eliminated every<br />

scrap of wood from our reefer design. All of which provides industry-leading<br />

thermal efficiency, reduced moisture intrusion and a safer, more sanitary<br />

container. Plus, at the end of the line, a promise delivered.<br />

www.greatdanetrailers.com/refrigerated<br />

G R E AT D A N E E V E R E S T T R U C K L O A D R E E F E R S<br />

T L<br />

S S<br />

DOWNLOAD OUR FREE IPAD ®<br />

INTERACTIVE PRODUCT APP<br />

Great Dane and the oval are registered trademarks of Great Dane Limited Partnership.<br />

C OC MO M MI T I T WW I TI TH H C O N F I D E N C E


spring | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

Legislative Look-In<br />

“The challenge for us is that 99 percent of the current cases are fine with the level the<br />

way it is. So it seems like there is a lot of effort being put into that 1 percent. We do feel<br />

like if that level is raised, it’s going to be a big challenge for a lot of our smaller members<br />

to be able to afford it.”<br />

— Brad Bentley, TCA President<br />

By Dorothy Cox<br />

We’ve all seen it at fairs and carnivals. It’s a tower with a bell<br />

on top and a lever at the bottom. You pay your money, take the mallet<br />

and give the lever a whack, hoping you’ve exerted enough might<br />

to make the puck go all the way to the top and ring the bell, indicating<br />

success.<br />

There’s a catch, though. Only the most muscle-bound contestants<br />

are able to ring the bell.<br />

How is that fair if instead of a carnival game we’re talking about<br />

business? Should only the bigger carriers be able to ring the bell of<br />

success?<br />

That’s what it must feel like to many small- to medium-sized carriers<br />

when the subject of raising the insurance minimum comes up.<br />

According to U.S. Rep. Matt Cartwright, D-Pa., who introduced a<br />

bill two years ago to increase the minimum, it’s a matter of “public<br />

safety.” He says the minimum of $750,000 set in 1980 by Congress<br />

hasn’t kept up with inflationary healthcare costs. His bill would increase<br />

it to $4.4 million.<br />

As <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association President Brad Bentley says,<br />

“Who is going to be able to afford it? Not everybody is going to be<br />

able to do it.”<br />

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) said<br />

this time last year that if minimum insurance rates had kept up with<br />

the core consumer price index, which is a measure of inflation, it<br />

should be $1.62 million. Or if the minimum had kept even with the<br />

medical consumer price index it would have reached $3.18 million by<br />

now.<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


The agency hasn’t come up with a specific dollar amount, but has<br />

been working on its own analysis and said it is considering a proposal to<br />

raise the minimum from $750,000 to an as-yet-to-be decided amount.<br />

In its Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) the agency<br />

said by way of explanation that it had “determined that the current financial<br />

responsibility minimums are inadequate to fully cover the costs<br />

of some crashes in light of increased medical costs and DOT’s revised<br />

value of statistical life estimates. The FMCSA is also considering extending<br />

the financial responsibility requirements to private motor carriers” as<br />

authorized by Congress.<br />

“The challenge for us,” Bentley told <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>, “is that 99<br />

percent of the current cases are fine with the level the way it is. So it<br />

seems like there is a lot of effort being put into that 1 percent. We do<br />

feel like if that level is raised, it’s going to be a big challenge for a lot of<br />

our smaller members to be able to afford it.”<br />

Cartwright’s office cited a published study by a trucking stakeholder<br />

that said 42 percent of the dollar settlements paid by trucking companies<br />

between 2005 and 2011 for motor vehicle accidents “exceeded the minimum<br />

insurance requirement.” That group supports higher minimums.<br />

“This is a matter of public safety. Tragically, more than 100,000<br />

people have been killed in commercial vehicle collisions since 1980,”<br />

Cartwright said. “This legislation is essential to protecting our nation’s<br />

highways and ensuring that victims receive the proper amount of compensation<br />

for their losses.”<br />

The current minimum of $750,000 fails to perform the basic functions<br />

that Congress intended: to promote safe operations by holding insurers<br />

responsible for inspecting trucking operations prior to underwriting policies<br />

and to protect the public, Cartwright said.<br />

Opponents to the increase see it more like pushing the minimum so<br />

high no one but the strongest (or largest) can afford it.<br />

“We are definitely concerned,” says Bentley. “We were talking about<br />

this recently at a meeting on gaps and barriers to hiring in the trucking<br />

industry. We were discussing military hiring, where they have implemented<br />

skills waivers. It’s the same issue as the insurance. A lot of big<br />

carriers are self-insured, but without some help with dollars from somewhere<br />

even on the front end from a training perspective, and converting<br />

some of those veterans into civilian jobs, it’s hard for the small guy. How<br />

much extra does it cost for them to bring in somebody like that on a<br />

skills waiver and do the training? Not everybody has those resources. So<br />

the same thing could happen on the insurance side of things if the [increased]<br />

premiums go into effect.”<br />

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) says<br />

raising the minimum will “harm small business truckers unnecessarily.”<br />

“It depends on what kind of an increase they ultimately come up<br />

with,” adds OOIDA spokesperson Norita Taylor.<br />

The current trend with owner-operators, she explains, has been toward<br />

owning their own authority. And “I think the trend toward their own<br />

authority would certainly come to a halt if it’s as high as the number we<br />

saw floating around like the $4 million minimum.”<br />

Indeed, it’s the worry of many smaller carriers that such an increase<br />

could put them out of business.<br />

Many trucking stakeholders think it won’t be as high as the $4.4 million<br />

in the Cartwright bill but would be more like $2.5 million when all<br />

is said and done. There has even been speculation that the $4.4 million<br />

figure is purposefully high so that when a slightly lower but also unaffordable<br />

figure is finalized, it will be accepted.<br />

Critics point out that the amount of insurance carried by motor carriers<br />

has never been shown to have a correlation with safety.<br />

“Broadly,” says American Trucking Associations spokesman Sean Mc-<br />

Nally, “we have yet to see any evidence that increased insurance minimums<br />

will lead to improved highway safety and until we can see that<br />

evidence, we do not support changing the limits.”<br />

David Owen, president of the National Association of Small Trucking<br />

Companies (NASTC), says smaller carriers already have an unfair disadvantage<br />

compared with larger fleets when it comes to insurance coverage.<br />

“Based on conversations with underwriters and the premium rates<br />

available to small carriers at the $750,000 required levels,” he says, “I<br />

believe any increase would damage the ability of small service providers<br />

to earn adequate profit and attract new capital, contrary to the national<br />

transportation policy.” In comments to the FMCSA, Owen continues that<br />

“A good rate for a large, established fleet might be $4,000 per unit while<br />

a new entrant can expect to pay as much as $10,000 to $12,000 per<br />

unit for the same insurance.”<br />

In fact, he says, “Many underwriters simply will not write carriers<br />

with less than three years of experience and new entrants can be required<br />

to pay as much as two and a half times as much as established<br />

fleets.”<br />

He adds that of NASTC’s some 1,500 members, he wasn’t aware of<br />

any carrier claims which weren’t resolved within current limits, nor had<br />

any of the member carriers had to file bankruptcy because of crash liability.<br />

The comment period on FMCSA’s ANPRM ended on February 26.<br />

OOIDA notes that its comments highlighted “a legislative and regulatory<br />

history of insurance requirements” that found “Congress and the<br />

Department of Transportation intended that any requirements be responsive<br />

to a broad range of economic considerations. Those considerations<br />

included the health of the motor carrier industry, the needs of both<br />

large and small motor carriers and the ability of the insurance industry<br />

to provide adequate coverage at reasonable prices.” FMCSA’s decision<br />

“to move forward with this rulemaking not only flies in the face of these<br />

comments,” says Todd Spencer, OOIDA’s executive vice president, “but<br />

also the data on crash costs analyzed by the agency … shows that more<br />

than 99 percent of truck-involved crashes are covered in the current requirements.”<br />

The owner-operator group also says the survey cited by Cartwright’s<br />

office used only a “small number of carriers.”<br />

Clearly, small and medium carriers see the “strong man” contest as<br />

patently unfair to begin with and that trucking can be enough of a carnival<br />

as it is without forcing good companies out of business by hiking<br />

insurance minimums.<br />

Five Things to Know About<br />

Insurance Minimums<br />

1. Higher minimums could quash a trend toward<br />

truckers owning their own authority.<br />

2. There are no proven safety benefits to higher<br />

minimums.<br />

3. Higher minimums could further skew<br />

disparities between what large and small<br />

carriers pay for insurance.<br />

4. FMCSA says the current minimum is<br />

“inadequate” and is considering a rulemaking<br />

to change it.<br />

5. Some think one lawmaker’s suggested<br />

change to $4.4 million is purposely high so<br />

that a lower but equally unaffordable amount<br />

will be readily accepted.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>


CapItol recap<br />

A review of important news coming out of our nation’s capital.<br />

By Lyndon Finney<br />

REGULATORY<br />

RACE<br />

I f you think the wheels of justice turn slowly, take a<br />

look at the federal regulatory rulemaking and legislative<br />

processes.<br />

Talk about the tortoise and the hare (but in this<br />

case, the hare wins).<br />

Or think about a NASCAR vehicle circling the track<br />

in a race with a conventional four-wheeler, or about<br />

Mickey Mantle in a race to first base with Yogi Berra<br />

(note to members of the younger generation: Mantle<br />

was once considered the fastest man in baseball, Yogi<br />

the slowest).<br />

Or about the space race with the old Soviet Union<br />

to see who could get to the moon and back first (note to<br />

those non-history buffs: the U.S. won 6-zip).<br />

Justice wins by a landslide.<br />

Take a look at the DOT’s monthly report on the<br />

progress of significant rulemakings (scan QR code) and<br />

you’ll find the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration<br />

is working on 14 rulemakings by itself, 13 of which<br />

relate directly to trucking. The agency<br />

shares one rulemaking with the National<br />

Highway Traffic Safety Administration<br />

or NHTSA (Heavy Truck Speed<br />

Limiters), while NHTSA has one of<br />

its own — Electronic Stability Control<br />

Systems for Heavy Vehicles.<br />

Of those 16 rulemakings in Get progress, the freeonly mobile one app at<br />

— the MAP-21 mandated Electronic http:/ Logging / gettag.mobi Devices<br />

and Hours of Service Supporting Documents — is a<br />

sure bet to reach the final rule stage this year.<br />

Two other final rules — the MAP-21 mandated<br />

Commercial Driver’s License Drug and Alcohol<br />

Clearinghouse and the Prohibition of Coercion — are<br />

scheduled to be published this year, but meeting the<br />

proposed Dec. 14 release date for the highly-anticipated<br />

drug and alcohol clearinghouse rulemaking is<br />

highly unlikely given the propensity for the Office of<br />

Management and Budget (i.e., the White House) to use<br />

a double-strength microscope to peer over and over<br />

and over at a rulemaking before giving their stamp of<br />

approval. Talk about slowpokes.<br />

The coercion rulemaking, with its scheduled Sept.<br />

10 publication date, has a better chance to reach the<br />

printer, but see the previous paragraph for the reason<br />

it might not.<br />

FMCSA is also scheduled to issue an Advanced<br />

Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) on Financial<br />

Responsibility for Motor Carriers, Freight Forwarders<br />

and Brokers (i.e., liability insurance minimums), which<br />

means the agency would publish its initial analysis of<br />

the subject and ask for public comments, which should<br />

fill more than 10 mailboxes.<br />

Jointly, FMCSA and NHTSA are scheduled to issue<br />

the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) on speed<br />

limiters, which will finally reveal whether it is the oft-suggested<br />

65 mph or another speed.<br />

But with the ELD rulemaking an accepted reality<br />

among carriers and drivers alike (although there are<br />

some from both groups who don’t like the idea), the<br />

hottest regulatory topic doesn’t even appear on the<br />

rulemaking list!<br />

34-hour<br />

Restart<br />

Welcome to Restartgate.<br />

The trucking industry pulled an unprecedented end<br />

run on FMCSA in late 2014 to get the more restrictive<br />

34-hour restart provision at least temporarily rescinded,<br />

thanks in great part to Barry Pottle, a past <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Carriers Association chairman and president and CEO<br />

of Pottle’s Transportation in Hermon, Maine. He sat<br />

down with Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, and explained<br />

how the new provision had negatively impacted productivity.<br />

The industry’s action came after repeated attempts<br />

to convince then-FMCSA Administrator Anne Ferro to<br />

go back to the restart rule in place before July 1, 2013,<br />

the same rule that was reinstated when the July 1 rule<br />

was suspended.<br />

Ferro steadfastly refused, throwing down the<br />

gauntlet during the question-and-answer session at the<br />

Mid-West Truck & Trailer Show in Peoria, Illinois, on Jan.<br />

31, 2014.<br />

“We are not changing the rule,” Ferro said firmly.<br />

“This is the first time in a decade that we’ve got a<br />

rule that passed legal challenge. There are today no<br />

changes afoot.”<br />

However, Ferro quickly followed with a comment<br />

that the door was still open to comments.<br />

“There continues, though, to be commitment on<br />

my part to one, take what we are hearing to improve<br />

how we are explaining the rules so that everybody has<br />

examples you can use while training your drivers, dispatchers<br />

and safety directors,” Ferro said. “And that we<br />

understand what the impact is on your operation and<br />

how many different ways that’s being interpreted. And<br />

two, continue to research to see, down the road, you<br />

know … to see what is the best approach. But again,<br />

this rule is in place.”<br />

Trucking continued to comment against the new<br />

restart provision, and finally at least partially out of<br />

frustration, turned to lawmakers for help.<br />

“I care deeply about safety on our nation’s roads,<br />

and no one wants to see an accident caused by driver<br />

fatigue or by any other cause. What has become<br />

clear is that new federal rules, implemented last year,<br />

have presented some unintended and unanticipated<br />

consequences that are not in the best interest of public<br />

safety, truck drivers or the businesses and consumers<br />

who depend on their services,” Collins said as a result<br />

of the meeting with Pottle. “There is increasing concern<br />

that these regulations are forcing more trucks on the<br />

road during the most congested morning hours — during<br />

a time when commuters are traveling to work and<br />

children are traveling to school.”<br />

The 34-hour restart now in effect that can be used<br />

multiple times a week and doesn’t require two 1 a.m. to<br />

5 a.m. shifts is a boon to the long-haul trucking industry,<br />

says Dan Doran, TCA’s second vice chair and president<br />

of Ace Doran Hauling & Rigging in Cincinnati.<br />

“The [current] 34-hour restart is a great tool for the<br />

long-haul, coast-to-coast driver,” Doran said. “It allows<br />

the driver to restart his clock while taking an extended<br />

time off. The new rule of July 1, 2013, complicated the<br />

rule and shortened the new week by as much as one<br />

day, or one load, depending on the driver’s activity.”<br />

Dennis Dellinger, an at-large TCA officer and<br />

president of Cargo Transporters of Claremont, North<br />

Carolina, said while he couldn’t necessary point to<br />

any specific productivity loss under the July 1 rule, the<br />

168-hour restriction was the real culprit, making it very<br />

difficult to ensure Monday deliveries to customers.<br />

What’s more, the 168-hour restriction could limit a<br />

driver’s earnings, he noted.<br />

“If a driver had a doctor’s appointment, a dental appointment<br />

or any other type of appointment in between<br />

the time they had hours to drive, there was no way to<br />

make that time up. With the old restart, you could make<br />

it up for the most part because that restart didn’t have<br />

to always be the same day of the week,” Dellinger said.<br />

Along with suspending the 2013 rule, Congress<br />

mandated FMCSA conduct a field study comparing the<br />

two restart provisions.<br />

The FMCSA in January 2014 released the results<br />

of a study it had conducted to determine the efficacy of<br />

the new restart provision, but only 36 of the total 106<br />

participants were over-the-road drivers. Forty-four were<br />

local drivers who rarely, if ever, would need to use the<br />

restart provision.<br />

The new study, to be conducted by Virginia Tech<br />

Transportation Institute under contract with the FMCSA,<br />

was scheduled to start around April 1.<br />

The study will divide participants into two groups,<br />

one following the more restrictive provision, the other<br />

following the provision now in place.<br />

Drivers were recruited from small, medium and<br />

large fleets across a variety of operations — long-haul,<br />

short-haul and regional — to help ensure statistically<br />

significant results, VTTI said, adding that the research<br />

plan also involves including a variety of haul types in<br />

the study, including flatbed, refrigerated, tanker, and<br />

dry-van trailers. The research study will be conducted<br />

on-the-job for five months.<br />

Drivers will be compensated by up to more than<br />

$2,000 for their participation.<br />

Rep. Richard Hanna, R-N.Y., a member of the<br />

House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee,<br />

warned the FMCSA and VTTI to make sure the study<br />

had a representative sample of drivers.<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


“The FMCSA and the research team should ensure that the drivers selected for<br />

the study are truly representative of the industry,” Hanna said in a letter to Transportation<br />

Secretary Anthony Foxx. “It is my understanding that current driver-recruitment<br />

efforts are focusing on drivers who routinely work between 60-70 hours per week<br />

and who typically work at night. This is concerning because it indicates the researchers<br />

do not understand how the 34-hour restart is being used in practice. This small<br />

subset of truck drivers is not representative of drivers who use the restart provision<br />

and not representative of drivers who have been impacted by the July 2013 restart<br />

restrictions.”<br />

Even Congress, which can be painfully slow, is having to jump-start FMCSA.<br />

Congress recently pushed the agency to complete and publish the final rule of<br />

ELDs June 1, but sources and common sense say that’s not likely to happen given<br />

the bureaucratic nightmare that typically makes a mockery out of scheduled rulemaking<br />

progress dates.<br />

There are both ups and downs to the use of ELDs, Doran believes.<br />

“We are currently implementing ELDs,” he said. “Local drivers see the most benefit,<br />

less time filling out logs and more quality time at home. Regional drivers seem<br />

the most effected. Regional drivers spend more time away from home, and electronic<br />

logs complicate loading and unloading time. I think the ELD rule will have very little<br />

impact on safety; it will, however, reduce productivity for each driver and that will<br />

result in more trucks on the road.”<br />

Cargo Transporters has had 100 percent ELDs since late 2008 and Dellinger<br />

says the devices have been beneficial to both drivers and back office personnel<br />

in developing schedules and that ELDs had been accepted by drivers.<br />

A recent rehire shared with Dellinger how work was like without ELDs.<br />

“We had a driver return to us and he told us that he worked for a company for<br />

several years that didn’t have ELDs,” Dellinger related. “He said ‘at the end of a<br />

trip I spent 45 minutes trying to put my paper logs in order. That’s time that is my<br />

time.’”<br />

The organization that has expressed the most concern about ELDs is the<br />

Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, which says there’s no proof that<br />

the devices improve safety and called into question a VTTI study on ELDs.<br />

“The study’s conclusion is flawed because it included all other types of crashes<br />

except those that supposedly would be prevented with electronic logging devices,”<br />

said OOIDA Executive Vice President Todd Spencer.<br />

The study said trucks equipped with ELDs would have 11.7 percent fewer preventable<br />

crashes and 5.1 percent fewer non-preventable crashes than trucks without<br />

such devices.<br />

Spencer pointed out that the report’s researchers readily admitted that there<br />

wasn’t enough data to find any safety benefits when comparing DOT-recordable and<br />

fatigue-related crashes.<br />

“The possible changes that hold the most promise in improving highway safety<br />

are things like driver training, better working environments, support systems and safe<br />

parking,” Spencer said.<br />

The ELD rulemaking has reached the point that the FMCSA has announced that<br />

it is expecting 22 manufacturers of ELDs to register their devices in anticipation of<br />

the new rule.<br />

It is anticipated each company will submit four devices.<br />

T he issues of speed limiters and coercion have received less attention and<br />

debate, but it is a fact that the major associations support speed limiters — most in<br />

the 65 mph range — while many company drivers see limiting speed as an impediment<br />

to revenue.<br />

OOIDA also isn’t on board with the idea.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

ELDs<br />

speed Limiters<br />

J. J. KELLER’S ELD INSIGHTS<br />

How ELDs Make IFTA Easier<br />

Few fleet tasks are as tedious and time-consuming as preparing quarterly<br />

International Fuel Tax Agreement (IFTA) reports.<br />

Just think how many hours you, your staff, and your drivers spend each<br />

month filling out Individual Vehicle Mileage Reports (IVMRs), chasing down<br />

missing reports, and reconciling miles driven and fuel receipts. Plus, there’s<br />

the hassle of deciphering drivers’ handwritten IVMRs, managing a mountain<br />

of paperwork, and following strict document retention requirements.<br />

Another frequent issue is that using your drivers as accountants to compile<br />

the necessary data often leads to errors and late reporting.<br />

Once the data has been received at your office, staff must then complete<br />

the quarterly IFTA reporting form that summarizes miles, fuel purchased,<br />

average fleet miles per gallon, and tax paid or tax credit due — all<br />

broken down by state and province. Late reporting or errors made in the<br />

completion of this form can make your company prone to audits, and<br />

audit fines tend to be very high.<br />

Those challenges can be virtually eliminated with an electronic logging<br />

device (ELD) system.<br />

The Advantages of Automation<br />

Automating IFTA reporting via an ELD system allows your company to immediately<br />

capture the required information. Such a system also eliminates<br />

human errors, including gap miles, transposing numbers, moving decimal<br />

points, dropping zeroes, etc. The result is saved driver and administrative<br />

time and stress, increased operational efficiency, and 100% accurate and<br />

compliant IFTA submissions — all positive contributions to your bottom line.<br />

Under IFTA, carriers are allowed to use an ELD system as long as it’s able to<br />

capture and prepare the same information a driver’s IVMR does, including:<br />

• Starting and ending dates for the trip<br />

• Trip origin and destination<br />

• Routes of travel or latitude and longitude position fixes<br />

• Beginning and ending odometer reading (some states/provinces<br />

do not require this)<br />

• Total trip distance<br />

• Mileage in each state/province<br />

• Unit number.<br />

Some states/provinces also require that the driver and any intermediate<br />

stops be identified. As long as these requirements are met and the raw<br />

data is retained in the correct format, the ELD system can be used for<br />

IFTA reporting.<br />

The Bottom Line<br />

By outfitting your fleet with ELDs and a back-office system<br />

that takes care of your IFTA work, you can eliminate errors,<br />

save time, and simplify recordkeeping. Just click “run,”<br />

“print,” and review the printed form (or copy<br />

the information onto the jurisdiction’s required<br />

form); then sign it and send it on its way!<br />

To download our complete “Technology Makes IFTA Easier” whitepaper,<br />

visit JJKeller.com/IFTA. To learn about J. J. Keller’s Encompass® ELD and<br />

E-Log system, see the ad in this publication or visit JJKellerELogs.com.<br />

with E-Logs<br />

www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>


“A few select groups, claiming to represent the<br />

interests of the entire trucking industry, have been<br />

misinforming public officials throughout North America<br />

about the benefits of requiring all heavy trucks to<br />

employ speed limiters,” OOIDA said in a paper sent to<br />

its members. “As studies and experience have shown,<br />

mandating speed limiters in the U.S. will actually make<br />

highways less safe and will hurt small businesses and<br />

the economy without any real environmental benefit.<br />

“Mandating speed limiters rewards large corporations<br />

who fail to hire the safest, most experienced<br />

drivers available and punishes the small businessmen<br />

and women who have built a career on fuel economy<br />

and safety.”<br />

Dellinger said 450 Cargo Transporters’ tractors have<br />

been speed limited at 63 mph since 2009 when the<br />

speed was dropped from 65 mph. He said he was sure<br />

if a rulemaking set the limit at 65 mph his trucks would<br />

be raised to that speed.<br />

“As the economy eased up, we re-evaluated our<br />

speed and said we didn’t feel good about sending a<br />

signal that we were going to trade out safety for driver<br />

retention,” he said. “We feel like speed is a major factor<br />

on safety. That is not favorable to our drivers. They live<br />

with it but if I asked them what’s your single-most wish,<br />

50 to 75 percent would say they want speed because<br />

they have about everything else we could give them.”<br />

Dellinger said he’d recently reviewed driver comments<br />

on the carrier’s nomination to be part of the<br />

TCA’s Best Fleets To Drive For contest.<br />

“Our chairman, John Pope, and I had a discussion<br />

yesterday and I said, ‘John, if I knew giving them<br />

back two miles an hour would suffice, I would do that.’<br />

There were people requesting 68; there were people<br />

requesting 70. I’ve told people in our open roundtable<br />

meetings as long as I was in charge I was going to stick<br />

with that 63.”<br />

Coercion<br />

C oercion has long been a problem in trucking,<br />

primarily with the way some dispatchers force drivers<br />

into unsafe situations, and the way drivers are treated<br />

by shippers and receivers.<br />

Coercion was also an issue in the original ELD<br />

rulemakings, which were quashed by the courts for failing<br />

to include language that would prevent carriers from<br />

using the technology to coerce drivers into tasks that<br />

the driver felt could impact safety.<br />

substance abuse<br />

A nd then there’s the question of the drug-andalcohol<br />

clearinghouse. The central database for verified<br />

positive controlled substances and alcohol test results<br />

is designed to keep drivers from hopping from one carrier<br />

to another without the new carrier having the ability<br />

to have knowledge of any previous substance abuse<br />

problems.<br />

But even with the clearinghouse, some are wary<br />

of the accuracy of urine tests and point to recent hair<br />

follicle testing that has proven far more accurate.<br />

Random testing has somewhat reduced substance<br />

abuse among drivers, but “there is still a problem on<br />

a small level,” says Doran. “Hair follicle testing is more<br />

accurate and reliable.”<br />

The Department of Transportation has yet to approve<br />

hair follicle testing as part of the clearinghouse<br />

program, so results gained from that type of testing<br />

cannot be shared among carriers.<br />

So once again trucking turned to Congress.<br />

The Drug-Free Commercial Driver Act of <strong>2015</strong> has<br />

been introduced in the Senate by Sens. John Boozman,<br />

R-Ark., Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., and Sen. Heidi Heitkamp,<br />

D-N.D., and in the House by Rep. Rick Crawford,<br />

R-Ark., Rep. Eleanor Holmes Norton, D-D.C., and Rep.<br />

Dan Lipinski, D-Ill.<br />

It would give fleets the option of using hair testing<br />

as an alternative to traditional urine tests to meet<br />

federal requirements.<br />

One issue important to trucking executives hasn’t<br />

even reached the Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking<br />

stage: entry-level driver training.<br />

entry-level<br />

training<br />

T he FMCSA has responded to trucking’s<br />

concern about this issue and has formed a 26-member<br />

advisory committee that is tasked with updating classroom<br />

and new behind-the-wheel training requirements<br />

for professional truck and bus drivers.<br />

“Over the next 30 years, we’re going to be relying<br />

on trucks — and truckers — to move more than 40<br />

percent more freight than they currently do,” Foxx said.<br />

“With more people and freight crossing our country<br />

than ever before, this committee’s work will be critical<br />

to ensuring that commercial drivers are fully capable of<br />

operating their vehicles safely.”<br />

TCA’s Director of Safety and Policy David Heller is<br />

a member of the advisory committee.<br />

“Ensuring roadway safety starts with the driver,”<br />

said FMCSA Chief Counsel Scott Darling, who is in<br />

charge at the FMCSA until a new administrator is appointed.<br />

“Finalizing new training requirements for truck<br />

and bus operators is one of my top priorities and we<br />

have tapped a group of uniquely qualified stakeholders<br />

to help us work through the details and meet this goal.”<br />

csa<br />

Y et trucking and FMCSA remain at a stalemate<br />

on other issues.<br />

One of those is CSA scoring, specifically the fact<br />

that carriers are held accountable for accidents which<br />

their drivers didn’t cause and couldn’t have known were<br />

going to happen. FMCSA did a study on the problem<br />

and decided that determining who is at fault in crashes<br />

is too costly and too difficult to achieve for purposes<br />

of CSA data, adding that police accident reports don’t<br />

include enough viable data to judge who was at fault.<br />

Determining crash fault doesn’t improve prediction<br />

of crash risk, the report found.<br />

To which trucking stakeholders responded that it is<br />

illogical to label carriers unsafe based on crashes they<br />

didn’t cause.<br />

The roads have been littered with recent crashes<br />

caused by other vehicles, including a March 20 fatality<br />

caused by off-duty police officers traveling the wrong<br />

way on a divided highway; another March 20 fatal crash<br />

in Texas where a suspected drunk driver going the<br />

wrong way on I-27 hit a truck head-on; and a March 24<br />

fatality in Washington DC in which a passenger was<br />

killed after the drunken driver struck a parked CMV.<br />

And the list goes on and on. This could be another area<br />

where trucking must turn to Congress to get relief.<br />

Transportation<br />

Bill<br />

O ne important Capital occurrence that falls<br />

outside the regulatory arena, however, is the need to<br />

pass a new surface transportation bill before the current<br />

MAP-21 expires May 31.<br />

Foxx has sent a $471 billion six-year transportation<br />

bill to Congress under the acronym GROW AMERICA,<br />

which stands for Generating Renewal, Opportunity, and<br />

Work with Accelerated Mobility, Efficiency, and Rebuilding<br />

of Infrastructure and Communities throughout<br />

America.<br />

But the bill is another Washington “kick the can<br />

down the road” action because it fails to provide the<br />

long-term stability desperately needed for states to<br />

initiate major road and bridge projects with the certainty<br />

that money will be available when it comes time to pay<br />

the bills.<br />

Instead it calls for a one-time 14 percent transaction<br />

tax on the up to $2 trillion of untaxed foreign earnings<br />

that U.S. companies have accumulated overseas.<br />

The one-shot funding would supplement current<br />

revenues from the Highway Trust Fund, with the current<br />

fuel tax providing an estimated two-thirds of the money<br />

needed to keep the trust fund solvent and the transaction<br />

tax providing the other one-third.<br />

But if the bill passes in its current form, what assurance<br />

would states have that the federal portion of<br />

money needed to complete projects would be available<br />

in 2020?<br />

There are many highway projects that are funded<br />

through federal/state money that are 10- 15-year projects,<br />

trucking stakeholders note.<br />

There’s already caution among states under MAP-<br />

21 as many have suspended projects because they<br />

don’t know whether the necessary funds will be available<br />

when the time comes.<br />

Well-placed sources say the 14-percent tax hasn’t<br />

been warmly received on Capitol Hill.<br />

Nor for that matter, has it been too widely received<br />

in corporate boardrooms across America.<br />

An increase in the gas and diesel tax — the funding<br />

mechanism supported by TCA and other trucking<br />

associations — is probably the only way to sustain the<br />

Highway Trust Fund over a 10- to 20-year period and<br />

thus provide states with the certainty the money will be<br />

there when needed.<br />

It’s been estimated that the fuel tax would have to<br />

be increased 10 cents and indexed to inflation in order<br />

to keep the Highway Trust Fund solvent for an extended<br />

period of time.<br />

But Congress also seems hesitant to consider a<br />

fuel tax increase, so it would appear that there’s a good<br />

chance that MAP-21 might be extended a second time.<br />

Doing so would certainly not be unprecedented.<br />

After all, SAFETEA-LU, which was signed into law<br />

by President George W. Bush on Aug. 10, 2005, and<br />

was supposed to expire on Sept. 30, 2009, was extended<br />

10 times while Congress wrangled over a new<br />

bill that was finally passed as MAP-21 in 2012.<br />

So here we sit in April, waiting to see how all these<br />

issues plays out.<br />

Will the tortoise actually beat the hare and all the<br />

promised rulemaking activities be completed on time?<br />

Coming down the home stretch in late December,<br />

it’s a good bet the hare will win.<br />

10 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


Keep Your Fleet Rolling With<br />

Automated IFTA Reporting<br />

NO TRIP SHEETS • NO LOG BOOKS • NO SPREADSHEETS<br />

with E-Logs<br />

The most affordable E-Log on the market.<br />

Now with automated IFTA reporting for<br />

ALL J. J. Keller ® E-Log Editions!<br />

PC111145<br />

Request Your FREE Quote Today!<br />

Visit JJKellerELogs.com/IFTA or call 855.693.5338


WHERE<br />

STATES<br />

STAND<br />

life’s a beach<br />

Myrtle Beach is considered one of the top vacation locales on<br />

the Atlantic Ocean catering to 14 million visitors each year. It<br />

boasts 140 resorts that offer amenities such as heated pools,<br />

hot tubs and indoor activities like bowling lanes, racquet ball<br />

and game rooms. All resorts are conveniently located near<br />

endless entertainment venues, premier restaurants and factory<br />

specialty shops up and down the 60 glorious miles of The Grand<br />

Strand, which includes numerous fishing piers.<br />

An inside look at key<br />

transportation<br />

legislation in<br />

statehouses across<br />

America.<br />

By Lyndon Finney<br />

In the State Spotlight:<br />

South Carolina<br />

A plan to change how the state Department of Transportation operates is stalled in the South Carolina Senate and could derail the entire proposal to get more money to<br />

roads and bridges. Gov. Nikki Haley has vowed to veto any bill that doesn’t include DOT reform along with income tax relief and additional money for roads. Lawmakers<br />

have less than two months to get it all accomplished before the session ends in June. Complicating matters is a change eight years ago that allowed the governor<br />

to appoint the leader of DOT. That change ends in July, meaning doing nothing would remove the governor’s control of the agency.<br />

Minnesota<br />

A Republican-aligned political group will counter Gov. Mark Dayton’s tax plan for road<br />

and bridge repairs with a barrage of radio and direct mail ads. In a series of ads expected<br />

to launch soon, the Minnesota Jobs Coalition will brand the governor’s proposal to raise<br />

the gasoline tax as both harmful and unnecessary. The group also is targeting a handful<br />

of Democratic lawmakers who may be vulnerable in the 2016 election, mentioning them<br />

in the radio ads by name that they want to raise the gas tax. Dayton and fellow Democrats<br />

have been touring the state to drum up support for his plan, which includes a gas<br />

tax of at least 16 cents per gallon and higher vehicle registration fees.<br />

Michigan<br />

If voters agree to raise taxes for Michigan’s deteriorating road and bridge system, 61<br />

cents of every dollar would go to local agencies that say the money could gradually<br />

restore roads to respectability within a decade. The large funding increase at the local<br />

level, phased in over three years, would include $491 million more to 83 counties and an<br />

additional $274 million to more than 500 cities and villages, according to the nonpartisan<br />

House Fiscal Agency. Local officials say the money would help tackle long-deferred<br />

road work, promote longer-lasting fixes instead of short-term patches, replace aging<br />

plows and salt trucks, and beef up dwindling road commission employee levels.<br />

12 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


Arkansas<br />

The Arkansas Highway Commission in early April voted to end split speed<br />

limits on the state’s rural-area interstate highways. Since 1996, trucks have<br />

been limited to 65 mph on rural-area interstates while other vehicles could go<br />

70 mph. The commission cited traffic flow as a factor in the decision. Scott<br />

Bennett, director of the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department,<br />

said he saw firsthand the effect of the different speed limits on traffic flow<br />

during a trip on Interstate 40 to Memphis. “There were a couple of times that<br />

I was in the left lane behind a truck that was going about 65.1 mph and trying<br />

to pass a truck in the right lane going 65.0 mph. It took me somewhere around<br />

17 minutes to get around one of those trucks. It took me about 15 minutes to<br />

get around the other one,” he said.<br />

North Carolina<br />

Gasoline taxes in North Carolina appear headed downward by a little bit very<br />

soon as the General Assembly has voted for a compromise plan that avoids<br />

a sharp drop this summer that bill supporters said would wreck future roadbuilding<br />

plans. The House and Senate gave preliminary approval to the agreement.<br />

Additional votes in each chamber were expected before it heads to the<br />

desk of Gov. Pat McCrory, who has already praised the final product, reached<br />

after a few weeks of negotiations. As part of the deal, the tax would drop from<br />

the current 37.5 cents per gallon to 36 cents, then fall to 35 cents next January<br />

and 34 cents in July 2016. Starting in January 2017, the tax would be adjusted<br />

based on increases in state population and a consumer energy price index. The<br />

current North Carolina tax is among the highest in the nation.<br />

Mississippi<br />

Mississippi lawmakers neared final approval of House Bill 1630, which<br />

would use $36 million a year in casino taxes mainly to rebuild deficient<br />

bridges on state highways. Lawmakers agreed after casinos opened to use that<br />

revenue stream for road projects to improve access to casinos. But with those<br />

projects completed and bonds mostly paid off, the money in recent years has<br />

been flowing to the state Department of Transportation to spend as it wants.<br />

Under a conference report to the House and Senate released recently, the<br />

House authorized $200 million in bonds for bridge repairs, lower than the<br />

$400 million proposed earlier.<br />

Connecticut<br />

Gov. Dannel P. Malloy says he’s trying to keep everyone focused on the need to overhaul<br />

Connecticut’s aging transportation infrastructure. Malloy recently met with reporters<br />

underneath the Interstate 84 viaduct in Hartford. The Department of Transportation<br />

said it’s the busiest section of highway in Connecticut, serving more than 175,000<br />

vehicles daily. It was built between 1959 and 1969 and was designed to carry 55,000<br />

vehicles a day. Funding to design a rehabilitated structure is part of Malloy’s five-year,<br />

$10 billion transportation ramp-up initiative, which is awaiting legislative approval.<br />

Nebraska<br />

Nebraska lawmakers remain split over a proposed fuel-tax increase as they debate the<br />

best way to pay for roads and bridges. The measure would phase in a 6-cent increase<br />

over four years, raise the total gas tax to 31.6 cents per gallon and generate an estimated<br />

$19 million a year for the aging infrastructure. Sen. Jim Smith of Papillion said he<br />

proposed the bill as a “user fee” because it only applies to motorists when they fill their<br />

tanks. Other senators questioned the measure’s timing — introduced when gas prices<br />

have fallen — and argued the tax hits hardest the motorists who can least afford it.<br />

Oregon<br />

Oregonians could begin flying along certain highways at 75 mph after lawmakers<br />

heard testimony recently on a bill upping speed limits from 65 mph<br />

on interstate highways. Under the proposal, passenger cars would be able to<br />

go 10 mph faster than the current limit. It also ups the speed limit on state<br />

highways to 65 mph. Certain vehicles, such as trucks and school buses, would<br />

have to stick to the 55-mph limit on interstate and state highways. Troy Costales,<br />

an administrator at the state Department of Transportation, cautioned<br />

lawmakers at the public hearing that increasing the speed limit might lead to<br />

more crashes and fatalities.<br />

New Mexico<br />

Starting next year, you won’t be able to drive more than 55 mph on New<br />

Mexico county roads where there’s no speed limit posted. Gov. Susana Martinez<br />

has signed legislation that makes 55 mph the default speed limit on<br />

county roads. Republican Sen. Pat Woods of Broadview says the current 75<br />

mph legal limit doesn’t make sense for many local, narrow, dirt roads. He<br />

says these roads aren’t designed or built for the higher speeds allowed on the<br />

state’s highways and interstates. The new default speed limit will take effect<br />

Jan. 1, 2016.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 13


From Where We Sit<br />

INSURANCE LIABILITY MINIMUM EDITION<br />

industry stakeholders discuss THE INSURANCE MINIMUM<br />

“As chairman of the TCA it is my fiduciary responsibility to represent the majority of the members of the association<br />

and the majority of our members have said they are opposed to increasing the liability limits on the<br />

insurance. As chairman, I will to speak to what most of our members have expressed as far as their opinion on<br />

liability insurance limits.”<br />

— TCA Chairman Keith Tuttle<br />

“Who is going to be able to afford it? Not everyone is going to be able to do it.”<br />

— TCA President Brad Bentley<br />

Raising the minimum “will harm small business truckers unnecessarily” but it “depends on what kind of an increase<br />

they ultimately come up with.”<br />

— Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association<br />

Spokesperson Norita Taylor<br />

“This legislation is essential to protecting our nation’s highways and ensuring that victims receive the proper<br />

amount of compensation for their losses.”<br />

— U.S. Rep. Matt Cartwright, D-Pa., who introduced a bill two<br />

years ago to up the minimum to $4.4 million<br />

“I believe any increase would damage the ability of small service providers to earn adequate profit and attract<br />

new capital, contrary to the national transportation policy.”<br />

— David Owen, president of the National<br />

Association of Small Trucking Companies<br />

“ … The current financial responsibility minimums are inadequate to fully cover the costs of<br />

some crashes in light of increased medical costs and DOT’s revised value of statistical life<br />

estimates. … ”<br />

— The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration in its Advanced<br />

Notice of Proposed Rulemaking<br />

“We have yet to see any evidence that increased insurance minimums will<br />

lead to improved highway safety and until we can see that evidence, we do<br />

not support changing the limits.”<br />

— American Trucking Associations<br />

Spokesman Sean McNally<br />

14 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


y o u r<br />

d r i v e r s<br />

r e a d<br />

the trucker<br />

n e w s p a p e r<br />

shOuldn’t yOu?<br />

On news stands natiOnwide.<br />

FOr subscriptiOns Or tO advertise<br />

call (800) 666-2770.<br />

OFFicial partner OF trucklOad authOrity<br />

G e t y o u r t r u c k i n G n e w s e v e r y d a y a t t h e t r u c k e r . c o m


spring | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

Tracking The Trends<br />

By Cliff Abbott<br />

If you can’t list all the expenditures in the American Recovery and Reinvestment<br />

Act of 2009, popularly known as the “stimulus bill” and which<br />

was supposed to create jobs to help those who became unemployed during<br />

the Great Recession, well, you’re not alone.<br />

In the eyes of many, the Act was another Washington blunder, but<br />

nevertheless one key provision could still have a tremendous impact on<br />

the trucks the industry will depend on in the future.<br />

In January 2011, then U.S. Secretary of Energy Steven Chu announced<br />

that more than $115 million in Department of Energy (DOE) grants would<br />

By go to Cliff three Abbott trucking-industry manufacturers to develop the next generation<br />

of freight-hauling machines.<br />

In August the same year, a fourth<br />

builder announced that it had received<br />

$19 million for the same<br />

purpose.<br />

To meet the goal of improving<br />

Class 8 tractor efficiency by 50 percent<br />

over then-current models by<br />

<strong>2015</strong>, grantees agreed to develop<br />

new technologies in the areas of<br />

reducing engine idling, improving<br />

combustion, recovering waste heat,<br />

improving aerodynamics and developing<br />

powertrain hybridization.<br />

Under the cost-shared, public-private<br />

program, grant recipients agreed<br />

to match the government-provided<br />

funds.<br />

The participants teamed up with engine<br />

and trailer manufacturers, industry<br />

suppliers, universities, laboratories and<br />

fleet customers to work toward the final<br />

product.<br />

Cummins received $38.8 million from<br />

the program, proposing to work with Peterbilt<br />

Motors Co. to develop a more aerodynamic<br />

tractor and trailer combination.<br />

Cummins also received an additional $15<br />

million to develop a fuel-efficient, low emissions<br />

diesel engine for light-duty vehicles that exceeds<br />

2010 Environmental Protection Agency standards<br />

while achieving 40 percent better fuel economy<br />

compared to then-current gasoline engine technology.<br />

Daimler Trucks North America received $39.6 million<br />

for its efforts, which included its own aerodynamic tractor-trailer.<br />

The company unveiled the tractor from the super<br />

combination during a press event at the Mid-America Trucking<br />

Show in Louisville, Kentucky, in March.<br />

Navistar received $37.3 million for its aerodynamic entry, which also<br />

featured tires with reduced rolling resistance.<br />

Volvo Group announced in August 2011 that it had received $19 million<br />

for a bi-lateral project conducted both in the U.S. and Sweden.<br />

The DOE specified separate goals for improvement of engine efficiency<br />

and tractor-trailer efficiency, setting specific targets in Brake-Thermal Efficiency<br />

(BTE) for engines and ton-miles per gallon. The end result was<br />

intended to be a demonstration of what is possible using current technology<br />

rather than a product ready for the assembly line.<br />

The teams took different approaches to achieving the efficiency gains,<br />

but there were a number of similarities, too. The principles of aerodynamics,<br />

for example, dictate that the tractor shape and trailer treatments be<br />

similar. Products like tires with low rolling resistance, equipped with tire<br />

pressure monitoring/automatic inflation systems were used, too.<br />

Currently available products like 6 x 2 axle configurations, which replace<br />

one tandem drive axle with one that can be lifted to save rolling<br />

resistance when not needed for weight bearing, were also utilized by the<br />

teams.<br />

Engine displacement, “downspeeding,” drivetrain hybridization and<br />

other technologies differed among the participants.<br />

Pedestrians got a glimpse of the Cummins-Peterbilt SuperTruck in February<br />

2014, parked outside DOE headquarters in Washington,DC. Superimposed<br />

on a map of the U.S. and adjacent to a 25-foot American flag<br />

graphic, was “10.7 mpg,” an achievement that beat the program’s efficiency<br />

goal by 34 percent.<br />

The SuperTruck was in the nation’s capital after serving as a backdrop<br />

to a President Barack Obama speech in Upper Marlboro, Maryland, the prior<br />

evening, as fuel-efficiency standards for large vehicles was the topic.<br />

The Cummins-Peterbilt entry was a Model 579 equipped with a Cummins<br />

ISX15 engine. Developments in technology convert a portion of exhaust<br />

heat into engine power, while electronic control software continuously<br />

adapts performance. The unit also features construction with some<br />

weight-saving alloys that are not<br />

yet commercially feasible.<br />

When Daimler revealed its SuperTruck<br />

at MATS, the company<br />

announced that its prototype had<br />

achieved an efficiency increase<br />

of 115 percent, 65 percent higher<br />

than DOE goals.<br />

The company claimed that its<br />

team achieved a whopping 12.2<br />

mpg in real-world testing on Texas<br />

highways, running at 65 mph and<br />

weighing, including load, 65,000<br />

pounds.<br />

The tractor features an articulated<br />

grill that consists of four panels that<br />

open when the engine needs additional<br />

cooling at lower speeds and close<br />

to decrease the vehicle’s aerodynamic<br />

profile at higher speeds. Like the Cummins-Peterbilt<br />

entry, exhaust heat is<br />

recovered and used to help power the<br />

unit. Also utilized is engine downspeeding,<br />

including a feature that allows the engine<br />

to idle while the vehicle goes downhill<br />

with the cruise control engaged.<br />

Some components of the SuperTruck,<br />

including some aerodynamic features and<br />

a 6 x 2 axle configuration, are already<br />

used in the company’s Cascadia Evolution<br />

model. Others, such as pre-loaded<br />

3D digital maps to control shifting<br />

and coasting capability, could be incorporated<br />

at a future date.<br />

Navistar and Volvo have not<br />

demonstrated working Super-<br />

Truck models yet, but both<br />

have provided frequent updates<br />

of their progress and displayed current<br />

production models at MATS that<br />

incorporate some of their technology<br />

developments.<br />

Last year, Navistar announced<br />

its goal of a demonstration model<br />

SuperTruck by first-quarter<br />

<strong>2015</strong>.<br />

While prototype SuperTrucks<br />

may or may not be converted<br />

into commercially viable products<br />

as built, the industry is<br />

already reaping benefits from<br />

developments in technology.<br />

In fact, the SuperTruck<br />

teams made early progress by<br />

incorporating some products<br />

that are currently available.<br />

Products like low rolling-resistance<br />

tires, wheel covers,


Sponsored by<br />

trailer side fairings and “tails,” and automated manual transmissions are<br />

already widely available. Truck manufacturers have been wind-tunnel<br />

testing and refining tractor shapes to increase aerodynamic efficiency for<br />

decades.<br />

Manufacturers’ displays at this year’s MATS touted some similar offerings<br />

that are now being incorporated into their most fuel-efficient models.<br />

Lift axles, once considered necessary only for heavy-haul or bulk operations<br />

that needed additional weight capacity, are now replacing drive axles<br />

in 6 x 2 configurations offered by component manufacturers. Improvements<br />

in vehicle software and component compatibility have resulted in<br />

engines and transmissions that “talk” to each other, selecting the opportune<br />

gear and rpm for current torque requirements.<br />

The term “downspeeding” is a new buzzword as manufacturers find<br />

ways to run the engine at lower speeds, even at idle when possible. Decades<br />

ago, some drivers slipped the gearshift to neutral on downgrades<br />

in a dangerous maneuver humorously known as putting the truck into<br />

“Georgia overdrive.” Today, it’s done by computer with an ability those<br />

long-ago drivers didn’t have — to re-engage the transmission and apply<br />

the engine compression brake when cruising speed is reached.<br />

Technology is producing more power from each engine, too. Industry<br />

efforts to maximize the output of the 15-liter diesel engine have run their<br />

course. Similar technology will wring enough power from 13-liter models<br />

to make their larger cousins obsolete before giving way to newer powerplants<br />

that are smaller yet. Daimler’s SuperTruck is powered by a 10.7-<br />

liter engine that produces 390 horsepower and 1,400 ft.-lbs. of torque.<br />

Several truck builders discussed versions of “adaptive”<br />

cruise control, which uses GPS data to<br />

adjust speed, gear selection and engine rpms to the terrain ahead.<br />

Nik Varty, WABCO president, Americas, and vice president, mergers<br />

and acquisitions, announced that his company intends to add adaptive<br />

steering to the product line by year 2020. Adaptive braking, a feature of<br />

collision mitigation systems, is already commonplace in the industry.<br />

Video cameras will undoubtedly play a role in the truck of the future.<br />

They’re already being used to provide a 360-degree look around a moving<br />

vehicle, and a view of the person driving it, in some systems. Camera<br />

lenses will replace mirrors in the near future, with video displays projected<br />

onto windshields or side windows to provide the same visual information<br />

while further reducing aerodynamic drag.<br />

Louvered shutters that control cooling air passing through the radiator<br />

were commonplace not so long ago. Daimler’s SuperTruck took them a<br />

step further, using the louvers themselves as a part of the vehicle’s aerodynamic<br />

structuring.<br />

Even such mundane products as mud flaps have benefitted from advances<br />

in technology, using airfoil-shaped “slots” to reduce drag while<br />

helping drop water from the airstream.<br />

Some of the available technologies will be pushed aside by other, newer<br />

ideas that haven’t yet left the drawing board. Others will be further<br />

refined in an effort to squeeze every efficiency gain possible.<br />

Some won’t ever see the assembly line as their cost to purchase or<br />

maintain will outweigh the efficiency gains they provide.<br />

In fact, rather than making a debut as a new model, the SuperTruck<br />

may be introduced to the market one super part at a time.<br />

Whatever the shape of the future Class 8 tractor, whatever<br />

its features and technology advances, the DOE SuperTruck<br />

program has demonstrated that the future<br />

can be accelerated when dedicated teams<br />

work to make it happen.


The stories your trailers tell<br />

part II<br />

By Dorothy Cox<br />

Editor’s note: This is the second of a twopart<br />

series on trailer-tracking technology,<br />

what tales these trailers tell and what they’ll<br />

be doing in the future.<br />

Imagine a trailer or container equipped<br />

to generate battery power by its very<br />

movement, or trailer-tracking technology<br />

that communicates the status of a trailer’s<br />

tires and brakes wherever it goes — or<br />

a reefer with sensors disguised as other<br />

equipment to evade thieves.<br />

Picture cargo tracking technology that<br />

monitors cargo from ship to rail to truck to<br />

store, and everywhere in between. Or how<br />

about a device that lets customers know<br />

from 15 minutes to an hour ahead of time<br />

that the parts they ordered are on the way,<br />

letting them gear up an assembly line and<br />

the precise number of workers needed in<br />

advance, a “just-in-time assembly line,” if<br />

you will.<br />

Some of these technologies are already<br />

in play; others are around the corner or<br />

closer.<br />

“There’s been an incredible amount<br />

of evolution” of hardware products over<br />

the past two years, said SkyBitz’s Henry<br />

Popplewell, “and that’s going to continue.”<br />

Accelerometers are used in tablet<br />

computers and digital cameras so that<br />

images on screens are always displayed<br />

upright. “They use motion to perform<br />

applications. Could they be used to generate<br />

power to recharge batteries?” asked<br />

Popplewell, SkyBitz’s senior vice president<br />

and general manager.<br />

“Keeping devices charged is a major<br />

problem in the industry,” he added, and<br />

“our claim to fame is power consumption<br />

technology. Today we have a global locating<br />

system (GLS) that lasts five to six years on<br />

its original set of batteries” and in the future,<br />

“power technology will continue to expand<br />

the range of batteries.”<br />

He predicts that sensor technology will<br />

branch out to detect whether trailers or<br />

containers are loaded or empty, mounted<br />

on a chassis or not. Customers today who<br />

have already invested in trailer-tracking<br />

technologies are saying, “What else can you<br />

do for me?” Popplewell said.<br />

“Cargo and tire pressure monitoring<br />

exist today; some are more leading-edge<br />

tire pressure monitors and trailer weight<br />

[monitoring] is just now launching.” The<br />

future is about trailers having a number of<br />

sensors, a “smart trailer,” as it were, that<br />

communicates data not just about the<br />

freight but about its maintenance needs<br />

and current readings of all its components.<br />

“That’s where the future lies for hardware,”<br />

said Popplewell.<br />

Omnitracs senior product manager Mark<br />

Alsbrook agreed that “The need is to have<br />

devices that talk with each other, and that<br />

will grow.” Exploring use of this technology<br />

will let customers watch their cargo go<br />

“from ship to rail to flatbed,” he said, adding<br />

that this fosters and will continue to foster<br />

a “holistic” approach to the trailer and its<br />

components “like the condition of the tires<br />

and brakes and … communicating that back<br />

to the driver.”<br />

Data in and of itself is a good thing. It’s<br />

even better when that data can be swiftly<br />

acted on when necessary.<br />

SenseAware, technology created on<br />

behalf of FedEx Custom Critical and<br />

enclosed in a device just a little bigger than<br />

a cell phone, can be put in a package or on<br />

a pallet to track and monitor a product’s<br />

temperature, humidity, location, barometric<br />

pressure and if it’s been exposed to light.<br />

ShipmentWatch, FedEx Custom Critical’s<br />

18 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


Big<br />

Data<br />

small monthly fee<br />

with no upfront investment<br />

introducing<br />

as a Service<br />

SkyBitz as a Service includes hardware, TMS integrations, battery<br />

replacements, damage protection, and obsolescence protection.<br />

You get our industry leading analytics tools delivered by the widest range<br />

of cellular and satellite products for a worry-free lifetime of fleet optimization.<br />

SkyBitz as a Service is the easiest and fastest way for your business to<br />

implement trailer tracking without any upfront hardware investment.<br />

Start optimizing your fleet today.<br />

Call for a quote. Terms and conditions apply.<br />

888-698-1733 | skybitz.com/SBS


Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />

SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />

monitoring service, can program SenseAware to customers’ specifications<br />

and use it to track their shipments. All ShipWatch moves are monitored by<br />

a 24/7, 365-days-a-year team, SecureComm.<br />

When something happens, they act. Because, as Custom Critical’s<br />

President and CEO Virginia Albanese said, what good is seeing something<br />

happening if you don’t have the ability to react?<br />

The largest critical shipment carrier in the world, FedEx has its own<br />

security force, who Albanese said work closely with law enforcement,<br />

government enforcement agencies, the Food and Drug Administration,<br />

U.S. Customs and local police. “Our team contacts the correct law<br />

enforcement [agency] to involve authorities quickly to get issues resolved,”<br />

she told <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>.<br />

If the temperature, say, should go out of range, either a back-up<br />

system kicks into gear in the trailer or a replacement trailer is sent to<br />

the scene, said Dave Hill, senior communications specialist for FedEx<br />

Custom Critical.<br />

SenseAware sensors are used on FedEx trucks but can also be used<br />

on other carriers’ trucks or airplanes, as the case may be.<br />

As to that ‘just-in-time assembly line’ mentioned above, Albanese said<br />

SenseAware is being used by one of their customers to track and monitor<br />

kits full of parts and let the customer know when the refurbished parts are<br />

on their way back so that their assembly line can be ready. “They’re using<br />

the [SenseAware] devices to manage their inventories,” she said.<br />

And speaking of management, Alsbrook said data gathered by trailertracking<br />

technology can be used to discover which pieces of equipment<br />

— tires for example — work best with which trailers. Or which brand of<br />

tractors are the best economical fit for a certain trailer, down to the make,<br />

model and year. It’s a way of drilling down further into asset management<br />

and discovering new layers of cost-savings.<br />

“It’s a matter of getting more done with less equipment,” explained Jim<br />

Kennedy, vice president of maintenance for McKenzie Tank Lines. “It’s<br />

pretty important to know what specific tank we have where. We have to<br />

match it up to the specific product. It’s increasing utilization.”<br />

Mitch Otte, operations manager for Taylor Truckline, agreed, noting that<br />

trailer-tracking technology has reduced trailer idle time at his company.<br />

Transportation Services Inc. is using SkyBitz’s subscription-based<br />

solution, SkyBitz as a Service, and its Web-based application, InSight,<br />

not only to gather realtime trailer location data but to perform yard<br />

checks, monitor trailer pools for enhanced utilization and measure fleet<br />

performance metrics to improve maintenance practices.<br />

Indeed, SkyBitz’s Popplewell noted that the use of tracking information<br />

will increasingly be used in predictive analytics or “benchmarking” to look<br />

at the industry as a whole to set acceptable metrics for performance of<br />

the trailer and its components — for example — to benchmark optimum<br />

trailer idle time and bring a fleet’s idle time in line with the industry’s best<br />

practices.<br />

And, of course, there’s always a need to improve cargo security.<br />

And even though technology providers agree that a thief will steal what<br />

he’s made up his mind to steal, they said crooks can be fooled and/or<br />

discouraged from taking a load in the first place.<br />

Most trailer sensors will send a signal to the back office or central<br />

reporting station if they’re tampered with. When that happens, a fleet’s<br />

own security team and/or authorities can immediately follow thieves and<br />

get the cargo back.<br />

But it’s even better if they’re deterred altogether.<br />

Alsbrook offered the idea that tracking sensors could be disguised to<br />

look like other parts of the trailer to prevent thieves from ripping them off,<br />

with Jim Sassen, senior manager of product marketing, adding that he<br />

can see a time coming when trailer OEMs incorporate “covert” sensors<br />

on their trailers that are at once more powerful and more discreet and<br />

harder to detect.<br />

“We learned post-911 the need and desire for higher levels of security<br />

… so we developed more security services to meet those needs,” said<br />

Custom Critical’s Albanese.<br />

Speaking of the SenseAware device, she said, “It can tell a good tale<br />

while it’s out there.”<br />

20 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


<strong>Truckload</strong> trends crucial to you and your business @ DAT.com<br />

The Give and the Get<br />

It’s not 2014, but freight is<br />

strong, although capacity is<br />

much more available than it<br />

was a year ago (see graphic).<br />

We’re seeing more typical, seasonal trends, but<br />

exception freight rates for vans including fuel surcharge<br />

for exception freight were down 5.1% in February<br />

compared to a year ago. Nationally, that’s about a 10¢<br />

difference per mile; the average linehaul rate was<br />

actually 9¢ higher in February <strong>2015</strong> than the previous<br />

year.<br />

prices meant that carriers spent about 18.5¢ less per<br />

mile on fuel compared to 2014.<br />

In partnership with<br />

By Ken Harper, DAT Solutions Marketing Director<br />

4. Win on Fuel Payment Terms<br />

A steep drop in fuel prices can also give carriers a<br />

boost. Contract carriers get paid a fuel surcharge that<br />

varies at the pump, and receive their surcharge based<br />

on last month’s fuel prices. When fuel prices drop<br />

quickly, carriers stay ahead of the falling rate. When<br />

fuel prices rise rapidly, the carrier has the opposite<br />

problem.<br />

Diesel (January <strong>2015</strong>)<br />

Retail Price: $3.00/gallon<br />

You can be assured that shippers are aware of<br />

increased capacity and dropping fuel prices while being<br />

mindful of the pain caused by last year’s Polar Vortex, so<br />

they want to “guarantee” capacity.<br />

The trick for carriers will be the give on fuel vs. the get<br />

on linehaul.<br />

1. <strong>2015</strong>-<strong>2015</strong>: Fuel Comparisons<br />

Diesel averaged $2.90 per gallon nationally at the end of<br />

February, $1.11 less than a year ago. Consequently, the<br />

average fuel surcharge in February <strong>2015</strong> was down to<br />

29¢ per mile, 11¢ lower than last year.<br />

The lower the cost of fuel, the lower the cost of<br />

operations. At an average of 6 MPG, February’s diesel<br />

2. Shippers Come Back to <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

The congestion on rails led shippers to shift more freight<br />

from intermodal rail to trucks during Q3 2014, which<br />

hasn’t happened since 2010. Rail capacity is still tight,<br />

and intermodal costs are affected less by fuel price<br />

fluctuations than by fixed costs like terminal operating<br />

expenses. As lower oil prices reduce the cost gap<br />

between rail and trucks, more shippers could opt for<br />

trucks in <strong>2015</strong>.<br />

3. Driver Availability With oil prices<br />

dropping, so will new oil drilling. The result? Less oilindustry<br />

cargo to move but less competition for drivers<br />

from that sector.<br />

Taxes<br />

Distribution & Marketing<br />

Refining<br />

Crude Oil<br />

16%<br />

33%<br />

13%<br />

38%<br />

What you pay for in a gallon of diesel, from eia.org.


<strong>2015</strong>-04-10 10:46:17 TCA<br />

Game<br />

ChangerPART 2<br />

0612:10-15 L<br />

By Cliff Abbott<br />

The Case for Cameras<br />

In-cab video recording systems have<br />

grown so greatly in popularity that most<br />

carriers — and many drivers — have at<br />

least considered installing them. In the<br />

first “Game Changer” article, published<br />

in the Winter-<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>2015</strong> issue of <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong> magazine, some available<br />

products and potential uses of commercial<br />

video systems were outlined, as well as a<br />

few benefits and pitfalls of using them.<br />

In this, the second article in the Game<br />

Changer series, we’ll present some of the<br />

reasons that every carrier should make<br />

use of this evolving technology. Future articles<br />

will explore some of the pitfalls in<br />

more detail and summarize the information<br />

presented.<br />

Perhaps the most obvious benefit of<br />

video recording products is the protection<br />

they provide against unjustified consequences<br />

of incidents or accidents. Commercial<br />

vehicle drivers often deal with<br />

motorists who contribute to accident risk<br />

with erratic lane changes or sudden stops.<br />

Unfortunately, some truck drivers have<br />

used claims of such actions by others to<br />

explain their involvement in rear-end collisions.<br />

Without a credible witness, a safety<br />

officer’s task of determining fault and<br />

preventability can be nearly impossible.<br />

Accident reports, written by a responding<br />

law enforcement official, often contain<br />

little factual information other than what<br />

vehicles were involved and the details of<br />

place, time, and weather conditions. Narrative<br />

portions of the reports, when completed<br />

at all, record the often contradictory<br />

claims and comments of each party<br />

involved.<br />

Single vehicle accidents can also be<br />

problematic. Some drivers, reluctant to<br />

admit sleepiness or distraction, instead<br />

report swerving to avoid an object or a<br />

head-on collision with another vehicle.<br />

The usual result is that decisions of preventability<br />

are made with an eye toward<br />

erring on the side of safety, assigning<br />

blame to the driver.<br />

Insurance fraud abounds as well. The<br />

well-known “Swoop and Squat” scheme<br />

involves a vehicle that intentionally makes<br />

a sudden lane change and stop — the<br />

“squat,” in front of another vehicle, causing<br />

a rear-end collision. The vehicle usually<br />

contains several passenger-victims who<br />

claim injury. A “swoop” vehicle typically<br />

travels alongside the intended victim, preventing<br />

a lane change prior to impact and<br />

conveniently, a car full of eyewitnesses to<br />

support the fraudulent narrative.<br />

Recorded video provides evidence that<br />

can exonerate both driver and carrier in<br />

these situations. The view from the windshield<br />

supports or refutes the driver’s<br />

claim(s) about the actions of others. Undoubtedly,<br />

that’s a huge selling point for<br />

the personal dash-cameras, sometimes<br />

called “crash cams,” that are now available<br />

at every truck stop.<br />

The downside for carriers is that those<br />

cameras come with a self-contained<br />

memory that the driver owns and controls.<br />

Video segments that exonerate the<br />

driver have a much greater chance of being<br />

shared with the carrier, while evidence<br />

that points toward driver guilt can be withheld<br />

or disappear entirely.<br />

Even when shared, video from personal<br />

units can be of poor quality.<br />

Commercial video systems, however,<br />

provide an array of benefits that personal<br />

dash-cams can’t approach. In some systems,<br />

video is transmitted immediately<br />

after the incident through the vehicle’s<br />

telemetrics system or through cellular or<br />

other means.<br />

Systems that incorporate an inwardfacing<br />

camera can record the driver’s preincident<br />

response, along with behaviors<br />

that may have contributed.<br />

The result can be a much clearer picture<br />

of the events that contributed to a<br />

crash in a format that can be difficult to<br />

refute.<br />

At a general session at the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Carriers Association 77th annual convention<br />

in Kissimmee, Florida, in March, Bob<br />

Peterson, president of Tulsa, Oklahomabased<br />

Melton Truck Lines, discussed his<br />

22 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


support for video recording systems. “I am a table-pounder for<br />

in-cab cameras,” he said.<br />

Peterson provided some details of the part the Lytx Drive-<br />

Cam system played in two greatly different accident situations.<br />

In one, a lawsuit was derailed when a motorist who claimed that<br />

a Melton vehicle had caused a crash was clearly seen in the video<br />

veering into the truck’s lane and striking it. In the other case, a<br />

Melton driver who claimed that a rear-end collision was caused<br />

by a motorist who cut in front and hit the brakes was shown in<br />

the video to be texting just before impact — and carrying an unauthorized<br />

passenger, too.<br />

“If we are doing something wrong,” Peterson explained, “I<br />

want to know so we can do the right thing. I believe those cameras<br />

have more than paid for themselves.”<br />

SmartDrive CEO Steve Mitgang commented: “Drivers and carriers<br />

are often falsely accused when accidents occur and it can<br />

be difficult to defend against. If everyone isn’t tired of that, they<br />

should be.”<br />

He continued, “If we can help a driver exonerate himself and<br />

the fleet, it’s very hard to argue against a system that does<br />

that.”<br />

Costs associated with accidents claim a substantial amount of<br />

a carrier’s operating expenses, and it’s a fact that some carriers<br />

are one catastrophic accident away from closing the doors. Video<br />

systems can help prevent paying accident costs needlessly.<br />

Using a modern video recording system for protection against<br />

false claims, however, is only scratching the surface of the system’s<br />

capabilities. When incidents occur, carriers often must<br />

determine how to respond to driver actions. Egregious actions<br />

usually call for immediate consequences when carriers decide<br />

to remove a driver from the fleet. There are, however, situations<br />

where coaching or additional training can substantially reduce<br />

the risk of keeping that driver behind the wheel. Video can<br />

provide an assist in that determination as well, helping carriers<br />

identify behaviors that should be changed.<br />

With the number of qualified drivers available to the industry<br />

continually shrinking, retention of drivers is a goal of every carrier<br />

in these times. A driver who can be coached to an acceptable<br />

performance level means one less replacement hire the carrier<br />

has to make.<br />

That’s where the predictive analytics that accompany videobased<br />

systems can shine. Using data collected by the vehicle’s<br />

electronic network, analytics can paint a picture of the driver’s<br />

minute-by-minute performance. Most diesel engine manufacturers<br />

utilize the Society of Automotive Engineers J1939 protocol to<br />

allow the engine to communicate with other vehicle components.<br />

Added pressure on the throttle pedal, for example, can signal<br />

the fuel pump to increase flow, the engine compression brake to<br />

turn off, the transmission to downshift one gear, and cause other<br />

system adjustments.<br />

Add-on safety systems like collision-mitigation, lane departure<br />

or roll stability products also communicate through the system.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 23


Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />

SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />

<strong>2015</strong>-05-02 11:34:47 TCA<br />

“Drivers and carriers are often falsely accused<br />

when accidents occur and it can be difficult to<br />

defend against. If everyone isn’t tired of that, they<br />

should be. If we can help a driver exonerate himself<br />

and the fleet, it’s very hard to argue against a<br />

system that does that.”<br />

Every electrical pulse sent through the<br />

system is data that can be captured<br />

and used.<br />

How the data is used depends on<br />

carrier needs, but coaching is a frequent<br />

goal. “This is a tool that is not<br />

designed to be a stick,” said Lytx Vice<br />

President of Safety Services Del Lisk.<br />

“It is designed to be an objective tool<br />

for continuous improvement.”<br />

Clay Merches, vice president of<br />

Safety and Human Resources at J&R<br />

Schugel Trucking, says the Lytx system<br />

provides him with abilities to manage<br />

his team. “I’m a coach with 600 athletes<br />

and I can’t see them play their game,”<br />

he said. “Not only does DriveCam allow<br />

me to see them play, but it allows us to<br />

break down the performance into the<br />

technical aspects of each task.” He described<br />

how a hitting coach in baseball,<br />

for example, can break down a batter’s<br />

swing to identify mechanical things<br />

that need tweaking. “We can identify<br />

what might be only a small piece of a<br />

driver’s performance that could make a<br />

big difference,” he said. “We can identify<br />

which drivers need training; identify<br />

exactly how to target the training, and<br />

even use video of another driver who is<br />

doing it right for training purposes.”<br />

Lisk also used a sports analogy. “My<br />

17-year old son plays high-school football,”<br />

he explained. “On Mondays, the<br />

team reviews video from the most recent<br />

game, not to determine who did<br />

anything wrong but to determine where<br />

to get better.”<br />

Mitgang uses the sports vernacular,<br />

too. “Carriers want to be proactive<br />

in managing risk, helping drivers make<br />

sure they bring their ‘A’ game every day,”<br />

he said. “In sports, game films are used<br />

every day to make sure the team is getting<br />

the most recent feedback.”<br />

The SmartDrive system, according to<br />

Mitgang, uses 70 different data points to<br />

- Steve Mitgang, SmartDrive CEO<br />

0892:16-15 P<br />

create a portrait of driver activity, with an<br />

additional capability. Mitgang explained<br />

that “Unlike some of our competitors,<br />

our platform is an open platform. That<br />

means we’re not restricted to only working<br />

with systems that fit our platform.<br />

We can determine what the most important<br />

video today is, and design a way to<br />

obtain that video.”<br />

SmartDrive systems have been<br />

adapted, according to Mitgang, to monitor<br />

such activities as handling hoses and<br />

fittings during a petroleum delivery and<br />

monitoring a backhoe operation to ensure<br />

that pedestrians stay clear.<br />

The Lytx DriveCam system incorporates<br />

more than 100 data points. These<br />

include such common occurrences as<br />

hard braking, hard acceleration and<br />

speeding, but can also include just about<br />

any information collected or transmitted<br />

by the vehicle’s system, including some<br />

the company doesn’t make public.<br />

Bryan Cook, vice president of Business<br />

Intelligence and Analytics at Lytx,<br />

said the company compares captured<br />

data with accident information to pinpoint<br />

what behaviors are related. “For<br />

example,” he said, “if we look at a triggering<br />

event like hard braking, and cell<br />

phone use turns up with equal frequency<br />

2018-06-08 12:05:07 TCA<br />

between collision and non-collision drivers,<br />

we know that behavior isn’t predictive.”<br />

Cook explained that Lytx, with more<br />

current subscriptions for video management<br />

systems than all its competitors<br />

combined, uses data from multiple customers<br />

to obtain larger sample sizes.<br />

The data, he explained, can be grouped<br />

by selected parameters to determine<br />

what is most applicable to a particular<br />

customer. Data from carriers who run local<br />

delivery routes, for example, can be<br />

excluded from data used to analyze an<br />

over-the-road carrier.<br />

Most systems allow carrier input into<br />

the algorithms used to calculate risk.<br />

The Lytx DriveCam system, according to<br />

Merches, “had a baseline for analytics,<br />

about a hundred points of measurement,<br />

if I recall. I was able to go in and adjust<br />

those triggers that are important to us.”<br />

Merches described a process where<br />

his team rode in several different models<br />

of tractor pulling both van and refrigerated<br />

trailers to determine a triggering<br />

point for G-forces.<br />

The analytics provided by the Bendix<br />

Safety Direct system are also customizable,<br />

according to TJ Thomas, director of<br />

marketing and customer solutions. “The<br />

customer specifies weights for each type<br />

of incident and the results are used for a<br />

Driver Division Report,” he said.<br />

Predictive analytics provides a way<br />

to identify the drivers who are at highest<br />

risk, enabling the carrier to intervene<br />

before an accident occurs. Most<br />

of the systems provide some form of<br />

scorecard that can be used to determine<br />

where attention is needed and<br />

help pinpoint training needs.<br />

G & P Trucking Director of Safety<br />

John Billingsley says his company<br />

“Not only does DriveCam allow me to see them play,<br />

but it allows us to break down the performance<br />

into the technical aspects of each task. We can<br />

identify what might be only a small piece of a<br />

driver’s performance that could make a big<br />

difference.”<br />

- Clay Merches, Vice President of Safety and Human<br />

Resources, J&R Schugel Trucking<br />

0662:11-15 L<br />

24 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


A D V E R T I S E M E N T<br />

TA and Petro Announce Citizen Driver Award Honorees<br />

March, <strong>2015</strong><br />

WESTLAKE, Ohio<br />

In his 27 years on the road, Richard Ash, from<br />

Lakewood, Colorado, has traveled 2.8 million<br />

accident-free miles. A strong believer in paying<br />

it forward, Rick helps out his elderly neighbors<br />

by shoveling snow and checking in on them<br />

<br />

Kisses to fuel attendants, toll booth operators,<br />

and others—a simple act of kindness that lets<br />

these folks know he appreciates them. He is a<br />

life member of OOIDA, chairman and founder of<br />

Trucking Solutions Group, an annual volunteer<br />

at Feed My Starving Children in Denver, and a<br />

member of Trucker Buddy International. Rick<br />

stands out as a highly-polished professional,<br />

assisting others to be the best they can be. He<br />

<br />

one another to move the entire trucking industry<br />

forward.<br />

Gary Buchs, from Colfax, Illinois, has been<br />

driving professionally for over 25 years. He has<br />

logged 2.25 million miles without an accident.<br />

He is a man of deep faith with a strong moral<br />

compass, and follows this in all he does. Gary<br />

is extremely attentive to his family. When his<br />

son was deployed to Afghanistan, Gary took a<br />

full year off from driving and moved from Illinois<br />

to Hawaii to become a full-time caregiver to<br />

his grandchildren. He is 9-time winner of the<br />

Landstar Star of Quality Award, as well as the<br />

recipient of a Platinum Star, awarded after he<br />

came upon a car accident, and stopped to help.<br />

He pried the car door open and pulled a woman<br />

out, saving her life.<br />

<br />

behind the wheel for over 21 years and 2.5<br />

<br />

is very committed to safety and has received<br />

multiple driving and safety awards in his career.<br />

He participates in the Maine State Truck Driving<br />

Championships, which has stringent safety<br />

requirements. Participants must remain accident,<br />

incident and violation free for the previous year<br />

to compete. Rob is a 4-time State Champion<br />

in multiple classes of competition. He supports<br />

many charities, including New England Truck<br />

<br />

Kids Charity, Special Olympics Convoy, Pull<br />

A Plane for Wounded Warriors and Wreaths<br />

Across America. He is also a former Trucker<br />

Buddy, speaking with school children via penpal,<br />

then visiting them with a truck at the end of<br />

the school year.<br />

Sandy Long, from Marceline, Missouri has<br />

<br />

3 millions miles without an accident! This has<br />

earned her 3 different safety awards from 3<br />

<br />

more responsible or more positive about her<br />

profession—and she still makes caring for her<br />

elderly mother a priority. Sandy is a Senior<br />

Life member of OOIDA. She is a staff writer<br />

for ExpediteNow/Road Gorilla magazines<br />

and Canadian Trucking Magazine, and has<br />

<br />

Magazine, as well as maintaining her own<br />

popular blog. She is a charter and active<br />

member of the Women in Trucking Association,<br />

<br />

nominee in 2013.<br />

Former Marine Micheal Sheeds is from Bandera<br />

Texas, and has driven over 3 million accidentfree<br />

miles in 25 years. September 6 will mark<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

to offer. Mike is a leader, a Christian, and allows<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

free all the passengers until paramedics arrived.<br />

He is active in his PTO, regularly gives blood,<br />

and donates books. He and his wife, Donna,<br />

have adopted four daughters through foster<br />

care. He has spent countless hours advocating<br />

for change and assistance for foster children, as<br />

well as volunteering with a post-adoption support<br />

group. He is also involved in the Trucker Buddy<br />

program.<br />

A D V E R T I S E M E N T


The road to<br />

protecting<br />

your fleet<br />

Insurance Brokers & Consultants<br />

Transportation Insurance Specialists<br />

Since 1970<br />

888-313-3226 Offices in PA, MD, SC<br />

www.ecbm.com<br />

Sponsored by SKYBITz<br />

SKYBITz.com | 866.922.4708<br />

looked at two manufacturers and chose SmartDrive “mostly<br />

due to their back-office systems.” He continued, “The information<br />

provided is something that we’ve never gotten<br />

before.” Billingsley likes the system’s ability to score driving<br />

performance. “It allows us to home in on driving habits,” he<br />

said. “A guy can see his own score on a smartphone.”<br />

Mitgang described a widespread situation at one carrier<br />

that video helped to correct. Automatic application of the<br />

vehicle’s roll stability system had triggered video recording<br />

that indicated that drivers were entering curved exit ramps<br />

with the cruise control engaged, relying on the system to<br />

slow the vehicle to safe speeds. While such confidence in<br />

the system might be a plus for the manufacturer, it isn’t the<br />

safest way to operate the vehicle. Using the data collected,<br />

the carrier was able to address the problem.<br />

Using the captured video for training purposes is another<br />

benefit of recording systems. Safety Vision Account Executive<br />

David Wehmeyer thinks video is valuable for teaching.<br />

“The best training tool is to let the driver watch himself<br />

drive,” he said. “It’s a great tool.”<br />

In fact, many carriers are using the driver’s own video<br />

image to coach and train the driver. At G&P, a former driver<br />

was hired as a full-time driver coach. “His goal and ours,”<br />

said Billingsley, “is to take good drivers and make them into<br />

great drivers.”<br />

Con-way Freight has developed a system that utilizes<br />

their most experienced drivers to coach others. Peter Ferguson,<br />

a 30-year veteran, talked about his company’s use<br />

of the DriveCam system at the 2014 American Trucking Associations<br />

Management Conference and Exhibition in San<br />

Diego, California. “Using peers to do the coaching makes it<br />

easier because the drivers don’t feel as threatened,” he said.<br />

“I tell them ‘it’s just you and I.’”<br />

Ferguson said that drivers often approach him to discuss<br />

an event. “They know something was recorded, and sometimes<br />

they want to get a perspective on whether they reacted<br />

in the right way,” he explained.<br />

In addition to individual coaching, video can be used to<br />

educate groups on the wrong — or the right way — of doing<br />

things.<br />

The Bendix Safety Direct system, according to Thomas,<br />

displays video separately from other vehicle information<br />

such as speed or turn-signal use so that the behavior can<br />

be observed without identifying the driver. “So if the video is<br />

used, for example, in a safety meeting, no one can tell which<br />

truck or driver it came from,” he said.<br />

Once the training is administered, the carrier can monitor<br />

driver scorecards to validate the success of the training. If<br />

the training was created to address a specific problem, the<br />

data should show a reduction in occurrences of the problem<br />

after the training is delivered. For example, incidents of hard<br />

braking caused by following too closely should decline if the<br />

training was effective.<br />

Finally, every carrier benefits from a positive safety image.<br />

Improvement of a company’s safety record is the most<br />

obvious image builder, but the message sent by an investment<br />

in video technology isn’t lost on lawmakers, insurance<br />

providers or juries.<br />

While installation of video cameras in trucks can create<br />

an initial backlash from drivers, the improved safety record<br />

and opportunity for performance improvement they supply<br />

can provide tools for retaining current drivers and recruiting<br />

new ones.<br />

Whether the goal is self protection, performance improvement<br />

or positive image projection, managed video systems<br />

can be the answer.<br />

26 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org


Mind<br />

our<br />

Maintenance<br />

Battling the basics<br />

By Cliff Abbott<br />

New feature exclusive to<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>!<br />

Keeping your tractors and trailers operating at peak<br />

efficiency and your Vehicle Maintenance BASIC score in<br />

check are critically important to your business’s bottom<br />

line. In this issue, <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> begins a recurring<br />

series, “Mind Your Maintenance,” that will offer insight on<br />

how to maintain peak performance at all times and drive<br />

profitability.<br />

hile carriers attempt to make changes<br />

in the Federal Motor Carrier Safety<br />

Administration’s Compliance, Safety<br />

and Accountability program, Kerri Wirachowsky<br />

thinks they could be doing more to impact their<br />

own CSA scores in the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC<br />

category.<br />

The head of Enforcement Program Evaluation<br />

for the Carrier Enforcement Program Office of the<br />

Ontario Ministry of Transportation, Wirachowsky is<br />

also chair of the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance<br />

(CVSA) Vehicle Committee. In that role, she oversees<br />

a team that is responsible for how vehicle inspections<br />

are conducted and for making updates to the<br />

North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria.<br />

While CVSA is not a part of the CSA program,<br />

inspections conducted under its guidance definitely<br />

impact CSA scores, and that’s where Wirachowsky<br />

feels carriers can help their own cause.<br />

Wirachowsky recently addressed a group of<br />

trucking maintenance executives at the Technology<br />

and Maintenance Council’s annual meeting and<br />

later spoke with <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> in an exclusive<br />

interview.<br />

A review of the top 25 for-hire trucking companies<br />

revealed scores in the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC<br />

ranging from the low teens to well above the intervention<br />

threshold.<br />

Some of that disparity might be explained by<br />

operational differences. Carriers who count a large<br />

percentage of independent contractors in their fleets,<br />

for example, could have a smaller impact on the<br />

equipment of owner-operators who are responsible<br />

for their own maintenance. Those with large numbers<br />

of local routes may see equipment at company<br />

maintenance facilities much more often than carriers<br />

who keep large numbers of trailers in pools at remote<br />

customer locations.<br />

Still, some carriers may be contributing negatively<br />

to their own vehicle maintenance scores by not addressing<br />

a few simple items.<br />

The first is driver education.<br />

“I think drivers who don’t identify violations on<br />

their trucks belong in one of two categories,” Wirachowsky<br />

said in the interview. “One, they don’t do a<br />

proper daily inspection at all or, two, they’re doing the<br />

best they can but just don’t know what to look for.”<br />

As an example of the latter, Wirachowsky points<br />

to brake inspections. “Brake adjustment is always<br />

a part of the top 10 percent of violations,” she said.<br />

“But when you ask a driver what size of brake<br />

chamber is on his truck’s steer axle, most don’t have<br />

a clue. How can they be expected to know what the<br />

push-rod travel should be if they don’t even know<br />

what’s on their truck?”<br />

She explained that many items, including brakes,<br />

can be inspected by the driver without physically<br />

crawling under the vehicle. “The driver,” she said, “is<br />

basically responsible for things they can find while<br />

walking around the truck.” She explained that most<br />

brakes are equipped with an indicator that can be<br />

seen without crawling. “If you can bend over and<br />

look to the other side, you can see the indicator.”<br />

At the TMC meeting, Wirachowsky explained the<br />

double hit that carriers take for brake adjustment<br />

violations. The out-of-adjustment brake violates two<br />

provisions of the regulations: one that says push-rod<br />

travel must be within legal parameters and another<br />

that requires working automatic slack adjusters on<br />

vehicles manufactured after Oct. 20, 1994. If the<br />

brake is out of adjustment, then that automatic adjuster<br />

isn’t working. Four weighting “points” are assigned<br />

to each violation, plus an additional two if the<br />

infraction is serious enough to put the vehicle OOS.<br />

The potential resulting weight of 10 is then multiplied<br />

by a time weight factor of three, adding 30 points to<br />

the carrier’s Vehicle Maintenance BASIC calculation<br />

for the next six months. The time weighting factor<br />

drops to two after six months and drops again to one<br />

after a year, causing the impact of the violations to<br />

decrease over time, but Wirachowsky notes that the<br />

points could have been avoided altogether.<br />

With so much of a carrier’s score in the Vehicle<br />

Maintenance BASIC riding on the driver, Wirachowsky<br />

detailed a huge disparity between daily driver<br />

inspections and law enforcement roadside inspection<br />

results. “In 25 years of inspecting commercial motor<br />

vehicles,” she said, “I find that 99 percent of drivers<br />

indicate no violations on the daily vehicle inspection<br />

report while 20 to 25 percent of trucks fail the<br />

[roadside] inspection. Something doesn’t match up!”<br />

she concluded.<br />

She noted that in the U.S., for most CMVs a DVIR<br />

is no longer required if no discrepancies are found,<br />

but that the daily inspection is still mandatory, even if<br />

the paperwork isn’t. “I tell drivers, ‘if you did a good<br />

pre-trip inspection every day, I’d be bored out of my<br />

mind.’”<br />

Part of the problem, Wirachowsky said, is that<br />

“automatic” slack adjusters can give the truck<br />

owner a false sense of security. “They still have to<br />

be checked,” she said, “even if they’re automatic.<br />

If they’re out of adjustment, the technician needs<br />

to find out why.” She explained that if technicians<br />

manually adjust the brake and send the truck out,<br />

“whatever made it go out will happen again.”<br />

According to data shared in Wirachowsky’s TMC<br />

presentation, out-of-adjustment brakes resulted in<br />

194,284 violations in 2014 inspections. Combined<br />

with 389,660 other brake violations, the total was just<br />

shy of 584,000 violations.<br />

During the annual Brake Safety Week conducted<br />

by CVSA, the 2014 results showed 16.2 percent of<br />

vehicles inspected were placed OOS, compared<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 27


with 13.5 percent in 2013. It should be noted that<br />

jurisdictional participation and selection criteria were<br />

not consistent across the reported years; however,<br />

there’s still cause for concern.<br />

Returning to roadside inspections for all of 2014,<br />

violations involving head, tail or brake lights were<br />

responsible for a whopping 823,540 violations, with<br />

nearly 75,000 resulting in a vehicle placed OOS.<br />

Those violations hit CSA scores even harder than<br />

brakes, weighted at six points each plus another two<br />

for OOS violations.<br />

Another 545,500 violations were issued for inoperative<br />

clearance lights, weighted at two points each.<br />

During her Nashville presentation, Wirachowsky<br />

noted that LED lighting could drastically reduce the<br />

number of violations because of its durability and<br />

because, when it fails, it typically does gradually<br />

rather than all at once. A taillight, for example, can<br />

still shine brightly enough to meet legal requirements,<br />

even with some of its diodes not functioning.<br />

“A driver can see that a light needs replacing before<br />

it fails entirely,” Wirachowsky explained.<br />

A violation that’s becoming more common is missing<br />

or damaged conspicuity tape. “Trailers equipped<br />

with conspicuity tape are now showing some age,”<br />

said Wirachowsky. “After bumping the dock a few<br />

hundred times, there could be some damage.”<br />

Violations for missing, unsecured or discharged<br />

fire extinguishers and missing flares or triangles have<br />

been occurring for years.<br />

While daily vehicle inspections are part of the solution,<br />

Wirachowsky notes that drivers aren’t trained in<br />

maintenance and inspections to the extent they are<br />

in other areas. “More training of the drivers in vehicle<br />

components would be helpful,” she said. “The driver<br />

is the carrier’s No. 1 line of defense.”<br />

Comparing maintenance regulations with others<br />

the driver is responsible for, she said, “If drivers don’t<br />

understand the Hours of Service, they can get by because<br />

the operations people dispatch them within the<br />

rules. If they don’t know the regulations on vehicle<br />

maintenance, they’re out there in unsafe trucks.”<br />

When drivers know the regulations and report vehicle<br />

deficiencies to their carrier, a problem can still<br />

exist. Some drivers are reluctant to report violations<br />

if they lack confidence that the item will be repaired.<br />

Others fear that reporting a defect means they’ll be<br />

delayed, without additional pay, at a repair facility, an<br />

especially unsavory outcome if the problem happens<br />

to be on a trailer dropped by another driver.<br />

Increasing the number of rules, by regulation or by<br />

carrier policy, is one potential answer.<br />

“In Ontario, we require daily inspections according<br />

to a published schedule,” Wirachowsky explained.<br />

“For minor violations, if the driver writes it up and it<br />

doesn’t get fixed, we hold the carrier responsible.”<br />

Programs that reward the driver for identifying<br />

problems and working with the carrier to get them<br />

repaired could be another solution. Unfortunately,<br />

such programs are rare.<br />

When violations are found, too often they aren’t<br />

taken seriously by the carrier or truck owner, she said.<br />

“Too many truck owners don’t want to fix something<br />

until it’s an OOS,” she explained. “Don’t wait until a<br />

problem is an OOS item before repairing it.”<br />

Even when confronted with a violation at an<br />

inspection, carriers can be indifferent, according to<br />

Wirachowsky. “I’ve had drivers with violations call their<br />

carriers and they get asked, ‘is it an OOS violation?’ If<br />

it isn’t, they tell the driver to leave it. If you drive, you’re<br />

still in violation,” she said.<br />

An example she provided is a trailer with an inoperative<br />

tail light. Although in violation, the vehicle isn’t<br />

OOS until the other one quits, too. “Would you repair<br />

the one that’s out, or just wait until the other one goes<br />

out, too, so you’ll be OOS?” Wirachowsky asked.<br />

When the truck does go into the shop for repairs,<br />

components that need or will soon need attention can<br />

be overlooked in an effort to get the equipment rolling<br />

quickly. Wirachowsky said that it was common for her<br />

to identify a brake problem such as worn linings on<br />

one wheel, only to have the driver point to the wheel<br />

on the other side and tell her it had recently been repaired.<br />

“Wouldn’t you think they’d look at the other end<br />

of the same axle while it was in the shop?” she asked.<br />

A thorough inspection process during regularly<br />

scheduled preventive maintenance is critical, but<br />

can be supplemented by an inspection process<br />

that accompanies an unscheduled repair. A tire<br />

replacement, for example, is an excellent opportunity<br />

to inspect all the tires. Any repairs requiring the<br />

vehicle to be placed on a lift should automatically<br />

include inspection of other parts that perform the<br />

same function.<br />

When it comes to maintenance, improved driver<br />

education, quick attention to items in violation and<br />

thorough inspection processes both in the shop and<br />

on the road can go a long way toward a better score in<br />

the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC of CSA.<br />

WE VALUE THE SAFETY OF YOUR<br />

COMPANY AND YOUR DRIVERS<br />

We give you tools to reduce crashes and save lives. Our safety<br />

professionals are there to consult with you on your company’s safety<br />

program which includes assisting you with your regularly scheduled<br />

educational seminars, keeping you informed on the latest safety and risk<br />

management techniques and regulatory changes in the trucking industry.<br />

We understand your business. Since trucking is all we do, we know<br />

the importance of keeping your trucks moving safely. Our Value-<br />

Driven® Company program, which includes modules on safe driving,<br />

health, leadership, and operations, is designed to easily help you<br />

create and maintain a safety culture within your organization.<br />

We help keep you moving. We provide your drivers with techniques<br />

to improve the overall driving experience with tips on staying<br />

alert, eating right, proper lifting, and getting enough exercise.<br />

SAFETY IS<br />

OUR PASSION<br />

Great West Casualty Company — No matter where the<br />

road takes you, we’re with you for the long haul.<br />

GREAT WEST CASUALTY COMPANY<br />

The Difference is Service<br />

Not available in all states. All policy terms, conditions,<br />

<br />

<br />

TO FIND AN AGENT VISIT GWCCNET.COM<br />

AND CLICK ON “FIND AN AGENT”<br />

800-228-8053<br />

800-228-8053<br />

gwccnet.com<br />

gwccnet.com<br />

28 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

GWCC_SFTY_HP_COL_TCA_14.indd 1<br />

2/25/2014 2:09:38 PM


<strong>Spring</strong> | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

Member Mailroom<br />

“What can I do as a <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />

Association member to become more<br />

involved in the regulatory process?”<br />

Contact your<br />

Congressman<br />

or Senator<br />

Get involved in<br />

FMCSA feedback<br />

Be informed — read <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong><br />

and The <strong>Truckload</strong> Carrier Report<br />

The answer to this question that I receive most often<br />

is both simple and complex. The simple part comes by<br />

just staying on top of information as it happens. Be sure<br />

to read <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>, TCA’s official magazine, and<br />

The <strong>Truckload</strong> Carrier Report, TCA’s weekly e-newsletter.<br />

Both are an excellent recap of the most recent news<br />

and provide a good synopsis for our members to gather<br />

information as it relates to their fleets. It has been my<br />

experience that sound policy and good debate will almost<br />

always happen when people are informed and that<br />

is the simple way a member can help with the regulatory<br />

process. But that, of course, does not always answer<br />

the questions that members are asking. The complex<br />

answer comes by being more involved.<br />

Carriers become more involved in the regulatory<br />

process by providing feedback and comments to rules<br />

as they are issued by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety<br />

Administration. While many at the agency enjoy their<br />

conversations with me from time to time, they much<br />

prefer to hear from the folks that practice truck safety<br />

on the roads every day. You, as a carrier member, will<br />

almost always provide real world insight to an issue<br />

that you encounter often, sometimes even daily.<br />

Continuing along the path of regulatory involvement,<br />

I encourage members to regularly meet with<br />

your congressional representation. Again, while TCA<br />

is a trade association, in my experience, it goes a long<br />

way when your Senator or Congressperson can schedule<br />

a visit to your home terminal to see exactly how<br />

trucking works. After all, you do operate in their districts<br />

and employ their constituents.<br />

Does this work? Does being involved really have an<br />

impact? Yes, yes, yes and inevitably, yes. An informed<br />

and involved member makes all the difference in the<br />

world. Involvement helps almost exponentially, if I can<br />

describe it that way. The recent Hours of Service regulations<br />

contained over 25,000 comments to the rule. We,<br />

as an industry, spoke and our voices were heard. We<br />

spoke to our representatives and everyone else that was<br />

involved about how the rules didn’t work and eventually<br />

the restart provision was suspended in an effort to collect<br />

new data and write a rule that makes sense.<br />

Member involvement in the regulatory process<br />

needs to happen in order to be a more robust and<br />

active association. A trade association, by its very<br />

nature, must be involved in the rulemaking process<br />

by communicating its message and policies because<br />

its members strongly believe in them. As part of an<br />

industry that hauled 74 percent of the freight in this<br />

nation in 2012, we clearly have a seat at the table<br />

when it comes to the rulemaking process. That being<br />

said, now is the time to make an impression upon<br />

the people that actually make the decisions, Congress<br />

and FMCSA, so that they can become more informed<br />

about the impact of their rule on us, as well.<br />

— Dave Heller<br />

Director, Safety and Policy<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 29


spring | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

A Chat With The Chairman<br />

Happy<br />

Warrior<br />

Foreword and Interview by Micah Jackson<br />

“Welcome to Toledo,” he said with a smile as wide as a mid-summer’s day is long. As a lifelong Toledo, Ohio, native this is the city<br />

that molded and shaped TCA Chairman Keith Tuttle. A once-vibrant economic hub that boasted some of the largest and most successful<br />

companies in the world, it has seen the technological revolution of the past two decades erode its blue collar manufacturing foundation<br />

and starve its economic engine. It’s a harsh reality that didn’t deter Chairman Tuttle during our recent “Chat” while he navigated the<br />

streets of downtown and passionately expounded on the history of the area and its on-going revitalization efforts. It’s the same passion<br />

he displayed during lunch the next day at the prestigious downtown Toledo Club when he talked about the trucking industry and<br />

the essential role the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association plays in it.<br />

From his easygoing charm to his penchant for telling humorous stories at a moment’s notice (fictional and non-fictional alike),<br />

Chairman Tuttle is best described as a man of principle and passion. His devotion to fighting for the causes he believes in can be most<br />

easily seen in his service to the Shriners, even serving as Potentate last year. Whether it is the health and well-being of sick and injured<br />

children, the revitalization of his hometown or the struggle to reduce burdensome regulations and promote increased involvement<br />

by trucking industry stakeholders, one fact is crystal clear: Chairman Tuttle is the quintessential “Happy Warrior.”<br />

Thank you, Mr. Chairman for joining us for the first Chat under<br />

your chairmanship. Please tell readers when and why you<br />

became passionate about the trucking industry.<br />

From a young age trucking is just about all I’ve ever known. You<br />

don’t have to be the sharpest tool in the shed to be passionate about<br />

something you really believe in. Any issue in our industry you have<br />

to be passionate about because the average person has no idea how<br />

critical and how vital and how relevant this industry is. We drive the<br />

economy, that’s all there is to it.<br />

What is it about trucking that you find most enjoyable?<br />

It’s all about the people. That’s all there is to it, it’s all about the<br />

people. I’ve known many people who’ve tried and tried again. Some<br />

of them haven’t done as well as others in this industry, but Kathy<br />

(wife) and I have had some amazing success in our own business<br />

and as we’ve become involved with the different associations, I’ve<br />

had the opportunity to work alongside some amazing people. In fact,<br />

there are a couple of people who started with me over 30 years ago<br />

with nothing more than a vision and a couple of empty pockets that<br />

we’re still together with every day at birthday parties, weddings and<br />

unfortunately the older I get, too many funerals. There are so many<br />

stories I can tell you about hardworking guys with a dream and a<br />

tremendous attitude — I can name 50 of them — who have built<br />

incredible companies and they all know that nothing in this business<br />

is easy. In some cases it took more than one try to get it right and<br />

be successful. But it’s all about the people. That’s what I find more<br />

enjoyable than anything else.<br />

You are a lifelong and proud Toledo, Ohio, native. What values<br />

did you learn growing up that have served you well in the<br />

trucking business?<br />

There are two values more than any other passed down through<br />

our family and hopefully down to my own children that have served<br />

me well in whatever success I’ve had in trucking, and those would<br />

be personal relationships and just plain hard work. I’m going to relate<br />

that my grandfather, who passed away before I was born, was<br />

in sales and management during his 30 years in the industry with a<br />

number of different LTL carriers until the early 1950s. My own father<br />

for many years was in LTL sales and management, and split his time<br />

between Chicago and Cleveland before ending up in Toledo, Ohio,<br />

where he went to work for an LTL carrier and started a family. I<br />

will tell you that my mom and dad were constantly entertaining<br />

customers and hosting other guys in transportation sales in<br />

our little house in Toledo — a house with one bathroom<br />

and a family of seven, five kids and mom and dad.<br />

Back in the late 1960s and early 1970s, Toledo<br />

and northwest Ohio was home to a number of<br />

30 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


Sponsored by


Sponsored by Mcleod software<br />

McLeodSoftware.com | 877.362.5363<br />

Fortune 500 companies, a lot of which have<br />

moved out and gone to the South, and trucking<br />

was a vibrant part of that success story.<br />

Back in the early ’70s when I got my nose<br />

bloodied and started to learn a lot about this<br />

business, there were 174 LTL carriers with a<br />

presence in the Toledo area. And as my dad<br />

would later say, everyone’s rates were set by<br />

the government and were pretty much the<br />

same, so the freight would go to whomever<br />

the traffic manager had the best relationship<br />

with.<br />

I can remember early in my career when<br />

I had a very small fleet I made multiple sales<br />

calls on a major food manufacturer in Napoleon,<br />

Ohio, and it wasn’t until I got the guts<br />

up to ask this traffic manager and his wife to<br />

dinner that he loosened up and we became<br />

great friends and he began to offer us the<br />

pick of whatever freight he had. We became<br />

lifelong friends and he attended many of my<br />

kids’ birthday parties and graduation parties<br />

and it wasn’t too many years ago that I<br />

went to see him in a retirement center in Las<br />

Vegas and soon after lost him as a very good<br />

friend and business associate. I really miss a<br />

lot of things this industry used to have and a<br />

lot of those are the close personal relationships<br />

that were built over many, many years.<br />

We seem in some cases to have gone from<br />

a world of great personal relationships to<br />

impersonal e-mails, text messages, national<br />

freight bids and the loads going to whomever<br />

is the lowest cost. Most of the face-to-face<br />

personal relationships from a carrier/shipper<br />

relationship have in some cases gone away,<br />

which makes this association we belong to<br />

and the networking opportunities and the<br />

great working relationships that a lot of us<br />

in this association have even more special to<br />

me.<br />

For our carrier members and those folks<br />

who are going to read this article, that’s one<br />

of the greatest things about the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Carriers Association. I can call guys from the<br />

smallest carriers — a lot smaller than we are<br />

— to the Robert Low’s of the world for whom<br />

I have deepest respect, and we can talk<br />

about things. And it’s because of my involvement<br />

with TCA that those avenues have been<br />

open to me. And for that, I’m grateful to this<br />

association.<br />

In this business, you better not be afraid<br />

to work and work hard and I’m sure like everybody<br />

else who is going to read this, this<br />

is not an 8-to-5 business. I still have my CDL<br />

and it wasn’t too long ago that I would ride<br />

along with our drivers and maybe even drive<br />

on the way back. When we were just starting<br />

the company I would spend Friday and Saturday<br />

nights shuttling trailers to one of our<br />

major food customers so our over-the-road<br />

drivers could get a break in their schedule.<br />

And seeing the guy who was putting out dollars<br />

to buy trucks, the guy whose tail was on<br />

the line, seeing him work right alongside of<br />

you, I believe that added to the credibility of<br />

what we were trying to build as a company.<br />

I wasn’t just the guy who was meeting with<br />

the bankers. I could also put the boots on<br />

and run through the gears and work hard<br />

alongside the rest of those guys. And I think<br />

that’s helped me a lot being able to relate to<br />

drivers and others, some of whom are still<br />

here 35 years after we started the company.<br />

I grew up sweeping shop floors and<br />

changing oils in trucks, and I still know how<br />

to break down a tire. But I will tell you I still<br />

remember my first rides in a big truck and I<br />

don’t think that thrill will ever, ever be gone.<br />

I probably sacrificed a little time with my<br />

kids. I went to ballgames and such, but I<br />

spent most of the day Saturday in the office,<br />

and Sundays after church trying to build a<br />

business and our relationship with banks and<br />

customers and so forth. I can tell you that in<br />

high school I worked on the freight docks for<br />

various LTL companies. I got a job working at<br />

nights for a trucking company while in college<br />

that was a major automotive truckload carrier<br />

that’s still around. And that job absolutely<br />

helped me pay for college. Deregulation in<br />

1980 brought many of those LTL carriers<br />

to their knees and put most of them out of<br />

business. I was around when that same deregulation<br />

brought tremendous opportunities<br />

to the truckload carriers that have become<br />

incredible success stories. We can’t be afraid<br />

of competition because for every story of<br />

incredible success, I’ve also had friends in<br />

this business who have experienced tremendous<br />

financial hardship. That’s the way our<br />

American free enterprise system works and<br />

contrary to what some people in Washington,<br />

DC, think, that system needs to continue to<br />

grow and prosper.<br />

32 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>


For the readers who are not aware, the<br />

carrier to which you refer is Motor<br />

Carrier Service (MCS). It has been a huge<br />

part of your career. What are the things<br />

you are most proud of having led MCS<br />

for so long?<br />

There’s absolutely no question when I<br />

think about this: We always put safety in<br />

front of growth at Motor Carrier Service. We<br />

don’t pay lip service to safety at MCS. It’s in<br />

the fabric of everything we do. I give a lot of<br />

credit for that to my COO John Fritzius and<br />

his team. We’ve received numerous safety<br />

awards. One of our customers, a major<br />

Fortune 100 company, has used our safety<br />

scores and our safety program as a benchmark<br />

that they use to grade all the other<br />

carriers they do business with. Hundreds of<br />

other carriers are measured based on the<br />

benchmarks from our company. Twice in the<br />

last eight years, MCS was named the overall<br />

winner in our Insurance Captive and that’s a<br />

feat that we are extremely proud of. We beat<br />

out 70 of the safest trucking companies in<br />

the country. I can tell you to be named best<br />

of the best among this esteemed group is a<br />

huge testimonial to the hard work of John<br />

and his team and I give them all the credit.<br />

I would be remiss if I didn’t bring up our<br />

little company being named a five-time winner<br />

of TCA’s Best Fleets to Drive For competition,<br />

one of only three companies that have<br />

been named a winner five times. We were<br />

named the overall Best Fleet to Drive For<br />

in 2012. This is a grueling, comprehensive<br />

process that absolutely validates the great<br />

strides our company has made as well as all<br />

of the other nominees and companies have<br />

continued to make. I’ve heard some carriers<br />

say they don’t want to be nominated because<br />

they don’t want to be put through the<br />

process and don’t want to be evaluated on<br />

everything they do. But I do think for the carriers<br />

whose drivers recommend them, it really<br />

validates what a great job these carriers<br />

are doing in taking care of their drivers. Our<br />

driver turnover rate continues to be between<br />

25 and 30 percent a year. I still consider that<br />

unacceptable, but it’s a lot better than most<br />

others in our industry, although I will tell you<br />

we still have a lot of work to do. TCA’s Best<br />

Fleets program that’s hosted by TCA and CarriersEdge<br />

is gaining momentum and I’d love<br />

to see 300 carriers nominated by their drivers<br />

next year, up from the 150 nominated this<br />

past year.<br />

Tell <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> readers how<br />

and why you got involved in TCA.<br />

I can tell you we were involved with the<br />

Ohio Trucking Association long before the<br />

TCA. It was apparent that the guys doing well<br />

financially and the guys in the truckload business<br />

who really seemed to know what they<br />

were doing, the common thread was that<br />

they were members of TCA. A guy named<br />

Dick Durst runs Artic Express of Columbus,<br />

Ohio. I was on the board of directors of the<br />

Ohio Trucking Association with Dick and Dick<br />

told me what a great association the TCA<br />

was. Guys before me like Kevin Burch, Ray<br />

Haight and Barry Pottle were instrumental in<br />

urging me and our company to become more<br />

involved in TCA. And as they’ve said and as<br />

Duff Swain, founder of Trincon Associates, a<br />

consulting group in Columbus, Ohio, told me,<br />

“Keith, if you really want to raise the bar in<br />

your company, get involved in TCA” because<br />

as our mission statement says and as our<br />

strategic plan says, we are the only association<br />

whose sole focus is the truckload segment<br />

of the motor carrier industry. For me,<br />

John and our safety people, it has been well<br />

worth the time we’ve put into the association.<br />

It certainly is a great and humbling honor<br />

to serve as TCA chairman. But I think what<br />

we don’t often realize is the weight of<br />

responsibility and expectation one must<br />

feel when serving in such an important<br />

leadership role so tell us what it’s like for<br />

you to carry this type of responsibility.<br />

I’m going to tell you something a little<br />

bit humorous and I think that our readers<br />

might appreciate this. A couple of months<br />

ago I traveled to Nashville to attend the TCA<br />

Recruiting and Retention Conference with<br />

200 people interested in learning more and<br />

improving what they are doing in terms of<br />

recruiting and retention. I was sitting in a<br />

roundtable discussion and I was questioned<br />

about the title on my badge that said vice<br />

chairman of TCA. I explained this was a fiveto<br />

seven-year commitment, including the<br />

chairmanship, and after spending about 10<br />

minutes explaining my travel plans for this<br />

year and a couple of things we wanted to<br />

get done at TCA, my time away from home<br />

and my time away from business and all of it<br />

on a volunteer basis, two of the people said,<br />

“Are you crazy? Why would you do such a<br />

thing, especially as a volunteer?” And I’ll tell<br />

you that this is an industry that has been<br />

extremely good to me. If through TCA I can<br />

help others and we can help others be safer,<br />

and more successful, be more profitable and<br />

be better representatives of this industry, I<br />

will consider my time on the board and as<br />

chairman well spent. Yes it is a challenge.<br />

And when I look back at some of the incredible<br />

leaders, all you have to do is look back<br />

20 years at the leadership at the TCA and<br />

there have been some extraordinary leaders<br />

from very big carriers to guys even smaller<br />

than our company, but they’ve all worked<br />

hard and they’ve all represented this industry<br />

extremely well and they’ve given hours<br />

and hours and hours of their time to raise<br />

the level of awareness about how important<br />

this industry is to the American economy.<br />

Much of TCA membership is made up of midto<br />

smaller-sized carriers. Having led such<br />

a carrier for many years, you’ve had a<br />

great vantage point. So how can TCA best<br />

serve these members into the future?<br />

Well, let me say first of all that I have<br />

the deepest respect for the Robert Low’s<br />

and the Mike Gerdin’s and the Kevin Knight’s<br />

and the Jerry Moyes’, the Stephen Russell’s<br />

and Ike Brown’s and Dan England’s and Max<br />

Fuller’s and all the other highly successful<br />

large carriers. They have done things right<br />

and been very successful at doing things<br />

right for a long time. I’m going to say for<br />

our smaller and our medium-sized carriers,<br />

the networking opportunities that you’re<br />

able to get through the TCA are just bottom-line<br />

powerful. The guys I was able to sit<br />

around the table with at our benchmarking<br />

meetings or at other TCA meetings, these<br />

companies sometimes 10 and 20 times our<br />

size, we both learned off of each other best<br />

practices through benchmarking and best<br />

practices in committee meetings. I think<br />

some people say, “Well, it’s a small carrier.<br />

What do I have to offer other people?”<br />

And many people say, “Well, you guys are<br />

much more flexible than what we are as<br />

a big company and we’re going to try and<br />

take some of your ideas and use them at<br />

our much bigger company” and even though<br />

I’ve heard some of our huge carriers have<br />

their own training and some have their own<br />

in-house programs, we continue to get great<br />

representation from most of our large carriers.<br />

I just went over the list of attendees<br />

that are going to come to our Safety and<br />

Security meeting in Charlotte, and some of<br />

the largest carriers in the country are sending<br />

their safety people to this very important<br />

meeting, and there’s a good reason for that.<br />

Because this meeting, like most everything<br />

else we do at TCA, is member-driven and it<br />

is not the staff, it’s member-driven.<br />

Along those same lines I know a passion<br />

of yours is to get folks off the sidelines<br />

and into the game. Why do you feel so<br />

passionately about this?<br />

Well, I’ve always said in this industry<br />

we’ve got the proverbial 80-20 rule. We’ve<br />

got 20 percent carrying the water and doing<br />

the work for the other 80 percent. And<br />

we can either stand back and watch our<br />

legislators make rules that are tremendously<br />

burdensome for us and we can continue to<br />

get rules passed on by the Department of<br />

Transportation and the Federal Motor Carrier<br />

Safety Administration, or we can become<br />

more vocal as an industry and have people<br />

do the right thing so it’s not burdensome. But<br />

I’ll tell you that we are the most over-regulated<br />

deregulated industry. And people say,<br />

“We were supposedly deregulated in 1980,”<br />

but every year there are more rules coming<br />

down the pike that if we are not more vocal<br />

we are absolutely going to get run over. I<br />

hear people saying, “Well, we’re going to stay<br />

quiet; we don’t want people to know about<br />

us” and if not for people out there fighting<br />

the small minority, fighting for those who are<br />

in the vast majority, this industry is going to<br />

be in further trouble than what it is. And it’s a<br />

very frustrating issue that so few of us really<br />

want to take the ball and run with it. Because<br />

all we can look forward to is that things will<br />

continue to change in our industry and if we<br />

34 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


“In this business, you<br />

better not be afraid<br />

to work and work<br />

hard ... this is not an<br />

8-to-5 business.”<br />

Keith Tuttle, TCA Chairman <strong>2015</strong>-2016<br />

don’t know the players and issues we are absolutely<br />

going to get left behind.<br />

You spoke at the annual convention<br />

about TCA’s continued relationship<br />

building with ATA’s leadership. The<br />

revitalization of this began under past<br />

Chairman [Robert] Low’s leadership so<br />

explain the importance and the benefit<br />

for TCA and the industry as a whole that<br />

this relationship continues to grow and<br />

thrive.<br />

Our advocacy work is handled through<br />

the American Trucking Associations. ATA<br />

President and CEO Bill Graves, with the assistance<br />

of Chris Spear and Dave Osiecki<br />

have a challenging job representing all the<br />

different segments of the trucking industry.<br />

With that said, it’s important that we in<br />

truckload have our voices heard. I am very<br />

supportive of the ATA. I have personally<br />

served on numerous committees. I’m supportive<br />

and a true believer that PAC dollars<br />

help. They don’t buy us votes but they’re<br />

very important and getting our voice continually<br />

heard and even a louder voice by<br />

those people at the ATA that continue to<br />

advocate for the interests of truckload becomes<br />

more and more important. And we<br />

need to strengthen our relationships and<br />

continue to work on our relationships under<br />

these committees at the ATA and to<br />

make sure that our truckload interests are<br />

heard. Over 90 percent of freight is moved<br />

in truckload volumes. And we need to do<br />

everything we can as the TCA and as the<br />

member-driven association we are to make<br />

sure our voice is heard on Capitol Hill and<br />

with the different regulators that control<br />

our bottom lines.<br />

If there’s one thing you want members to<br />

discover about you this year that they<br />

don’t know already, what is it?<br />

I can say that I welcome any phone<br />

calls, I welcome any e-mails, I welcome any<br />

suggestions that will make this association<br />

more relevant, that will help this association<br />

be more important to our members,<br />

that will help our members be more profitable.<br />

I also want the members to know that<br />

just because they’re not involved right now<br />

doesn’t mean we don’t want you to become<br />

active in committee meetings. I went<br />

to four or five Highway Policy Committee<br />

meetings before I volunteered to be vice<br />

chairman of that committee and then I became<br />

chairman of the Highway Policy Committee<br />

and then I moved on to something<br />

else at the TCA and then on to something<br />

else. A couple of years later somebody said,<br />

“You’ve been to all the meetings. Would<br />

you possibly look at an officer’s position?<br />

You’ve served the association quite well.”<br />

And I said, “You know, I’m humbled to be<br />

asked,” and that’s how things happened for<br />

me. I think we really need to expand our<br />

bull pen as we have tremendous talent that<br />

is not being currently tapped. I heard from<br />

a number of people at our recent meeting<br />

in Florida who said, “We like what we<br />

see. How do we become more involved?”<br />

The answer is you just need to ask and<br />

volunteer. You need to talk to the guys that<br />

are chairing committees right now and go<br />

to committee meetings and make yourself<br />

more visible and we’d love to have more<br />

people who play a more active role in guiding<br />

our association into the future.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 35


spring | TCA <strong>2015</strong><br />

Talking TCA<br />

TCA Honors America’s<br />

best fleets<br />

®<br />

Sponsored by:<br />

By Lyndon Finney<br />

Two Nebraska motor carriers<br />

have been named overall winners of<br />

the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association’s/<br />

CarriersEdge <strong>2015</strong> Best Fleets to<br />

Drive For.<br />

Grand Island Express of Grand<br />

Island, Nebraska, was selected as<br />

the Best Overall Fleet for the small<br />

carrier category, an award sponsored<br />

by Bose Corp., and Fremont Contract<br />

Carriers of Fremont, Nebraska, was<br />

selected as the Best Overall Fleet for<br />

the large carrier category, an award<br />

sponsored by Marsh Inc.<br />

Best Fleets to Drive For is an annual<br />

survey and contest that recognizes<br />

North American for-hire trucking<br />

companies providing the best<br />

workplace experiences for their drivers.<br />

To participate, fleets must be<br />

nominated by a company driver or<br />

independent contractor working with<br />

them, after which they are evaluated<br />

across a broad range of categories<br />

reflecting current best practices in<br />

human resources. The top 20 finishers<br />

are identified as Best Fleets to<br />

Drive For and then divided in half<br />

according to size. The highest scoring<br />

fleet in each category is named<br />

overall winner.<br />

This is the second time Grand<br />

Island Express (GIE) has earned an<br />

overall winner award. Like last year,<br />

its drivers said the company cares<br />

deeply about its people. For example,<br />

it has created a closed Facebook<br />

page for spouses of drivers to help<br />

them stay connected and share information.<br />

GIE also utilizes the latest<br />

technology, providing tablets to all of<br />

its drivers. It convenes ad-hoc committees<br />

of drivers to research new<br />

technologies and make recommendations<br />

about future purchases.<br />

Fremont Contract Carriers (FCC)<br />

is also a previous winner of an overall<br />

award as <strong>2015</strong> marks its third<br />

time. While it was being evaluated,<br />

the judges noted that FCC is a proactive<br />

company, analyzing a variety<br />

of data points to identify potential<br />

problems with shippers and address<br />

them with customers before problems<br />

arise. It has also created an innovative<br />

maintenance management<br />

system that is connected directly to<br />

each truck. The system streamlines<br />

maintenance scheduling and makes<br />

drivers’ lives easier.<br />

Jane Jazrawy, CEO of CarriersEdge,<br />

noted that both overall<br />

winners have shown a commitment<br />

to adding new driver programs while<br />

refining existing ones. Thus, they<br />

are perpetually improving the driving<br />

experience for their people. In<br />

addition to best-in-class program<br />

scores, both companies rated better<br />

than 90 percent driver satisfaction<br />

and demonstrated strong safety and<br />

retention scores.<br />

“Make no mistake . . . our two<br />

overall winners keep surfacing in this<br />

contest, but that doesn’t mean that<br />

either fleet has rested on its laurels,”<br />

she said. “Both of these fleets are<br />

providing multiple opportunities to<br />

not only recognize their drivers, but<br />

also allow them to provide input on<br />

company operations and decisions.<br />

People want to work where they feel<br />

needed and valued. So it’s not surprising<br />

that we keep seeing them<br />

back at the podium.”<br />

Brad Bentley, TCA’s president,<br />

agreed. “These two fleets keep impressing<br />

us year after year as they<br />

constantly provide excellent examples<br />

of innovation and creativity<br />

in the workplace,” he said. “In<br />

fact, in addition to Fremont, I’d like<br />

to recognize two other companies<br />

— Motor Carrier Service of Northwood,<br />

Ohio, and Paramount Freight<br />

Systems of Ft. Myers, Florida — who<br />

have made the Top 20 winners list<br />

for five consecutive years. This is no<br />

easy feat.”<br />

The Best Fleets to Drive For survey<br />

and contest is open to any fleet<br />

operating 10 trucks or more, regardless<br />

of TCA membership status.<br />

Nominated fleets are evaluated in<br />

areas such as driver compensation,<br />

pension and benefits, professional<br />

development, driver and community<br />

support, and safety record.<br />

Craig Dancer, left, senior vice president of Marsh Inc. and<br />

Jane Jazrawy, right, CEO of CarriersEdge, present the<br />

<strong>2015</strong> Best Fleets to Drive For large carrier category to<br />

Susan Hilgenkamp, director of human resources for<br />

Fremont Contract Carriers.<br />

Al Anderson, Bose Corp.’s national sales manager, left,<br />

and CarriersEdge CEO Jane Jazrawy, present the <strong>2015</strong><br />

Best Fleets to Drive For small carrier category to Grand<br />

Island Express Vice President of Operations Andy<br />

Winkler.<br />

36 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


TCA Honors America’s<br />

safest fleets<br />

Sponsored by:<br />

By Lyndon Finney<br />

GREAT WEST CASUALTY COMPANY<br />

The Difference is Service<br />

Patrick Kuehl, left, executive vice president, Great<br />

West Casualty Co., presents the 2014 National Fleet<br />

Safety Award, Small Carrier Division, to Travis<br />

Arnold, president of FTC Transportation.<br />

Rob Penner, executive vice president and COO of<br />

Bison Transport, accepts the 2014 National Fleet<br />

Safety Award, Large Carrier Division.<br />

FTC Transportation Inc. of Oklahoma City<br />

and Bison Transport of Winnipeg, Manitoba,<br />

Canada, are grand prize winners of the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Carriers Association’s prestigious 2014<br />

National Fleet Safety Award sponsored by<br />

Great West Casualty Co.<br />

FTC Transportation, represented by Travis<br />

Arnold, president, won the award for truckload<br />

companies in the small carrier division<br />

(25 million miles or less). Bison Transport,<br />

represented by Rob Penner, executive vice<br />

president and COO, won for truckload companies<br />

in the large carrier division (25 million<br />

or more miles). It is the fifth consecutive<br />

year Bison Transport has won the large carrier<br />

division. Both companies will be recognized<br />

again during TCA’s Safety & Security<br />

Division Annual Meeting, to be held May 3-5<br />

at the Charlotte Westin in Charlotte, North<br />

Carolina.<br />

“In the trucking industry, safety is our<br />

highest objective. Therefore, earning one<br />

of these two grand prizes is an extremely<br />

important and enviable achievement,” TCA<br />

President Brad Bentley said. “We want to<br />

showcase the incredible safety programs that<br />

these fleets demonstrate so that other carriers<br />

can strive to do the same.”<br />

FTC Transportation (FTCT) operates differently<br />

than most other transportation<br />

companies because it is the core carrier for<br />

the nonprofit charity, Feed the Children. Its<br />

drivers assist with hunger and disaster relief<br />

efforts throughout the United States. In between<br />

its regular loads, the carrier also hauls<br />

general commodities for third-party customers<br />

and brokers. Drivers come to FTCT because<br />

they admire the organization’s work;<br />

they stay because they are treated well and<br />

know the company’s steadfast commitment<br />

to safety will keep them safe while on the job.<br />

The company has been very successful in attracting<br />

and keeping safe drivers: Its driver<br />

turnover rate was only 14.63 percent as of<br />

December 2014.<br />

From extensive training to safety-based financial<br />

incentives, FTCT’s employees (including<br />

non-drivers) have the culture of safety<br />

instilled in them from the moment they apply<br />

for the job. Everyone is tracked monthly on<br />

a “balanced scorecard” that includes at least<br />

one safety element. Professional truck drivers<br />

receive a $25 gift card and are entered in an<br />

annual cash drawing every time they pass a<br />

roadside/DOT inspection with zero violations.<br />

New drivers receive sign-on bonuses for remaining<br />

accident-free for six months and one<br />

year after beginning their employment. The<br />

months of April and October are set aside<br />

for extra emphasis on employee health and<br />

safety matters, with special events designed<br />

to raise safety awareness and avoid complacency<br />

(for example, a backing skills course<br />

and contest, a mirror adjustment station,<br />

mock DOT inspections, etc.).<br />

New in 2014, the company began completing<br />

on-road observations (OROs) with<br />

each driver to fully survey the drivers’ safety<br />

habits and to offer coaching and counseling<br />

for any deficiencies. The OROs are conducted<br />

with every professional driver, regardless of<br />

length of service or driving experience.<br />

According to the company’s grand prize<br />

application, “At FTC Transportation, we are<br />

never content with our current safety picture.<br />

Our president has pushed us to try new and<br />

different approaches to safety while building<br />

on the safety processes that have been proven<br />

to work. He has reminded us continually<br />

over the past 12 years that ‘if you always do<br />

what you have always done, you will always<br />

get what you have always gotten.’ So, we<br />

do not settle for merely achieving our safety<br />

goals, but instead we strive to exceed them<br />

and then set new, higher goals.”<br />

Bison Transport’s safety program can only<br />

be described as outstanding. From its rigorous<br />

driver selection process, to innovative<br />

training, equipment and maintenance procedures,<br />

accident support team, and incentives<br />

— both monetary and motivational — every<br />

detail has been well planned and executed<br />

to ensure sustainability of its safety performance.<br />

The company culture values making personal<br />

connections with each professional truck<br />

driver. Bison’s leadership defines exactly what<br />

constitutes desirable behavior and then motivates,<br />

recognizes and rewards safe behavior.<br />

Everyone in the company knows exactly how<br />

to earn their incentives, how to improve and<br />

how to track their progress toward achieving<br />

goals. When drivers perform safely, they can<br />

earn a wide variety of rewards that stretch<br />

beyond pay incentives, including certificates,<br />

pins, decals, jackets, crystal trophies and<br />

special gold rings with diamond add-ons for<br />

additional miles/years.<br />

Bison Transport adapts training to fit<br />

each individual and job to be performed. The<br />

company is moving to a more intense Skills<br />

Evaluation Program that combines in-cab instruction<br />

with a computer simulator. In their<br />

first year, drivers will complete, on average,<br />

five instructor-led courses with a simulation<br />

component, and 17 online courses. Ongoing<br />

assessments continue over the driver’s tenure<br />

with the company, and refresher courses<br />

and updated safety training are provided as<br />

the needs of the individual and fleet change.<br />

According to the company’s grand prize<br />

application, “At Bison, we want to raise the<br />

bar for everyone, including the industry. We<br />

must continually monitor and be critical of<br />

our performance. There must be no flatlining<br />

on key performance indicators. We must<br />

make improvements and show progress. An<br />

overall commitment to preventing incidents<br />

from occurring in the first place requires accountability<br />

at every level.”<br />

The application process for the National<br />

Fleet Safety Awards began with fleets submitting<br />

their accident frequency per million miles driven.<br />

TCA selected the top three winners for each of six<br />

mileage-based divisions and had the results audited for<br />

accuracy by an independent expert. In December, TCA<br />

announced the names of the 18 division winners and invited<br />

them to submit further documentation about their<br />

safety programs. In order to be granted the grand prize,<br />

both winning companies had to demonstrate that they<br />

strive to meet stringent standards in their overall safety<br />

programs, on and off the highway, and were judged to<br />

be the best in their commitment to improving safety on<br />

North America’s highways.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 37


TCA Honors America’s<br />

Top Drivers<br />

Sponsored by:<br />

By Lindon Finney<br />

It would be safe to say that in<br />

general, Americans take trucking for<br />

granted and for sure rarely stop to<br />

think about — and appreciate — the<br />

professional truck driver who is making<br />

it possible to have a well-constructed<br />

brick home, food on their table, clothes<br />

on their backs and a television above<br />

the mantel.<br />

The unsung heroes who move billions<br />

of tons of goods across the country<br />

every year are away from home<br />

days, even weeks, at a time. They<br />

miss baseball games, dance recitals,<br />

school plays and their child’s first<br />

date.<br />

They can’t necessarily be at home<br />

when a loved one is ill, or when a family<br />

member is about to give birth.<br />

Therefore, it takes on a little extra<br />

special meaning when an organization<br />

pays homage to a driver whose exemplary<br />

service, loyalty and driving skills<br />

are publicly recognized.<br />

So it was with special meaning that<br />

the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association and<br />

its partner Randall-Reilly honored professional<br />

drivers Gary Teel and Thomas<br />

Miller during the association’s annual<br />

convention awards banquet.<br />

Teel, who lives in Whiting, Iowa,<br />

and drives for Wenrich Truck Line of<br />

Hinton, Iowa, was named 2014 Company<br />

Driver of the Year.<br />

Miller, who lives in Bunker Hill, Illinois,<br />

and is leased to Prime inc. of<br />

<strong>Spring</strong>field, Missouri, was named 2014<br />

Owner-Operator of the Year.<br />

For Teel, the moment was bittersweet.<br />

He almost didn’t attend because<br />

his mother was in the hospital near<br />

death. His sister and the team at Weinrich<br />

convinced him to come, but three<br />

hours after Teel received his award, his<br />

mother passed away. But not before<br />

Teel had the chance to share the news<br />

with her.<br />

As for Miller, he was on top of the<br />

world because three weeks prior to the<br />

meeting he’d learned he was going to<br />

be a grandfather. When asked what<br />

he loves most about his job, he said<br />

“coming home, especially now that I’m<br />

going to be a grandfather.”<br />

The prestigious annual awards,<br />

sponsored by Love’s Travel Stops of<br />

Oklahoma City and Cummins Inc. of<br />

Columbus, Indiana, recognize the top<br />

company drivers and owner-operators<br />

in the United States and Canada<br />

who provide reliable and safe truck<br />

transportation in moving the nation’s<br />

goods.<br />

The overall winners are selected<br />

from six finalists based on safe driving,<br />

efforts to enhance the public image of<br />

the trucking industry, and positive contributions<br />

to the winners’ local communities.<br />

For owner-operator candidates,<br />

business skills are also judged.<br />

Both men received a $25,000 cash<br />

prize for their achievements. “This is a<br />

unique opportunity to give back to professional<br />

truck drivers and show them<br />

how much we, as an industry, value<br />

them,” said Jon Archard, vice president<br />

of sales for Love’s Travel Stops. “Love’s<br />

is honored to show our appreciation for<br />

the hard work they do day in and day<br />

out by being the platinum sponsor of<br />

the cash prize.”<br />

Miller, who has been leased to<br />

Prime inc., for more than 15 years,<br />

has traveled 2.7 million miles without<br />

an accident. He is a former captain of<br />

America’s Road Team, a national public<br />

outreach program led by a small group<br />

of professional truck drivers who share<br />

superior driving skills, remarkable<br />

safety records, and a strong desire to<br />

spread the word about safety on the<br />

highway. His other notable achievements<br />

have included being selected<br />

as the Missouri Trucking Association’s<br />

(MTA) Driver of the Month and earning<br />

several safety awards from that organization<br />

as well as from Prime inc.<br />

Miller has competed for 15 years in<br />

a row in MTA’s Truck Driving Championships<br />

and has also competed twice<br />

in the National Truck Driving Championships.<br />

In his spare time he likes<br />

to volunteer with his daughter’s Little<br />

League softball teams and a church<br />

youth group.<br />

When asked to describe Miller,<br />

Robert Low, president and founder of<br />

Prime inc., said: “We can always count<br />

on Thomas to deliver on-time and<br />

safely each and every time. He exemplifies<br />

the attributes that I value in our<br />

associates.”<br />

Teel has driven more than 3.6 million<br />

accident-free miles during his 26<br />

years with Weinrich Truck Line. His<br />

supervisors note that he is loyal, detail-oriented<br />

and very knowledgeable<br />

about the equipment he operates. The<br />

ability to form positive relationships<br />

with others comes easily to Teel, who<br />

is known for going above and beyond<br />

when it comes to performing his job to<br />

the best of his ability. In 2014, he was<br />

named the Iowa Motor Truck Association’s<br />

Driver of the Year.<br />

He has the most longevity of any<br />

professional truck driver at that company<br />

and was recently awarded a<br />

brand new tractor to drive as a reward<br />

for his many years of safe motoring.<br />

“Gary is on time with his loads,<br />

pleasant with our customers and helpful<br />

with our other drivers,” said Donna<br />

Thomas Miller of Prime inc., second from left, was presented the<br />

award as the 2014 Company Owner-Operator of the Year. He is<br />

shown with Brad Holthaus, left, vice president of sales of the Truck<br />

Media Group at Randall-Reilly; Darrel Hopkins, controller at Prime<br />

inc.; and Amy Boerger, vice president North American engine<br />

business at Cummins.<br />

Gary Teel, a company driver with Weinrich Truck Line, smiles and<br />

gives a thumbs-up after being named winner of the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />

Association’s 2014 Company Driver of the Year contest. With Teel is<br />

Donna Weinrich-Lucht, president and CEO of the Hinton, Iowa-based<br />

carrier.<br />

Weinrich-Lucht, company president and CEO. “Safety is always his<br />

goal, as you can tell by his safe driving record. He takes pride in taking<br />

care of our equipment and especially the tractor he is assigned.<br />

Witnessing Gary’s excitement and pride when he received [our] truck<br />

will certainly go down as one of the highlights in the 54-year history of<br />

our company.”<br />

“It has been such a pleasure meeting these outstanding professional<br />

drivers,” said Shepard Dunn, TCA’s past chairman and president and<br />

CEO of Bestway Express Inc. of Vincennes, Indiana. “They showcase<br />

the very best that trucking has to offer.”<br />

Other owner-operator finalists were Glen Horack of Elkland, Missouri,<br />

who is leased to Prime inc.; and Bryan Smith of Asbury, Iowa,<br />

who is leased to Art Pape Transfer Inc. of Dubuque, Iowa.<br />

Other company driver finalists were Danny Smith of Shelbyville,<br />

Tennessee, who drives for Big G Express Inc., also of Shelbyville; and<br />

Johnny Chestnut of Lakeland, Florida, who drives for Saddle Creek<br />

Transportation Inc., also of Lakeland.<br />

38 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


some aspects of an organized association, but because of the educational<br />

opportunities, the networking opportunities, the safety programs, the image<br />

programs, we feel like we need to be part of TCA.”<br />

B r a d b e n t l e y | T C A P r e s i d e n t<br />

As he looks ahead after six months in the position, <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers<br />

Association President Brad Bentley’s aspirations for the organization could<br />

be summed up in one word: More.<br />

As in:<br />

More membership.<br />

More involvement.<br />

More collaboration.<br />

More education.<br />

More challenges.<br />

During his young tenure, he’s probably spent as much time on the road<br />

as he has in the office, visiting<br />

carrier and associate members<br />

and state trucking associations,<br />

speaking at industry conferences,<br />

participating in discussions<br />

about regulatory issues, or in<br />

image programs such as Wreaths<br />

Across America, Highway Angel,<br />

the U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree<br />

project and the Vietnam Veterans<br />

Memorial Fund Traveling Wall<br />

— in general — seeking to get<br />

the “lay of the land” to find out<br />

what’s expected of him as the<br />

organization’s leader and seeking<br />

input on how the association can<br />

better serve its constituencies.<br />

In an interview shortly after<br />

the 77th Annual Convention<br />

in Orlando, Florida, Bentley expanded<br />

on the five previously<br />

listed areas.<br />

MORE MEMBERSHIP<br />

The recent Great Recession<br />

was tough on everybody, but it<br />

was especially tough on trade associations,<br />

Bentley believes.<br />

Through adept planning, TCA<br />

was able to retain the majority of<br />

its membership base during the<br />

recession.<br />

But now Bentley says it’s<br />

time to go after carriers and allied<br />

professionals who might be<br />

new to the industry or might<br />

never have been involved in TCA<br />

with a message of how the association<br />

can be of benefit.<br />

The organization’s strength<br />

has long been its members,<br />

Bentley said.<br />

“The thing I like about TCA<br />

— and this was even prior to me<br />

getting this position having been<br />

involved in committees and so<br />

forth — is that the strength of<br />

the organization is in the companies we serve,” he said, but added he believes<br />

TCA is at a crossroads in terms of membership. “I think TCA needs to<br />

go after members that might have dropped out in the past and also focus<br />

on getting some new members, thus having more revenue to work with.<br />

That would put us in a position where we can ramp up our staff and allow<br />

us to get to the next level.”<br />

Bentley is hoping he can encourage many of the so-called “micro” and<br />

“mega” carriers to join TCA.<br />

“I want both small and large carriers to feel like they are missing out<br />

not being involved in TCA. I want to focus on the programs that we have, to<br />

give those carriers a reason to pause and say, ‘Maybe we are not happy with<br />

MORE INVOLVEMENT<br />

“We have a lot of people who are very active and very engaged, and I<br />

don’t think it’s a coincidence that a lot of the same companies are showing up<br />

time and time again,” Bentley said. “They’re winning the fleet safety awards,<br />

the Best Fleets To Drive For contest, and are the ones who are participating<br />

in our various image programs.”<br />

But there’s room for more.<br />

For one thing, Bentley wants more carriers to become involved in the<br />

health and wellness of drivers.<br />

“I think this is critical for us. There are several factors at work here,<br />

among them the aging workforce, the sedentary lifestyle, sleep apnea and a<br />

lot of other things that are documented,” he said. “Over time I want TCA to<br />

be known for health and wellness, but that’s going to require our members<br />

to participate with us in this important issue.”<br />

Mega carriers blessed with the financial resources may have the ability to<br />

develop health and wellness programs of their own, but with smaller carriers<br />

help is needed.<br />

“We want to be that resource for them so they’ll be able to have those<br />

same types of programs,” Bentley said.<br />

He also wants to see more involvement in the effort to hire veterans.<br />

“About 700,000 veterans are<br />

either unemployed or under-employed<br />

and there are about 1<br />

million soldiers who will be transitioning<br />

out of the service over<br />

the next five years,” Bentley said.<br />

“The challenge for us as an industry<br />

is that everyone else is starting<br />

to get on the veteran hiring<br />

bandwagon, which shrinks the<br />

potential pool of candidates.”<br />

What’s happening, he noted,<br />

is that a lot of large companies<br />

— Google, Home Depot, Starbucks,<br />

Uber, Capital One, among<br />

others — are implementing hiring<br />

initiatives of their own. These<br />

are substantial. I’m talking about<br />

50,000-100,000 commitments<br />

each, Bentley said.<br />

“We have several carriers and<br />

associate members that have<br />

done a great job over the years<br />

of transitioning veterans into the<br />

jobs we offer. But we have to do<br />

more.”<br />

Bentley recently attended a<br />

meeting at the Federal Motor Carrier<br />

Safety Administration on gaps<br />

and barriers to hiring in the trucking<br />

industry.<br />

“One of the attendees was<br />

from the American Legion, who<br />

I learned is the largest veterans<br />

service organization with 2.4 million<br />

members,” he said. “They are<br />

having a summit in late April to<br />

make connections between military<br />

experience and credentials<br />

required for civilian careers. I<br />

asked if we could attend to see if<br />

they may be a potential partner.”<br />

MORE COLLABORATION<br />

“One of the things I was asked<br />

to do and I have been happy to<br />

do is make sure TCA has a good<br />

relationship with the American Trucking Associations — and I think we are<br />

making progress,” Bentley said. “We have monthly calls among myself, our<br />

Chairman Keith Tuttle, ATA President and CEO Bill Graves and ATA Chairman<br />

Duane Long to talk about common issues. That’s been very helpful. We’ve<br />

invited them to be a part of our meetings, such as our annual convention.”<br />

Bentley moderated a panel at the recent convention entitled “Our Industry:<br />

Setting the Course” that featured Tuttle, Graves and Long as panelists.<br />

“I’m also big into partnerships so it’s good for me that a lot of people have<br />

reached out since I have become TCA president and said, ‘Hey, let’s work together.’<br />

A good example is the Commercial Vehicle Training Association (CVTA)<br />

and its efforts on the Workforce Innovation and Opportunities Act (WIOA).<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 39


WIOA is designed to help job seekers access<br />

employment, education, training and support services<br />

to succeed in the labor market and to match<br />

employers with the skilled workers they need to<br />

compete in the global economy.<br />

Input from state and local workforce leaders<br />

goes a long way in determining who is awarded<br />

grants, and of course, local leaders want the money<br />

to come their way.<br />

“One of the challenges we face as an industry<br />

is when federal dollars get down to the local level<br />

we are competing against local industries and a lot<br />

of times trucking isn’t recognized for having local<br />

jobs,” Bentley said. “Now you say, ‘How could that<br />

be? We have a huge driver shortage.’ But the fact is<br />

depending on who is over that local board, and who<br />

they reach out to within that community, they may<br />

not see trucking as an in-demand job.”<br />

So, Bentley said, CVTA is spearheading an effort<br />

to change that perception.<br />

“We’ve actually hosted a couple of meetings in our<br />

office with representatives from CVTA, the American<br />

Moving and Storage Association, the Owner-Operator<br />

Independent Drivers Association and the International<br />

Foodservice Distributors Association,” he said.<br />

“We are working on a grassroots campaign where<br />

everyone can reach out through their governors and<br />

their local politicians with letter-writing campaigns<br />

— all the things we can do to say, ‘Hey, we have<br />

the jobs.’ It shouldn’t matter whether you’re down in<br />

Tampa, Florida, and you have Werner Enterprises, as<br />

an example, with headquarters in Omaha. They can<br />

hire students from those driver training programs<br />

from the Tampa area. We shouldn’t be punished as<br />

an industry just because the job may not be domiciled<br />

in that local area.”<br />

Another example of collaboration is the current<br />

34-hour restart controversy.<br />

An industry-wide effort led Congress to temporarily<br />

suspend the 34-hour restart provision that<br />

became effective July 1, 2013, and which was loudly<br />

denounced by the trucking industry because the<br />

industry documented that it cut productivity.<br />

“ATA led the charge, but we were involved,”<br />

Bentley said. “We reached out to our members<br />

who contacted their local politicians and made sure<br />

people understood the importance of having those<br />

revisions in there. And that was successful, at least<br />

temporarily.”<br />

The suspension also included a requirement for<br />

a 34-hour restart study and TCA has encouraged its<br />

members to consider participating in the study.<br />

“There are a lot of things happening where<br />

I think more people are going in together,” he<br />

said. “We were part of the devolution letter to<br />

Congress that went out with 38 organizations<br />

warning lawmakers about the dangers of devolving<br />

the federal highway program and urging<br />

passage of a robust, long-term highway bill that<br />

secures the federal role in transportation.<br />

“We need to continue to do things such as<br />

those. We’re not always going to have policies<br />

aligned such as on the size and weight issue. But I<br />

think for the most part if we can take these common<br />

issues and all work on them together we’ll get<br />

a lot further. And I feel the people who are in place<br />

now at their respective organizations — at least the<br />

ones I’ve dealt with — have been terrific.”<br />

MORE EDUCATION<br />

One of the things that so thoroughly impressed<br />

Bentley when he stepped into the new<br />

role was the depth of the organization’s benchmarking<br />

program where carriers are placed<br />

in small, usually like-size, geographical and<br />

service areas and share certain performance<br />

data. Those areas include, but aren’t necessarily<br />

limited to, expense per revenue mile, company<br />

versus owner-operator operating mode,<br />

maintenance costs, operating profit, and IT<br />

information.<br />

There are currently four benchmarking<br />

groups at TCA.<br />

“The beauty of benchmarking is you are<br />

able to compare yourself against another fleet<br />

with similar challenges and see where you<br />

stack up,” he said. “It’s a huge benefit and we<br />

are looking to take it to the next level by creating<br />

more groups, including open deck and flatbed carriers,<br />

where there’s a strong interest.”<br />

Why is sharing this type of information important<br />

in an industry that is in many ways very competitive?<br />

“I think benchmarking helps keep more carriers<br />

in the black. Sharing best practices can also help<br />

members see what trends are coming because they<br />

are looking at everything from fuel economy to<br />

what attributes make a trucking company successful,”<br />

Bentley stated. “Without that ability to always<br />

know where you stand and see what some of the<br />

trendsetters are doing, you can fall further behind.<br />

And as we all know, the margins are not that large<br />

in the trucking industry.”<br />

The organization also offers educational webinars<br />

on topics critical to the industry and has the<br />

ability to develop and air webinars on emerging issues<br />

almost overnight.<br />

“Now we’re trying to increase the frequency and<br />

offer more of these as sponsored webinars, which<br />

means they are free to our members. We see participation<br />

really go up when that happens.”<br />

Conventions and conferences are being planned<br />

with more educational content.<br />

“At we were preparing for our convention this<br />

year, people I talked to said, ‘We’re here on business<br />

and times are good in trucking again so let’s<br />

gain every edge that we can, let’s learn as much as<br />

we can,’” Bentley said. “And when members speak,<br />

it is important that TCA listens.”<br />

There was a shift this year when free time that<br />

was traditionally scheduled on Monday afternoon<br />

was filled with educational content.<br />

“Our events team implemented more Trucking<br />

in the Round sessions than before, and I think<br />

we are going to see that trend continue,” Bentley<br />

added. “Our chairman is a big believer in education,<br />

and so am I.”<br />

An ongoing educational initiative is the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Academy On-demand, where members can<br />

purchase recordings of conference sessions, workshops<br />

and webinars at their convenience.<br />

There are some new programs in <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

Academy, including DriverConnect, a training program<br />

focused on continuing education for drivers.<br />

There is also a fleet manager certification program<br />

and a Truckers Against Trafficking program, which<br />

some companies have made part of driver orientation.<br />

TCA soon will offer certification programs on<br />

recruiting and retention as well as motor carrier<br />

risk.<br />

MORE CHALLENGES<br />

“Certainly the driver shortage is first and foremost<br />

in my mind,” Bentley said. “Some of that is<br />

based on my background in driver recruitment advertising,<br />

but you can look at the American Transportation<br />

Research Institute data and see it’s one<br />

of the top issues in our industry. We are going to<br />

continue to be involved in a recruiting and retention<br />

conference to share best practices gleaned from<br />

submitted topics that have been vetted through our<br />

committee process.”<br />

Hiring of veterans will also help ease the shortage.<br />

Bentley believes veterans are “hard wired” for<br />

success.<br />

“When it comes to recruiting drivers regardless<br />

of the source we need to highlight the successes<br />

of our industry,” Bentley said, including the entrepreneurial<br />

component of trucking. “There are not<br />

many places you can go and after a few months or<br />

a year you’ll be in a position where you can start<br />

your own business, and certainly we’ve had a lot of<br />

people who have done that.”<br />

There’s also a growing shortage of technicians<br />

in the industry, which TCA will focus on in the future,<br />

Bentley said. “We can’t lose site of the fact<br />

that we need more warm bodies to begin with and<br />

it’s more than just drivers.”<br />

And, of course, another challenge is the onslaught<br />

of regulations for an industry that’s often<br />

called the most regulated deregulated industry in<br />

the country.<br />

“You’re always going to have regulations. We<br />

mentioned Hours of Service and the restart study,”<br />

Bentley said, but at least trucking is having input on<br />

some of the new rules.<br />

The FMCSA has recently formed an entry-level<br />

driver training advisory committee and TCA has a<br />

seat at the table.<br />

“It is really interesting to be part of the process.<br />

First of all, you’re working on something they made<br />

a run at in 2007 and it wasn’t approved, but the<br />

need hasn’t changed,” he said. “Having the opportunity<br />

to shape policy is important and it’s good to at<br />

least have an opportunity for our voices to be heard<br />

not only for TCA but for the Professional Truck Driver<br />

Institute which is managed out of this office.”<br />

“I don’t think we’re going to see a decrease<br />

in activity coming out of the agency, but I’m glad<br />

more people seem to be getting involved.”<br />

Ah, there’s that word “more” again.<br />

40 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


TALK<br />

A QUICK LOOK AT IMPORTANT TCA NEWS<br />

SMALL<br />

A QUICK LOOK AT<br />

IMPORTANT TCA NEWS<br />

Fund Raising Gala<br />

Rick <strong>Spring</strong>field, who recorded his first hits in the<br />

1980s, invited the ladies of the audience to come to<br />

the stage for a special serenade.<br />

You look up and J.R. Ewing is walking in the door, Stetson<br />

and all.<br />

On the wall is a picture of the Berlin Wall crashing<br />

down.<br />

Someone says “look up, the Blues Brothers are sitting<br />

at the table over in the corner.”<br />

Bobby McFerrin’s hit “Don’t Worry, Be Happy” is blaring<br />

on the loud speaker, followed by Michael Jackson’s big<br />

seller “Thriller.”<br />

The music is being played via some newfangled thing<br />

called a compact disc, or CD for short.<br />

The music is so loud that it’s hard to hear what your table<br />

guests are saying, and you’re reminded of what George<br />

H.W. Bush said in a debate with Michael Dukakis: “Read my<br />

lips — no new taxes.”<br />

Up on the big screen, they’re showing a replay of the<br />

World Series — the one where Boston’s Bill Buckner lets<br />

the ball squirt through his legs and the Mets go on to win in<br />

seven games.<br />

Oh my, what is the lady over there wearing? Are those<br />

stonewashed jeans? And she’s wearing pink leg warmers<br />

to boot.<br />

And finally you notice that someone is preserving the<br />

evening using something called a camcorder so highlights<br />

can be shown on that new network called CNN.<br />

Well, none of that actually happened, but the 1980s did<br />

come back to life for one “awesome” night as the <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

TALK<br />

Carriers Association held its second annual gala to benefit<br />

the association’s Scholarship Fund, a party complete with<br />

many guests who dressed as they would have in the 1980s.<br />

Pilot Flying J of Knoxville, Tennessee, and Freightliner<br />

Trucks of Duluth, Georgia, companies themselves that were<br />

around in the 1980s, sponsored the event.<br />

The gala raised over $230,000 for the Scholarship<br />

Fund, which has been providing scholarships for students<br />

affiliated with TCA members since 1973. Beginning with<br />

tables and individual seats purchased in advance by various<br />

companies and individuals, the gala consisted of an ’80sthemed<br />

reception and dinner, the chance to bid on auction<br />

prizes — both silently and with an auctioneer — and the<br />

opportunity to get up close and personal with the iconic ’80s<br />

pop legend, Rick <strong>Spring</strong>field.<br />

In addition to the Scholarship Fund, participants raised<br />

over $76,000 for the TCA Past Chairman’s Fund, which<br />

seeks to name a scholarship in the names of each past<br />

chairman. The first such scholarship, named after late<br />

former chairman John Kaburick, was awarded last summer.<br />

Kaburick’s widow Carolyn, in memory of Kaburick and<br />

in honor of former chairmen Ray Haight and Kevin Burch,<br />

made a donation to the Past Chairman’s Fund, noting that<br />

Kaburick referred to himself, Haight and Burch as the “three<br />

amigos.”<br />

Mark Kessler, general manager, trucking at PeopleNet<br />

and TCA Scholarship Trustee, and whose idea led to the establishment<br />

of the Past Chairman’s Fund, generously made<br />

items available twice — donating the Whistling Straits<br />

package for the live auction and then offering a second<br />

package if the runner-up bidder would match the winning<br />

bidder, which they did.<br />

Steve Kriebel of Ritchie Bros. Auctioneers stirred<br />

up the audience to the tune of over $230,000.<br />

There were three donations of $10,000 or more to the<br />

Past Chairman’s Fund, with total pledges to the fund reaching<br />

$77,003. Jack Porter of Decisiv and Scott Phillips of<br />

Electronic Funds Source each made $10,000 donations and<br />

PeopleNet pledged $1,000 for each of the 10 past chairmen<br />

present at the gala.<br />

Then at the last minute, <strong>Spring</strong>field himself offered private<br />

backstage passes, which ended in a three-way bidding<br />

battle at $1,350 each.<br />

“We’re very grateful to our sponsors because they<br />

offset most of the costs, making it possible for 100 percent<br />

of the table and auction proceeds to go directly to the<br />

Scholarship Fund. That’s a major financial boost for our taxdeductible<br />

501(c)(3) charity,” said Debbie Sparks, TCA’s vice<br />

president of development.<br />

“What a way to support trucking families,” said Josh<br />

Kaburick, John Kaburick’s son, who is chairman of the TCA<br />

Scholarship Fund and the CEO of Earl L. Henderson Trucking<br />

Company of Salem, Illinois. “This gala is critical to our<br />

ongoing ability to provide scholarships of up to $6,250 per<br />

student. Also, I have to say it was ‘totally tubular’ to see<br />

the senior management of some of North America’s most<br />

influential truckload carriers donning their preppy fashions,<br />

jean jackets, and ‘big hair’ to ‘party to the max’ for such a<br />

good cause!”<br />

The four, live auction items consisted of a luxury golf<br />

resort package, ringside seats and behind-the-scenes access<br />

to a World Heavyweight Championship fight, “gnarly”<br />

diamond earrings, and airfare, accommodations, registration,<br />

dinner and a spa treatment at TCA’s next annual<br />

convention, scheduled for March 6-9, 2016, at the Wynn<br />

Resort in Las Vegas. Silent auction items included a hot air<br />

balloon ride, a football autographed by Peyton Manning, a<br />

NASCAR race package, an Apple iPad mini, jewelry, trips,<br />

and more.<br />

Applications for the <strong>2015</strong>-16 scholarships will be due<br />

in June.<br />

Past Chairman’s Award<br />

Josh Kaburick, CEO of Earl L. Henderson Trucking,<br />

accepts the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association’s<br />

Past Chairman’s Award on behalf of his late father<br />

John Kaburick, who passed away last April. Kaburick’s<br />

widow Carolyn stands by her son’s side.<br />

John Kaburick was owner of the trucking company<br />

prior to his death.<br />

Go to any <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association convention<br />

and you couldn’t help but run into John Kaburick at some<br />

point.<br />

It might be in the meeting room, it might be in the<br />

exhibit hall or it might be at the annual banquet where his<br />

countenance filled the room.<br />

You couldn’t help but miss him.<br />

His heart was as big as his stately stature.<br />

His smile and his laugh were infectious.<br />

What’s more, his knowledge was invaluable.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 41


PAGE 18<br />

He led the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association as chairman in 2010-11 at a time when the trucking<br />

industry was beginning to dig out from under the Great Recession and was looking for guidance<br />

that could only be provided by industry veterans like John Kaburick — men and women<br />

whose experience and expertise were worth much more than the traditional “thousand words.”<br />

He continued to be active in association work after his term ended — he was a strong supporter<br />

and participant in the benchmarking program, saying it made him a better businessman<br />

and his company operate more efficiently. He and others who served before him worked together<br />

to began to set the stage to pass the torch to a new generation, among them his son Josh, who is<br />

now an officer in the association and in line to one day become chairman.<br />

He never got to see that new generation guide TCA. Sadly, John Kaburick, who purchased<br />

Earl L. Henderson Trucking Co. in 1990, passed away last April 22 at age 61, leaving the industry<br />

in a state of shock and wondering just how to honor a man who gave so much so unselfishly.<br />

So it was a fitting tribute that when Tom Kretsinger, president and CEO of American Central<br />

Transport and TCA chairman 2013-14, and Tom Schilli, president of Schilli Transportation Services<br />

and TCA chairman in 1988-89, stood at the podium during the recent TCA convention and<br />

announced that John Kaburick had posthumously been named recipient of the organization’s<br />

prestigious <strong>2015</strong> Past Chairman’s Award, the entire audience rose to its feet and burst into long,<br />

thunderous and respectful applause as Josh, who is now CEO of Earl L. Henderson Trucking and<br />

TCA’s Scholarship Fund chairman, escorted his mother to the podium to receive the award on<br />

behalf of his father.<br />

Carolyn Kaburick, who had been married to her husband for some 41 years, tightly grasped<br />

the right arm of her son as she fought back the tears.<br />

Josh Kaburick’s voice cracked as he thanked TCA for honoring his father in such a manner.<br />

He and his mother left the stage to another appreciative round of applause.<br />

The Past Chairman’s Award is the highest honor given by TCA. It goes to a leader who has<br />

made a significant contribution to the business community, the trucking industry and the organization.<br />

Contrary to the title of the award, the recipient does not have to be a past chairman of the<br />

association.<br />

John Kaburick started his trucking career as an owner-operator with just one truck in 1973.<br />

Two years later, he and a partner launched a small trucking company that quickly grew to a<br />

fleet of 30 trucks.<br />

In 1977, he decided to leave the trucking company to work as a salesman for a local truck<br />

dealership. This position helped build an extensive network of friends and contacts within the<br />

industry. It was 1990 when a long-time customer made Kaburick an offer he could not refuse<br />

— ownership of Earl L. Henderson Trucking. Since then, under John’s leadership, the company<br />

has grown from 125 power units to 400.<br />

After acquiring Henderson, which was already a TCA member, Kaburick became active in the<br />

association through a variety of committees and eventually became an officer of the Refrigerated<br />

Division and later chairman of the association. While Kaburick’s role in TCA grew steadily over the<br />

years, he had also been actively involved in the American Trucking Associations and the Illinois<br />

Transportation Association.<br />

After Kaburick’s unexpected death, his many trucking industry friends and colleagues<br />

wanted a permanent way to honor his memory. Within just a few days, funds were collected to<br />

fully endow a new Past Chairman John Kaburick Scholarship, to be given annually to a student<br />

affiliated with the truckload industry.<br />

“John Kaburick was truly an icon within the trucking family,” said Brad Bentley, TCA’s president.<br />

“On both the state and national levels, he was fully committed to the industry that he loved<br />

so much. He generously gave his time, his effort and his money. I only wish we could present this<br />

award to him in person.”<br />

Lee J. Crittenden Award<br />

Simply puT.<br />

“Great Dane supports <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> for its work on behalf of the TCA and because<br />

its readers are many of our most valuable customers and partners.”<br />

WHERE STATES STAND • HOS STRESS • TCA HONORS INDUSTRY EXCELLENCE<br />

O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />

SPRING 2014<br />

CARLY FIORINA<br />

AMERICAN<br />

EXCLUSIVE<br />

06 30 34<br />

TRAILBLAZER<br />

EXECUTIVE ACTION | OUT OF SERVICE | WALKING AWAY A WINNER<br />

ANNUAL CONVENTION PREVIEW | HIGHWAY ANGEL OF THE YEAR | TCA INDUSTRY HONORS<br />

O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />

SPECIAL<br />

ANNUAL<br />

CONVENTION<br />

EDITION<br />

CLINTONVS. BUSHAGAIN?<br />

ARE WE GOING BACKTOOUR<br />

FUTURE? PAGE 6<br />

FORMER CIA OPERATIVE TIM<br />

BALLARDIS ON THE FRONT<br />

LINES IN THE FIGHTAGAINST<br />

HUMANTRAFFICKING. PAGE 12<br />

THE STORIES TRAILERS TELL<br />

<strong>2015</strong>-03-08 11:04:27 TCA<br />

Dave Gilliland,<br />

VP National Accounts,<br />

great dane trailers<br />

GAME<br />

CHANGER<br />

16STL 10:30:00P<br />

0612:10-15 L<br />

SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY IS REVOLUTIONIZING<br />

THE TRUCKING INDUSTRY AND CHANGING<br />

THE WAY BUSINESS IS DONE.<br />

PAGE 22<br />

BEST FLEETS TO DRIVE FOR • NATIONAL FLEET SAFETY AWARD WINNERS • DRIVERS OF THE YEAR<br />

O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O C I A T I O N<br />

12<br />

19<br />

24<br />

WINTER/SPRING <strong>2015</strong><br />

FIRED UP<br />

WITH CHAIRMAN SHEPARD DUNN<br />

EXCLUSIVE<br />

MAKE LOVE, NOT POLITICS WITH<br />

JAMES CARVILLE & MARY MATALIN<br />

TECH TAKEOVER<br />

COMING RETRACTIONS<br />

SUMMER 2014<br />

FROM WHERE WE SIT • HIGHWAY ANGEL TOUR WITH LINDSAY LAWLER • WREATHS ACROSS AMERICA<br />

BILL O’REILLY<br />

EXCLUSIVE<br />

expanding to 6 issues in <strong>2015</strong>.<br />

become a partner in the excitement today.<br />

To inquire about partnership and space availability,<br />

call (800) 666-2770 or email publisher@thetrucker.com.<br />

NO SPIN MEDIA MOGUL<br />

WINTER<br />

2013-14<br />

O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E T R U C K L O A D C A R R I E R S A S S O<br />

CRACKING UP (NO LAUGHING MATTER) | 06<br />

RIDICULUDICROUS \ r -’dik-y -’lud-e-kres \ | 10<br />

DOWN TO BUSINESS WITH CHAIRMAN KRETSINGER | 24<br />

TCA CELEBRATES 75 YEARS: FOUNDATION OF THE FUTURE | 33<br />

KRTS Transportation Specialists President Kim Richardson grew up around<br />

trucking as his father was a professional truck driver who started the company<br />

in 1989.<br />

Kim Richardson, president of KRTS Transportation Specialists of Caledonia, Ontario,<br />

Canada, has been named the <strong>2015</strong> recipient of the Lee J. Crittenden Memorial Award, presented<br />

by the Professional Truck Driver Institute (PTDI).<br />

The Crittenden Award, sponsored by Cengage Learning of Clifton Park, New York, is<br />

given to a person who exemplifies the overall mission of PTDI for which Lee Crittenden was<br />

a staunch supporter until his death in April 1998. PTDI raises the quality of truck driver<br />

training courses by establishing and promoting minimum training standards and by certifying<br />

courses that meet those standards.<br />

“Cengage Learning is pleased that PTDI’s highest honor will be going to someone who<br />

is known far and wide as a passionate advocate for the training and development of truck<br />

drivers,” said Erin Brennan, product team manager for Cengage Learning. “Kim’s dedication<br />

to the industry is unmatched. Cengage Learning can think of no more worthy recipient of<br />

this award.”<br />

Richardson grew up around the trucking industry because his father was a professional<br />

truck driver. Working from a card table in his basement, he launched a family business in<br />

1989 that would grow into the company that it is today. Offering specialized training for the<br />

transportation and construction industries, KRTS now services more than 400 corporate<br />

clients and has helped more than 9,000 people obtain their CDLs.<br />

Richardson first got involved with PTDI in 1996 when the organization was known as the<br />

Professional Truck Driver Institute of America. Being from Canada, one of his early achievements<br />

was convincing the organization to drop the last two words of its title to include North<br />

America. He was involved with PTDI’s board of directors as both an advisor and a full board<br />

member, and has remained on the board for 19 years. He has served on PTDI’s standards<br />

review, nominating and image committees, as well as its Driver Finishing Task Force, and<br />

has served on TCA’s school committee since 2011.<br />

Over the years, Richardson has participated in the development, implementation and revisions<br />

of PTDI’s standards, and has been relentless in his promotion of quality truck driver training.<br />

42 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


“Wherever he goes, he is constantly talking of quality<br />

and professional training within our industry,” said Robert<br />

McClanahan, the executive director of the National Association<br />

of Publicly Funded Truck Driving Schools, and the 2007<br />

recipient of the Crittenden Award. “As publisher of the Rear<br />

View Mirror, Kim’s articles raise the bar by informing readers<br />

of best practices and the need to offer students proper<br />

training. I am inspired by his leadership and enthusiasm.”<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> Academy<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong> Academy is adding to its suite of educational<br />

options a new subscription-based, online learning<br />

platform specifically tailored to training professional truck<br />

drivers.<br />

Driver Connect, powered by CarriersEdge and KRTS<br />

Online Highway, fits the lifestyles of professional drivers,<br />

while giving trainers an easy-to-implement educational<br />

program. CarriersEdge is the association’s partner in the<br />

Best Fleets to Drive For annual survey and contest.<br />

Prior to launch, the program was piloted by TCA member<br />

fleets familiar with online training programs available<br />

to the industry.<br />

Many educational offerings focus primarily on the<br />

information needed to educate the end-user. The Driver<br />

Connect platform adds another layer to the training equation:<br />

It considers the learning styles of those taking the<br />

courses and provides an interactive learning experience<br />

designed to engage the driver.<br />

Drivers can log in from their desktop, mobile device, or<br />

through their vehicle’s satellite to choose from a library of<br />

courses, including refresher courses.<br />

Equally as important, Driver Connect is also<br />

designed with the trainer or manager in mind. The<br />

interface allows trainers to set up and manage driver<br />

accounts, assign courses, and monitor progress.<br />

Through advanced reporting tools, managers can run<br />

and automate reports, track compliance, analyze trends<br />

company-wide, and review individual training status. Testing<br />

and assessment tools help managers identify where<br />

training has been most effective or where additional help<br />

is needed. When a driver successfully completes a course,<br />

managers can also print certificates.<br />

Carriers interested in the training platform can learn<br />

more at <strong>Truckload</strong>Academy.org/driver-connect.<br />

Scholarship Donation<br />

The Trucker News Organization has made a $5,000<br />

donation to the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association’s Gary<br />

Salisbury Past Chairman’s Fund in the name of <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong> to promote and encourage journalism.<br />

The Trucker partners with TCA in publishing <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong>, the association’s official magazine.<br />

The Past Chairman’s Fund is a part of the TCA Scholarship<br />

Fund and seeks to name a scholarship after each past<br />

chairman. <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> began through the leadership<br />

of Salisbury, who served as chairman in 2011-2012.<br />

Salisbury is chairman and CEO of Fikes Truck Line.<br />

“As partners with The Trucker in the publishing<br />

of <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> for almost three years now, our<br />

two organizations have forged a strong and prosperous<br />

relationship,” said Josh Kaburick, chairman of the TCA<br />

Scholarship Fund. “It only stands to reason that when<br />

one of those organizations does something of this value<br />

for the other, the only thing you can say is thank you so<br />

very much.”<br />

“We are proud to support the TCA scholarship program<br />

while promoting the growth of journalism in the<br />

trucking industry,” said Micah Jackson, general manager<br />

Micah Jackson, publisher and general manager of<br />

The Trucker and publisher of <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>,<br />

presented a check for $5,000 for the TCA Scholarship<br />

Fund to Debbie Sparks, TCA vice president<br />

of development. Looking on are Mark Kessler, left,<br />

of PeopleNet and a scholarship fund trustee, and<br />

TCA Immediate Past Chairman Shepard Dunn.<br />

and publisher of The Trucker and publisher of <strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong>. “Millions of people depend on The Trucker<br />

News Organization for industry and business news and<br />

insight, so we know firsthand how vital it is to have<br />

outstanding and dedicated journalists working in transportation.”<br />

Since 1973, TCA has been helping students associated<br />

with the truckload industry reach their dreams. Its Scholarship<br />

Fund awards up to $6,000 per year to full-time college<br />

students. Much of the program’s support comes from<br />

within the truckload family — companies and individuals<br />

who are committed to their community’s future.<br />

TCA will begin accepting applications for scholarships<br />

for the <strong>2015</strong>-2016 academic year on April 21.<br />

LESS FRUSTRATION HERE.<br />

MORE PRODUCTIVITY HERE.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 43


TCA CONVENTION <strong>2015</strong><br />

Members of the <strong>Truckload</strong> Carriers Association gathered in sunny<br />

Kissimmee, Florida, March 7-11, <strong>2015</strong>, for the 77th annual convention.<br />

The event began with the opportunity to view the The Moving Wall, the<br />

traveling half-size replica of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, which<br />

is being transported across the U.S. by TCA members. Convention<br />

festivities kicked off Monday with Denver Bronco quarterback Peyton<br />

Manning as keynote speaker, who shared some of the highlights of his<br />

17-year career in the National Football League. Afterwards, Chairman<br />

Shepard Dunn gave a recap of a successful 2014, followed by an 80’s<br />

themed gala, which raised $230,000 for the TCA Scholarship Fund<br />

that evening. New TCA President Brad Bentley challenged members<br />

on Tuesday to plug in and get engaged in the association. The annual<br />

banquet Tuesday evening honored winners of the “Best Driver,” “Best<br />

Fleets to Drive For” and “Safest Fleets” competitions. Wednesday<br />

brought the inauguration of new Chairman Keith Tuttle, who said he<br />

would be pressing forward with the many trucking image programs as<br />

well as educational and networking offerings.<br />

The panel during Tuesday’s<br />

“Creating a Culture of Safety<br />

- Taking it Viral.”<br />

L-R: Moderator, Pat Kuehl;<br />

Participants, Bob Peterson,<br />

Rob Penner and Brian Fielkow.<br />

Gaylord Palms Resort, Kissimmee, Florida<br />

Exhibit attendees<br />

enjoy learning about<br />

technology products<br />

by McLeod Software.<br />

TA/Petro booth in the<br />

<strong>2015</strong> exhibition hall.<br />

Broncos<br />

quarterback<br />

Peyton Manning<br />

as the <strong>2015</strong><br />

keynote speaker.<br />

<strong>2015</strong> Chairman, Keith Tuttle, with<br />

NFL quarterback Peyton Manning.<br />

Conference attendees network over breakfast Monday morning.<br />

2014 Chairman, Shepard Dunn,<br />

addresses the crowd at the general<br />

session on Monday.<br />

44 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org TCA <strong>2015</strong>


Silent auction items at the Scholarship Gala.<br />

Rick <strong>Spring</strong>field<br />

performing at the<br />

Scholarship Gala.<br />

The Moving Wall.<br />

Learn more at vvmf.org.<br />

A night of fun at the 80’s themed Scholarship Gala.<br />

TCA staff at the 80’s themed<br />

Scholarship Gala.<br />

The <strong>2015</strong> Top 20 Best Fleets to Drive<br />

for winners on stage at the banquet<br />

Tuesday evening.<br />

L-R: Shepard Dunn, Tom Kretsinger, Jr. and Tom<br />

Schilli present the Past Chairman’s Award to the<br />

family of the late John Kaburick. Pictured are<br />

Kaburick’s widow, Carolyn, and son, Josh.<br />

Chairman Tuttle giving<br />

his inaugural address<br />

at Wednesday’s general<br />

session.<br />

President Brad Bentley speaks at The Moving Wall exhibit.<br />

New TCA president Brad Bentley speaks to<br />

the crowd on Tuesday.<br />

The Moving Wall. Learn more at vvmf.org.<br />

TCA <strong>2015</strong> www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org | <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> 45


Mark Your Calendar<br />

Find more information on any of the following events at<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong>.org or contact TCA at (703) 838-1950.<br />

april <strong>2015</strong><br />

APRIL 16 >> WEBINAR<br />

Mobile recruiting: active and passive recruiting strategies<br />

APRIL 30-may 1 >> tca benchmarking TC-05<br />

The Loews New Orleans Hotel in New Orleans - Invitation Only<br />

May <strong>2015</strong><br />

MAY 3-5 >> <strong>2015</strong> Safety & Security Division Annual Meeting<br />

The Westin Charlotte in Charlotte, North Carolina<br />

MAY 4-5 >> tca benchmarking TC-06<br />

Chicago Marriott in Chicago - Invitation Only<br />

CAT Scale’s Weigh My Truck app<br />

allows your drivers to weigh and pay for<br />

their transaction using their smartphone,<br />

so they can get back on the road faster.<br />

Find out more at weighmytruck.com.<br />

Now accepting the<br />

EFS Fleet Card as<br />

a payment option!<br />

may 7 >> WEBINAR<br />

Obamacare3: Navigating through the ACA — what trucking companies<br />

need to know<br />

MAY 11-12 >> tca benchmarking TC-07<br />

Chicago Marriott Suites in Chicago - Invitation Only<br />

may 14 >> WEBINAR<br />

E-screening vs. pre-clearance: Do you know the difference?<br />

may 21 >> WEBINAR<br />

Developing an outbound recruiting strategy<br />

July <strong>2015</strong><br />

july 7-8 >> tca benchmarking TC-01<br />

Stowe Mountain Lodge in Stowe, Vermont - Invitation Only<br />

july 8-10 >> <strong>2015</strong> Refrigerated Division Annual Meeting<br />

Stowe Mountain Lodge in Stowe, Vermont<br />

march 2016<br />

march 6-9 >> 2016 Annual Convention<br />

Wynn Las Vegas in Las Vegas - Exhibitor opportunities available<br />

© <strong>2015</strong> CAT Scale Company<br />

Do yourself a<br />

favor and watch<br />

this video now!<br />

Scan here or log onto<br />

YouTube<br />

and search:<br />

<strong>Truckload</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong>,<br />

“Members Say<br />

It Best”<br />

Get the free mobile app at<br />

http:/ / gettag.mobi<br />

46 <strong>Truckload</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> | www.<strong>Truckload</strong>.org


Trucking has its challenges. When K&B Transportation encountered a<br />

loading dock issue at one of their largest customers, Wabash National went<br />

to work on a solution: from engineering and manufacturing to customer<br />

service and sales. With a rapid response team, Wabash National developed<br />

an innovative solution that was quickly produced, tested and installed.<br />

Problem solved.<br />

“Wabash responded with amazing speed.”<br />

— Brock Ackerman - Owner, K&B Transportation<br />

When you face challenges in your operation, call the team that<br />

gets things done. To hear more about how we helped K&B, visit<br />

wabash-trailers.com/responsive.<br />

W A B A S H - T R A I L E R S . C O M | 8 7 7. 4 2 9 . 5 1 8 0<br />

© 2014 Wabash National, L.P. All rights reserved. Wabash ® and Wabash National ®<br />

are marks owned by Wabash National, L.P.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!