Grimsditsch et al Pemba Resilience Survey 2009 low res
Grimsditsch et al Pemba Resilience Survey 2009 low res.pdf Grimsditsch et al Pemba Resilience Survey 2009 low res.pdf
Detailed Results 4.4 Crown-of-thorns starfish predation Crown-of-thorns (Acanthaster planci) starfish are corallivorous starfish that can cause major coral mortality on reefs if their populations explode. It is unknown what the trigger for population outbreaks is. Removal of predators through over-fishing, improved survival of larvae due to land-based nutrient inputs and increasing sea-surface temperature have all been postulated as potential triggers. Crown-of-thorns starfish outbreaks have recently become a regular occurrence on Pemba’s reefs, and are a major cause of coral mortality on the island. Paradise had the highest incidence of crown-of-thorns starfish feeding scars observed on coral colonies, with 5% of colonies being predated (graph below). This high predation rate could explain the low survivorship of coral recruits at this site. A crown-of-thorns starfish outbreak (over 50 individuals seen during one dive) was also observed at Fundo Inner, explaining the high incidence (3%) of predated coral at this site. 5 Incidence of Crown-of-thorns predation 4.5 4 % coral colonies 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 Paradise Fundo Inner Misali Fundo Outer Manta Swiss Mandela Msuka Bay Njao Gap The Hole Simba Kokota 27
Detailed Results 4.5 Fish community structure Herbivorous fish were classified into different functional groups depending on their feeding modes. Each functional group plays a different role in coral reef resilience. Excavators and scrapers (parrotfish) are important for preventing the establishment of macro-algae, removing algal turf and preparing the substrate for colonization by coral recruits. Grazers (surgeonfish, rabbitfish, angelfish) are important for removing algal turf and preventing the establishment of macro-algae. Browsers (unicornfish, batfish, some parrotfish) feed on macroalgae, and are important in reversing phase shifts to macro-algal dominated reefs. Pemba island is showing very strong signs of extreme over-fishing. 450 Major Fish Families Individuals per 250m2 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Acanthuridae Scaridae Lutjanidae Caesionidae Chaetodontidae Lethrinidae Kyphosidae Labridae Mullidae Balistidae Pomacanthidae Haemulidae Serranidae Carangidae Ephippidae Siganidae Sharks The bar graph shows that small bodied herbivorous Acanthuridae (surgeonfish) and Scaridae (parrotfish) are the most common fish surveyed in Pemba. No sharks and very few Serranidae (groupers) were seen, a clear indication of overfishing showing that very large bodied predators are left in the food chain. The main predators are Lutjanidae (snappers), but mostly small individuals were seen. 300 Fish Herbivory Individuals per 250m2 250 200 150 100 50 0 Grazers Scrapers Browsers Grazers/detritivores Small excavators Large excavators The bar graph shows that within the herbivorous functional groups, grazers, scrapers and browsers are most common. Hardly any Bolbometopon spp. which are large excavators were seen. Again, this is an indication of overfishing, as large bodied excavators are usually among the first to disappear on an overfished reef. 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Misali Fundo Outer Simba Paradise Swiss Mandela Kokota Njao Gap The Hole Manta Fundo Inner Fundo Lagoon Msuka Bay Density 250m2 Other groups Grazers/detritivores Small excavators Scrapers Large excavators Grazers Brow sers Fish Densities for all Functional Groups The bar graph shows fish densities for all functional groups including non-herbivores (‘other groups’) at the site level. 28
- Page 1 and 2: Coral Reef Resilience Assessment of
- Page 3 and 4: Coral Reef Resilience Assessment of
- Page 6 and 7: Executive Summary 1 Executive Summa
- Page 8 and 9: Executive Summary 2. Tackle the ove
- Page 10 and 11: The Study coral colony and coral co
- Page 12 and 13: The Study Table 2.1. Sites surveyed
- Page 14 and 15: The Study 7. Resilience indicators
- Page 16 and 17: Major Findings on the site that is
- Page 18 and 19: Major Findings rabbitfish, angelfis
- Page 20 and 21: Major Findings 2. Tackle the overfi
- Page 22 and 23: Detailed Results 4 Detailed Results
- Page 24 and 25: Detailed Results % coral colonies 1
- Page 26 and 27: Detailed Results 4.2 Coral communit
- Page 28 and 29: Detailed Results 4.3 Coral populati
- Page 30 and 31: Detailed Results Moderate Faviid Su
- Page 34 and 35: Detailed Results Density 250m2 200
- Page 36 and 37: Detailed Results 4.6 Resilience ind
- Page 38 and 39: Detailed Results Influence of resil
- Page 40 and 41: Detailed Results Fundo Lagoon Msuka
- Page 42: INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR CONSERVATIO
D<strong>et</strong>ailed Results<br />
4.5 Fish community structure<br />
Herbivorous fish were classified into different function<strong>al</strong> groups depending on their feeding modes. Each<br />
function<strong>al</strong> group plays a different role in cor<strong>al</strong> reef <strong>res</strong>ilience. Excavators and scrapers (parrotfish) are<br />
important for preventing the establishment of macro-<strong>al</strong>gae, removing <strong>al</strong>g<strong>al</strong> turf and preparing the substrate for<br />
colonization by cor<strong>al</strong> recruits. Grazers (surgeonfish, rabbitfish, angelfish) are important for removing <strong>al</strong>g<strong>al</strong> turf<br />
and preventing the establishment of macro-<strong>al</strong>gae. Browsers (unicornfish, batfish, some parrotfish) feed on<br />
macro<strong>al</strong>gae, and are important in reversing phase shifts to macro-<strong>al</strong>g<strong>al</strong> dominated reefs.<br />
<strong>Pemba</strong> island is showing very strong signs of extreme over-fishing.<br />
450<br />
Major Fish Families<br />
Individu<strong>al</strong>s per 250m2<br />
400<br />
350<br />
300<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Acanthuridae<br />
Scaridae<br />
Lutjanidae<br />
Caesionidae<br />
Cha<strong>et</strong>odontidae<br />
L<strong>et</strong>hrinidae<br />
Kyphosidae<br />
Labridae<br />
Mullidae<br />
B<strong>al</strong>istidae<br />
Pomacanthidae<br />
Haemulidae<br />
Serranidae<br />
Carangidae<br />
Ephippidae<br />
Siganidae<br />
Sharks<br />
The bar graph shows that sm<strong>al</strong>l<br />
bodied herbivorous Acanthuridae<br />
(surgeonfish) and Scaridae<br />
(parrotfish) are the most common<br />
fish surveyed in <strong>Pemba</strong>. No sharks<br />
and very few Serranidae (groupers)<br />
were seen, a clear indication of<br />
overfishing showing that very large<br />
bodied predators are left in the food<br />
chain. The main predators are<br />
Lutjanidae (snappers), but mostly<br />
sm<strong>al</strong>l individu<strong>al</strong>s were seen.<br />
300<br />
Fish Herbivory<br />
Individu<strong>al</strong>s per 250m2<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Grazers<br />
Scrapers<br />
Browsers<br />
Grazers/d<strong>et</strong>ritivo<strong>res</strong><br />
Sm<strong>al</strong>l excavators<br />
Large excavators<br />
The bar graph shows that within the<br />
herbivorous function<strong>al</strong> groups,<br />
grazers, scrapers and browsers are<br />
most common. Hardly any<br />
Bolbom<strong>et</strong>opon spp. which are large<br />
excavators were seen. Again, this is<br />
an indication of overfishing, as large<br />
bodied excavators are usu<strong>al</strong>ly<br />
among the first to disappear on an<br />
overfished reef.<br />
300<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Mis<strong>al</strong>i<br />
Fundo Outer<br />
Simba<br />
Paradise<br />
Swiss<br />
Mandela<br />
Kokota<br />
Njao Gap<br />
The Hole<br />
Manta<br />
Fundo Inner<br />
Fundo Lagoon<br />
Msuka Bay<br />
Density 250m2<br />
Other groups<br />
Grazers/d<strong>et</strong>ritivo<strong>res</strong><br />
Sm<strong>al</strong>l excavators<br />
Scrapers<br />
Large excavators<br />
Grazers<br />
Brow sers<br />
Fish Densities for <strong>al</strong>l Function<strong>al</strong><br />
Groups<br />
The bar graph shows fish densities<br />
for <strong>al</strong>l function<strong>al</strong> groups including<br />
non-herbivo<strong>res</strong> (‘other groups’) at<br />
the site level.<br />
28
Change language