14.10.2015 Views

abu-maria-book-final

abu-maria-book-final

abu-maria-book-final

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

estowed favor, not of those who have evoked [Your] anger or of those who are astray.<br />

And may blessings of Allah be upon Muhammad" (Ad Durar Saniyyah 8/217)<br />

And Mulla Ali Al Qari - may Allah have mercy on him - said: "And our scholars have<br />

said, "If you find ninety nine reasons to make Takfeer on a Muslim and you find a single<br />

reason to keep him in Islam then the Mufti 20 and the judge should work based on that one<br />

reason and this is implied from his saying "Avoid the legal penalties over the<br />

Muslims as much as possible. If you find a way out for a Muslim then let him go, for the<br />

Imam making a mistake in forgiving is better than him making mistake in punishment."<br />

Reported by At Tirmidhi and other than him and Al Haakim said it is Saheeh [Sharh al<br />

Shafa by Mulla Ali al Qari 2/502]<br />

And after this introduction, we will cite the sayings of the scholars regarding one who<br />

fights under a banner of Kufr 21 in order to repel the Kuffar and this is an even greater<br />

evidence against Takfeer on the one who fights under a Sunni banner or an Islamic one in<br />

which there is a deficiency. And these people make Takfeer on the ones who fight under<br />

these banners merely based on doubts and assumptions and that which cannot be based<br />

upon even for issuing the smallest of Shareeah rulings, so how about that which is for<br />

even greater rulings? Like making Takfeer based upon the news from the Kuffar or the<br />

immoral ones and like the Takfeer based on news in the newspapers of the Kuffar, rather<br />

making Takfeer on nations based on a statement of a Christian official who said that they<br />

had cooperated with them. And Allah has spoken the truth:<br />

‎2‎‏َفِ/كُمْ‏ سَم َّاعُو'َ‏ لَ$ُمْ‏<br />

"And among you are avid listeners to them". (Surat at Tawba 9:47)<br />

If only this unconfirmed matter would in reality have been a Kufr! But they are after all<br />

doubts and issues of assumptions; And is merely sitting with the Kuffar something which<br />

is considered a nullifier of Islam? And is merely having communication with the Kuffar a<br />

nullifier of Islam? Surely this is an astounding thing.<br />

And if we were to assume that a skilled disbeliever offered a service to a Muslim, then is<br />

that Muslim considered a deviant or having diluted his beliefs? Is everyone to whom the<br />

Kuffar give weapons considered a Kaafir?<br />

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!<br />

20 !Mufti!is!the!one!who!is!in!authority!to!issue!legal!religious!verdicts.!<br />

21 !It!is!a!banner!that!disbelieves!in!Allah!and!His!messenger!and!refuses!to!acknowledge!His!Shareeah.!

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!