Title Slide
download - the Bermuda Captive Conference
download - the Bermuda Captive Conference
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Title</strong> <strong>Slide</strong><br />
Second Header
Captive Insurance Exit & Run-Off Solutions<br />
Speakers:<br />
• Tom Booth, CFO, Randall & Quilter Investment Holdings plc<br />
• Sean Logan, Chairman, Principal, ACG Limited<br />
• Jeremy Brasier, EVP, RFIB Group Limited<br />
Moderator:<br />
• Nick Frost, President, R&Q Quest Management Services
Contents<br />
• Potential drivers for sale of Captive<br />
• Captive restructuring solutions<br />
• Captive exit solutions<br />
• Pricing and process<br />
• Recent deals<br />
• Contact details
Potential drivers for sale of Captive<br />
• Ownership of multiple captives following M&A activity<br />
– Different jurisdictions<br />
– Different fronting and collateral arrangements<br />
• Captive owner in liquidation or some other form of restructuring / corporate activity at the Parent level<br />
• Captive no longer utilised<br />
– annual costs resulting in declining NAV<br />
– Soft external insurance market offers better economics than retaining risk<br />
– Investment returns are much reduced<br />
– Company strategy and risk appetite changes<br />
• Long tail exposures create ongoing uncertainty<br />
– Unutilised aggregate limits remain available for further losses to be advised<br />
• Desire to free up the significant assets (cash) tied up in the captive especially in collateral obligations to front<br />
companies<br />
– Inability to close captive due to past liability underwriting<br />
– Front Company unwilling to offer deductible buy-back or commutation of liabilities or at an acceptable price<br />
• Change of Front Company<br />
– Increased collateral requirements<br />
– Lack of incentive for previous front(s) to reduce collateral requirements<br />
– More tax efficient against dividend/capital reduction or commutation/wind-up routes<br />
• Changes to tax, accounting or regulatory environment
Captive restructuring solutions<br />
Solutions to remove risks & free up excess collateral<br />
The on-going use of a Captive may still be desirable but novation of certain<br />
prior year policies may have substantial benefits to the owner including:<br />
• Removing/reducing exposures to long tail liabilities and/or undesirable perils or from former<br />
subsidiaries/recently acquired companies as well as those from a certain period<br />
• Releasing significant collateral obligation to front companies, often substantially above estimated<br />
reserves, for re-investment; in the captive or elsewhere<br />
• Removing involvement with one or more legacy front companies<br />
• Streamlining the captive’s business ahead of restructuring or wind-up
Captive exit solutions<br />
• Captive/Cell Acquisition<br />
– All liabilities/obligations and assets<br />
of the captive/cell are assumed<br />
– New owner maintains the<br />
relationship as reinsurer of the<br />
Fronting Company (if applicable)<br />
• Including meeting collateral obligations<br />
– New owner also assumes all<br />
record keeping and claims<br />
management<br />
• Original TPA arrangement generally<br />
continues with oversight<br />
– Regulatory approval obtained<br />
• Generally received promptly and prior to<br />
completion<br />
<br />
<br />
• Novation/Portfolio Transfer<br />
– Identified risks transferred to a<br />
third party owned cell or existing<br />
captive/insurance company<br />
– Transferee entity replaces the<br />
original captive as reinsurer of the<br />
Fronting Company<br />
– Transfer effected by means of a<br />
Novation agreement between the<br />
parties<br />
• Assignment/replacement of the same<br />
collateral obligations<br />
– All record keeping and claims<br />
management assumed<br />
• Original arrangements generally<br />
continue with oversight<br />
– Regulatory approval obtained<br />
promptly and generally prior to<br />
completion
Pricing and process <br />
• Acquisitions<br />
– Captives typically acquired at a<br />
discount to NAV to achieve<br />
required return on capital<br />
– Once future standalone run-off<br />
costs are factored in, true discount<br />
to NAV is often significantly<br />
reduced/eliminated<br />
• Transaction may therefore be effectively<br />
NAV accretive for the vendor as well as<br />
cash positive<br />
• Novations<br />
– An appropriate margin is generally<br />
charged over the reserves<br />
assumed to account for future runoff<br />
costs and to generate required<br />
return. If there is potential reserve<br />
uncertainty/inadequacy, a further<br />
“risk” margin may be required<br />
– Existing collateral is either:<br />
• Replaced by new collateral from the transferee: the<br />
provision of which will be factored into the pricing<br />
• Acquired/assigned to new owner together with the liabilities<br />
making the transaction akin to an acquisition i.e. priced on a<br />
discount to NAV basis<br />
• Provided on a continuing basis by transferor to whom it is<br />
released back over time<br />
Attractive offers can be made:<br />
• Primarily by sharing internal cost efficiencies with vendors<br />
• Because core business is the run-off of long-tail liabilities and reserve adequacy can be fairly<br />
assessed<br />
• Because wider relationships with fronting insurers may alleviate future collateral requirements
Pricing and process (cont’d)<br />
1. Indicative offer based on:<br />
Latest audited financial statements and management accounts<br />
Summary of business written including loss limits, aggregates and coverage periods<br />
Latest actuarial report and claims triangles (if available)<br />
Full claims listing including those closed, opened and reopened<br />
Details or front company involvements and collateral obligations<br />
2. If offer accepted, a Heads of Terms will be executed outlining price, assumptions<br />
and any other terms along with an exclusivity period<br />
3. Due diligence and drafting of legal documents undertaken<br />
4. Final terms agreed and any required regulatory approvals sought and documents executed<br />
Process can take as little as 4-6 weeks from initial information request to completion
Recent deals<br />
Acquisi7on of Barbados based cap7ve<br />
Acquisi7on of Guernsey<br />
based cap7ve<br />
Acquisi7on of Guernsey based cap7ve<br />
Acquisi7on of Guernsey based cap7ve<br />
RAB Insurance Company Limited<br />
Acquisi7on of Isle of Man based cap7ve<br />
Acquisi7on of Guernsey based cap7ve
Contact details<br />
Tom Booth<br />
Group CFO<br />
+1 441 295 2185<br />
tom.booth@rqih.com<br />
Paul Corver<br />
Investment Director<br />
+44 (0)20 7780 5944<br />
paul.corver@rqih.com<br />
Maralyn Fichte<br />
Insurance Investments<br />
+44 (0)20 7977 0493<br />
maralyn.fichte@rqih.com