<strong>GAD</strong> Back to <strong>the</strong> Future…Åke LernmarkÅke Lernmark, MD, Ph.D., is R.H.Williams Professor of Medicine at<strong>the</strong> University of Washington inSeattle. Lernmark focused hisattention on diabetes and <strong>the</strong><strong>anti</strong>gen that later proved to be<strong>GAD</strong> at an early stage. Lernmarkwas first to demonstrate <strong>the</strong> presenceof <strong>anti</strong>bodies against <strong>GAD</strong>in patients <strong>with</strong> insulin-dependentdiabetes, and to use molecularmethods to define HLA genes thatare necessary, but not sufficient todevelop <strong>the</strong> disorder.The beta cell specific loss associated <strong>with</strong><strong>the</strong> clinical onset of Type 1 diabetesmellitus (T1DM) is a remarkable phenomenon.The ablation of <strong>the</strong> insulinproducingcells does not seem to affectneighboring cells producing glucagon,somatostatin or pancreas polypeptide. The eradication of <strong>the</strong>beta cells is a testimony to <strong>the</strong> laser knife-like precision of<strong>the</strong> immune system to recognize and attack <strong>anti</strong>gen. Theimmune mediated loss of beta cells is well documented inpancreas specimens from T1DM patients of short diseaseduration. The degree and character of <strong>the</strong> inflammatory cellinfiltration vary from patient to patient and would not predictclinical onset. The loss of beta cells appears more predictiveand <strong>the</strong> major question that we and o<strong>the</strong>rs try to answeris whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong> immune attack on <strong>the</strong> beta cells can bereversed by controlling <strong>the</strong> autoimmune reaction againstglutamic acid decarboxylase (<strong>GAD</strong>65) ei<strong>the</strong>r before or afteronset. While auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies to insulin and IA-2 are predictiveof T1DM primarily in <strong>the</strong> young, <strong>the</strong> predictive value of<strong>GAD</strong>65 auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies appears less age-dependent. It is <strong>the</strong>reforeoften argued that <strong>GAD</strong>65 is <strong>the</strong> major auto<strong>anti</strong>gen inT1DM, which is consistent <strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>65 auto<strong>anti</strong>bodiesbeing most prevalent (more than 80% of new onset patients)at onset. Although recent follow up studies suggestthat <strong>GAD</strong>65 auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies are not necessarily <strong>the</strong> firstauto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong> to appear before <strong>the</strong> clinical diagnosis is made,appearance of all three auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies to <strong>GAD</strong>65, IA-2 andinsulin is <strong>the</strong> best predictor of disease. Recognition of<strong>GAD</strong>65 by helper CD4 and killer CD8 positive cells are likelyto precede <strong>the</strong> auto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong> appearance. At present,<strong>the</strong>re is a lack of reliable and standardized tests that detectT cell reactivity against islet auto<strong>anti</strong>gens (1). This is in contrastto <strong>GAD</strong>65 and IA-2 auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies, which can be reliablymeasured against a WHO standard (2). At least <strong>the</strong>rewill be one reliable way to monitor whe<strong>the</strong>r SpecificImmune Therapy (SIT) <strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>65 might alter <strong>the</strong> courseof T1DM disease associated autoimmunity.Following <strong>the</strong> molecular cloning of <strong>the</strong> human (3) androdent <strong>GAD</strong> proteins (4) it was possible to carry out experiments<strong>with</strong> recombinant <strong>GAD</strong>65 to demonstrate that spontaneousdiabetes in <strong>the</strong> NOD mouse (5, 6) was preventable.Of equal importance was <strong>the</strong> observation that diabetes wasnot inducible by <strong>GAD</strong>65 in rats (7) and mice (8). T1D <strong>the</strong>reforedid not immediately seem to mimic o<strong>the</strong>r autoimmunediseases, which have animal models that are based on <strong>the</strong>actual immunization of an auto<strong>anti</strong>gen. About 10 yearsafter <strong>the</strong> demonstration that NOD mouse diabetes was preventable,Phase I (toxicity) and Phase II (safety) clinical trialsof <strong>GAD</strong>65 have been completed. In <strong>the</strong> absence of adverseevents among <strong>the</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>65 auto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong> positive Type 2 diabetespatients (so-called LADA patients or LatentAutoimmune Diabetes in <strong>the</strong> Adult) it may now be possibleto move into Phase III clinical trials to test whe<strong>the</strong>r<strong>GAD</strong>65 SIT is efficacious.The future approach to determine whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>GAD</strong>65 SIT1994Researchers showthat transplantedislets survivelonger if <strong>the</strong>y arepretreated <strong>with</strong><strong>GAD</strong>1998Researcherstransfer diabetesbetween animals<strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>-reactiveT cellsStart ofPhase Iclinical trial<strong>Diamyd</strong> Phase Iclinical trial in 24healthyindividualscompleted<strong>Diamyd</strong> Medicalinitiatesdevelopment of a<strong>GAD</strong> baseddiabetes vaccine1996Researchers showthat progressionto T1DM isassociated <strong>with</strong> achange in <strong>GAD</strong>Aisotypes1999Researchers showthat ß-cellexpression of <strong>GAD</strong>is required fordevelopment ofT1DM in <strong>the</strong> NODmouse2000Start of Phase IIclinical trial
is truly inducing immune tolerance, deviation, or both, is tocarefully move from adult patients who already have diabetessuch as LADA patients to new onset adult T1DM patientsand <strong>the</strong>n possibly to triple auto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong> positive firstdegree relatives since our ability to predict disease in suchsubjects is now well documented thanks to <strong>the</strong> DPT-1study <strong>with</strong> parenteral insulin administration (9). Theattempts to approach prevention in <strong>the</strong> fashion modeled inanimals will by necessity require a carefully staked outpathway. Novel observations are particularly tantalizing asto <strong>the</strong> possibility to use <strong>GAD</strong>65 SIT and cause no harm inhealthy subjects.The beta cell expression of <strong>GAD</strong>65 in human beta cells iswell established. There is a lack of qualitative and qu<strong>anti</strong>tativestudies on <strong>GAD</strong>65 in <strong>the</strong> non-insulin producing endocrineislet cells. Also, we still do not fully understand <strong>the</strong> roleof GABA for normal beta cell function. Recent observationssuggest that increased body mass index (BMI) is associated<strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>65 auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies in subjects not developing diabetes(10, 11). It will be critical to find out if subclinical<strong>GAD</strong>65 autoimmunity is related to obesity phenotypes arisingbecause of altered beta cell function, insulin resistance,or both. Future studies will also require detailed studies of<strong>GAD</strong>65 gene expression in CNS areas controlling food intakesince <strong>GAD</strong>65 gene polymorphisms affecting GABA productionmay be related to morbid obesity (P. Boutin and P.Frougel, personal communication). The role of <strong>GAD</strong>65 genepolymorphism in food intake regulation, obesity developmentand beta cell function may <strong>the</strong>refore need to be fur<strong>the</strong>rstudied before we can embark on large scale <strong>GAD</strong>65SIT.The relationship between Stiff Man Syndrome and <strong>GAD</strong>autoimmunity was critical to <strong>the</strong> demonstration that T1DMsera immunoprecipitated 64K protein <strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong> enzymeactivity (12). We have now learned that <strong>the</strong> immune responseto <strong>GAD</strong>65 in SMS is qualitatively and qu<strong>anti</strong>tatively diffferentfrom T1DM and <strong>the</strong> approach to prevent ei<strong>the</strong>r SMS,T1DM, or both may require different<strong>GAD</strong>65 SIT. One approach may be tobase <strong>the</strong> SIT on <strong>the</strong> HLA association<strong>with</strong> <strong>the</strong> disease. In <strong>the</strong> InsulinAutoimmune Syndrome <strong>the</strong> auto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong>formation is strongly associated<strong>with</strong> HLA DRB1*0401. This haplotypeis insufficient for <strong>the</strong> association <strong>with</strong>insulin auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies in T1DM, whichis ra<strong>the</strong>r associated <strong>with</strong> HLADQA1*0501-B1*0201. Hence insulin aswell as <strong>GAD</strong>65 is <strong>the</strong> auto<strong>anti</strong>gen ofmore than one disorder of autoimmunecharacter. Future studies will needto take <strong>the</strong>se similarities and differencesinto account to design interventiontrials that may lead to <strong>the</strong> identificationof novel approaches to prevent orreverse auto<strong>anti</strong>gen-specific autoimmunity.Don’t sit around, <strong>GAD</strong> back to<strong>the</strong> future…References1. Peakman M, et al,Characterization of preparations of <strong>GAD</strong>65, proinsulin, and <strong>the</strong> islet tyrosinephosphatase IA-2 for use in detection of autoreactive T cells in Type 1 diabetes:report of phase II of <strong>the</strong> Second International Immunology of Diabetes SocietyWorkshop for Standardization of T cell assays in Type 1 diabetes.Diabetes 50:1749-1754, 2001.2. Mire-Sluis AR, et al,The World Health Organization International Collaborative Study for Islet CellAntibodies.Diabetologia 43:1282-1292., 2003. Karlsen AE, et al,Cloning and primary structure of a human islet isoform of glutamic acid decarboxylasefrom chromosome 10.Proc Natl Acad Sci US 88:8337-8341, 1991.4. Kaufman DJ, et al,Autoimmunity to two forms of glutamate decarboxylase in Insulin-dependentdiabetes mellitus.J. Clin. Invest. 89:283-292, 19925. Kaufman DL, et al,Spontaneous loss of T cell tolerance to glutamic acid decarboxylase in murineinsulin-dependent diabetes.Nature 366:69-72, 1993.6. Tisch R, et al,Immune response to glutamic acid decarboxylase correlates <strong>with</strong> insulitis in nonobesediabetic mice.Nature 366:72-75, 1993.7. Bieg S, et al,<strong>GAD</strong>65 and insulin B chain peptide (9-23) are not primary auto<strong>anti</strong>gens in <strong>the</strong>Type 1 diabetes syndrome of <strong>the</strong> BB rat.Autoimmunity 31:15-24, 1999.8. Plesner A, et al,Immunization of diabetes-prone or non-diabetes-prone mice <strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>65 doesnot induce diabetes or islet cell pathology.J Autoimmun 11:335-341, 1998.9. DPT-1: Effects of insulin in relatives of patients <strong>with</strong> Type 1 diabetes mellitus. NEngl J Med 346:1685-1691, 2002.10. Rolandsson O, et al,Levels of glutamate decarboxylase (<strong>GAD</strong>65) and tyrosine phosphatase-like protein(IA-2) auto<strong>anti</strong>bodies in <strong>the</strong> general population are related to glucose intoleranceand body mass index.Diabetologia 42:555-559, 1999.11. Weets I, et al,Male-to-female excess in diabetes diagnosed in early adulthood is not specific for<strong>the</strong> immune-mediated form nor is it HLA-DQ restricted: possible relation toincreased body mass index.Diabetologia 44:40-47, 2001.12. Baekkeskov S, et al,Identification of <strong>the</strong> 64K auto<strong>anti</strong>gen in insulin-dependent diabetes as <strong>the</strong> GABAsyn<strong>the</strong>sizingenzyme glutamic acid decarboxylase.Nature 347:151-156, 1990.Researchers preventT1DM in <strong>the</strong>NOD mouse byvaccination <strong>with</strong><strong>GAD</strong>-plasmid DNAScientists prevent T1DM in<strong>the</strong> NOD mouse <strong>with</strong> <strong>GAD</strong>genemodified Vaccinia virusResearchers report that<strong>GAD</strong> gene polymorphismmay be associated <strong>with</strong>obesity200120022003ADA says in its Clinical PracticeRecommendations for 2002 that“auto<strong><strong>anti</strong>body</strong> tests may be of value toidentify which newly diagnosedpatients have immune-mediated Type 1-diabetes in circumstances where it is notobvious".Resarchers successfullyuse <strong>GAD</strong> gene <strong>the</strong>rapy fortreatment of Parkinson’sdisease in an animalmodel<strong>Diamyd</strong> Phase IIclinical trial in47 LADApatientscompleted
- Page 4 and 5: forewordResearch Scientists through
- Page 6 and 7: The Story ofGADRobert Dinsmoor1975R
- Page 8 and 9: Åke Lernmark, MD, Ph.D., and his c
- Page 10 and 11: theory, the immune system mistakenl
- Page 14 and 15: 100GAD in GraphsGAD65 DNA vaccinati
- Page 16 and 17: In Nature, Anything that CanHappen
- Page 18 and 19: References1. Baekkeskov, S., et al,
- Page 20 and 21: GAD in GraphsIncidence of diabetes
- Page 22 and 23: References1. Quinn A, et al,MHC cla
- Page 24 and 25: References1. Tisch, R., et al,Induc
- Page 26 and 27: Vaccination with GAD PlasmidSuppres
- Page 28 and 29: GADGAD in GraphsGAD ELISPOT outperf
- Page 30 and 31: GAD in GraphsA1004 wks of age% Inci
- Page 32 and 33: Mark Atkinson, Ph.D.,is an American
- Page 34 and 35: GAD in GraphsIL-4 (pg/ml)2501007550
- Page 36 and 37: References1. Kobayashi T, et al,Isl
- Page 38 and 39: References1. A.Falorni, et al,Radio
- Page 40 and 41: References1. Chattopadhyay, S., et
- Page 42 and 43: Diamyd’s Commercial Development o
- Page 44: T cell GAD65For use of GAD in immun