06.12.2012 Views

LEGIONELLA - World Health Organization

LEGIONELLA - World Health Organization

LEGIONELLA - World Health Organization

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Table . Compar son of methods for laboratory d agnos s of Leg onna res’ d sease<br />

Method<br />

Sens t v ty<br />

(%)<br />

Spec f c ty<br />

(%) Comments References<br />

Culture • “Gold standard”<br />

Sputum 5–70 100 • Requires 2–4 days,<br />

sometimes<br />

BAL or<br />

transtracheal<br />

aspirate<br />

30–90 100<br />

(rarely) up to<br />

14 days<br />

• Highest specificity<br />

Lung biopsy 90–99 100<br />

Blood 10–30 100<br />

Serology • Seroconversion<br />

Seroconversion 70–90 95–99 may require<br />

3–9 weeks<br />

Single<br />

specimen<br />

Ur nary<br />

ant gen<br />

(unknown) 50–70<br />

75–99 99–100 • Only for L.p.sg1,<br />

limited data for<br />

other serogroups<br />

or species<br />

• Very rapid<br />

(15 min–3 h),<br />

frequently earliest<br />

positive finding,<br />

may remain positive<br />

for several<br />

weeks/months<br />

DFA test ng • Very rapid (2–4 h)<br />

Sputum 25–75 95–99 • Limited sensitivity<br />

or BAL<br />

• Experience needed<br />

Lung biopsy 80–90 99<br />

• No validated<br />

reagents for nonpneumophila<br />

species<br />

Edelstein & Meyer, 1994;<br />

Stout & Yu 1997; Harrison<br />

et al., 1998; Maiwald,<br />

Helbig & Lück, 1998;<br />

Fields, Benson & Besser,<br />

2002; Lück, Helbig &<br />

Schuppler, 2002<br />

Edelstein & Meyer, 1994;<br />

Plouffe et al., 1995; Stout<br />

& Yu, 1997; Harrison et al.,<br />

1998; Fields, Benson &<br />

Besser, 2002; Lück, Helbig<br />

& Schuppler, 2002;<br />

Edelstein & Meyer, 1994;<br />

Stout & Yu, 1997; Harrison<br />

et al., 1998; Fields, Benson<br />

& Besser, 2002; Lück,<br />

Helbig & Schuppler, 2002;<br />

Uldum & Molbak, 2002<br />

Edelstein & Meyer,<br />

1994; Stout and Yu, 1997;<br />

Harrison et al., 1998; Fields,<br />

Benson & Besser, 2002<br />

<strong>LEGIONELLA</strong> AND THE PREVENTION OF LEGIONELLOSIS

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!