VIOLENCE INSTEAD OF TREATMENT: POLICEKILLINGS OF BLACK WOMEN IN MENTALHEALTH CRISISIn the absence of adequate mental health resources for the vast majority of Black communities, lawenforcement <strong>officer</strong>s often serve as the first and only responders to mental health crises experiencedby Black women. Police <strong>officer</strong>s, however, are not mental health professionals, and often lack the skillsand training necessary to handle these situations. This lack of training, compounded with a takecharge-at-all-costsattitude on the part of some <strong>officer</strong>s, has led to the loss of life of those whom thepolice were called to serve. In several tragic instances, police <strong>officer</strong>s have perceived Black womenwho are experiencing mental health crises as dangerous or as individuals who possess “superhuman”strength no matter how vulnerable, fragile, or in distress they might be. Instead of offering the compassionatesupport these women needed, police criminalized them and responded with deadly force.Tanisha AndersonNovember 13, 2014 / Cleveland, Ohiowouldn’t know anything was wrong with her.” 43Johnson indicated that despite media narratives,Anderson was not violent, and that it wasthe behavior of the police in isolating her fromher family that made her panic.Michelle CusseauxAugust 13, 2014 / Phoenix, Arizona18The family of 37-year-old Tanisha Andersonreached out for assistance to calm their daughterduring a mental health crisis. Anderson grewincreasingly agitated when the police separatedher from her family and attempted to place herin the confined space of the police vehicle. Duringthe struggle, a police <strong>officer</strong> performed a“takedown” move on her, slamming her againstthe concrete sidewalk. He placed his knee on herback and handcuffed her as she lay face-downon the pavement. The <strong>officer</strong>s refused to allowAnderson’s family to comfort her as she lay dyingand exposed on the snow-covered street.She was pronounced dead upon arrival at thehospital. The Cuyahoga County medical examinerruled her death a homicide. 42 Anderson’sfamily has filed a wrongful death lawsuit againstthe City of Cleveland and two of its police <strong>officer</strong>s.Anderson suffered from bipolar disorder,but her mother, Cassandra Johnson, explainedthat as long as she was on her medication, “youPolice shot Michelle Cusseaux to death in her homewhile they were attempting to take her to a mentalhealth facility. Cusseaux refused to let the police inher home, prompting Officer Percy Dupra to breakthrough the screen door to gain entry. Dupra encounteredCusseaux holding a hammer and shother in the heart. Dupra claimed that although Cusseauxsaid nothing to threaten him, “she had thatanger in her face like she was going to hit someonewith that hammer.” Cusseaux’s mother, FrancesGarrett wondered, “What did the police <strong>officer</strong> seewhen he pried open the door? A Black woman? Alesbian?” 44 Cusseaux’s mother further explained
that Cusseaux was changing the lock on the doorwhen the police arrived, and that was why she hadtools out. 45 Moreover, the police knew when theyarrived at her home that Cusseaux suffered frommental illness, but they were ill-prepared to managethe situation and ended her life instead of protectingit. 46 In February 2015, Cusseaux’s mother filed alawsuit against the City of Phoenix, arguing that thepolice sergeant either ignored Michelle’s condition,or was inadequately trained to respond to it.Kayla Moore, a Black transgender woman,was killed by Berkeley police who came to herhome in response to a call for help from herroommate because Kayla was experiencing amental health crisis. Instead of escorting Kaylato a medical facility as requested, the <strong>officer</strong>sattempted to arrest her on a warrant fora man 20 years her senior, who had the samename Kayla was given at birth. Several <strong>officer</strong>soverpowered Kayla in her own bedroom, suffocatingher to death in the process. Afterward,<strong>officer</strong>s delayed monitoring her vital signs, referredto her using transgender slurs, and failedto administer adequate life-saving treatment.Kayla’s body was also exposed during and afterthe police assault. Activists in Berkeley haveorganized to publicize her case, and her familyhas filed a lawsuit against the Berkeley police<strong>officer</strong>s responsible for her death. 48Shereese FrancisMarch 15, 2012 / Queens, New YorkPearlie GoldenMay 7, 2014 / Hearne, TexasPolice <strong>officer</strong> Stephen Stem fatally shot PearlieGolden, a 93-year-old woman, after her nephewcalled to report that she was waving a gun. Hernephew said that Golden was upset because hehad taken her car keys after she failed a drivingtest. When Stem saw the elderly woman wavingthe gun around, he fired 4-5 rounds at her,hitting her at least twice. Four days later hewas fired from the police department. A grandjury failed to indict him for Golden’s killing. 47Kayla MooreFebruary 12, 2013 / Berkeley, CaliforniaShereese Francis’ family called for an ambulanceafter she became emotionally distraughtfollowing an argument with her mother. Franciswas schizophrenic and at the time was not takingher medication. Four police <strong>officer</strong>s arrivedat their home in Queens and tried to convinceFrancis to go to the hospital, but she refused.The <strong>officer</strong>s reported that she was uncooperativeand that she lunged at them. In response,all four <strong>officer</strong>s pinned her down and attemptedto handcuff her. Francis stopped breathingduring this altercation, and the hospital pronouncedher dead shortly afterward. The coroner’sreport concluded Francis had died due tothe “compression of [her] trunk during agitatedviolent behavior.” Her family has filed a wrongfuldeath lawsuit, and the police departmenthas yet to release its records in response to aFreedom of Information Act request. 49Tyisha MillerDecember 28, 1998 / Riverside, California19Three days after Christmas, police <strong>officer</strong>s fatallyshot 19-year-old Tyisha Miller after findingher unconscious in a car that had brokendown. A gun rested on Tyisha’s lap, as she layunconscious. Friends said the gun was likelydisplayed for protection because a man hadbeen harassing her when they left to get help.Police arrived and broke a side window of thecar, rousing Miller. As she regained consciousness,<strong>officer</strong>s fired 24 shots at her, striking herwith 12 bullets. Following the shooting the <strong>officer</strong>swere placed on administrative leave, butno one was charged with the shooting. 50 19