30.07.2015 Views

john donne, a poet more of spirituality than of sensuality

john donne, a poet more of spirituality than of sensuality

john donne, a poet more of spirituality than of sensuality

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

John Donne, a PoetIn ‘Elegy XII: His Parting from Her’, Donne portrays the picture <strong>of</strong> a lover who is not in anykind <strong>of</strong> mechanical love but in real love. As a result, he has mutually enjoyed all the sighs,tears and fevers <strong>of</strong> love. This love challenges fortune saying;Rend us asunder, thou canst not divideOur bodies so, but that our souls are ty’d,And we can love by letters still and gifts,And thoughts and dreams; Love never wanteth shifts.Rejection <strong>of</strong> body is very special about this love where he says;Declare yourself base Fortunes enemy,No less by your contempt <strong>than</strong> constancy:That I may grow enamoured <strong>of</strong> your mind,When mind own thoughts I there reflected find.This increase <strong>of</strong> love is thought to be the victory <strong>of</strong> love against fortune. In the end hedeclares his constancy saying;Take therefore all in this: I love so true,As I will never look for less in you.So, here Donne praises <strong>spirituality</strong> under a wrapper <strong>of</strong> love that gives emphasis on sharingfeelings together, united souls and constancy <strong>of</strong> love. ‘Elegy: On His Mistresse’ is also apoem about the separation <strong>of</strong> two lovers who are afraid <strong>of</strong> the outer world. The lover,here, says to;Think it enough for me to have had thy love,Visibly it is a poem concerned about the lonely beloved and about preparing well beingfor beloved in absence <strong>of</strong> lover. But, Donne’s ‘Elegy: To His Mistresse Going To Bed’appears to be very frank in colloquial <strong>sensuality</strong> as it brings forth sexual language andinnuendoes;The foe <strong>of</strong>t-times having the foe in sight,Is tired with standing though they never fight.99This may have been the reason <strong>of</strong> this poem being banned from the 1633 edition. But itmust be noted that Donne assumes here, as elsewhere, that the language <strong>of</strong> sexual loveis not a special lovers’ language, rather, it includes any idea that comes to hand whethertaken from ordinary realities <strong>of</strong> daily life, or from wide range <strong>of</strong> his reading. Even in such apoem borrowed idea from the theology <strong>of</strong> Caluin is found. Caluin has argued that menare unable to win salvation through any merit <strong>of</strong> their own where a few get therighteousness or ‘grace’ <strong>of</strong> God or Jesus Christ as they are to be saved due to the‘imputed grace’ provided by the God. Here Donne suggests that no man can enjoy thecompany <strong>of</strong> woman but can only hope that the woman will impute to him her owninfinitely superior qualities and love him for them. Donne calls the activities <strong>of</strong> theprotagonist and the mistress as something where there is ‘no penance’ but ‘much lessinnocence’. Thus, the elegies clarify the spiritual ideas to bring morality before all in a verycomprehensive way.John Donne’s ‘Songs and Sonnets’ are product <strong>of</strong> different attitudes according to themood <strong>of</strong> the moment but in these poems Donne discovers his love philosophy to win overthe argument <strong>of</strong> superiority <strong>of</strong> body and soul in love. For, ‘The Flea’ the mood is certainly aromantic one though there is a logical trickery made by Donne. However the target forDonne’s trickery is audience if the dramatic situation, that <strong>of</strong> a man wining an argumentagainst a woman, is produced for the audience to find their own decision in this regard.Any debate competition can be won by pure and prolific logic but the ethical decision isthrown to every audience. It is surely the audience who is to take decision seeing thedebate. But, the mood in ‘The Good Morrow’ is for one newly in love who rejoices as thehttp://www.bdresearchpublications.com/journal/


Dipak Kumar Sarkar100love is reciprocated. Again, Donne celebrates the joy <strong>of</strong> true love in ‘The Sunne Rising’.Here, he depicts the picture <strong>of</strong> Sun being criticized by a lover. The lover is strong due to histrue love and so he has the strength to ‘eclipse and cloud them with a wink’. It is a superbappreciation <strong>of</strong> a reciprocated true love. But, Donne becomes doubtful in ‘Song: Go andCatch a Falling Star’ about finding a true woman. He says;If thou find’st one, let me know,Such a pilgrimage were sweet,Yet do not, I would not go,Though at next door we might meet,Though she were true, when you met her,And last, till you write your letter,Yet sheWill beFalse, ere I come, to two, or three.In spite <strong>of</strong> the doubt, shown in this poem, Donne is upset in ‘A Valediction: ForbiddenMourning’ as he has to get separated from his beloved for time being. Here, Donneadmits a new kind <strong>of</strong> love not a ‘Dull sublunary lovers’ love’ where the soul is the mainessence. He also says;But we by a love, so much refin’dThat ourselves know not what it is,Inter-assured <strong>of</strong> the mind,Careless, eyes, lips and hands to miss.Besides, the famous conceit <strong>of</strong> the Compass, used here by Donne, provides theassumption that both are true and the compasses will describe a circle, perfecting theirmovement in the symbol <strong>of</strong> infinity and eternity. Donne, thus, has proved that the perfectand complete love has no need <strong>of</strong> outward show. Even the absence <strong>of</strong> body is not agood reason to destroy a true love, as the main essence <strong>of</strong> a true love is soul. This view istaken forward in ‘The Extasie’ where Donne makes an addition to this view puttingemphasis on body too. Donne in ‘The Extasie’ says;But O alas, so long, so farOur bodies why do we forbear?They are ours , though they are not we, We areThe intelligences, they the sphere.Nevertheless, it is through a physical meeting that they know each other and for that theyshould be grateful. At this stage none can consider body worthless. So, Donne describes alove where there is a mixture <strong>of</strong> body and soul. The body, which is inferior, is madevaluable by the union with soul, which is the superior part <strong>of</strong> any being. About this Donnesays;As our blood labours to begetSpirits, as like souls as it can,Because such fingers need to knitThat subtle knot, which makes us man:This kind <strong>of</strong> love is worth to be called legend as they, both the lover and beloved, are‘mysterious by this love’ and can ‘die by it, if not live by love’. They and their love will be fitfor sonnets if not for chronicles. By these hymns all men will recognize that they have been‘canonized for love’. Future ages will ‘invoke’ them as lovers;Who did the whole worlds soule contract, and droveInto the glasses <strong>of</strong> your eyes(So made such mirrors, and such spies,That they did all to you epitomize,)Countries, Townes, Courts: Beg from aboveA patterne <strong>of</strong> your love!This notion <strong>of</strong> true love is upheld in ‘The Relique’ also where the lovers are capable <strong>of</strong>making miracle possible. Due to this, their grave is ‘The Relique’ to be worshipped by thehttp://www.bdresearchpublications.com/journal/


John Donne, a Poetpeople. Thus, Donne brings his philosophy <strong>of</strong> love before us where there is true love isconcocted from <strong>sensuality</strong> and <strong>spirituality</strong>. So, after this discussion, it is unjust to call Donnea worshipper <strong>of</strong> body as he puts an emphasis on both giving soul and <strong>spirituality</strong> thedistinction <strong>of</strong> being superior at the time <strong>of</strong> love.‘Divine Poems’ are not the poems celebrating the moment <strong>of</strong> vision <strong>of</strong> the Ultimate Oneor not about the union <strong>of</strong> Donne with the Ultimate One, God, but these are poems,marked by an effort <strong>of</strong> his will, which are produced to examine and discipline his mind.After the death <strong>of</strong> his wife, Anne Moore, Donne seeks in religion for the sense <strong>of</strong> securityand completeness that she has been for him. That is why Donne in ‘Holy Sonnet-I’ says;Thou hast made me, and shall thy work decay?Repair me now, for now mine end doth haste;The ‘old subtle fore’ tempts him butThy Grace may wing me to prevent his art,And thou like Adamant draw mine iron heart.Donne’s another divine poem, ‘Oh My Blacke Soule’, is also a prayer for grace withoutwhich the <strong>poet</strong> cannot be truly repentant <strong>of</strong> his sins. Donne, here, brings theologicalparadox to say that only through God’s loving care, if freely given, the sinful human likehim can recognize to seek God’s forgiveness. The poem is thus concerned with the largequestions <strong>of</strong> free will that have been the center <strong>of</strong> religious controversy in that period. Asthe free will is brought in focus here, the death is unveiled in the same manner in ‘HolySonnet-X: Death Be Not Proud’. Donne addresses death denying its power. He also makesa list <strong>of</strong> what comprises the enslavement <strong>of</strong> death and says;And poppy or charms can make us sleep as wellAnd better <strong>than</strong> thy stroke;In the same way by the holy sonnet, ‘A Hyme to God the Father’ Donne brings thepossible sins, committed by men like him, before all. In this poem Donne talks about fivekinds <strong>of</strong> sins. About the first sin, he says;…that sin where I begun,Which was my sin, though it were done before?His second sin is the sin that he commits everyday. Though he tries to resist that sin, hecannot do so. Donne’s contempt about the religion is found when he thinks that enticingpeople to the then religious view is a sin. His fourth sin is the sin;…which I did shunA year or two, but wallow’d in,…And, finally with the utterance <strong>of</strong> fifth sin Donne conforms the possibility <strong>of</strong> grace toeveryone, as he thinks the doubt in getting God’s grace and God is itself a sin. The fear <strong>of</strong>sin has turned into the sin <strong>of</strong> fear for Donne though the fear shows the possibility <strong>of</strong> free willand grace from God. These are not the only things that are matter <strong>of</strong> concern for Donne.But, Donne is concerned with Judgment Day also in the Holy Sonnets like, ‘This is My Play’sLast Scene’ and ‘At the Round Earth’s Imagin’d Corners’. Between these two poems, inthe first one Donne imagines himself in the deathbed preparing to meet the JudgmentDay but in the later one Donne imagines the Day <strong>of</strong> Judgment itself. All these arediscussed with a desire to get an intellectual rest woven with a need for the emotionalserenity. In ‘Holy Sonnet-XIV’ Donne cries out to God in the accents <strong>of</strong> love;Take me to you, imprison mee, for IExcept you’enthrall mee, never shall be free,Nor ever chast, except you ravish mee.This is the last wish <strong>of</strong> Donne where he seeks for God’s love and pity. Donne in ‘DivinePoems’ shows how one can prepare for the better after life with less sin, true relation,pleasant death and a reward after death. So it can be said that the Divine poems are not101http://www.bdresearchpublications.com/journal/


Dipak Kumar Sarkara good example to accuse Donne for <strong>sensuality</strong>, rather, these poems are his greatcreation for bringing discipline and sense <strong>of</strong> morality to all.John Donne in his <strong>poet</strong>ry sets before all an ideal to discuss or analyze which finally helps t<strong>of</strong>ind out what is the best for all though the spirit <strong>of</strong> the then writers has been a differentone. The first initiation comes from the scientists who try to establish that the earth and theother planets revolve in orbit around the sun. This has been an attempt to displace manfrom the center <strong>of</strong> creation both literary and metaphorically. As a result the new thoughtcomes in conflict with the traditional teaching <strong>of</strong> the church. Though the old theory seesthe sight <strong>of</strong> victory for a time being, it fails with the emergence <strong>of</strong> the great scientist,Galileo Galilei (1564-1642). Donne in this regard says that ‘new philosophy calls all indoubt’. The second step comes from the writings <strong>of</strong> Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527),which introduces science presently known as political science. Machiavelli simply ignoresthe fanciful topics, used by medieval theorists, as he tries to analyze the real nature <strong>of</strong>power in the states. As a step he produces ‘The Prince’ in 1513 which deals with the waysby which political power can be won and held without regard to the question <strong>of</strong> divinepurpose. In chapter-15 he explains clearly that his intension is to present things as theyreally are in fact. It is this scientific spirit that Francis Bacon applauds when he writes, in1623, that we all are indebted to Machiavelli and other writers <strong>of</strong> that class who openlyand unfeignedly describe what men do and not what men ought to do. Bacon arguesthat soundly based scientific knowledge will lead to technical mastery over the world <strong>of</strong>nature. Many <strong>of</strong> his contemporaries have been less optimistic about his new thought andhave been anxious about the change. The fullest expression <strong>of</strong> this can be found in manydramatists <strong>of</strong> that time. William Shakespeare, in particular, has been preoccupied with asense <strong>of</strong> discrepancy between what men do and what they ought to do’. In ‘Troilus andCressida’ Shakespeare provides a pr<strong>of</strong>ound illustration <strong>of</strong> this new skepticism. Donne doesnot <strong>of</strong>fer any new skepticism but he takes the reader to that situation with his brilliantpower <strong>of</strong> imagery to discover the truth and the right one with the taste <strong>of</strong> reality. In ‘TheApparition’ Donne creates a situation by means <strong>of</strong> imagery where a lover threatens tohave revenge as the beloved has rejected him. Here, Donne takes the readers to thebeloved’s room where he, in future though, is going to be present as a ghost. And, therethe beloved has been seen sleeping in the arms <strong>of</strong> another man. Donne says;Then shall my ghost come to your bed,And thee, feign’d vestal, in worse arms shall see;This lady who has rejected the lover on the issue <strong>of</strong> losing virginity, is found having pleasure<strong>of</strong> adultery. So, the stage is set, and the drama is played. Now it is the turn <strong>of</strong> the readersto decide which the right one is. But, at last Donne takes the lover back keeping theemotion and thought in readers’ mind saying;I had rather thou shouldst painfully repent,Than by my threatenings rest still innocent.It is the desire <strong>of</strong> Donne in ‘The Flea” too where he sets a dramatic situation <strong>of</strong> a saucylover appealing for sexual pleasure too his beloved who rejects him. In ‘ A Hymn to GodThe Father’ Donne by the discussion on sins shows the options, which are to follow, andwhich are to be avoided. Sincerity <strong>of</strong> <strong>poet</strong>’s feeling can be found in ‘Oh My Blacke Soule’which shows <strong>poet</strong>’s agony and sense <strong>of</strong> guilt with his willingness to pray for the debt <strong>of</strong> sinsthrough repentance and suffering. It is a struggle to make a truth appropriate, which doesnot defeat all <strong>poet</strong>ry but gives us a <strong>poet</strong>ry whose intensity is a moral one. Moreover inpoems like, ‘The Anniversary’, ‘A Valediction: Forbidden Mourning’, ‘The Extasie’ and soon the main character is Donne and thus he makes experiment on himself. Donne onlyshares the options or the outcomes that are to be or can be followed. Donne does notplay the role <strong>of</strong> a school teacher to lead the innocent school students to the right path byadvice or punishment, rather, he discusses all the sides <strong>of</strong> a coin and brings the real coinbefore the audience who themselves can choose the right one. In this way, Donne wishesthe active participation <strong>of</strong> the audience, as the audiences are to decide and take theright way to uphold the morality.It is not that the sexual or bodily apprehensions are totally absent in Donne but the desireto uphold the morality or <strong>spirituality</strong> dominates him <strong>more</strong>. The discovery <strong>of</strong> right andperfect relationship between men and women, soul and God are crucial steps in the102http://www.bdresearchpublications.com/journal/


John Donne, a Poetsearch <strong>of</strong> the truth. At first Donne seems to have responded to the excitements <strong>of</strong> the city,London in 1590’s, as he is found to be a great visitor <strong>of</strong> ladies, a great frequenter <strong>of</strong> plays,a great writer <strong>of</strong> conceited verses. This is the picture <strong>of</strong> Donne in his earlier life where herepresents a brilliant young man <strong>of</strong> town, as has been confirmed by Richard Baker, abiographer. But, in the latter part <strong>of</strong> his life, he has produced the most brilliant <strong>of</strong> his poemsthat becomes moral in theme. Donne’s marriage with Anne Moore brings him face t<strong>of</strong>ace with the problems and difficulties <strong>of</strong> real life. That situation is summed up in a punningepigram: John Donne, Anne Donne, undone. This marriage also helps Donne to find thereal meaning <strong>of</strong> love where he finds both body and soul important. This helps to definethe relation between men and women. After the death <strong>of</strong> his wife, Anne Donne, Donne isseen to be engrossed with his unresolved religious position and the death, itself. He findsthe peace in the discussion <strong>of</strong> death, soul, God and ultimately wishes to seek true religion.In this way Donne’s <strong>poet</strong>ry is a journey from the excitements <strong>of</strong> earthly life to theenlightenment <strong>of</strong> the soul. That is why Donne is a <strong>poet</strong> <strong>more</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>spirituality</strong> <strong>than</strong> <strong>sensuality</strong>.ReferencesAbrams, M.H. (1998). A Glossary <strong>of</strong> Literary Terms. Wordsworth PublishingBennett, J. (1984). Five Metaphysical Poets. Great Britain: CambridgeBush, D. (1963) English Literature in the Earlier Seventeenth Century. N. York: OxfordCookson, L and Loughrey, B. (1990). The Metaphysical Poets. Great Britain: LongmanEmden, J.V. (2005). The Metaphysical Poets. India: Replica Press Pvt. Ltd., KundliEliot, T. S. (1953). Selected Prose. U.K: Harmonds worthFerguson, Salter, and Stallworthy. (1996). The Norton Anthology <strong>of</strong> Poetry. United States <strong>of</strong>America: W.W. Norton & CompanyGardner, H. (1965). John Donne: The Elegies and the Songs and Sonnets. United States <strong>of</strong>America: OxfordGardner, H. (1962). John Donne, A Collection <strong>of</strong> Critical Essays. United States <strong>of</strong> America:Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J.Handley, G. (1991). The Metaphysical Poets. Great Britain: Macmillan PressLovelock, J. (1973).Donne: Songs and Sonets. Great Britain: Macmillan Press.Lewis, C. S. (1964). The Discarded Image. New York: CambridgeMallett, P. (2001). John Donne, Selected Poems. India: Pearson Education (Singapore) Pte.Ltd, India Branch, 482 F.I.E. Patparganj, Delhi-110092, IndiaStephen, M . (2000). English Literature, a student guide. England: Pearson EducationLimitedRedpath, T. (1956). The Songs and Sonets <strong>of</strong> John Donne. Great Britain: Cambridge103http://www.bdresearchpublications.com/journal/

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!