HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor

HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor

juliano.multiculturas.com
from juliano.multiculturas.com More from this publisher
21.07.2015 Views

HIGH AND LATE MEDIEVAL NATIONAL HISTORIOGRAPHY 197in 1177, 61 one should mention above all the major historiographicwork of the politically and literarily most significant personality ofmedieval Iceland, Snorri Sturluson (1178/79–1241), 62 who stood inclose relation to King Hakon IV of Norway and his jarl Skúli. Inthe 1220s, he wrote a Norwegian history, which is known asHeimskringla, 63 after the introductory words of the text Kringla heimsis(“the circle of the world”). The depiction, which is exemplary for itsobvious concern for objectivity and withholding judgment, consistsof sixteen individual sagas, with the focal point being the depictionof the life of Olaf the Holy (Óláfs saga Helga). In contrast to the otherkings’ sagas, this one depicts—in the Ynglinga saga—the legendaryearly history of the Norwegian kings as well and ends accordinglyat 1177.The heyday of the Danish empire in the so-called Valdemar periodunder Knut VI (1182–1202) and Waldemar II (1202–41) was theperiod in which the blueprints of Danish national historical thoughtwere formulated. 64 The first sketch, written around 1185, stems froman author hardly identifiable as an individual, Sven Aggesen, nephewof the former archbishop Eskil of Lund (1137–77, †1181/82). HisBrevis Historia regum Dacie 65 depicts the history of legendary ancestorsof the Danish kings Skjold (sic) to the year 1185. The circumstancesof the writing are not completely clear; he himself complains in theforeword that he has not yet found any compilations of the individualkings.Equally unclear is the identity of the most significant medievalDanish historian. Saxo (†after 1202/08), who later received the epithetGrammaticus, was a cleric at the court of Archbishop Absalonof Lund (1178–1201) and his successor Andrew Suneson (1202–28)61Ágrip af Nóregskonunga sogum, in Ágrip af Nóregskonunga sogum. Fagrskinn—Nóregskonunga tal, ed. B. Einarsson, Íslenzk fornrit 29 (Reykjavík, 1985), 1–54; andFagrskinna–Nóregs konunga tal, ibid., 55–373.62See Ciklamini (1978); Fix, ed. (1998).63Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla, 3 vols., ed. B. Adalbjarnarson, Íslenzk fornrit 26(Reykjavík, 1941–51); Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla. History of the Kings of Norway,trans. L. M. Hollander (Austin, Texas, 1995). See also Bagge (1990) and (1991).64For an overview of medieval Danish historiography, see Jørgensen (1931);Damshold (1992).65Svenonis Aggonis filii Brevis Historia regum Dacie, in SS hist. Dan. 1 (1917/18),94–141. In Danish: Sven Aggesøns historiske skrifter. Oversatte efter den paa grundlag af CodexArnæmagnæanus 33, 4 to restituerede text by M. Cl. Gertz (Copenhagen, 1916/17; repr.1967). See also Sawyer (1985).

198 NORBERT KERSKENand worked, during a long period beginning in the 1180s, on a monumentalhistorical work known today as Gesta Danorum, 66 dedicatedto King Waldemar and Archbishop Andrew Suneson. The GestaDanorum may be regarded, in a historiographic as well as literarysense, as the most sophisticated text of the Scandinavian MiddleAges. The work is divided into sixteen books, of which the first eightdeal with the earliest period, and Books IX–XVI consider the periodof Christianization. In addition, four books form a representativeblock: Books I–IV deal with the pre-Christian period and offer aunique insight into the oldest saga and cultural history of Scandinavia.Books V–VIII consider the period up to the extension of the Christianmission to Denmark; Books IX–XII deal with the period from theintroduction of Christianity to Denmark up through the conclusionof the Danish church organization; and, finally, Books XIII–XVItreat Danish history since the establishment of the archbishopric ofLund. 67 This conception of the internal structure of the work beliesSaxo’s view of the coherence of Danish history. His periodization ofDanish history, determined to some extent by church history, managesto integrate Danish history into the universal Christian worldviewwhile not negating the cultural historical inheritance present fromthe pre-Christian North. Finally, this approach offers the possibilityof constructing a coherent Danish folk, regional, and imperial historywithout writing an affirmative history of rulers.Approximately one generation after Saxo, in the middle of thethirteenth century, two anonymously delivered texts on the subjectof Danish history also arose in the circle of the Icelandic kings’ sagas.The Knÿtlingasaga, the history of the descendants of Knut the Great,is a history of the Danish kings from Harald Bluetooth to the ruleof Knut VI. 68 Óláfr Thórdarson Hvitaskáld (ca. 1210–59), a nephew66Saxonis Gesta Danorum, ed. J. Olrik and H. Ræde, 2 vols. (Copenhagen, 1931,1957); English trans. by Hilda Ellis Davidson/Peter Fisher: Saxo Grammaticus, TheHistory of the Danes. Books I–IX, 2 vols. (Cambridge, Mass., 1979/80); also SaxoGrammaticus, Danorum regum heroumque historia, Books X–XVI, ed. and trans. EricChristiansen, 3 vols. (Oxford, 1980/81). Since no medieval manuscripts have survived,the original title of the work is unknown. Important new studies includeSkovgaard-Petersen (1969), (1987), and (1988); Johannesson (1978); as well as threecollections of studies of Saxo: Boserup (1975), Friis-Jensen (1981), and Santini (1992).67Inge Skovgaard-Petersen has called attention to this.68Skjöldunga saga, Knÿtlinga saga, Ágrip af sögu Danakonunga, ed. B. Gud¯nason, Íslenzkfornrit 35 (Reykjavík, 1982).

HIGH AND LATE MEDIEVAL NATIONAL <strong>HISTORIOGRAPHY</strong> 197in 1177, 61 one should mention above all the major historiographicwork of the politically and literarily most significant personality ofmedieval Iceland, Snorri Sturluson (1178/79–1241), 62 who stood inclose relation to King Hakon IV of Norway and his jarl Skúli. Inthe 1220s, he wrote a Norwegian history, which is known asHeimskringla, 63 after the introductory words of the text Kringla heimsis(“the circle of the world”). The depiction, which is exemplary for itsobvious concern for objectivity and withholding judgment, consistsof sixteen individual sagas, with the focal point being the depictionof the life of Olaf the Holy (Óláfs saga Helga). In contrast to the otherkings’ sagas, this one depicts—in the Ynglinga saga—the legendaryearly history of the Norwegian kings as well and ends accordinglyat 1177.The heyday of the Danish empire in the so-called Valdemar periodunder Knut VI (1182–1202) and Waldemar II (1202–41) was theperiod in which the blueprints of Danish national historical thoughtwere formulated. 64 The first sketch, written around 1185, stems froman author hardly identifiable as an individual, Sven Aggesen, nephewof the former archbishop Eskil of Lund (1137–77, †1181/82). HisBrevis Historia regum Dacie 65 depicts the history of legendary ancestorsof the Danish kings Skjold (sic) to the year 1185. The circumstancesof the writing are not completely clear; he himself complains in theforeword that he has not yet found any compilations of the individualkings.Equally unclear is the identity of the most significant medievalDanish historian. Saxo (†after 1202/08), who later received the epithetGrammaticus, was a cleric at the court of Archbishop Absalonof Lund (1178–1201) and his successor Andrew Suneson (1202–28)61Ágrip af Nóregskonunga sogum, in Ágrip af Nóregskonunga sogum. Fagrskinn—Nóregskonunga tal, ed. B. Einarsson, Íslenzk fornrit 29 (Reykjavík, 1985), 1–54; andFagrskinna–Nóregs konunga tal, ibid., 55–373.62See Ciklamini (1978); Fix, ed. (1998).63Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla, 3 vols., ed. B. Adalbjarnarson, Íslenzk fornrit 26(Reykjavík, 1941–51); Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla. History of the Kings of Norway,trans. L. M. Hollander (Austin, Texas, 1995). See also Bagge (1990) and (1991).64For an overview of medieval Danish historiography, see Jørgensen (1931);Damshold (1992).65Svenonis Aggonis filii Brevis Historia regum Dacie, in SS hist. Dan. 1 (1917/18),94–141. In Danish: Sven Aggesøns historiske skrifter. Oversatte efter den paa grundlag af CodexArnæmagnæanus 33, 4 to restituerede text by M. Cl. Gertz (Copenhagen, 1916/17; repr.1967). See also Sawyer (1985).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!