HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor

HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE MIDDLE AGES - Julian Emperor

juliano.multiculturas.com
from juliano.multiculturas.com More from this publisher
21.07.2015 Views

WORLD HISTORIOGRAPHY IN THE LATE MIDDLE AGES 167his rule in 1363. A certain Bavarian emphasis in the material isthereby established, which is also conditioned by the fact that thechronicler is located in Eichstätt. With this emphasis, Heinrich Taube’schronicle is very similar to the Munich world chronicle. Nonetheless,the emphasis already is weakened by virtue of the fact that HeinrichTaube is writing simultaneously a history of the bishops in Eichstätt,which can take up regional aspects. With the trinity of pope, emperor,and bishop history, he creates a new sequencing model that will berealized elsewhere somewhat later and independently of him. HeinrichTaube occupies a special position among the writers of Flores Temporumcontinuations also by virtue of his position toward the emperorsLudwig of Bavaria and Charles IV, as well as toward the popes ofAvignon. Heinrich Taube stood in circumstances in Eichstätt thatforced him to judge Ludwig negatively in the conflict with the curiaand to represent Charles IV correspondingly positive. Thus, bothHeinrich Taube and the Munich world chronicle demonstrate howlocally conditioned ressentiments among authors of the same work canlead to opposingly structured texts.To the second category belong those chroniclers who stand in thetradition of Martin of Troppau but do not link up with him directly.Rather, these chroniclers require intermediary links to his chronicleand period. First we should mention Closener and Twinger ofKönigshofen. 34 As Klaus Kirchert shows, Closener and Twinger connectworld history and city history with each other in many respects. 35Their works differ insofar as one can regard Closener as a preparatorywork for Twinger. Closener begins with a rudimentary popecatalogue, most likely derived from Martin of Troppau. He thencontinues with a detailed imperial history, which he creates first outof material from Martin of Troppau, then from Ellenhard’s chronicle[Chronicon Ellenhardi] 36 and the First Bavarian Supplement of theSaxon world chronicle. The Strasbourg section that is added has adouble theme: the bishop history and the civil city history. In theformer, the Bellum Waltherianum, the author inserts the battle between34Fritsche Closener, Chronik, bis 1392, ed. K. Hegel, Die Chroniken der Städte oberrheinischenStädte, Straßburg 1, Die Chroniken der deutschen Städte 8 (Leipzig, 1870), 1–151;Twinger of Königshofen, Chronik, ed. Hegel.35Hofinger (1974); Kirchert (1993).36Chronicon Ellenhardi, ed. P. Jaffé, MGH SS 17 (1861), 122–44.

168 ROLF SPRANDELbishop and city in the thirteenth century and a kind of early warmonograph. The civil city history is arranged according to overarchingthemes such as fires, war marches, persecutions of Jews,et al., which in turn are ordered chronologically and contain regionalsources, including again the Chronicon Ellenhardi among others.Twinger, in contrast, reinforced the embeddedness in world historyby preparing a book about the first five [world] epochs. Herelies there mainly on the Latin world historiography of the GermanHigh Middle Ages. The books about emperors and popes follow thisone. Already the order of both is reversed, in comparison withClosener, which also certainly is meaningful. For the younger emperors,Twinger relies additionally on Mathias of Neuenburg. Both parts,but in particular the pope section, are considerably amended, usingalso excerpts from Martin of Troppau. A history of the bishops ofStrasbourg follows, as with Closener (there the third part, in Twingerthe fourth part). For each, twenty-five pages became seventy-fivepages in the editing. At the beginning of this bishop-history, Twingerlets it be known once more how important it is for him that theLandesgeschichte be anchored in world history. He reports the supposedfirst episcopal appointment in Strasbourg by King Dagobert andembeds this in the chain of imperial history beginning with theRomans by considering the relationship of Romans, Franks, French,and Germans.The civil urban history of Strasbourg that follows begins againwith a history of origin. Then comes the history of Christianizationand the city’s expansion. Increasingly, Twinger comes closer toClosener’s scheme and orders the materials according to subject. Thesixth part comprises a register of key words arranged in alphabeticalorder. This register can be classified as belonging with the remaininglexicographical works of Closener and Twinger. Kirchert is,unfortunately, too brief with respect to the chronicles. However, heplaces the lexicographical works beyond the framework of merescholastic purposes and—probably correctly—understands them asspecific, tradition-rooted “organizational structures, which the mindplaces upon the world being depicted”. 37 By virtue of their arrangementand classification, along with the combination of Landesgeschichte37Kirchert (1993), 136.

168 ROLF SPRANDELbishop and city in the thirteenth century and a kind of early warmonograph. The civil city history is arranged according to overarchingthemes such as fires, war marches, persecutions of Jews,et al., which in turn are ordered chronologically and contain regionalsources, including again the Chronicon Ellenhardi among others.Twinger, in contrast, reinforced the embeddedness in world historyby preparing a book about the first five [world] epochs. Herelies there mainly on the Latin world historiography of the GermanHigh Middle Ages. The books about emperors and popes follow thisone. Already the order of both is reversed, in comparison withClosener, which also certainly is meaningful. For the younger emperors,Twinger relies additionally on Mathias of Neuenburg. Both parts,but in particular the pope section, are considerably amended, usingalso excerpts from Martin of Troppau. A history of the bishops ofStrasbourg follows, as with Closener (there the third part, in Twingerthe fourth part). For each, twenty-five pages became seventy-fivepages in the editing. At the beginning of this bishop-history, Twingerlets it be known once more how important it is for him that theLandesgeschichte be anchored in world history. He reports the supposedfirst episcopal appointment in Strasbourg by King Dagobert andembeds this in the chain of imperial history beginning with theRomans by considering the relationship of Romans, Franks, French,and Germans.The civil urban history of Strasbourg that follows begins againwith a history of origin. Then comes the history of Christianizationand the city’s expansion. Increasingly, Twinger comes closer toClosener’s scheme and orders the materials according to subject. Thesixth part comprises a register of key words arranged in alphabeticalorder. This register can be classified as belonging with the remaininglexicographical works of Closener and Twinger. Kirchert is,unfortunately, too brief with respect to the chronicles. However, heplaces the lexicographical works beyond the framework of merescholastic purposes and—probably correctly—understands them asspecific, tradition-rooted “organizational structures, which the mindplaces upon the world being depicted”. 37 By virtue of their arrangementand classification, along with the combination of Landesgeschichte37Kirchert (1993), 136.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!