13.07.2015 Views

Nos. 7 to 12 KARL FREDRIK WINCRANTZ. Managing Director of ...

Nos. 7 to 12 KARL FREDRIK WINCRANTZ. Managing Director of ...

Nos. 7 to 12 KARL FREDRIK WINCRANTZ. Managing Director of ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

VOL. 7 1930<strong>Nos</strong>. 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong><strong>KARL</strong> <strong>FREDRIK</strong> <strong>WINCRANTZ</strong>.<strong>Managing</strong> Direc<strong>to</strong>r<strong>of</strong> Telefonaktiebolaget L. M. Ericsson1922—1930.ENGLISHEDITION


THE L. M. ERICSSON REVIEWENGLISH EDITION.JOURNAL OFTELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET L. M. ERICSSON, STOCKHOLM.Responsible publisher: HEMMING JOHANSSONEdi<strong>to</strong>r: WOLDEMAR BRUMMER.Issued quarterly. / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / Yearly subscription rate: 7/ -All communications and subscriptions <strong>to</strong> be forwarded <strong>to</strong> the Edi<strong>to</strong>r.Karl FredrikWincrantz.Karl Fredrik Wincrantz, born in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm in1874, graduated from the University <strong>of</strong> Technologyin 1897, but already in 1893, while still a youngundergraduate, he was engaged as an assistant inthe Royal Board <strong>of</strong> Telegraphs, where he remaineduntil 1900, when he entered the service <strong>of</strong> theS<strong>to</strong>ckholms Allmanna Telefonaktiebolag as its AssistantManager under Mr. H. T. Cedergren. During1898—1906 he also served in the Royal PatentOffice, where he was some time Secretary, sometime Chief Engineer.On the death <strong>of</strong> Mr. Cedergren in 1909, Wincrantzwas appointed his successor as <strong>Managing</strong>Direc<strong>to</strong>r <strong>of</strong> the A.-B. S<strong>to</strong>ckholms Telefon, formedthe year before, which owned and ran the largeprivate telephone net <strong>of</strong> S<strong>to</strong>ckholm and neighbourhood.He led this firm until 1918, when itwas taken over by the Swedish Government.The Aktiebolaget S<strong>to</strong>ckholms Telefon was thenre-organized as the Allmanna IndustriaktiebolagetH. T. Cedergren, which firm <strong>to</strong>ok over the S<strong>to</strong>ckholmTelephon Cable Works at Alvsjo and workshopsin S<strong>to</strong>ckholm. Wincrantz was at the sametime appointed Manager <strong>of</strong> the new firm.In 1922, the Industri A.-B. Cedergren was amalgamatedwith Telefonaktiebolaget L. M. Ericsson,and with Mr. H. Johansson Wincrantz became aco-Manager <strong>of</strong> the enlarged company. In 1925, thecompany general meeting having resolved thatthere would be only one managing direc<strong>to</strong>r, Wincrantzwas appointed sole <strong>Managing</strong> Direc<strong>to</strong>r, andretired from that position on September 3rd <strong>of</strong>this year.- 98 -


The Svenska Radioaktiebolaget Audio-frequency Genera<strong>to</strong>r, withcontinuously variable frequency Adjustment.By TorbernLaurent.I. Introduction.The present paper is a description <strong>of</strong> theSvenska Radioaktiebolaget Audio-FrequencyGenera<strong>to</strong>r, Model TFG 529, intended for audi<strong>of</strong>requencymeasurements. The following pointsare satisfied by this genera<strong>to</strong>r:1) The frequency must be continuously variablefrom 200 <strong>to</strong> 10,000 cycles, with possibility<strong>to</strong> increase the range by a variable auxiliarycondenser for the 50—200 cycles range.2) The audio-frequency current must be practicallysinusoidal.3) The frequency adjustment dials must allowa sufficiently accurate setting <strong>of</strong> the frequencyfor any and every occurring measurement.4) The frequency must be practically unaffectedby the properties <strong>of</strong> the valves, and <strong>of</strong> voltagevariations in the D. C. supply <strong>of</strong> the audi<strong>of</strong>requencygenera<strong>to</strong>r.5) The frequency must be practically unaffectedby the output utilized.6) Utilized output must be practically thesame, whatever frequency the apparatus is setfor.7) The audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r must becapable <strong>of</strong> a minimum effect <strong>of</strong> 200 m\V.8) The audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r must notgive rise <strong>to</strong> static or magnetic fields which mayhave a disturbing effect in the neighbourhood.0) The audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r must notcause disturbing currents in the D. C. batterysupply leads connected <strong>to</strong> the genera<strong>to</strong>r.Points 1, 2, and 7 are intended <strong>to</strong> make anyusual audio-frequency measurements possible. Ifpoints 3, 4, and 5 are complied with, frequencymeasurements will be superfluous. A calibratingtable for the frequency adjustment dials<strong>of</strong> the audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r, made up onceand for all, will enable the genera<strong>to</strong>r <strong>to</strong> be setfor any frequency desired. Compliance withpoint 6 facilitates measurements with constanteffect at different frequencies, and provides acertain protection for thermo-couples possiblyused in the measuring devices.Points 8 and 9 are introduced <strong>to</strong> allow themeasuring devices <strong>to</strong> be placed in the immediatevicinity <strong>of</strong> the audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r,as is usually done when a test board is used, andalso <strong>to</strong> allow the genera<strong>to</strong>r <strong>to</strong> be run by directcurrent from the same batteries as other appliances,e. g. telephone repeaters.In order <strong>to</strong> satisfy all these demands by comparativelysimple means, the design <strong>of</strong> the audi<strong>of</strong>requencygenera<strong>to</strong>r has been based on an entirelynew principle, whereby many important simplificationsand improvements have beenachieved.To obtain a suitable design, it has been foundexpedient <strong>to</strong> introduce a few extra valves. Butas measuring devices are not used in large numbers,nor continuously, the increase in the number<strong>of</strong> valves cannot be considered an economicdrawback.2. The principle <strong>of</strong> the Audio-FrequencyGenera<strong>to</strong>r.The new fundamental principle applied in theSvenska Radioaktiebolaget Audio-FrequencyGenera<strong>to</strong>r is the use <strong>of</strong> a serial resonance circuitas a tuning circuit, instead <strong>of</strong> the parallel resonancecircuit previously exclusively employed,which endows the audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>rwith particularly valuable properties as regardspoints 1, 2, and 6, while at the same timeseveral important advantages are gained fromthe point <strong>of</strong> view <strong>of</strong> manufacturing.Fig. 1 is a diagram <strong>of</strong> the principle <strong>of</strong> theaudio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r. The tuning circuitconsists <strong>of</strong> a variable condenser C. in series withan inductance coil L, which by means <strong>of</strong> a switch99


Fig. 1.may be taken in<strong>to</strong> use wholly or partly. Whenonly a portion <strong>of</strong> the induction coil L is used,a resistance r„ r v or r, is also introduced in<strong>to</strong>the tuning circuit.The potentiometers P x and P., are in serieswith the tuning circuit. From the former thereaction voltage is taken, and from the latterthe grid voltage for an amplifier (4.,, T u A vA„ T 2 ), from the output transformer <strong>of</strong> whichthe audio-frequency current is supplied. In thisgenera<strong>to</strong>r two oscillating valves are used, 4, andA t , which are connected in cascade by means<strong>of</strong> the resistance coupling M.A special problem has been the arrangemen<strong>to</strong>f the D. C. feed <strong>to</strong> the valve 4,, which on accoun<strong>to</strong>f point 9 must prevent access <strong>of</strong> theaudio-frequencies <strong>to</strong> the anode battery, while atthe same time the arrangement must not act asa load on the valve A 2 , either as regards capacitycr inductivity. Experience had proved thatwhile a D. C. feed through a resistance, with thecondenser connexion <strong>to</strong> the cathode necessitatedfor passing the alternating currents, requires anexcessively large condenser, a D. C. feed by chokecoil requires this coil <strong>to</strong> possess excessively highself-induction.By the device shown in fig. 1, however, theproblem is solved in a satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry manner. Thisdevice consists <strong>of</strong> two resistances R1, and R2.,two large condensers K l and K 2 . and two largechoke coils D 1 and D 2 . The impedance formed bythe coil D.,, connected in parallel <strong>to</strong> the condenserA',, is negligible in comparison <strong>to</strong> the impedance<strong>of</strong> the coil D,. The condenser A'„ with acapacity K v and the coil D,, with a self-inductionD, and a loss resistance R D as well as the resistancesR, and R.,, with the resistance valuesR l and R., respectively, are so dimensioned thatFor all frequencies within the normal workingrange <strong>of</strong> the genera<strong>to</strong>r, the impedance betweenanode and cathode <strong>of</strong> this device will be equal <strong>to</strong>an ohmic resistance Jt x .The resistance coupling M with its choke coils(not shown in the figure) is also dimensioned sothat the phase angle between the EMF in theanode circuit <strong>of</strong> the valve A x and the grid voltage<strong>of</strong> valve A 2 for practical purposes may be disregardedfor the genera<strong>to</strong>r's frequency range.According <strong>to</strong> the above, the reaction voltagewill thus be in phase with the original oscillations,which is an essential condition for ensuringfrequency stability as desired by point 4.By using two oscillating valves, the phase <strong>of</strong>the reaction voltage is changed 180° so that theconditions necessary for oscillation are obtained.The natural frequency <strong>of</strong> the genera<strong>to</strong>r is thusdetermined solelv bv the current-resonance <strong>of</strong>100


the condenser C and the coil L. The condenserC, made up <strong>of</strong> mica condensers and one air condenser,has a loss resistance <strong>of</strong> negligible magnitude,and the coil L, which has no iron core,has a loss resistance practically independent <strong>of</strong>the frequency, and equal <strong>to</strong> its D. C. resistance.By current-resonance, the impedance <strong>of</strong> the tuningcircuit will therefore be practically equal <strong>to</strong>the D. C. resistance <strong>of</strong> the utilized part <strong>of</strong> thecoil with a resistance r v r„, or r 3 added, sufficient<strong>to</strong> make it equal the resistance <strong>of</strong> thewhole coil. This impedance is therefore a pureresistance, the size <strong>of</strong> which is independent <strong>of</strong>the size <strong>of</strong> the condenser C and <strong>of</strong> the portion<strong>of</strong> the coil L utilized. Any voltage and currentin the oscillating system will thus be independen<strong>to</strong>f the frequency setting, that is <strong>to</strong> say, theamount <strong>of</strong> reaction and, apart from a small dis<strong>to</strong>rtionin the amplifier, the amount <strong>of</strong> outputwill be independent <strong>of</strong> the frequency setting. Bypoint 5, the output should be independent <strong>of</strong> thefrequency setting, but the fact that the amoun<strong>to</strong>f reaction is also independent <strong>of</strong> this settingis <strong>of</strong> great value, particularly for obtaining ahigh frequency stability and satisfying the demands<strong>of</strong> point 2.The design <strong>of</strong> the tuning circuit is interesting.The loss resistance <strong>of</strong> the induction coil L should,on account <strong>of</strong> points 2 and 4, be <strong>of</strong> approximatelythe same magnitude as the resistance P, andthe potentiometer resistances P, and P 2 . Thereason for this is that the frequency stabilityand the ability <strong>of</strong> the oscillating circuit <strong>to</strong> filterharmonics increase with the reactance <strong>of</strong> thecoil compared <strong>to</strong> the ohmic resistance in the circuitpassed by the oscillating currents. As theloss resistance <strong>of</strong> the coil must be comparativelysmall <strong>to</strong> prevent the self-induction from beingexcessively large, the resistance R i must besmall, which is feasible by using two oscillatingvalves, with consequent powerful excess <strong>of</strong> amplification,which may be suitably consumed bythis resistance. For the same reason, the potentiometerresistances P, and P., should besmall, which is all <strong>to</strong> the good, as the potentiometersare designed as rheostats. However, thedesign requires the induction coil L <strong>to</strong> be madecomparatively large, whereby the condenser Cbecomes comparatively small. This also is entirelybeneficial, as the impedance <strong>of</strong> the inductioncoil is purely a matter <strong>of</strong> winding, whichhardly affects the cost <strong>of</strong> the coil, while the cos<strong>to</strong>f a condenser is practically proportional <strong>to</strong> itscapacity.3. Apparatus design.Fig. 2 shows a front view <strong>of</strong> the Audio-FrequencyGenera<strong>to</strong>r, and fig. 3 shows the arrangementsat the back <strong>of</strong> the panel.I 1851 Fig. 2.The manufacture <strong>of</strong> the induction coil is rathera troublesome problem. Iron must beavoided in the coil for the sake <strong>of</strong> the frequencystability; <strong>to</strong> secure frequency stability, and withdue regard <strong>to</strong> the task <strong>of</strong> the oscillating circuit<strong>to</strong> filter away harmonics, the loss resistance <strong>of</strong>the coil must be comparatively small in proportion<strong>to</strong> its self-induction; <strong>to</strong> avoid any possibledisturbance <strong>of</strong> the neighbourhood (point 8), thecoil must not give rise <strong>to</strong> any external magneticfield. The problem is solved by using an aircoilenclosed in a 3 mm thick copper casing,visible in fig. 3 as a cylindrical box marked"CUB 240". For the highest frequencies anothersmall coil, marked "CUB 1 a" is used. Fig. 3also indicates how the other component parts<strong>of</strong> the Audio-Frequency Genera<strong>to</strong>r are arranged.On the front <strong>of</strong> the Audio-Frequency Genera<strong>to</strong>rpanel (fig. 2) the terminal connexions <strong>of</strong> theD. C. voltages are shown on the left, and on theright the terminals for the audio-frequency current.At the bot<strong>to</strong>m a jack-strip is seen, <strong>to</strong> whicha I). C. instrument may be plugged for checkingthe anode- and grid currents. The four lowerdials belong <strong>to</strong> a decade condenser with a variableair-condenser for fine adjustments, and- 101 -


the induction coils are connected as desired bythe two keys located above. As will be readilyunders<strong>to</strong>od from the above, these dials and keysare used for setting the frequency. The filamentvoltage, indicated by the voltmeter locatedbelow the valves, is adjusted by the dial <strong>to</strong> theleft <strong>of</strong> the keys; the dial on the right controlsthe audio-frequency power output, and the reactionis adjusted by the dial above the keys.A 6-volt filament battery, a <strong>12</strong>0-voIt anodebattery, and a 24-volt grid battery are requiredfor running the audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r.The audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r works the bestwhen the I). C. voltages are correctly adjustedand the reaction is kept near the singing point.The audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r shown in figs.2 and 3 can be provided with a can cover andfitted on a test rack instead <strong>of</strong> in a box.Fig. 3.The Use <strong>of</strong> Personal Telephone calls in Sweden, and in TrafficBetween Sweden and other Countries.The long distance telephone traffic <strong>of</strong> S<strong>to</strong>ckholmhas increased considerably during 1929.In 1928 the number <strong>of</strong> trunk calls emanating fromS<strong>to</strong>ckholm was 4.663.033. The correspondingnumber <strong>of</strong> calls in 1929 was 4.889.418, showingan increase in the number <strong>of</strong> outgoing calls by4.9 per cent.The number <strong>of</strong> incoming trunk calls in S<strong>to</strong>ckholmis about 10 per cent, larger than that <strong>of</strong>outgoing calls, and the incoming traffic during1929 may therefore be estimated at 5.380.000calls. In considering these figures from the pointcf view <strong>of</strong> comparative frequency, however, itshould be remembered that the S<strong>to</strong>ckholm freedistrict includes 180 Local Exchanges outside the<strong>to</strong>wn proper, involving about 32.000 subscribers'stations within a radius <strong>of</strong> 40 kilometres (24miles), and that up <strong>to</strong> 200.000 free calls — shortdistance or district calls — are put through oncertain week-days, or about 52.000.000 annually.Similar calls abroad are almost invariably chargedfor and included in the number <strong>of</strong> trunk calls recorded.Personal calls continue <strong>to</strong> increase in number,and at a more rapid rate than the <strong>to</strong>tal traffic.Personal calls originated in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm thus increasedfrom 1927 <strong>to</strong> 1928 by 7 per cent., andfrom 1928 <strong>to</strong> 1929 by 9.4 per cent.In 1924, 29 per cent, <strong>of</strong> all calls originating inS<strong>to</strong>ckholm were pre-advised.In 1927 the proportion had increased <strong>to</strong> 39 per cent.» 1928 • » » » , 41 »> 1929 » > > > > 43 > >102


showing a continuous large increase in personalcalls. This indicates that the Swedish public fullyappreciates the advantages <strong>of</strong> the personal call.To the administration, these personal calls — inspite <strong>of</strong> the low pre-advice fee — mean an increase<strong>of</strong> income which, as far as S<strong>to</strong>ckholm isconcerned, covers 50 per cent, <strong>of</strong> the <strong>to</strong>tal cos<strong>to</strong>f the supervision and service staff at the TrunkExchange.The transmission <strong>of</strong> pre-advices on the trunklines naturally takes up some time, but this isvery short, amounting <strong>to</strong> an average <strong>of</strong> at theoutside 15 seconds each time. Out <strong>of</strong> the 477trunk lines serving S<strong>to</strong>ckholm, 228 <strong>of</strong> which areexclusively employed for outgoing calls, only about3 lines would therefore be occupied for this purposeif all the advices from S<strong>to</strong>ckholm could beassumed <strong>to</strong> be transmitted one after another onthese lines, irrespective <strong>of</strong> the destination <strong>of</strong> thecall.The following table indicates how the personalcalls emanating from S<strong>to</strong>ckholm are distributedamong the several Rate Districts:In comparison <strong>to</strong> the foreign traffic <strong>of</strong> 1928,this is an increase <strong>of</strong> 54 per cent, in the number<strong>of</strong> calls, and <strong>of</strong> 46 per cent, in the number <strong>of</strong>pre-advised calls. Personal calls from S<strong>to</strong>ckholmhave increased by 53 per cent., while the increasein personal calls <strong>to</strong> S<strong>to</strong>ckholm is 36 per cent.As it may be <strong>of</strong> interest <strong>to</strong> compare the use <strong>of</strong>personal calls in the traffic with the differentcountries, a table is given below showing theS<strong>to</strong>ckholm traffic during 1929 on some <strong>of</strong> theprincipal international trunk lines.The traffic <strong>to</strong> the neighbouring countries <strong>of</strong>Norway and Denmark shows the highest percentage<strong>of</strong> personal calls, and their incidence isabout the same in both directions.74 per cent, <strong>of</strong> the calls <strong>to</strong>, and 70 per cent,from, Norway, were pre-advised.The corresponding figures for the Danish trafficare 65 and 61 respectively. The high percentage<strong>of</strong> personal calls is accounted for by thefact that this form <strong>of</strong> call is quite familiar <strong>to</strong>the traffic with these countries since many years,and the percentage is approximately the same asfor the longer trunk lines <strong>of</strong> Sweden.But for other countries the differences arelarger:As already stated, the personal calls emanatingfrom S<strong>to</strong>ckholm during 1929 amounted <strong>to</strong> 43 percent, <strong>of</strong> the <strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> calls.The increasing use <strong>of</strong> personal calls with increasingdistance is very apparent in this table.If we now pass on <strong>to</strong> the telephone trafficbetween S<strong>to</strong>ckholm and abroad, we find a considerabledevelopment during 1929. 317.766 internationalcalls were put through, 153.344 <strong>of</strong>which were pre-advised as personal calls or ascalls <strong>to</strong> a specified extension line.This shows the percentage <strong>of</strong> personal callsfrom S<strong>to</strong>ckholm <strong>to</strong> these countries <strong>to</strong> be considerablyhigher than in the opposite direction.As the fees in international traffic are manytimes larger than in inland traffic, one would expectthe percentage <strong>of</strong> personal calls from abroad<strong>to</strong> be larger than has actually been the case.When the fee is high, it is <strong>of</strong> course more important<strong>to</strong> find the person <strong>to</strong> whom one wishes<strong>to</strong> speak, or <strong>to</strong> obtain the information desired,than when the fee is lower, so that the heavyexpense <strong>of</strong> the call may not be wasted. Consideringalso how the call period is computed, a personalcall is worth while. In a call <strong>to</strong> a certainstation, the taxed call period is reckoned from the103


Personal calls allowed only from Oct. 1929.mcment when the two stations are connected, eachhaving previously replied <strong>to</strong> the call signal. Theinterval between this and the moment when theperson enquired for by the caller arrives at thetelephone apparatus, if he is net pre-advised, mayfrequently cost quite a lot <strong>of</strong> money.The reason why the personal call is so muchmore rarely used in traffic <strong>to</strong> Sweden, however,may be found partly in the fact that this form<strong>of</strong> call is new in most other countries, and thatconsequently the subscribers there are not aware<strong>of</strong> its existence and value, and partly in that theinternational regulations for taxing personal callswere originally unfavourable in so far that inmany cases the caller had <strong>to</strong> pay for a call eventhough he did not find the person <strong>to</strong> whom thepre-advise was directed. From Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 1st 1929,however, these regulations are improved so thatno call fee is payable in case the person preadvisedis not at hand.Gradually, as knowledge <strong>of</strong> the personal calland its advantage <strong>to</strong> the subscriber becomes moreuniversally spread abroad, the frequency withwhich it is employed will certainly increase. Theexpansion during 1929, in comparison <strong>to</strong> 1928,is already considerable.In the directionfrom Germany lit Sweden, these calls have increasedduring 1929 by 18 per cent.,from Holland <strong>to</strong> Sweden, these calls have increasedduring 1929 by 60 per cent.,and from Switzerland <strong>to</strong> Sweden, these calls have increasedduring 1929 by 197 per cent.S<strong>to</strong>ckholm, February 14th 1930.A. Lignell- 104 -


The Hallsberg Electric Interlocking Signal Plant.By Herman Holmqvist, Signed Engineer.Progress in the field <strong>of</strong> electric interlockingsignalling deviees has heen rapid in recentyears, and the system applied in the Malmo plant(1925) led <strong>to</strong> further improvements. The firststep was the Hasselhohn interlocking plant ( 1926),where the mechanical locking system was whollydiscarded, and the levers only connected electrically.As this plant has now heen in use for sometrafficked junction. The plans were therefore revised,and the result may be said <strong>to</strong> be a compromisebetween the old system and the new whichis <strong>of</strong> great interest and has worked well in practice.The Hallsberg railway station is a junction <strong>of</strong>two important railway lines, the electrified S<strong>to</strong>ckholm—Gothenburgline and the steam Krylbo—Mjolby line, which latter has double tracks fromFig. 1.years, and has proved perfectly satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry fromthe point <strong>of</strong> view <strong>of</strong> security and reliability, thetime has been considered ripe <strong>to</strong> apply the system<strong>to</strong> other large installations planned, primarilythen at Lund, Gothenburg, and S<strong>to</strong>ckholm C. Inthe mean time, however, plans for another largeplant, Hallsberg, had been completed in the beginning<strong>of</strong> 192.S, with the intention <strong>of</strong> using theelder mechanical locking devices, i. e. allowingonly two train routes <strong>to</strong> he laid by each lever.But the advantages <strong>of</strong> the Malum system, permittingtrains from any <strong>of</strong> the lines <strong>to</strong> enter or leaveall tracks, were considered desirable at this heavilyOrebro <strong>to</strong> Hallsberg. On account <strong>of</strong> the <strong>to</strong>pographicalconditions the Krylbo—Mjolhy line is nota through line, but the tracks from Kuinla andfrom Asbro both enter at the east end <strong>of</strong> thestation yard. This implies a change round or exchange<strong>of</strong> the engines <strong>of</strong> all the trains at Hallsberg.and the Palsboda track must necessarilybe crossed either coining in or going out. Inaddition there are through carriages <strong>to</strong> and fromOrebro in a majority <strong>of</strong> the trains on the S<strong>to</strong>ckholmGothenburg line, involving a hurried shunting<strong>of</strong> passenger coaches from one train <strong>to</strong> another.Train traffic goes on all day and night.1 105


Fig. 2.


with groups <strong>of</strong> express trainsbetween 1—2 and 3—t a. m.Further, a number <strong>of</strong> goodstrains, usually very long, passthe station on their way <strong>to</strong>and from the shunting yard,situated immediately <strong>to</strong> thewest <strong>of</strong> the passenger station.This is a centre for the StateRailway long distance goodstraffic <strong>to</strong> and from Gothenburg,Malmo (Xassjo), S<strong>to</strong>ckholm,and Krylbo (Norrland).As far as possible, the more importantgoods trains are madeup and sorted out in this marshallingyard, and the work ismostly done at night.The above indicates thatsafety devices at this placemust fill a very real need, andsuch have therefore long been planned.The electric interlocking plant now erected atHallsberg is principally concerned with the passengerstation only. The attached diagram (fig. 1)shows the disposition <strong>of</strong> the tracks in the junction,4 passenger tracks and 2 goods tracks.Between the passenger tracks there are two platforms,connected mutually and <strong>to</strong> the stationbuilding by subways. The signal cabin is situatedFig. 4.107Fig. 3.on the cuter platform between the covered instairways <strong>to</strong> the passenger subway, and is intended<strong>to</strong> be run by the train dispatcher alone,which for the present, however, does not seemfeasible without assistance when large train groupsare passing. In the signal cabin (fig. 2) is anilluminated track plan, as well as shelves for relays,instrument panel, etc. Space being ratherlimited on account <strong>of</strong> the siting <strong>of</strong> the cabin, thecuter wall <strong>to</strong>wards track No. IVhas been doubled, forming akind cf bay (fig. 3). The outerwall consists <strong>of</strong> hinged shutters,and on the inner wall theterminals <strong>of</strong> most <strong>of</strong> the cablesfrom the yard, safety devices,signal transformers, crossinggatesrelays, and so on aremounted.All the tracks are providedwith track circuits extendingbeyond the distant signals,whereby the arrival <strong>of</strong> trainsis signalled. This is essential,as no less than five pairs <strong>of</strong>level crossing gates are controlledelectrically from thecabin. All main signals areelectric light signals, and thedistant signals are gas light


signals. On account <strong>of</strong> the curving track, thehome signal from Asbro has a repeat signal 150metres further out, showing only green lights, butextinguished when the home signals indicates s<strong>to</strong>p.A number <strong>of</strong> dwarf signals are also put up in thestation yard, normally showing the neutral signal— two lights at an angle <strong>of</strong> 45° <strong>to</strong> the right(fig. 4). The dwarf signals are in this instancenot used for the guidance <strong>of</strong> ordinary shunting,lint are designated for the laying <strong>of</strong> starting routesand for the passage <strong>of</strong> goods trains <strong>to</strong> and fromthe shunting yard. The centrally controlled pointsare as a rule connected in pairs on the same lever,all <strong>of</strong> which are provided with point locking devicesin connexion with track circuits. The pointscan also be changed over locally from localoperating contacts in the yard. Certain points andscotch-blocks are locked by electric locking devices,and others are locked by control locks, the keys <strong>of</strong>which are kept in locks, electrically connected <strong>to</strong>the respective coupling circuits, in the signal cabin.A smaller, mechanical, switching stand is put upin the shunting yard for safeguarding the start <strong>of</strong>the goods trains <strong>to</strong>wards Ostansjo, which have <strong>to</strong>cross the track leading <strong>to</strong> the shunting yard.A detailed study <strong>of</strong> the signal interlocking gearshows that this is comparatively roomy, withspace enough for 72 levers numbered in sequence.Signals and points are given the same numbersas their respective levers. The dwarf signals aredesignated by the letter D, and the main signalsby the letter H, for instance D 61 and H 69/70,The former signifies that this dwarf signal hasbeen set for neutral when the lever 61 is <strong>to</strong> theleft, and the latter that the main signal is controlledby the levers 69 and 70. The points, aswe have said above, being generally interconnected,both points are given the same number,e. g. 18, the one furthest westwards being called18 a, and the other one 18 b.The interlocking plant is <strong>of</strong> the Ericsson standarddesign, but with an unusually broad tracklocking gear, providing space for no less than40 road rulers (fig. 2).To lay the points for an incoming train, twolevers have generally <strong>to</strong> be moved, an inner one,choosing the right track, and an outer one actuatingthe light signal. Either lever locks the pointlevers in its group mechanically, and checks thes<strong>to</strong>p position <strong>of</strong> the dwarf signals required. Theincoming tracks are indicated <strong>to</strong> the engine driverby different main signal combinations, but notby the dwarf signals as is the case for the outgoingtracks. The start signals show a green anda red light only, but each outgoing route is indicatedby two dwarf signals also, each controllingits section <strong>of</strong> the track. Three levers musttherefore be moved <strong>to</strong> lay an outgoing route.The centre dwarf signal is first set, and movingthe lever sets this in the 45° go-position. Whenthe inner dwarf has also been set <strong>to</strong> 45°, theouter start signal lever is moved, which sets thestart signal <strong>to</strong> clear line and the two dwarf signals<strong>to</strong> the 90° go-position. On the power cable gallowsacross the platform repeat signals withgreen lights are fixed, announcing <strong>to</strong> the stationmaster when the line is clear for start, when thenumber <strong>of</strong> lights enables him <strong>to</strong> check which <strong>of</strong>the three lines is indicated. If the train is so longthat it reaches beyond the first dwarfsignal, thego-signal may still he given from the start signal,although the dwarf signal will only show 45°.No clear line signal can be given for eitherincoming or outgoing tracks until the level crossinggates are down. The normal procedure istherefore first <strong>to</strong> set the signal levers for theproper route, which does not give a clear linesignal. When the train enters the outermosttrack circuit, or for the outgoing line when thetrain is nearly due <strong>to</strong> start, the gate lever is turned.When the gates are right down, which, includingthe cautionary ringing signal, will takeabout 40 <strong>to</strong> 50 sees., the clear line signal au<strong>to</strong>maticallyappears in the respective signals. Thewiring connexions are such that when the signalhas once shown clear line, the gate lever mayagain be turned <strong>to</strong> its normal position, whichdoes not affect the gates until the last truck axlehas passed the level crossing, when the gates areau<strong>to</strong>matically raised.The abovementioned division <strong>of</strong> the train routesin<strong>to</strong> several sections, each with its signal lever,makes it possible <strong>to</strong> combine these levers so thateach line entering the junction may be routed<strong>to</strong> or from any track, wherever the track systemwill permit this. Track V and VI may also beentered or left by two routes, an inner one bypoints No. 39 and an other one by points No. 35.This is <strong>of</strong> great importance in avoiding, as muchas possible, blocking the level crossing in thewestern part <strong>of</strong> the station yard by the long goodstrains.— 108 —


R 1724 Fig. 5.The new L. M. Ericsson designs <strong>of</strong> operatingmachinery, incorporating a point lock (fig. 5),control the points electrically. The mo<strong>to</strong>rs aredriven by 130 volt D. C. By discarding the hooklocking device (fig. 4) lubrication and cleaning<strong>of</strong> the points is facilitated, especially in wintertime when ice and snow <strong>of</strong>ten interfere with theworking <strong>of</strong> the hook locks. Rollers are furtherprovided underneath the point <strong>to</strong>ngues, whichwill carry the <strong>to</strong>ngues during switching and makelubrication <strong>of</strong> the points quite unnecessary.The arrangements for local operation <strong>of</strong> thepoints are <strong>of</strong> new design in so far as, <strong>to</strong> allowthis, the switch lever must not only be placed inan intermediate position, but a relay placed ina small box close <strong>to</strong> the switching lever mustalso be dropped. This is done by means <strong>of</strong> atumbler switch above the interlocking gear (fig. 2,the far part <strong>of</strong> the cabin). A control lamp inthis box is also lit when the relay is attracted.When the relay drops, the mo<strong>to</strong>r circuit fromthe levers is broken and the scotch-block is disconnectedfrom the track circuit. Permission forlocal switching may thus be given and retractedeven if the train is standing on the track circuitthrough the points concerned, which is a greatadvantage when the trains are so long that thereis not room enough for them in the loops. Adim light at the local operating controls in theyard announces in the now usual manner thatthe points may be operated locally.The loose key used for local switching mustbe taken out after each switching operation andinserted the opposite way in the key-hole. Thisis designed so that when the key is inserted thehandle must point the way in which the <strong>to</strong>ngueshave <strong>to</strong> move. When the points are connectedin pairs, the points furthest from the local leveralways move the first, which makes it easy <strong>to</strong>see when the switching is completed, as therewill be no current for the near points until thefar ones have closed. As an additional check,a switching light is always provided at the farpqints.As mentioned above, five pairs <strong>of</strong> level cross-Fig. 6. Fig. 7.— 109 -


ing gates, the furthest <strong>of</strong> which is no less than950 metres distant <strong>to</strong>wards Palsboda, are controlledfrom the signal cabin. No shunting takesplace either at this crossing or at the one on theAsbro line, and consequently no proper gatesignals are given for the trains. The dropping<strong>of</strong> the gates here is controlled solely by mainsignals. As the mo<strong>to</strong>r traffic at these level crossingsis very heavy, light-signals are installedwhich show a red light <strong>to</strong> the road when theinterlocking gear by means <strong>of</strong> a control lock,provided with contacts on the local lever. Thismakes the main signal independent <strong>of</strong> the position<strong>of</strong> the gates. When the gates are set forlocal control, a dim light on the local lever contactis lit. When the gates are set for centralcontrol this is shown by a light in a control lampclose <strong>to</strong> the switch in the cabin.The illuminated track plan in the signal cabin(tig. 2) is <strong>of</strong> a neat and practical design, andFig. 8.cautionary ringing signal logins. A special devicein the gate lifting machinery disconnects thesesignals while the bar is still lifting, before it isright up. Similar light-signals are installed atthe level crossing in the western part <strong>of</strong> the stationyard. The gates are raised and lowered byelectric winches <strong>of</strong> the usual type, placed nearthe gates and joined <strong>to</strong> them by steel wire ropes(fig. (>). Contact devices on the gates provide acheck that the gates are actually down. Switchesin the signal cabin (fig. 2 <strong>to</strong> the right) make andbreak the current for the bar winches. If thecurrent should fail, the winches may be operatedby means <strong>of</strong> a crank handle. The gates at thecrossings where shunting occurs may also beclosed or opened on the spot. For this purposea special switch is turned in the cabin, and theguard at the gates must then drop a relay in theindicates the position <strong>of</strong> both track relays, signals,and level crossing gates. The track plan lampsare 3 and 6 volt telephone lamps behind varicolouredlenses. White lights on the track circuitsindicate that these are free <strong>of</strong> vehicles.When the lamps in a dwarf signal in the planare extinguished, that signal shows s<strong>to</strong>p. Neutralis marked by a white light, the 45° position bya yellow light and the 90° position by a greenlight. The main signals show red and greenlights. When the distant signal shows a greenlight, this is also shown on the plan. When thelight is changed <strong>to</strong> white, the lamp in the planis turned out. The level crossing gates in theplan are marked by lamps showing a red lightwhen the bars are up and green when they aredown. There is also a plain check light for thelevel crossing signals <strong>to</strong>wards the roads. The— 110 —


signal levers that must be moved for a certaincombination <strong>of</strong> the various train routes are plainlynoted on the track plan. Normal points positionscan also be read from the plan. A trainroute may thus be laid without recourse <strong>to</strong> lockingschedules, solely by observing the position<strong>of</strong> the points in the plan and the number <strong>of</strong> thelevers for the route in question.A special connexion has been used for the trackcircuit, with a condenser connected in front <strong>of</strong>D. C. primary cells, and have repeating relays inthe cabin.A machine room for the supply <strong>of</strong> current isarranged in one <strong>of</strong> the station buildings, wherethree-phase 220 volt A. C. is provided by therailway light-supply (fig. 9). A reserve <strong>of</strong> 2X220volt D. C. is also available from local supplylines. D. C, 130 volt for the point-driving andlevel crossing gate mo<strong>to</strong>rs, and 30 volt for controlcurrent, is obtained from two Westinghouse me-Fig. 9.the feed transformer. This gives a practicallyconstant secondary current, which is advantageousfor the shunt values <strong>of</strong> the track circuits. Thetrack relays are <strong>of</strong> two-phase type and placedin the interlocking machine, with relay transformersin cast iron boxes along the track ( fig. 4).Feed transformers and condensers are placed inwooden cases in the station yard (fig. 7). Trackcircuits outside the main signals are fed fromtal rectifiers (<strong>to</strong> the left in figs. 8 and 9). In case<strong>of</strong> A. C. failure, this may also he obtained froma D. C. driven rotary converter I <strong>to</strong> the right infig. 8).A plant <strong>of</strong> this size naturally requires a largecapitaloutlay, but the operating economies effectedby the reduction <strong>of</strong> staff made possibleby the installation <strong>of</strong> these safety devices providegood interest on the initial expenditure.111


On Cross-talk between Telephone Lines.By M. Vos.Introduction.The present theoretical research has for itspurpose <strong>to</strong> calculate the cross-talk betweentwo parallel homogeneous double wire lines, e. g.two homogeneous overhead lines located on thesame poles. The immediate reason for makingthis research was two questions which le ComiteConsultatif International des CommunicationsTelephoniques a Grande Distance (C. C. I.),das Nebensprechen in Kombinierten Fernsprechkreisen»,E. T. Z., 1920, page 188, also publishedby J. Springer, Berlin, 1919; F. Breisig, "Oberdas Nebensprechen in Fernsprechkreisen",E. T. Z., vol. 42, 1921, page 992; and K. Kupfmuller,"Cber das Nebensprechen in mehrfachenFernsprechkabeln und seine Verminderung",Arch. f. Elektr. vol. <strong>12</strong>, 1923, especially Part III"Theorie des Nebensprechens in langen homogenenLeitungen", page 173.Fig. 1.submitted <strong>to</strong> the 3rd Commission <strong>of</strong> Assessors2 at its plenary session in Berlin in June1929. The questions concerned were 6 b and16 b, which in translation read as follows:1) What value should he prescribed for crosstalkbetween any two carrier channels in thesame transposition system.2) Choice <strong>of</strong> a system <strong>of</strong> uniform transpositionsin short sections for aerial line networksin various countries.Cross-talk between homogeneous telephonelines has previously been theoretically dealt withby several investiga<strong>to</strong>rs. Amongst these mayhere onlv be mentioned: R. Lichtenstein, "Cber1 A lecture delivered at Ihe Meeting <strong>of</strong> the Swedish F.Iectro-Kngineers Association, on March 7th. 193.2 Peals with questions relating <strong>to</strong> Transmission and Maintenance.As the method <strong>of</strong> calculation used by theauthor differs from those used by earlier investiga<strong>to</strong>rs,and certain important, not generallyknown results have been attained, a publication<strong>of</strong> the present research may be justified.Most earlier investiga<strong>to</strong>rs have concentratedon the calculation <strong>of</strong> the so-called near-endcross-talk, which in ordinary audio-frequencytelephony is <strong>of</strong> the greatest interest. In carriertelephony with different carrier frequencies forthe two directions <strong>of</strong> talk, far-end cross-talk is <strong>of</strong>the greatest interest.Fig. 1 shows diagrammatically the ordinaryarrangement <strong>of</strong> two such carrier current channelswhich operate with the same carrier frequencies,one for each direction, on two separatedouble wire lines on the same poles between the1<strong>12</strong>


terminals A and B. 5, and S,' are two transmittersat A, which operate with the same carrierfrequency fa S., and S,' are two transmitters atB, which operate with the same carrier frequency/„; the frequencies generated at A by S, and S/are received at B by the respective receivers M,and M1' the frequencies generated at B by S 2and S 2 ' are received at A by the respective receiversif, and A/,'. Consequently the transmissionfrom A <strong>to</strong> B occurs for both channels withthe same carrier frequency f v and from B <strong>to</strong> Awith the same carrier frequency f 2 . In order thatturally unable <strong>to</strong> suppress the frequencies whichare generated by the transmitter at the otherterminal, and induced in<strong>to</strong> the channel throughan electro-magnetic coupling, i. e. the filters areunable <strong>to</strong> prevent far-end cross-talk. One <strong>of</strong>the main results <strong>of</strong> the present research is, however,that under certain conditions also far-endcross-talk can be made <strong>to</strong> disappear, though anelectro-magnetic coupling exists between thelines. The practical consequence <strong>of</strong> this is thatwe may be able <strong>to</strong> save the expense <strong>of</strong> a specialsystem <strong>of</strong> transpositions in short sections forthe transmitters S, and S,' do not affect thereceivers M 2 and M./ respectively, belonging <strong>to</strong>the same channel and located at the same terminal,there are inserted before the receivers tw<strong>of</strong>ilters F, and F,' respectively, which only passthe carrier frequency /„ and the side-band intendedfor these receivers. Likewise the filtersF, and F s ' are inserted at B before the receiversM 1 and 3// <strong>to</strong> prevent the transmitters S 2 andS/ respectively from influencing these receivers.An induction between the lines 1 and 2 cannotcause near-end cross-talk between subscriber 1and 2 at A, because a tension <strong>of</strong> frequency /,induced in line 2 is suppressed by the filter F'...and a tension <strong>of</strong> the same frequency /, inducedin line 1 is suppressed by the filter F 2 . The conditionsat the terminal B are quite analogous.With such an arrangement as shown in fig. 1near-end cross-talk between two high-frequencychannels is, consequently, not <strong>to</strong> be feared, althoughthe same frequencies are used on separatelines on the same poles.Fifr 2.- 113On the other hand, the filters inserted are nacarrieroperation, and be satisfied instead withthe existing transposition or twisting systems.Formulating the Problem.The problem the author has first placed beforehimself is as follows: (cf. fig. 2).Two parallel homogeneous double wire lines1 and 2 <strong>of</strong> the same length / are given. Betweenthese lines there exists a magnetic couplingwhich is constant for the whole length <strong>of</strong> thelines. A point on the line is characterised bythe distance .r from one terminal, which we callthe "near-end". The other terminal, which issituated at the distance x = / from the nearendwe call the "far-end".At the near-end an alternating current genera<strong>to</strong>rwith a sinusoidal tension E, independen<strong>to</strong>f the load, is connected <strong>to</strong> line 1. Line 2 isterminated in an impedance B,„ at the near-endand in an impedance R n at the far-end. Line 1is at the far-end terminated in an impedance B„.Line 1 may also he denominated as the induc-


ing. and line 2 as the induced line. Our taskis then, <strong>to</strong> calculate the tensions over the terminatingimpedances W,„ and /f L ,,. With a givengenera<strong>to</strong>r tension E these tensions V. 2tl and V%indicate respectively the magnitude <strong>of</strong> the nearamifar-end cross-talk between the two lines.Method <strong>of</strong>Calculation.As the two double wire lines <strong>to</strong>gether forma system <strong>of</strong> four parallel lines, the problemshould properly be dealt with by the aid <strong>of</strong> Maxwell'sequations for the electro-magnetic field <strong>of</strong>such a system.The electro-magnetic field <strong>of</strong> a system <strong>of</strong> parallelconduc<strong>to</strong>rs has previously been dealt withby several investiga<strong>to</strong>rs. Lord Rayleigh 1 wasthe first <strong>to</strong> work out such a theory on the basis<strong>of</strong> Maxwell's equations. Afterwards, Max Abraham-in his text-book "Theorie der Elektrizitat"has further developed the same. The stricttheory for the transmission <strong>of</strong> electro-magneticwaves along a system <strong>of</strong> lines has up <strong>to</strong> thepresent day been carried through only for a fewspecial line arrangements. A summary accountis given by Max Abraham in "Enzyklopedie d.Mathm. Wissen", Vol. V, Art. 18, par <strong>12</strong>, entitled"Induktionswirkungen von Wanderwellenin Nachbarleitungen".K. W. Wagner 3 has shown that also for non-Staticnary phenomena on a system <strong>of</strong> parallellines it is permissible <strong>to</strong> calculate as if the fieltldistribution were stationary, provided one canneglect the ohmic resistance <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rsand the leakage in the surrounding medium.These assumptions purport that the electro-magneticfield is entirely transversal, i. e. that thelines <strong>of</strong> force run in planes that are at rightangles <strong>to</strong> the longitudinal direction <strong>of</strong> the system<strong>of</strong> lines. In reality there is always a componentin the longitudinal direction due <strong>to</strong> the resistance<strong>of</strong> the wires, but a simple calculation goes<strong>to</strong> prove that for ordinary overhead long distancelines this component is so small in proportion<strong>to</strong> the transversal one, that in practice we mayalways reckon as if the field were merely transversaland stationarv.i Urd Rayleigh, Phil. Mag. Series 5, Vol. II. 1897. p. 199.- M. Abraham Theorie der Elrrtrizitat" Vol. 1, 5, 191H, par. 72,p. 293.K. \V. Warner "Induktionswirkungen von Wanderwellen inNacbbarleitnngen" E. T. 2. Jahrg. 35, 1914, p. 639.Wagner 1 considers a system <strong>of</strong> n parallel cylindricalconduc<strong>to</strong>rs with arbitrary section. Theground is denominated by 9 and the conduc<strong>to</strong>rsby 1, 2, 3 n. By the use <strong>of</strong> magnitudeswell defined for stationary electro-magnetic phenomena,e. g. magnetic induction coefficientsand electrical potential coefficients, as well asknown theses in respect <strong>of</strong> the transmission <strong>of</strong>electro-magnetic waves over a system <strong>of</strong> parallellines, Wagner arrives at the result that the tensionV, between a conduc<strong>to</strong>r »- and earth at acertain point <strong>of</strong> the system can be expressed asa linear function <strong>of</strong> the currents in all n conduc<strong>to</strong>rsat the same points viz.:J,, is the current in the conduc<strong>to</strong>r »-.W„, is the mutual surge impedance betweenthe conduc<strong>to</strong>rs « and y.W„ is the surge impedance for the very conduc<strong>to</strong>rv-Wagner further shows that W, and W„ aregiven by the following relations:andwhere: L uy is the mutual magnetic inductioncoefficient between the loops formed bythe conduc<strong>to</strong>r u and earth and the conduc<strong>to</strong>rv and earth.L rr is the self-induction coefficient <strong>of</strong>the loop formed by the conduc<strong>to</strong>r andearth.c is the speed <strong>of</strong> light in space andf is the dielectric constant <strong>of</strong> the mediumsurrounding the line system;the permeability <strong>of</strong> the medium is assumed= 1.As Abraham- had already shown, the generalsolution applying <strong>to</strong> the differential equationsfor such a system <strong>of</strong> lines is:andIn these equations qv is the charge per lengthunit on the conduc<strong>to</strong>r r, t is the time variable,1 loc. cit.2 Abraham loc. cit. p.114


X is the distance <strong>to</strong> the point referred <strong>to</strong> from afixed point, e. g. the near-end <strong>of</strong> the line system;/ and g are arbitrary functions. The equations(4) and (5) represent two electro-magnetic waveswhich are transmitted with the same speedone <strong>of</strong> form f, in a positive direction,the other <strong>of</strong> form g, in a negative direction.Equation (4) is the expression for the chargewaves, and equation (5) for the current waves.The functions /", and ;/, are arbitrary, so thatwaves <strong>of</strong> any form whatsoever may occur insuch a line system, but they are determinedby the limiting conditions.where r'„, = r',.„ is equal <strong>to</strong> the distance l>etweenthe conduc<strong>to</strong>r u and the mirrorimage <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>r »>, or vice versa.On the basis <strong>of</strong> equation (2) there is then:andso is also:In the same way the self-induction coeffien<strong>to</strong>f the loop formed by the conduc<strong>to</strong>r r and theearth is:Fig. 3.Calculation <strong>of</strong> the Surge Impedances\V„, and \V„,.As the surge impedances \V„,, and W„ for asystem <strong>of</strong> parallel conduc<strong>to</strong>rs are directly proportional<strong>to</strong> the corresponding magnetic inductioncoefficients for the same system, we mayfirst calculate these.For two conduc<strong>to</strong>rs ;< and y, fig. 3, placedupon a height h„ respectively h, above ground0 and at a distance r„, from one another, themutual magnetic induction coefficient, is, as weknow:where h, is the height <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>r v aboveground and o, the radius <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rV-On the basis <strong>of</strong> equation (8) there is then:Calculation <strong>of</strong> the Surge Impedances<strong>of</strong> Two Parallel HomogeneousWire Lines:<strong>of</strong> a SystemDoubleWe consider a system <strong>of</strong> two parallel homogeneousdouble wire lines <strong>of</strong> which fig. 4 showsan arbitrary cross-section. The line I is formedby the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs 1 and 2 at an average height115


HI above ground 0; V and 2' are the mirrorimages <strong>of</strong> 1 and 2, when the ground is consideredas the mirror surface. The line II is formedby the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs 3 and 4 at an average heightHII above ground; 3' and 4' are their mirrorimages.The use <strong>of</strong> the equation (1) on all four conduc<strong>to</strong>rsthen gives us the following system <strong>of</strong>equations:andThe system <strong>of</strong> equations (10) by this becomes:ror the tensions between the branches wetherefore get:Fig. 4.In these equations V„„ V.,,,, V.„, and V 411 aretensions between the respective conduc<strong>to</strong>rs 1, 2,3, 4 and earth; J v J.,, J. u J i currents in the respectiveconduc<strong>to</strong>rs; W tv W T2 , W,.„ IV 44 surgeimpedances between the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs.In a double wire line the current in one branchis equal <strong>to</strong>, but <strong>of</strong> an opposite direction from,the current in the other branch, so that we areable <strong>to</strong> assume:if we put:the equation (13) passes in<strong>to</strong>:11(5


Through W r . — W llt (equation 7a) is also:The equation (15) thus passes in<strong>to</strong>:Z n and Z.,., are the surge impedances for thedouble wire lines 1 respectively 2. Z,, = Z 21are the mutual surge impedances between thedouble wire lines.For such a double wire line h > 30' = 9.15 m.;r <strong>12</strong> = <strong>12</strong>" = 30.5 cm.; 2 o = 0.104" = 2.64 mm.;Q = 0.052".As the distance between the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs issmall compared with their height above ground,r u ' ^ 2 h, as we have assumed here before, andthe formula (17) holds good. With f = 1 andC = 3 - 10 1 " cm/sec. the surge impedance is thencalculated <strong>to</strong>:Fig. 5.Calculation <strong>of</strong> the Surge Impedance Z lt for aBalanced Double Wire Line.or, since 1 e. m. e. is equal <strong>to</strong> 10 -9ohm:For a balanced double wire line (1—2) is:andwith the result that according <strong>to</strong> (9):Calculation <strong>of</strong> the Mutual Surye Impedance Z r ,between two Double Wire Lines (1—2) andAccording <strong>to</strong> equation (7) is:Since according <strong>to</strong> (7a) W n<strong>to</strong> W„ we get:is always equaland then according<strong>to</strong> (14)so that:orSince according <strong>to</strong> (14):As in most caseswe get:By way <strong>of</strong> example we may calculate the surgeimpedance for a double wire line, which is verymuch used by the Bell Company in U. S. A. 11Ct.: "Carrier systems on Long Distance Telephone Lines".B. S. T. Jl. Vol. 7, July 1929. p. 815.If the distance between the lines is short comparedwith their height above ground, we can.without any very great error, put:so that (18) is reduced <strong>to</strong>:117


tion) and by V1'', the tension for a retrogressivewave, the <strong>to</strong>tal tension between the branches is:By way <strong>of</strong> example we may calculate the mutualsurge impedance between two double wirelines <strong>of</strong> the same design as in the previousexample, erected beside each other on the samecrcss-arms as those practised by the Bell Companyin U. S. A. (cf. fig. 5). 1The height above ground is, as before, h > 30= 9.15 m, i. e. great in comparison with thedistance between the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs, so that formula(19) may be employed. The distance betweenthe conduc<strong>to</strong>rs in every double wire lineis: r <strong>12</strong> = r M = <strong>12</strong>". As the distance betweenthe insula<strong>to</strong>r pins <strong>of</strong> the same cross-arm isIn the same way it holds good for double wireline (2):If we define a current as positive when it flowsin the direction <strong>of</strong> increasing x-values, and if thecurrents in the progressive and retrogressivewave on line 1 are I1' and I" respectively, the<strong>to</strong>tal current is:in the same way it holds good for double line 2:Fig. 6.throughout <strong>12</strong>", r„, = <strong>12</strong>"; r ]4 = 36"; r„ = 24"and r. 4 = 24" and with f = 1,The use <strong>of</strong> the equation (15 a) on the progressivewaves on the lines 1 and 2 then resultsin:Calculation <strong>of</strong> Cross-talk between two HomogeneousParallel Double Wire Lines when theElectro-magnetic Coupling is Constant all alongthe Line.We will now consider a system <strong>of</strong> two homogeneousparallel double wire lines with a constantelectro-magnetic coupling between the linesas per fig. 6. If we denominate the tension betweenthe branches <strong>of</strong> line 1 by V,' for a progressivewave (transmission in a positive direciCS. B. S. T. JI. Vol. 7, July 192«. P. 581.In these equations Z 1X and Z 22 , as before, denominatethe wave resistances <strong>of</strong> lines 1 and 2respectively, and Z ]2 the mutual surge impedancebetween the lines. For the retrogressive waveswe get:If we assume that the tension caused by thegenera<strong>to</strong>r V 10 is sinusoidal and <strong>of</strong> the angularvelocity a>, undamped waves are transmitted onthe line system both in a positive and negativedirection with a speed <strong>of</strong>— 118 -


) line 2:where a is the wave-length constant for the linesystem. If A 1 ' is the amplitude <strong>of</strong> the voltagewave at the beginning <strong>of</strong> the line 1 (x = 0) thevoltage at a point x on the same line is:In the same way we obtain for the voltage atpoint x on the line 2 for the progressive wave:For the retrogressive waves we get:But the voltage V 20 at the beginning <strong>of</strong> theline 2 must also be equal <strong>to</strong> the voltage dropwhich the current I20 causes in the impedanceR 20 , i. e.:2) for x = I.a) line 1.or according <strong>to</strong> the aboveIf B t ' and B x " are the amplitudes <strong>of</strong> the progressiveand retrogressive current waves at thebeginning <strong>of</strong> line 1, and B.,' and B." the equivalentcurrent amplitudes for line 2, we get thefollowing system <strong>of</strong> equations:The voltage drop over the impedance R^ bywhich the line is terminated must also be equal<strong>to</strong> V n so that:By combining (29), (30) and (31) we get:If the electro-magnetic coupling between thelines is so loose that the reaction <strong>of</strong> the currentin line 2 on the voltage on line 1 can be neglected,(22) and (23) are reduced <strong>to</strong>:b) line 2.andWe assume in the following that this is thecase. By the combination <strong>of</strong> (22 a) and (23 a)with (24) and (25) we get:Here, <strong>to</strong>o, V a at the terminal <strong>of</strong> the line 2must be equal <strong>to</strong> the voltage drop which thecurrent J 2/ causes in the impedance 7? a , whichterminates the line 2, i. e.By a combination <strong>of</strong> (33), (34) and (35) weobtain:If we consider the limiting conditions at bothterminals <strong>of</strong> the line system (0 and /) for bothdouble wire lines, we get:1) for x = 0a) line 1If in the following we put e +jal = m ande -jal = n, (32) and (36) respectively are:By inserting in (27), (28), (32 a) and (36 a)for A/, A" 2 , ,4/' and A" their values extractedfrom (36) we get the following system <strong>of</strong> equations:119


B.,' is calculated from (38 a) in a known manner<strong>to</strong>:or after reduction:For B." we obtain in the same way:In the form <strong>of</strong> a determinant the system <strong>of</strong>equations (37) becomes:The near-end cross-talk then becomes:We assume now at first that the lines are terminatedin impedances which are equal <strong>to</strong> thesurge impedance <strong>of</strong> the respective lines, so that:The determinant (38) then becomes:Since:andThe near-end cross-talk tension across the terminatingimpedance R, 0 = Z.,. z , according <strong>to</strong>(28), therefore is:If we put:we obtain by reduction:For the purpose <strong>of</strong> calculating the currentI20 in the terminating impedance R 20 = Z 22 atthe near-end <strong>of</strong> the induced line 2, which currentgives rise <strong>to</strong> near-end cross-talk, we needonly calculate B1' and B2'' I20 is then:The far-end cross-talk current !», i. e. thecurrent in the terminating impedance R% = Z?><strong>of</strong> the induced lines is calculated according <strong>to</strong>(34) <strong>to</strong>:In view <strong>of</strong> (40) and (41) we get:we get:<strong>12</strong>0


or also:I. e.: If the inducing line 1 at the far-end isterminated in an impedance R-i equal <strong>to</strong> thesurge impedance Z tl <strong>of</strong> the inducing line, andthe induced line 2 at the near end is terminatedin an impedance B.,,, equal <strong>to</strong> the surge impedanceZ.,., <strong>of</strong> the induced line, the far-end crosstalkbetween the lines disappears, no matterwhat the frequency and the length <strong>of</strong> lines maybe. In this case is does not matter in what impedancethe induced line is terminated at thefar-end, since current and tension there are equal<strong>to</strong> zero.If this conclusion is correct, it must also provethat B! and B," are independent <strong>of</strong> the impedanceR»i in which the induced line is terminated,and that it is unnecessary <strong>to</strong> assume thatB 2; is equal <strong>to</strong> the wave resistance Z a <strong>of</strong> theline.In order <strong>to</strong> control this we shall now onlyassume that R u = Z u and R n = Z22.The determinant (38) then becomes:We put:As will be seen, (39) is identical with (30),no matter whether R 3l — Zu or not.For B," we obtain in this case:orThe calculation <strong>of</strong> the determinant results in:As will be seen, also (50) is identical with(41) and this proves that far-end cross-talk disappears,no matter in what impedance the inducedline is terminated at the distant end.For the sake <strong>of</strong> completeness we calculatealso /,„, i. e. the current fed in<strong>to</strong> the inducingline by the genera<strong>to</strong>r V,„.Since I 10 , = B1' + B1" we compute B,' andB1" from (38 a) <strong>to</strong>:The calculation <strong>of</strong> the determinant results in:In the preceeding case B.,' hecomes:and<strong>12</strong>1The current fed in<strong>to</strong> the inducing line by thegenera<strong>to</strong>r then becomes:


The reciprocal value is:This result was <strong>to</strong> be expected.With the aid <strong>of</strong> B/ and B," we are also easilyable <strong>to</strong> calculate the current J u and the tensionV\t at the near-end <strong>of</strong> the inducing line:According <strong>to</strong> (30):which, in view <strong>of</strong> (51) and (52) becomes:The near-end cross-talk attenuation is then:The cross-talk is greatest, i. e. b becomes aminimum, when cos 2al = — 1; thenandFrom these formulas it is obvious that onaccount <strong>of</strong> the terminating impedance R u havingbeen selected equal <strong>to</strong> Z„ no reflected waveis developed at the near-end <strong>of</strong> the inducing line.For the amplitude <strong>of</strong> the voltage waves onboth lines and in both directions we get withregard <strong>to</strong> (26), (40), (41), (51) and (52):By way <strong>of</strong> example we may with the aid <strong>of</strong>formula (64) calculate the minimum cross-talkattenuation between two double wire lines whichare very much used by the Bell Company inU. S. A. 1 , and for which we have previously inthis article (cf. pp. 8 and 9) calculated theirsurge impedance as well as the mutual surge impedance.With the values for the surge impedances computedon pages 8 and 9 viz:the minimum attenuation for these non-transposedlines becomes:Calculation <strong>of</strong> the near-end cross-talkbetween the lines.According <strong>to</strong> (44) is:attenuationThe author has also with the aid <strong>of</strong> formula(54) made certain calculations concerning thecross-talk attenuation between two twisted pairs<strong>of</strong> the type cus<strong>to</strong>mary in Sweden, and which arelocated beside each other on the same crossarms.The minimum cross-talk attenuation wtas calculatedat 6.06 Neper for two twisted pairs whichrotate in the same direction and in the samephase.Sincewe getComparisons with the Results Obtained byKiipfmiiller '- by another Method.Kiipfmuller's equation (45) for near-end crosstalkbecomes with our denominations:The absolute value <strong>of</strong>is:<strong>12</strong>2In this equation K is Kupfmiiller's "electromagneticcoupling" hetween the lines at point XI1 Cf. B. S. T. Jl. Vol. 7. July 1928, pp. 581 and 592.2 Kupfmuller. Arrh. (. F.lektr., Vol. <strong>12</strong>. 1923, p. ISO.


φ is the angular velocity and y, respectivelyy> 2 the propagation constants for the lines 1and 2.where C is the capacity <strong>of</strong> the double wire lineper unit length. A comparison with (43) thenshows that:If we assume the electro-magnetic coupling A'lo he constant and equal <strong>to</strong> K 0 for all x's, theintegration gives:If in accordance with our previous assumptionswe put:we get:Calculation <strong>of</strong> the Cross-talk between two HomogeneousLines when the Coupling Z <strong>12</strong> isa Function <strong>of</strong> x.We consider now an arrangement accordinglo fig. 7. The inducing line, with the surge impedanceZ 11 , is assumed as very short, its lengthis denominated by dx; at x, the beginning <strong>of</strong> theline referred <strong>to</strong>, an alternating current genera<strong>to</strong>rFig 7A comparison with our equation (43) showsthat the two equations (43) and (67) lead <strong>to</strong>the same result if:orNowis the velocity <strong>of</strong> propagation <strong>of</strong>the waves on the line system, for which reason(69) may he written:Kupfmiiller shows that equation (67) can alsobe written in the following form:with sinusoidal tension Vj, is connected <strong>to</strong> theline; at the other end x + dx the line is terminatedin an impedance equal <strong>to</strong> the surge impedanceZ 11The induced line with the surge impedanceZ22 is much longer; its length is /. At x = 0Ihe induced line is terminated in an impedanceequal <strong>to</strong> the surge impedance Z.,.,. At the otherterminal x = I the line is terminated in an arbitraryimpedance. Between the lines there isan electro-magnetic coupling which between xand x + dx is constant and equal <strong>to</strong> Z tx .The arrangement according <strong>to</strong> fig. 7 is thenperfectly equivalent <strong>to</strong> an arrangement as perfig. 6, in which R u = Z n and R„ = Z„. Thepart <strong>of</strong> the induced line <strong>to</strong> the left <strong>of</strong> x, whenlooked at from x, is equivalent <strong>to</strong> an impedance7,... The impedance <strong>of</strong> the part <strong>to</strong> the right <strong>of</strong>x + dx, on the other hand, may be arbitrary, as<strong>12</strong>3


we have previously seen in the case <strong>of</strong> an arrangementas per fig. 6.With regard <strong>to</strong> the equivalence <strong>of</strong> the arrangementsand equation (44) the tension at point x<strong>of</strong> the induced line is:The tension hetvveen the branches <strong>of</strong> the inducedline at x + dx, on the other hand, according<strong>to</strong> (46) is:As may also bewritten:The arrangements according <strong>to</strong> fig. 8 is equivalent<strong>to</strong> the arrangement as per fig. 7. Thepart <strong>of</strong> the inducing line added <strong>to</strong> the left <strong>of</strong> xhas no inducing effect upon the line 2, and thetension V r , set up by the genera<strong>to</strong>r V 10 at thepoint x is assumed <strong>to</strong> be equal <strong>to</strong> \\ x in fig. 7.Xor has the part <strong>of</strong> the inducing line attached<strong>to</strong> the right <strong>of</strong> x + dx any effect upon line 2,and its impedance, looked at from point x + dx,is, as in fig. 7, Z 1VUnder the circumstances we are able <strong>to</strong>write:and in view <strong>of</strong> (76) and (77):Fig. 8.The tension dV 2x at point x sets up a tensionat point 0 <strong>of</strong> the induced line:As the tension dV 2(x+dx) = 0. the tension <strong>of</strong>the induced line at the far end x = I also becomeszero, so that we are able <strong>to</strong> write:For a line arrangement according <strong>to</strong> fig. 8,in Which the electro-magnetic coupling is notlimited <strong>to</strong> a single point on the line, but wherethe coupling can be expressed as a variable function<strong>of</strong> at, in view <strong>of</strong> the principle <strong>of</strong> superpositionholding good in this case, we get:This holds good irrespective <strong>of</strong> in what waythe line is terminated at the terminal /, nor doesit matter whether the part <strong>of</strong> the line between(at + dx) and / has the wave resistance Z ri ornot, or whether it is homogeneous or not.We now pass on <strong>to</strong> a consideration <strong>of</strong> an arrangementaccording <strong>to</strong> fig. 8. in which an electro-magneticcoupling Z, 2 between the lines onlyexists between the points x and x -f- dx.With this we arrive at the main result <strong>of</strong> thisresearch, viz:That the far-end cross-talk between two homogeneouslines <strong>of</strong> which the inducing line at thefar end and the induced line at the near end areterminated in their own impedances, always disappears,no matter how the electro-magnetic<strong>12</strong>4


coupling may b2 distributed along the linesystem.If we assume that Z v , in equation (81) is constant,i. e. independent <strong>of</strong> x, we get:As will be seen, (83) is identical with (44),which ought <strong>to</strong> be the case if our calculationsare right. Likewise (82) is identical with (46).In a future work the author intends <strong>to</strong> showthat similar results are obtained for the crosstalkbetween two parallel homogeneous telephonelines whose line resistance is low- comparedwith the surge impedance. The waves arein that case damped. If the propagation constanty = p + j a , ( a is the wave-length constant;ft is the attenuation constant) is equal forthe two lines, and if the lines are terminated aswe have previously stated, the equation (44) forthe near-end cross-talk can be written:The far-end cross-talk tension is, as before,practically:By way <strong>of</strong> summary we may say that the farendcross-talk between two parallel homogeneoustelephone double wire lines practically disappearsif the far end <strong>of</strong> the inducing line and thenear end <strong>of</strong> the induced line are terminated intheir own impedances. The distribution <strong>of</strong> theelectro-magnetic coupling along the line systemis, in this case, without any influence.From a physical point <strong>of</strong> view we may givethe following explanation <strong>of</strong> the cross-talk whichoccurs in lines that are not terminated in theaforesaid way.If the induced, but not the inducing, line isterminated in its own impedance, there occursa reflected wave at the far end <strong>of</strong> the latter. Thisreflected wave may be considered as being awave emanating from a genera<strong>to</strong>r at the far end,i. e. it causes near-end cross-talk at the far-end<strong>of</strong> the induced line. The far-end cross-talk ob-served is, therefore, in this case in reality a nearendcross-talk due <strong>to</strong> the reflected wave, and itsintensity is directly proportional <strong>to</strong> the amplitude<strong>of</strong> the reflected wave. When the inducingline, but not the near-end <strong>of</strong> the induced line, isterminated in its own impedance, far-end crosstalkis due <strong>to</strong> reflexions in the near-end <strong>of</strong> theinduced line <strong>of</strong> the same wave, which causesthe near-end cross-talk. As has previously beendemonstrated the wave emanating from the genera<strong>to</strong>rproduces at a coupling point betweenthe lines a wave in the induced line, which isenly transmitted in the direction <strong>of</strong> the near-end<strong>of</strong> the line system.. This wave gives rise <strong>to</strong> nearendcross-talk, but since we have assumed thatthe induced line at this point is not terminatedin its own impedance, a part <strong>of</strong> the wave is reflectedand travels along <strong>to</strong> the far end, whereit also causes far-end cross-talk.If neither line is terminated in its own impedancefar-end cross-talk is caused by superposition<strong>of</strong> the phenomena described for the twoprevious cases.The Practical Importance <strong>of</strong> the Results <strong>of</strong> theResearch.It seems <strong>to</strong> be obvious from this research thatin carrier current telephone systems whichoperate with different frequency bands for thetwo directions <strong>of</strong> conversation, we might be able<strong>to</strong> considerably diminish far-end cross-talk,which is the only one <strong>of</strong> any importance in thisinstance between the different carrier channelson the same poles, by dimensioning the equipmentsat the terminal and intermediate amplifyingstations in such a way that their input Impedancefor all important frequencies coincidesas much as possible with the characteristic impedance<strong>of</strong> the lines connected <strong>to</strong> them. As thereare no essential technical difficulties in bringingabout good agreement between the said impedances,it seems as if this method, which directlyattacks the cause <strong>of</strong> cross-talk, could diminishthe demands which must he made upona transposing or twisting system for lines fortransmitting the high frequencies used in carriercurrent telephony. We might, possibly, even besatisfied with the systems <strong>of</strong> transposition andtwisting which are now cus<strong>to</strong>mary for low frequencytelephony and thus effect a great savingin the line costs.— <strong>12</strong>5 —


Practical Points About Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm.By Harold Ekman, Supervising Engineer <strong>of</strong> the S<strong>to</strong>ckholm Fire Brigade.The stupendous advances made in technicsduring the past twenty or thirty years hashad a revolutionizing effect on individuals andthe community as a whole. What seemed out <strong>of</strong>Kin. t a. Diagram <strong>of</strong> an Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm installation.(Eacfc fire-alarm section comprises a certain part <strong>of</strong> the premises.)Fig. 1 b. Diagram <strong>of</strong> an Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm installation.(The black dots represent the au<strong>to</strong>matic thermo-contacts.)reach yesterday may <strong>to</strong>-day be made available <strong>to</strong>all and sundry, and as a result <strong>of</strong> the abundance<strong>of</strong> technical aids and the necessities created bythem we make ever greater demands on the functioning<strong>of</strong> the organs which supply our needs.— <strong>12</strong>6 —The wave <strong>of</strong> rationalization rolling over theworld is receiving added stimulus from the economicpressure resulting from depression inbusiness and severe competition. But <strong>of</strong> whatavail is a good organizationand well-planned operation,based on what seems <strong>to</strong> bedependable calculations, ifthe whole venture can beupset by the ravages <strong>of</strong>fire. The material objectsone can insure but not thepresent and future prospects<strong>of</strong> the business.Economical fire protectionis not only a nationalgain, it is a good investmentfor the individualbusiness man who has realizedin time the benefitsaccruing from it.An efficient fire protectionorganization must embraceboth arrangementsfor preventing the inceptionand spreading <strong>of</strong> thefire, and fire extinguishingdevices suitable for the localconditions. One feature<strong>of</strong> such an organizationwhich is <strong>of</strong> primary importanceis that absolutelydependable means shouldbe provided for alarmingand directing the fire-crew<strong>to</strong> the spot. It should bepossible for the fire-crew<strong>to</strong> find the right placequickly, because any loss <strong>of</strong> time means thatthe fire will get a further start, and mayattain such a size that the available fire extinguishingarrangements will be insufficient <strong>to</strong>cope with it, no matter how efficient the organi-


Fig. 2. An Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm Station Apparatus for 6 Sections,including Charging Board for S<strong>to</strong>rage Batteries. The diagram showssignal lamps and various illuminated signs which, <strong>to</strong>gether withbells, au<strong>to</strong>matically register fire alarm and faults <strong>of</strong> every kind,and also control that every switch is correctly thrown.zaticn happens <strong>to</strong> be. I wish at this point <strong>to</strong>emphasize the immense importance <strong>of</strong> discoveringthe fire in good time, and the fact that thereis an intimate connection between the stage atwhich the fire is discovered, and alarm given, andthe losses which the fire will cause in the end.The fire grows in practically all cases from aninsignificant start, is developed gradually withsteadily increased power <strong>of</strong> expansion, and thecurve for the spread <strong>of</strong> the fire rises violently.Minutes are valuable, especially at the earlieststage <strong>of</strong> the fire, and the results that can be accomplishedat that time with a very simple fireextinguishingoutfit may at the later stage bebeyond the capacity <strong>of</strong> even the best fire fightingorganization.Experience teaches us a number <strong>of</strong> interestinglessons on this score and gives valuable informa-Fig. 3. Central Fire Alarm Board for a large station (311 Sections).tion which is collected in the statistics <strong>of</strong> firelosses and the journals <strong>of</strong> the fire brigades.In practically all cases <strong>of</strong> fire where some personhas been present at the inception, or has arrivedon the spot shortly after the outbreak, theperson has himself or with aid called <strong>to</strong> his assistancebeen able <strong>to</strong> put out the fire or in anyevent confine the fire <strong>to</strong> a limited area. Veryfew large conflagrations have for this reasontaken place during working hours, except inattics, warehouses or other places <strong>of</strong> that kindleft without regular attendance. In a community,fac<strong>to</strong>ry or other working premises peopleare all the time in watchful movement, and thefire, as already intimated, is in all these casesimmediately discovered and, according <strong>to</strong> statistics,is usually put out with a hand fire-pump,chemical fire-extinguisher or the like, and a seriousconflagration avoided.It is <strong>of</strong> interest <strong>to</strong> examine the journals <strong>of</strong> theS<strong>to</strong>ckholm fire brigade <strong>to</strong> see what they have <strong>to</strong><strong>12</strong>7


Fig. 4. Central Fire Alarm Board for a large station (open).Fig. 5. Thertno-contact.closed.Fig. 6. Thermo contact after giving alarm.l28


Fig. 7. Thermo.-contact filled in Wood-drying Kiln.Fig. 10. Alarm Bell for A.Ccurrent.Fig. 9 Alarm Bell <strong>of</strong> powerful type,with bell <strong>of</strong> 250 mm diam.Fig. 8. Tbermo-contact fitted underneath stage floor.— <strong>12</strong>9 —


Fig. 11. Mo<strong>to</strong>r-genera<strong>to</strong>r for au<strong>to</strong>matic connection <strong>to</strong> Fire AlarmBoard. To be used il several A.C. alarm bells are au<strong>to</strong>matically <strong>to</strong>give fire alarm.relate on the subject <strong>of</strong> calls <strong>to</strong> put out firesduring night hours or after working hours or,generally speaking, concerning large fires.This is a very interesting chapter. Most largefires have occurred in premises which have beenunguarded during the inception and early stage<strong>of</strong> the fire, and the fire brigade has in these cases<strong>of</strong>ten been alarmed by outsiders after the firehas bursted windows and shutters, or even burntthrough floors and walls. All the largest fires inS<strong>to</strong>ckholm during recent years, among themSvenska Teatern, Galarvarvet, Hasselbacken, Alhambra,Ostermalmsteatern, Separa<strong>to</strong>r, Tattersall,have started between 11.45 p. m. and 3.30Fig. 13. Same Fire Alarm Box as Fig. <strong>12</strong>, but with the door open.a. m. and in consequence have not been discovereduntil a far advanced stage. The recentfire in the paper s<strong>to</strong>rage <strong>of</strong> the Svanstrom firmat Herkulesgatan also belongs <strong>to</strong> this category.The fire raged undisturbed in the large basements<strong>to</strong>rey, where it s<strong>to</strong>red up an enormousamount <strong>of</strong> energy and choking gases, which madeit difficult <strong>to</strong> localize and attack the heart <strong>of</strong> thefire. In the last mentioned case the delayedalarm caused losses amounting <strong>to</strong> several millionkroner.From what has been said in the foregoing oneis justified in the cause <strong>of</strong> fire protection <strong>to</strong> insis<strong>to</strong>n the enormous importance <strong>of</strong> the quickestpossible means <strong>to</strong> give notification <strong>of</strong> the out-Fig. 14. Branch Fire AlarmBox which may be connected<strong>to</strong> au<strong>to</strong>matic fire alarm station.The box is <strong>to</strong> bo connectedin a separate loop orin an existing thermo-enntat Isection.Fig. <strong>12</strong>. Fire Alarm Box with telephone, intended as main firealarm box for transmitting au<strong>to</strong>matic alarm <strong>to</strong> F'ire Brigade.Telephone can also be used for manual operation.Fig. 15, Fire Station Apparatus forFire Brigade, with two telegraphinstruments.— 130 -


R 1591Fig. 16. Fire Station Apparatus <strong>of</strong> the Fire Brigade in the <strong>to</strong>wn ot Jonkdping.break <strong>of</strong> fire, and demand that the most up-<strong>to</strong>datedevices which modern technics have createdshould be utilized for preventing such abnormallylarge fires.With such devices I have in mind the au<strong>to</strong>maticfire alarm system, where the alarm isput in<strong>to</strong> function by the fire itself at the veryoutbreak. This system signifies that one nolonger leaves it <strong>to</strong> chance <strong>to</strong> determine the momentfor giving alarm, but the work <strong>of</strong> puttingout the fire can be instituted at once, and,furthermore, by means <strong>of</strong> a special alarm boardit is possible <strong>to</strong> determine where on the premisesthe source <strong>of</strong> the fire is located.The au<strong>to</strong>matic fire alarm system is based onelectric circuits connected <strong>to</strong> fire alarm contacts(thermo-contacts) distributed over the premisesthat are <strong>to</strong> be protected and which are susceptihle<strong>to</strong> heat and connected by electric circuits<strong>to</strong> a local alarm board. Should one or more <strong>of</strong>these contacts be heated owing <strong>to</strong> a rise <strong>of</strong> thetemperature in that part <strong>of</strong> the premises, theyau<strong>to</strong>matically begin <strong>to</strong> function and close a certaincircuit by means <strong>of</strong> the relays and otherreceiving devices on the alarm board. As a resul<strong>to</strong>f such changes, signal bells or sirens areput in<strong>to</strong> operation, or the alarm may be transmittedthrough fire alarm boxes direct <strong>to</strong> thefire brigade. The alarm board <strong>of</strong> the receiving3.131 —set indicates inter alia from whichplace on the premises the alarmhas been given. For facilitating thisplace indication the thermo-contactsare grouped in<strong>to</strong> a numbera separate, locally delimited, firealarmsections, which each have adesignation on the alarm board.The alarm board is preferably <strong>to</strong>be set up at the main entrance orother frequented place on the premises.A controlled s<strong>to</strong>rage batterysupplies the current required<strong>to</strong> operate the system.The value <strong>of</strong> such an au<strong>to</strong>maticalarm installation can not be overrated,provided it complies in alltechnical respects with the demandsfor reliability in operation:otherwise it may do more harmthan good. It is necessary <strong>to</strong> keepin mind that an au<strong>to</strong>matic firealarm system, without any human interventionand under the very worst practical conditions,must infallibly register and transmit it may beonly a single important fire alarm and thatmany years after the system has been installed,at a time when the interest in, and the attendanceand care <strong>of</strong>, the system may not be so much aliveas when it was new.The decision <strong>to</strong> instal an au<strong>to</strong>matic fire alarmsystem <strong>of</strong> this kind means both for the insuredand the insurance companies the transfer <strong>of</strong> animportant responsibility on<strong>to</strong> the system, whichis then made practically the sole protec<strong>to</strong>ragainst fire.The technics relating <strong>to</strong> electric signalling havemade rapid strides during the last decade ortwo; what was considered satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry andgenerally speaking good enough sometime agomust now be discarded in view <strong>of</strong> recent progressand the increased demands made on the reliabilityand effectivity <strong>of</strong> such devices.The alarm board is the most vital part <strong>of</strong>the whole receiving outfit. This apparatus shallconstantly control not only the circuit thermocontacts,battery and, in some cases, main firealarm box for transmitting the alarm <strong>to</strong> the firebrigade, but also in as far as possible its ownfunctions. That is <strong>to</strong> say, it must consist interalia <strong>of</strong> a larger or smaller number <strong>of</strong> relays, i. e.


R <strong>12</strong>90 Fig. 17. Fire Station Apparatus <strong>of</strong> the Kalarina Fire Brigade in the City <strong>of</strong> S<strong>to</strong>ckholm.Fig. 18 Telegraph Rogm <strong>of</strong> the Ostermalm Fire Brigade in the City <strong>of</strong> S<strong>to</strong>ckholm.132 —


Fig. 20 a. "Svenska Tcatern" lire in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm 29.6.1925. Alarm turned in 3.13 a. rSlage ceiling has collapsed but the ceiling joists over audi<strong>to</strong>rium are still intact.Fig.20 b. "Svenska Teatern" fire in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm 29.6.1925. Ceiling; over audi<strong>to</strong>rium has collapsed133


Fig. 19.small sensitive electrical magnets which are actuatedand balanced by weak electrical currentsand provided with variously connected electricalshort circuits and circuit breakers. The number<strong>of</strong> such relays must be made as small aspossible, at the same time as theabsolutely necessary organs SOT thereliable operation <strong>of</strong> the fire alarmmust be insisted upon. Furthermore,the design and construction<strong>of</strong> these relays must be the bestpossible, and all the relays <strong>of</strong> thefire alarm system must au<strong>to</strong>maticallycontrol the current. The mutualcombination <strong>of</strong> the relays isalso <strong>of</strong> great importance.The electric contacts <strong>of</strong> the alarmboard included in the fire alarmcircuit shall also be as few andreliable in operation as possible;thus preferably circuit-breakingcontacts or such as are closed when the systemis at rest, which consequently au<strong>to</strong>maticallycontrol the current and break the circuit whengiving alarm. A working contact, i. e. a contactwhich under normal conditions is open, is un-Fig. 21 a. Tallersall" fire in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm 18.3.1913. Alarm turned in 1.31 a. m.- 134 -


A further demonstration <strong>of</strong> the risk <strong>of</strong> leaving the fire <strong>to</strong> itself.135Door covered by sheetiron on both sides which has resisted the fire Iron door deformed by fire.Effects <strong>of</strong> fire on unprotected steel STRUCTURESFig. 21 b. "TATTERSALL" fire in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm 18.3.1913


eliable, as its contact surfaces are liable <strong>to</strong> becomeoxidized or covered with an insulatinglayer <strong>of</strong> dust, oil or the like which, with theweak currents employed, may not let throughthe current when wanted.The arrangements for res<strong>to</strong>ring the system aftera fire alarm has been given, or in case <strong>of</strong>line faults etc., should be simple and definite,and the connections properly guided, so as <strong>to</strong>nuke faulty connections impossible. After readjustmentthe alarm board shall plainly andpermanently indicate the fault which has madethe readjustment necessary.The au<strong>to</strong>matic fire alarm system devised andintroduced by Telefonaktiebolaget L. ML Ericssonhas been designed in the smallest detail withthe view <strong>to</strong> comply with the above demands forreliability. With same it has been found possible<strong>to</strong> produce the necessary functions withoutmaking the system dangerously complicated.Required functions in connection with givingfire alarm have been amply provided for, andthe system besides au<strong>to</strong>matically controls all thefaults which might prevent alarm being givenat the proper time. All parts <strong>of</strong> the system arethus constantly au<strong>to</strong>matically controlled bymeans <strong>of</strong> closed current, so that the faults <strong>of</strong>any kind whatever are immediately indicated assoon as that appear.The main features <strong>of</strong> the system have conduced<strong>to</strong> establish even greater reliability, whichis carried <strong>to</strong> a point always regarded as thehighest desideratum, namely the elimination <strong>of</strong>the effects <strong>of</strong> dangerous line failures, so thatthese, even if they should occur at the very momentthe alarm is <strong>to</strong> be given, cannot preventthe alarm from being transmitted. This timemoment,and the current impulses generated inconnection with same, may be very critical,especially if the circuit is very extensive and thusexposed <strong>to</strong> strains <strong>of</strong> different kinds in thecourse <strong>of</strong> years. The risk <strong>of</strong> line faults andether failures in a system <strong>of</strong> any kind is <strong>of</strong>course bound <strong>to</strong> increase in order as the systembecomes older.Even the sensitive thermo-contacts have beendesigned in a special way in order <strong>to</strong> obtain necessarycontrol. At the same time the degree<strong>of</strong> safety for producing the alarm impulses hasbeen quadrupled for a single thermo-contact, inaddition <strong>to</strong> which the different thermo-contactsin a certain section collaborate in giving thealarm.Space does not permit a more detailed accoun<strong>to</strong>f the special arrangements for detecting faults,giving alarm etc. The foregoing is merely intended<strong>to</strong> give an idea <strong>of</strong> the importance <strong>of</strong> au<strong>to</strong>maticfire alarm, and the technical demandssuch a system must comply with.—136 —


New Interlocking and Signalling Plant at Lund.By Ivar Larsson, Sitjiud Enyineer in the State Railways.The railway station at Lund was one <strong>of</strong> thefirst in Sweden <strong>to</strong> be equipped with interlockingand signalling installations. In the years1899—1901 there was erected a plant with twomechanical interlocking machines for the southpart <strong>of</strong> the station, and in 1901—1902 there waserected an interlocking machine in the northernpart, so that a complete plant was obtained thatwas equipped with those devices and arrangementsfor safeguarding trains and securing the work <strong>of</strong>the station service which were then consideredi>erfect. Signalling technics have, however, prosidiarycompany, the "Signalbolaget", received ancrder <strong>to</strong> supply the material and erect a completeelectric installation.This new installation embraces only one interlockingmachine. This has been located at thenorthern end <strong>of</strong> the station. The switch movementsthere are more numerous and more complicatedthan in the south part <strong>of</strong> the station, andit was in consideration <strong>of</strong> this circumstance thatthe place was selected.The cabin is on three floors. The ground-floorcontains the power plant for the interlocking Bin-Part <strong>of</strong> the station yard. The signal cabin on the right.gressed incessantly, and, when the station was rebuiltin the year 1927, the old plant was quiteantiquated. It was provisionally adapted <strong>to</strong> thenew station, and there was, <strong>of</strong> course, no impossibility<strong>of</strong> completing the same, but withoutdoubt a new structure was the only rational thing<strong>to</strong> be able <strong>to</strong> satisfy up-<strong>to</strong>-date requirements <strong>of</strong>safety and labour saving. For this reason a perfectlynew interlocking and signalling safety plantwas erected, following those modern lines andprinciples which have been the foundation <strong>of</strong> theplants erected by the State Railways in recentyears.Interior <strong>of</strong> Cabin.The L. M. Ericsson Company, through its subchine,a workshop for repairs and the heating installationfor the cabin. The first floor is reservedal<strong>to</strong>gether for relays and other auxiliaryinstruments, while the <strong>to</strong>p floor is the switch-roomproper. From the same a good view is obtained<strong>of</strong> the northern part <strong>of</strong> the station, but no viewcan be had <strong>of</strong> the central and southern parts <strong>of</strong>the station.The switch apparatus is manufactured with onlyelectric interlocking register: all locking and dependenciesare. therefore, carried out electrically.Previously a similar interlocking installation hadbeen erected by L. If. Ericsson on behalf <strong>of</strong> theState Railways, viz. at Hasslcholm (described in- 137 -


General plan <strong>of</strong> tracks, signits, points, and track circuits.this Review in 1927, Xos. 1—3). The machinesupplied for Lund is constructed on the same linesas that at Hassleholm, but the design had beenaltered by making use <strong>of</strong> the experiences gainedat Hassleholm. The whole machine is higher, sothat the levers are approximately on a level withthe elbow <strong>of</strong> an average-sized man. By this meansthe advantage <strong>of</strong> a more natural grip <strong>of</strong> the leversis gained. These levers are arranged in a row thesame as in L. If. Ericsson's older interlockingmachines. The shape <strong>of</strong> the handle on the leverhas been altered so as <strong>to</strong> present similarities <strong>to</strong> asmall door-handle. It has been possible <strong>to</strong> effectsuch grouping on the apparatus that every otherlever is a signal-lever and every other an interlockinglever. The signal-lever is in a normal positionwith its handle straight up. It can 1M?switched over <strong>to</strong> right or left (each movement70 2 ), thus being used for operating different signals.The switch-lever has in its normal positionthe handle obliquely downwards <strong>to</strong> the right, andon switching over it is turned 140° <strong>to</strong> the left.Particular care has been devoted <strong>to</strong> the developmen<strong>to</strong>f the design in so far that both the lever'shorizontal shaft, which is rigidly connected withthe handle, and the co-operating vertical contactshaftget a perfectly steady and exact motion, sothat make and break occurs with all desirableprecision. Control windows above the lever havebeen utilized in the following way. The switchmanis informed by a white or red signal-plate ifthe switch occupies a position coincident with thelever, and closes completely, or if such is not thecase. Besides, a blue pointer in the window <strong>of</strong> thelever indicates that the switch is blocked for changing.This pointer disappears when the switch isfree. A white or blue signal-plate in the windowsabove the signal-lever indicates if the lever is disengagedfor changing over or locked.The interlocking machine is in no way connectedwith any release instruments or the like operatedby the train dispatcher. The signalman must,therefore, himself lay the tracks and display the"clear" signal. This arrangement is consideredsuitable here, because safety measures have beenadopted for au<strong>to</strong>matic control that the tracks arefree from vehicles when a start-signal can be displayed.This system is preferable when the trafficin a station is in any way extensive. As, therefore,the opera<strong>to</strong>r on his own responsibility lays thetracks, it is important for him <strong>to</strong> be able <strong>to</strong> controlin a simple manner that the track is clear <strong>to</strong> orfrom an intended track when the start-signal isgiven. This has been done in such a way that theswitch installation is equipped with small auxiliaryinstruments in the shape <strong>of</strong> a push but<strong>to</strong>n switch,one for each track. On a sign-board l>elonging<strong>to</strong> each switch it is indicated which incoming oroutgoing signal is meant, as well as the number<strong>of</strong> the track <strong>to</strong> or from which a track is <strong>to</strong> be laid.Hefore the signal lever for a main signal becomesdisengaged for switching over, this push-but<strong>to</strong>nswitch must tie changed over. If the signal leverthen becomes free for switching over, the opera<strong>to</strong>ris sure that the points or switches are set for thevery track intended, i. e. he obtains a simple andeasily grasped control instead <strong>of</strong> having <strong>to</strong> examinewith meticulous care the position <strong>of</strong> the levers,in order <strong>to</strong> prevent shifting switches.On enamelled signs above the levers there aregiven the necessary directions for the positionwhich other levers must occupy <strong>to</strong> enable thelever <strong>to</strong> be operated, and by this means all thetrack-tables are set out on the very interlockingmachine.The installation is made for al<strong>to</strong>gether 80 levers,and was at the beginning fitted with 29 signallevers,31 switch-levers, 3 interlocking levers, 1bcom-lever, and 16 spare places. Its length is6.6 m. It is lacquered the ordinary deep-greencolour, and its appearance is smart and attractive.For the State Railway lines connected <strong>to</strong> it,double track line <strong>to</strong> Uppakra and Stangby, theblocking <strong>of</strong> the line is arranged by means <strong>of</strong> a3-field block instrument located at each gable <strong>of</strong>the machine.The illuminated track plan is set up separatelybehind the interlocking machine. On this planare set out the signal images <strong>of</strong> the main anddwarf signals, as well as the condition in the tracksections provided with track line. All instructionson the track plan take place by means <strong>of</strong> lampscountersunk behind separate index windows. Anoccupied track is marked by a lighted lamp in thetrack window, and a free track with an extinguishedlamp, an arrangement which on fairlylarge track-plans gives a better survey than if themore cus<strong>to</strong>mary opposite method were employed.All tracks (19 home and 19 outward tracks)are locked by track interlocking, and the release138139


is effected au<strong>to</strong>matically by the train. For emergencyrelease there are separate, sealed keys. Thetrack for the home roads are not locked until thetrain has reached the track-line immediately outsidethe home signals, i. e. it is approximately1400—<strong>12</strong>00 m. outside the appurtenant advancesignal. If an expected train has not reached thispoint, the signal can be taken up and the road releasedwithout having <strong>to</strong> break the seal and usingthe emergency key.With the exception <strong>of</strong> the interlocking group inthe north, the track area <strong>of</strong> the interlocking installationis equipped with complete track lines.These have been excluded in the north on accoun<strong>to</strong>f the expense, because the direct survey from theIncoming and outgoing signals at north end <strong>of</strong> yard.interlocking apparatus has been considered <strong>to</strong> constitutesufficient safety measures.The devices for actuating the switches are <strong>of</strong> anew design, and they are made with interior mechanicallocking, for which reason the hook- andlink-locks hither<strong>to</strong> employed for locking the pointcan be dispensed with. It is hoped by this means<strong>to</strong> counteract, inter alia, <strong>to</strong> some extent the difficultiesarising in case <strong>of</strong> a fall <strong>of</strong> snow. Theswitches are, in so far as circumstances permit,coupled in pairs <strong>to</strong> the same lever, and it happensin some instances that three mo<strong>to</strong>r actuating devices,two for switches and one for scotch block,are connected <strong>to</strong> the same lever. Both parallelcoupling and serial coupling have been employed.The entire number <strong>of</strong> switch and scotch blockactuating mechanisms is 49. There are no mechanismsfor local manipulation. Four interlockingmechanisms for merely locally operated switchesand scotch blocks are laid down.The entire station area connected with the interlockinginstallation is equipped with a completesystem <strong>of</strong> dwarf-signals. These are used not onlyfor interlocking motions but also for train movements.All switch roads are interlocked by thesesignals, and for the southern and central parts <strong>of</strong>the stations switches in front <strong>of</strong> switch-vehiclesare locked when the appurtenant dwarf-signal hasbeen passed, even if the signal in question is taken<strong>to</strong> s<strong>to</strong>p. As <strong>to</strong> the northern part <strong>of</strong> the station,which can be surveyed direct from the interlockingplant, no such locking has been employed, because,as has been stated here before, no tracklinesnecessary for this purpose have been putdown. The dwarf-signals are <strong>of</strong> the standard typeused by the State Railways, optical signals beingmade by two white lights which form a horizontalconnecting line at an angle <strong>of</strong> 45° or vertical. Forthe outward tracks the dwarf-signals have also<strong>to</strong> serve as outward signals. The circumstancethat a track is switched <strong>of</strong>f is shown by the verticalposition <strong>of</strong> the dwarf-signals. By this means onehas obtained safe signalling with the aim that thelocomotive driver will be able <strong>to</strong> check that thisoutward track is set and clear, without having <strong>to</strong>resort <strong>to</strong> outward signals for each track. We are,therefore, restricted <strong>to</strong> one outward signal for eachline, and also an inner outward signal <strong>of</strong> maintype near the main tracks in view <strong>of</strong> the trainspassing at a high speed.All main signals are light signals. Track signallingon the main home signals is done with one<strong>to</strong> three green lights. Besides, the home signalshows on signalling for a main line train whetherthere be a free passage or not. In the former casea white intermittent light is visible, in the lattercase a green intermittent light, <strong>of</strong> course also inboht cases a fixed green light. Tracks can be set<strong>to</strong> and from all seven pairs <strong>of</strong> rails for the StateRailway lines, whereas the trains <strong>of</strong> the crossingprivate railway can be signalled in and out ontracks 6 and 7 north and south, as well as in andout on track 7 in the south.On platform 1 near the station building are locatedrepeaters for the home and outward signals,so that the train dispatcher can check their interlocking.To facilitate the work <strong>of</strong> the train dispatcherin his clearing, there are also arranged— 140 —


at certain places separate repeat signals for themost commonly used outward tracks.One detail <strong>of</strong> the installation that may be speciallymentioned are the arrangements for the levelcrossings, which exist south <strong>of</strong> the station building,about 650 m. from the interlocking installation.The street is shut <strong>of</strong>f by means <strong>of</strong> electricallyoperated booms, which are operated fromthe interlocking plant. The booms are interlockedby the home and outward signals, so that there isno need <strong>to</strong> risk the booms being forgotten andthe trains are yet signalled along over an openroad. When the booms are lowered and a signalis set for a train <strong>to</strong> go ahead, the boom lever canat any moment whatsoever be returned <strong>to</strong> a positioncorresponding <strong>to</strong> raised booms. The boomsremain nevertheless in a dropped position, but theboom-mo<strong>to</strong>r obtains au<strong>to</strong>matically a current whenthe train has passed the level crossing. For thepurpose <strong>of</strong> warning street traffic (this place isvery busy occasionally) there have been set upspecial signals which by a powerful red light,visible even in daylight, show that the booms arebeing, or have been, lowered. These signals, oneoutside each room, show s<strong>to</strong>p already whenthe warning bell on the booms begin <strong>to</strong> ring,i. e. a good while before the booms themselvesbegin <strong>to</strong> drop. When the booms rise the signalsgo out as soon as the booms have been raisedsufficiently for allowing vehicular traffic <strong>to</strong> pass.These extra signals have proved <strong>to</strong> be <strong>of</strong> greatbenefit; no difficulties whatsoever have occurred<strong>to</strong> have the road traffic s<strong>to</strong>pped and the crossingcleared when the booms are lowered, though theyare operated from an interlocking cabin from whichthe street traffic cannot be observed. It is obviouslyso that when the way-farer knows that adrop-boom is operated mechanically so as <strong>to</strong> dropunrelentlessly, it inspires a great deal more respectthan a crossing-keeper close by, who, in case<strong>of</strong> need, can s<strong>to</strong>p the motion; in the latter casemany a way-farer is tempted <strong>to</strong> hum' on <strong>to</strong> thetrack, although the lowering <strong>of</strong> the boom hasstarted, in order <strong>to</strong> escape having <strong>to</strong> stand waitingbefore dropped booms.The interlocking installation is operated bothwith direct and alternating current. The City <strong>of</strong>Lund Electric Works supplies both kinds <strong>of</strong> current.3-phase alternating current, 50 periods, istaken from its alternating current net, with a highvoltage transformer erected within the stationarea, and on the secondary side 3X'30/100 55volt are drawn in the interlocking installation'sown transformer. The lamp voltages are 55 in thedwarf-signals and <strong>12</strong> volt in the main signals; thelatter voltage is obtained from local transformersset up in cabins close <strong>to</strong> the signals. The tracklinesare fed with alternating current, c:a 2 volttension between the rails, and this voltage is steppedup <strong>to</strong> about 4.5 volt for feeding the track-phase<strong>of</strong> the track-coils located in the interlocking cabin;the local phase is fed with 110 volt, the interlockingcontrol coils (the SS-coils) operate with twophases, both with 110 volt. Direct current (<strong>12</strong>volt) for operating currents for signal and releasecoils as well as block magnets is obtained from aPower station.metal rectifier (copper oxide rectifier). The interlockingmo<strong>to</strong>rs, made for <strong>12</strong>0 volt direct current,are fed direct from the city's direct current net.A converter is also set up in the power-room <strong>of</strong>the installation as a reserve. The latter is operatedwith direct current. It has been considered thatsince the city has very reliable arrangements forthe supply <strong>of</strong> direct current, a separate reservebatten' can be dispensed with. It has, therefore,been possible <strong>to</strong> carry out the entire power plantcomparatively simple. The energy consumption <strong>of</strong>the installation is about 32000 kwh alternatingcurrent and about 450 kwh direct current perannum.As has been stated in the preceding, the entireoperation is now confined <strong>to</strong> a single interlockingmachine. This concentration affects, as a matter<strong>of</strong> course, the signalling staff beneficially. In— 141 —


the old plant, with its three interlocking machines,11 men were on interlocking duty with the sametraffic conditions as now. The new interlockinginstallation has hither<strong>to</strong> been served by a staff <strong>of</strong>al<strong>to</strong>gether 6 men, but it is quite possible that thisnumber can be reduced when the staff have becomesufficiently accus<strong>to</strong>med and expert. Thesaving in personnel is thus at least 5 men. Theinstallation has cost 280000 Swedish kronor. Althoughthe motive for such installations in thefirst instance must be considered as a measure forsafeguarding the trains and bringing about sufficientspeed and rapidity in operating the station,the saving in personnel already effected in thiscase constitutes a very good contribution <strong>to</strong>wardspaying interest and amortisation on the initial investment.The installation was fitted up in the summer <strong>of</strong>1929, the work taking about 3 months, which mustbe looked upon as very smart. Electrically operatedspecial drilling machines and welding machinesare, as much as possible, used for the mechanicalwork <strong>of</strong> fitting up, and this work was done bythe State Railways themselves. When working ata very busy station it is <strong>of</strong> great advantage for therate at which the work is done, if electric currentis available and can be used for operating portablemachine <strong>to</strong>ols.Interior <strong>of</strong> relav room.H 1690View <strong>of</strong> station yard with level crossing. Station building on the right.142


On Impedance and Impedance Measurements as well as a Description<strong>of</strong> the Impedance Measuring set Manufactured bySvenska Radioaktiebolaget.By TorbernLaurent.I. Introduction.For telephone engineers who are not inclusivelyengaged in electrical measurements andthe mathematical dealing with the results <strong>of</strong>measurements, there arises <strong>of</strong>ten the need <strong>of</strong>hrief descriptions <strong>of</strong> various methods <strong>of</strong> measurementand calculation as a support or refresherfor the memory. Such descriptions may <strong>of</strong>tenalso be <strong>of</strong> value as a medium <strong>of</strong> instruction forless qualified personnel. In the present paperbrief descriptions <strong>of</strong> some devices generally usedin line impedance measurements as well as <strong>of</strong>the mathematical dealing with such impedancemeasurements have been summarized. The calculationsare, furthermore, in certain instancesillustrated by figures which, as is well knownfrom experience, many a time may make it easier<strong>to</strong> understand the methods.Special importance has been attached <strong>to</strong> thesuitability <strong>of</strong> the methods for practical purposes,and it has been shown how the measurements,and especially the calculations, may be simplified.The same views also form the basis for theconstruction <strong>of</strong> a new impedance measuring set,described in the last part <strong>of</strong> the paper, which ismanufactured only by Svenska Radioaktiebolaget.The principles <strong>of</strong> the instrument have previouslybeen published by the author in "TekniskaMeddelanden fran Kungl. Telegrafstyrelsen"(Technical Papers from the Telegraph Office)No. 4, 1925, and in "Elektrische NachrichtenTechnik", Volume 5, Part 5, 1928.The resistances r form a ratio 1:1, G is anaudio frequency oscilla<strong>to</strong>r supplying simple harmoniccurrent <strong>of</strong> the angular frequency φ, HTFa telephone receiver, N a variahle non-eapacitativeand non-inductive resistance, C a variablecondenser practically free <strong>of</strong> losses, and O, respectivelyO, switches. The measurement is effectedby varying the resistance N and the capacityC until a sound minimum is obtained inthe telephone receiver HTF.After setting the sound minimum the followingrelations hold good between the impedanceZ, expressed in amplitude Z and phase angleφ or resistance R and reactance X, as well as resistanceN and capacity C:For bridge-coupling according <strong>to</strong> figure 1 applies:the plus sign applies <strong>to</strong> switch position 2 andthe minus sign <strong>to</strong> switch position 1.For bridge coupling according <strong>to</strong> figure 2 applies:2. Impedance Measuring by Means <strong>of</strong> Resistanceand Capacity.Figures 1 and 2 show the bridge devices inmeasuring an impedance Z with a small respectivelylarge phase-angle.The plus sign applies <strong>to</strong> switch position 1 andthe minus sign <strong>to</strong> switch position 2.143


Fig. 2.Fig. 1.Sonic drawbacks or difficulties with thesemeasuring devices for practical measurementsin telephone technics may be pointed out.Mostly the bridge-coupling according <strong>to</strong> figure1 is made use <strong>of</strong>, and no matter whether theimpedance is <strong>to</strong> be expressed in \Z\ and φ or Rand X, comparatively difficult calculations arenecessary. The bridge-coupling according <strong>to</strong> figure2 is as a rule not resorted <strong>to</strong> unless thephase angle <strong>of</strong> the impedance is so great thatmeasuring with bridge-coupling according <strong>to</strong> figure1 is impossible because the resistance Ncannot be made indefinitely great. It thereforevery <strong>of</strong>ten happens that we obtain series <strong>of</strong>measurements made with different bridge-couplings,and, therefore, the uniformity in the calculationsis lost. Besides, it is <strong>of</strong>ten tiresome <strong>to</strong>have <strong>to</strong> change a measuring method in a measur-ing series, since the impedance <strong>of</strong> the objectmeasured occasionally is dependent upon thecurrent intensity.The capacity C consists as a rule <strong>of</strong> mica condensers,which by means <strong>of</strong> decades are interconnectedin various ways in such a mannerthat, <strong>to</strong>gether with a variable air condenser, theyform a continuously variable capacity. The capacityvalue should naturally be capable <strong>of</strong> beingdirectly read from the decade settings, withoutany conversions and corrections. Thiscalls for a certain adjustment <strong>of</strong> the mica condensers,which is particularly troublesome andexpensive.3. Impedance Measuring by Means <strong>of</strong> Resistanceand Self-induction.Another measuring device is based upon theuse <strong>of</strong> a variable self-induction. In fig. 3, whichshows the measuring device, the denominations144


, N, G, Z and HTF possess the same significanceas in figures 1 and 2. L is the variable selfinductionwith a loss-resistance a, which is balancedin the bridge by the equally great resistanceb.Measuring is carried out by varying the resistanceA' and the self-induction L until asound-minimum is obtained in the telephone receiverHTF. in which casethe plus sign applies <strong>to</strong> switch position 1 andthe minus sign <strong>to</strong> switch position 2.In measuring with this arrangement the impedanceas a rule is expressed by R and -Y, liecausethe relation between N and L, as well asR and X, is obviously remarkably simple. Forthis reason impedance measurement by self-inductionis generally preferred <strong>to</strong> impedancemeasurement by condenser.The variable self-induction consists as a rule<strong>of</strong> a variometer with an empirically graduatedscale. The practical disabilities or drawbackswith such a variometer are as follows:The variometer is large and cumbersome.The accuracy <strong>of</strong> measurement is adventuredby mechanical changes in the ro<strong>to</strong>r's suspensionin the sta<strong>to</strong>r.The variometer's open field does not permit theproximity <strong>of</strong> iron. E. g. the variometer cannotbe mounted on an iron rack or covered by aniron casing or the like.The variometer is subject <strong>to</strong> disturbances bymagnetic induction.These drawbacks or disabilities can be diminishedby certain special measures, but neverentirely eliminated.4. Calculating the Constants <strong>of</strong> a Telephone linefrom Open and Closed Circuit ImpedancesMeasured.By impedance measurements from one terminal<strong>of</strong> a telephone line it is possible <strong>to</strong> fully determinethe electrical characteristics <strong>of</strong> the line.Let us assume at first that the characteristics<strong>of</strong> the line are <strong>of</strong> interest <strong>to</strong> us for a certain angularfrequency φ only. We measure then theopen circuit impedance Z t and the closed circuitimpedance Zt between the branches <strong>of</strong> the lineat one terminal for this angular frequency, thebranches at the other terminal being open orshort-circuited.In accordance with a method <strong>of</strong> calculationwhich is deduced in the work "TelefonledningarsElektriska Egenskaper" (Electrical Qualities <strong>of</strong>Telephone lines) by H. Pleijel, we shall calculatefrom these impedances the different electricalqualities <strong>of</strong> the line.Assume that the amplitudes and phase angles<strong>of</strong> the two impedances are determined bymeasurements for the angular frequency OJ, viz.Fig. 3.145


The characteristic impedance Z. <strong>of</strong> the line iscalculated according <strong>to</strong> the equationsFor determining the propagation<strong>of</strong> the line we calculate firstconstantsBy calculation we getby which we obtain the attenuation bs <strong>of</strong> theline according <strong>to</strong> the equationorwhereWe now calculate the characteristics <strong>of</strong> theline according <strong>to</strong> equation (4)and the wave-length constant a fromorwhereand A' is a whole number which grows by leapswith increased frequency and an increasedlength <strong>of</strong> line.It is <strong>of</strong> a certain interest that the same calculationresult is obtained if we pu<strong>to</strong>rAccording <strong>to</strong> equation (5) we calculateAccording <strong>to</strong> equation (6) we may calculateFor determining in the above manner comparativelylarge line attenuations the calculationsmust be carried out with great accuracy.from which value the attenuation may be calculated:Example 1.For a copper line with a length <strong>of</strong>S =20.90 km.impedance measurements have been made withthe angular frequency φ = 5000 radians sec.from one terminal <strong>of</strong> the line, the followingresult being obtained:According <strong>to</strong> equation (7) we calculateFor such fairly low frequency and such fairlyshort line as in this example, the constant Kprobably is 0,146


ErgoIf the line is homogeneous the so-called primaryline constants, listed below, may be calculatedfrom the so-called secondary line constantsdetermined by the above calculations. The primaryline constants are:r = the resistance in ohms/km. double line.a = the leakage 1/ohm km. (= Siemens/km.):L = the self-induction in Henry/km. double line.C = the capacity in Farad/km.The relation between primary and secondaryconstants is:If we take out the primary constants fromthis system <strong>of</strong> equation we obtainorAccording <strong>to</strong> the equations (9) we obtainr = 5 ohms/km. double line.L — 2.43 m. H/km. double line.a = 1.05 • 10~ 6C = 0.00516 ,uF/km.mhos/km.These values are reasonable, which proves thatwe have selected a proper value for the constantK.An arbitrary apparatus composed <strong>of</strong> resistances,condensers and coils, with two input andtwo output terminals e. g. a transformer or anelectrical filter may be looked upon as a telephoneline with a certain characteristic impedanceand certain propagation constants,which are determined from open and closed circuitmeasurements in the same way as for atelephone line. Measurements carried out fromthe input and output terminals as a rule givedifferent characteristic impedances but, providedany possible ironcore coils in the apparatusare only lightly magnetised, the same propagationconstants are always obtained.5. Line Impedance as a Function <strong>of</strong> the MeasuringFrequency.Example 2.For the line in example 1 has been calculatedby whichThe characteristic impedance and the openand closed circuit impedances <strong>of</strong> a line as afunction <strong>of</strong> the measuring frequency are discussedin a paper "Matningar a Gotlandskabeln"(Measurements Made on the Gotland Cable), byJ. Skoglund in "Tekniska Meddelanden franKungl. Telegrafstyrelsen" (Technical Papersfrom the Telegraph Office) Xo. 7, 1921. Figure 44. 147


Fig. 4.is taken from this paper, and it renders in curveformmeasured impedances as a function <strong>of</strong> themeasuring frequency on a 16 km. long loadedcable.As we see, both the open and closed circuitimpedance vary periodically with rising frequency.This is the result <strong>of</strong> the superposition<strong>of</strong> the waves coming from the measuring end<strong>of</strong> the line, and those reflected at the far end,and returning <strong>to</strong> the measuring end. The samething is apparent from the equations <strong>of</strong> the openand closed circuit impedances.148


We are, therefore, in the first section, whereA = 0.At any rate, the constant A can clearly be determinedby measuring the open or closed circuitimpedance as a function <strong>of</strong> the frequency,and fix the section concerned from their periodicalvariations.The wave-length constant grows almost proportionally<strong>to</strong> the measuring frequency and, consequently,the functions cos 2 a s and sin 2asvary periodically between the values + 1 and— 1. The attenuation fi, on the other hand,grows comparatively slowly and the functionscosh 2 ps and sinh 2 fis are not periodical. Theopen and closed circuit impedances, therefore,van.- periodically between the values6. Approximative Equations for CalculatingAttenuation.It has been mentioned in chapter 4 that incalculating comparatively large line attenuationsthe calculations stated must be carried out withgreat care and accuracy. This entails a fairlytroublesome mathematical labour, which may,however, be saved by making use <strong>of</strong> the followingapproximative equation:As will be seen from fig. 4, the curves may bedivided in<strong>to</strong> sections between which the value schanges its sign. As will be seen, the value <strong>of</strong>the constant A depends upon in which sectionthe measuring frequency falls, and if this canbe judged, we are also able <strong>to</strong> determine thevalue <strong>of</strong> A' for the said frequency.The signs for the sections are as follows:1st section f positive, Z t > Z k , φ k >φt, K = 02nd » a negative, Z,\ < |ZJ, φ k > φt, K = 13rd • e positive, \Z,[


Fig. 5.If we measure the impedance from one terminal<strong>of</strong> a line terminated in its own impedancehut suffering from an inhomogeneity at a pointat the distance s from the measuring end, weohtain an impedance with the amplitudeFigure 5 shows curves for such impedances.If we plot curves which pass through the maximumand minimum points <strong>of</strong> the impedances(see the curves drawn with dashes), we obtaincurves with the equationswhere p and q are magnitudes that are determinedhy the nature <strong>of</strong> the inhomogeneity. Thisequation has the same character as the equations(10), and the impedance y therefore, variesperiodically.and the relation150


Fig. 6.can be calculated from these for an arbitraryfrequency.In calculating (ps + p) from the equations(14) and (15) we obtainobtainingoi in radian/secIf the inhomogeneity consists <strong>of</strong> a break onthe line or a short circuit between the branchesp = 0. The impedance curve consists in suchcase <strong>of</strong> an open or closed circuit impedance fora length s <strong>of</strong> the line, and for this length theattenuation bs can obviously be calculated bymeans <strong>of</strong> the equation (16).Example 4.Figure 6 shows the amplitude curve <strong>of</strong> ameasured closed circuit impedance on a 64.4km. long loaded cable, whose attenuation weare <strong>to</strong> calculate.According <strong>to</strong> the curves for Z im „ and Z^minwe calculate firstFrom the value obtained for n 0 - we thencalculate the attenuationobtainingφ in radian/sec (is in neper (i in neper/km.3000 0.73 0.01135000 0.76 0.01187000 0.79 0.0<strong>12</strong>3The value bs + p can in the same way be calculatedfor an arbitrary inhomogeneity according<strong>to</strong> the equation (16). In the next chapterwill be shown, how the distance s <strong>to</strong> the inhomo-151


geneity can be calculated from the amplitudecurve <strong>of</strong> the impedance. With a knowledge also<strong>of</strong> the attenuation per km. line j}, which, e. g.,can be determined from the amplitude curvefor the closed circuit impedance in accordancewith example 4, the attenuation <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneitycan be calculated and by thisor <strong>of</strong> an inhomogeneity in the self-induction<strong>of</strong> the line, we obtain that character for theamplitude curve <strong>of</strong> the impedance, which is apparentfrom curve B in fig. 5, i. e. the curvefor |yl max and y min diverges with rising frequency.For such inhomogeneityIf the inhomogeneity consists in a change <strong>of</strong>the characteristic impedance from Z <strong>to</strong> Z l at thepoint <strong>of</strong> inhomogeneity and the impedances arepractically purely ohmic and independent <strong>of</strong>frequency, we obtain that character <strong>of</strong> the amplitudecurse <strong>of</strong> the impedance which is apparentfrom the curve A in fig. 5, i. e. the curves ' y | mMand ] y ' min are running parallell. For such inhomogeneityis practicallyExample 5.The inhomogeneity represented by periodicalvariations <strong>of</strong> the amplitude curve A lies at thedistance a 4- 64.4 km. from the measuring end.The attenuation per kilometer is the same asfor the line in example 4. We are then able <strong>to</strong>calculate p according <strong>to</strong> equation (16 a).m2n 0 fis + p p3000i 095v^T= 0.720 1.23 0.5215205000 U^= 0.720 1.25 0.49lbOO7 000 v ^ = 0.735 1.28 0.4916boergo p is almost constant. The inhomogeneityis actually a change in the characteristic impedancefrom Z = 1350 ohm <strong>to</strong> Z 1 = 2900 ohm,brought about artificially. The latter characteristicimpedance is represented by a resistanceR = 2900 ohm. According <strong>to</strong> equation (17):which practically coincides with the p-valucscalculated from the amplitude curve A.If the inhomogeneity consists <strong>of</strong> an increaseor decrease <strong>of</strong> the capacity per km. <strong>of</strong> the line,wherefor the surplus or deficit δc in capacityandfor the surplus or deficit δL in self-induction.Example 6.The inhomogeneity represented by periodicalvariations in the amplitude curve B lies at thedistance S = 64.4 km. from the measuring end.The attenuation per km. is the same as for theline in example 4. We are then able <strong>to</strong> calculatep according <strong>to</strong> equation (16 a).a n 02δs + p p3000 j^jj = 0.869 1.68 0.955000 ^ ^ = 0.789 1.41 0.65lo20'000 !S? = 0.723 1.26 0.471 / 30The inhomogeneity consists in reality in a rise<strong>of</strong> the capacity per km. <strong>of</strong> the line, broughtabout artificially, by additionFrom equation (18) follows:o) K p3000 1300 • 3000 • 0.089 • 10~ 6 = 0.347 0.895000 1350 • 5000 • 0.089 • 10" 6 = 0.600 0.627000 1400 • 7000 • 0.089 • 10 « = 0.872 0.46which practically coincides with the /^-valuescalculated from the amplitude curve B.For a line with two capacitative inhomogeneitiesthe amplitude curve <strong>of</strong> the impedance assumesthe character shown by curve C in figure5. By introduction <strong>of</strong> the "inhomogeneity impedance",lines with several minor inhomoge-152


ncities can very easily be dealt with (see thepapers cited).In plotting amplitude curves for investigatinga line's homogeneity, the line must be terminatedso as <strong>to</strong> give as little reflexions as possible. Thetermination <strong>of</strong> the line should, therefore, havean impedance as nearly equal <strong>to</strong> the line's characteristicimpedance as possihle. As a suitabletermination may, by way <strong>of</strong> example, be connecteda balancing network made for the line.Example 7.From the amplitude curve in figure 6 <strong>of</strong> theclosed circuit impedance <strong>of</strong> a 64.4 km. long loadedcable line we obtain 6 maximum values betweenthe angular frequencies ω = 3450 andω = 8050. The distances between the consecutivemaximum and minimum values appear<strong>to</strong> be almost equal. We may then assume thatthe function m is constant within the said frequencylimits and according <strong>to</strong> equation (20)we get8. Localising Inhomogeneities from AmplitudeCurves for Measured Line Impedance.As has already been stated, we are able <strong>to</strong>determine the location <strong>of</strong> the inhomogeneityfrom measured impedance curves. Since an arbitraryfault on the line as a rule entails an inhomogeneityon the line, we are able <strong>to</strong> localiseline-faults <strong>of</strong> an arbitrary nature by means <strong>of</strong>impedance measurements. The theoretical basisfor localising inhomogeneities has been dealtwith in the papers cited in the previous chapter.If ω t and ω2 are the frequencies corresponding<strong>to</strong> two consecutive maximum or minimum values<strong>of</strong> the amplitude curve, it holds good that thedistance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneityExample 8.The amplitude curve C in figure 5, which isplotted for a line <strong>of</strong> the same nature as inexample 7, shows two inhomogeneities. In calculatingthe distance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneity whichcorresponds <strong>to</strong> the shorter frequency distancesbetween the amplitude values we obtainaccording <strong>to</strong> example 7where ip' is a function. If this function is known,the distance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneity can consequentlybe calculated. From the equation (19)it is evident that the distance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneityis greater the shorter the frequency distancebetween the consecutive maximum or minimumvalues <strong>of</strong> the impedance curve.In order <strong>to</strong> determine the function 1/ we plotan open or closed circuit impedance curse fora line <strong>of</strong> the nature in question and with aknown length » x . The frequency distancesw 2 — w, between the maximum or minimumvalues <strong>of</strong> the impedance are calculated from thecurve, and by thisby which according <strong>to</strong> equation 19:or(The actual distance was 64.4 km.)In calculating the distance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneitywhich corresponds <strong>to</strong> the greater frequencydistances between the amplitude values we obtainand153(The actual distance was 32.2 km.)In the case <strong>of</strong> loaded cables, it is impossible<strong>to</strong> determine the distance <strong>to</strong> the inhomogeneity


with any greater accuracy than one coil section,i. e. approximately 2 km.9. Localising Cross-talk by Means <strong>of</strong> ImpedanceMeasurement.In accordance with a method published in thepaper "Mc<strong>to</strong>d for uppmiktning av laget av enoverhorning mellan tvenne ledningar" ("Methodfor Measuring the Position <strong>of</strong> Cross-talk betweentwo Lines"), by E. Fridh, in "Tekniska Meddelandenfran Kungl. Telegrafstyrelsen", No. 3,1926, localisation <strong>of</strong> cross-talk can be accomplishedby means <strong>of</strong> impedance measurements.Figure 7 shows diagramatically the measuringdevice: An impedance curve for line I is plottedwith the measuring bridge (R, HTF, X). Theaudio frequency oscilla<strong>to</strong>r G, which supplies themeasuring current <strong>to</strong> the potentiometer P alsosends out a disturbing current on line II. Atthe cross-talk point this current causes a disturbanceon line I, which appears as an inhomogeneityin the impedance curve. In order <strong>to</strong> allowthe periodical variations in the impedance curve,which correspond <strong>to</strong> the disturbance, <strong>to</strong> becomemore prominent, impedance measurements arecarried out both with and without any interferingcurrent on line II.The difference between these two measurementsis al<strong>to</strong>gether due <strong>to</strong> the disturbance, andcan be made great relatively <strong>to</strong> the impedanceby making the measuring current small in relation<strong>to</strong> the interfering current by means <strong>of</strong> thepotentiometer P.The calculations are carried out in the sameway as in localising inhomogeneities. In thiscase a value for S x («, oij) must be used, whichis the mean value between the S t (w, — ojj) valuesfor the lines I and II, e. g. calculated from closedcircuit impedance curves plotted for each line.10. Impedance Adaptation.At junctions between two telephone lines <strong>of</strong>different kinds or at junctions between a telephoneline and a subscriber's apparatus, forexample, a greater or smaller fraction <strong>of</strong> the telephonecurrents is generally reflected. This reflexionis always detrimental <strong>to</strong> the transmission<strong>of</strong> speech, the result being additional attenuationand dis<strong>to</strong>rtion <strong>of</strong> the speech transmitted. Thisholds good particularly in respect <strong>of</strong> long telephonelines equipped with amplifiers. As a ruleit is, therefore, a problem in telephone engineeringalways <strong>to</strong> arrange the lines and apparatusin such a way that the reflexions are reducedas much as possible.154


The relation between the magnitude <strong>of</strong> the reflectedcurrent and that reaching the point <strong>of</strong>reflexion is:where Z x and Z, are the characteristic impedances<strong>of</strong> two interconnected lines or Z x thecharacteristic impedance <strong>of</strong> a line which is connected<strong>to</strong> an apparatus <strong>of</strong> an arbitrary kind withthe input impedance Z 2 .We assume that the difference in phase betweenthe impedances Z, and Z, is q\ the relationbetween the impedances may then be representedby the vec<strong>to</strong>r diagram as per figure 8.forThe reflexion disappears completely when alsoif> = 0.We must, therefore, endeavour <strong>to</strong> get theamplitudes <strong>of</strong> the two impedances as equal aspossible and also the difference in phase angleas small as possible.The question remains, however, how the impedances<strong>of</strong> lines and instruments may be altered,so that impedance matching is attained at thepoints <strong>of</strong> interconnection. As a rule neither linesnor instruments are altered directly, as thismostly encounters insurmountable practical difficulties.The way, therefore, is <strong>to</strong> introduceapparatus which are capable <strong>of</strong> effecting moreor less good impedance matching in such cases.We have such an apparatus in the transformer.Figure 9 shows diagrammatically impedancematching between the impedances Z x and Z 2 byFig. 8.According <strong>to</strong> the cosinus theorem:We put this expression =the denominationV'y and introduceand obtain thenIn order <strong>to</strong> make the reflexions as small aspossible, we must make y as small as possible.If y is derived in respect <strong>of</strong> )) we obtain:means <strong>of</strong> a transformer with a ratio <strong>of</strong> turns <strong>of</strong>1 :n from the terminals I, 2 <strong>to</strong> the terminals 3, 4.We assume that the transformer is an ideal one,i. e. that the shunt impedance between the linebranches and the series impedance in the linebranches caused by the transformer, may be ignored.As a matter <strong>of</strong> fact, we can design andbuild transformers in respect <strong>of</strong> which this holdsgood approximately, or in which the relationbetween the series impedance and the shuntimpedance is adapted in such a manner that thesame result is attained.If we measure the impedances from the terminals,1, 2 <strong>to</strong>wards the transformer we shallthen obtain an impedancefrom which it will be seen that the minimumreflexion isand if we perform the same measurement fromthe terminals 3, 4 we obtain155


n is, however, a scalar magnitude from whichit follows thatAccording <strong>to</strong> the preceding we obtain a minimum<strong>of</strong> reflexions at the terminals 1, 2 and3, 4 ifbe connected with an unloaded undergroundcable. By loading the cable it is, however, possible<strong>to</strong> alter its characteristic impedance insuch a way that it coincides better with that <strong>of</strong>the overhead line, and the addition <strong>of</strong> suitableloading coils may, therefore, occasionally be anappropriate means for bringing about good impedanceadaption. (See the paper "Pupiniseringav inledningskablar" ("Loading Terminal Cables"),by A. Holmgren, in "Tekniska meddelandenfran Kungl. Telegrafstyrelsen", No. 6 b—7,1924.)and this gives the condition for the minimum <strong>of</strong>reflexions, viz.We are obviously unable <strong>to</strong> eliminate by meretransforming those reflexions which are causedFig. 10.by a difference in the phase angle between theimpedances Z, and Z.,. Nevertheless, telephonelines as a rule have small phase angles, makingthe differences in phase angles also small. Sufficientlygood impedance matching is thereforeobtained by mere transforming.Figure 10 shows repeating coils, manufacturedby the Svenska Radioaktiebolagct, which, interalia, are used for impedance matching.If the characteristic impedances <strong>of</strong> two connectedlines do not have the same impedancefrequencycurve, the impedance can be matchedby repeating coils for a single frequency only.Such a case occurs when an overhead line is <strong>to</strong>11. Line Balancing.In line balancing we are faced by the problem<strong>of</strong> designing by means <strong>of</strong> resistances, condensersand possibly, self-induction coils, an impedancenet whose impedance for all important frequencieswithin the voice range is as far as possibleequal <strong>to</strong> the input impedance <strong>of</strong> the telephoneline. This line balance and the line itself areconnected <strong>to</strong> the same hybrid coil in a telephonerepeater.From the preceding it is obvious that the inputimpedance <strong>of</strong> a telephone line is determinedboth by the wave outgoing on the line and thewaves reflected at the inhomogeneities <strong>of</strong> theline and at the other terminal. The outgoingwave may be balanced with a line-balance whoseimpedance is, as far as ever possible, equal <strong>to</strong>the characteristic impedance <strong>of</strong> the line. When,for example, an overhead line is led in<strong>to</strong> the stationby a terminal cable, near-by reflexions mayoccur. These reflexions may be balanced byconnecting before the line-balance an artificialline with, as far as possible, the same electricalcharacteristics as those <strong>of</strong> the terminal cable.On account <strong>of</strong> the attenuation <strong>of</strong> the line,which the reflected currents have <strong>to</strong> pass, distantreflexions are less noticeable in the input impedance<strong>of</strong> the line than near-by ones. Such reflexionscannot without very great practical difficultiesbe balanced. Since from all points <strong>of</strong>view it is better <strong>to</strong> try directly <strong>to</strong> reduce theline reflexions <strong>to</strong> a minimum, efforts are nevermade <strong>to</strong> balance reflexions from distant points.Often the reflexions are also variable, due <strong>to</strong>the fact that at the far end <strong>of</strong> the line other linesand instruments with different electrical characteristicsare alternatelv connected, and even156


the line itself may by reason <strong>of</strong> climatic changesbe subject <strong>to</strong> periodcial changes.In order <strong>to</strong> calculate a line-balance whichreproduces the characteristic impedance <strong>of</strong> theline, we must know the primary line constants(e. g. obtained from open and closed circuitimpedance measurements) and also, in the case<strong>of</strong> loaded line, the self-induction <strong>of</strong> the loadingcoils and the coil spacing.The characteristic impedance <strong>of</strong> an overheadline can with fairly good approximation be re-are the primary line constants, including theself-induction and resistance <strong>of</strong> the coils, andS is the coil spacing and d the length <strong>of</strong> cablefrom the beginning <strong>of</strong> the line <strong>to</strong> the first loadingcoil in km., we obtain the following dimensioningformulae:When the line-balance is assembled, its impedanceshould be measured and compared withthe measured input impedance <strong>of</strong> the line. Ifthe coincidence is poor, either the line-balanceor the line is defective. The former is testedby checking the elements constituting the linebalance, and the latter by DC or AC linemeasurements.The relation between the detrimental currentreturning <strong>to</strong> the amplifier and that sent out onthe line is determined by the expressionFig. 11.produced by a resistance R in series with a condenserK (see figure 11), whereandL, C and r are the primary line constants.A fairly short unloaded terminal cable beforethe overhead line may with good approximationbe reproduced by a T-device (see fig. 11) withtwo resistances g'2 and a capacity rj, dimensionedin such way, that Q = <strong>to</strong>tal resistanceand t) = the <strong>to</strong>tal capacity <strong>of</strong> the cable.The characteristic impedance <strong>of</strong> a loaded linemay, for example, be reproduced by a Hoyt-balancesuch as shown in fig. <strong>12</strong>. If L, C and rwhere Z L is the input impedance <strong>of</strong> the line andZ B the impedance <strong>of</strong> the line balance.Assume for a moment that the input impedance<strong>of</strong> the line equals Z B . The balance isthen complete and no currents return in<strong>to</strong> theamplifier. As <strong>to</strong> reflexions, the amplifier thenhas an apparent interior resistance = Z B .Suppose now that the input impedance <strong>of</strong> theline is Z L . In this case a reflexion occurs betweenthe amplifier and the line, determined bythe above term, and the reflected current is justthat one returning in<strong>to</strong> the amplifier.The balancing problem can, therefore, be dealtwith as a reflexion problem, where it is a question<strong>of</strong> diminishing the reflexions between theline and the line balance. According <strong>to</strong> chapterFig. <strong>12</strong>.10 we are then able immediately <strong>to</strong> state thatZ L shall, as far as possible, be equal <strong>to</strong> Z B \and that the difference in phase angle betweenthem shall be as small as possible. We assume157


that ZL is almost equal <strong>to</strong> Z B and that thesaid difference in phase angle, which we denominateq, is small.We are then able <strong>to</strong> writeThe amplitude <strong>of</strong> the input impedance <strong>of</strong> theline or the impedance <strong>of</strong> the line-balance thusappears as denomina<strong>to</strong>r in equation (25), andwe are consequently forced <strong>to</strong> calculate the amplitudein those instances where the impedancesZi and Z B are expressed in resistance and reactance.If we express equation (25) in amplitudes\Zj\ and \Z B and,difference in phase angleq, (expressed in arc measure) the equation assumesthe following simple appearance:We are thus able <strong>to</strong> judge the conformity betweena line and its line-balance by two terms,one merely containing the amplitude relation\Znand the other merely the difference in phase1**1angle ^.<strong>12</strong>. How Should an Impedance be Expressed inthe Most Appropriate Manner?From chapters 4 and 6 we find that by calculatingthe constants <strong>of</strong> a line the simplest wayis <strong>to</strong> have the impedance expressed in amplitudeand phase angle; from chapter 7, that amplitudecurves can be used for calculating the attenuation<strong>of</strong> the line and the magnitude <strong>of</strong> inhomogeneities;from chapter 10, that we arechiefly interested in the impedance amplitudes,when it is a question <strong>of</strong> impedance matching;and from chapter 11, that the impedances arel>est expressed in amplitude and phase angle injudging the conformity between a line and itsline-balance.There exists, therefore, an actual need <strong>to</strong> obtainmeasured impedance expressed in amplitudeand phase angle, which in no instance can beasserted about impedance expressed in reactanceand resistance. By impedance measurements ishere not meant measurements <strong>of</strong> resistance, capacityand self-induction.The fact that in spite <strong>of</strong> this we generally expressimpedance in reactance and resistance issimply due <strong>to</strong> the trouble and difficulty in conversingthe bridge readings <strong>of</strong> the impedancemeasurement bridges now generally used (seechapters 2 and 3) in<strong>to</strong> impedance expressed inamplitude and phase angle, while resistance andreactance can be easily obtained.This is, <strong>of</strong> course, decisive in such cases wherethe impedance not necessarily has <strong>to</strong> be expressedin amplitude and phase angle, e. g. inlocalising inhomogeneities and cross-talk, in accordancewith chapters 8 and 9, in which casethe calculations can as well be made from theperiodical variations in resistance and reactance.A natural consequence is also that an endeavourhas been made <strong>to</strong> get along with impedance expressedin resistance and reactance even in suchcases where impedance expressed in amplitudeand phase angle would have been more valuable.The problem <strong>of</strong> measuring directly with asimple bridge the amplitude <strong>of</strong> the impedanceas well as a measure <strong>of</strong> its phase angle is, however,now solved both theoretically and technicallyby the Impedance Meter Type IM 329manufactured by Svenska Radioaktiebolaget.This improved measuring method makes itpossible without inconvenience <strong>to</strong> express an impedancedirectly in amplitude and phase angle,which, consequently, in future should be normallyemployed.13. The Principles <strong>of</strong> the Svenska Radioaktiebolaget'sImpedance Measuring Set.Fig. 13 illustrates the principles <strong>of</strong> the measuringbridge. The various elements are given thefollowing denominations, which, simultaneously,indicate their electrical magnitudes:R two equal ratio resistances, A T a variableresistance, X the unknown impedance, G anaudio frequency oscilla<strong>to</strong>r with the output voltageV and the angular velocity' <strong>to</strong>, ML p an aircore transformer with the primary self-inductionL p and a variable mutual inductance M, K'an impedance and HTF a telephone receiver.Measuring is done by setting the resistance Nand the mutual impedance M for sound minimumin the telephone receiver HTF. The currentin the receiver is in such a case practically equal<strong>to</strong> zero. A current I., passes then through theresistance N and the impedance X. a current /,158


The resistance X, therefore, becomes equal <strong>to</strong>the amplitude |A'| <strong>of</strong> the impedance and thephase angle ^ can be calculated from the valuesfor ω, M and A.The mutual impedance can be made both negativeand positive (e. g. by inversion <strong>of</strong> the secondarywinding <strong>of</strong> the transformer and the setting<strong>of</strong> the bridge can, therefore, be made forboth negative and positive phase angles tp.The calculation <strong>of</strong> the phase angle can beFig. 13.through the two resistances R, and a current l tthrough the impedance A" and the primarywinding <strong>of</strong> the transformer ML pIf we assume that the impedance A" is <strong>of</strong> sucha nature that the current l t is in phase with thecurrent l x the induced E.M.F. ω 3// 3 in the secondarywinding <strong>of</strong> the transformer will be inphase quadrature <strong>to</strong> the current /j and <strong>to</strong> thepotential drop /?/,. The vec<strong>to</strong>r diagram shownin fig. 14 is then obtained, q: representing thephase angle <strong>of</strong> the impedance X.From this vec<strong>to</strong>r diagram follows immediatelythatandIf A" is the impedance value <strong>of</strong> the impedanceA connected in series with the primary impedance<strong>of</strong> the transformer, which is mainlydue <strong>to</strong> the inductive resistance <strong>of</strong> the self-inductionL,„ we obtain the relationby which the above equations becomeFig. 14.further simplified if the impedance A (whichis obviously pure ohmic) for all measuring frequenciesis set on a value that is proportional<strong>to</strong> ω.If, therefore,where F is a constant, the equations (27) assumethe appearancewhere the phase angle is determined merely bythe mutual inductance M.14. The Practical Design <strong>of</strong> the Svenska Radioaktiebolaget'sImpedance Measuring Set.Fig. 15 shows the exterior appearance <strong>of</strong> theSvenska Radioaktiebolaget's Impedance MeasuringSet, and fig. 16 the arrangements below thepanel. Fig. 17 shows the markings and designationson the front <strong>of</strong> the panel, and fig. 18the circuit diagram.159


Fig. 15.Fig. 16.160


The resistance N consists <strong>of</strong> a decade resistancevariable by means <strong>of</strong> four decades between0 and 11110 ohm with steps <strong>of</strong> 1 ohm.If it is desired <strong>to</strong> measure impedances beyond11110 ohm or with greater accuracy than 1 ohm.the short circuit plate between the terminalsmarked "N" should be removed and an additionalresistance connected between said terminals.This resistance is then connected in serieswith the decade resistance N.The design and construction <strong>of</strong> the transformer(ML,, in fig. 13), whose appearance willbe seen from fig. 10, is very interesting. Theprimary is a non-capacitive winding on a ringmade <strong>of</strong> insulating material, giving a homogeneous<strong>to</strong>roidal-shaped magnetic field. The secondarywinding is without inter-winding capacityarranged outside the primary and is providedwith a series <strong>of</strong> terminals which are connected<strong>to</strong> the contacts <strong>of</strong> the four decade switchesmarked '. tg ^- (see fig. 17).The mutual inductance may, therefore, bevaried by connecting <strong>to</strong> the telephone receivercircuit a variable fraction <strong>of</strong> the secondarywinding. The secondary is inversed in relation<strong>to</strong> the receiver by means <strong>of</strong> the switch marked*qj*, reversing the sign <strong>of</strong> the mutual inductance.The air core transformer, which replaces thedecade condenser in the bridge according <strong>to</strong>fig. 1 and 2 or the variometer in the bridge according<strong>to</strong> fig. 3, possesses the following advantages.1) The air core transformer can be mademuch smaller than both the decade condenserand the variometer.2) The air core transformer can without anydifficulty be adjusted with the desired precision.3) In contradistinction <strong>to</strong> the variometer theair core transformer does not send out any exteriormagnetic field, thus obviating magneticdisturbances on near-by instruments.4) For the same reason the air core transformeris insusceptible <strong>to</strong> iron masses in the vicinity,which may endanger measurements madewith a variometer.Fig. 17.161


The air core transformer can, therefore, withoutany disadvantages be mounted on an ironrack or covered with an iron casing. This willbe the case when the instrument is mounted ontest-racks.5) For the same reason the impedancemeasuring set can be protected against exteriormagnetic disturbances, because the instrumentcan he covered with a protective iron casing.6) The adjustment <strong>of</strong> the air core transformeris not endangered by mechanical wearand tear, as, for example, is the case with variometerswhere the bearings are gradually worn.In chapter 13 is stated that the impedance A"(see fig. 13) must be <strong>of</strong> such a nature that thecurrent /., is in phase with the current /,. Thisis done by adjusting the handles marked "ffor the frequency / which is <strong>to</strong> be used for themeasurement. The switches "/" are both providedwith a frequency scale.The magnitude <strong>of</strong> the impedance A (see equation28) can by means <strong>of</strong> the handle marked"f'" be varied for 10 different values, selectedwith regard <strong>to</strong> 10 <strong>of</strong> the most important measuringfrequencies, viz. 400, 500, 600, 800, 1000,<strong>12</strong>00, 1400, 2000. 2800 and 3600 cycles/sec. andthe positions <strong>of</strong> the handle marked "f" aremarked with these frequencies. If we exchangeFig. 18.— 162 —the short circuit plate between the terminalsA' for a variable resistance, an arbitrary valuecan be added <strong>to</strong> the impedance A'.The dimensioning <strong>of</strong> the impedance A is suchthat a correction for the slight error which occursthrough capacity in the air core transformeris considered.The unknown impedance is connected <strong>to</strong> theterminals marked "X"; an audio frequency oscilla<strong>to</strong>r<strong>to</strong> the terminals markedU GEN"; and atelephone receiver <strong>to</strong> the terminals markedU HTF".In order <strong>to</strong> obtain more accurate adjustmen<strong>to</strong>f the handles marked u f the switch marked"AAA. MATS" is placed in the position "AAA"(calibration), a sound minimum thus being obtainedin the telephone receiver if the saidhandles are properly adjusted. By this meanswe obtain simultaneously a check on the measuringfrequency. In measuring, the said switchmust be in position U MATX" (measuring).15. Measurements.After every alteration in the measuring frequencyf the handles u f" are adjusted for thisfrequency. As has already been pointed out, adjustmen<strong>to</strong>f the said handles can be made more


safely l>y means <strong>of</strong> adjustment for a soundminimumwith the switch "KAL. MATN* in position*KAL* (calibration), inasmuch as we obtainat the same time a check on the measuringfrequency.The switch "KAL. MATX" is put in<strong>to</strong> position"MATff and the measuring is done by adjusting. . • f w"a sound-niinimum with the decades —— tg —and "A". The switch "m", whose positions arealso marked with the sign <strong>of</strong> the phase angle <strong>of</strong>the object <strong>to</strong> be measured, may have <strong>to</strong> be reversed<strong>to</strong> enable sound-minimum adjustment.From the adjustment <strong>of</strong> the decades "AT" weread directly the amplitude <strong>of</strong> the measured impedance,and from the adjustments <strong>of</strong> the de-T 9* r


Fig. 1.Fig. 2. Fig. 3.


Electric Interlocking Plant at Vanneboda Station.By G.Pervall.At the end <strong>of</strong> the year 1927 tenders were in-.. vited for an interlocking plant for VannebodaStation, on the Grangesberg—OxelosundRailway. The station, whose track system isshown on the sketch, fig. 1, is a junction for thelarge ore shipments from the various ore fieldsin the Bergslagen District <strong>to</strong> the port <strong>of</strong> Oxelosund,and serves as a junction for passengertraffic <strong>to</strong> and from the surrounding part <strong>of</strong>Bergslagen. The tender concerned a mechanicalplant, but for purposes <strong>of</strong> comparison tendersfor an electric plant were also invited, becauseon account <strong>of</strong> the size and traffic conditions <strong>of</strong>the station it was impossible <strong>to</strong> decide withoutany further ado which type <strong>of</strong> plant would bemost advantageous. The railway has alreadya large number <strong>of</strong> mechanically operated plants,which have been quite satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry ami withwhich the staff are quite conversant. The stationswhich have been equipped with such installationsare, however, smaller than Vanneboda.On the other hand, there did not existany electrically operated plant, and, consequentlyno staff capable <strong>of</strong> running such.In order <strong>to</strong> get an economically practicablemechanical inlerloeking plant, a locking machine<strong>of</strong> detached crank type and with signals <strong>of</strong> thesemaphore type was also a sine qua non forVanneboda. The scheme for the electrical interlockingplant also necessitated its being capable<strong>of</strong> being housed in a low building, suitably locatedbetween the platform tracks and in sucha way that the train dispatcher would be personallyable <strong>to</strong> look after it in the course <strong>of</strong> hisduties, whereas for shunting purposes the centrallyoperated points would be manipulatedby local devices. To facilitate inspection <strong>of</strong> thepermanent way tracks were <strong>to</strong> be put down atboth ends <strong>of</strong> the station for checking whetherthe line was open and setting the signals againstthe trains. The signals in this instance were<strong>to</strong> be made in the shape <strong>of</strong> daylight signals withthe lamps <strong>of</strong> the main signals normally fed fromthe existing <strong>12</strong>7-volt alternatic current electriclight net. The mo<strong>to</strong>r current battery was <strong>to</strong>serve as an emergency power source in case <strong>of</strong>a breakdown in the supply <strong>of</strong> alternating current.Fig. 2 and 3 represent sketches on the samescale, showing the two frames suggested. Thelength <strong>of</strong> the electric interlocking machine (fig.3), a normal 24-lever frame, is 1950 mm., andthe length <strong>of</strong> the crank apparatus (fig. 2) is5040 mm. As will be seen from the sketch, theelectric interlocking machine contains 7 spareplaces for future enlargement, whereas the possibility<strong>of</strong> spares in the crank apparatus islimited <strong>to</strong> 2 cranks and one track lever.On comparing the two types <strong>of</strong> plant the railwaymanagement, after the costs for certainwork which the railway itself was <strong>to</strong> carry out,e. g. laying down <strong>of</strong> line-drums etc. for the mechanical,and the erection <strong>of</strong> a cabin for the electricalplant, that the initial costs <strong>of</strong> the twoplants were on the whole equal. It was found,however, that the train dispatcher himself wasnot <strong>to</strong> manipulate the mechanical interlockingplant, but a separate opera<strong>to</strong>r or opera<strong>to</strong>rs would— 164 —


F 1584 Fig. 4. Interlocking Machine.be required for this purpose, enchancing the runningor working expenses <strong>of</strong> the mechanical plantas compared with the electrical. The railwaymanagement consequently decided <strong>to</strong> have theelectrical plant on account <strong>of</strong> its being the moreeconomical. The choice proved its merits alreadyfrom the beginning inasmuch as a desideratum<strong>of</strong> laying down further tracks couldeasily be accomplished, which would have beenimpossible if a mechanical plant had been erected,because the local capacity <strong>of</strong> the crank-apparatusdesign in this respect was already fullyutilized.From the machine, shown in fig. 4 are operatedthose points which are <strong>to</strong> occupy different positionsfor the most frequently occurring tracksand are locked by the aid <strong>of</strong> electrical locking devices,fig. 5 the points and switcheswhich are operated locally and requirelocking for the varioustracks. The locking devices areprovided with point contacts, theyare integral parts <strong>of</strong> the apparatus,and are connected with lock-magnetson appurtenant lever in sucha way that the latter cannot be pu<strong>to</strong>ver unless the points are in alcckable and proper position.Out <strong>of</strong> the points 23, 24 and26 located immediately outside theinterlocking plant, as well as thescotch blocks Sp IV and Sp V thetwo scotch blocks and point 23are provided with point contactswhich are connected with a relayequipped with an optical signal inthe machine, enabling control <strong>of</strong>the proper position when a trackdepending upon the said pointand scotch block is <strong>to</strong> be put over.Points 24 and 26, which are facingpoints for the said track, arelocked by key-locks which cooperatenot only reciprocally butalso with a key-lock on <strong>to</strong>p <strong>of</strong> theinterlocking machine, this keylockbeing provided with contactsfor obtaining the necessary electricaldependence between thepoints and the signal lever corresponding<strong>to</strong> the track.As has been stated in the preceding, the mainsignals are erected as electric daylight signalsand are controlled by means <strong>of</strong> signal controllamps placed in separate housings on <strong>to</strong>p <strong>of</strong> theinterlocking machine (see fig. 3 and 4). Toprevent the lamp in the light signal from becomingextinguished, the control lamp is providedwith a shunt-resistance. Fig. 6 showsthe h ome signals B 1/2 and C 1/2/3, which aremade with masts <strong>of</strong> reinforced concrete. Au<strong>to</strong>maticbells with the use <strong>of</strong> insulated tracks havealready previously been arranged at the twolevel crossings at the outer ends <strong>of</strong> the station.These tracks have also been utilized in the plantfor the purpose <strong>of</strong> being able <strong>to</strong> control <strong>to</strong>getherwith tracks specially laid down for the same,that the parts <strong>of</strong> the tracks at the outer ends <strong>of</strong>R 15S3 Fig. 5. Electrical Locking Device with Locally Operated Scotch Block.— 165 —


R 1588 Fig. 6. Home Signals B 1/2 and C 1/2/3.the station are clear <strong>of</strong> vehicles. All track linescan be controlled by the track relays, Scy, Scietc., provided with optical signals, these relaysbeing housed in the casing on <strong>to</strong>p <strong>of</strong> the machine.The relays are under normal conditions currrentless,but are supplied with current via the pedalcontact which is an integral part <strong>of</strong> the machine,when the tracks have <strong>to</strong> be controlled. The necessarydependence is obtained by contacts onthe track relays, so that no signal can be set forclear if a track-line on the corresponding trackis occupied by vehicles. The track-lines laiddown through the centrally operated pointsare also used for locking a respective point-lever<strong>to</strong> prevent its change over while any vehicle ispassing the point or is in it.The direct current necessary for the plant issupplied by two Xife accumula<strong>to</strong>rs, a mo<strong>to</strong>r current— and a control current battery which arecharged by means <strong>of</strong> mercury rectifiers from theexisting alternating current net.The plant has now been in operation sincethe spring <strong>of</strong> 1928, and has all the time proved<strong>to</strong> fully come up <strong>to</strong> the desiderata <strong>of</strong> the buyerin so far as reliability, convenient and easyoperation both in dispatching trains and shuntingare concerned, as well as low charges foroperation and maintenance are concerned.Fig. 7.Cabin.— 166 —


Porcelain Insula<strong>to</strong>rs and Insula<strong>to</strong>r Porcelain.Observations and Views on the Causes <strong>of</strong> Insula<strong>to</strong>r Failure.By Sten Velander. Pr<strong>of</strong>essor at the Royal Technical University, S<strong>to</strong>ckholm, Sweden.Report <strong>to</strong> the World Engineering Congress at Tokyo 1929.The subject discussed in this paper has beendealt with earlier by the author; first, in thetreatise mentioned on the next page and publishedas No. 90 among the "'IngeniorsvetenskapsakademiensHandlingar" (Monographs <strong>of</strong> TheRoyal Swedish Institute for Scientific-IndustrialResearch), and second, in a report <strong>to</strong> the Paris Congress<strong>of</strong> 1929. At that stage, however, the extensiveinvestigations given here in condensed form<strong>of</strong> the destructive temperature differences, whicheven moderate leakage currents are able <strong>to</strong> produce,had not been completed. These researchesalso show how the thermal stresses arise and howlittlethey have <strong>to</strong> do with the different coefficients<strong>of</strong> expansion for porcelain, iron and cement.They strongly support a number <strong>of</strong> explanationspreviously advanced more as hypotheses<strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failures. However, they mustbe viewed against the background <strong>of</strong> earlier researcheson operating experiences, etc., which latter. have therefore been reviewed in this report despitethe fact that they were published earlier inthe papers mentioned.Prcelain is <strong>of</strong> great importance as an insulatingmaterial within all branches <strong>of</strong> electricalengineering. Only if the porcelain insula<strong>to</strong>rsare reliable and durable at all points can ourelectric plants and especially our power transmissionsystems give fully first class service.In other fields research has very largely siftedand marshalled the phenomena concerned andsolved the most important problems, but in thecase <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r porcelain as well as many otherinsulating materials much still remains beforecalculation, design and manufacture have theproblem so well in hand as they have withinother branches <strong>of</strong> engineering.This drawback has especially made itself feltin electric power transmissions, where the deterioration<strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs has reduced and stillseriously threatens the reliabilitv <strong>of</strong> the service.Innumerable theories concerning insula<strong>to</strong>r deteriorationhave been advanced, tested, and rejected.The porcelain insula<strong>to</strong>rs on our power linesare exposed <strong>to</strong> many different stresses, bothelectrical and mechanical. The electric forcesare derived, first, from the continuously operatingworking voltage and, second, from impactstresses set up by excess voltages. The mechanicalforces are, first, in the main continuousstresses from wires or cables, second, oscillatingforces transmitted through the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs, third,internal stresses due <strong>to</strong> faults in manufactureand erection, fourth, thermal stresses due <strong>to</strong>expansion <strong>of</strong> the porcelain, cement, iron, etc.resulting from temperature rises and above allunequal temperature distribution in the insula<strong>to</strong>r.The magnitudes <strong>of</strong> these different forces arenot directly determinable, not even approximatively.For this reason as well as in view <strong>of</strong>the complicated shape <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>rs and theproperties <strong>of</strong> the porcelain, it is at present impossible<strong>to</strong> establish on a mathematical basis thestresses occuring in the insula<strong>to</strong>r. We mustcontent ourselves with the fact that in manycases these forces and their resultant stressesbecome so intense that they, at least gradually,bring about a deterioration <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>r.Insula<strong>to</strong>r statistics obtained from variouscountries and distributing systems as well asthe existent literature on operating experienceswith porcelain insula<strong>to</strong>rs have been analysed inorder <strong>to</strong> ascertain by an indirect method whetherand under what conditions the different kinds<strong>of</strong> forces are capable <strong>of</strong> causing insula<strong>to</strong>r failure.These investigations were commenced some 7years ago. For particulars <strong>of</strong> this analysis the— 167 -


eader is referred <strong>to</strong> the description <strong>of</strong> theauthor's insula<strong>to</strong>r researches published in 1929under the title <strong>of</strong> "Porzellanisola<strong>to</strong>ren und Isola<strong>to</strong>renporzellan"in the "IngeniorsvetenskapsakademiensHandlingar" (Monographs <strong>of</strong> theRoyal Swedish Institute for Scientific-IndustrialResearch, S<strong>to</strong>ckholm). The method adopted atthis investigation was <strong>to</strong> compare the relativenumber <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failures under conditionsthat had been different with respect <strong>to</strong> the magnitudeand frequency <strong>of</strong> the forces capable <strong>of</strong>producing electrical or mechanical stresses inthe insula<strong>to</strong>rs.This siudy <strong>of</strong> operating experiences has giventhe following result:The electrical forces play no noteworthy primarypart in insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration. The initialfault is practically always a crack produced bymechanical or thermal stresses. Electric punctureis a secondary phenomenon.The forces with which wires and cables actupon the insula<strong>to</strong>rs are a distinctly contribu<strong>to</strong>rycause <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failure. The continuous stressprobably contributes its share, though the effec<strong>to</strong>f the vibrations is most clearly discernible.The internal forces, strains in the porcelain,swelling <strong>of</strong> the cement, extra stresses from theerection, and suchlike, appear <strong>to</strong> be without appreciableeffect where due care in manufactureand erection has been practised.The thermal stresses arising from unequaltemperature within the insula<strong>to</strong>r appear <strong>to</strong> playa very important part as a destroyer <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs.In all coast-regions, where the atmosphereand winds are more or less saliferous,semi-conducting deposits settle on the insula<strong>to</strong>rs.As a consequence there arise powerfulleakage currents, which with for instance 50 kVpin-type insula<strong>to</strong>rs may develop an effect <strong>of</strong> amagnitude <strong>of</strong> .5 k\V per insula<strong>to</strong>r, at least ifthere are no salt ribs. The generation <strong>of</strong> heatthen principally takes place under the lowestpetticoat, where the salt deposit is least, i. e.the resistance greatest. Heating tests, whichimitate the actual conditions under which heatingoccurs through leakage currents, have beenperformed on two different types <strong>of</strong> 50 kV insula<strong>to</strong>rs,one consisting <strong>of</strong> three pieces joined<strong>to</strong>gether with hemp (v. Fig. 1) and the othermade in one piece. The salt ribs on the insula<strong>to</strong>rin Fig. 1 do not appreciably alter thedistribution <strong>of</strong> temperature, having only the effectthat under otherwise equal conditions theyincrease the leakage resistance and thus reducethe leakage effect. With a heating effect <strong>of</strong> 200watts placed under the lowest petticoat, differences<strong>of</strong> temperature amounting <strong>to</strong> over 100° Cwere obtained within the insula<strong>to</strong>r, as can beseen from Fig. 1. The other tests gave correspondingresults. With a leakage effect <strong>of</strong> .5 kW,the temperature differences <strong>to</strong> be reckoned withwould then be at least 200° C for such insula<strong>to</strong>rs.In cemented insula<strong>to</strong>rs still larger differences<strong>of</strong> temperature may doubtless arise. In this wayconsiderable thermal expansions and stresses areproduced. Poor service from insula<strong>to</strong>rs in districtsalong salt-water coasts is in fact an experiencecommon <strong>to</strong> all parts <strong>of</strong> the world. Ina similar way the pronounced variations <strong>of</strong> temperaturein alpine regions appear <strong>to</strong> contribute<strong>to</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration.It has not been possible <strong>to</strong> establish any effectfrom the height <strong>of</strong> the temperature in itself, andthus there is no support for the hypothesis thatascribes insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration <strong>to</strong> the differentcoefficients <strong>of</strong> thermal expansion for the porcelainand cement. Nor has it proved possible <strong>to</strong>find any operating experiences which confirmthe theory that the slow chemical alteration andinduration <strong>of</strong> the cement is a cause <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rfailure. On the other hand, as shown by anotherinvestiga<strong>to</strong>r, the cement has the propertyunder otherwise similar conditions <strong>of</strong> powerfullyincreasing the differences <strong>of</strong> temperaturewithin assembled cemented insula<strong>to</strong>rs. On eachside <strong>of</strong> the cement joint there are formed capilliary,highly heat-insulating, layers <strong>of</strong> air. Theeffect <strong>of</strong> the cement in insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration isthus <strong>of</strong> a different character from that till nowassumed, but is also quite certainly considerablyless than hither<strong>to</strong> thought. The same influence isdoubtless exercised by all kinds <strong>of</strong> joints. Forinstance, the previously-mentioned heating experimentswith an insula<strong>to</strong>r composed <strong>of</strong> threeparts joined <strong>to</strong>gether by hemp showed that thehemp joints absorbed 25—30 % <strong>of</strong> the <strong>to</strong>tal differencein the temperature between the outerand inner surfaces <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>r (v. Fig. 1).The slow chemical change which occurs in thecement has however been the hither<strong>to</strong> acceptedcause <strong>of</strong> the so-called ageing <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>rs,i. e. that insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration does not begin— 168 —


at once, but first after some years,when it begins <strong>to</strong> manifest itself asa cracking process in the insula<strong>to</strong>rs.In order <strong>to</strong> shed some light on thisageing phenomenon I have analyseda very large volume <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r statistics,principally from Swedishtransmission lines. The insula<strong>to</strong>rson the Swedish plants in questionhave been under such control thatthey have practically always been replacedbefore the cracking has proceededso far as <strong>to</strong> give rise <strong>to</strong> electricalpuncture. My investigations aswell as others have shown that thecracks do not arise all at once butcommence as fine probably submicroscopiccracks, <strong>of</strong>ten on the inner side<strong>of</strong> the porcelain shells and thenwander very slowly through the porcelain.It may take months for thecrack <strong>to</strong> penetrate the 15 <strong>to</strong> 20mm. shell and years before the porcelainis completely cracked. Such anevolution <strong>of</strong> the crack proves that itcannot be produced either by internalstrains or by occasional stressesreaching up <strong>to</strong> the breaking limit.The investigation further showedthat, as above mentioned, the number<strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failures is not evenlydistributed all years. The first fewyears are practically speaking freefrom such failures. After that thenumber <strong>of</strong> cracked and destroyed insula<strong>to</strong>rsgrows for every year. Withinsula<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>of</strong> good and uniform qualityunder similar conditions a veryclear and regulated variation in thefrequency <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failures is obtained.If for a group <strong>of</strong> such insula<strong>to</strong>rsa curve is set up showingthe frequency <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs with differentlengths <strong>of</strong> life, the maximumfrequency is obtained at a certainservice age, the frequency then diminishingfor both shorter and longerlives. Fig. 2 shows a frequency curve <strong>of</strong> thisdescription. As will be seen from the figure,the frequency curve for the life <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>rsR 1748 Fig. 1. Heating Test on Porcelain Insula<strong>to</strong>r.At the points denoted by o> on the surface and within the porcelain the temperaturemeasured is given in ° C under a heating effect <strong>of</strong> 200 watts. Isothermshave been drawn in on the basis <strong>of</strong> these temperature. Surrounding temperature 20° C169 —corresponds with unusually great exactness <strong>to</strong>the normal frequency curve founded on thetheory <strong>of</strong> probability.


R mm Fig. 2. Above, Frequency Diagram. Below DistributionCurve for Life-times <strong>of</strong> Pin Type Insula<strong>to</strong>rs Type --lion a South-Swedish Overhead Line.Number <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs: 867; average life: 9.5 years. The broken line indicates<strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> replaced insula<strong>to</strong>rs; the unbroken line <strong>to</strong>tal number replacedon account <strong>of</strong> cracks — on account <strong>of</strong> a general change <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs all havenot been in service until they cracked.The life-time has been counted as extending <strong>to</strong> time <strong>of</strong> discovery <strong>of</strong> a visiblecrack. The occurrence <strong>of</strong> cracks was controlled by half-yearly inspections. Thefrequency diagram indicates the number <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs (in percentages <strong>of</strong> the<strong>to</strong>tal number) falling within each half-yearly interval <strong>of</strong> the life-time. Thedistribution curve is the cumulative curve <strong>of</strong> the frequency diagram.The small circles and dot-and-dash curves give the frequency curve calculatedby the equationand the corresponding distribution ram (probability curves) obtained by integration.In the equationu — frequency, here in " for the half-year;N — the <strong>to</strong>tal number, here 100 %;y — the average deviation; calculated in the same way as the radius <strong>of</strong> intertiafor the surface between the frequency curve and the axis <strong>of</strong> the abscissaewith reference <strong>to</strong> the line <strong>of</strong> symmetry <strong>of</strong> this surface;m — the average life-time, the abscissa for the line <strong>of</strong> symmetry <strong>of</strong> the frequencycurve;i — the time, the length <strong>of</strong> life.170Thus, around a certain normal life-time insula<strong>to</strong>rswith a shorter or longer life distributethemselves in a manner which conformably <strong>to</strong>the theory <strong>of</strong> probability corresponds <strong>to</strong> a naturaldispersion, dependent on chance, aroundthe normal value. For insula<strong>to</strong>rs put in<strong>to</strong> serviceat the same time the frequency curve for insula<strong>to</strong>rfailure coincides with the frequencycurve for the life-times or service age <strong>of</strong> theinsula<strong>to</strong>rs and may then be used for theanalysis. If the insula<strong>to</strong>rs are put in<strong>to</strong>service at different times, however, thefailure frequency must be converted in<strong>to</strong>life-time frequency in order <strong>to</strong> get accurateresults. For many different sorts<strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs and for different powertransmission lines in Sweden as wellas in other countries such frequencycurves or, as the case may be, distributioncurves (i. e. the integral curve forthe frequency curve) have been set upand their correspondence with the probabilitycurve ascertained. This is readilyachieved by seeing if the distributioncurve drawn on so-called "probabilitypaper"turns out <strong>to</strong> be a straight line.When analysing insula<strong>to</strong>r statistics,however, different sorts <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rsmust not be confused, nor must statisticsfrom lines with dissimilar externalconditions be compared, for then theresult will be a distribution curve consisting<strong>of</strong> several different components,each showing a different normal lifetime.Such an indiscriminate collectionand treatment <strong>of</strong> the primary materialleads <strong>to</strong> erroneous and misleading conclusions. In those cases believed <strong>to</strong> showa constant failure percentage per annum,i. e. no normal life-time for theinsula<strong>to</strong>rs, just such very heterogeneousfailure statistics would appear <strong>to</strong> be involved.Judging from everything, therefore,we have <strong>to</strong> proceed from the assumptionthat a given sort <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r undergiven external conditions has a normallife, around the normal value <strong>of</strong> whichthere is a dispersion corresponding <strong>to</strong>the theory <strong>of</strong> probability. Nor is thisfact reconcilable with the hypothesis <strong>of</strong>an occasional high stress attaining <strong>to</strong> thebreaking limit and therefore cracking the insula<strong>to</strong>r.The hypothesis <strong>of</strong> the subsequent induration<strong>of</strong> the cement as cause is also incompatible withthe progress <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r deterioration, for insula<strong>to</strong>rshave considerably different lengths <strong>of</strong>


R 1751 Fig. 3. Above, Distribution Curves for Life-times <strong>of</strong> PinType Insula<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>of</strong> Types A1, A2 and D on a South-Swedish Overhead Line.Broken lines indicate <strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> replaced insula<strong>to</strong>rs and unbroken lines thosereplaced on account <strong>of</strong> faults (cracks). The small circles and dot-and-dash linesindicate the probable course <strong>of</strong> actual distribution curves. For A, compare Fig. 2.The curves marked St are for insula<strong>to</strong>rs on straining <strong>to</strong>wers, those marked Su forinsula<strong>to</strong>rs on suspension masts (flexible).Below, Stress-Strain Diagram obtained from Bending Tests on porcelainrods sawn out from the different insula<strong>to</strong>r types.The diagrams marked g are for glazed porcelain, those marked u for un glazed.The coefficient <strong>of</strong> linear expansion established by tests is given for .4, and D.life under varying climatic conditions, underheavy or light conduc<strong>to</strong>rs, etc., and the cementcannot harden faster if the insula<strong>to</strong>r supportsa heavy cable than if it carries a light wire, etc.The course and development <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rcracks as well as the frequency curve for thelife-times <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>rs admit, however, <strong>of</strong>a very natural and plausible explanation if oneassumes that insula<strong>to</strong>r cracks are a fatigue phenomenon.The possibility <strong>of</strong> fatigue originatingcracks in porcelain has been contested by many,and this for various reasons.It has been considered that the fatigue-crackpresupposes a recrystallisation, i. e. a physicalchange in the material, a change whose nonoccurencehas been ascertained by microscopicand electrical tests on insula<strong>to</strong>rs that have beenin service a long time. The fatigue-crack doesnot however imply any change whatever <strong>of</strong> thematerial, but at the most strained spot in thematerial there arises, in consequence <strong>of</strong> varyingforces acting for longer or shorter periods, amolecular crack that slowly makes its way furtherin<strong>to</strong> the material and finally becomes visible.For such a gradual disturbance <strong>of</strong> the cohesivebond between the molecules considerably smallerstresses are required than those necessary <strong>to</strong>produce immediate fracture.It has further been denied that porcelain,glass, and other silicates could exhibit fatiguecracksbecause the limit <strong>of</strong> proportionality andthe ultimate strength coincide; that is <strong>to</strong> say, nopermanent set appears in these materials, it beingconsidered as established that for metals thefatigue limit lies at about the limit <strong>of</strong> proportionality.However, a closer examination showsthat in certain cases the fatigue limit for metalsfalls considerably below the limit <strong>of</strong> propor-171


R 1750 fig. 4. Comparison between Stress-Strain Diagrams.To the left for a strong and weak insula<strong>to</strong>r porcelain. To the right for steeland cast iron.tionality. Further is <strong>to</strong> notice that even if glassand porcelain do not show any permanent deformationsunder short-time loads, this does notimply anything respecting the conditions underloads acting for months or years. At least forglass, moreover, it has been established thatsmall loads applied during a long period alsoproduce a permanent set.It is thus not straightway evident cither thatthe fatigue limit for all materials is bound upwith the limit <strong>of</strong> proportionality or that rapidlyrepeated loads produce fatigue cracks in glassand porcelain because they generally do so inmetals A few fatigue tests on glass and porcelainperformed in the course <strong>of</strong> a few dayscannot therefore be assigned any conclusivevalue. To ascertain the behaviour <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rporcelain under varying stresses extensive longtimetests are required. Such have been commencedby me. It would however be desirableif parallel experiments could be undertaken a<strong>to</strong>ther centres, as such investigations absorb verylong time.So far, then, it seems that nothing concerninginsula<strong>to</strong>r failure has been advanced that isin conflict with the results and conclusionsreached by me on the strength <strong>of</strong> my analysis<strong>of</strong> operating experiences and insula<strong>to</strong>r failures,172viz. that crack-formation is thedominating feature in insula<strong>to</strong>rdeterioration and that the crackis a fatigue fracture produced bythose heterogenous and varyingforces and stresses which withmore or less intensity act uponevery insula<strong>to</strong>r in service.If within the engineeringworld a construction is mechanicallylacking in durability, thismust be remedied in the firstplace by altering the dimensionsin order <strong>to</strong> keep down the stresses,and in certain cases by areduction <strong>of</strong> the forces at play.Such measures are also utilisedin the case <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs, and asthey are comparatively wellknown I will on this point merelyrefer the reader <strong>to</strong> my detailedtreatise. When improvements <strong>of</strong>this nature in shape and dimensionshave not the desired effect, it is usualwithin the majority <strong>of</strong> other technical fields <strong>to</strong>go in for higher quality, <strong>to</strong> try a stronger material.Should for instance cast iron fall shor<strong>to</strong>f what is required, steel is used, in some casesalloy steel.Unfortunately this aspect <strong>of</strong> the problem hasbeen entirely neglected where insula<strong>to</strong>rs areconcerned. In all but a few minor details insula<strong>to</strong>rshave been manufactured and purchased,delivered and tested, as if all porcelainwere <strong>of</strong> equal quality from a mechanical poin<strong>to</strong>f view. When deliveries <strong>of</strong> iron and machinemanufacture come in<strong>to</strong> question, the quality andproperties <strong>of</strong> the material are most carefully controlledand tested. In most insula<strong>to</strong>r deliveriesit has not as yet been the practice <strong>to</strong> troubleabout the mechanical properties <strong>of</strong> the porcelainused.While engaged on my analysis <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rstatistics I found that different deliveries <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rshad markedly different lengths <strong>of</strong> lifein spite <strong>of</strong> shape and dimensions as well as externalconditions being similar. I then wentin for a purely mechanical bending test on prismaticaltest-pieces sawn out from the insula<strong>to</strong>rs.These tests showed that insula<strong>to</strong>rs made <strong>of</strong> weakporcelain, under otherwise similar conditions,


always had a relatively short life, while insula<strong>to</strong>rs<strong>of</strong> mechanically strong porcelain had a relativelylong life. Fig. 3 gives some typical instances<strong>of</strong> the results from these tests. The testalso revealed that the porcelain used in normaland according <strong>to</strong> the cus<strong>to</strong>mary specificationsfully first class insula<strong>to</strong>rs may be subject <strong>to</strong>such extreme variations as are indicated inFig. 4. The porcelain in our insula<strong>to</strong>rs has thushad, and unless our views and specificationsare changed will presumably continue <strong>to</strong> have,mechanical properties that are aimlessly and capriciouslyallowed <strong>to</strong> vary within a latitude thatis relatively speaking almost as wide as tha<strong>to</strong>ver which all our varieties <strong>of</strong> iron and steelextend. Hence it is not <strong>to</strong> be wondered at tha<strong>to</strong>perating records and views concerning insula<strong>to</strong>rshave been so exceedingly at variance.The chief reason that mechanically weak porcelainhas found frequent use in insula<strong>to</strong>rs isobviously that nobody has given heed <strong>to</strong> thesignificance <strong>of</strong> the mechanical properties. Attentionhas been exclusively concentrated uponthe electrical qualities, and porcelain with highdielectric strength has been demanded, thoughthis is as a rule accompanied by inferior mechanicalqualities. Moreover, weak and brittlepcrcelain is generally easier <strong>to</strong> manufacture.Although the investigations on the reliabilityand durability <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>rs with reference <strong>to</strong> themechanical properties <strong>of</strong> the porcelain used arenot yet so great in number, they point so unmistakablyin one direction that it can be assertedwith a high degree <strong>of</strong> certainty that the use <strong>of</strong>a porcelain with high mechanical strength andductility ought <strong>to</strong> yield insula<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>of</strong> very highreliability and considerable durability even undersevere climatic conditions. This is naturallyen condition that certain other features such assuitable shape, etc., which experience has taught,ought <strong>to</strong> receive attention, are not neglectedeither in the manufacture or in the erection.It is conceivable that a variety <strong>of</strong> porcelainmight be selected that is resistant <strong>to</strong> short-timestresses but relatively less resistant <strong>to</strong> fatiguestresses than another sort which happens <strong>to</strong> havea somewhat lower ultimate strength. This point.however, must be cleared up by a conscientiousstudy <strong>of</strong> the resistance <strong>of</strong> different sorts <strong>of</strong> porcelain<strong>to</strong> the various forms <strong>of</strong> stresses. Thiswill be a problem for ceramists, who must takeas an example the splendid advance attained bysystematical and conscientious research in the ,iron and steel industries during but a few decades.For the present, however, we must conten<strong>to</strong>urselves with demanding a high ultimatestrength in the porcelain material used; concomitantlythere ought <strong>to</strong> be a high probability<strong>of</strong> also obtaining great fatigue strenght. In anycase the probability <strong>of</strong> securing such ought <strong>to</strong>be considerably greater than if, as hither<strong>to</strong>, nodemand is made with respect <strong>to</strong> the mechanicalproperties <strong>of</strong> the insula<strong>to</strong>r porcelain.Summary.Reliable and durable insula<strong>to</strong>rs are <strong>of</strong> thegreatest technical and economical importance forelectric plants and overhead lines. Analyses <strong>of</strong>operating records and insula<strong>to</strong>r statistics frommany countries and lines show that the primarycause <strong>of</strong> insula<strong>to</strong>r failure is a crack producedby mechanical (and thermal) forces. The electricpuncture is a secondary phenomenon. On accoun<strong>to</strong>f the development and course <strong>of</strong> thecracks and <strong>of</strong> the time it takes for the cracks<strong>to</strong> arise, it may be concluded that in all probabilitythe cracking is due <strong>to</strong> a mechanical fatiguephenomenon. The view <strong>of</strong> some observersthat porcelain and glass do not exhibit fatiguefracture is not founded on conclusive investigations.Rest-arch is however in progresson this point. The porcelain used in insula<strong>to</strong>rsreveals exceedingly variable mechanical properlies.The variation is as great as l>etween ordinarycast iron and high-grade steel. Low resistanceand low ductility in the porcelain appear<strong>to</strong> involve poor service reliability ami ashort life for the insula<strong>to</strong>rs. Therefore, withdue attention <strong>to</strong> suitable shape, etc.. the insula<strong>to</strong>rsshould lie made <strong>of</strong> mechanically strong and<strong>to</strong>ugh porcelain. To ensure that our insula<strong>to</strong>rsshall stand on a level with the rest <strong>of</strong> the plantin quality and reliability, a conscientious andmethodical inquiry in<strong>to</strong> the mechanical properties<strong>of</strong> the different sorts <strong>of</strong> porcelain underdifferent stresses is recommended.— 173 -


The Svenska Radioaktiebolaget Valve-testing set.By TorbernLaurent.1. General.The Valve Testing Set Model RPR 829 <strong>of</strong> theSvenska Radioaktiebolaget is an instrumentworking on entirely new principles, and is particularlysuitable for practical measurementsand tests <strong>of</strong> amplifying valves, e. g. in a telephonerepeater station, or in a valve retailingshop. This Valve Testing Set will assess the effectiveamplification <strong>of</strong> a valve in a way which,while expressing the working conditions objectively,is still perfectly explicit. Further, theinternal resistance <strong>of</strong> a valve, its grid voltagespace, and the magnitude <strong>of</strong> the non-linear dis<strong>to</strong>rtionintroduced by the amplifier, can be determinedby the Valve Testing Set.This is very simple in design, and althoughthe effective amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> a valve willbe directly measured, no audio-frequency genera<strong>to</strong>r,valve voltmeter, etc. is required.The measurements are very easily taken, andthe method allows great precision without anydifficulty.The Valve Testing Set is suitable for routinetests as well as for a more thorough investigation<strong>of</strong> various types <strong>of</strong> valves.The risk <strong>of</strong> measurement errors caused by anoverloaded valve, which is present when valvesare measured by any previously known method<strong>of</strong> amplification measurement, is entirely eliminatedin this Valve Testing Set.In all probability the Svenska RadioaktiebolagetValve Testing Set will make valve tests ona much larger scale than hither<strong>to</strong> economicallypossible, and valve consumers will thus alwaysbe assured <strong>of</strong> good quality amplification.2. The Principle.It is generally known that an amplifier valve,the anode- and grid circuit <strong>of</strong> which are coupled,will act as an oscilla<strong>to</strong>r if the conditions requiredfor oscillations are present. The amplifyingcapacity <strong>of</strong> the valve, and the amount <strong>of</strong> reaction,are also among the fac<strong>to</strong>rs involved inthese conditions for oscillation. For a certainamplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> the valve, the reactionmust not fall short <strong>of</strong> a certain minimum valueif the conditions for oscillation are <strong>to</strong> be fulfilled,and under otherwise unchanged conditionsthis minimum will diminish as the amplifyingcapacity is increased. This minimum reactionvalue is thus a function <strong>of</strong> the amplifying capacity<strong>of</strong> the valve, and the Svenska RadioaktiebolagetValve Testing Set is based on this fact.Fig. 1 gives a diagram <strong>of</strong> the Valve Tester.R is the amplifier valve tested, receiving its gridbias, filament voltage, and anode voltage fromthe batteries B,, B 2 , and B 3 respectively. Theanode transformer T is provided with severalprimary winding taps (2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64), representingdifferent anode load impedances, andthe anode is connected <strong>to</strong> the tap which will givean anode load impedance as closely corresponding<strong>to</strong> the normal working conditions <strong>of</strong> thevalve as possible. Connected <strong>to</strong> the secondaryside <strong>of</strong> the transformer is a condenser C which,<strong>to</strong>gether with the secondary self-induction <strong>of</strong>the transformer, forms an oscillating circuittuned <strong>to</strong> an easily audiable frequency, e. g.800 c/s. Parallel <strong>to</strong> the condenser C is the potentiometerP 2 , in series with a high resistancetelephone receiver H, shunted with a small resistancer. Ry means <strong>of</strong> the potentiometer P 2 ,the amount <strong>of</strong> reaction can be varied, and bylistening in the telephone receiver H one ascertainswhether the device oscillates or not.The grid bias <strong>of</strong> the valve may be varied bythe potentiometer P v above the grid battery B„and as a rule this is set for the grid bias withwhich the valve is meant <strong>to</strong> work.— 174 -


Fig. 1.When the D. C. voltages and the anode loadimpedance <strong>of</strong> the valve are adjusted as closelyas possible <strong>to</strong> the desired working conditions,the measurement is taken simply by setting thepotentiometer P, <strong>to</strong> the limit <strong>of</strong> the oscillatingcapacity <strong>of</strong> the system, which can be observedby listening in the telephone receiver H. Theamplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> the valve is then readdirectly on the scale for the setting <strong>of</strong> the potentiometerP 2 , which is graduated empirically.After this preliminary survey <strong>of</strong> the working<strong>of</strong> the Valve Testing Set, some <strong>of</strong> the attendantconditions will be explained in more detail.To enable a reaction-coupled valve <strong>to</strong> oscillate,the reaction device must be such that the alternatingvoltages returned <strong>to</strong> the grid from theanode induce in the anode circuit <strong>of</strong> the valvean E.M.F. which is exactly in phase with theoriginal E.M.F. If, as is done in the Valve TestingSet, a tuned circuit is introduced in thereaction device, the reaction phase characteristicswill very largely depend on the frequency,when this is anywhere near the resonance frequency<strong>of</strong> the tuned circuit. Somewhere nearthis resonance frequency <strong>of</strong> the tuned circuit,a frequency fulfilling the above phase conditioncan therefore generally be found, and the valvewill consequently oscillate with this frequency.If the valve, as in fig. 2, is regarded as a source<strong>of</strong> current, the E.M.F. and internal resistance<strong>of</strong> which is E and R { respectively, loaded by atuned circuit consisting <strong>of</strong> a capacity C, an inductionL with a small loss resistance /, and thepotentiometer resistance R B , the resistance R Bwill cause a voltage drop V z , the relations <strong>of</strong>which <strong>to</strong> the electromotive force E will be studiedbelow.The impedance <strong>of</strong> the tuned circuit is obviously(a) = the angular frequency)orHenceorFig. 2.We assume the imaginary component <strong>of</strong> thedenomina<strong>to</strong>r <strong>to</strong> be small in comparison <strong>to</strong> thereal component, and the amplitude relationshipmay then be written175


and the phase angle between the voltage V x andthe E.M.F. Eat the limit <strong>of</strong> oscillations for the valve (E = /.tV g ).The amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> the valve can obviouslybe determined by means <strong>of</strong> the relations(5) and (6), when a and the anode impedanceare known.The anode impedance is assumed <strong>to</strong> be selectedas nearly equal <strong>to</strong> the internal resistance Ri<strong>of</strong> the valve as possible. If we regard fig. 3,illustrating the same point as fig. 2, but in whichthe transformer T <strong>of</strong> the ratio n:l is put in (theresonance impedance <strong>of</strong> the tuned circuit is assumed<strong>to</strong> be included in the potentiometer resistanceR B ), we therefore getIf the phase changes caused by, for instance,the transformer T, which it is the task <strong>of</strong> theangle y <strong>to</strong> compensate, are small, the amplitudeVrelationship ~ will, according <strong>to</strong> equ. (3), beb.independent <strong>of</strong> the angular frequency w- Thiswill make the reaction independent <strong>of</strong> the phasecompensation, and in the computation <strong>of</strong> theamount <strong>of</strong> reaction the tuned circuit need onlyThis makes the primary voltage <strong>of</strong> the transformerA measure <strong>of</strong> the amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> thevalve has been chosen which will as far as possibleexpress the working properties <strong>of</strong> the valve,particularly when used as an amplifying valvebe regarded as a shunting impedance =fCWhen the reaction is adjusted <strong>to</strong> the limi<strong>to</strong>f the oscillating capacity <strong>of</strong> the valve, the gridvoltage V g , regenerated by the E.M.F. acting inthe anode circuit E, will be just enough <strong>to</strong> inducein the anode circuit an E.M.F. equal <strong>to</strong>the original E. If the amount <strong>of</strong> reaction is definedaswhere V g is the voltage at the output end <strong>of</strong> thereaction device when this is disconnected fromthe valve grid, we may, in other words, saythatFig. 3.n I6J5 Fig. 4.for electric communication purposes, and this isdefined as the natural logarithm for the relationbetween the voltage V,. re-transformed <strong>to</strong> a fixedcharacteristic impedance selected in the ValveTesting Set <strong>to</strong> 1M? = 600 ohms, and the grid voltageV 0 . Consequently we get the amplifyingcapacity176


orIf the resistance H 0 <strong>of</strong> the potentiometer R Bcorresponds <strong>to</strong> an amplifying capacity b = 0,we getwhere V 0 is the voltage drop at the resistanceR 0 . Obviously the relation3. Description <strong>of</strong> the Apparatus.Fig. 4 shows the external appearance <strong>of</strong> theValve Testing Set, and fig. 5 the arrangementsat the back <strong>of</strong> the panel. Fig. 6 is a circuit diagram<strong>of</strong> the Valve Testing Set, where the symbolsR, T, C, P,, P, and r have the same significanceas in fig. 1.The batteries B t , B 2 , and B :1 are connected <strong>to</strong>the terminals V g „ V k , and V m and by the voltmeterV the grid voltage (with two ranges), thefilament voltage, and the anode voltage, may beread by inserting the plug B in the jacks A,, A„A., and A t respectively. The telephone receiveris connected <strong>to</strong> the terminals HTF.The primary winding taps <strong>of</strong> the transformerT represent the following anode resistances:(The anode impedance being practically pureohmic)will then be obtained, and consequentlyAlthough the anode resistance cannot alwaysbe made <strong>to</strong> correspond exactly <strong>to</strong> the internalresistance <strong>of</strong> the valve, the amplifying capacityindicated by the reading on the potentiometerP, will nevertheless be practicallyR 1656 Fig. 5.The scale setting <strong>of</strong> the potentiometer whenthe potentiometer resistance is R0 represents azero-point on the scale. Potentiometer readingsabove and below this zero point will then representnegative and positive amplifications respectively.as will be shown in the next chapter.In fig. 4 we see the voltmeter V <strong>to</strong> the left atthe <strong>to</strong>p, the socket for the valve <strong>to</strong> be tested <strong>to</strong>the right at the <strong>to</strong>p, and in the centre the potentiometerP.,, the setting <strong>of</strong> which is read on amovable scale visible through a window. Underneaththe voltmeter V is the potentiometerPj by which the grid bias is regulated, andunderneath the valve socket is the dial for adjustingthe anode resistance. At the bot<strong>to</strong>m wesee the terminals, and in the centre the plug B,which is lifted and plugged in<strong>to</strong> the jacks abovewhen the D.C. voltages are measured.4. Theories for the Impedance adaption in theAnode Circuit.According <strong>to</strong> the above, only certain values,differentiated by multiples <strong>of</strong> 2. can be selectedfor the anode resistance. We will now examinethe significance <strong>of</strong> this limitation <strong>of</strong> the number177


Fig. 6.<strong>of</strong> possible anode resistances. If we regard thevalve as a source <strong>of</strong> current with an E.M.F. <strong>of</strong>a V g , an internal resistance Ri, and loaded bythe anode resistance Ry as shown in fig. 7, thevoltage drop caused by the resistance R y will beThe Valve Testing Set will therefore measurean amplifying capacityorFig. 7.This voltage, re-transformed <strong>to</strong> a characteristicimpedance <strong>of</strong> 600 ohms, will beThe first term <strong>of</strong> this expression is obviouslythe actual amplifying capacity tested, and thesecond term represents the error in measuremen<strong>to</strong>ccasioned bv the internal resistance R t <strong>of</strong> the- 178


valve not being the same as the anode resistanceIty.When R y = /?, we haveBut, on the other hand, if R y ± ft,,As a function <strong>of</strong> R y ,value when R y = R,.We assumeb has thus a maximumwhere R and 2R are two /^-values which mayhe set on the scale, and introduce the symbolWhen using ft y = ft, and R y ~2R respectivelyfor measurements, we thus get the respectivevaluesft 2 —b v By computing the difference ft 2 —ft, fromthe scale values ft, and ft, observed, the amplifyingcapacity sought may thus be determinedwith the assistance <strong>of</strong> these curves, and the internalresistance <strong>of</strong> the valve may also be computedif the resistance ft is known.We see, however, that if the highest <strong>of</strong> thetwo values b 1 and ft, is accepted (in other words,the highest scale value obtained when testingwith different anode resistances) as being equal<strong>to</strong> the amplifying capacity b 0 , the error cannever exceed .015 neper, i. e. 1.5 per cent. Inpractice, an error <strong>of</strong> that description is usually<strong>of</strong> no importance. The determination <strong>of</strong> the internalvalve resistance cannot <strong>of</strong> course be madewith any very great precision, but then we arenot interested in the internal resistance <strong>of</strong> thevalve except in so far as this affects its effectiveamplifying capacity, and this influence is ratherinsignificant in the neighbourhood <strong>of</strong> the bestimpedance-adaptation.5. Amplification Tests with different anoderesistances.The above shows that the amplifying capacity<strong>of</strong> an amplifying valve, defined asOn the above assumption, ft, and ft, will consequentlybe the two largest scale values obtainedwhen using different anode resistancesfor the tests, and this <strong>of</strong>fers an opportunity <strong>to</strong>ascertain the two anode resistances for whichthe above assumption is valid.The equations (11) contain only two unknownquantities, viz. b 0 and ft,, which may obviouslybe computed from the values <strong>of</strong> b1 ft,, and ft.Fig. 8 gives curves computed from the equations(11) for the measurement errors b 0 — ft,, as wellas b0— b2, and the relation ft, : ft as functions <strong>of</strong>and its internal resistance may be determinedwith the Valve Testing Set by making a series<strong>of</strong> tests with different anode resistances. In amore thorough investigation <strong>of</strong> a valve withthe Valve Testing Set, such a test series is thereforecompleted.Fig. 9 shows actual amplification tests <strong>of</strong>some different types <strong>of</strong> Marconi valves madewith different anode resistances. The roundrings mark the scale values observed, and thecrosses the internal resistances <strong>of</strong> the respectivevalves given by the maker.This shows distinctly what we have alreadypointed out, namely that the amplificationreaches a maximum value when the anode resistanceis equal <strong>to</strong> the internal resistance <strong>of</strong>the valve. We further note that the maximumamplifications recorded on the scale only differslightly from the amplifying capacities b 0 <strong>to</strong>be determined. For a more exact determination<strong>of</strong> the amplifying capacity b„ and internal re-— 179 —


Fig. 8.180


-10Fig. 9.sistance W, <strong>of</strong> a valve, the correction curves <strong>of</strong>fig. 8 are used, in which case the symbols b v b.,etc. refer <strong>to</strong> the plotting in fig. 8 <strong>of</strong> b as a function<strong>of</strong> Ry,6. Amplification Tests with different Grid Biases.To determine by means <strong>of</strong> the Valve TestingSet the grid voltage space <strong>of</strong> a valve and themagnitude <strong>of</strong> the non-linear dis<strong>to</strong>rtions arisingin the valve, a series <strong>of</strong> amplification tests aremade with different grid biases. The fulldrawncurve in fig. 10 gives the result <strong>of</strong> such a testscries on a Marconi valve. We note that theamplification increases with decreased grid bias,for the reason that the slope <strong>of</strong> the valve characteristicis increased.In this connexion we will comment upon acircumstance which may he <strong>of</strong> some interest.When the amplification <strong>of</strong> an amplifier is mea-— 181 —


Fig. 10,sured in the usual manner with an audio-frequencygenera<strong>to</strong>r, artificial line, and valve voltmeter,the valve is made <strong>to</strong> work during the testwith an audio-frequency voltage <strong>of</strong> a certainamplitude on the grid. The amplification arrivedat is then determined hy a kind <strong>of</strong> averagevalue for the slope <strong>of</strong> the valve characteristicwithin the grid voltage range utilized by theaudio-frequency voltages. When measuring theamplification with the Valve Testing Set however,the conditions are different. If the reactionis slowly increased until the amount isleached when the valve hegins <strong>to</strong> oscillate, thisamount <strong>of</strong> reaction must be characteristic <strong>of</strong> thecondition <strong>of</strong> the valve before oscillation had begun.The amplification measured will thereforebe determined by the slope <strong>of</strong> the valve characteristicat that point <strong>of</strong> the curve which corresponds<strong>to</strong> the grid bias selected.We will introduce the designation "point amplification"for the amplification measured bymeans <strong>of</strong> the Valve Testing Set, as this amplificationcharacterizes conditions in one particularpoint <strong>of</strong> the valve characteristic.The point amplification must obviously be independen<strong>to</strong>f the grid bias within the range <strong>of</strong>grid voltages employed if the amplification obtainedis <strong>to</strong> be free from dis<strong>to</strong>rtion or, in otherwords, within the said range <strong>of</strong> grid voltages thetulldrawn curve b = f(V 0 ) <strong>of</strong> fig. 10 must bea straight line parallel <strong>to</strong> the axis <strong>of</strong> abscissas.If this is not so, the amplifier will introduce— 182 —


non-linear dis<strong>to</strong>rtion, the magnitude <strong>of</strong> whichwill depend on the amount <strong>of</strong> deflection <strong>of</strong> thecurve b = f(V g0 ) from the mean value <strong>of</strong> thepoint amplifications within the range <strong>of</strong> gridvoltages employed. The dotted curve <strong>of</strong> fig. 10shows the mean value <strong>of</strong> point amplificationswithin ranges <strong>of</strong> grid voltages distributed equallyon either side <strong>of</strong> the —10-volt grid bias insuch a way that the average amplification <strong>of</strong> arange <strong>of</strong> grid voltages will correspond <strong>to</strong> theordinate at the limit voltages <strong>of</strong> that range. Ifwe consider that when amplifying audiable currents,the range <strong>of</strong> grid voltages nearest <strong>to</strong> thegrid bias will be used the most, the dotted curveshows that the point amplification <strong>of</strong> the gridbias in question may also be regarded as ameasure <strong>of</strong> the average amplification. The advantage<strong>of</strong> defining the amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong>a valve as point amplification for the grid biasin question is that the amplification capacitywill be explicitly defined. Deviations in thepoint amplification at other grid biases whencompared <strong>to</strong> the grid bias employed will thenbe regarded as sources <strong>of</strong> dis<strong>to</strong>rtion.It must be pointed out that when measuringamplifications by the usual method previouslymentioned, the amplifying capacity ascertainedwill partly depend on the properties <strong>of</strong> the indica<strong>to</strong>rappliance used (e. g. a valve voltmeter).As a matter <strong>of</strong> fact, different types <strong>of</strong> indica<strong>to</strong>rappliances will treat the disturbing voltagescaused by dis<strong>to</strong>rtion in the amplifier in varyingways. Valve voltmeters, based on rectification<strong>of</strong> only positive or negative half-cycles <strong>of</strong> themeasured voltages, do not usually give the sametest result when the negative and when the positivehalf-ccyles are rectified, and the questionthen immediately arises which is <strong>to</strong> be consideredcorrect. There is a great risk <strong>of</strong> getting the6. 183Fig. 11.measurement results all wrong with these amplificationtest devices, if from one cause or anotherthe valve is overloaded, which risk is nonexistentwhen the Valve Testing Set is used.7. The Effective Amplification <strong>of</strong> an Amplifier.Fig. 1 shows an amplifier connected withoutreflection losses on the input and output side <strong>to</strong>lines with the characteristic impedances Z, and/., respectively. The grid transformer, whichhas a ratio <strong>of</strong> 1 :n, introduces in<strong>to</strong> the device anamplification <strong>of</strong>where ti g represents an effective attenuation inthe transformer. If Z 1 is = 600 ohms, we getIf the attenuation in the anode transformer is£ a , and the amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> the valvethe amplifier will bethe effective amplification <strong>of</strong>If the amplifier consists <strong>of</strong> several valves connectedin cascade, the amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong>each valve will enter as a term <strong>of</strong> the effectiveamplification <strong>of</strong> the amplifier, and each couplingbetween the valves will be represented byits own term. If all the terms entering in theeffective amplification are added <strong>to</strong>gether, exceptthe amplifying capacity <strong>of</strong> the valves, anamplification exponent, characteristic <strong>of</strong> theamplifying device, is obtained.It this amplification exponent be determinedonce and for all. the effective amplification <strong>of</strong>the amplifier can be determined by adding <strong>to</strong>this the amplifying capacities <strong>of</strong> the severalvalves, measured by the Valve Testing Set.


The characteristic impedance 600 ohms whichenters in<strong>to</strong> the definition <strong>of</strong> the amplifying capacity<strong>of</strong> a valve, has been chosen because thatcharacteristic impedance is frequently used intelephone technics, particularly for measurements.8. Valve Testing.The Valve Testing Set is primarily intendedfor routine tests <strong>of</strong> valves. The anode resistanceis then adjusted in as close correspondenceas possible <strong>to</strong> the specified internal resistance<strong>of</strong> the valve. It is <strong>of</strong> course also possible <strong>to</strong> producea valve tester for certain types <strong>of</strong> valves,so designed that anode resistances identical withthe internal resistances <strong>of</strong> the valve types inquestion may be employed. The valves are testedwith normal filament voltage, anode voltage,and grid bias, and the amplifying capacity ispassed as sufficient if it reaches a certain specifiedvalue. Tests should also be made withFig. <strong>12</strong>.— 184 —say 75 per cent higher and lower grid biases,when the valve will be passed if the amplificationsmeasured do not deviate from those atnormal grid bias by more than a certain specifiedamount.If, for some particular calculations, it is desired<strong>to</strong> graduate the reaction potentiometer scale<strong>to</strong> any other amplification units thanthis can <strong>of</strong> course easily be done. The reactionpotentiometer may for instance be graded inwhere S is the slope, and these quantities maythen be directly measured.Fig. <strong>12</strong> illustrates the relation between the expressionsfor the amplificationand


On the Calculation <strong>of</strong> Delays in an Au<strong>to</strong>matic Telephone System.By Stig Ekel<strong>of</strong>.When in an au<strong>to</strong>matic telephone system it isa question <strong>of</strong> calculating the number <strong>of</strong>switches required for carrying a certain amoun<strong>to</strong>f traffic, we as a rule start from the condition<strong>of</strong> allowing a certain "loss", in other words,we estimate the number <strong>of</strong> switches in such away that, for instance, 2 %o <strong>of</strong> the calls are"lost" through all switches being engaged. Inthis case it is necessary that all subscribers whodo not at once find a disengaged switch, immediatelyreplace their receiver and do not renewtheir call until a short time has elapsed. As abasis for calculating on these lines serve, byway <strong>of</strong> example, the well-known lossformulae<strong>of</strong> Erlang.Sometimes it may, however, be <strong>of</strong> interest <strong>to</strong>calculate with u delays" instead. We premisethen that a subscriber who cannot get throughimmediately waits with the receiver <strong>of</strong>f, untilhe can get a free line finder. In this case wewant <strong>to</strong> be able <strong>to</strong> calculate the <strong>to</strong>tal number<strong>of</strong> calls which are delayed or the number delayedmore than a certain period.In the ensuing pages we shall give an accoun<strong>to</strong>f the calculation <strong>of</strong> accompanying charts fordelay calculation worked out by the author.The foundation for these consists <strong>of</strong> certain delayformulaededuced by Pr<strong>of</strong>. Pleijel. It should bepointed out that Pr<strong>of</strong>. Pleijel in his deductionalso <strong>to</strong>ok in<strong>to</strong> consideration the otherwise generallyneglected fact, that the number <strong>of</strong> callsdiminishes in the proportion in which the subscribersare engaged.Deduction <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>. Pleijels Formulae.We assume a group <strong>of</strong> l subscribers who fortheir calls have available x linefinders. Asregards the registers it is assumed that thedevices and arrangements are such that evervline-finder always has at its disposition a disengagedregister.We now consider a certain time interval bthe "busy hour", and assume that every subscriberduring the same makes e calls. Everycall is premissed <strong>to</strong> occupy the linefinder duringthe constant time interval a.The system is, furthermore, imagined <strong>to</strong> be<strong>of</strong> such a nature that a subscriber who callsat a moment when all Iinefinders are engaged,will wait until a linefinder is free. If thereare several subscribers waiting simultaneously,we assume that they will get a linefinder inthe same order in which they have called.Our first problem then will be <strong>to</strong> investigatehow <strong>of</strong>ten it happens that m subscribers are engagedby reason <strong>of</strong> these calls with concomitantconversations.For solving the same we make use or Erlang'smethod <strong>of</strong> "statistical equilibrium*. We considera very large number P <strong>of</strong> groups <strong>of</strong> / subscribersaccording <strong>to</strong> the preceding. At a certain momen<strong>to</strong>f time we have different conditions inthe different groups with regard <strong>to</strong> the number<strong>of</strong> subscribers who are engaged. The entiresystem should nevertheless be in a statisticalequilibrium, so that the number <strong>of</strong> groups P m ,which have m subscribers engaged (we say:the number <strong>of</strong> groups <strong>of</strong> the order m) shouldbe equal at every moment. The condition forsuch an equilibrium <strong>to</strong> exist is obviously thatduring every time element as many groups <strong>of</strong>the order m pass in<strong>to</strong> such <strong>of</strong> order m + 1 byadditional calls as the number <strong>of</strong> groups whichpass from order m + 1 <strong>to</strong> m on account <strong>of</strong>finished calls.We introduce "the traffic intensity* y, bywhich is meant the number <strong>of</strong> calls which onan average originate during the time <strong>of</strong> a conversationa.We denote further by r the number <strong>of</strong> callswhich are made during the time interval a in185


a group P 0 , i. e. in a group where no subscribersare engaged. If we take a as time unit,the number <strong>of</strong> calls in such a group duringthe time interval dt becomes equal <strong>to</strong> zdt andin all groups P 0 we obtain al<strong>to</strong>gether P 0 zdtcalls.In a group <strong>of</strong> order m we have only /— msubscribers who are able <strong>to</strong> make calls. The<strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> calls within these P m groupsduring dt is then obviouslyorWe now insert the probability S,„ <strong>of</strong> havingat a certain arbitrary moment m subscribersengaged in conversation.ObviouslyIt is here assumed that none <strong>of</strong> the / subscribersare engaged by incoming calls. Inreality we must as a rule premiss that the incomingtraffic is equally large as the outgoing,so that on an average y subscribers are constantlyengaged by calls from other subscribers.Consequently, on an average at the mostl—y subscribers are able <strong>to</strong> make calls, i. e.we kan include the effect <strong>of</strong> arriving conversationsby assuming that the group has only/ — y subscribers. The difference for large I is,however, very slight, for which reason, in order<strong>to</strong> make the numerical calculations more convenient,we ignore this correction. Should itbe found in a certain case that this is not permissible,we have only everywhere in the formulae<strong>to</strong> substitute l—y for l.We now select the time interval dt so smallthat we are able <strong>to</strong> ignore all those cases wheretwo or more calls occur or get lost in a groupduring this period. The expression P„,—-then gives us the number <strong>of</strong> groups which onaccount <strong>of</strong> new calls are passing from ordern <strong>to</strong> m + 1.For calculating the number <strong>of</strong> groups thatpass from order m + 1 <strong>to</strong> order m we assumefirst that in + 1 < I , so that all engaged subscribersarc talking. The IB + 1 conversationsgoing on will clearly all be finished after theinterval 1. If we assume that the conversationsfinish continously, (m + 1) dt are concluded inthe period dt, so that the number concludedwithin all P m t groups iszdtand consequentlyfrom whichwheredenominates the binomial coefficientFor m = x we get speciallyWe assume now instead m > x and putm = x + r. All linefinders are then engaged,so that x conversations are on while r subscribersare waiting. In the time interval dt thenxdt conversations disappear. The condition forequilibrium becomes in that caseor if we here put the probabilityfrom whichi. e.equilibrium consequently de­The statisticalmandsfor R1 = S1186


By the use <strong>of</strong> the previously deduced expressionfor S y we then geti. e.If we also here substitute S m for Rm we getIf we employ the notationwhether m'—x,we can thus writeandorFor determining S 0 we make use <strong>of</strong> the factthat the sum <strong>of</strong> the probabilities for all possiblecases is equal <strong>to</strong> 1. The highest possible number<strong>of</strong> engaged subscribers in a group is clearly/. We therefore get the relationas well asIf these values are inserted for r and S„ inthe expressions (1) and (2) for S m and H m , weobtain ultimatelyIn order <strong>to</strong> enable the system <strong>to</strong> operate properly,the number <strong>of</strong> delayed subscribers must,as we are aware, be very small, so that 1'H mis very small in proportion <strong>to</strong> 1. We are thenable without serious error <strong>to</strong> substitute S m forR m in the above relation and then getandOur next problem will be <strong>to</strong> express r in y.Because y is the number <strong>of</strong> calls which on anaverage fall during the time interval 1 withina group, the number <strong>of</strong> calls in this period inall P groups <strong>to</strong>gether becomes P . y, so thatWe now pass on <strong>to</strong> the actual problem, viz. thecalculation <strong>of</strong> how many calls hare <strong>to</strong> wait forlinefinders longer than a certain period <strong>of</strong> time.A call originating in a group with m < x engagedsubscribers will get a linefinder at once.If a call comes in a group where x subscribersare engaged it will on an average have <strong>to</strong> waitfor the period — = the period which on anaverage elapses before a linefinder becomes idle,reckoned from a certain moment when all areengaged. If x + 1 subscribers are engaged, thecall will be delayedand if generallyx + r — 1 subscribers are engaged the delaywill beThe number <strong>of</strong> calls for the time interval


The <strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> calls in the period dtis, however, Pffdt, so that the number <strong>of</strong> calls2R— 1which are delayed for a time— , calculatedin proportion <strong>to</strong> the entire number <strong>of</strong> callsbecomesThe number <strong>of</strong> calls delayed for a timethus isFor r 0 =1 we get especially the <strong>to</strong>tal<strong>of</strong> delayed subscribersnumberIt is also interesting <strong>to</strong> know the average delayT per call. The number <strong>of</strong> calls in all groupswith r — 1 delayed subscribers was xP x + rdt forthe period dt. Each one <strong>of</strong> these calls has <strong>to</strong>wait for the time so that the <strong>to</strong>taldelay isIf we sum up for all groups with r> 1 anddivide by the <strong>to</strong>tal number <strong>of</strong> calls Pydt, wegetWe uow introduce thenotationsand then haveFormulae for Numerical Computation.We pass on <strong>to</strong> deducing formulae suitablefor numerical computation. It obviously dependsupon summing up expressions <strong>of</strong> the formwhereandAccording lo the precedingThe order <strong>of</strong> magnitude <strong>of</strong> a. p and X is188


We, therefore, make an extremely slight errorif instead <strong>of</strong> the upper limit l— x in the sumswe put :x.For computing D and D l we shallthese sums in powers <strong>of</strong> a p.expandIt is then appropriate <strong>to</strong> introduce the notationit l y ~ l = the sum <strong>of</strong> all possible products<strong>of</strong> v <strong>of</strong> the numbers 1, 2 ... s— 1.On inserting the expressions for ,T,» 'we seelhat the other a and b will be composed <strong>of</strong>sums <strong>of</strong> the formWe shall, therefore, first calculate n n for somedifferent values <strong>of</strong> n.We getWe have thenwill have <strong>to</strong> satisfy te relationhenceFor D and D t we now getwherewithWe now getas well aswe immediately calculate<strong>to</strong>189


withForconsequentlyIf we introduce thenotationas before, we will havewe getAs a rule it is therefore sufficient <strong>to</strong> includeonly the first terms in the parentheses and putis here independent <strong>of</strong> ;/.Spec, we getFor high values <strong>of</strong> r (busy traffic) x grows,however, and may in such cases which arepossible rise <strong>to</strong> approximately 0,8. In suchcase the correction <strong>of</strong> the neglected terms becomesmuch greater, so that we should gel <strong>to</strong>osmall values for D and D t .This is, however, balanced by the formulafor R m at high z giving <strong>to</strong>o large values. Forwith a busy traffic our H m are comparativelylarge and by substituting H m by S m in the expressionSo + S1 . . . + S x + R x +1 + .... + Ri = 1we get <strong>to</strong>o great a value for S„ and consequentlyfor Rm.We therefore calculate withIf we have properly calculated a certain N r0according <strong>to</strong> the preceding formulae, it will beeasy <strong>to</strong> extract from this value the N r for otherr-values.First N R0 + 1 can be computed fromwhereis smallThusin proportion <strong>to</strong>FurthermorewhereWe now begin by computing X r , i. e.thenumber <strong>of</strong> calls delayed for a periodin proportion <strong>to</strong> the <strong>to</strong>lal number <strong>of</strong> calls.The equations (5) and (9'') give usand analogously190


generally thusExample: We supposel = 500 subscribersx = 45 linefindersIn this way the accompanying charts havebeen computed.Abscissa is « = 2r— 1, as ordinates have beenput N 1 N2, N 3 etc. for u = 1, 3, 5 etc.Approximation Formulae.We easily find simple approximation formulaefor the number <strong>of</strong> delayed calls S and theaverage delay T.According <strong>to</strong> the equations (5 1 ) and (9")We firsl calculatewhich is independent <strong>of</strong> y.FurthermoreThe equations (6) (9') and (9 11 )givefurthermorethusThe average delay per delayed call finally iswas, as we know (see page 157) the timewhich a call was delayed on an average if itwas the only one delayed. With this intervalas unit we get consequently191


Fig. 1. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 20 linefinilers over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.Example: Let us suppose a group <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers with x = 20 linefinders. .M= 700 SM and the duration <strong>of</strong> conversationa = 2 minutes. We want <strong>to</strong> know the number <strong>of</strong> calls delayed > 6 seconds, F'irst we calculate e fromThe curve for 700 SM then gives us <strong>to</strong>r this ((-value P = 13 ‰


Fig. 2. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 25 linefinders over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.193


Fig. 3. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 30 linefindera over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.194


Fig. 4. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 35 linefinders over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.195


Fig. 5. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 40 linefinders over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.196


Fig. 6. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 45 linefinders197over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.


Fig. 7. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 50 linefinders over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.198


Fig. 8. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 55 linefindersover a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.199


Fig. 9. Delays at free selection <strong>of</strong> 60 linefinders over a multiple <strong>of</strong> 500 subscribers.200


Working Reliability and Maintenance <strong>of</strong> the L. M. EricssonAu<strong>to</strong>matic Telephone System.By Anders Lignell, Direc<strong>to</strong>r <strong>of</strong> Telephones,S<strong>to</strong>ckholm.By working reliability <strong>of</strong> a telephone systemwe understand the capacity <strong>of</strong> the system<strong>to</strong> function correctly if properly used by thesubscriber.In the manual system, this reliability dependsnot only on the correct functioning <strong>of</strong> the technicalplant, but also — and not least — on theefficiency <strong>of</strong> the opera<strong>to</strong>rs, while in the whollyau<strong>to</strong>matic plant the personal opera<strong>to</strong>r is eliminatedand the reliability depends entirely on<strong>to</strong> what extent the technical devices can betrusted <strong>to</strong> perform their various functions.Continuous reliability control is highly importantfor satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry service, assuming thatthe control is arranged <strong>to</strong> test the whole systemand that the examination includes a sufficientnumber <strong>of</strong> calls <strong>to</strong> make the control results representative<strong>of</strong> the whole traffic.If that is the case, and if the control is applied<strong>to</strong> actual traffic and not <strong>to</strong> test calls madeby the staff, a clear idea <strong>of</strong> the real quality <strong>of</strong>the service is obtained, as the latter method forseveral reasons will not give the desired completeand reliable information regarding thetraffic. Further, provision should be made forfaulty connexions <strong>to</strong> be locked during the controland the faults traced and remedied. Thecontrol will then simultaneously act as a generalsearch for and removal <strong>of</strong> faults in the plant.In an au<strong>to</strong>matic system, where a remainingfault in any organ may disturb a great portion<strong>of</strong> the traffic, the importance <strong>of</strong> this is obvious.The efficiency <strong>of</strong> an au<strong>to</strong>matic system is frequentlyjudged by the number <strong>of</strong> repaired faultsrelatively <strong>to</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> subscribers or calls.But the fact that a comparatively small number<strong>of</strong> faults are discovered and put right is noguarantee that no faults remain in the system,nor that the service is satisfac<strong>to</strong>ry. The onlymeans <strong>of</strong> ascertaining this is by continuous reliabilitycontrol, which will give an actual picture<strong>of</strong> the service efficiency. The traffic controlpanels in S<strong>to</strong>ckholm are therefore arranged:partly for continuous reliability control,partly „ tracing faults and assisting thesubscribers (when any direc<strong>to</strong>ris occupied <strong>to</strong>o long, or whenthere is a fault caused by thesubscriber or by the equipment,a red lamp is lighted),and partly „ individual control, i. e. control<strong>of</strong> all traffic on a certain subscriber'sline.The accompanying Table I gives the result <strong>of</strong>continuous reliability control in 1929 <strong>of</strong> our oldestau<strong>to</strong>matic exchange "Norra Vasa" — a10 000 line exchange with 7 300 subscribers —which at the end <strong>of</strong> 1929 had been working for6 years.The "Total" column shows that out <strong>of</strong> 71 629controlled calls from subscribers — an average<strong>of</strong> 5 969 month, evenly distributed between alltraffic routes —93.53 per cent, have been faultless,3.28 „ „ <strong>of</strong> the faults have been causedby the subscriber,0.02 „ „ „ „ „ have been causedby the opera<strong>to</strong>r ina manual exchange,0.17 „ „ „ „ „ have been causedby the technicalequipment (subscribers'stationsor lines, or exchangeequipment).Out <strong>of</strong> the faults caused by the technicalequipment — 0.17 per cent — the origin <strong>of</strong> 57,or 0.08 per cent., have been located; 40 <strong>of</strong> these.— 201 —


TABLE I.or 0.05 per cent., have been located in the au<strong>to</strong>maticsystem, and 17, or 0.03 per cent., in otherexchanges, direct lines, or subscribers' stations.If we assume that the same percentage <strong>of</strong> the64 not located causes <strong>of</strong> faults can be referred<strong>to</strong> equipment outside the au<strong>to</strong>matic plant, whichis a safe assumption, as it is considerably moredifficult <strong>to</strong> locate faults outside the exchangethan inside it, only 0.107 per cent, <strong>of</strong> the causes<strong>of</strong> faults can be blamed on the au<strong>to</strong>matic equipment.The Table also shows very nearly the samepercentages during each <strong>of</strong> the several months,which proves that the reliability has been fairlyconstant throughout the year.The average <strong>of</strong> the faults committed by subscribersduring the year is 3.28 per cent.This high percentage is explained by the factthat the change <strong>to</strong> the au<strong>to</strong>matic system in thewhole telephone area has not yet proceeded farenough for the majority <strong>of</strong> the subscribers <strong>to</strong>become familiar with the proper way <strong>of</strong> dialling,and by faulty memorizing by the calling partywhen translating the manual numbers.— 202 —


TABLEII.The results <strong>of</strong> the control during January andFebruary 1930 are shown in Table II below.It will be noted out <strong>of</strong> 9 825 controlled calls— 4 900 per month —97.40 per cent, have been faultless,2.50 „ „ <strong>of</strong> the faults have been causedby the subscriber,0.10 „ „ „ „ „ have been causedby the technicalequipment.Out <strong>of</strong> the faults caused by the technical equipment— 0.10 per cent., <strong>of</strong> 9 825 controlled calls— the causes in 5 instances — 0.05 per cent. —have been located in the au<strong>to</strong>matic system, in1 instance — 0.01 per cent. — in a manual exchange,and in 4 instances — 0.04 per cent. —time has been <strong>to</strong>o short for the cause <strong>to</strong> be located.A maximum <strong>of</strong> 0.09 per cent <strong>of</strong> the faultscan thus be charged <strong>to</strong> the au<strong>to</strong>matic system,but this figure is <strong>to</strong>o high, as some <strong>of</strong> the 4 unlocatedfaults certainly should be referred <strong>to</strong>causes outside the au<strong>to</strong>matic plant. Losses frominsufficient exchange facilities do not occur inthe L. M. Ericsson system, as any such lack willonly prolong the time for obtaining a connexion.The control may therefore be said <strong>to</strong> havegiven the au<strong>to</strong>matic system an excellent characterfor reliability.Faults caused by the calling party are alsoreduced from 3.28 <strong>to</strong> 2.50 per cent.The results <strong>of</strong> the control designed <strong>to</strong> assistsubscribers and simultaneously <strong>to</strong> trace faults ifrequired are shown in the attached Table III.The red lamp is lit immediately if the callerdials a combination which is not on the selec<strong>to</strong>rregister, and after 24 seconds if the direc<strong>to</strong>r isheld <strong>to</strong>o long (handset removed from the cradlerest), if an insufficient number <strong>of</strong> figures aredialled, or if there is a technical fault.During the year 19 736 calls on red lampshave been examined. In 19 361 <strong>of</strong> these, or 98.1per cent., the fault has been the subscriber's, whohas then received assistance and requisite advice.Out <strong>of</strong> the 375 remaining instances, or 1.9per cent, <strong>of</strong> these red lamp signals,149 have been faults in own exchange,31 „ „ „ „ other exchanges,23 „ „ „ „ subscribers' lines, and20 „ „ „ „ subscribers' stations, a<strong>to</strong>tal <strong>of</strong> 223 faultswhich have been traced and remedied, whiletime has not allowed 152 <strong>of</strong> the faults <strong>to</strong> betraced. 189 causes <strong>of</strong> faults in the au<strong>to</strong>maticsystem (40 by continuous control and 149through red lamp signals) have thus been removedby the control, which is 35 per cent, <strong>of</strong>all faults remedied in the au<strong>to</strong>matic system duringthe year. The importance <strong>of</strong> this control forthe working reliability <strong>of</strong> the exchange is obvious.Regarding maintenance costs, it might be mentionedthat in the Kungsholmen au<strong>to</strong>matic Exchange,opened in June 1928 and equipped for15 000 subscribers with an average <strong>of</strong> 10 640— 203 -


TABLE III.connected lines during 1929, the year's maintenancecosts have been Kr. 4:02 per subscriber.This cost includes all work and material,cleaning <strong>of</strong> premises and equipment, also cost <strong>of</strong>night attendance as well as staff holidays andsick leave. The maintenance staff has consisted<strong>of</strong> nine male repairers, 6 <strong>of</strong> whom are detailed<strong>to</strong> the selec<strong>to</strong>r rooms and 3 <strong>to</strong> the cross-connexionfield and the faults department, and two femaleassistants.The average traffic is 6 calls per day andsubscriber, and 0.7 calls per subscriber in TheBusy Hour.The third kind <strong>of</strong> control — individual control— is used for faultfinding subscribers, and isessential <strong>to</strong> facilitate the straightening out <strong>of</strong>complaints regarding recording <strong>of</strong> calls or theservice generally, which cannot be satisfac<strong>to</strong>rilychecked in any other way.April 15th 1930.— 204 —


Lead Covered Rubber Cable Installations.By EinarThe jubilee celebrated in 1929 in memory <strong>of</strong>the invention by Edison <strong>of</strong> the incandescentelectric lamp was at the same time a jubilee <strong>of</strong>the popular use <strong>of</strong> electricity. It is true thatelectricity had been utilized as a source <strong>of</strong> lightquite a number <strong>of</strong> years before, but it was notuntil the invention <strong>of</strong> the handy little Edisonglow lamp that electric light became a domesticsource <strong>of</strong> light. By this invention electricity becameby and by the property <strong>of</strong> everybody whichat present we can consider it <strong>to</strong> be.During the first decades <strong>of</strong> this developmentelectricity was, however, <strong>to</strong> costly a merchandisefor the ordinary man. It is true that electicitygeneration plants were erected in a great number<strong>of</strong> cities, but owing <strong>to</strong> the high costs onlyprominent dwelling-houses, hotels and publicbuildings were provided with electric light.For industrial purposes electric light came in<strong>to</strong>use at rather an early date, since it had beenfound out that the output <strong>of</strong> labour increasedwith improved illumination.In the solid dwelling-houses and other technicallycomparable places where the first installations<strong>of</strong> electric light were introduced, theinstallation conditions were rather favourableand in addition the voltage applied amounted asa rule only <strong>to</strong> 110 volts. The strain on the installationmaterial was therefore unimportantand as a natural consequence here<strong>of</strong> the materialwas, in many respects, <strong>of</strong> rather a frail construction.It <strong>to</strong>ok so long a time before electric light hadbecome in a proper sense generally spread that atradition, rather deeply rooted, as <strong>to</strong> the construction<strong>of</strong> electrical installations had had time<strong>to</strong> develop before that. Unfortunately, this traditionwas not based on pr<strong>of</strong>ound studies <strong>of</strong> theproblem but was sooner the result <strong>of</strong> experiencegained in the working places. The manufacturersthemselves did not pay much attention <strong>to</strong>Olsson.the installation problem and the specific installationmaterial was constructed chiefly from thepoint <strong>of</strong> view <strong>of</strong> cheapness. This point <strong>of</strong> viewbecame more and more prominent in the course<strong>of</strong> time, and a considerable portion <strong>of</strong> the installationmaterial sold during the years 1910—1920was appreciably inferior <strong>to</strong> the material in themarket during the previous ten years.When electricity came in<strong>to</strong> use in industrialplaces it became necessary <strong>to</strong> undertake a number<strong>of</strong> reconstructions and it was now that theheavy armoured conduit material and the singlecoreconduc<strong>to</strong>r installations were wrought out.However, both these systems suffered from certaindeficiencies, but as long as electricity wasused chiefly in thickly settled communities or inindustries having installers <strong>of</strong> their own, thedifficulties due <strong>to</strong> unsuitable construction <strong>of</strong> theinstallation material were fairly well overcome.That no vigourous measures were taken, may beexplained by the fact that electricity was so newthat those busy in this sphere knew nothing elsebut that it should be troublesome. Besides, theintroduction <strong>of</strong> electric light always involved sogreat an improvement that the difficulties encounterednow and then were not considered <strong>to</strong>be <strong>of</strong> any great importance.The difficulties began in earnest when, withthe invention <strong>of</strong> the three phase alternating current,it became possible <strong>to</strong> distribute electricityalso in rural areas. To this contributed aswell that the local conditions in the <strong>of</strong>fices <strong>of</strong> afarm are <strong>of</strong> such a kind as <strong>to</strong> expose the installationmaterial <strong>to</strong> very hard stress <strong>of</strong> chemical,electrical and mechanical nature.In Sweden the electrification fever in therural districts during the time <strong>of</strong> the world-wardisclosed in sharp colours illuminated by firesand marked by deaths and accidents the defects<strong>of</strong> the materials used, and forced on the reconstructionwork which finally resulted in the lead— 205 -


Light installation with lead covered rubber cable material incow-stables.covered rubber cable system coming every davmore and more in<strong>to</strong> use.It was in the first place the fire-insurancecompanies who drew the attention <strong>of</strong> the manufacturersand other technicians <strong>to</strong> the subject,and an intensive work commenced with aview <strong>to</strong> repair the deficiencies. Now the installationproblem was studied in detailfor the first time, and soon enough itbecame evident that the accidents occurredcould not very well be regardedas the result <strong>of</strong> the concurrence<strong>of</strong> a number <strong>of</strong> unlucky circumstancesbut that rather a combination <strong>of</strong>lucky circumstances was required inorder that no accidents should happen.In other words, the installationmaterial used was unsuitable andthe installation methods did not givesafe results.If we make a short technical review<strong>of</strong> the way in which older installationsystems, single wire conduc<strong>to</strong>rson porcelain insula<strong>to</strong>rs andarmoured conduit installations, actagainst stress <strong>of</strong> different nature, we obtain thepro<strong>of</strong>s <strong>of</strong> the unsuitability <strong>of</strong> these systems.It is perfectly clear that the mechanicalstrength <strong>of</strong> an installation with thin single conduc<strong>to</strong>rson porcelain insula<strong>to</strong>rs is very imperfect.The insula<strong>to</strong>rs situated at a distancefrom one another <strong>of</strong> about one meter give a badhold <strong>to</strong> the wires which are easily <strong>to</strong>rn away.The insula<strong>to</strong>rs themselves are easily brokenwhich also applies <strong>to</strong> the fittings and the switches.From an electrical point <strong>of</strong> view thestrength <strong>of</strong> a plant is measured by its insulation,that is, its resistance <strong>to</strong> earth, and experiencehas shown that this insulation is, in the case <strong>of</strong>single conduc<strong>to</strong>r installations, <strong>to</strong> a high degreedepending on the humidity in the place. If theinsulation measurements are executed in wintertimewhen the localities are warm and damp itis <strong>of</strong>ten impossible <strong>to</strong> obtain any measurablevalue by the aid <strong>of</strong> an ordinary insulation measuringinstrument. One is therefore quite justifiedin saying that in the case <strong>of</strong> single conduc<strong>to</strong>rinstallations a more or less strong leakage <strong>of</strong>electricity always takes place in damp places.This circumstance is also reflected in the prescriptions,where no definite value <strong>of</strong> insulationis stipulated for single conduc<strong>to</strong>r installations.It is, above all, the joints insulated by handwhich cause the bad insulation. Such a jointinsulated with rubber and insulation tape excludesthe moisture as long as the tapes are new,but as soon as the rubber and the tapes havedried thev absorbe moisture. Since the wholeHusum sulphate mill, entirely equipped with lead covered rubber cable.— 206 —


Husum sulphate mill, hall <strong>of</strong> paper machines.braiding <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>r is generally soakedwith moisture the outer part <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rbecomes alive, electricity leaks out and there isdanger <strong>of</strong> life present.Most <strong>of</strong> those who have been working in placeswhere the electrical installations are executed bymeans <strong>of</strong> single-core conduc<strong>to</strong>rs know wellenough how easy it is <strong>to</strong> get a "shock" from theconduc<strong>to</strong>rs.It is those leak currents which make a singleconduc<strong>to</strong>r plant so little resistant from a chemicalpoint <strong>of</strong> view. As an example may be mentioneda single conduc<strong>to</strong>r installation mountedon the damp hay-l<strong>of</strong>t above a horse-stable. Thisinstallation had been in service onlya few months, but during this periodthe wires had worn <strong>of</strong>f a couple <strong>of</strong>times, and from this reason been soheated that they had broken. Glowingparticles had fallen down in<strong>to</strong>the hay s<strong>to</strong>red on the l<strong>of</strong>t. The heavymoisture on the l<strong>of</strong>t had come fromsome ventilation ducts leading fromthe stable <strong>to</strong> the l<strong>of</strong>t. Thanks <strong>to</strong> thismoisture the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs were destroyedbut at the same time the haybecame so damp that it was not se<strong>to</strong>n fire by the glowing pieces <strong>of</strong> conduc<strong>to</strong>rsfalling down in<strong>to</strong> it.It is <strong>to</strong> the electrolysis always occurringin damp places that the destruction<strong>of</strong> material is due. Electrolysisalways presents itself where twometals <strong>of</strong> different nature are connectedwith one another by means <strong>of</strong>a fluid acting as electrolyte. This isgenerally the case with all the water<strong>of</strong> condensation in a damp locality,which absorbes or dissolves in it anumber <strong>of</strong> corrosive gasses.From what has been said above weobtain the following conditions forinstallations in damp places; firstly,that all live parts should be hermeticallyenclosed in an effective manner,secondly, that all combination <strong>of</strong> differentmetals should be avoided or,where this is not possible, that themetals should be well insulated fromone another.An armoured conduit installationis mechanically strong as far as concerns theconduc<strong>to</strong>rs placed in the conduit. On the otherhand the fittings are more fragile. This obtainsespecially with regard <strong>to</strong> rigid tube pendants.The ordinary armoured conduit consists as arule <strong>of</strong> rather thin stuff and this applies also<strong>to</strong> the conduit boxes. A piece <strong>of</strong> tube screwedin<strong>to</strong> the cover <strong>of</strong> a box and thus rigidly fixedis easily broken even in the case <strong>of</strong> a relativelysmall stress at the lower end <strong>of</strong> the tube wherethe fittings are.From electrical standpoint an armoured conduitinstallation is solid as long as the temperatureis the same all over the various parts <strong>of</strong>Lead covered rubber cable installation in cow-stables.207


the tube system. Since this, however, is neverthe case the electric strength is generally ratherproblematic. The prescriptions require an insulation<strong>of</strong> at least 220.000 ohms between anytwo successive fuses or for each group <strong>of</strong> lamps,and as long as the installation does really showthis insulation it is also reliable. But ratherlittle is required <strong>to</strong> lower the insulation so muchthat danger arises. The worst enemy <strong>of</strong> tubeinstallations is condensation <strong>of</strong> moisture withinthe tubes. There are still people who believethat an armoured tube installation is a closedsystem, and it is possible <strong>to</strong> so construct an installation<strong>of</strong> this kind that it becomes hermeticallyclosed. This is done by sectionalizing thesystem in<strong>to</strong> a number <strong>of</strong> small parts by means<strong>of</strong> filling in compound and by making tight allthe tube joints by the aid <strong>of</strong> <strong>to</strong>w prepared withread lead. However, if only a rubber packingin a conduit box. is dried, or the sealing <strong>of</strong> aswitch becomes untight, this is enough <strong>to</strong> givethe external air free access <strong>to</strong> the tube system.As a rule the external air is supposed <strong>to</strong> haveaccess <strong>to</strong> the tubes and it is endeavoured <strong>to</strong> reduceby drainage the risks thereby involved.Condensation <strong>of</strong> moisture in the tubes alwaystakes place when the tube passes from a hotroom <strong>to</strong> a colder one. As soon as the humidity<strong>of</strong> the air exceeds the point <strong>of</strong> saturation corresponding<strong>to</strong> the existing temperature, part <strong>of</strong>it comes out in the form <strong>of</strong> water <strong>of</strong> condensation.This water <strong>of</strong> condensation attacks theinsulation <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs and makes thebraiding rot away on the wires and the tubesrust internally. Current leakage takes place aswell at joints dried through in the junction boxesas at points where the insulation is damaged.Most <strong>of</strong> the fires caused by electricity are due<strong>to</strong> defective tube installations.The result obtained from researches as <strong>to</strong> thenumerous accidents in the rural areas was disheartening,and it became clear <strong>to</strong> all partiesconcerned that the installation problem ought <strong>to</strong>be considered in full if a lasting result was <strong>to</strong> beexpected.Upon the application <strong>of</strong> a number <strong>of</strong> personsinterested in this question the Sieverts Kabelverk<strong>to</strong>ok up the problem in 1922. Quite naturallyit was in the first place the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs whichwere made the object <strong>of</strong> the interest <strong>of</strong> the fac<strong>to</strong>ry,and by utilizing the experience gainedFig. 1. Lead covered rubber cables:Bare cableUnarmoured cableArmoured cablefrom the manufacture <strong>of</strong> lead cables, the construction<strong>of</strong> lead covered rubber cables shownin tigure 1 came out as the result <strong>of</strong> a number<strong>of</strong> experiments. This cable consists <strong>of</strong> tinnedcopper conduc<strong>to</strong>rs insulated by means <strong>of</strong> vulcanizedrubber. In the case <strong>of</strong> multi-core cablestwo or more such conduc<strong>to</strong>rs are twisted <strong>to</strong>getherand further insulated with vulcanizedrubber so that a circular cross section is obtained.A lead sheath is pressed around therubber and the bare lead covered rubber cableshown at the <strong>to</strong>p <strong>of</strong> figure 1 is finished. Conduc<strong>to</strong>rs<strong>of</strong> this kind with uncovered metal sheathmay only be utilized in places where they areprotected from both chemical and mechanicalinjurs'. The lead sheath <strong>of</strong> the cable shown inthe middle <strong>of</strong> figure 1 is protected from chemicalaction by means <strong>of</strong> a serving <strong>of</strong> asphalt compoundover which are wrapped several carefullyimpregnated cellulose tapes. Outermost is placeda braiding, likewise impregnated. Conduc<strong>to</strong>rs<strong>of</strong> this construction can be installed anywherewhere they are not exposed <strong>to</strong> serious mechanicalinjury. The third cable shown in figure 1is the armoured lead covered rubber cable thathas been most in use up <strong>to</strong> now. It has prooved<strong>to</strong> bear exceedingly well any kind <strong>of</strong> strain <strong>of</strong>mechanical as well as <strong>of</strong> chemical and electricalnature. The armouring consists <strong>of</strong> two leadplatedand asphalted iron tapes.The outer braiding <strong>of</strong> the lead covered rubbercable is impregnated either with a kind <strong>of</strong> asphaltcompound or with red lead and linseedoil.The first-mentioned impregnation is moreresistant from the chemical point <strong>of</strong> view and itshould be employed in all places where it is notdesired <strong>to</strong> have the cable painted in other thanblack colour. But where that is the case the redlead impregnation is used. Places in which the- 208 —


ed lead impregnated cable is not resistant arethose where the reaction <strong>of</strong> the condensed humidityis basic. For linseed-oil is an organicgrease which is easily changed in<strong>to</strong> soap andwashed away when attacked by basic solutions.As an example <strong>of</strong> places where the red lead impregnationshould not be employed may be mentionedcattle-stables <strong>of</strong> any kind and laundries.To secure a reliable installation it is notsufficient <strong>to</strong> possess excellent conducting materialsbut it is also necessary that fittings andswitching devices should be just as reliable. Tosolve this problem was thus the next step in thework. As mentioned before the investigation <strong>of</strong>the older installation systems had clearlv mani-Fig. 2. Complete lamp fitting with switch and shade.fested that in order <strong>to</strong> obtain a resistant installationin damp places all live parts ought <strong>to</strong> behermetically enclosed. This was also made acondition not <strong>to</strong> be dispensed with when workingout the constructions. Simplicity <strong>of</strong> constructionand resistance against all kinds <strong>of</strong>strains were also requirements which it was endeavoured<strong>to</strong> fulfil as far as possible. The resultis indicated in figure 2 showing a complete lampfitting with conduit box, switch and lamp holderwith protective globe and shade.The junction box is made <strong>of</strong> lead-plated ironplate, japanned cast iron, or bakelite. In themetal boxes there is a connecting block <strong>of</strong> bakelitecarrying two, three or four connectionsockets. The connections are performed byloopingthe conduc<strong>to</strong>rs around the sockets andfixing them with nuts. The switch is connected<strong>to</strong> the junction box by plugging three contactplugs on its upper side in<strong>to</strong> the sockets <strong>of</strong> theconnecting block.The switch is a press but<strong>to</strong>n switch manoeuvredby means <strong>of</strong> an external and an internallever arm, both joined <strong>to</strong> a shaft placed in aspecial bearing. The cover <strong>of</strong> the switch and itsinner conducting parts are made entirely <strong>of</strong>bakelite. On the <strong>of</strong>f side <strong>of</strong> the switch, countedfrom the junction box, there are two sockets forthe connection <strong>of</strong> the lamp holder.To the external manoeuvre arm <strong>of</strong> the switchis fixed a strap equipped at its other end with apulling ring. This pulling strap can if necessarybe led through a guide pulley or through glassrings <strong>to</strong> the place from where it is desired <strong>to</strong>handle the switch. It is, however, preferable <strong>to</strong>have the plant arranged in such a way that thisprocedure is not necessary.The lamp holder is also <strong>of</strong> bakelite, and bymeans<strong>of</strong> contact plugs it is either, like theswitch, directly connected <strong>to</strong> contact sockets inthe junction box or <strong>to</strong> a switch fixed <strong>to</strong> thejunction box. The lamp socket is provided withnormal Edison thread but this thread is not conducting.Contact with the lamp is effected bymeans<strong>of</strong> a spring contact and <strong>of</strong> an elastic ring.Contact is not made until the lamp is almost entirelyscrewed in<strong>to</strong> the socket. Neither the lampholder nor the switch are provided with anyscrewingdevices, but are both held fast <strong>to</strong> thejunction box by means <strong>of</strong> screws from theholding ring fixing the glass globe <strong>to</strong> the lampholder.Between the different parts <strong>of</strong> the fittingsare inserted packings <strong>of</strong> first-rate rubber.Thanks <strong>to</strong> the broad and even surfaces betweenthe various parts the stress on these packings isnot hard and their life-time is therefore considerable.The holding ring also holds in place the shadesbelonging <strong>to</strong> the fittings. If necessary a protectiveguard may be screwed <strong>to</strong> the holding ring.The protective globe consists either <strong>of</strong> ordinarytransparent glass or <strong>of</strong> glass with opalescentcasing. The former construction is usedin rooms where no very accurate work is <strong>to</strong> becarried out and the latter in places where thelamp glare may be dangerous or diminish thelabour output.The reflec<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>of</strong> the fittings are <strong>of</strong> two kinds.One shades the light so as <strong>to</strong> produce a lightcone with a <strong>to</strong>p angle <strong>of</strong> <strong>12</strong>0° whereas the other— 209 -


Fig. 3. Connec<strong>to</strong>r with rubber-lead packing.one gives a light cone with a <strong>to</strong>p angle <strong>of</strong> 180°,that is, the light is shaded in such a way thatthe upper limiting surface becomes a plane goingthrough the luminous body <strong>of</strong> the lamp. Thereflec<strong>to</strong>rs are coded according <strong>to</strong> the <strong>to</strong>p angle<strong>of</strong> the light and are called <strong>12</strong>0° and 180° reflec<strong>to</strong>rsrespectively. The first-mentioned one ismore economic and should be preferred in roomsthe height <strong>of</strong> which exceeds 3.5 meters.The most important detail <strong>of</strong> the constructionis the jointing at the point where the conduc<strong>to</strong>renters the junction box, and much constructionand experimental work has been devoted <strong>to</strong> thisdetail, a work that finally resulted in the leadcovered rubber joint shown in figure 3. It consists<strong>of</strong> a rubber bushing both ends <strong>of</strong> which arecovered with lead. Fig. 3 shows how the closingup <strong>of</strong> the joint is carried out. When the packingis compressed a metallic connection between thelead sheath and the junction boxes is obtainedat the same time as the joint is tightened. TheFig. 4. Junction box with three outlets.lead sleeving on the rubber packing is hard pressed<strong>to</strong> both the lead sheath and the metal socke<strong>to</strong>f the box. At the same time as the lead groundsthe metal sheath <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>r it protects theFig. 5. Complete lamp fitting without switch but with 180° reflec<strong>to</strong>r.rubber from attacks <strong>of</strong> the air, which prevents,if not entirely, yet <strong>to</strong> a high degree, the rubberfrom aging. Experience gained from deliveredinstallations has shown that the rubber inpackings being in service since more than 6 yearsis still just as s<strong>of</strong>t and elastic as it was wheninstalled.The parts described above, viz. junction box,switch and lamp holder with protecting guardand reflec<strong>to</strong>rs can be combined in many differentways.If a box is equipped with a cover as indicatedin figure 4 we obtain a connection- or junctionbox. There are junction boxes with one, two,three, four or five outlets, and <strong>of</strong> connectionblocks there are threekinds, viz. blockswith two, three andfour connecting sockets.By combiningthese two parts wecan obtain 15 differentjunction boxes.If in addition thepackings are alsovaried an almost infinitenumber <strong>of</strong> combinationsis obtainedwhich should be able<strong>to</strong> satisfy almost anyimaginable requirements.In the boxesone-, two-, three-, andfour core conduc<strong>to</strong>rsup <strong>to</strong> 6 mm 2 can beFig. 6. Pendant with leadcovered rubber conduc<strong>to</strong>r.210


Fig. 7. Connecting cover for pendant with lead covered rubberconduc<strong>to</strong>rs.connected. For the connecting in <strong>of</strong> conduc<strong>to</strong>rsthicker than 4X6 mm 2 other boxes with biggerconnec<strong>to</strong>rs are used.To each one <strong>of</strong> the abovementioned types <strong>of</strong>junction boxes can be screwed a lamp holderwith or without reflec<strong>to</strong>r. In figure 5 is showna combination <strong>of</strong> junction box, lamp holder withprotective glass and 180° reflec<strong>to</strong>r. By fittingthe switch in between, further combinations areobtained.To complete the system a pendant constructionhas been worked out. This pendant shown infigure 6 consists at the <strong>to</strong>p <strong>of</strong> an ordinaryjunction box covered by a pendant cover <strong>of</strong> theconstruction indicated in figure 7. To this coverbelongs a connec<strong>to</strong>r differring from the onedescribed in the preceeding only by its somewhatgreater length. In the pendant cover there isfurther a bakelite block carrying connecting pinsin the case <strong>of</strong> the upper cover, and connectingsockets in the case <strong>of</strong> the lower cover, which isotherwise almost identical with the upper one.The pendant cable is armoured with iron wireand from figure 7 is seen how the connection isbrought about. The armouring wires are bentaround a ring which is placed between thepacking and the screwing sleeve with a washeron each side. When the screwing sleeve is pulledtight the mechanical fastening <strong>of</strong> the armouringwires is brought about as well as the closing up<strong>of</strong> the joint and the grounding. At the bot<strong>to</strong>mis fitted a lamp holder which can be equippedwith reflec<strong>to</strong>rs or protective guards as wanted. Ifa switch is <strong>to</strong> be provided for such a pendant itshould be mounted between the upper pendantcover and the junction box.Pendants always have some advantages overrigidly mounted fittings. So, for instance, thelamps last longer because they are less exposedFig. 8. Junction box for connecting lead covered rubber cable <strong>to</strong>single core conduc<strong>to</strong>r.<strong>to</strong> vibrations. In addition, when using pendantsit is easier <strong>to</strong> place the source <strong>of</strong> light at thepoint where it gives the best effect. The mostimportant advantage is, however, that this kind<strong>of</strong> fitting is not by far so much exposed <strong>to</strong> chemicalaction. The walls <strong>of</strong> a room are generallycolder than the air in the room, and the risk <strong>of</strong>condensation is at highest along these. It maybe true that the absolute percentage <strong>of</strong> humidityin the air close by a pendant fitting at a distance<strong>of</strong> one meter from the ceiling, is the same as inthe air near the ceiling, but since no coolingdown takes place no condensation <strong>of</strong> water canoccur on the fitting. It is therefore <strong>of</strong>tenpossible <strong>to</strong> employ pendants without protectiveglobes even in relatively damp places. In suchcases lamps up <strong>to</strong> 200 watts can be used for thefitting shown in figure 6.To the system beloag further devices for hermeticalenclosing <strong>of</strong> lamps up <strong>to</strong> 200 watts. Itdoes not pay <strong>to</strong> close in lamps <strong>of</strong> bigger sizehermetically since the costs <strong>of</strong> the coolingarrangements required will be <strong>to</strong>o high. As isknown the life-time <strong>of</strong> a lamp is much reducedif it is not kept well cooled.When reconstructing older installations constructedwith single core conduc<strong>to</strong>rs, it is <strong>of</strong>tennecessary <strong>to</strong> have the possibility <strong>of</strong> combiningFig. 9. Simplified fitting for rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>rs.— 211 -


in an easy way this system with the lead coveredrubber cable system. For this purpose are usedjunction boxes with connec<strong>to</strong>rs for single coreconduc<strong>to</strong>rs as shown in figure 8. This figureshows a so-called Y-box <strong>to</strong> which two singlecore conduc<strong>to</strong>rs are joined. The connec<strong>to</strong>rs forthese conduc<strong>to</strong>rs consist <strong>of</strong> a porcelain bushingand a rubber ring. In other respects it is identical<strong>to</strong> the box shown in figure 3. The rubberbushing shall close tightly <strong>to</strong> the rubber insulationwhich necessitates the removal <strong>of</strong> thebraiding.If the rubber-lead conducting material is <strong>to</strong>be joined <strong>to</strong> an armoured tube installation thisis done simply by screwing the tube directly orvia a reduction nipple in<strong>to</strong> the junction box, thethread in the conduc<strong>to</strong>r inlet being <strong>of</strong> the normalsize for the standard 19.2 mm armouredconduit (OP-tube).In places which are not damp a simplifiedform <strong>of</strong> fitting as shown in figure 9 may be employed.It consists <strong>of</strong> a standard table lampholder mounted in a junction box. The box isthen covered with a protective globe and theclosed fitting thus formed can be equipped withprotective guards and shades <strong>of</strong> various kinds.In dry places even if there is danger <strong>of</strong> firethese fittings are as reliable as those <strong>of</strong> the moreexpensive construction described previously.They are fire-pro<strong>of</strong> only as long as the protectiveglobe is unbroken, and this holds true <strong>of</strong>both constructions. In a damp room the simplifiedfitting is reliable as long as the protectiveFig. 10. Supporting board with cable clip.globe is unbroken but if the globe is broken —an eventuality always <strong>to</strong> be reckoned with —the cable will easily be destroyed when the dampair gets access <strong>to</strong> the cable ends in the box. Thisdanger does not exist in dry rooms where thesimplified fitting may therefore be advantageouslyutilized.In order that the advantages <strong>of</strong> the rubberleadconducting system shall be fully acknowledgedit is necessary <strong>to</strong> have it installed in asatisfac<strong>to</strong>ry way both technically and economically.It has already been pointed out thatthe worst enemy <strong>of</strong> this material in damp placesis electrolysis which should therefore be neutralized<strong>to</strong> the greatest possible extent. This isdone by means <strong>of</strong> insulation. The fittings andconduc<strong>to</strong>rs are insulated from the wall or theceiling by being mounted on a board impregnatedwith some good wood-impregnating stuff.This board is mounted at some distance fromthe wall boarding. The distance varies betweenFig. 11. Wall inlet with supporting cleats.10 and 50 mm according <strong>to</strong> the proportion <strong>of</strong>humidity in the place where the installation iscarried out. On this board (see fig. 10) the conduc<strong>to</strong>rsare mounted with double clips <strong>of</strong> impregnatedwood or porcelain. The latter materialis better but somewhat more expensive.The fittings and the clips are fastened by means<strong>of</strong> galvanized screws and the supporting boardsby means <strong>of</strong> galvanized nails.Within breweries the use <strong>of</strong> supporting woodenboards is not desired. The fact is that the woodcan get mouldy, and mould is one <strong>of</strong> the worstthings met with in a brewery where only suchfungi are desired as are necessary for the fermentation<strong>of</strong> the beer. The conduc<strong>to</strong>rs aretherefore fastened immediately <strong>to</strong> the wall, <strong>to</strong>the ceiling, or <strong>to</strong> the iron framework with porcelainclips.In slightly damp places the supporting boardcan be dispensed with and cables and fittingsbe installed in the same way as in breweries.But in this case wood clips can be used withoutany risk.In dry places the cable is installed in the same— 2<strong>12</strong> —


Fig. <strong>12</strong>. Junction box for switch.way as an ordinary conduc<strong>to</strong>r in a s<strong>of</strong>t metaltube (kuhlo-conduc<strong>to</strong>r) with a sheath <strong>of</strong> leadedor galvanized iron. But very <strong>of</strong>ten it is moreconvenient <strong>to</strong> make use <strong>of</strong> a supporting board.So for instance the installation will be easier andcheaper if a supporting board is used in the casecable. These cleats should have such dimensionsthat the bend <strong>of</strong> the cable does not exceed theone corresponding <strong>to</strong> a bending radius <strong>of</strong> fivetimes the diameter <strong>of</strong> the cable.Ceiling inlets are carried out in the same waywith the only difference that the cable shouldbe equipped with a mechanical guard up <strong>to</strong> aheight <strong>of</strong> 1.5 m above the upper surface <strong>of</strong> theframework. This guard can consist either otan iron tube fixed <strong>to</strong> the cable with compoundor <strong>of</strong> a properly adapted wood duct.When peeling the cable great care should betaken that the lead sheath is not damaged andalso that it is well cleaned up at the point encompassedby the packing. This is necessary <strong>to</strong>Fig. 13. Electrical installation project for big farm.where the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs are <strong>to</strong> be mounted underneatha concrete framework across the beams.Wall and ceiling inlets should be handled verycarefully. The cable is here specially protectedby means <strong>of</strong> a tube fastened <strong>to</strong> it with compund,before installing. The tube should be longenough <strong>to</strong> protrude at least 10 mm outside thewall, and the space between the tube and thewall should be carefully tightened, in a woodenwall with <strong>to</strong>w and oakum, in a s<strong>to</strong>ne wall withconcrete or plaster. Figure 11 shows a wall inletwith a lead tube fastened <strong>to</strong> the cable. Inthe same figure is also shown how supportingcleats should be applied at outward bends <strong>of</strong> theobtain an effective contact between the leadsheath and the junction box.Figure <strong>12</strong> shows the connections in a junctionbox intended for a switch. The connecting blockin a box <strong>of</strong> this kind must be equipped withthree connection sockets in order <strong>to</strong> permit theoutgoing conduc<strong>to</strong>r <strong>to</strong> be connected either beforeor behind the switch. The connectingsocket in the middle is surounded by a red ringand <strong>to</strong> this one the neutral wire should bejoined. One <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs in the cable isred coloured and by joining it <strong>to</strong> the neutral atthe distribution point and <strong>to</strong> the red sockets <strong>of</strong>all the junction boxes the correct connection is— 213 -


obtained. On installation the lamp holder willbe au<strong>to</strong>matically connected <strong>to</strong> the middle connectionsocket, and this whether a switch ismounted in between or not. The connections inthe box are so arranged that the switch as wellas the lamp holder can be joined <strong>to</strong> the junctionbox in one way only. This kind <strong>of</strong> connectionthus eliminates every possibility <strong>of</strong> confusion.If the connections in the junction box areTo derive full advantage <strong>of</strong> the rubber-leadcable system it is necessary <strong>to</strong> plan the installationscorrectly with application <strong>of</strong> all the possibilities<strong>of</strong> combination <strong>of</strong>fered by the system.This can be illustrated in the best and simplestway by an example. Figure 13 indicates a bigfarm the <strong>of</strong>fices <strong>of</strong> which are in part built <strong>to</strong>gether.The current is three phase alternatingcurrent <strong>of</strong> 500 volts. From the aerial line passingcarried out in the way shown in figure <strong>12</strong> theswitch will serve not only the lamp holder mounteddirectly on the switch but all the lamps behindit as well. If, on the other hand, the outgoingconduc<strong>to</strong>rs are connected <strong>to</strong> the samesockets as the incoming conduc<strong>to</strong>rs the lampslying behind will be entirely independent <strong>of</strong> theswitch. If the outgoing conduc<strong>to</strong>r is a threecoreconduc<strong>to</strong>r some <strong>of</strong> the subsequent lampsmay be manoeuvred by means <strong>of</strong> the switchfixed <strong>to</strong> the junction box and others be left independen<strong>to</strong>f it.The junction boxes can <strong>of</strong> course be utilizedfor one or more junctions at the same time asthey hold the switch and the lamp holder. Thejunctions can be connected before or behind theswitch.Fig. 14. Light installation in the <strong>of</strong>fices <strong>of</strong> a big farm.— 214by the farm an underground cable has been laid<strong>to</strong> a small transformer station erected in theyard between the buildings. From this transformerstation underground cables go <strong>to</strong> all thebuildings. For power purposes current <strong>of</strong> 500volts is used but for the illumination there is atransformer 500/220 volts. The lighting conduc<strong>to</strong>rs<strong>to</strong> the various buildings also consist <strong>of</strong>underground cables. In this way all live bareparts on the ground <strong>of</strong> the farm are avoided andat the same time the best possible reliability <strong>of</strong>service is secured.Figure 14 shows the light plant in the <strong>of</strong>fices.It consists entirely <strong>of</strong> lead covered rubber cable.Since it is important from the point <strong>of</strong> view <strong>of</strong>saving current and with respect <strong>to</strong> the risk <strong>of</strong>fire that the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs in the buildings should


not be alive any longer than is absolutely necessary,every group <strong>of</strong> lamps is equipped withan outdoor group switch which also lights anoutdoor lamp. By looking out in<strong>to</strong> the farmyardthe owner can therefore immediately seewhether the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs within the buildings arealive or not. All the switches appartaining <strong>to</strong> theplant ar? placed near the lamps. Thus all specialswitch conduc<strong>to</strong>rs with the dangers theyinvolve are avoided, and simultaneously thenumber <strong>of</strong> junction boxes is reduced.The question <strong>of</strong> costs is <strong>of</strong>ten decisive for thechoice <strong>of</strong> installation system. The cheapestsystem is generally preferred. But even herethe old paradox applies that "he who pays dearbuys cheap". It is not the initial material costsand the installation costs that should be compared<strong>to</strong> one another, but it is the sum <strong>of</strong> amortizationand maintenance costs that gives thereal comparative values.Figure 15 shows graphically the costs <strong>of</strong> installedconduc<strong>to</strong>rs for three installation systems,Fig. 15. Graphical tabic indicating installation costs with different conduc<strong>to</strong>r systems.If in planning an installation one hesitateswhether <strong>to</strong> install a junction box or <strong>to</strong> put ina few meters more <strong>of</strong> cable it may be mentioned,by way <strong>of</strong> information, that the installation costsfor a junction box correspond <strong>to</strong> that <strong>of</strong> fivemeters <strong>of</strong> cable. Thus, if it is possible <strong>to</strong> savemore than five meters <strong>of</strong> cable it will be cheaper<strong>to</strong> install an additional junction box but in othercases not.As is obvious from figure 14 the length perlamp <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs is relatively small in thecase <strong>of</strong> a well planned installation. Since thereliability is always depending upon the number<strong>of</strong> junction points and the length <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs,the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r system <strong>of</strong>fers,in this respect as well, important advantagesover older installation svstems.viz., single-core conduc<strong>to</strong>rs on insula<strong>to</strong>rs fordamp places, armoured conduit system and leadcovered rubber cable installations. From thetable is seen that the difference between thecosts <strong>of</strong> installation <strong>of</strong> the conduc<strong>to</strong>rs is rathersmall for the three systems. The rubber-leadconduc<strong>to</strong>r is somewhat cheaper than the singlecoreconduc<strong>to</strong>r but somewhat more expensivethan the armoured conduit. This is made stillclearer by figure 10 showing a table <strong>of</strong> the costs<strong>of</strong> construction for a number <strong>of</strong> installations.Compared with the single core conduc<strong>to</strong>r therubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r system is cheaper throughout,but it is somewhat more expensive thanarmoured conduit installations. The table showsthat this additional cost in the two cases is 5and 9 per cent respectively. However, if we8. 215


Fig. 16. Examples <strong>of</strong> cable costs for a number <strong>of</strong> installations.compare the sums for the various systems itwill be seen that the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>rsystem in the cases given is cheaper by 11 percent on the average.In the case <strong>of</strong> a complete installation therubber-lead system will, on the contrary, generallybe higher in price, and the examples givenin figure 17 show an average additional cost <strong>of</strong>22 per cent. This additional cost falls entirelyon the fittings. The fittings are constructed <strong>to</strong>comply with requirements quite other and morerigorous than does the ordinary installation material.and their price must therefore be higher.In order <strong>to</strong> reply <strong>to</strong> the question whether it willpay <strong>to</strong> install this more expensive material it isnecessary <strong>to</strong> know the relative life-time <strong>of</strong> thevarious systems. Unfortunately it is not yetpossible <strong>to</strong> answer <strong>to</strong> this question in full, hutexperience has furnished certain figures whichmay be guiding. In the case, for instance, <strong>of</strong> avery complicated installation where the singlecoreconduc<strong>to</strong>r system had <strong>to</strong> be replaced everythree months the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r installationwas still after six years in a satisfac<strong>to</strong>ryshape. The construction <strong>of</strong> the system excludesany condensation whatever in the conductingcables and if it should occur in the fittings theyought <strong>to</strong> have been exceptionally badly mounted.The fact that all live parts are hermeticallyFig. 17. Total installation costs for installations indicated in figure IS.enclosed in a carefully grounded metal coveringalmost excludes leakage. The result <strong>of</strong> all thisis that the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r installationsare the least dangerous and the most fire-pro<strong>of</strong><strong>of</strong> all the systems. The electrical strength andthe high insulation <strong>of</strong> this system place it in aspecial class. For an installation with leadcovered ruhber cable it is stipulated a minimuminsulation <strong>of</strong> 5 megohms, or more than 22 timesas high as that prescribed for armoured conduitinstallations. To this comes that there are nodifficulties whatever <strong>to</strong> reach this value, and asa rule the insulation is many times higher.In addition the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r systemhas been throughout worked out with a view <strong>to</strong>neutralize chemical action. As has been mentionedabove this purpose has also been fulfilled.This installation system is the only one whichit is allowed <strong>to</strong> use in damp places where thereis at the same time a risk <strong>of</strong> fire. According <strong>to</strong>the actual prescriptions it can and may be installedin any place where electrical installationis at all allowed. It makes possible unificationand standardization <strong>of</strong> installation technics, oneinstallation system for all kinds <strong>of</strong> places.In order <strong>to</strong> make it possible for owners <strong>of</strong>electric plants <strong>to</strong> have their installations modernizedwithout undue loss <strong>of</strong> time, a close collaboration<strong>of</strong> all parties busy in the sphere <strong>of</strong> instal-216 -


lation technics is required. Above all it is <strong>of</strong>great importance that all consulting engineersmake themselves thoroughly acquainted withthe properties <strong>of</strong> the rubber-lead conducting materials.To facilitate this work the consultingfirm Kraftkontrollen at Malmo has, at therequest <strong>of</strong> Sieverts Cable Works (Sieverts Kabelverk)prepared a paper on installations inplaces exposed <strong>to</strong> moisture and <strong>to</strong> risk <strong>of</strong> fire.This paper from which the abovementionedfigures 15, 16 and 17 are taken, shows clearlythat the rubber-lead conduc<strong>to</strong>r system is alwayspreferable both from technical and economicalstandpoint as soon as it is the question <strong>of</strong> installationin industrial premises or in the <strong>of</strong>fices <strong>of</strong>a farm.For a contrac<strong>to</strong>r it is much less risk <strong>to</strong> workwith first-rate material than <strong>to</strong> handle materialnear the limit <strong>of</strong> what is permitted. When it is<strong>to</strong> be tendered for an installation which is intended<strong>to</strong> be constructed throughout <strong>of</strong> first-ratematerial the contrac<strong>to</strong>r runs no risk <strong>of</strong> having <strong>to</strong>replace or reconstruct part <strong>of</strong> it. He can determinehis costs entirely in advance and almostall points <strong>of</strong> uncertainty are eliminated. In thesame way as a first-rate tailor gets better paymentfor a suit than does a second-rate one, acontrac<strong>to</strong>r who always deliveres a first-rate jobcan be well paid.CONTENTS: Karl Fredrik Wincrantz. — The Svenska Radioakticholaget Audio-frequency Genera<strong>to</strong>r, with continuouslyvariable frequency Adjustment. — The Use <strong>of</strong> Personal Telephone calls in Sweden, and in Traffic betweenSweden and other Countries. — The Hallsberg Electric Interlocking Signal Plant. — On Cross-talk between TelephoneLines. — Practical Points about Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm. — New Interlocking and Signalling Plant at I.und. —On Impedance and Impedance Measurements as well as a Description <strong>of</strong> the Impedance Measuring set manufacturedby Svenska Kadioaktiebolaget. — Electric Interlocking Plant at Vanneboda Station. — Porcelain Insula<strong>to</strong>rs and Insula<strong>to</strong>rPorcelain. — The Svenska Kadioaktiebolaget Valve-testing set. — On the Calculation <strong>of</strong> Delays in an Au<strong>to</strong>maticTelephone System. — Working Reliability and Maintenance <strong>of</strong> the L. M. Ericsson Au<strong>to</strong>matic Telephone System.— Lead Covered Rubber Cable Installations.217


Vol. VII. 1930.CONTENTS.Biographical data. Xos. Page.Karl Fredrik Wincrantz 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 98FireProtection.Practical Points about Au<strong>to</strong>matic Fire Alarm 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> <strong>12</strong>6Metering Devices.Impedance and Impedance Measurements as well as a Description <strong>of</strong> the ImpedanceMeasuring Set Manufactured by Svenska Radioaktiebolaget 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 143Instrument for Grouping Fifteen-minutes Loads in order <strong>of</strong> their Magnitude ... 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 60Localisation <strong>of</strong> Line Faults with the Resistance and Capacity Bridge constructedby the Svenska Radioaktiebolaget 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 69New Swedish Electricity Meters 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 86The Svenska Radioaktiebolaget Valve-testing Set 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 174Miscellaneous.Use <strong>of</strong> Electricity in Modern Life 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 48PlantHighLowConstruction.Tension.Lead Covered Rubber Cable Installations 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 20,>Porcelain Insula<strong>to</strong>rs and Insula<strong>to</strong>r Porcelain 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 167Static Condensers for the Improvement <strong>of</strong> the Effect Fac<strong>to</strong>r in A. C. nets 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 33Tension.New Swedish Carrier Current Telephone and Telegraph Systems on TelephoneLines 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 23Railway Signalling.Electric Interlocking Plant at Vanneboda Station 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 164Hallsberg Electric Interlocking Signal Plant 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 105Interlocking and Signal Plant at Lund 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 137Telephony.Calculation <strong>of</strong> Delays in an Au<strong>to</strong>matic Telephone System 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 185Organized Service for Information as <strong>to</strong> Subscribers' Numbers in Large TelephoneExchanges 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 5Suburban Telephone Traffic 1 <strong>to</strong> 6 16Use <strong>of</strong> Personal Telephone Calls in Sweden, and in Traffic between Swedenand other Countries 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 102Working Reliability and Maintenance <strong>of</strong> the L. M. Ericsson Au<strong>to</strong>matic TelephoneSystem 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 201Theoretical.Cross-talk between Telephone Lines 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 1<strong>12</strong>Wireless.The Svenska Radioaktiebolaget Audio-Frequency Genera<strong>to</strong>r, with ContinouslyVariable Frequency Adjustment 7 <strong>to</strong> <strong>12</strong> 99Kurt Lindbtrg, Boktntckeriakliebolaq, S<strong>to</strong>ckholm 1930.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!