Argyll and Bute Proposed Local Development Plan Representation ...

Argyll and ButeProposed Local Development PlanRepresentation FormWe would like your views on any of the issues, policies, sites and proposals set out in the Argyll and ButeProposed Local Development Plan and also on the Plan’s supporting documents, including the DraftSupplementary Guidance.This form should be used for all representations. The Planning Authority will only accept responses usingthis form. On line and electronic versions are available at www.argyll-bute.gov.uk/ldp as well as guidancenotes.Please use a separate form for each individual aspect of the Proposed Plan, Draft SupplementaryGuidance or other related document you wish to comment on.Your representation must be received by 29th April 2013 before 5 p.m.Please return the form to:-On line:Electronic copy:Hard copy:Submitted directly using submit buttone-mail to ldp@argyll-bute.gov.ukPost to Development Policy Team, Argyll and Bute Council, ManseBrae Offices, Lochgilphead, PA31 8RD or Fax to 01546 6046431 Please give us your contact details.Please note that representations cannot be treated confidentially and will be scanned and made available forpublic inspection, except any information which would be subject to the Data Protection Act 1998. They mayalso be passed to the Scottish Government’s Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals in orderthat they can involve you in any Examination of the Plan.Only representations that include a name and a method of contact will be validated.Name:Murdo Macdonald (Trust Convenor)Organisation NameRosneath Peninsula West Community DevelopmentTrustAddress:Craig Ailey , Cove, Helensburgh, G84 0PLTelephone:Agent :Agent Address:Agent Telephone:E Mail:If you provide an Agent’s name the Councilwill direct all subsequent correspondenceto your Agent.Agent E Mail:Office use onlyRec Valid Cusref Code1 Code2 Code3

Argyll and Bute Proposed Local Development PlanRepresentation FormPlease use a separate form for each issue/site/aspect2 Please indicate which document you are making a representation on:Tick one box onlyProposed LocalDraft SupplementaryDevelopment Plan√GuidanceOtherEnvironmental Report(please specify)3 Please tell us which part of the above document you wish to make a representation on.Fill in all that applyPage No(s) Chapter No(s) Paragraph No(s)Policy ReferenceSite Referencee.g. H3001Policy TitleSite Name4 Please indicate whether your representation is in support of the document or whetheryou would wish to see it changed (i.e. your representation is an objection)Tick one box onlySeek a change/Support as writtenObjection√5a Please provide your reasons for supporting or objecting to the matter you havehighlighted.This is not been submitted as an objection to any specific part of the draft Local Development Plan, but ingeneral support alongside comments seeking the addition of detailed proposals for developments on theRosneath Peninsula.The Rosneath Peninsula West Community Development Trust fully supports the Key Policy Themes of the proposedArgyll & Bute Local Development Plan. The objectives of the Trust, reflecting the ambitions of people in the PeninsulaWest local communities, mirror those of the Local Development Plan in its policies for protecting and enhancing theenvironment, growing a sustainable economy, including the development of renewables, strengthening communities,maximising resources and improving connectivity and infrastructure. The Trust welcomes the intention that delivery ofthese policies will be partly implemented through the consideration of planning applications against all relevant policieswithin the Local Development Plan (LDP 1.4).With reference to planning applications, the Community Development Trust has extensive recent local experience ofdevelopment work leading to a wind farm planning application. The Trust welcomes the continuing commitment of theCouncil, through the Local Development Plan, to promoting and supporting such developments. The Trust supports thefact that the Plan proposes the retention of a balanced approach to renewable development, which recognises not onlytheir economic, environmental and social importance, but also the landscape and visual issues concerned.As an organisation in an area including Cove and Kilcreggan, which saw the number of children reduced by 23% andadults of working age by 7% falling between 2001 and 2009, and are designated by the Plan as ‘Key Rural Settlements’,the Trust supports the view expressed in the plan that sustainable long-term economic growth is needed ‘to support theretention and growth of our population’ through attention to services, the natural and built environment and quality-oflife(1.6.1).The Trust supports the recognition in the Local Development Plan that ‘an effective land supply‘ will be required ‘toaccommodate new business and retail opportunities, homes, leisure facilities together with the necessary infrastructureand services required to support them.’ These resources all featured in the Peninsula West Community Action Plan,

which was based on a wide-ranging community consultation, involving a household survey sent all adults in the Trustarea, a young people's survey, a community groups’ survey, a business survey and very well attended projectprioritisation events open to all members of the local community. As the improvements in the Community Action Plandrawn up by the Trust and its 400+ members to meet identified local needs, very closely match this Local DevelopmentPlan list, the Trust welcomes the intention to steer significant new developments to particular areas, including the localKey Rural Settlements (1.6.2).It is also encouraging to read Key Objective C, and its stated intention that the Council will be seeking ‘to work inpartnership with local communities in a way that recognises their particular needs to deliver successful and sustainablelocal regeneration;’ Following its creation in 2010, the main work of the Trust was to establish community need anddevelop proposals to respond to that need through community involvement in surveys and interactive events, and it isgood to anticipate positive partnership working with the Council and other statutory bodies in finding ways to implementthe Community Action Plan, which brought together information about the improvements required locally to respond tothe needs identified.Within the context of the positive nature of the Policy Themes and Key Objectives, the Community Development Trustis disappointed that the sections of the Local Development Plan dealing with Helensburgh and Lomond (2.3) focuslargely on Helensburgh and its adjacent communities. Whilst those communities may be ‘subject to differentdevelopment pressures from the rest of Argyll & Bute’ (2.3.1), the communities of the Rosneath Peninsula share thepressures experienced by smaller communities across the Council area.Distance and relative inaccessibility from main population centres have contributed to features of decline on theRosneath Peninsula in recent years, including: derelict public amenities; weak and costly transport links; very limitedfacilities for young people; an absence of local job opportunities; lack of affordable housing; lack of special needshousing for older people; closure of the Council library; the sale of former community centre and church hall; andenvironmental degradation.It is therefore unfortunate that the section on Helensburgh and Lomond only refers to ‘taking into account ....... the needsof the Rosneath Peninsula’ in the most general terms, and that the only other relevant general references are to improvedferry services and community led renewable energy projects. Whilst Cove and Kilcreggan and separately Rosneath aredesignated Key Rural Settlements and are also both Areas for Action, the only actions identified for Kilcreggan areenvironmental enhancements and an enhanced passenger ferry terminal, and the only actions identified for Rosneath arefor medium scale housing development, Camsail Wood forest restoration and management and a broad reference tovillage centre development and environmental improvement.5bPlease indicate the changes that would be required for you to remove your objectionThe Community Development Trust understands that the detailed housing proposals made in the draft LocalDevelopment Plan reflect the terms of the Argyll and Bute Housing Needs and Demand Assessment (HNDA). Howeverthe Trust is aware of a very widely expressed need on the Rosneath Peninsula for both affordable housing for youngerpeople and families, and for special needs accommodation for older people and people other age groups with particularneeds. These housing developments are needed on the Rosneath Peninsula to address the population decline in childrenand families, which is a strategic and local issue recognised in many parts of the Local Development Plan. Housing isalso required to address the needs of older people, who have no local access to special needs accommodation.Recognising the terms of the current HNDA, the Trust would want to see a commitment within the Local DevelopmentPlan to the Council working with the Trust on a new form of rural housing needs and demand assessment, which wouldassess the housing needs in of the Key Rural Settlements on the Rosneath peninsula. Potential sites have been identifiedbeyond the top of Church Road in Cove for affordable housing, and on Shore Road or Fort Road for special needshousing.Whilst the CAP was completed for the Peninsula West area, the comments made by people in Rosneath and Clynder,within the Cove Windfarm planning application process, suggest that the needs expressed and developments proposed inthe Community Action Plan fairly reflect the views and ambitions of people across the whole of the Rosneath Peninsula.The Community Development Trust recognises that it is not possible to include very detailed local area analysis andproject planning within a Local Development Plan for Argyll & Bute. However, within the section concerningHelensburgh and Lomond, the Trust would want to see recognition of the key importance of the Rosneath PeninsulaWest Community Action Plan, with its assessment of local needs, and its detailed project proposals to meet those needs,including: youth and recreation facilities; arts and culture events and festivals; employment, business and tourism

esources and workshop space; transport development; environmental improvements to villages and foreshore; healthand welfare supports and housing. The Annex below provides a full listing of the priorities set out in the CommunityAction Plan, and these are described and can be accessed in greater detail on the Community Development Trustwebsite: http://www.rosneathpeninsulawest.com/?page_id=162The detail of actions and outcomes provided in Section 5 of the Local Development Plan, and its policy for‘Strengthening Our Communities Together’ closely match those of people within the Peninsula West communities asexpressed in the Community Action Plan. Within the section on Helensburgh and Lomond, and the final action points ofthe final Local Development Plan, the Trust would therefore wish to see a specific commitment to partnership workingbetween the Council and the Rosneath Peninsula West Community Development Trust to deliver all of theimprovements laid out in the Community Action Plan, which are consistent with those of the Local Development Planand relevant other council policies.Part 5 Notes : Your response in part 5 should be no more than 2,000 words. Please use continuation page(s) asnecessary and attach securely to this form. If you intend to attach any supporting documentation, please provide asummary of your representation using this form, which should not exceed 2,000 words. There is no automaticopportunity for parties to expand on a proposed Local Development Plan representation later in the process.