Vol 7 No 1 - Roger Williams University School of Law

Vol 7 No 1 - Roger Williams University School of Law Vol 7 No 1 - Roger Williams University School of Law

13.07.2015 Views

ural and remote areas, where access to information andcommunications technologies [ICT], even to a telephone,is often scarce. Most of the information exchanged overglobal networks such as the Internet is in English, thelanguage of less than ten percent of the world’spopulation.10Those statistics, while grim, are not surprising. As the Reportrecognizes, they reflect the general socio-economic disparitybetween the developed and less-developed world.11The DOT Force Report sets forth nine action points as itsGenoa Plan of Action.12 They are:1. Help Establish and Support Developing Country &Emerging National e-Strategies;2. Improve Connectivity, Increase Access and Lower Costs;3. Enhance Human Capacity Development, KnowledgeCreation and Sharing;4. Foster Enterprise and Entrepreneurship for SustainableEconomic Development;5. Establish and Support Universal Participation inAddressing New International Policy and TechnicalIssues raised by the Internet and ICT;6. Establish and Support Dedicated Initiatives for the ICTInclusion of the Least Developed Countries;7. Promote ICT for Health Care and in Support AgainstHIV/AIDS and Other Infectious and CommunicableDiseases;8. National and International Effort to Support LocalContent and Applications Creation;9. Prioritize ICT in G8 and Other Development AssistancePolicies and Programmes and Enhance Coordination of10. Id. at 6.11. See id.[The] “digital divide” is, in effect, a reflection of existing broader socioeconomicinequalities and can be characterized by insufficient infrastructure,high cost of access, inappropriate or weak policy regimes, inefficiencies in theprovision of telecommunication networks and services, lack of locally createdcontent, and uneven ability to derive economic and social benefits frominformation-intensive activities.Id.12. Genoa was the site of the G8 meetings from July 19-22, 2001.

Multilateral Initiatives.13The DOT Force places responsibility for implementing its planwith developing countries’ governments working alongsidecorporations and non-governmental organizations.14 It plans toplay an advisory role in assisting these entities in taking therelevant steps toward bridging the “Digital Divide.”15Reducing a problem as complex as the global “Digital Divide”to a nine-step plan of action is indeed a noteworthyaccomplishment. However, skeptics might question whether—even if the DOT Force plan would work—the money and willexists to implement it. Translating the plan from politicalplatitudes into action requires money, and the Report says littleabout from what sources and in what magnitude that money willcome. Further, the Report makes certain assumptions about thedesirability of competitive markets that some nations do notshare.16 Developing countries may not be interested in the GenoaPlan if they view it as simply another way in which the developedworld seeks to foist its policy agenda on less-developed countries.Indeed, the most difficult part of implementing any global planmay be determining how to accommodate local cultural valuesthat can vary widely, even within a single country.B. Access to Broadband TechnologiesDecisions of policymakers will also influence what technologycitizens have access to, and under what terms. Technologymarches on, but only about five percent of American householdshave access to broadband.17 One definition describes broadband13. See Digital Opportunity Task Force, supra note 1, at 13-20.14. See id. at 10.15. See id. (“[T]he DOT Force can . . . play a critical and significant role bysuggesting, initiating and/or supporting these actions.”).16. See id. at 8 (stating that “pro-competitive policies” are prerequisites to thedevelopment of communications infrastructure and access, which are required toreduce the digital divide).17. The Internet Freedom and Broadband Deployment Act of Law: Hearing onH.R. 1542 Before the House Comm. on the Judiciary, 107th Cong. (2001), available at2001 WL 21755660, at *3 (statement by James K. Glassman, Resident Fellow,American Enterprises Inst., House Comm. on the Judiciary) (“Today, barely 5 percentof households have even the most rudimentary form of broadband—or fast access to theInternet. As a result, the promise of the Internet is not being enjoyed by 95 percent ofAmericans—an increasingly frustrated group. Incredibly, in the first quarter of thisyear, for the first time ever, the number of Americans with Internet access of any sort

Multilateral Initiatives.13The DOT Force places responsibility for implementing its planwith developing countries’ governments working alongsidecorporations and non-governmental organizations.14 It plans toplay an advisory role in assisting these entities in taking therelevant steps toward bridging the “Digital Divide.”15Reducing a problem as complex as the global “Digital Divide”to a nine-step plan <strong>of</strong> action is indeed a noteworthyaccomplishment. However, skeptics might question whether—even if the DOT Force plan would work—the money and willexists to implement it. Translating the plan from politicalplatitudes into action requires money, and the Report says littleabout from what sources and in what magnitude that money willcome. Further, the Report makes certain assumptions about thedesirability <strong>of</strong> competitive markets that some nations do notshare.16 Developing countries may not be interested in the GenoaPlan if they view it as simply another way in which the developedworld seeks to foist its policy agenda on less-developed countries.Indeed, the most difficult part <strong>of</strong> implementing any global planmay be determining how to accommodate local cultural valuesthat can vary widely, even within a single country.B. Access to Broadband TechnologiesDecisions <strong>of</strong> policymakers will also influence what technologycitizens have access to, and under what terms. Technologymarches on, but only about five percent <strong>of</strong> American householdshave access to broadband.17 One definition describes broadband13. See Digital Opportunity Task Force, supra note 1, at 13-20.14. See id. at 10.15. See id. (“[T]he DOT Force can . . . play a critical and significant role bysuggesting, initiating and/or supporting these actions.”).16. See id. at 8 (stating that “pro-competitive policies” are prerequisites to thedevelopment <strong>of</strong> communications infrastructure and access, which are required toreduce the digital divide).17. The Internet Freedom and Broadband Deployment Act <strong>of</strong> <strong>Law</strong>: Hearing onH.R. 1542 Before the House Comm. on the Judiciary, 107th Cong. (2001), available at2001 WL 21755660, at *3 (statement by James K. Glassman, Resident Fellow,American Enterprises Inst., House Comm. on the Judiciary) (“Today, barely 5 percent<strong>of</strong> households have even the most rudimentary form <strong>of</strong> broadband—or fast access to theInternet. As a result, the promise <strong>of</strong> the Internet is not being enjoyed by 95 percent <strong>of</strong>Americans—an increasingly frustrated group. Incredibly, in the first quarter <strong>of</strong> thisyear, for the first time ever, the number <strong>of</strong> Americans with Internet access <strong>of</strong> any sort

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!