Full-48.2 - Royal Institution of Surveyors Malaysia

Full-48.2 - Royal Institution of Surveyors Malaysia Full-48.2 - Royal Institution of Surveyors Malaysia

13.07.2015 Views

The <strong>Malaysia</strong>n Surveyor is a quarterlypublication which covers the development <strong>of</strong>the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession,innovations in the surveying technology andsurveyors’ contribution towards the propertymarket and building industry.The Institute as a body does not hold itselfresponsible for statements made or opinionsexpressed in the articles and advertisementsprinted in this publication, or for the strictaccuracy <strong>of</strong> references to law cases, whichare intended only as a gloss on authorisedreports. Rights <strong>of</strong> translation andreproduction reserved.PresidentYBhg. Dato’ Sr Abdull Manaf Hj Hashim, FRISMHon. Secretary GeneralSr Ang Fuey Lin, MRISMEditorial BoardEditorPr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Dr. Ting Kien Hwa, FRISMSub-editorSr Mohamad Shazali Sulaiman, MRISMMembersSr Firdaus b Musa, FRISMAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Dr. Adi Irfan B Che Ani, MRISMAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Dr. Syahrul Nizam B Kamaruzzaman, MRISMDr. Norngainy Mohd Bt TawilPr<strong>of</strong>. Sr. Dr. Hj Wan Muhd Aminuddin B Wan Hussin, FRISMSr Dr. Hj Md Said @ Mohd Zaid B Abdullah, FRISMSr Dr. Helmi Zulhaidi B Mohd Shafri, MRISMSr Dr. Zulkiflee Abd. Latif, MRISMSr A. Mahadevan, FRISMAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Dr. Mohd Hisham Ariffin, FRISMSecretary to the BoardZarinah bt. Danial<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>3rd Floor, Bangunan JuruukurNo. 64-66, Jalan 52/446200 Petaling JayaSelangor Darul Ehsant: +603 7954 8358 (hunting line) / 7956 9728 / 7955 1773f: +603 7955 0253e: editor@rism.org.myw: www.rism.org.mySubscription Rates for Non-Members (Quarterly 4 issues)LocalRM48Overseas ASEAN countries US$30Asia & AustraliaUS$40Europe, Africa & America US$55Publishing ConsultantDeCalais Sdn BhdD-3-8, Plaza Damas60, Jalan Sri Hartamas 1Sri Hartamas50480 Kuala LumpurT +603 6201 8857F +603 6210 8850E: deepa@decalais.comCONTENTS45791222324650525659EditorialRISM ActivitiesYoung Achievers’ Awards (YAA) NationalCompetition 2012-2013RISM Family Day 2013Sabah International <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress (6thSabah <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress) EconomicTurbulence Survival or Opportunities?Peer Review ArticlesPemuliharaan & Pembaikan Masjid KayuTradisionalSuhana Johar, Hafsah Yahaya, Adi Irfan Che-Ani, NorngainyMohd. Tawil, Mazlan Mohd. TahirEmpirical Study <strong>of</strong> the Impact <strong>of</strong> Revitalise OldIndustrial Buildings on Property Prices TheCase <strong>of</strong> Hong KongHei Lam, PoonThe Impact <strong>of</strong> Information & CommunicationsTechnology (ICT) On Work-Life Balance <strong>of</strong>Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Women in the ConstructionIndustryLoh Chin Bok, Nurmimi Fardiana bt Mohd Toha, Kam PeiCheen et al.Pr<strong>of</strong>essional PracticeBuilding Surveyor’s Role In FacilitiesManagement In JKRNorizan Binti MahmudCurrent IssueDIBS: A factor causing high property prices &development land pricesPr<strong>of</strong>essor Sr Dr. Ting Kien HwaManaging StressManaging Stress by Developing a PersonalisedStress Prevention PlanW. M. A. Wan Hussin FRISMManagementWhether Prior Experience Is Necessary ForInnovationDr. Arshad Husain Ph.DRegularsMember Updates


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013EDITORIALChallenging the challenges forthe surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionDuring my term as Editor and Council member <strong>of</strong> RISM, Iobserved two distinctive groups <strong>of</strong> surveyors in RISM i.e. thepr<strong>of</strong>essional surveyors and the academic surveyors. Thepr<strong>of</strong>essional surveyors will refer to surveyors as those whopractice surveying whether in the public or private sectors,whilst the academic surveyors will refer to surveyors as thosewho work as academicians in institutions <strong>of</strong> higher learning.The increase in academic surveyors can be attributed to anincrease in surveying courses <strong>of</strong>fered in the public andprivate institutions <strong>of</strong> higher learning. Academic surveyors arecoming to the fore by participating actively in variouscommittees and council positions.Both groups contribute to the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession in manyways which are similar and yet different.Looking forward to the next 50 years, I reckon more have tobe done to enhance the future prospects <strong>of</strong> the surveyingpr<strong>of</strong>ession. The challenges to the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession are nomore confined within the national boundary. Externalchallenges arising from globalisation, liberalisation, fundflows, technology advancement, computer science,information technology, financial crises etc. have greatimpacts on the education, training and practice <strong>of</strong> thesurveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession.To take up the challenge on these challenges, my wish listsfor the pr<strong>of</strong>essional surveyors are:• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals are keen to write fullarticles/papers rather than preparingseminar/conference presentations in powerpoints.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals are prepared to cross thepr<strong>of</strong>essional-academia divide by embracing research as atool for the advancement <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional practice andbusiness development.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals pursue postgraduateeducation for the enhancement <strong>of</strong> knowledge.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals respond to the media onpublic issues relating to the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession andbuilt environment.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals provide thought leadershipin their respective fields.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals voluntarily taking upleadership roles and positions whether in local orinternational organisations.• More surveying pr<strong>of</strong>essionals could be innovative in theirservice delivery through the Blue Ocean strategy.On the other hand, my wish lists for the academic surveyorsare:• More academic surveyors are keen to write practicepapers and not necessarily academic research papers.• More academic surveyors are keen to rewrite researchpapers in a manner which is accessible and easilyunderstood by pr<strong>of</strong>essionals.• More academic surveyors are able to move out <strong>of</strong> theacademic ivory tower and reach out to the pr<strong>of</strong>ession,society and government.• More academic surveyors take up leadership roles inacademic and pr<strong>of</strong>essional organisations at local andinternational level.• More academic surveyors respond to the media onpublic issues relating to the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession andbuilt environment.• More academic surveyors could bridge the academicpr<strong>of</strong>essionalpractice divide by having better industrylinkages, ties and relationships.• More academic surveyors could provide researchleadership by carrying out cutting-edge research.• More academic surveyors provide thought leadershipthat could guide the future <strong>of</strong> the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession.Both lists could go on and on. The keywords to the future areleadership, innovation and <strong>of</strong> relevance to the society.Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Sr Dr. Ting Kien Hwa FRISMEditorSession 2010/2011-2012/2013ANNOUNCEMENTMAY 2014 PROFESSIONAL EXAMINATIONS(DIRECT FINAL/FINAL, INTERMEDIATE, FIRST AND FOUNDATION EXAMINATIONS)Applications to sit for the above examinations are now openand application forms can be obtained from the RISMSecretariat. The application form should be submitted to theRISM Secretariat not later than December 31, 2013together with the examination fees.A penalty fee is payable if you submit your applicationbetween January 1, 2014 and February 28, 2014 after whichno application will be accepted. The rules and syllabuses <strong>of</strong>the Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Examination and past years question papersare available for sale at the RISM Secretariat.The examination fees are as follows:-1. Foundation Exam – RM30.00 per subject2. First Exam – RM50.00 per subject3. Intermediate Exam – RM100.00 per subject4. Final/Direct Final Exam – RM150.00 per subject4


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>YoungAchievers’Awards (YAA)National Competition2012-2013The YAA National Final was successfullyhosted at Hotel Singgahsana, Petaling Jaya onthe 20 April 2013.For this session due to the overwhelming support fromthe sponsors, YAA was hosted for three days twonights instead <strong>of</strong> the usual two days one night. Thisallows the students to bond better and the organizingcommittee was able to include more activities, amongothers a technical visit to KeTTHA project in Karak andan eXtraDiction Game. YBhg. Dato’ Sr Abdull Manaf HjHashim was the Guest <strong>of</strong> Honour for the prize givingduring the Gala Dinner held on 20 April 2013.Sixteen (16) schools participated and they were:RISM Activities(a)East Cost BranchSekolah Menengah Kebangsaaan Ahmad MaherMaktab Sultan IsmailSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Kamil(b) Northern BranchSekolah Menengah Jenis Kebangsaan Chung Ling,Pulau PinangPenang Chinese Girls High SchoolPenang Free School(c) Johore BranchMaktab Sultan Abu BakarSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Dato’ Ali AhmadSekolah Tun Fatimah(d) Central BranchSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Aminuddin BakiSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Convent BukitNanasSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan MeruSekolah Menengah Vokasional SepangSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Damansara JayaSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Tun RazakST John’s <strong>Institution</strong>5


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013A half day Technical Visit to Projek Penyaluran Air Mentah Pahang-Selangor (Karak) was held on Friday, 19 April 2013 and a welcomeDinner at Restoran Nelayan Gombak.The eXtraDiction game was conducted on the morning <strong>of</strong> 20 April2013 just before the YAA Competition. The winner for theeXtraDiction game as follows:ChampionMaktab Sultan Ismail1st Runner upSekolah Tun Fatimah2nd Runner upSekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Damansara JayaThe Winners for the YAA National Final Result Session 2012/2013 are as followsChampionSMK Damansara Jaya, PetalingJaya receiving RM3,000.00 in cash,winning plaques, trophy and YAAChallenge Trophy.1st runner upSekolah Tun Fatimah, Johor receivingRM2,000.00 in cash, winning plaquesand trophy.2nd runner upSMJK Chung Ling, Pulau Pinangreceiving RM1,000.00 in cash, winningplaques and trophy.The Chairperson and the Organizing Committee wish to express their gratitude to the followingsponsors for their continuous support:1. Association <strong>of</strong> Authorised Land <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>2. Board Of Land <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>3. Board <strong>of</strong> Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>4. Board <strong>of</strong> Valuers, Appraisers & Estate Agents <strong>Malaysia</strong>5. Construction Industry Development Board <strong>Malaysia</strong>6. C.H. Williams Talhar & Wong Sdn Bhd7. Econcos Consultants Sdn Bhd8. Geometra Surveys Sdn Bhd9. Henry Butcher <strong>Malaysia</strong> Sdn Bhd10. HMF QS Consult11. Jurukur Bahan Antara12. Metropolis Property Consultants Sdn Bhd13. MF Associates Sdn Bhd14. Mokhnar & Associates15. Mojigoh Surveying Consultants Sdn Bhd16. Pakatan Ukur Bahan Sdn Bhd17. Perunding PCT Sdn Bhd l6


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>RISMFamilyDay2013The Committee hassuccessfully organised theRISM Family Day 2013 on 13April 2013 at Tasik Taman Jaya,Petaling Jaya, Selangor.RISM members and their familiestogether with seven children fromRumah Solehah Orphanage wereentertained by MC YM Sr Dr. TunkuFauzi Dato’ Tunku Abd. Malek, whois an energetic aerobics instructorand Az the Clown while mingling atthe 10 table flea market. The fleamarket sells goodies ranging fromfood to antiques.RISM Activities7


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013The participants were from allages who took part in the wellorganisedtelematch, quiz atMuseum Petaling Jaya andkaraoke competition beforeenjoying a good buffet lunch. Thebuffet spread included, amongstothers, satay and ice creampotong. l8


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Sabah International <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress (6th Sabah <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress)Economic TurbulenceSurvival or Opportunities?RISM ActivitiesThe <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong><strong>Malaysia</strong> (Sabah Branch) has successfullyorganised our 6th Sabah <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congresswith the collaboration <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong>Chartered <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> and the Sabah<strong>Surveyors</strong> Board on 14th and 15th May 2013 at thePacific Sutera Hotel, Kota Kinabalu, Sabah.After organising five previous Sabah <strong>Surveyors</strong>'Congress, RISM Sabah Branch ambitiously decidedto give ourselves a big challenge by organising acongress one-level-up at the international level. Theresult – the first Sabah International <strong>Surveyors</strong>’Congress was born! The first Sabah International<strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress was attended by 206participants, the highest figure in our record so far!The Guest <strong>of</strong> Honour <strong>of</strong> the Congress was theDirector <strong>of</strong> the Department <strong>of</strong> Lands and Surveys,Sabah, Datuk Sr Hj Osman bin Hj Jamal, a fellow <strong>of</strong>both the <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> andthe <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> Chartered <strong>Surveyors</strong>. In hisaddress, the Director pointed out that no one isspared from business turbulence and that“preparedness” is the essence in overcomingturbulence successfully.He said, “The theme for the Congress is “EconomicTurbulence – Survival or Opportunity?” This is9


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013indeed an appropriate theme in the business world <strong>of</strong>change and uncertainty. None <strong>of</strong> us can be spared from theeffect <strong>of</strong> economic turbulence. Perhaps, some <strong>of</strong> us are moreprepared and, therefore, less severely affected than others bythe turbulences <strong>of</strong> the economy. However, when we arecaught unprepared, an unexpected economic turbulencemay tip our business <strong>of</strong>f balance and cost us dearly.”He continued to say in his concluding remark that,“Economic turbulence, whether it is a game <strong>of</strong> survival or agolden opportunity depends on how you perceive themarket and how well prepared you are in creating asustainable long-term pr<strong>of</strong>itable business model. Success is<strong>of</strong>ten found at the end <strong>of</strong> a long journey and to besuccessful, we must be ready and able to smooth over thechallenges <strong>of</strong> the bumpy stretch <strong>of</strong> the journey.”The keynote speaker <strong>of</strong> the Congress was Sr Ong See Lian,the immediate global Past President <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong><strong>of</strong> Chartered <strong>Surveyors</strong>. In his keynote address, Sr Ong gavean insightful overview <strong>of</strong> the importance <strong>of</strong> the surveyingpr<strong>of</strong>essions within the context <strong>of</strong> a fast growing andchanging world economy. We had local speakers as well asinternational speakers from Singapore, Brunei and China.The participants were kept wide awake throughout theCongress by the learned speakers.The topics included “Mapping Transformation: Defence andSecurity” by Brigadier General Dato' Ir Zaharin bin Din,“Singapore's Smart Cadastre System” by Mr Soh Kheng Peng,“National Spatial Data Infrastructure <strong>of</strong> Brunei Darussalam”by Dr Hjh Norzammi, “Building Information Modelling” by DrKherun Nita Ali, “Asset Management for Building and RelatedInfrastructure” by Mr Chin Chi Haw, “Project Management –A Case Study in Shanghai” by Mr Eric Yip, “AffordableHousing Policy in Singapore” by Dr Anthony Yeong, “PropertyManagement from the <strong>Surveyors</strong>' Perspective - Challenges inthe Current Era” by Sr Prem Kumar, “Value Management: TheEconomic Management <strong>of</strong> Public Construction Projects”byPuan Rohanis binti Ad Ghani, “Waste Minimisation inConstruction Industry” by Dr Mohd Pauze Bin MohamadTaha and others.We were also privileged to have the Deputy Speaker <strong>of</strong> theSabah State Assembly, Datuk Dr Johnson Tee, a greatmotivational speaker, as one <strong>of</strong> the speakers. After a moresombre topic <strong>of</strong> “Economic Indicators for Real EstateInvestment in Sabah” presented by Sr Liaw Lam Thye, DatukJohnson enlightened the participants and turned the hallinto sounds <strong>of</strong> rolling laughter with his humorous andcomical approach throughout his presentation on“Confidence in Managing Turbulence”. In one story, he told<strong>of</strong> the 'frog' who beat all others in a racing competition to bethe only one to reach a high tower. The reason for its successhas nothing to do with its physical fitness. The championfrog succeeded because it did not listen to thediscouragement from others, it believed in itself. At the end,we found that the champion frog was deaf!No doubt, the organising committee had experiencedturbulences in the process <strong>of</strong> organising the Congress. Butwith a close and self-giving collaboration <strong>of</strong> the organisers,the speakers and the participants, the first SabahInternational <strong>Surveyors</strong>’ Congress had turned out to be ajubilant success. The Congress Organising Committee wishesto thank all the speakers, participants and supporters formaking this Congress a great success. l10


<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Educational LoanAwards for 2012/2013<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> invites application from<strong>Malaysia</strong> Citizens for Educational Loans to pursue full-time coursesat local universities.UniversitiesUniversity <strong>of</strong> MalayaUniversity <strong>of</strong> Technology <strong>Malaysia</strong>University <strong>of</strong> Technology MARAUniversity <strong>of</strong> Science <strong>Malaysia</strong>International Islamic University <strong>of</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>University Tun Hussein Onn <strong>Malaysia</strong>Field <strong>of</strong> StudyLand SurveyingQuantity SurveyingBuilding SurveyingProperty Management / Estate ManagementEligibility• Candidates must have obtained an <strong>of</strong>fer for admission for full time studies to any <strong>of</strong>the universities in any <strong>of</strong> the field specified above.• Candidates must not have received any scholarship or financial assistancefrom the Government or any other organization.• Candidates must have obtained at least CGPA <strong>of</strong> 3.20 to be short listed to call for an interview.Special Incentive• Degree course candidates who obtained in their studies with CGPA 3.75 and above, the student having to firstapply for the conversion <strong>of</strong> the loan to scholarship for consideration and approval by General Council.• Diploma course candidates are not eligible to apply for conversation <strong>of</strong> their loan to scholarship.Value <strong>of</strong> LoanDegree: Up to RM7,000 per annumDiploma: Up to RM5,000 per annumGuarantorsCandidates shall obtain the consent <strong>of</strong> two acceptable guarantors who must provide personal guarantee forrepayment <strong>of</strong> the loan.Repayment <strong>of</strong> LoanLoan amount must be repaid with a period <strong>of</strong> not less than 36 months after the recipient has graduated.How to applyThe application form, may be obtained from the RISM Secretariat or downloaded from RISM website:http://www.rism.org.my.All application must be sent to:The ChairmanScholarship and Education Fund Committee<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>3rd Floor, Bangunan Juruukur, 64-66, Jalan 52/4, 46200 Petaling Jaya


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Pemuliharaan & PembaikanMasjid KayuTradisionalSuhana Johar 1 , Hafsah Yahaya 2 , Adi Irfan Che-Ani 1 , Norngainy Mohd. Tawil 1 , Mazlan Mohd. Tahir 11 Fakulti Kejuruteraan & Alam Bina,Universiti Kebangsaan <strong>Malaysia</strong> (UKM),43600 UKM Bangi, Selangor2 Fakulti Senibina & Alam Bina, TwintechInternational University College <strong>of</strong> Technology<strong>Malaysia</strong> (TWINTECH), 52200 Kuala LumpurKecacatan dan kerosakan adalah lumrah dalam mana-manabangunan tidak kira pada bangunan baru atau lama. Bangunanyang dibina dari bahan kayu sememangnya tidak dapat lari darifaktor kerosakan dan kecacatan yang dapat mengurangkan nilaikepenggunaan. Dalam melakukan mana-mana kerja pembaikan,penelitian terhadap punca kerosakan adalah penting begitu jugadengan pemilihan teknik pembaikan. Dalam amalan pemuliharaan,beberapa prinsip kerja perlu difahami terlebih dahulu, tentang apayang boleh dan apa yang tidak seharusnya dilakukan bagimemastikan objektif pemuliharaan suatu elemen itu benar-benardicapai. Beberapa teknik digunapakai dalam memulihara elemenkayu seperti teknik penggantian samada penggantian penuh atausebahagian, sistem WER, suntikan resin dan penggunaan sistemsokongan mekanikal bagi memastikan bahan binaan ini dapatterus dikekalkan penggunaannya.1.0 PengenalanPemuliharaan di <strong>Malaysia</strong> merupakan satu bidang yang tidakasing lagi. Walaupun ia bermula agak lewat berbanding dengan negaranegaraluar yang lain, perkembangan bidang ini semakin mendapat tempat dihati masyarakat <strong>Malaysia</strong> kini. Di celah-celah kepesatan pembangunan danperkembangan teknologi, masih terselit kesan-kesan dan tinggalan sejarah yangmasih berdiri seperti Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad, Masjid Jamek di KualaLumpur, Masjid Tengkera di Melaka, tugu-tugu dan sebagainya. Bangunanbangunanlama ini yang masih berdiri teguh jelas menunjukkan keunikan senibinanya dan peninggalan bangunan bersejarah ini yang tidak ternilai harganya(Ahmad, 1997; Kamal, 2007). Kepentingannya tidak boleh disangkal, justeru itu,pemuliharaan menjadi satu tanggungjawab penting yang harus dipikul oleh setiapindividu dalam masyarakat masa kini khususnya bagi mengekalkan12


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Pemuliharaanmenekankan konsepketulenan dan pengekalanmerupakan pendekatanyang selalu digunakandalam mana-manaprogram pemuliharaanPeer Review Articlekesinambungan sejarah yang pernahberlaku dahulu.Sebagaimana bangunan dengan rekaanistimewa yang lain, masjid juga turutmenyumbang kepada kesinambungan senibina di negara ini. Masjid-masjid lamadengan rekaan vernakular tradisional iniamat perlu dipulihara kerana bilangannyaamat sukar didapati sekarang. Sungguhpunmasjid-masjid ini telah banyak yangmengalami perubahan dari segipenggunaan bahan binaan asal, namunkebanyakannya masih mengekalkanpenggunaan struktur yang sama. Masjidmasjidlama ini dahulunya menggunakankayu-kayu keras tempatan, dibina denganmenampilkan kehalusan dan kemahiranseni pertukangan yang sukar didapatisekarang.Dalam meniti usia yang semakinmeningkat, bangunan masjid ini juga tidakterlepas dari mengalami masalah kecacatandan kerosakan akibat proses ‘wear andtear’. Masalah ini jelas dapat dilihat lebihlebihlagi pada bangunan lama yang tidakdijaga dan tiada penyelenggaraan khususdilakukan. Lazimnya, masalah yang seringmelanda pada bangunan kayu khususnyabangunan yang berada dalam kawasantropika adalah kebanyakannya berpuncaakibat lembapan dan serangan biologiseperti anai-anai dan kulat pereput.13


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Pendedahan yang berterusan pada ejen perosak danpersekitaran tanpa langkah pencegahan yang betul akanmenyebabkan bangunan lebih cepat usang (Glover 2000,Abdullah 1994). Dalam menjalankan kerja-kerja pembaikan,perlunya pemahaman terhadap punca kerosakan bagimemastikan cara pembaikan terbaik dapat dicapai. Malah,pemahaman terhadap punca dan agen kerosakan dapatmengurangkan risiko kerosakan yang lebih besar (Glover,2000). Kecacatan bangunan perlu dilihat secara menyeluruhdan kegagalan dalam mengenal pasti kecacatan bangunanboleh menyebabkan pemilihan kerja pembaikan yang salah(Richardson, 2001 & Ransom 1981). Kerja pembaikan yangdijalankan haruslah tepat dengan kerosakan dan tidakmerosakkan nilai warisan yang wujud dalam suatu strukturtersebut (Fielden, 2000).Pemuliharaan menekankan konsep ketulenan danpengekalan merupakan pendekatan yang selalu digunakandalam mana-mana program pemuliharaan. Mengekalkanpenggunaan bahan asal, seni bina, ciri-ciri sejarah dansebagainya adalah beberapa aspek yang sering ditekankan.Pemilihan dan penggunaan teknik pembaikan yang betulpada struktur berkayu adalah penting selain bagi memenuhiobjektif pemuliharaan, suatu struktur berkayu dapat terusdigunakan dan mengekalkan nilai-nilai warisan yang adapadanya.2.0 Apakah Pemuliharaan dan KonsepPemuliharaanUmumnya pemuliharaan dikenali sebagai aktiviti atautindakan untuk memanjangkan hayat sesuatu benda.Pemuliharaan mengandungi dua aktiviti iaitu pulih danpelihara; dan merupakan penjagaan terhadap sesuatudaripada musnah atau diubah tanpa perancangan yang teliti(Harun, 2005). Pemuliharaan juga dilihat sebagai prosesmenguruskan perubahan dan dalam waktu yang samapembangunan merupakan mekanisme yang membawaperubahan (Orbasli, 2008). Maksud pemuliharaan khususnyaapabila digunakan dalam bidang alam bina juga meliputiaktiviti untuk mencegah pereputan, yang mengandungisemua perbuatan untuk memanjangkan hayat suatu budayadan warisan semula jadi (Fielden, 2000).Berdasarkan pandangan Fielden (2000), aktiviti dan amalanpemuliharaan dilihat sebagai suatu yang teknikal yang manalangkah atau aktiviti untuk mencegah pereputanmemerlukan pengetahuan dan kaedah yang bersifat sains.Definisi pemuliharaan yang diberikan tidak hanya menumpupada aspek teknikal malah ia juga menjurus kepadaperancangan dan pengurusan bangunan bersejarah yanglebih dinamik dalam proses dan pemanjangan hayatbangunan.Dalam pemuliharaan, penelitian terhadap aspek ‘nilai’merupakan perkara penting dalam menentukan kepentingansuatu harta budaya untuk dipulihara (Fielden, 2000). Konsepkeaslian pula amat ditekankan bagi memastikan suatu hartabudaya itu adalah benar-benar bernilai untuk dipulihara. Iniditegaskan oleh Young (1991) bahawa suatu warisan ituperlu dipulihara dengan keasliannya yang sebenarsebagaimana bukti sejarah yang ada kerana ia merupakansebahagian daripada bahan-bahan dokumentasi yangmembolehkan suatu anggapan berkenaan masa lampauPenelitian terhadap aspekkeaslian bahan penting kerana iamembolehkan kita mengetahuitentang teknologi yang lepasdapat dilakukan. Menurut Fielden (1979), dalammelaksanakan kerja-kerja pemuliharaan, empat (4) aspekkeaslian yang perlu dipertimbangkan dan dipraktikkanseperti yang digariskan oleh ICCROM (International Centrefor Study on Preservation and Restoration <strong>of</strong> CulturalProperty) iaitu keaslian bahan, keaslian reka bentuk, keaslianmutu kerja dan teknik pembuatan dan keaslian susun aturdan pembinaan. Penelitian terhadap aspek keaslian bahanpenting kerana ia membolehkan kita mengetahui tentangteknologi yang lepas. Ini turut dinyatakan oleh Rahman(2006) bahawa kerja-kerja pemuliharaan yang berteraskankeaslian hendaklah dipraktikkan di mana pengekalanharuslah dibuat terhadap bahan binaan berdasarkan kepadajenis bahan, warna dan tekstur. Menurut Fielden (2000),kepelbagaian transformasi yang telah dialami bagi sesebuahbangunan telah melahirkan konsep keaslian reka bentukiaitu kajian bagi mengenal pasti struktur asal bangunan, gayaseni bina dan hubungan bangunan dengan persekitaran.Keaslian pada susun atur bangunan perlu bagi dapatmemberi gambaran sebenar berkenaan bentuk bangunandan mengaitkannya dengan peristiwa-peristiwa sejarah yangpernah dialami. Biasanya keaslian ini dapat ditentukandengan melakukan penyelidikan arkeologi (Harun, 2005).Manakala, keaslian mutu kerja adalah bagi mengekalkanketulenan seni pertukangan dan teknik pembuatan yangamat sukar didapati sekarang.3.0 Prinsip dan Pendekatan PemuliharaanMasjidBeberapa prinsip asas dalam melaksanakan kerjapemuliharaan perlu difahami terlebih dahulu. Prinsipmerupakan aspek penting yang menjadi panduan dalammana-mana aktiviti pemuliharaan bangunan dan monumenbersejarah. Ini terkandung dalam pelbagai piagamantarabangsa.Pemuliharaan telah dikenal pasti sebagai satu tindakan atauaktiviti yang berkaitan dengan kerja-kerja membaikikerosakan dan penjagaan bangunan bersejarah. Setiapaktiviti pemuliharaan itu akan melibatkan gangguan iaituperkara yang menyentuh kepada ‘nilai’ suatu bangunanbersejarah. Gangguan tersebut adalah sebaiknya yang palingminima kerana ia akan melibatkan kehilangan nilai danseharusnya ia boleh dikawal atau disesuaikan mengikutkeadaan. Ini dinyatakan dalam mana-mana piagamantarabangsa yang berfungsi bagi memandu kerja-kerjapemuliharaan warisan seperti dalam Piagam Burra danVenice. Menurut Ahmad (2006), kejayaan dalam setiap kerjakerjapemuliharaan warisan adalah berdasarkan kepadaprinsip-prinsip asas pemuliharaan warisan itu sendiri jikaianya dipatuhi. Sehubungan dengan itu, kerja-kerjapemuliharaan warisan perlu dijalankan dengan teknik dan14


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>kaedah pemuliharaan yang betul. Ahmad (2006) jugamencadangkan empat prinsip utama yang perlu sentiasadiamalkan dalam kerja-kerja pemuliharaan di <strong>Malaysia</strong> iaitu:1. Meminimakan Gangguan. Seperti yang terkandungdalam (Piagam Burra Artikel 3, 1979) menggariskanbahawa “....pemuliharaan merupakan kerja-kerja yangmengganggu bangunan dari segi kedudukan dan fabrikbangunan. Oleh itu sebarang gangguan untukpenyelidikan dan kerja awalan mestilah palingminima....”.2. Menjalankan kajian saintifik dan ujian makmal. Sepertiyang terkandung dalam ICOMOS, Artikel 13, 1998 yangmenggariskan “..pemuliharaan seharusnya berdasarkanpenyelidikan dan penyiasatan fizikal dan sebaiknya iabersifat tidak memusnahkan” dan Artikel 10 (e)..“..gangguan awalan seharusnya mendahulukan kerjakerjaadalah penyelidikan, penyiasatan dan merekodyang bersesuaian”.3. Mendokumentasikan kerja-kerja pemuliharaan. Initerkandung dalam Artikel 10 (f), ICOMOS 1998 yangmenggariskan .. “..rekod dan dokumentasi pemuliharaanseharusnya dijaga dan diselenggara termasuklah rekodbangunan atau tapak dalam arkib yang bersesuaian..”4. Mengaplikasikan kaedah dan teknik yang terbuktiberkesan. Dalam Fasal 4, Artikel 4.1 dan 4.2, PiagamBurra menggariskan bahawa “..pemuliharaan harusmemanfaatkan seluruh ilmu pengetahuan, kemahirandan disiplin yang dapat memberi sumbangan padakajian dan pemuliharaan suatu tempat..” dan “.. bahandan teknik tradisional lebih diutamakan bagipemuliharaan bahan yang signifikan. Bagi keadaantertentu, penggunaan teknik moden dan bahan yanghampir sama boleh disesuaikan…”.Umumnya terdapat tujuh (7) pendekatan yang digunakanbagi suatu program pemuliharaan, dan ianya bolehdigabungkan bergantung kepada situasi dan keperluandalam memenuhi objektif pemuliharaan tersebut iaitupemeliharaan, pengekalan, pengembalian semula,penjagaan, pembangunan semula, pemulihan danpengukuhan (Kamal & Ahmad 2007, Idid, 1996, Fielden1982).Dalam memulihara bangunan keagamaan khususnya sepertimasjid, beberapa pendekatan diguna pakai bagimemanjangkan penggunaan bangunan ini kepadamasyarakat Islam. Antaranya seperti pemeliharaan,pengekalan, penjagaan dan pengembalian semula. Projekpemuliharaan Masjid Tinggi Lama di Bagan Serai (gambarfoto 1), Perak misalnya telah menjalani kerja-kerjapemulihan dan pemuliharaan dengan mengekalkanbeberapa ciri-ciri penting seperti bahan binaan, reka bentukbangunan dan lokasi. Manakala pemuliharaan MasjidKampung Laut di Nilam Puri, Kelantan pula telah melaluikerja-kerja pengembalian semula setelah dipindahkan darilokasi asalnya akibat ancaman bencana alam.Dalam memulihara bangunan masjid ini, tidak semuapendekatan boleh diguna pakai dan ia bergantung padajustifikasi keadaan. Konsep pengembalian semula yangGambar foto (1): Masjid Tinggi Lama Bagan Serai dibina pada 1897, dantelah menjalani kerja pemuliharaan bangunan.Gambar foto (2): Masjid Lama Kg. Mendun, Negeri Sembilan yang berusiahampir 100 tahun masih berdiri dengan binaan tambahan struktur yangboleh dibezakan dengan yang asal. Masjid ini dikatakan dibina padatahun 1928 yang diasaskan oleh Tuan Hj Mohd Said B.Patun, salahseorang penduduk tetap dan ulama di kampung tersebut.dirujuk dalam Artikel 1.7, Piagam Burra (1999) misalnya, iabermaksud mengembalikan semula struktur yang sedia adakepada keadaan asal seperti yang diketahui denganmembuang tambahan-tambahan atau memasangkomponen atau elemen bangunan yang pernah terdapattanpa menggunakan atau memperkenalkan sebarang bahanbaru ke atasnya. Burden (2004), mendefinisikanpengembalian semula sebagai usaha untuk mendapatkanbentuk dan butiran secara tepat sesuatu benda sewaktu iawujud melalui penanggalan atau penggantian bahan yangtelah hilang dengan yang baru. Berbeza dengan keadaanmasjid lama khususnya yang masih digunakan di manapenambahan-penambahan ruang dapat dilihat dengan jelaskerana konsep masjid adalah untuk menggalakkankehadiran jemaah (lihat gambar foto 2). Struktur-strukturyang kebanyakannya adalah dalam bentuk kekal ini tidakdigalakkan untuk diroboh mengikut konsep pengembaliansemula kerana ia akan menjejaskan konsep sebuah masjid.Peer Review Article15


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Namun, ia boleh digunakan jika terdapat justifikasi lainseperti adanya masjid baru yang dibina berdekatan atau iatidak lagi digunakan.Sebagaimana memulihara bangunan-bangunan lama yanglain, kaedah pembaikan dan penggantian terhadap elemenelemenyang rosak dan hilang pada sebuah masjid perlulahmenggunakan pendekatan yang bersesuaian. Misalnyapenggunaan jenis kayu bagi menggantikan elemen yangtelah rosak akibat pereputan yang serius, ia perlulahmengikut jenis kayu yang sama. Jika sukar didapati,penggunaan kayu yang mempunyai ciri dan kekuatan yanghampir sama boleh digunakan. Untuk elemen yang telahhilang pula, konsep pengembalian semula digunakan iaitudengan menghasilkan semula dengan melakukan peniruandari segi rekaan dan penggunaan bahan binaan. Inibersesuaian dengan konsep pembinaan semula menurutArtikel 1.8, Piagam Burra (1999) iaitu denganmengembalikan sesuatu itu sedekat yang mungkin kepadakeadaan asalnya dan boleh dibezakan denganmenggunakan bahan-bahanlama dan baru. MenurutBurden (2004), pembinaansemula didefinisikan sebagaipembinaan baru terhadap apayang telah hilang ataumusnah, dalam bentukkeadaan yang asal dari segibahan binaan dan perincianyang asli. Apa-apa penggantianterhadap elemen yang hilangatau mengalami keusanganyang teruk mestilah mampukelihatan bersatu dan harmonidengan keadaan keseluruhandan boleh dibezakan antarabahan atau elemen yang asaldengan yang baru melalui satupemeriksaan yang teliti.4.0 TeknikPembaikan Bangunan KayuDalam mana-mana kerja bangunan, penggunaan teknik yangbetul dapat memastikan suatu kerja itu dilakukan dengantepat. Pemilihan teknik yang bersesuaian dalampemuliharaan bangunan, berserta mengaplikasikan prinsipasas pemuliharaan adalah penting bagi menjayakan suatukerja pemuliharaan. Kerja-kerja pemuliharaan amat menitikberatkan pengekalan keaslian suatu harta budaya tersebut.Dalam memenuhi kriteria ini, beberapa prinsip asas telahdiwujudkan bagi memastikan gangguan atau kerja-kerjayang dijalankan dilakukan sebaik mungkin dan ini tidaksemestinya tetap kerana ia bergantung pada keadaankeadaantertentu. Menurut Weaver (1999), antara prinsipkerja pembaikan kayu yang lazimnya digunakan adalah:1. Cari dan buang/ hapuskan punca kerosakan. MenurutRidout (2000), punca utama yang menyebabkankerosakan pada kayu adalah kelembapan. Mana-manabahagian yang terjejas teruk akibat kerosakan yangdisebabkan oleh kehadiran kelembapan yang tinggiPemilihan teknik yangbersesuaian dalam pemuliharaanbangunan, bersertamengaplikasikan prinsip asaspemuliharaan adalah penting bagimenjayakan suatu kerjapemuliharaan. Kerja-kerjapemuliharaan amat menitikberatkan pengekalan keasliansuatu harta budaya tersebut.perlulah di cari puncanya. Bahagian-bahagian sepertikebocoran atap atau bumbung, talang air (gutter) danruang pengudaraan perlu dibaiki sama ada ditampalatau ditukar bergantung pada tahap kerosakan.2. Kekalkan seberapa banyak kerja-kerja asli yangterdahulu.3. Apabila membaiki atap bumbung dan lantai kayu ditingkat atas, perhatian diperlukan terutamanya padabahagian bawah siling khususnya apabila terdapatnyakerja-kerja dekorasi seperti lepaan (plastering) padatingkat bawah bangunan.4. Kaedah meluruskan bahagian struktur yang bertukarbentuk (deformed) perlulah dilakukan dengan berhatihati.Pada keadaan tertentu, struktur ini amat senanguntuk patah, meregang dan akhirnya tidak bolehdigunakan.5. Pastikan kayu yangdidedahkan adalah memangdireka bentuk untukdidedahkan. Banyakkerosakan kemudiannyadikesan apabila cat pelindung,‘stucco’ misalnya dibuangkerana tersilap tafsiranbahawa permukaan sebenarkayu adalah tanpa sebarangcat.Selain sebagai panduan asas,pengamatan dan penggunaanprinsip ini dalam kerjapembaikan juga dapatmemastikan bahawa suatukerja pemuliharaan itu tidaktersasar dari matlamatsebenarnya. Dalam manamanakerja pemuliharaan danpembaikan, gangguan yangminimum adalah penting, justeru itu tidak semua keadaanmemerlukan penggantian bahan yang baru. Untukpemuliharaan struktur kayu, empat jenis teknik yanglazimnya digunakan dan dalam suatu projek tidaksemestinya menggunakan satu teknik malah bolehdigabungkan mengikut kesesuaian yang dikehendaki.Kaedah atau teknik bagi kerja-kerja restorasi danpemuliharaan kayu ini boleh dibahagikan kepada beberapajenis dan ianya sama ada penggunaan teknik penggantian,penggunaan teknik reinforcement mekanikal, pengukuhandengan pengisitepuan (consolidation by impregnation) dangabungan pengukuhan dengan reinforcement (consolidationand reinforcement) (Weaver, 1999; Ridout 2000 & Ashurt,1989).4.1 Penggantian Penuh dan SeparaSalah satu jenis teknik pembaikan bagi bangunan kayuadalah menggunakan konsep guna semula. Penggunaansemula struktur kayu dilakukan sama ada secara penuh atau16


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>sebahagiannya. Jika kayu-kayu lamayang terdapat pada suatu bangunanitu berada dalam keadaan usang danteruk kerosakannya, kerja-kerja baikpulih boleh dilakukan sama adasecara separa iaitu mengeluarkanbahagian yang rosak dan digantikandengan yang baru atau penggantiankeseluruhan anggota struktur denganyang baru. Penggantian separadigunakan jika suatu struktur itumasih berada dalam keadaan yangbaik dan hanya memerlukanpembaikan pada kawasan-kawasanyang tertentu sahaja. Bahagian yangrosak teruk akan dipotong dandigantikan dengan kayu baru.Manakala penggantian keseluruhandiaplikasikan apabila suatu struktur itumengalami kegagalan yang agakserius. Penggantian separa ini akanmemerlukan beberapa kaedahpemasangan dan sokongan yang betulbagi memastikan suatu struktur itukembali berfungsi seperti yangdikehendaki. Kedua-dua penggantianini perlulah melihat kepada beberapaaspek yang ditekankan dalampemuliharaan bangunan. Kayu baruyang menggantikan kayu lama iniperlu sesuai sama ada dari segi jenisdan spesies kayu, kualitinya, warnadan arah ira bagi memastikanpenggantian bahan baru ini harmonidengan keadaan yang asalnya.Zon reput: digantidengan resinRod keluli ditanambersama resinkayu kukuhPandangan keratan pada pembaikan rasuk kayuBahagian yang reput diganti dengan epoxy resinBahagian yang lemah dikukuhkan dengan likatanrendah epoxy resin (low viscosity epoxy resin)Rod keluli ditanam bersama resinGambar rajah 1: Kaedah WER (Wood Epoxy Reinforcement) dalam pembaikan rasuk kayu(Diubahsuai dari Weaver, 1999; Ashurt, 1989; Young & Philips, 2008; Johar & Ahmad, 2011)Peer Review Article4.2 Sistem MekanikalReinforcementTeknik ini adalah denganmengembalikan penggunaan kayumelalui sistem penyambunganmekanikal. Bahagian kayu yang rosakakan digantikan dengan kayu barudan dicantum pada bahagian kayuyang masih elok. Untukmemperkukuhkan cantuman ini,kaedah ‘mekanikal reinforcement’digunakan. Umumnya ia dikenalidengan penggunaan sistempenyambungan ‘bolt and nut’, dowel(penetap), pegs (pacang) yangdiperbuat daripada sama ada darikayu, besi atau ‘fibre glass reinforcedplastik’ untuk menguatkan bahagianstruktur kayu tersebut. Sistempenyambungan kayu yang telahlemah boleh dibaiki atau digantidengan penggunaan ‘bracket angleiron’, fishplates’, ‘stirrups’ (rakap) dan‘hangers’.4.3 Pengukuhan denganPengisitepuanPenggunaan teknik ini adalah denganmenggunakan suntikan ‘syntheticresin’ bagi mengisi ruang-ruang yangrepui untuk meneguhkan strukturyang rosak. Apabila kayu-kayu lamamenjadi agak berserbuk atau repuiakibat tindakan serangga, fungus dankerosakan termal (terbakar), bahagianyang tinggal atau berlohong dicantumsemula dengan kaedah ‘impregnation’kayu dengan ‘synthetic resin’ dengankelikatan rendah atau penggunaan‘molten wax’. Penggunaan ‘syntheticresin’ ini juga boleh digunakandengan ‘filler’ bagi menyatukan kayuketika terdapatnya ruang-ruangpemisah (gap). Cara penggunaanresin ini adalah dengan menggerudikayu untuk dibuat lubang dandimasukkan menggunakan picagari‘hypodermic’ atau ‘bulk loading guns’.4.4 Pengukuhan danReinforcementLazimnya kaedah ini dikenali sebagaiSistem WER (Wood EpoxyReinforcement) yang dihasilkan dariCanada (lihat gambar rajah 1).Menurut Weaver (1999) terdapat satulagi sistem yang menggunakankonsep serupa yang dihasilkan dandigunakan di Belanda iaitu SistemBETA. Dua kaedah ini menggunakangabungan ‘synthetic resin’ dan kelulireinforcement untuk mengembalikanstruktur kayu lama danmembolehkannya untuk menanggungbeban semula. Penggunaan kaedahini adalah dengan membuangbahagian yang mengalami kerosakandan pereputan teruk. Untukmenggantikan bahagian ini,penggunaan epoxy mortar yangdiperkukuhkan dengan penggunaanreinforcement dipasang dan17


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013abcGambar rajah 2: Kaedah pembuangan cat, (a) menggunakan sapuan ‘paint remover sebelum dikikis; (b) menggunakan kaedah haba; (c) menggunakan alat‘sander’ (Diubahsuai dari DoItYourself, 1995; Johar & Ahmad, 2011; Mustafa et al, 2011)disambungkan kepada bahagian kayu lama yang masih elok.Penggunaan sistem ini diaplikasikan apabila kayu beradadalam tahap keusangan yang serius dan menggantikannyadengan kaedah lain akan menjejaskan konseppemeliharaannya.4.5 Pembuangan Lapisan CatBangunan-bangunan kayu lama akan turut mengalamiperubahan sebagaimana bangunan lama yang lain.Penggunaan bahan cat sebagai kemasan akhir banyakdikesan pada rumah-rumah, dan bangunan kayu di <strong>Malaysia</strong>.Penyingkiran bahan ini lazimnya dilakukan bagimengembalikan semula warna asal kayu yang dikehendakidalam suatu kerja pemuliharaan. Proses pembuangan catdapat dilakukan dengan pelbagai cara dan setiap satunyamempunyai kelebihan dan kekurangannya tersendiri.Terdapat tiga cara yang lazimnya digunakan bagi membuanglapisan cat iaitu dengan penggunaan cecair penghilang cat(paint remover), teknik haba dan penggunaan alat penghalus(sander).4.6 Pengawetan kayu dan Pengawalan SeranganSeranggaPengawetan kayu selalunya digunakan bagi melindungikayu-kayu yang senang diserang oleh agen biologi dengankekuatan menahan serangan tersebut. Terdapat tiga jenisiaitu berasaskan minyak tar (coal-tar creosote); pelarutorganik (Pentachlorophenol, Naphthenate, Tributyl tin oxide,Organo boron compounds, synthetic pyrethroids, gammahexachloro-cyclohexane);dan bahan yang larut dalam air(cooper, zink, chromium and arsenic, CCA). Umumnya yangpaling lazim digunakan adalah copper, chromium arsenicsalts (CCA) namun penggunaannya terhad pada strukturstrukturawam seperti jambatan dan tiang-tiang kayu(Hoadley (2000). Pada bangunan pula, bahan pengawetseperti cooper azole banyak digunakan bagi menggantikanpenggunaan CCA.Perkara yang ditekankan dalam pengawetan adalahpenyerapan bahan pengawet ke dalam kayu. Bahagian yangmenyerap bahan awetan ini adalah bahagian yang selalunyadilindungi. Justeru itu, pemilihan jenis kayu perludipertimbangkan sama ada mudah menyerap atausebaliknya. Proses pengawetan dilakukan dalam dua caraiaitu menggunakan kaedah tekanan (pressure) ataupuntanpa tekanan (kaedah rendaman, celupan/ dipping, sapuanberus). Kaedah berusan atau celupan biasanya digunakanbagi melindungi dan mengawet permukaan kayu sahaja.Kaedah ini lazimnya tidak menghasilkan serapan bahanpengawetan yang dalam, tetapi tujuannya melindungibahagian-bahagian yang terdedah dari serangan biologi.Kesalahan yang lazimnya dilakukan apabila menggunakankaedah sapuan ini adalah mengaplikasikannya apabilastruktur binaan itu telah dibina. Ia seharusnya diaplikasikansebelum dibina terutamanya pada bahagian sambungan danpada bahagian yang terdedah kepada risiko kelembapan.Bahagian-bahagian yang terdedah dengan hujan dankeadaan persekitaran luar, walaupun secara asasnyaterdedah pada kelembapan, namun ia lebih cepat mengeringkerana dengan adanya bantuan cahaya matahari danpengudaraan. Ini berbeza dengan bahagian-bahagian yangterlindung seperti bahagian sambungan yang mana jikaterdapatnya kelembapan, ia lambat untuk mengering. Justeruitu, mengaplikasikan bahan pengawetan ini perlulahdilakukan sebelum kayu ini digunakan dalam sambunganstruktur kerana jika sapuan dilakukan selepas itu, amat sukarbagi memastikan sapuan yang rata dapat dicapai. Tekniksapuan tidak dapat bertahan lama terutamanya jika terdedahsecara terus dan terhakis pada cuaca persekitaran. Justeruitu, kaedah pengawetan yang menjanjikan resapanmendalam bersama kaedah sapuan dapat membantumemanjangkan hayat penggunaan kayu dari seranganbiologi ini.Kerja-kerja pengawalan serangan serangga dan kulat tidakhanya tertumpu pada pengawetan kayu, malah ia perlu juga18


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Jadual 1: Penggunaan teknik pembaikan yang diaplikasikan dalam kerja pembaikan danpemuliharaan masjid kayu lama di <strong>Malaysia</strong>Nama MasjidKayu LamaMasjid LamaMulong, KelantanMasjid Lama KgKuala Dal, KualaKangsarMasjid Lama KgJerang, NegeriSembilanMasjid Lama Kg.Sungai Relai,Negeri SembilanMasjid TinggiLama, BaganSeraiMasjid Kg. Laut,KelantanSistemPenggantianPenuh/Sebahagiandilakukan pada persekitaran bangunankhususnya bagi menggalakkanserangan anai-anai. Penggunaan racunserangga yang digunakan sama adadiinjek dalam tanah, pada kayu ataublok umpan (repellant). Bagi seranggalain seperti kumbang, penggunaanracun serangga sama ada melaluiteknik semburan, injek, kabus(fogging) adalah untuk mengurangSistemPengukuhanMekanikalPengukuhandenganPengisitepuanPengukuhandenganReinforcementdan membunuh kumbang danlarvanya yang berada di dalam kayu.Kayu yang telah disembur denganbahan pengawet atau racun ini akanmenyebabkan larva kumbang kurangberminat untuk menjadikan sap kayusebagai makanan lalu akhirnya mati.Pemilihan teknik bagi kawalanserangga adalah bergantung padakeadaan kawasan tersebut misalnyateknik fogging sesuai bagi kawasanyang sukar dimasuki (Ridout, 2000).5.0 Pembaikan MasjidKayu LamaUmumnya, tiada teknik khusus telahdidokumenkan bagi pembaikanmasjid-masjid lama. Ini adalah kerana,tidak semua kes-kes pemuliharaan itusama malah pemilihan teknikbergantung pada beberapa perkaraseperti kos, jenis pemuliharaan,keadaan dan tahap kerosakan sertasumber yang ada. Umumnya, teknikbagi membaiki masjid-masjid lamakhususnya kayu telah menggunakancara pembaikan bagi bangunan kayulama yang lain.Dalam membaiki dan mengembalikanfungsi suatu bangunan kayukhususnya masjid kayu lama, kaedahyang lazimnya dikesan adalah denganmenggunakan teknik penggantiansama ada penuh atau separa. Inidapat dilihat pada kerja-kerjapembaikan terdahulu seperti padaMasjid Tinggi Lama, di Perak, masjidKg Laut di Kelantan, Masjid Kg.Mendun di Negeri Sembilan, MasjidKg. Tuan di Terengganu dan yangPeer Review ArticlebacGambar foto 3: Kerja-kerja pembaikan dan pemuliharaan masjid kayu, (a) Kerja-kerja kemasan dalam pembaikan MasjidLama Mulong, Kelantan (b) Proses kerja mengenal pasti warna cat asal, (c) Pembaikan Masjid Lama Kg. Jerang yang hampirsiap (Johar, 2012)19


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Pembaikan dan Pemuliharaan Masjid Kayu LamaKerja-kerja baik pulih kerosakan bangunanKerja-kerja Pemuliharaan BangunanKajian LanjutanKhidmat kepakaran teknikal- Decay Detecting Drill (Nondestructive survey)- Kenal pasti spesis kayuKajian TapakUjian Makmal- Kajian skema cat dan komposisi bahanKerja-kerja Sementara- Kerangka keselamatan- Bumbung sementaraKerja-kerja Menanggal/ buka dan pengasingan- Proses menaggal mengikut ruang danurutan- Kerja-kerja melabel/ tagging- Pengasingan mengikut keadaan dankerosakan bahan; rosak > 80% dilupuskandan yang masih elok dikekalkan untukdigunakan semula.DokumentasiPelupusan puncakerosakanProses membersih danmembuang bahagianyang rosakPenggantianPeneguhanMekanikalKerja-kerja Baik PulihPengisitepuanPengisitepuanreinforcemenTeknik pembaikan*aplikasi teknik bolehdigabungkan antarasatu sama lain,mengikut keperluanBahan yangmengandungipengawet kayu/cooper azoleSapuan berusKerja-kerja lapisan PerlindunganKerja-kerja PemasanganBahan yangmengandungipengawet kayu/cooper azole- Sapuan berus atausemburan- PerlindunganpersekitaranKerja-kerja kemasan dan perlindungan1.Perlindungan2.Lapisan Kemasan- 1 lapisan asas- 2 lapisan catkemasanMembuanglapisan cat lama- Alat ‘sander’- Alat pemanas- Cecair PelarutcatLaporan Kerja PembaikanRekod dan rujukanGambar rajah 3: Rangka kerja pembaikan kayu dalam amalan pemuliharaan bangunan (Diubahsuai dari Johar, 2012)terbaru Masjid Lama Mulong di Kelantan (gambar foto 3).Selain itu terdapat juga teknik khusus yang mula digunapakai iaitu mengaplikasikan penggunaan teknik pengukuhansecara mekanikal bagi mengukuhkan struktur kayuterutamanya pada bahagian sambungan.Penggunaan teknik yang lebih bersifat kejuruteraan(engineered) seperti pengukuhan pengisitepuan danpengukuhan reinforcement kebanyakannya tidakdiaplikasikan dalam aktiviti pemuliharaan bangunan kayu di<strong>Malaysia</strong>. Penggunaan teknik ini memerlukan kepakaran danpenggunaan bahan tertentu serta boleh melibatkan kos yangtinggi. Suatu struktur kayu yang menjalani proses ini perlulahsangat bernilai dimana kehilangan atau penggantiannyadengan bahan yang lain boleh menjejaskan ciri dan nilaisignifikan pada bangunan tersebut. Pemilihan teknikkonvensional lebih mudah digunakan disamping murahkerana tidak memerlukan kepakaran tertentu, namunpenggunaan teknik ini tidak banyak dapat mengekalkankeaslian binaan tersebut. Dalam setiap bangunan kayu,termasuk juga pada bangunan masjid, penggunaan bahanpengawet kayu amat penting bagi memanjangkanpenggunaan bahan binaan ini dalam alam binaan. Pemilihankayu dalam kerja-kerja pembaikan haruslahmempertimbangkan penggunaan kayu yang telah diawetuntuk mengelakkan kecacatan bangunan pada jangka waktuyang singkat terutama pada bahagian yang mudah terdedahpada agen pereputan. Penggunaan sapuan lapisan pelindungbukan hanya memelihara bangunan kayu dari cepat mereputmalah dapat mengekalkan ciri-ciri estetik kayu sebagai bahanbinaan semula jadi. Tata cara pembaikan kayu ini dapatdirujuk melalui gambar rajah 3 yang telah diringkaskan (tatacara ini boleh berubah mengikut keperluan pembaikanbahan binaan kayu tersebut).6.0 KesimpulanDalam memastikan suatu kerja pemuliharaan itu dijalankansebaiknya, pemilihan teknik yang sesuai perludipertimbangkan. Pemahaman terhadap kerosakan danfaktor kecacatan bangunan adalah penting diketahui dalammana-mana kerja pemuliharaan. Berdasarkan itu, beberapateknik pembaikan bagi bangunan berunsurkan kayu telahdihasilkan selain untuk memastikan penggunaan kayu dapatterus dilanjutkan. Pemahaman dalam penggunaan teknikbagi kerja pembaikan adalah penting bagi memastikan suatukerja pembaikan itu dijalankan dengan sempurna, dapatmengurangkan risiko kerosakan lanjutan dan dapatmemenuhi tuntutan suatu kerja pemuliharaan. l20


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>RujukanAbdullah, Hasnan (1994), Teknologi PengurusanPenyelenggaraan, Penerbit Universiti teknologi<strong>Malaysia</strong>, UTM Skudai, <strong>Malaysia</strong>.Ahmad, A.Ghafar. (1997). British ColonialArchitecture in <strong>Malaysia</strong> 1800-1930. MuseumsAssociation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>, Kuala Lumpur.Ahmad, A.Ghafar. (2006). Rangka KerjaPemuliharaan Bangunan Warisan di <strong>Malaysia</strong>,Bengkel Konservasi Monumen dan Tapak TanahBersejarah, 27-29 November 2006, Hotel Mahkota,Melaka. Ms.1-12.Ashurts, J. & Ashurt, Nicole (1989), PracticalBuilding Conservation Series; Volume 5: Wood,Glass and Resins, Gower Technical Press, England.Burden, E. (2004). Illustrated Dictionary <strong>of</strong>Architectural Preservation. McGraw-Hill, New York.DoItYourself. (1995). How to Remove Paint.Retrieved August 2009, from DoItYourself:http://www.doityourself.com/stry/h2removepaintFielden, M. Bernard (1979)., The Principle <strong>of</strong>Conservation, Conservation <strong>of</strong> Cultural Property(ICCROM), 1979.Fielden, M. Bernard. (2000). Conservation <strong>of</strong>Historic Buildings. Architectural Press, Oxford.Fielden, M. Bernard.( 1982), Conservation <strong>of</strong>Historic Buildings, London: Butterworth Scientific,1982.Glover, Peter (2003), Building Surveys, 5th Edition,Butterworth-Heinemann, Great Britain.Harun, S. Norlizaiha (2005), Amalan KerjaPemuliharaan Bangunan Bersejarah Di <strong>Malaysia</strong>,Phd Thesis USM, 2005.berasaskan Inventori Bangunan Warisan <strong>Malaysia</strong>.Kuala Lumpur: Badan Warisan <strong>Malaysia</strong>.Johar, S, Ahmad A.G. (2011).Pemuliharaan danPembaikan Masjid Kayu Tradisional: TinjauanTeknik Pembaikan, Pemuliharaan dan PromosiWarisan: Memperkasa Khazanah Negara,Simposium Warisan Kebangsaan- KelestarianWarisan Negara, 29 September 2011, PusatPengajian Sains Kemasyarakatan, Universiti Sains<strong>Malaysia</strong>, Pulau Pinang.Johar, S. (2012). Pembaikan dan PemuliharaanMasjid Kayu Lama Di <strong>Malaysia</strong>, Phd Thesis, USM,2012.Kamal, K.Syahril & Ahmad, A.Ghafar, (2007);Pendekatan dalam Kerja Pemuliharaan BangunanBersejarah di <strong>Malaysia</strong>: Satu Tinjauan Umum, PostGraduate Research Colloquium 2007, 30-31 January2007, Penang, <strong>Malaysia</strong>.Kamal, K.Syahril (2007), Kecacatan Dan KerosakanUmum Pada Rumah Melayu Tradisional: Kajian KesRumah Kutai, Proceedings 2nd Asean PostGraduate Seminar in Built Environment, 4-6December 2006, Kuala Lumpur, Pg. 189-198.Mustafa, N.K.F. et al. (2011). “Conservation andRepair Works for Traditional Timber Mosque in<strong>Malaysia</strong>: A Review on Techniques”. Proceedings <strong>of</strong>World Academy <strong>of</strong> Science, Engineering andTechnology. 77(May2011):862-867.Orbasli, Aylin (2008), Architectural ConservationPrinciple and Practice, Blackwell Publishing,Blackwell Science, USA.Rahman, N.H. (2006). Kepentingan Arkeologidalam Kerja-kerja Konservasi Monumen dan TapakTanah Bersejarah, 27-29 November 2006, HotelMahkota, Melaka. Ms.1-40.Peer Review ArticleHoadley, R.B. (2000). Understanding Wood: ACraftsman’s Guide to Wood Technology. TauntonPress.ICOMOS (1998). International Charters forConservtion and Restoration.http://www.international,icomos.org/, September2006.ICOMOS, A. (1979). Charter For The Conservation <strong>of</strong>Places <strong>of</strong> Cultural Significance (The Burra Charter).Australia: ICOMOS.ICOMOS. (1999). Principle for the Preservation <strong>of</strong>Historic Timber Structure, 1999. ICOMOS. Availableonline: http://www.international,icomos.org/,Accessed on March 2009.Idid. S.Z.A (1996), Pemeliharaan Warisan RupaBandar: Panduan mengenali Warisan Rupa BandarRichardson, B.A (2001), Defects and Deteriorationin Buildings, 2nd Edition, Spon Press, New York.Ridout, Brian (2000) Timber Decay in Buildings,The conservation Aproach to Treatment, E & FNSpoon, London & New York.Weaver, Martin. E (1997), Conserving Buildings, AManual Techniques and Materials, John Wiley andSons, Inc, New York.Young, David & Philips, Peter (2008), Timber Repair,Technical Leaflet, NSW Department <strong>of</strong> Planning,Victorian Goverment Department Of Planning andCommunity Development, Melbourne, Australia,March 2008. Available Online atwww.heritage.vic.gov.au, Accessed on 8 July 2009.Young, G. (1991). Authenticity in CulturalConservation, Australia Planner, Vol 29, 3-5.21


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Empirical Study <strong>of</strong> theImpact <strong>of</strong> RevitaliseOld Industrial Buildingson Property PricesThe Case <strong>of</strong> Hong KongHei Lam, PoonUndergraduate student, Department <strong>of</strong> Building and Real Estate,The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong;Email: 11601740d@connect.polyu.hk22


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Hong Kong’s economy has undergone a remarkable transformation in the past threedecades. The most visible phenomenon in this transformation is the relocation <strong>of</strong>traditional manufacturing activities to China since the 90’s. This has led many <strong>of</strong> the oldindustrial buildings under-utilised and dilapidated. The HKSAR Government launched the“Revitalising Industrial Buildings Policy” in order to revitalise these under-utilisedproperties with the aim to provide suitable land and premises to meet the local economicand social needs. Yet, as suggested in the literature, there is no evidence <strong>of</strong> positivedevelopment externalities reflected in improved real estate values for surroundingproperties. However, there are only a few empirical studies that have been carried out inHong Kong to investigate how revitalisation affects residential property prices in aneighbourhood. In this light, this study explores the relationships between therevitalisation <strong>of</strong> old industrial buildings and the market value <strong>of</strong> the neighbourhoodresidential properties, with a case study in Kwun Tong. A set <strong>of</strong> panel data is employedand price differentiation at different revitalisation stages is explored. The findings suggestthat revitalisation did not originate a net positive price effect on neighbourhoods’residential properties which is in line with findings <strong>of</strong> the previous studies. The study als<strong>of</strong>inds that negative externalities generated by the revitalisation during and postrevitalisationstages are almost similar in magnitudes. However, the wholesale conversionmode and small scale revitalisation have less negative impacts on the prices.Peer Review Article1. INTRODUCTIONThe change <strong>of</strong> economic structurein Hong Kong has significant impacts to thelocal industrial buildings. In the past decades,Hong Kong economic structure has graduallychanged from manufacturing base to services base.In 2010, the manufacturing sector only contributes1.7% to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), whereasthe services sector contributes 93% to the GDP(Census and Statistics Department, 2012). As aresult <strong>of</strong> Hong Kong’s economic reconstructing andrelocation <strong>of</strong> traditional manufacturing activities tothe Mainland, many <strong>of</strong> the industrial buildings arevacant or under-utilised (Development Bureau,2010). According to the report from the Rating andValuation Department (2012), there is 6% vacancyrate for private flatted factories at the end <strong>of</strong> 2011.This data suggested that there are about 1 millionsquare metre <strong>of</strong> floor area that is under-utilised.Also, the old industrial buildings are usuallyconsidered in undesirable conditions and hamperthe pace <strong>of</strong> urban renewal.In view <strong>of</strong> this, the Government tried to widenpermissible uses in industrial buildings by rezoningsuitable existing industrial land from “Industrial” (“I”)to “Other Specified Uses (Business)” (“OU(B)”)zones as early as 2001 in order to encourage therevitalisation <strong>of</strong> old industrial buildings.Recently, the Government launched the “RevitalisingIndustrial Buildings Policy” (the Policy) to furtherpromote the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> factory buildings (TheGovernment <strong>of</strong> the Hong Kong SpecialAdministrative Region, 2009). The policy providesmeasures to encourage redevelopment in nonindustrialzones and wholesale conversion in“industrial”, “other specified uses (business)”(“OU(B)”) and “commercial” zones (DevelopmentBureau, 2010). Refinements are introduced after themid-term review.As a result, the revitalisation potential is very highand it is foreseeable that the districts with plenty <strong>of</strong>old industrial buildings, such as Kwun Tong wouldbe changed dramatically in the future if theGovernment can increase the owners’ or developers’incentive to carry out the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> industrialbuildings.The objective <strong>of</strong> the policy is to provide suitable landand premises to meet Hong Kong’s economic andsocial needs. In other words, the aim <strong>of</strong> this policy isto create positive externalities to the society bytransforming the old dilapidated industrial buildinginto a modern sustainable building. However,building revitalisation may also bring severalproblems to the society, such as wall effect,reduction <strong>of</strong> openness and increase the burden <strong>of</strong>nearby mass transport system. These problemswould cause negative externalities to the society.Since the market value <strong>of</strong> the neighbourhoodresidential properties can reflect the impact <strong>of</strong> theexternalities produced by the revitalisations, thisstudy aims to analyse the relationships between therevitalisation <strong>of</strong> old industrial buildings and themarket value <strong>of</strong> the neighbourhood residentialproperties.23


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 20132. LITERATURE REVIEW2.1 Components affecting residential propertypricesThere are a number <strong>of</strong> researches studying the differentcombinations <strong>of</strong> property attributes on variation in residentialproperty prices. The determinants <strong>of</strong> dwelling prices aregrouped into the three categories, namely location, structuraland neighbourhood variables (Can, 1990). By urbaneconomic theory, location variables enter the pricedetermination equation <strong>of</strong> dwelling values because residentsliving far away from Central Business District incur highertransportation costs and should be compensated by lowerland and housing prices in order to maintain spatialequilibrium. Neighbourhood variables are also capitalisedinto property values through the amenity effect. Can (1990)shows that the effects <strong>of</strong> structural housing attributes areequally important within the broad housing market isincorrect, and that the influence <strong>of</strong> structural attributes onprices is characterised by spatial variability. Since the effect <strong>of</strong>structural attributes on price may vary depending on location,neighbourhood attributes may also depend largely uponother neighbourhood factors. More generally, potentialendogeneity <strong>of</strong> these effects at the neighbourhood level canaffect the pricing behaviour <strong>of</strong> owners <strong>of</strong> existing units, aswell as builders <strong>of</strong> new ones, and thereby are the result <strong>of</strong>,and lead to further, the process <strong>of</strong> neighbourhood change(Rothenberg et al., 1991).2.2 Impact <strong>of</strong> buildingrevitalisation to thevalue <strong>of</strong>neighbourhoodpropertiesThe definition <strong>of</strong> buildingrevitalisation may vary fromplace to place. According tothe 2009-10 PolicyAddress, the revitalisation<strong>of</strong> older industrial buildingsis promoted byredevelopment andwholesale conversion <strong>of</strong> vacant or under-utilised industrialbuildings (The Government <strong>of</strong> the Hong Kong SpecialAdministrative Region, 2009).In 1950s, the Hong KongGovernment decided to developKwun Tong into a major industrialarea. Residential buildings weredeveloped together with theindustrial area, due to the highdemand for housingLocally, there has been little empirical evidence on theimpact <strong>of</strong> building revitalisation to the value <strong>of</strong>neighbourhood properties. Chau et al. (2004) and Lai et al.(2007) investigated how two comprehensive redevelopmentprojects altered the spatial-price gradients <strong>of</strong> the residentialproperties in their neighbourhood, but the findings did notsuggest that comprehensive redevelopment projects create anet positive price effect on the residential properties in theirvicinity. Recently, Yau (2011) discovered that the proximity tothe project site had a significant positive impact on housingprices before the comprehensive redevelopment, but nochange was identified in the spatial-price gradient aftercompletion <strong>of</strong> the development. The results confirm Chau etal. (2004) and Lai et al. (2007) studies that housing pricesdo not respond to the change in the environmental qualityresulting from comprehensive redevelopment.In the overseas perspective, empirical studies suggest thatthe effect <strong>of</strong> the concentration <strong>of</strong> a large number <strong>of</strong> newdwellings on the value <strong>of</strong> neighbourhood properties ispresent and restricted geographically (Segal, 1977; Varady,1986). This implies that the geographic impact <strong>of</strong> most newdevelopment is expected to be limited (DeSalvo, 1974;Quigley, 1982; and Varady 1986). In the late 90’s, Simons etal. (1998) demonstrate that new housing development has asignificant positive effect on the neighbourhood propertiesvalues. The study found that there is a substantial positiveeffect <strong>of</strong> US$670 on the sales price <strong>of</strong> exiting units for eachnew housing construction within one to two blocks.However, rehabilitation was discovered to have a negativeeffect on the sales price <strong>of</strong> exiting units. Ding et al. (2000)extends Simons et al. (1998) works by analysing the effect <strong>of</strong>both new and rehabilitation residential investment onneighbourhood properties values in Cleveland. Theyconcluded with four findings. First, the effect <strong>of</strong> investmenton property values is geographically limited. Second, newinvestment has a greater impact on neighbourhood propertyvalues than rehabilitation. Third, the evidence shows thatnew construction and rehabilitation has a substantial positiveimpact in low-income areas and predominantly non-minorityneighbourhoods. Last but not least, it suggests thatneighbourhood property values has not affected by smallscaleinvestment. Weber et al. (2007) studies the spillovereffects caused by the creation <strong>of</strong> Tax Increment Financing(TIF) districts in the Chicago.Mixed-Use developmentsgenerate price enhancement,proximity to industrial TIF districtsreduces home priceenhancement, and proximity tocommercial districts had little orno measurable effect on priceenhancement (Weber et al.,2007). Rossi-Hansberg et al.,(2010), used data compiled fromconcentrated residential urbanrevitalisation programmesimplemented in Richmond tostudy residential externalities.Within the targetedneighbourhoods, increases in land value are consistent withexternalities that fall exponentially with distance. Newell(2010) recently established that there is no evidence <strong>of</strong>positive development externalities reflected in improved realestate values for surrounding properties, which challengesmany <strong>of</strong> the arguments used to champion urbanrevitalisation initiatives.3. METHODOLOGY AND DATA DESCRIPTION3.1 Case study in Kwun TongIn 1950s, the Hong Kong Government decided to developKwun Tong into a major industrial area. Residential buildingswere developed together with the industrial area, due to thehigh demand for housing. As mentioned before, theproduction lines <strong>of</strong> varies industries were migrated toMainland China from time-to-time. Nowadays, the industrialbuildings in Kwun Tong were fading out and left vacant,many <strong>of</strong> these buildings were undergoing revitalisation.24


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Table 1: Summary <strong>of</strong> the revitalisation projectsUnder the PolicyNOT under the PolicyUnited Overseas Plaza Rykadan Capital Tower Crocodile CenterLocation No. 11 Lai Yip Street No. 135 Hoi Bun Road No.79 Hoi Yuen RoadExecution Date 18 th February 2010 26 th September 2011 16 th January 2006Completion Date December 2010 Under construction November 2009Total GFA 96,126ft 2 207,000ft 2 230,000ft 2No. <strong>of</strong> Storey 11 25 25User Office Non-Residential Shop and Services & OfficeDevelopment Model Wholesale conversion Redevelopment RedevelopmentFormer Building United Overseas Industrial Building Elite Industrial Centre Crocodile Garment FactoryFormer User Industrial Industrial IndustrialAt the end <strong>of</strong> 2012, there were 28 special waiver (wholesaleconversion) cases and two lease modification(redevelopment) cases executed, while more than half <strong>of</strong> thespecial waiver cases were located in Kwun Tong Inland Lotsince the implementation <strong>of</strong> the Policy in April 2010(Development Bureau, 2010). The residential property pricesin this district rose over 100% from April 2009 to January2013, which was 20% ahead <strong>of</strong> the average growth rate inHong Kong (Midland Realty, 2013). Therefore, it createdsuspicions <strong>of</strong> whether such a strong growth rate from thefirst quarter <strong>of</strong> 2011 in Kwun Tong was attributable to thesuccessful applications <strong>of</strong> revitalising old industrial buildingwithin the neighbourhood. As a result, the uniquecharacteristic and development history in Kwun Tongprovided a platform for this study to be carried out.3.2 Background <strong>of</strong> the targeted projectsThree different revitalisation projects in Kwun Tong arechosen for this study namely, United Overseas Plaza (UOP),Rykadan Capital Tower (RCT) and Crocodile Center (CC).There are several reasons <strong>of</strong> adopting these projects. Firstly,UOP is the first wholesale conversion case under the Policy.Secondly, RCT is the only redevelopment case under thePolicy in Kwun Tong. Thirdly, CC is one <strong>of</strong> the recentredevelopment projects not developed under the Policy.Lastly, the locations <strong>of</strong> these buildings are not far away fromthe nearby residential properties. The particulars <strong>of</strong> theseprojects are summarised in Table 1.3.3 Hedonic Price ModelThis study selects Kwun Tong as a case study due to itscharacteristics and it is facing a huge transformation in terms<strong>of</strong> the building use nowadays. So, the Hedonic Price Model(HPM) will be applied in this district to explore therelationships between the market value <strong>of</strong> the residentialproperties and the residential properties’ attributes includingthe impacts <strong>of</strong> revitalisation <strong>of</strong> old industrial buildings indifferent stages <strong>of</strong> time and other attributes.The combination <strong>of</strong> double-log and log-linear functional formwill be adopted in this study because a constant elasticitycan be met by the double-log functional form, while the loglinearfunctional form can encounter the problem <strong>of</strong> thedummy variable. Since, it is not able to be logged if thedummy variable has the value <strong>of</strong> zero. Real transaction priceis used instead <strong>of</strong> nominal price to control for the possibleeffects <strong>of</strong> time. So, the nominal prices are deflated by thedomestic property price index compiled by the Rating andValuation Department in Hong Kong. The common variablesincluding, AGE it , FLOOR i , AREA i , PM i , MTR i and BS i areincorporated into the model to control price variation due tothese structural and locational attributes.The following is the hypothetical equation <strong>of</strong> the HedonicPrice Model adopted in this study:lnRP it = α 0 + α 1 lnAGE it + α 2 lnFLOOR i + α 3 lnAREA i + α 4 PM i+ α 5 lnMTR i + α 6 BS i + α 7 lnUOP i + α 8 lnRCT i + α 9 lnCC i +α 10 lnUOP i ×DURING_UOP i + α 11 lnRCT i ×DURING_RCT i +α 12 lnCC i ×DURING_CC i + α 13 lnUOP i ×AFTER_UOP i +α 14 lnCC i ×AFTER_CC i + ε iWhere RP it is the real transaction price <strong>of</strong> property i at time t(measured in million HKD); AGE it is the age <strong>of</strong> property i,which equals the difference between the date <strong>of</strong> the issue <strong>of</strong>the occupation permit and the date <strong>of</strong> the transaction t(measured in months); FLOOR i is the floor level <strong>of</strong> property i;AREA i is the saleable floor area <strong>of</strong> property i (measured insq. ft.); PM i is a dummy variable which equals 1 if there is aproperty management company serving the building inwhich the property i is located and 0 if otherwise; MTR i isthe minimum walking time (measured in minutes) betweenproperty i and the nearest Mass Transit Railway (MTR)stations; BS i is a dummy variable which equal to 1 if there isone or more Bus stop(s) located within one minute walkingtime from the property i and 0 if otherwise; UOP i is thedisplacement between property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> UnitedOverseas Plaza (UOP) (measured in metres); RCT i is thedisplacement between property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> RykadanCapital Tower (RCT) (measured in metres); CC i is thedisplacement between property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> CrocodileCenter (CC) (measured in metres); UOP i ×DURING_UOP i isan interaction variable which measure the displacementbetween property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> UOP (measured inmetres) and the transaction time <strong>of</strong> property i (duringrevitalisation stage <strong>of</strong> UOP); and it amounts to 0 for anyother stages; RCT i ×DURING_RCT i is an interaction variablewhich measure the displacement between property i and thecentre <strong>of</strong> RCT (measured in metres) and the transaction time<strong>of</strong> property i (during revitalisation stage <strong>of</strong> RCT); and itamounts to 0 for any other stages; CC i ×DURING_CC i is aninteraction variable which measure the displacementbetween property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> CC (measured inmetres) and the transaction time <strong>of</strong> property i (duringrevitalisation stage <strong>of</strong> CC); and it amounts to 0 for any otherstages; UOP i ×AFTER_UOP i is an interaction variable whichmeasure the displacement between property i and thePeer Review Article25


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Figure 1: Study area (750m) from the centre <strong>of</strong> the revitalisation projects (Lands Department, 2012)Table 2: Descriptive statistics <strong>of</strong> the property transaction dataVariable Mean σ Min. Max.Real transaction price (million HKD) 1.4878 1.1780 0.0849 57.7997Age (months) 443.2772 106.8933 97.0000 594.0000Floor level 7.6294 5.5447 1.0000 29.0000Saleable floor area (sq. ft.) 427.6618 145.7315 185.0000 3215.0000Present <strong>of</strong> property management company 0.9362 0.2444 0.0000 1.0000Minimum walking time to the nearest MTR stations (minutes) 5.4506 2.3951 1.0000 11.0000Accessibility to bus stop 0.6635 0.4726 0.0000 1.0000Displacement to the centre <strong>of</strong> UOP 742.0262 230.5711 310.0000 1126.0000Displacement to the centre <strong>of</strong> RCT 815.4042 197.5075 493.0000 1133.0000Displacement to the centre <strong>of</strong> CC 455.5572 146.5621 180.0000 983.0000Interaction <strong>of</strong> displacement and transaction time <strong>of</strong> UOP (during revitalisation stage) 70.9387 226.8341 0.0000 1126.0000Interaction <strong>of</strong> displacement and transaction time <strong>of</strong> RCT (during revitalisation stage) 75.1656 243.5757 0.0000 1133.0000Interaction <strong>of</strong> displacement and transaction time <strong>of</strong> CC (during revitalisation stage) 218.6012 244.1508 0.0000 983.0000Interaction <strong>of</strong> displacement and transaction time <strong>of</strong> UOP (post-revitalisation stage) 117.9758 285.4903 0.0000 1126.0000Interaction <strong>of</strong> displacement and transaction time <strong>of</strong> CC (post-revitalisation stage) 99.0458 204.5226 0.0000 983.0000centre <strong>of</strong> UOP (measured in metres) and the transactiontime <strong>of</strong> property i (post-revitalisation stage <strong>of</strong> UOP); and itamounts to 0 for any other stages; CC i ×AFTER_CC i is aninteraction variable which measure the displacementbetween property i and the centre <strong>of</strong> CC (measured inmetres) and the transaction time <strong>of</strong> property i (postrevitalisationstage <strong>of</strong> CC); and it amounts to 0 for any otherstages; α i is the coefficients to be estimated and ; ε i is thestochastic term.The transaction data for the residential properties within 750metre from the centre <strong>of</strong> the revitalisation projects is asshown in Figure 1 were obtained. Two years before “duringrevitalisation” stage will be considered as the prerevitalisationstage. While, “during revitalisation” stage isdefined as the construction or renovation period <strong>of</strong> the targetprojects. Regarding the post-revitalisation stage, it isconsidered as two years after the “during revitalisation”stage. Therefore, all the transaction records within the period<strong>of</strong> 16th January 2004 to 31st December 2012 were obtainedfrom the Economic Property Research Centre. The summarystatistics <strong>of</strong> the data are presented in Table 2.4. EMPIRICAL RESULTS AND ANALYSIS4.1 ResultsThe results <strong>of</strong> the HPM are shown in the Table 3. Theadjusted R-squared <strong>of</strong> this model is 0.6711 which is anacceptable value and the F-Test result is highly significance.Also, there are only one coefficient is found to be statisticallyinsignificant.In general, the findings suggest that most <strong>of</strong> the commonvariables are shown to be significant at 1% level except for26


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Table 3: Regression results for the hedonic price modelIndependent Variable Unstandardised Coefficient Std. Error t-statistic p-value VIFCONSTANT -3.9102 0.3353 -11.6630 0.0000 -LN_AGE -0.4709*** 0.0226 -20.7919 0.0000 2.3832LN_FLOOR 0.0538*** 0.0062 8.6244 0.0000 1.2178LN_AREA 1.0889*** 0.0181 60.0605 0.0000 1.4049PM 0.1491*** 0.0197 7.5698 0.0000 1.1288LN_MTR -0.0629*** 0.0217 -2.8965 0.0038 5.6700BS 0.0396** 0.0162 2.4417 0.0147 2.8623LN_UOP -0.3835*** 0.1070 -3.5827 0.0003 62.4671LN_RCT 0.5741*** 0.1323 4.3410 0.0000 53.7308LN_CC -0.2042*** 0.0446 -4.5779 0.0000 10.4389LN_UOP*DURING_UOP 0.0167*** 0.0041 4.0985 0.0000 3.0586LN_RCT*DURING _RCT 0.0276*** 0.0045 6.0822 0.0000 3.7512LN_CC*DURING_CC 0.0473*** 0.0020 24.0558 0.0000 1.7299LN_UOP*AFTER_UOP 0.0072* 0.0041 1.7474 0.0806 4.8351LN_CC*AFTER_ CC 0.0530*** 0.0040 13.3948 0.0000 4.7317Adjusted R-squared 0.6711 Durbin-Watson 1.3938F-statistic 585.9381 Number <strong>of</strong> observations 4015Prob (F-statistic) 0.0000Note: (***), (**) and (*) denote that the estimated coefficients <strong>of</strong> the variables are significant at the 1%, 5%and 10% level respectively.the accessibility to the bus stop which is significant at 5%level. Also, all common variables are matched with theexpected sign. The results reveal that residential propertyprices are negatively linked to building age and theminimum walking time to the nearest MTR station, whilepositively related to the floor level, saleable floor area, thepresence <strong>of</strong> property management in serving the buildingand the presence <strong>of</strong> bus stop(s) within one minuteworking time to the building.For the variables regarding the impacts <strong>of</strong> revitalisation, thefindings indicated that most <strong>of</strong> them are shown to besignificant at 1% level except for the interaction termLN_UOP*AFTER_UOP which is significant at 10% level.Thus, there is a significant relationship between thesevariables and the residential property prices except for thatinteraction term.Regarding the signs and degree <strong>of</strong> the coefficients, theresults indicated that in pre-revitalisation stage, there is 1%increase in displacement between the property and UnitedOverseas Industrial Building (former development <strong>of</strong>United Overseas Plaza) or Crocodile Garment Factory(former development <strong>of</strong> Crocodile Center) could cause0.3835% or 0.2042% decrease in property pricesrespectively, while 1% increase in displacement betweenthe property and the displacement <strong>of</strong> the Elite IndustrialCentre (former development <strong>of</strong> Rykadan Capital Tower)could induce 0.5741% increase in property prices. For the“during revitalisation” stage, the results returned that 1%increase in displacement between the property and UnitedOverseas Plaza, Rykadan Capital Tower or the CrocodileCenter could induce 0.0167%, 0.0276% or 0.0473%increase in property prices respectively. Concerning thepost-revitalisation stage, the results suggested that 1%increase in displacement between the property and theCrocodile Center could induce 0.0530% increase inproperty prices.For the overall price changes caused by the revitalisationprojects, the price gradient <strong>of</strong> United Overseas Plaza andCrocodile Center followed the same trend. Both <strong>of</strong> themare negative value on the pre-revitalisation stage and thenremain in slightly positive value in during and postrevitalisationstages. Although, both <strong>of</strong> the projects have thesame trend, the United Overseas Plaza always has the smallervalue compare with the Crocodile Center. Regarding theRykadan Capital Tower, it has a relatively high positive value atthe beginning stage and then falls down to slightly positivevalue on “during revitalisation” stage.Chartered Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong>Construction CostConsultantProject Managers: Juru Ukur Bahan Bertauliah: Penasihat Ekonomi Pembinaan: Pengurus ProjekPENANG OFFICE56D, 2nd & 3rd Floor, Perak PlazaJalan Perak, 10150 Penang, <strong>Malaysia</strong>Tel: 04-2285441 Fax: 04-226 6528Email: jubutara@gmail.comPeer Review Article27


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 20134.2 Analysis4.2.1. Pre-revitalisation stageThe negative coefficients <strong>of</strong> LN_UOP and LN_CC appear tocontradict the perception that proximity to an old industrialbuilding should result in a discount in property prices due tothe negative externalities. On the other hand, the positivecoefficient <strong>of</strong> LN_RCT proves that this intuition is correct. Thepossible explanation for this situation is that the negativeexternalities were outweighed by the higher levels <strong>of</strong>convenience and accessibility <strong>of</strong> the sites. Since, the projectsites for the United Overseas Industrial Building andCrocodile Garment Factory were located near the MTRstations namely, the Ngau Tau Kok station and Kwun Tongstation, while the Elite Industrial Centre is not. A similarresult was generated in the previous study about thedevelopment <strong>of</strong> Langham Place complex in Mong Kok (Yau,2011). Therefore, the positive value returned only in thecoefficient <strong>of</strong> LN_RCT and it indicated that the residents inKwun Tong District tend to purchase a residential propertyaway from the industrial buildings. This is likely because <strong>of</strong>the unpleasant views and air pollution problem <strong>of</strong> the oldindustrial buildings.The findings also suggest that among the degree <strong>of</strong> negativecoefficients, the negative externalities <strong>of</strong> the CrocodileGarment Factory are higher than the United OverseasIndustrial Building. One <strong>of</strong> the possible causes is that thedevelopment scale <strong>of</strong> the Crocodile Garment Factory (twoblocks) is much higher than the United Overseas IndustrialBuilding (single building). With the greater developmentscale, the opportunities to create unpleasant views and airpollution are higher.4.2.2. During revitalisation stageThe positive coefficients are consisting (consistent?) with thenotion that proximity to a conversion or redevelopment siteshould result in a discount in property prices because <strong>of</strong>negative externalities. These negative environmental impactsinclude air pollution created by the construction orrenovation, noise pollution generated during the process aswell as traffic jams induced by the trucks which affect theaccessibility. Thus, the residents in Kwun Tong District wish tobuy a residential property away from the conversion orredevelopment sites.In addition, the LN_CC*DURING_CC has the greatestnegative externalities to the neighbourhood, while theLN_UOP*DURING_UOP has the lowest. The possibleexplanations are related to the mode and the scale <strong>of</strong>revitalisation. When considering the mode <strong>of</strong> revitalisation,only the United Overseas Plaza has undergone the wholesaleconversion process, but the rest <strong>of</strong> the targeted projects wereredevelopment. It shows that the wholesale conversionmode creates less negative externalities compared with theredevelopment mode, since conversion <strong>of</strong> a building doesnot involve the demolition process, the negative impact fromthis process can be eliminated. In other words, the nuisancesto the residents in Kwun Tong District are less compared inthe conversion mode with the redevelopment mode.With Best ComplimentsfromHead OfficeG22A Jalan Pandan Prima 2,Dataran Pandan Prima,55100 Kuala LumpurTel: (603) 9287 4949Fax: (603) 92877552E-mail: piqs@streamyx.comWeb: www.pakatan.net.myKuchingLot 7022, 1st FloorSection 64, KTLD, Jalan Pending93450 Kuching SarawakTel: (6082) 330223Fax: (6082) 330221Penang70, Off Jalan Mahsuri11950 Bandar Bayan Baru, Pulau PinangTel: (604) 642 0255Fax: (604) 642 0262E-mail: pakatan_png@yahoo.comKota KinabaluLot 3-3, Blok A, 3rd FloorRuang Plaza LagendaHeritage Plaza, Jalan Lintas Luyang88830 Kota Kinabalu, SabahTel: (6088) 716696ISO 9001:2000ID NO. 1940 AiQS RICS28


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Usually, in large scales <strong>of</strong> revitalisation,the number <strong>of</strong> the construction activitieswould increase and consequently,aggravate the negative environmentalimpacts that were mentionedRegarding the scale <strong>of</strong> revitalisation, the CrocodileCenter has about 230,000 ft2 in Gross Floor Area,while the Rykadan Capital Tower and the UnitedOverseas Plaza only have about 207,000 ft2 and96,126 ft2 in Gross Floor Area, respectively. Itshows that the greater the scale <strong>of</strong> revitalisation,the greater is the negative externalities generated.Usually, in large scales <strong>of</strong> revitalisation, thenumber <strong>of</strong> the construction activities wouldincrease and consequently, aggravate thenegative environmental impacts that werementioned.4.2.3. Post-revitalisation stageThe coefficient <strong>of</strong> LN_CC*AFTER_CC has thepositive sign which suggest that the proximity to apost-revitalisation site result in a discount inproperty prices because <strong>of</strong> negative externalities.In theory, the transformation <strong>of</strong> an old dilapidatedindustrial building into a modern sustainablebuilding should create some positive externalitiesto the neighbourhood. Nevertheless, this studyindicates that the insignificant positiveexternalities created by the Crocodile Centercounter balance the negative externalities.Although the Crocodile Center has a distinctivearchitectural style as well as a comprehensiveshopping mall, the captivating outlook andfacilities still cannot provide a great enhancementin positive externalities to the neighbourhood andthis is likely owing to the negative environmentalimpacts generated by this modern building.Originally, the highest block in Crocodile GarmentFactory was 10-storey only, but now, theCrocodile Center has 25-storey. This giganticchange in building height seriously affects theopenness <strong>of</strong> view and ventilation issues in theneighbourhood residential buildings. In fact,some <strong>of</strong> the old industrial buildings are stillundergoing industrial business, the air pollutantsfrom these buildings and vehicles might not bedispersed easily because <strong>of</strong> the wall-effect <strong>of</strong> thisbuilding. Also, there are not enough greenfeatures or open spaces provided by this building.Therefore, the residents might suffer from seriousair pollution problem due to the blockage <strong>of</strong>breezeways by the Crocodile Center. As a result,this is reflected in the neighbourhood propertymarket and it counters the positive benefitsgenerated by this revitalisation project.4.2.4. The overall impact <strong>of</strong> revitalisation projectson residential property pricesThe results <strong>of</strong> this study confirm previous findings(Chau et al., 2004; Lai et al., 2007 and Yau, 2011)that Hong Kong revitalisation projects did notoriginate a net positive price effect onneighbourhoods residential properties, assumingthat all other factors are constant. The findings inthis study suggest that there are negativeexternalities generated by the revitalisationprojects throughout the stages <strong>of</strong> revitalisationand the magnitudes are almost similar in theperiod during and <strong>of</strong> post-revitalisation stage.In addition, a noteworthy point is that the modeand scale <strong>of</strong> the revitalisation projects in differentstages <strong>of</strong> revitalisation have a certain impacts onthe neighbourhood residential property prices. Itseems that the wholesale conversion have lessnegative impacts on property prices compare withredevelopment, while the higher the scale <strong>of</strong>revitalisation, the greater is the negative impactson the property prices.Furthermore, this study suggested that therevitalisation projects which are conducted underthe Policy and those are not share the similarimpacts on the neighbourhood residentialproperties prices in the during revitalisation stage.When considering the construction method, theRykadan Capital Tower is not likely to beconstructed in a sustainable way and the Policydoes not require Crocodile Center to have asustainable construction. Consequently, thesimilar value in during revitalisation stage is likelydue the scale <strong>of</strong> development as mentionedbefore but not the effect <strong>of</strong> the Policy.5. CONCLUSION ANDRECOMMENDATIONRevitalise old industrial buildings is an approachto provide readily available and suitable land andpremises by regenerate and maximise thedevelopment potential <strong>of</strong> the old dilapidatedindustrial buildings through wholesale conversionand redevelopment in order to improve the builtenvironment, catch the Hong Kong's economicneeds and enhance social benefits. To test thishypothesis, a Hedonic Price Model wasconstructed with a set <strong>of</strong> transaction data forresidential properties in the Kwun Tong District.The effect <strong>of</strong> the common property attributes areconfirmed in the study. Also, it examined thatrevitalisation projects did not originate a netpositive price effect on neighbourhoods'residential properties, provided that all otherfactors being constant. The projects which areconducted under the "Revitalising IndustrialBuildings Policy" have the similar impact on theneighbourhood residential properties prices withthe project which is not under the Policy in theduring revitalisation stage. The mode and scale <strong>of</strong>Peer Review Article29


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013...the policy maker should encouragemore wholesale conversionrevitalisations within the society andalso give some incentives in providinggreen features in the revitalisation,so the negative externalities could bereduced or even disappearthe revitalisation projects in different stages <strong>of</strong>revitalisation have a certain impacts on theneighbourhood residential property prices. Itseems that the wholesale conversion have lessnegative impacts on property prices compare withredevelopment, while the higher the scale <strong>of</strong>revitalisation, the greater is the negative impactson the property prices. Furthermore, there arenegative externalities generated by therevitalisation projects throughout the stages <strong>of</strong>revitalisation and the degree <strong>of</strong> negativeexternalities is similar in the period <strong>of</strong> during andpost-revitalisation stage.The reason <strong>of</strong> the revitalisation projects did notoriginate a net positive price effect onneighbourhoods' residential properties is likelycontributed to the negative environmental impact<strong>of</strong> the new development. Therefore, this studyprovides some evident or suggestions to thepolicy maker that the Government should have abetter control in the urban planning in order toreduce the negative environmental impactgenerated by the revitalisation projects, whichcontradicted with the propose <strong>of</strong> the Policy. Inaddition, this study provides the evident thatwholesale conversion mode <strong>of</strong> revitalisationinduce less negative impact to theneighbourhood compare with the redevelopmentmode. Therefore, the policy maker shouldencourage more wholesale conversionrevitalisations within the society and also givesome incentives in providing green features in therevitalisation, so the negative externalities couldbe reduced or even disappear.Since the Rykadan Capital Tower is still underconstruction during this study, further studies aresuggested to confirm the results. Also, accordingto the Outline Zoning Plan <strong>of</strong> Kwun Tong (South)approved by Town Planning Board (2012), asthere are number <strong>of</strong> permitted usages stated inBAHARUDDIN ALI & LOW SDN BHD(R.O.C. No. 63558-U) LJBM No.: 1993/FC00010Jurukur-Jurukur Bahan Berkanun & Ekonomis PembinaanChartered Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong> & Construction Cost ConsultantsHead Office217 & 219, Jalan Perkasa Satu,Taman Maluri, Cheras,55100 Kuala LumpurTel: (603) 9285 3744Fax: (603) 9285 5452/6231Email: balow@balow.com.myWebsite: www.balow.com.myBranch Office72B, Jalan Abiad,Taman Tebrau Jaya,80400 Johor Bahru,Johor Darul TakzimTel: (607) 333 8480Fax: (607) 333 9614Email: balowjb@balow.com.myWebsite: www.balow.com.my30


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>the Schedule <strong>of</strong> Uses, such as hotel, the impacts <strong>of</strong> type <strong>of</strong>revitalised buildings on the neighbourhood residentialproperty market would be worth studied in the futurewhen these revitalisations are completed. In addition,further study could address the influence <strong>of</strong> revitalisationon the neighbourhood residential property market in terms<strong>of</strong> distance. Last but not least, the usefulness <strong>of</strong> theRevitalising Industrial Buildings Policy in assisting KwunTong District to become a Central Business District 2 and itsimpacts on the neighbourhood residential property marketcould be investigate in the future. All <strong>of</strong> these proposedstudies can <strong>of</strong>fer public administrators and urban managersvaluable insights into how revitalisation should proceed,with a view to more justifiable economic, social andenvironmental sustainability.ACKNOWLEDGEMENTI would like to use this opportunity to give my sincerethanks to my family, friends and the other people whoencouraged, inspired, supported and helped me incompleting this work. Especially, Dr. Wadu MesthrigeJayantha, for his patient guidance, valuable advice andsupport throughout my working progress.This article was winner <strong>of</strong> Best Paper Award at the 5th RICS-RISM-AALSMInternational Surveying Conference for Undergraduates held on 19th – 20thApril 2013 at Taylor ’s University, Bandar Sunway , West <strong>Malaysia</strong> lReferencesCan, A. (1990). The measurement <strong>of</strong> neighborhooddynamics in urban house prices. Economic Geography,66(3), 254-272.Census and Statistics Department. (2012). Grossdomestic product (GDP) by economic activity -percentage contribution to GDP at basic prices.Retrieved November 2, 2012, fromhttp://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp250.jsp?subjectID=25&tableID=036&ID=0&productType=8Chau, K. W., Lai, L. W. C., Wong, W. S., Yiu, C. Y., & Wong,S. K. (2004). The economic and social impact <strong>of</strong>redevelopment – A Hong Kong case study. BuildingDilapidation and Rejuvenation in Hong Kong.DeSalvo, J. S. (1974). Neighborhood upgrading effects <strong>of</strong>middle-income housing projects in New York City.Journal <strong>of</strong> Urban Economics, 1(3), 269-277.Development Bureau. (2010). Revitalising industrialbuildings. Retrieved November 2, 2012,fromhttp://www.devb.gov.hk/industrialbuildings/eng/home/index.htmlDing, C., Simons, R., & Baku, E. (2000). The effect <strong>of</strong>residential investment on nearby property values:Evidence from Cleveland, Ohio. Journal <strong>of</strong> Real EstateResearch, 19(1), 23-48.Lai, L. W. C., Chau, K. W., Yiu, E. C. Y., Wong, K. S. K.,Wong, W. S., & Chan, P. Y. L. (2007). Measuring andinterpreting the effects <strong>of</strong> a public-sector-led urbanrenewal project on housing prices — an empirical study<strong>of</strong> a comprehensive development area zone developedupon 'taking' in Hong Kong. Environment and PlanningB: Planning and Design, 34, 524-538.Lands Department. (2012). Geospatial information hub.Retrieved January, 15, 2013, fromhttp://www1.map.gov.hk/gih3/view/index.jspMidland Realty. (2013). Midland property price chart(Kwun Tong). Retrieved January 25, 2013, fromhttp://proptx.midland.com.hk/mpp/default.jsp?districtId=18Newell, T. A. (2010). Development and neighborhoodrevitalization: The effects <strong>of</strong> residential investment onproperty values in durham, NC. The Michigan Journal <strong>of</strong>Business, 3(2), 97-120.Quigley, J. M. (1982). Nonlinear budget constraints andconsumer demand: An application to public programsfor residential housing. Journal <strong>of</strong> Urban Economics,12(2), 177-201.Rating and Valuation Department. (2012). Hong Kongproperty review 2012. Retrieved November 2, 2012,fromhttp://www.rvd.gov.hk/en/doc/hkpr12/PR2012_full.pdfRossi-Hansberg, E., Sarte, P. D., & Owens III, R. (2010).Housing externalities. Journal <strong>of</strong> Political Economy,118(31).Rothenberg, J., Galster, G. C., Butler, R. V., & Pitkin, J. R.(1991). The maze <strong>of</strong> urban housing markets: Theory,evidence, and policy University <strong>of</strong> Chicago Press.Segal, D. (1977). Urban economics RD Irwin.Simons, R. A., Quercia, R. G., & Levin, I. M. (1998). Thevalue impact <strong>of</strong> new residential construction andneighborhood disinvestment on residential sales price.Journal <strong>of</strong> Real Estate Research, 15(2), 147-161.The Government <strong>of</strong> the Hong Kong SpecialAdministrative Region. (2009). 2009-10 policy address.Town Planning Board. (2012). The approved Kwun Tong(south) outline zoning plan no. S/K14S/16.Varady, D. P. (1986). Neighborhood upgrading: Arealistic assessment SUNY Press.Weber, R., Bhatta, S. D., & Merriman, D. (2007). Spilloversfrom tax increment financing districts: Implications forhousing price appreciation. Regional Science and UrbanEconomics, 37(2), 259-281.Yau, Y. (2011). Does comprehensive redevelopmentchange the housing price gradient? A case study inMongkok, Hong Kong. Urbani Izziv, 22(2), 98.Peer Review Article31


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013The Impact <strong>of</strong> Information &Communications Technology (ICT) OnWork-Life Balance <strong>of</strong>Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Women inthe Construction IndustryLoh Chin Bok, Nurmimi Fardiana bt Mohd Toha, KamPei Cheen et al.Undergraduate student, Quantity Surveying Programme<strong>of</strong> School <strong>of</strong> Housing, Building and Planning,Universiti Sains <strong>Malaysia</strong>, Pulau Pinang, <strong>Malaysia</strong>;lohchinbok@gmail.comIn the transition to an information-based global economy, the linesbetween work and home are vague as technology reshapes theworkplace and the nature <strong>of</strong> home-life evolves. Work-life balancereflects an individual's orientation across career roles and non-careerlife roles as an incompatible inter-role phenomenon. Although worklifebalance has been heavily investigated for many years, the role <strong>of</strong>information and communications technology (ICT) has not beendiscussed exhaustively. The notion that ICT technology allowspr<strong>of</strong>essional women to establish a work-life balance easier ischallenged. The latest incarnations <strong>of</strong> work in relation to ICT haveshifted work accomplishment <strong>of</strong> the pr<strong>of</strong>essional women in theconstruction industry. The advancement <strong>of</strong> ICT such as portablegadgets, mobile computing as well as electronic mail facilitatesworking capabilities outside the confines <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>fice and at almostany time <strong>of</strong> the day. However, obstacles such as uneven adoption <strong>of</strong>policies, lack <strong>of</strong> formalisation, long working hours and temporaladjustment to working time are encountered by the pr<strong>of</strong>essionalwomen in achieving work-life balance. In an attempt to explore therelationship between work-life balance and ICT, a qualitativeresearch on pr<strong>of</strong>essional women in the construction industry wasundertaken. It was found that ICT plays a significant role in achievingwork-life balance and those pr<strong>of</strong>essional women are greatly satisfiedwith its impact. Consequently, time is effectively well managedbetween work and a plethora <strong>of</strong> life-related pursuits such as qualitytime with family, sports, volunteer work and further studies.32


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>1. INTRODUCTIONIn <strong>Malaysia</strong>, women account for only46% participation rate in the workforce whichis much lower than that <strong>of</strong> other Aseancountries, as reported previously by the WorldBank’s research (Lisa Goh, 2013). Besides, in theTalentCorp and Association <strong>of</strong> Chartered CertifiedAccountants (ACCA) survey shows that there is atotal <strong>of</strong> 65% <strong>of</strong> the women leave the workplacewith the reason <strong>of</strong> raising a family, followed bycomplaints about lack <strong>of</strong> work-life balance (43%),while some wanted to care for a family member(38%). Other reasons include expensive childcare(35%), lack <strong>of</strong> support facilities for women fromemployer (34%) and inflexible work arrangements(32%).Since the 1940’s, women have entered the labourforce in growing numbers at a rate <strong>of</strong> over 200percent (Riley and McCloskey, 1996). Thesetransformations are placing greater demands onwomen to balance work and family life. Accordingto human context, a family is a group <strong>of</strong> peopleaffiliated by consanguinity, affinity, or co-residence(Ivanovic, 2012).Work-life balance is about effectively creating,managing and maintaining supportive the jugglingact between paid work and other activities thatare vital to us which include spending time withfamily, taking part in sport and recreation,volunteering or undertaking further study (Ministry<strong>of</strong> Business, Innovation & Employment).Peer Review ArticleICT are <strong>of</strong> special interest to researchers seekingto understand the balance between work andpersonal life as they have been linked to afundamental shift in how the boundaries betweenwork and home are constructed (Golden andGeisler, 2007). Technology has changed thebusiness practices <strong>of</strong> millions <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essionalworkers worldwide. Today, the latest incarnations<strong>of</strong> work related information and communications<strong>of</strong> technology (ICT) have shift the way in whichwork is accomplish for pr<strong>of</strong>essional employees.The ICT tools such as mobile computing, mobilecommunication devices and portable gadgets,have support the work to be done outside theconfines <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>fice and at almost any time <strong>of</strong>the day (Tower et al., 2006). It is widely acceptedthat ICT play a crucial role in work-life balance byfacilitating working at home and after formalhours (Boswell & Olson-Buchanan, 2007).Based on the above discussion, this paper carriesthese objectives:1. To explore ICT in relation to Pr<strong>of</strong>essionalWomen in achieving work-life balance.2. To examine the impact <strong>of</strong> ICT on work-lifebalance.33


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 20132. INFORMATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGY (ICT)2.1 Definition <strong>of</strong> ICTAccording to Gholami (2006), ICT isthe result <strong>of</strong> the convergence <strong>of</strong> IT andCT technologies due to the acronym<strong>of</strong> ICT is used to represent a concept<strong>of</strong> a combination <strong>of</strong> two unrelatedconcepts, (1) information technologyand (2) communication technology.Information technology (IT) is theterm used to describe the equipmentand s<strong>of</strong>tware elements that allow usto access, retrieve, store, organise,manipulate and present informationby electronic means. Communicationtechnology (CT) is the term used todescribe equipment, infrastructure,and s<strong>of</strong>tware through whichinformation can be received andaccessed. For instance, phones,facsimile, modems, digital networksand DSL lines (Gholami, 2006). ICTcan also be defined as technologies ordevices that have the capacity toacquire, store, process, or transmitinformation (Steinmueller, 2000) andit includes personal computers, theInternet access, mobilecommunication devices and email.2.2 Types <strong>of</strong> ICT2.2.1 Portable GadgetsPortable gadgets such as smartphonesand personal digital assistants (PDAs)are the most significant drivers forimproving work-life balance whichhave made working ‘out <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>fice’or ‘work at home’ (Orange, 2006). Asmartphone is used to characterise awireless telephone set with a specialcomputer-enabled features notpreviously associated with telephonessuch as wireless email and webbrowsing while PDA is a PersonalDigital Assistant which refer to anyhandheld small device that <strong>of</strong>ferscomputing and information storage aswell as retrieval capabilities forpersonal or business use (Gill, 2008).It usually keeps the schedulecalendars and addresses bookinformation handy and easily access.Smartphones or any other electronicgadgets, allow us to talk, text, accesslocation-specific information as wellas accessing the <strong>of</strong>fice facilities, suchas diary appointments and thecorporate network, all whilst on theFigure 1: Reasons women leave the workforceTo raise a familyLack <strong>of</strong> work-life balanceTo care for a family memberChildcare is too expansiveLack <strong>of</strong> support facilitiesfor women from employerInflexible work arrangementsSource: TalentCorp & ACCAmove and at a time and placeconvenient to the user.2.2.2 3G and 4G Mobile(%) 0 10Gill (2008) defined the term 3G as the3rd Generation <strong>of</strong> developments inwireless technology, especially mobilecommunications. It includescapabilities and features such asenhanced multimedia (voice, data,video and remote control), usability onall popular modes (cellular telephone,e-mail, paging, fax, video conferencingand web browsing) and broadbandwidth and high speed. Interfacingthe phone with the laptop is no longernecessary, as long as the country is 3Genabled. By using the 3G data cardsslotted into the electronic devicesenable the users to access Internetwhen on the move. In public placeslike airport or on a train, 3Gconnection enables people to work aseffectively ‘out <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice’ as behind adesk.4G or the 4th Generation Mobilestandards are a series <strong>of</strong> measuresthat defines the demands <strong>of</strong> a 4Gnetwork and also the standards thatmust be met as described by What's AG (2013). 4G networks <strong>of</strong>fer 100Mb/sfor individuals on the move as well assupplies 1GB/s to an immobilelocation or one shifting at a slowmovingspeed, or standing still in thatperfect spot for instance. Although 4Gis faster than 3G, yet it is not widelybeing recognised. Therefore, peoplecan now access their email or38%35%34%32%43%20 30 40 50 60 70corporate network when <strong>of</strong>f-site,travelling between meetings orworking from home. It gives them theflexibility to work their own way, bemore productive and have more timeto dedicate to their private lives.2.2.3 Electronic Mail©The Star Graphics by LAZAR65%Email has been and still is the killerapplication according to Gill (2008). Itis the most used application globallyas it is easy to use and almost instant,and thus a very great tool to usewithin and without the <strong>of</strong>fice.According to New EncyclopediaBritannica (NEB, 2012), Email, in fullelectronic mail, is the messagetransmitted and received by digitalcomputers through a network. Anemail system allows computer userson a network to send text, graphics,and sometimes sounds animatedimages to other users. For instance,there are Google mail, Yahoo mail,Hotmail, and many more. On mostnetworks, data can be simultaneouslysent to a universe <strong>of</strong> users or to aselect group or individual. Recipientscan elect to view, print, save, edit,answer, forward or otherwise react tocommunications. Large corporationsand institutions use email systems asan important communication linkbetween employees and other peopleallowed on their networks. Email isalso available on major public onlineand bulletin board systems, many <strong>of</strong>which maintain free or low-cost globalcommunication networks.34


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>2.2.4 Mobile ComputingWith the introduction <strong>of</strong> mobile computing such aslaptop and tablets into the work environment as asubstitute for personal computers, the workersbecome mobile (Faigen and Fridman, 2002). Theterm “mobile computing” is used to describe theutilisation <strong>of</strong> computing devices which frequentlyinteract in some fashion with a central informationsystem, while away from the normal, fixed place(Zimmerman, J. B., 1999). Thus, Bowden et al. (2006)stated that mobile computing technologies canfacilitate a reduction in construction time and capitalcost as well as reducing the operation andmaintenance cost. In fact, Bowden et al. (2006)explained that mobile computing can help inproviding accurate real-time progress and costinformation as the project progresses.2.2.5 Cloud ComputingCloud computing is an evolving paradigm (Mell andGrance, 2011). It is a model for enabling ubiquitous;on-demand network access to a shared pool <strong>of</strong>configurable computing resources that can be rapidlyprovisioned and released with minimal managementeffort or service provider interaction. Cloudcomputing is basically the access <strong>of</strong> an organisedserver by using a computer or any device that couldaccess the servers. It is a general term for anythingthat involves delivering hosted services over theInternet. These services are broadly divided into threecategories: Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS),Platform-as-a-service (PaaS) and S<strong>of</strong>tware-as-a-Service (SaaS). The name was inspired by the cloudsymbol that’s <strong>of</strong>ten used to represent the Internet inflowcharts and diagrams. Cloud computing comesinto focus when you think about what technologyalways needs.3. WORK-LIFE BALANCEWheatley (2012) defined work-life balance or inanother term as work-home or work-family as thecapability <strong>of</strong> individuals, regardless <strong>of</strong> age or gender,to combine work and household responsibilities.“Work” in this context is considered paid employmentas well as unpaid work carried out for an employer.This is distinguished from “life” which refers to nonwork,comprised <strong>of</strong> free time spent in leisureactivities, and family time (Lowry and Moskos, 2008).The difference between work and life is problematicbecause the instance <strong>of</strong> work-related time, includingtravel-to-work, which cannot be considered asleisure, but equally cannot be considered work in thesense <strong>of</strong>, paid employment. Problems indistinguishing time-use aside, there exists inherentdifficulties in defining the term “balance” vis-à-vis(face-to-face) work-life balance.Peer Review ArticleHead OfficePerpetual 99, Jalan Raja Muda Abdul Aziz,50300 Kuala LumpurTel: 03-2698 0911Fax: 03-26911959Email: rhizpkl@streamyx.comhttp://www.raineandhome.com.my Valuers Market & Feasibility Researches Property Investment Advisers Estate Agents Rating Valuation Consultants Plant, Machinery & Equipment Valuers Property and Project ManagersBranchesPenang 04-263 8093Seremban 06-763 9510Ipoh 05-253 2804Melaka 06-284 8322Kelang 03-3342 0193Johor Bahru 07-386 3791Subang Jaya 03-5631 9688Kuantan 09-515 7100Petaling Jaya 03-7880 6542Kuching 082-235 236Miri 08-5433 701Kota Kinabalu 088-266 520 Representative <strong>of</strong>ficers throughout Asia, Australia, New Zealand,Europe, America & Africa35


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Guest (2002) argued that in the context <strong>of</strong> work and life, balancedoes not refer to an equal weighting <strong>of</strong> the two, but rather anacceptable and stable relationship. However, the desired pointmay differ considerably between individuals. In addition, balancemay be dynamic and changing either through employee’s needsor employer’s demands.3.1 Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Women in Construction IndustryPr<strong>of</strong>essionals play an important role in the construction industry.To design and build a building, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals are required toestablish a formal design team in order to assemble and plan thephysical proceedings, and to integrate those proceedings with theother parts (Hussin and Omran, 2009). The design usually hasbeen prepared by pr<strong>of</strong>essionals such as architects, interiordesigners, civil engineers, quantity surveyors, mechanicalengineers, electrical engineers and structural engineers.The Oxford Dictionary defined ‘pr<strong>of</strong>essional’ as a person who isengaged or qualified in a pr<strong>of</strong>ession. Hence, the ‘Pr<strong>of</strong>essionalWoman’ in this context refers to a woman who is engaged orqualified in a pr<strong>of</strong>ession such as Quantity Surveyor (QS) andArchitect. A pr<strong>of</strong>essional is the one who provides and <strong>of</strong>fers acertain standard level <strong>of</strong> service and the community can rely on.For example, according to the <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> Chartered<strong>Surveyors</strong> (RICS), routes to membership for quantity surveyor, oneobservation was made that most <strong>of</strong> the pr<strong>of</strong>essionals need to havetraining for at least five years, has a set <strong>of</strong> ethics, an annualconference and that the pr<strong>of</strong>ession provides supervisions,qualifications and has a code <strong>of</strong> discipline set. Similarly, the Board<strong>of</strong> Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> (BQSM) has provided the latestQUANTITY SURVEYORS ANDCONSTRUCTION COST CONSULTANTSNo. 18-1 Jalan PJS 8/12, Dataran Mentari, 46150 Petaling Jaya, SelangorTel: 03-56329999 (Hunting Line) Fax: 56363723 / 56367723E-mail: ymfsb@unifi.myLembaga Juruukur Bahan <strong>Malaysia</strong> Permit No. 1993/FC00009YONG DAN MOHAMMAD FAIZ (SABAH)Lot 23 Block C, 2nd Floor Plaza Grand Millennium,Jalan Pintas Penampang,89500 Penampang, Sabah.Tel: 088-733 611 & 088-733 622Fax: 088-733 699 Email: ymfsabah@yahoo.comIn Association With Rider Levett BucknallSingapore, Hong Kong, Jakarta, Bangkok, Vietnam, China, Phillipines,Australia, New Zealand, Great Britain, Europe, Africa, Middle East, India, U.S.A, Canadadata for registered quantity surveyor in 2012, whichthe total number <strong>of</strong> women registered quantitysurveyor are 251 out <strong>of</strong> 963 or 26.1% while the totalnumber <strong>of</strong> women registered graduate quantitysurveyor are 767 out <strong>of</strong> 1364 or 56.2%.3.2 Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Women in Work-Life BalanceWork-life balance generally refers to organisationalsupport for dependent care, flexible workarrangements and family or personal leave (Estes andMichael, 2009). Therefore, it is important forcontractors or employers to ensure that theirpr<strong>of</strong>essional women staff have work-life balance (Limand. Ling, 2012). Pr<strong>of</strong>essional women who achievedwork-life balance would not feel overworked andhence, be more satisfied with their jobs. This mightthen be translated into higher efficiency andproductivity, which would in turn benefit theemployers.There are a lot <strong>of</strong> researches which had been done onwork-life balance. For instance, Challenges <strong>of</strong> Work-Life Balance for Women/Mothers Working inLeadership Positions (Schueller-Weidekamm andKautzky-Willer, 2012). They focus on careeradvancement, time-consuming child care, family liferesponsibility as well as a woman’s tendency towardsbarriers to career development. Work-life enrichmenthas a positive spillover effect that spreads positiveenergy and helps to balance their work-liferelationship. For each individual, the allocation andinteraction with different resources such as time,money, scope <strong>of</strong> decision making, physical, emotionaland social resources were crucial to maintain theindividual work-life balance. Furthermore, to theexisting “glass ceiling,” the predominant responsibilityfor child care is still borne by a woman. The term“glass ceiling” refers to the condition that, despiteincreased entry <strong>of</strong> women into traditionally maledominatedfields, their advancement to leadershippositions is still limited. However, mentoringprogrammes, coaching, networking, and support <strong>of</strong>the partner or from other people help to strengthen afemale’s “s<strong>of</strong>t” skills in achieving work-life balance.3.3 Obstacles <strong>of</strong> Work-Life BalanceGenerally, obstacle is referring to a problem or anissue (Hyman and Summers, 2004). The issues <strong>of</strong>balance between work and non-work life and thegender division <strong>of</strong> employee can be traced to the 19thcentury (Bacik and Drew, 2006). The overall analysisshows there is only 51% who agreed that theycurrently have work and life balanced; 34.2 %disagreed and 14.8% have no idea (The Association <strong>of</strong>Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Engineers, Scientists and Managers,Australia, 2009).Based on the European Agency for Safety and Healthat Work (2012), it is estimated that more than onequarter <strong>of</strong> Europeans suffer from some form <strong>of</strong> workfamilyconflict. Relative to time: 27% <strong>of</strong> workers in theEuropean Union (EU) perceived that they spend toomuch time at work; 28% felt that they spend too littletime with their families; 36% felt that they do not36


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>have enough time for friends and other socialcontacts and 51% believed that they do not haveenough time for their own hobbies and interests.A research had been done by Hyman (2004) whichdiscovered few obstacles as describe below whichcan influence women in achieving work-life balancein most <strong>of</strong> the industries.3.3.1 Uneven Adoption <strong>of</strong> PoliciesFormal written policies have been unevenly adoptedaccording to enterprise size and sector. A number <strong>of</strong>recent data sets indicate that family-friendly policies(FFPs) and work-life balance policies are not evenlydistributed across sectors or organisations. TheWorkplace Employment Relations Survey (WERS)(1998) found that over a quarter <strong>of</strong> manufacturingestablishments had no policies <strong>of</strong> any kind over anyaspect <strong>of</strong> work-life balance including organisationswith fewer than 500 employees. Recent surveysindicate that whilst demand for better balance byemployees had grown, employers have yet to treatwork-life balance as a priority. Hence, from a surveyby the Department <strong>of</strong> Trade and Industry (DTI) surveyshows that a third <strong>of</strong> respondents looking for a jobwould willingly forsake pay for extra flexibility(Bargaining Report, 2003). However, an earlier study<strong>of</strong> 152 union representatives demonstrated stronglythat unpaid leave provided under the 1999legislation was unlikely to be <strong>of</strong> much practicalassistance to parents, many <strong>of</strong> whom wouldfinancially be unable to take advantage <strong>of</strong> the leaveprovisions. Paid parental leave was seen as a keyprovision (Labour Research, 2001).3.3.2 Lack <strong>of</strong> FormalisationLack <strong>of</strong> formalisation is something illegal or informalstatus (Oxford Dictionary). Many policies are informaland unwritten, under the direct control <strong>of</strong> linemanagers, many <strong>of</strong> whom are untrained and lackawareness and understanding <strong>of</strong> family-friendly andwork-life balance issues. Recent studies haveconfirmed that informal provision is common,especially in those small companies which do havework-life balance arrangements (Bond et al., 2002).Moreover, larger companies are more likely to haveformal policies but line managers can and doinfluence their impact by acting as “gatekeepers toemployees’ access” (Dex and Scheibl, 2001). In theirstudy <strong>of</strong> Scottish financial institutions, Bond et al.(2002) found that whilst line managers <strong>of</strong>ten haddiscretion over application <strong>of</strong> FFPs, this was <strong>of</strong>tenfounded upon considerable ignorance <strong>of</strong> bothstatutory requirements and <strong>of</strong> organisational policies.Very few line managers, including those withdelegated authority, had received any specific trainingover issues <strong>of</strong> family-friendly working or work-lifebalance. There was some evidence that even whereformal policy had been introduced, its interpretationand implementation was subject to informal and<strong>of</strong>ten uninformed line manager discretion. This couldlead to internal differences in application bymanagers <strong>of</strong> different departments, and betweendifferent employees responsible to the samemanager.3.3.3 Long Working HoursWomen are found to be less to attain work-lifebalance because they must follow “working longhours culture” which counter-productive (Lewis,2000; Rapoport et al., 2002). For those withsubstantial household responsibilities, <strong>of</strong>ten women,this will be particularly problematic (White et al.,2003). Simultaneously, if it’s the <strong>of</strong>fice culture <strong>of</strong> longhours, it is unfair to people especially with youngchildren to keep up with everyone. Currentimplementation <strong>of</strong> work-life balance fails to addressmany <strong>of</strong> the core issues due to the surrounding workconditions (Shorthose, 2004).3.3.4 Temporal AdjustmentWork-life balance is interpreted and implemented byemployers through temporal adjustments to workingtime, such as flexi-time. Temporal adjustment inworking time means a small alteration in time madeto achieve a desired fit or result. Nevertheless, othertangible and intangible work-derived factors intrudeinto people’s domestic lives. The evidence aboveindicates that notwithstanding identification <strong>of</strong> worklifebalance as temporal flexibility by employers andthe extended use <strong>of</strong> flexible time arrangements overrecent years; actual working hours for many peopleare increasing rather than decreasing. Pressures onworking people (and their families) are alsoexacerbated by the spreading intensification <strong>of</strong> worknoted by several authors (Cooper et al., 2001; Taylor,2001; Green, 2001). Evidence from the ScottishFuture <strong>of</strong> Work project confirms that work and itseffects can even intrude into people’s lives in waysthat extend beyond the working day (or night). Manyemployees, including those with young families, workshifts at weekends. Some work extra hours withoutcompensation and also pr<strong>of</strong>essional staff commonlytake work home after putting in a full working day intheir <strong>of</strong>fices (Harvey, 1999; Scase, 2002).4. ICT AND WORK-LIFE BALANCEInformation and Communications Technology (ICT)continues to develop at an exponential rate andvirtually everyone is involved in the constructionindustry (Ashworth et al., 2007). Life-long learning <strong>of</strong>ICT allows women to shift from the bottom <strong>of</strong> thecareer path to the mid-level or top-level <strong>of</strong> leadershippositions (Melhem, 2009). Increasing permeability <strong>of</strong>work-family boundaries from the utilisation <strong>of</strong> ICT hascaused the individuals become accessible at anytimeand at anywhere (Lewis & Cooper, 1999; Nippert-Eng,1996). Conversely, individuals may spend more andmore time on housework activities which may have anegative impact on their job performance (Kossekand Lautsch et al., 2006). Therefore, shifting fromisolated and specialised applications to environmentsas well as capable <strong>of</strong> communicating with others isone <strong>of</strong> the ways to characterise the recent advances<strong>of</strong> the ICT in the construction industry according toPeer Review Article37


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Bedard (2003). In fact, most <strong>of</strong> the pr<strong>of</strong>essionals are attracted andare willing to employ ICT which provide general purpose s<strong>of</strong>twareincluding Internet facility (Internet Explorer or Netscape) and E-mail facility (Micros<strong>of</strong>t Outlook, Yahoo, Hotmail, etc.).4.1. Impact <strong>of</strong> ICT on Work-Life BalanceOrange (September 2006) stated that ICT, such as mobiletechnology and mobile computing, is one <strong>of</strong> the drivers forimproving work-life balance. Some <strong>of</strong> today’s most notable effectson work-life balance occur through teleworking, in which workersuse information technologies including computers, email, mobilephones, facsimile machines, modems and other networkingdevices.Employees who are <strong>of</strong>ten on-call for work have reported that ICTdevices such as mobile phones actually increase the quality <strong>of</strong>their home life (Lowry & Moskos, 2005). Mobile phones allowemployees who were previously required to stay at home whileon-call for work the freedom to plan family outings during theiron-call hours. In addition, more control over interactions withothers due to the absence <strong>of</strong> unplanned interruptions frommanagers and co-workers decreases their levels <strong>of</strong> stress (Dubrin,1991).Women suffer higher levels <strong>of</strong> stress due to work-life imbalancewhere a recent study showed that the stress level from work-lifeimbalance almost doubled over the past decade (Guelzow et al.,1991). According to Quesenberry & Trauth (2005), parents whoare unable to provide abundant and affordable care for theirchildren may experience time lost from work or a decrease inproductivity. Moreover, interruptions due to familyobligations can violate on work. Duxbury and Higgins(2003) reported that “employees with high roleoverload are three and a half times more likely to havehigh levels <strong>of</strong> absenteeism due to physical, mental, oremotional fatigue than counterparts with low levels <strong>of</strong>role overload.” Therefore, flexibility is a key element <strong>of</strong>the family-supportive workplace (Pleck, Staines & Lang,1980). Related advances include policies such asflexible scheduling, which have been facilitatedthrough the implementation <strong>of</strong> technology that freesworkers from a fixed, standardised schedule for thecompletion <strong>of</strong> their work tasks (Valcour and Hunter,2004). As such, workplace flexibility enhanced theirproductivity (Golden & Veiga, 2005) and hence,indirectly improves their work-family balance (Golden& Veiga, 2005) as well as increases their jobsatisfaction (Bailey & Kurland, 1999).Similarly, greater flexibility by ICT allows workers todecide where they are able to complete their work(Day et al., 2010). For example, having access to virtualprivate network technology allows workers to accesstheir work computers from home, and email as well asmobile phones allows employers to stay in contactwith employees when they do work outside <strong>of</strong> the<strong>of</strong>fice. Apart from that, access to this type <strong>of</strong> technology<strong>of</strong>fers employees more opportunities to balance theirwork responsibilities together with their homeresponsibilities. Employees can avoid the commute tothe workplace and use ICT to complete important workwith technologies such as virtual meetings andteleconferences. Consequently, they can spend moretime with their family, thus improved work-life balance.Standen et al. (1999) suggested that employees whohave more flexibility and control over their workschedules due to the use <strong>of</strong> ICT are more likely toreport improved general quality <strong>of</strong> life such as moreaccess to leisure activities, improved employeepsychological functioning at work, improved workperformance, decreased time-based role conflict, andincreased family support. These positive effects <strong>of</strong> ICTassistedwork may also improve employee health andwell-being.‘‘Double-edged’’ sword is used to describe ICT in theworkplace by Lowry and Moskos (2005) as it is nothomogeneous in either its uses or its impact onemployees. With ICT, work can be done more easilyand make employees’ lives better. In fact, a recentreport by the US Department <strong>of</strong> Labor indicated that55.5% <strong>of</strong> employees required the use <strong>of</strong> a computerfor their job and approximately two <strong>of</strong> every fiveemployees use the Internet or email for workpurposes. Besides, ICT can make employees moreaccessible to others at work and can allow work andthe workplace to be more available to the employee.The portability <strong>of</strong> various technologies and easy accessto ICT functions enable employees to continue workingafter leaving the <strong>of</strong>fice for the day (Porter & Kakabadse,2006). It provides easier access to information andreduced travel time to get information such as reducingtravelling either to the workplace or to other sites38


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>housing required information.Communication technologies alsohave made it increasingly feasible foremployees to stay connected to workwhen not in the <strong>of</strong>fice (Boswell, &Olson-Buchanan, 2007).Evidence on the impact <strong>of</strong> technologyand telecommuting on aspects <strong>of</strong>work-life balance is equivocal.Generally, research suggests that theuse <strong>of</strong> portable information andcommunication technologies isassociated with increased negativespillover from work to family, evenwhen controlling for occupation, workhours, and commuting time (Chesleyet al., 2003). However, in a series <strong>of</strong>studies <strong>of</strong> International BusinessMachines (IBM) employees inpr<strong>of</strong>essional occupations, Hill et al.found that telecommuters reportedhigher levels <strong>of</strong> work-life balance andsuccess at personal/family life thandid employees who worked in atraditional <strong>of</strong>fice setting (Hill, Ferris, &Martinson, 2003; Hill, Hawkins, Ferris,& Weitzman, 2001; Hill, Miller, Weiner,& Colihan, 1998). Other studiesindicate that work intrudes on andinterferes with the family and personallives <strong>of</strong> telecommuters (Epstein et al.,1999; Bailey& Kurland, 1999).4.2. Application <strong>of</strong> ICT amongPr<strong>of</strong>essional WomenAmong the ICT tools that have beenpopularly used by pr<strong>of</strong>essionalwomen are portable gadgets, mobilecomputing and mobile phone. Theextent <strong>of</strong> ICT utilised to assist us withour work and productivity hasexperienced exponential growth,especially over the last two decades aspointed out by O’Driscoll et al. (2010).The use <strong>of</strong> these ICT is a fact that theyare not bound to a specific place butremain present regardless <strong>of</strong> place(Pica and Kakihara, 2003). Mostorganisational initiatives heraldedunder the banner <strong>of</strong> work-life (e.g.flexible time, job sharing, familyleaves, time <strong>of</strong>f for volunteering) havebeen developed in order to increasethe schedule flexibility afforded toemployees (Kingston, 1990). Formany workers, particularly the whitecollaremployees, flexiblecommunication technologies (such asportable computers, mobile phonesand email) are associated with workdesign characteristics that have thepotential to enableflexibility in the placeand timing <strong>of</strong> work.Some aspects <strong>of</strong> theeffects <strong>of</strong> a strongsociety in many ICTprogramme(Spradling, C. andC. J. Ansorge,2009). Theseinclude thehistory <strong>of</strong>computing,pr<strong>of</strong>essionalethics, computercrime, security,and intellectualproperty. Otheraspects <strong>of</strong> communityimpact is <strong>of</strong>ten notincluded or given minimaltreatment. These includecultural issues, accessibilityissues, and the effects <strong>of</strong> free opensource s<strong>of</strong>tware movement,computing and public policy, greencomputing, and computing forsustainability.Therefore, differences finer grainedindustry also instructive, because <strong>of</strong>differences in the nature <strong>of</strong>production technology acrossindustries related to differences in theability <strong>of</strong> individuals in a variety <strong>of</strong>work to integrate work and family.Other industries that are moredependent on the shape, flexible andmobile technology (example, the use<strong>of</strong> laptops and mobile phones amongpr<strong>of</strong>essionals or consultants) <strong>of</strong>fergreater opportunities for theintegration <strong>of</strong> work and familydemands because an employee hasgreater ability to control how, whereand when they use technology(Valcour & Batt, 2003).5. METHODOLOGYIn an attempt to explore therelationship between work-lifebalance and ICT, face-to-faceinterviews were conducted with eightpr<strong>of</strong>essional women in theconstruction industry; six <strong>of</strong> whom aremarried while two are single. Thecontacting information was acquiredfrom the Board <strong>of</strong> Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong><strong>Malaysia</strong> (BQSM) where relevant. Theimpact <strong>of</strong> the ICT is examined andthis study will be conducted in severalFigure 2: ICT assist in achieving work-life balanceNo25%stagesin order toachieve theobjectives. The first stage is toestablish the research problem andobjectives <strong>of</strong> the study. The secondstage is identifying the scope <strong>of</strong> studyand the third stage is the preparation<strong>of</strong> literature review to give an in-depthunderstanding regarding the topic <strong>of</strong>study. Qualitative research methodhas been conducted for datacollection. A few interview sessionswith randomly chosen pr<strong>of</strong>essionalwomen in Penang is conducted inorder to examine the researchobjectives. The research population <strong>of</strong>the study was targeted on thosepr<strong>of</strong>essional women who are married.Basically, all the information collectedwill be analysed and conclusion willbe done based on the result obtainedat the end <strong>of</strong> the study.6. FINDINGSYes75%It was found that ICT plays asignificant role in achieving work-lifebalance, and that the pr<strong>of</strong>essionalwomen are greatly satisfied with itsimpact. Among the respondents, 75%<strong>of</strong> the respondents acknowledgedthat ICT do play a vital role in helpingthem to achieve work-life balancewhile 25% <strong>of</strong> the respondents feltthat ICT do not assist much inachieving work-life balance.Significantly, the 25% that respondedslightly negatively were unmarriedpr<strong>of</strong>essional women.Peer Review Article39


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Undoubtedly, ICT play a vital rolein the world today. All (100%) <strong>of</strong>the respondents increased theirwork efficiency through theenhanced informationgathering, multitasking,coordination, and transitionto new tasks enabled byICT, such as portablegadgets, mobilecomputing and email. ICTtools are useful and ableto facilitate their work.With the use <strong>of</strong> thesmartphone, it allowsthem to receive and replyemail instantly. Forinstance, they can checktheir email and reply veryquickly when they are having atraffic jam or waiting for a trafficlight in car; or sometime their staffneed clarification from them urgently,they can respond immediately. Emailis considered one <strong>of</strong> the most usefultools to facilitate their works. Theyused it daily to contact people,sending or exchanging documentsduring work and at home. Manypr<strong>of</strong>essional women also spoke aboutthe benefit <strong>of</strong> ICT to limit the amount<strong>of</strong> face-to-face communication makestheir work quicker and easier. It isundeniable that, with ICT, it is easierto balance their work and home lives.When asked about how ICT aid themin achieving work-life balance (Figure2), 75% <strong>of</strong> the respondents opine thatICT facilitate their work, thus,increasing the quality time with theirfamily. As asserted by one <strong>of</strong> therespondents, she is able to report tothe organisation which she attachedby using ICT such as smartphone andmobile computing. ICT really cut shorttheir time in meeting others likeclients, contractors, staff and familywhile at the same time, their work canbe done. They managed to distributetime well for both work and life, asthey believe ICT do assist them andwork-life balance can be achievedmore easily. Besides, all therespondents agreed that email allowsthem to stay connected with peopleeasily and it is frequently used by therespondents.When asked about the difficulty in therelation <strong>of</strong> ICT with work-life balance,all (100%) the respondentsFigure 3: Feedback <strong>of</strong> ICT in achieving work-life balanceNegative25%Positive75%commentedthat they are able to handle the ICTwhich they want to use. It is all aboutICT now. Without ICT, one has to dowork old-style and manually. Forexample, people can be at the airportand checking their emails. At the sametime, they can read newspaper anduse Facebook with their smartphonesand gadgets. However, one <strong>of</strong> therespondents complained about theslow speed <strong>of</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> Wi-Ficompared to the speed in Jakarta andSingapore. Surfing with such a lowspeed is wasting time. This directlycreates pressure and tension, hence,affecting her personal mood and life. Ifthis issue is eliminated, she can getinformation and stay connected withothers easily. Another respondent alsosaid that she is aware <strong>of</strong> the latest ICTavailable but will only learn newtechnology if it is required. Spending alot <strong>of</strong> time just to learn all thetechnology skills will not benefit her inachieving work-life balance. If facingany problems regarding the lack <strong>of</strong>knowledge in the technology, she willdecided to pay others to complete herjob rather than attending the courseand learn the technology. She wouldrather pay other pr<strong>of</strong>essionals thanwaste her time and money to learnnew technology since money canactually be earned back. Similarly, theyagreed that ICT are actually makingour life more interesting and broadenour knowledge. Compared toprevious generations, it would seemthat life is stressful without the ICT<strong>of</strong> today. People cannot carry outtheir work when they are travellingor cannot contact family andfriends when they areoutstation for work. Withtoday’s technologies, theseproblems are solved. We cancommunicate easily withothers anywhere at cheaperprices by using networkapplication. Therefore, ICTreally has a significantimpact in achieving theirwork-life balance.Despite the positive aspects <strong>of</strong>ICT in achieving work-life balance,a number <strong>of</strong> negative aspects alsoemerged from the interviews (Figure3). About 25% <strong>of</strong> the respondentsdiscussed how ICT has led to a workenvironment where they are alwaysaccessible, something that negativelyimpacts work-life balance. Thisparadigm is incompatible with homelife, and gives responsibility toadvance in ICT making it possible forpeople to be continuously on call. Thesmartphone, despite its manysophisticated features and abilities topull in information from seeminglyanywhere, however, is still a normalfunction phone to the 13% <strong>of</strong> therespondents. The advancement <strong>of</strong> ICTis sometimes not really adapted by therespondents. Although ICT enableswork to be done faster, sometimes itends up with more work to be doneand thus, leads to work-life imbalance.About 50% <strong>of</strong> the respondents facedobstacles when achieving work-lifebalance. Rigid time and long workinghours are disliked by the respondents.One <strong>of</strong> the respondents shared herexample, being a pr<strong>of</strong>essional QSsometimes can be extremely exactingbecause industry demands facialinteraction. She needs to attend avariety <strong>of</strong> meetings all the time, whichincludes meetings with clients,architects, contractor and engineers. Inaddition, she needs to arrive at theairport early in the morning just tocatch the earliest flight; reach hometired around eight or nine o’clock atnight and sleeps late, and she alsoneeds to prepare for the next day’smeeting. Sometimes, she rushes herwork in the weekend before tender40


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Figure 4: Facing obstacles when achieving work-life balanceYes50%No50%deadline. There are a lot <strong>of</strong> demands during peak time<strong>of</strong> projects, where she needs to stay out <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>ficemost <strong>of</strong> the time.With regards to overcoming the difficulties in achievingwork-life balance, one <strong>of</strong> the respondent points outthat one must set the priority first before doinganything. Temporal adjustments in working time areunavoidable most <strong>of</strong> the time, “We should alwaysdiscuss and communicate with our pr<strong>of</strong>essional arenaby asking how we are going to give our services.”Generally, one needs to do a lot <strong>of</strong> communication. Wecannot blindly say ‘yes’ to everything, yet sometimes itis hard to achieve by saying ‘no’. Hence, for thepurpose <strong>of</strong> striking a balance between a ‘yes’ and a‘no’, we need to identify the deadline and its urgencyfirst. Another respondent also mentioned that shecannot release her kids unsupervised when focus onher career. By using technologies, she is able to see thekids with CCTV installed at home, supervise her maidand communicate with them via phone connection.She can also recognise her children’s friend circle byusing social networking such as Facebook andmonitoring them in good condition. Next, she opinesthat these days women can have their own careercompared to the past where they work from 8am to5pm and still need to cook for the family after back tohome. Now, eating outside from home can solve theproblem. The only important thing is that careerwomen ought to have knowledge and must know allthe appropriate use <strong>of</strong> ICT. In the future, the motherscan stay away from house; see their children byinstalling CCTV in the house like her. She thinks thatthe only reason why women who do not want a careeris laziness. Women are capable to do everything thesedays.When ask about suggestion for other pr<strong>of</strong>essional women inachieving work-life balance, she emphasises that clear priorityalways comes first. Top priority can only be one; it is either familyor work. Once in a while, the decision can be swapped as there israther hard for both <strong>of</strong> them to be in the top priority. It dependson individual and situation. With that, work-life balance can beachieved. Sometime project and appointment have to sacrifice forthe family and vice versa. Furthermore, she mentioned aboutdifferent view for past and present on work-life balance wherepast women are considered to achieve work-life balance bycooking in the kitchen and doing household responsibility as wellas taking care <strong>of</strong> the children all the day. In contrast, modernwomen now can consider achieve work-life balance when theyare back from work and have time to interact and communicatewith their children. Thus, it all depends to individual. Deciding thepriority is the utmost important thing in achieving work-lifebalance. Besides, being a mother <strong>of</strong> three children as well as apr<strong>of</strong>essional woman, family support is crucial for the respondentdue to the reason that children cannot be left alone while she isnot always available all the time for them. Her focus now will bethe family. She will arranged and automate things well for herchildren and work. On weekends, she will spend her time with herfamily. Another respondent also said that one must be happy withwhat you are doing no matter who you are in any <strong>of</strong> the industry.With that, definitely you can achieve work-life balance.Lastly, for the individual satisfaction level regards to work-lifebalance, 63% <strong>of</strong> the respondents rate themselves as four out <strong>of</strong>five while 37% <strong>of</strong> the respondents rate themselves as three out <strong>of</strong>five.JS VALUERS PROPERTY CONSULTANTS SDN BHDRegistered Valuers - Property Manager & ConsultantsReal Estate Agents - Compensation & Rating ValuersUnit No. B-11-15, Block B, Megan Avenue II, 12 Jalan Yap Kwan Seng, 50450 Kuala LumpurTel: 03-21624133 Fax: 03-21624188Email: admin@jsvaluers.com.my Website: www.jsvaluers.com.myOFFICES ATKOTA KINABALU, SABAHIPOH, PERAKUnit No. B1123, 11 th FloorJS’s House @ 11, Jalan LabrooyWisma Merdeka Phase II30100 IpohJalan Tun RazakPerak88000 Kota Kinabalu, Sabah Tel: 05-5062698, 5063098 Fax: 05-5062098Tel: 088-254877 (5 lines), 216502 Fax: 088-256812 Email: ipoh@jsvaluers.com.myEmail: kotakinabalu@jsvaluers.com.mySANDAKAN, SABAHMIRI, SARAWAK1 st Floor, Lot 11, Block 19 Lot 760, 1 st FloorBandar IndahJalan MerpatiMile 4, Jalan Utara98008 Miri, Sarawak90000 Sandakan, Sabah Tel: 085-418101, 428101 Fax: 085-413101Tel: 089-217013, 229117 Fax: 089-220614Email: miri@jsvaluers.com.myEmail: sandakan@jsvaluers.com.myTAWAU, SABAHMELAKALot 5, Block 31, 2 nd Floor No. 669A, Jalan Melaka Raya 8Fajar ComplexTaman Melaka Raya91000 Tawau, Sabah 75000 MelakaTel: 089-765621, 765622 Fax: 089-765623 Tel: 06-2833338 Fax: 06-2868400Email: tawau@jsvaluers.com.myEmail: melaka@jsvaluers.com.myPENANGBATU PAHAT, JOHORERoom 105, 1 st Floor32A-1B, 2 nd Floor(Formerly Southern Bank Building)Jalan RahmatNo.21, Lebuh Pantai83000 Batu Pahat, Johore10300 Penang Tel: 07-4317327, 4323191 Fax: 07-4317327Tel: 04-2625003, 2624985 Fax: 04-2634525 Email: batupahat@jsvaluers.com.myEmail: penang@jsvaluers.com.mySUBANG JAYA, SELANGORRESEARCH & CONSULTANCYNo. 52, (1 st Floor) Unit No. B-11-15, Block B,Jalan SS15/4C, Subang Jaya, 47500 Selangor Megan Avenue II,Tel: 03-56369199 (3 lines) Fax: 03-56369193 12 Jalan Yap Kwan Seng,Email: selangor@jsvaluers.com.my50450 Kuala Lumpur,Tel: 03-21624133 Fax: 03-21624188Email: consultancy@jsvaluers.com.myPeer Review Article41


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 20137. DISCUSSIONIt is projected that the use <strong>of</strong> ICT in the workplacewill only continue to increase in the coming years.We define ICT as technologies that are effectively,integrated and available to individuals throughouttheir environment. What was the most important tothese pr<strong>of</strong>essional women was the ability to usetechnology anytime and anywhere. Although thisdefinition is narrower in scope, however, webelieve that the findings represent wider aspects <strong>of</strong>the utilising <strong>of</strong> ICT in achieving work-life balance.First, the pr<strong>of</strong>essional women spoke about multipletechnologies, thus one person can utilise morethan one technology to assist them to maintaintheir work-life balance. Second, they felt that thetechnologies are useful and easily available when they need them.Finally, the pr<strong>of</strong>essional women consider these technologies asintegral to their social environment and daily lives. Deeperunderstanding <strong>of</strong> the range <strong>of</strong> work-life balance considerations forpr<strong>of</strong>essional women and their impact on the use <strong>of</strong> ICT areexamined. Thus, in responding to our research questions, our datademonstrates that ICT do play a crucial role in achieving work-lifebalance.As ICT have become so integrated in the construction industry, itwas somewhat surprising to uncover that the some <strong>of</strong> therespondents indicated negative aspects <strong>of</strong> ICT which virtuallydemand constant round-the-clock vigil <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice activities. At theoutset, it was expected that respondents would primarily show aAs ICT have become so integrated in theconstruction industry, it was somewhatsurprising to uncover that the some <strong>of</strong> therespondents indicated negative aspects <strong>of</strong>ICT which virtually demand constant roundthe-clockvigil <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice activitiespositive attitude, as the use <strong>of</strong> ICT is so much a part <strong>of</strong>their pr<strong>of</strong>ession. Even more remarkable is the findingthat the respondents implied that ICT made their worklifeeasier. In summary, with the availability <strong>of</strong> ICT, theexpectations <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional women to achieve worklifebalance in construction industry have risen as workis able to handle more efficiently. ICT have made thelives <strong>of</strong> the pr<strong>of</strong>essional women in the constructionindustry easier and thus achieving work-life balance.8. CONCLUSIONICT is facilitating dramatic new alternatives for where,when, and how work is accomplished. In addition,domestic nature <strong>of</strong> home-life is evolving aspr<strong>of</strong>essional women have entered the workforce. Thisevolution is placing greater demands on pr<strong>of</strong>essionalwomen to balance their work and life. Proper work-lifebalance is absolutely essential to live a contented life.UKUR BAHAN KONSULTQUANTITY SURVEYORS & BUILDING ECONOMISTSNO. 16-A, JALAN PERSIARAN ZAABATAMAN TUN DR. ISMAIL60000 KUALA LUMPURTel : 603-7729 8100 (4 Lines)Fax : 603-7727 1636E-mail : ubkqs@tm.net.myubkqssb@gmail.comThe important issue closely related to work-life balanceis the impact <strong>of</strong> ICT used to overcome the obstacles inachieving work-life balance. In this context, unevenadoption, lack <strong>of</strong> formalisation, long working hours andtemporal adjustment to working time have beenidentified as the obstacles for pr<strong>of</strong>essional women toachieve work-life balance. The majority <strong>of</strong> ICT tools,especially computers, laptops and smart phones, arebeing used effectively in order to provide the bestpossible in achieving work-life balance as well ascoping these barriers.In addition, a variety <strong>of</strong> ICT types have been exploredin this paper as the commonly used tools in theapplication <strong>of</strong> work-life and home-life such as mobilecomputing, portables gadgets and electronic mails. It isproven that the ability to use these latest ICT enablesthe pr<strong>of</strong>essional women to enhance the quality <strong>of</strong> theirlife and work.With the supportive data from the analysis, whereby75% <strong>of</strong> the respondents agreed the ICT provide avariety <strong>of</strong> ways for them to further develop their worklifebalance. Therefore, it is safe to draw intoconclusion that, ICT has the potential to make radicalchanges in the lines between work and home. Thehuge increase in ICT and the ability <strong>of</strong> people to applythe ICT from the comfort <strong>of</strong> their own has created newpossibilities for ICT to increase the opportunities for42


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>pr<strong>of</strong>essional women in construction industry to achievetheir work-life balance.9. FUTURE STUDIESRECOMMENDATIONSThe findings presented in this paper highlight severalareas for future research. First, additional analysis isneeded to examine how pr<strong>of</strong>essional women in theindustries other than construction industry use ICT inmaintaining work-life balance. These findings wouldcontribute knowledge to a wider understanding <strong>of</strong> howpr<strong>of</strong>essional women in the construction industrycompare to pr<strong>of</strong>essional women employed in otherareas. Finally, additional research is needed to examinehow men in the industry use ICT to achieve work-lifebalance. These findings would contribute knowledge toa wider understanding <strong>of</strong> the role <strong>of</strong> ICT in achievingwork-life balance.ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSThe authors gratefully acknowledge the support fromAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Azlan Ra<strong>of</strong>uddion Hj Nuruddin and otherlecturers as well as Universiti Sains <strong>Malaysia</strong> final yearQuantity Surveying undergraduates especiallyMuhammad Hariz Radzi, Toh Shenq Jia, Normah bt MdNoh, Mohamad Farhan bin Mohamad Arshad andMohd Fatazi B Aman for their contribution to thesuccessful completion <strong>of</strong> this research.This article was winner <strong>of</strong> Best Mentioned Paper Award at the 5thRICS-RISM-AALSM International Surveying Conference forUndergraduates held on 19th – 20th April 2013 at Taylor ’s University,Bandar Sunway , West <strong>Malaysia</strong> lREFERENCESAshworth, A. Hogg, K (2007). Willis’s Practice andProcedure for The Quantity Surveyor. 12th edition,Wiley-Blackwell Publishing.Bacik, I. & Drew, E. (2006, April). Struggling withjuggling: Gender and work/life balance in the legalpr<strong>of</strong>essions. In Women's Studies International Forum(Vol. 29, No. 2, pp. 136-146). Pergamon.Bailey, N. B. K. D. E. & Kurland, N. B. (1999). Theadvantages and challenges <strong>of</strong> working here, there,anywhere, and anytime. Organizational Dynamics,Autumn, 53-67.Bargaining Report (2003), No. 234, Labour ResearchDepartment, London.Bédard, C. (2003). Changes and the Unchangeable:Computers in Construction. In Proc. <strong>of</strong> 4th Joint Int'lSymposium on IT in Civil Engineering, ASCE,Nashville, USA.Board <strong>of</strong> Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> (BQSM).Available on:http://www.bqsm.gov.my/index.php?lang=enBond, S., Hyman, J., Summers, J. and Wise, S. (2002),Family-Friendly Working? Putting Policy into Practice,York Publishing Services, York.Bowden, S., Dorr, A., Thorpe, T. & Anumba, C. (2006).Mobile ICT support for construction processimprovement. Automation in Construction, Vol15(5),664-676.Boswell, W. & Olsen-Buchanan, J. (2007). The use <strong>of</strong>communication technologies after hours: The role<strong>of</strong>work attitudes andwork–life conflict. Journal <strong>of</strong>Management, Vol 33(4), 592−610.Chesley, N., Moen, P., Shore, R. P. & Moen, P. (2003).The new technology climate. It’s about time:Couples and careers, 220-241.Cooper, C., Dewe, P. and O’Driscoll, M. (2001),Organizational Stress, Sage, London.Day, A., Scott, N. & Kelloway, E. K. (2010).Information and communication technology:Implications for job stress and employee well-being.Research in Occupational Stress and Well-being, 8,317-350.Dex, S. & Scheibl, F. (2001). Flexible andFamily-Friendly Working Arrangements in UK-BasedSMEs: Business Cases. British Journal <strong>of</strong> IndustrialRelations, 39(3), 411-431.Dubrin, A. J. (1991). Comparison <strong>of</strong> the jobsatisfaction and productivity <strong>of</strong> telecommutersversus in-house employees: A research note on workin progress. Psychological Reports, Vol 68: 1223-1234.Duxbury, L. and Higgins, C. (2003). Work-life Conflict:Myths Versus Realities, FMI Journal(14:3), 16-20.Epstein, C. F., Seron, C., Oglensky, B. & Sauté, R.(1999). The part-time paradox: Time norms,pr<strong>of</strong>essional life, family, and gender. New York:Routledge.Estes, S. B. and Michael, J. (2009), Work-familypolicies and gender inequality at work: a Sloan Workand Family. Encyclopedia entry, available at:http://wfnetwork.bc.edu/encyclopedia_entry.php?id¼1230&area¼All(accessed December 10, 2009).European Agency for Safety and Health at Work.(2012). Family Issues and Work-Life Balance. E-Facts.Faigen, G. S., Fridman, B. & Emmett, A. (2002).Wireless data for the enterprise: making sense <strong>of</strong>wireless business. McGraw-Hill.Gholami. R, (2006), Essays on information andcommunication technology: Investment, postadoptionand economic impacts.Peer Review Article43


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Gill, G. (2008). Remote Working Technologies,Benefits and Challenges. Doctoral dissertation,University <strong>of</strong> Nottingham.Golden, A. G. & Geisler, C. (2007).Work–lifeboundary management and the personal digitalassistant. Human Relations, 60(3), 519-551.Golden, T. & Veiga, J. (2005). The impact <strong>of</strong> extent<strong>of</strong> telecommuting on job satisfaction: Resolvinginconsistent findings. Journal <strong>of</strong> Management, Vol31(2), 301−318.Green, F. (2001). It’s Been A Hard Day’s Night: TheConcentration and Intensification <strong>of</strong> Work in LateTwentieth Century Britain. British Journal <strong>of</strong>Industrial Relations, 39(1), 53-80.Guelzow, M. G., Bird, G. W. and Koball, E. H.(1991). An Exploratory Path Analysis <strong>of</strong> the StressProcess for Dual-Career Men and Women. Journal<strong>of</strong> Marriage Family, Vol (53), 151-164.Guest, D. E. (2002). Perspectives on the study <strong>of</strong>work-life balance. Social Science Information,41(2), 255-279.Harvey, M. (1999), Economies <strong>of</strong> time: aframework for analysing the restructuring <strong>of</strong>employment relations, in Felstead, A. and Jewson,N. (Eds), Global Trends in Flexible Labour,Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp. 21-42.Hill, E. J., Ferris, M. & Märtinson, V. (2003). Does itmatter where you work? A comparison <strong>of</strong> howthree work venues (traditional <strong>of</strong>fice, virtual <strong>of</strong>fice,and home <strong>of</strong>fice) influence aspects <strong>of</strong> work andpersonal/family life. Journal <strong>of</strong> VocationalBehavior, 63(2), 220-241.Hill, E. J., Hawkins, A. J., Ferris, M. & Weitzman, M.(2001). Finding an extra day a week: The positiveinfluence <strong>of</strong> perceived job flexibility on work andfamily life balance. Family Relations, 50(1), 49-58.Hill, E. J., Miller, B. C., Weiner, S. P. & Colihan, J.(1998). Influences <strong>of</strong> the virtual <strong>of</strong>fice on aspects<strong>of</strong> work and work/life balance. PersonnelPsychology, 51, 667-683.Hussin, A. A. & Omran, A. (2009, 14-15 November2009). Roles <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals in ConstructionIndustry. The International Conference onAdministration and Business.Hyman, J. & Summers, J. (2004). Lackingbalance?: Work-life employment practices in themodern economy. Personnel Review, 33(4), 418-429.Ivanovic. J, (2012). Family CommunicationPatterns, Australian Science.Kingston, P. W. (1990). Illusions and ignoranceabout the family-responsive workplace. Journal <strong>of</strong>Family Issues, 11(4), 438-454.Kossek, E. E., Lautsch, B. A. & Eaton, S. C. (2006).Telecommuting, control, and boundarymanagement: Correlates <strong>of</strong> policy use andpractice, job control, and work–familyeffectiveness. Journal <strong>of</strong> Vocational Behavior,68(2), 347-367.Labour Research (2001), What working parentsreally need, Labour Research Department,London, pp. 10-13Lewis, S. (2000), Organisational change andgender equity: case studies from the UnitedKingdom, in Haas, L. and Russell, G. (Eds),Organizational Change and Gender Equity:International Perspectives on Fathers andMothers at the Workplace, Sage, Thousand Oaks,CA, pp. 181-95Lewis, S., & Cooper, C. L. (1999). The Work- FamilyResearch Agenda in Changing Contexts. Journal <strong>of</strong>Occupational Health Psychology, Vol 4(4), 382-393.Lim, L. J., & Ling, F. Y. (2012). Human resourcepractices <strong>of</strong> contractors that lead to jobsatisfaction <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional staff. Engineering,Construction and Architectural Management,19(1), 101-118.Lisa Goh, (2013). The Star Online, 05 March 2013.Available on: http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2013/3/3/nation/12786920&sec=nationLowry, D., & Moskos, M. (2005). Hanging on themobile phone: experiencing work and spatialflexibility. National Institute <strong>of</strong> Labour Studies,Flinders University.Lowry, D. and Moskos, M. (2008), Mobile phones,spillover and the ‘work–life balance, in Hislop, D.(Ed.), Mobility and Technology in the Workplace,Routledge, Oxford, pp. 167-79Melhem, S., Tandon, N., & Morrell, C. (2009).Information and Communication Technologies forWomen's Socio-Economic Empowerment (Vol.176). World Bank Publications.Mell, P. and Grance, T. (2011). The NIST Definition<strong>of</strong> Cloud Computing. National Institute <strong>of</strong>Standards and Technology, U.S. Department <strong>of</strong>Commerce.Ministry <strong>of</strong> Business, Innovation & Employment,Work-life balance in New Zealand.New Encyclopedia Brittanica Online AcademicEdition (2012)Nippert- Eng, C.E. (1996). Home and Work.Chicago: The University <strong>of</strong> Chicago Press.O’Driscoll, M. P., Brough, P., Timms, C., &Sawang,S. (2010). Engagement with information and44


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>communication technology and psychologicalwell-being. Research in Occupational Stress andWell-being, 8, 269-316.Orange. (2006). Improved Work-Life Balance: TheRole <strong>of</strong> ICT .Oxford University. (Ed.) (2013) OxfordDictionaries. Oxford University: Oxford UniversityPress.Pica D., Kakihara M (2003) The duality <strong>of</strong> mobility:designing fluid organizations through stableinteraction. Association for Information Systems,11th European Conference on InformationSystems, Naples, 19–21 June 2003Pleck, J. H., Staines, G. L., & Lang, L. (1980).Conflicts between work and family life. MonthlyLab. Rev., 103, 29.Porter, G. & Kakabadse, N. K.(2006). HRMperspectives on addiction to technology andwork. Journal <strong>of</strong> Management Development, Vol25(6), 535–560.Quesenberry, J. & Trauth, E. (2005). The Role <strong>of</strong>Ubiquitous Computing in Maintaining Work-LifeBalance: Perspectives from Women in theInformation Technology Workforce. DesigningUbiquitous Information Environments: Socio-Technical Issues and Challenges, 43-55.Rapoport, R., Bailyn, L., Fletcher, J. and Pruitt, B.(2002), Beyond Work-Family Balance: AdvancingGender Equity and Workplace Performance,Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.Riley, F. and McCloskey, D. W. (1996). GTE'sExperience with Telecommuting: Helping PeopleBalance Work and Family, in Proceedings <strong>of</strong> the1996 ACM SIGMIS Conference on PersonnelResearch, New York: ACM Press, 1996, pp. 85-93<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> Chartered <strong>Surveyors</strong> (RICS).Available on: http://www.rics.org/my/Scase, R. (2002). Living in the Corporate Zoo: Lifeand Work in 2010, Capstone, Oxford.Schueller-Weidekamm, C. & Kautzky-Willer, A.(2012). Challenges <strong>of</strong> Work–Life Balance forWomen Physicians/Mothers Working inLeadership Positions. Gender Medicine.Shorthose, J. (2004). Like summer and good sex?The limitations <strong>of</strong> the work-life balancecampaign. Capital & Class, 28(1), 1-8.Spradling, C., Soh, L. K. &Ansorge, C. J. (2009). Acomprehensive survey on the status <strong>of</strong> social andpr<strong>of</strong>essional issues in United Statesundergraduate computer science programmesand recommendations. Computer scienceeducation, 19(3), 137-153.Standen, P., Daniels, K. & Lamond, D. (1999). Thehome as a workplace: Work-family interaction andpsychological well-being in telework. Journal <strong>of</strong>Occupational Health Psychology, Vol4, 368–381.Steinmueller, W. E. (2000). Will new informationand communication technologies improvethe'codification'<strong>of</strong> knowledge? Industrial andCorporate Change, 9(2), 361-376.Taylor, R. (2001). The Future <strong>of</strong> Work-Life Balance,ESRC Future <strong>of</strong> Work Programme Seminar Series,Economic and Social Research Council, SwindonThe Association <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Engineers, S. A.M., Australia (APESMA) (2009).[Women in thePr<strong>of</strong>essions Survey Report].Towers I, Duxbury L, Higgins C, Thomas A (2006)Time thieves and space invaders: technology,work and the organization. Organ ChangeManage 19:593–618Valcour, P. M. & Batt, R. (2003). Work Exhaustion,Organizational Commitment and Work-LifeIntegration: The Moderating Effects <strong>of</strong> Work-Family Identity Salience (Working Paper #03-07).Ithaca, NY: Bronfenbrenner Life Course Center.Valcour, P. M., & Hunter, L. W. (2005).Technology,organizations, and work-life integration. Work andlife integration: Organizational, cultural, andindividual perspectives, 61-84.What’s A G (2013), A Little History <strong>of</strong> the G MobileGenerations (online). Available on:http://www.whatsag.com/G/Generation_History.phpWheatley, D. (2012). Work-life balance, travel-towork,and the dual career household. Emerald,41(6), 813-831.White, M., Hill, S., McGovern, P., Mills, C. &Smeaton, D. (2003).High-performance’Management Practices,Working Hours and Work–Life Balance. BritishJournal <strong>of</strong> Industrial Relations, 41(2), 175-195.Workplace Employment Relations Survey-WERS(1998).Department for Business Innovation &Skills.Zimmerman, J. B. (1999). Mobile Computing:Characteristics, Business benefits, and the mobileframework. University <strong>of</strong> Maryland EuropeanDivision-Bowie State, INSS, 690.Peer Review Article45


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Building Surveyor’s Role InFacilitiesManagementIn JKRNorizan Binti MahmudPublic Works DepartmentEmail: NorizanMD@jkr.gov.myIn 2007, the former Minister Of PublicWorks Department, Datuk Seri S Samy Vellu hadannounced that the Public Works Department(PWD) will set-up a new department for BuildingSurveying in order to inspect and verify allgovernment’s buildings after construction, to ensurethat the contractor and sub-contractor follows all thespecifications and scope <strong>of</strong> works mentioned andagreed in the respective contract. Hence the PWD isentrusted to drive the initiatives to ensure the higheststandard <strong>of</strong> design and monitoring quality is achievedin the maintenance and construction completion <strong>of</strong>the projects. Therefore in 18 February 2008, the firstbatch <strong>of</strong> Building Surveyor had reported to PWDunder the Engineering Maintenance Department leadby Dato' Ir. Annies bin Md Ariff. Six years on, theBuilding Surveyor pr<strong>of</strong>essional manpower strength inPWD had grown to 43 <strong>of</strong>ficers all over <strong>Malaysia</strong>(Figure 1) to implement these aspirations.NAFAM 2007 and the FacilitiesManagement ContractIn 2007, the National Asset & Facility ManagementConvention (NAFAM) was held at PWTC with thetheme “Asset & Facility Management: Coping withFuture Challenges.” It was chosen in view <strong>of</strong> itsincreasingly important role in effective management<strong>of</strong> expanding asset bases as well as promoting andenhancing the pr<strong>of</strong>essional standards in <strong>Malaysia</strong>.The former Prime Minister <strong>of</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>, The Hon.Dato' Seri Abdullah bin Haji Ahmad Badawi had46


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Figure 1: Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Skim in PWDkindly consented to <strong>of</strong>ficiate anddeliver the Keynote Address onMonday, 13 August 2007 as well asdelivering the Closing KeynoteAddress on Tuesday, 14 August 2007.It is hope that this convention, as part<strong>of</strong> our initiatives in promoting theincreasing relevance <strong>of</strong> the CorporateSocial Responsibility (CSR), it will:1. Serve as a means to help andfacilitate the success <strong>of</strong> asset &facility management in <strong>Malaysia</strong>;2. Help to create awareness oncurrent issues and challenges inmanaging government assets; and3. Improve the standards <strong>of</strong><strong>Malaysia</strong>’s practices to sustainablestandards and performances byaddressing the most challengingand pertinent issues fromtechnical and strategic viewpoints.In order to achieve the NAFAM 2007’sresolution, the PWD had take theirinitiative in 2008 with the set-up <strong>of</strong> acommittee to develop FacilityManagement Contract PWD FM2008and now, it has been used at some <strong>of</strong>the government buildings. SinceBuilding Surveyor is the onlypr<strong>of</strong>ession in the JKR that has abackground in Facility Managementsubject at university level, some <strong>of</strong> theBuilding <strong>Surveyors</strong> in the PWD havebeen selected to the committee todevelop and to administer the FacilityManagement Contract (FM Contract).The phases in FacilitiesManagementThere are three phases in an FMContract where the BuildingSurveyor’s roles are important in orderto ensure a successful implementation<strong>of</strong> the contract (Figure 2).25002000150010005000ArchitectBuilding SurveyorCivil EngineerPlanning PhaseThe planning phase is the phasewhere the transition <strong>of</strong> assets anddocuments <strong>of</strong> the premise from theclient/agency to JKR. During thisphase, the Building Surveyor shouldplay their role to conduct the BuildingCondition Survey (BCA) and PostOccupancy Evaluation (POE) in orderto diagnosis the method to upgradecorrective operation; procurement <strong>of</strong>facilities project through service levelagreement or contracts based oncontinuous performance; health andsecurity awareness within workplacedesign. This will help apply thetechniques <strong>of</strong> asset maintenance andeffective operation, evaluate facilitiesoperation techniques for the agency,appraise facilities performance levelfor a work place and proposeupgrading for facilities components.The Building Surveyor will also gatherall the information <strong>of</strong> the premise inElectrical EngineerMechanical EngineerQuantity SurveyorLand Surveyororder to make the asset registrationand to compile all the data, manuals,reports and other documents <strong>of</strong> thepremise which will be updated intothe Sistem Aset Tak Alih Kerajaan(MySPATA). With the information anddata <strong>of</strong> the premises, the scope <strong>of</strong> theFacilities Management Contract for thepremise will be determined and theKey Performance Indicator for the FMCwill be set-up together with thedocument preparation for theprocurement <strong>of</strong> the FacilitiesManagement Contract.Procurement PhaseDuring the procurement phase, theBuilding Surveyor in JKR will conductthe FM tenderer’s briefing and sitevisit. Basically, the Building Surveyorwill provide a brief on the scope <strong>of</strong> theservices, which has been determineearlier for the site and the BuildingSurveyor will bring all the tenderersaround the site for a review.Pr<strong>of</strong>essional PracticeFigure 2: PWD Facilities Management Contract TimelinePLANNING PHASE (7 Months)FM CONTRACTORPROCUREMENT MANAGEMENT PHASE (5 Months)FM CONTRACT PERIOD ( 39 Months)FM OPERATION PERIOD ( 36 Months)1START3 monthsUndertake NewAsset24 monthsPreparation &Documentation32 monthsTender43 monthsContract Award5Letter <strong>of</strong>Acceptance1 monthTRANSITION PERIODA ( MOBILISATION) B( 3 months)Operation StartContract StartTRANSITION PERIODC ( DEMOBILISATION) D( 3 months)ContractDemobilise StartEnd( 3 months)EAccountClosedCommencementSite PossessionExpiry <strong>of</strong>contractNote :During Transition Period , the Client/ Owner shall responsible to all & OM activities47


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Since Building Surveyor is the only pr<strong>of</strong>ession in the JKR that has a backgroundin Facility Management subject at university level, some <strong>of</strong> the Building<strong>Surveyors</strong> in the PWD have been selected to the committee to develop and toadminister the Facility Management Contract (FM Contract).The FM tenderers will submit their qualification which will beverified by the Building Surveyor in JKR. Only the qualifiedtender will receive the invitation to submit their tender.After the tender is closed, the Building Surveyor togetherwith other <strong>of</strong>ficers from JKR will implement the tenderevaluation and come out with the tender evaluation reports,which will be submitted to the tender board for theirapproval and proceed to the select the FM Contractor.FM Contract PhaseThe FM contract phase in PWD FM 2012 contract includesthe transition period and operation period which takes about39 months throughout the contract.i) Transition Period ( 3 months)During the transition period, the FacilitiesSuperintending Officer (FSO) will convene with aTransition Coordination Group together with the FMContractor, existing/succeeding FM Contractors andcustomers.The Transition Coordination Group will carry out theFacilities Familiarisation and Verification (FFV) and reportto the FSO. The FFV report should identify any defectsfound at the site and any recommendations to rectifythe defects should be included. On a weekly basis, theFSO should receive reports from the FM Contractor onthe rectification work done by the relevant parties. Anyon-going defects will be identified by the FM Contractorand shall be immediately notified to the FSO. The FFVshall also help a new FM Contractor to familiarise withthe site and verify all the site documents which arehanded over by the outgoing FM Contractor.In this process, the Building Surveyor will make sure thedetails <strong>of</strong> how the FM Contractor shall manage theservices to ensure service levels shall be met during theTransition Period taking into account the phasing <strong>of</strong>construction work, staggered Defect Liability Period(DLP), effects <strong>of</strong> construction works on the services andthe use <strong>of</strong> technology during the Transition Period; andduring the hand-over from the previous FM Contractor.The Building Surveyor will also ensure that the FMContractor shall submit to the FSO a detailed schedule<strong>of</strong> all activities and key milestones during themobilisation and demobilisation phases. The scheduleshall show the critical path for the successful and timelymobilisation and demobilisation <strong>of</strong> the contractors’responsibilities.ii)Operation Period (36 months)During the Operation Period <strong>of</strong> the FM Contract, BuildingSurveyor will be part <strong>of</strong> the FSO team and will makesure the FM Contractor shall manage the services toensure the provision <strong>of</strong> high quality services andamenities to the customer. On the other hand, theBuilding Surveyor needs to be more stringent in order tomake sure that the Garis Panduan PenyenggaraanBerjadual Bangunan Kerajaan has been referred by theFM Contractor as a minimum guide for them to starttheir work. The FM Contractor shall implement a fullyintegrated approach to the management <strong>of</strong> the servicesto deliver a safe, secure and comfortable environment.The Building Surveyor will supervise the FM Contractorto make sure that all activities undertaken under thecontract shall be coordinated and approved by the FSO.The Building Surveyor will verify the activities <strong>of</strong> the FMContractor to ensure that they shall manage its work to:1. ensure that its planning and programming iscomprehensive and provides for the delivery <strong>of</strong> all theperformance included in the contract;2. proactively liaise with and satisfy the requirements <strong>of</strong>all relevant authorities;3. diligently address safety and security, functionability,maintainability, sustainability, durability, reliability andaesthetics in all aspects <strong>of</strong> the services;4. provide for the services which are coordinated withand complementary to the activities <strong>of</strong> the FSO andother authorities;5. diligently minimise disruption and inconvenience toall customers when carrying out routine work; and6. ensure corrective and preventive work orders andinstructions are raised proactively as a result <strong>of</strong> FMContractor’s inspection rather than customer’s orFSO’s observation. In particular, a substantial number<strong>of</strong> work orders shall be raised proactively by the FMContractor as a proportion <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong>work orders raised in respect <strong>of</strong> common use areas.Additionally, the Building Surveyor will make sure thatthe FM Contractor shall participate in the process <strong>of</strong>performance management include monitoring, review,reporting, auditing and agreement with the FSO againstthe performance indicators. It shall include but notlimited to:48


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>1. Conduct and analyse, on aquarterly basis, the year’sobjective customer surveys toaccurately assess actualperformance against theperformance indicators. Thecustomer surveys shall beconducted on a representativesample which shall be in linewith acceptable statisticalmethods <strong>of</strong> sampling;2. Convene monthly performancereviews with the FSO;3. Undertake, on quarterly basis,the year’s audits inconsultation with the FSO onits performance with regards toeach performance indicator;inviting the FSO to attend allperformance audits;4. Diligently enter performanceassessments and comments ona continuous basis into theinformation managementsystem;5. Liaise with the FSO to discussperformance assessments andcomments in order to meet thekey performance indicators(KPI);6. Provide the reports required bythe FSO and in accordance tothe contract; andFigure 3: Scope <strong>of</strong> servicesScope <strong>of</strong> ServicesA. ManagementServicesB. Operaon andMaintenanceServicesC. Engineering/MinorWorks ServicesD. Pr<strong>of</strong>essional/ConsultancyServicesItem1. Transion Management Services2. Administraon & Financial Management Services3. Quality Management Services4. Ulies Management Services5. Safety, Health And Environmental Management Servicesa. Risk Management Services6. Incident Response And Disaster Recovery Management(IRDRM) Services7. Human Resource Management Services8. Customer Care Management Services9. Management Informaon System (MIS) Servicesa. Inventory Management Servicesb. Warranty Management Servicesc. Technical Library Management Services10. Energy Management And Conservaon Services11. Waste And Redundant Materials Management Services12. Security Management Services13. Event Management Services1. Civil/Architecture2. Mechanical3. Electrical4. House keeping5. Pest control6. Landscape7. Security1. Repair/Replacement2. Renovate3. Refurbishment4. Rehabilitaon5. Retr<strong>of</strong>ing6. Upgrading7. Conservaon1. Proposal Report2. Technical AdvicePr<strong>of</strong>essional Practice7. Maintain comprehensiverecords <strong>of</strong> all incidents.The Scope <strong>of</strong> the FacilityManagement ContractThroughout the FM Contract, Building<strong>Surveyors</strong> will be included asmembers <strong>of</strong> the FacilitiesSuperintending Officer (FSO) wherethe Building Surveyor shall receiveinstructions from the FSO only. TheBuilding Surveyor shall act as theFSO’s representative in checking andverifying work in progress, work done,inspections, records and reportssubmitted by the FM Contractor. Toachieve this, no records or reportsshall be submitted to the FSO withoutfirst being signed by the FMContractor’s Operation Director andcountersigned by the BuildingSurveyor. The FM Contractor shallassist the process by providing allrequired records and databases to theBuilding Surveyor. There are four mainscopes <strong>of</strong> service categories which areprovided in the PWD FM 2012, whichincludes but not limited to (Figure 3).ConclusionIn conclusion, to achieve goodgovernance in Facilities ManagementIn my pr<strong>of</strong>essional view, a department <strong>of</strong>Building Surveyor should be established in PWDin order to guarantee a career path for theBuilding <strong>Surveyors</strong> in the PWD.Contract in PWD, the BuildingSurveyor with its developed processesand tools is the best to check andverify work in progress, work done,inspections, records and reportssubmitted by the FM Contractor. In mypr<strong>of</strong>essional view, a department <strong>of</strong>Building Surveyor should beestablished in PWD in order toguarantee a career path for theBuilding <strong>Surveyors</strong> in the PWD. Thiswould help the PWD to extend theirrole to be a technical department <strong>of</strong>reference in the Facilities Managementwork in all government agencies. Withthe establishment <strong>of</strong> the BuildingSurveyor Department in PWD, it willopen up opportunities to BuildingSurveyor graduates to join the PWDand contribute to the improvement <strong>of</strong>government building facilitiesmanagement and <strong>Malaysia</strong>’s buildingindustry in general. l49


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013DIBS: A factorcausing high propertyprices & developmentland pricesPr<strong>of</strong>essor Sr Dr Ting Kien HwaUniversiti Teknologi MARAEmail: tingkien@salam.uitm.edu.myIt is reported in The Star on 25 June 2013 that Bank Negara is studying the risks arising from thedeveloper interest-bearing scheme (DIBS) with a view <strong>of</strong> imposing curbs on it. The DIBS wasintroduced during a period <strong>of</strong> weak property market condition and it is designed to stimulate demandby allowing property buyers to make property purchase with minimal capital outlay.Since the weak property market condition isover and with the current low interest rate environment,prolonging the DIBS does more harm than the benefitsthat it claims to bring.In fact, I would argue that the DIBS is one <strong>of</strong> the causes <strong>of</strong>the current high housing prices and residential developmentland prices.Firstly, the DIBS encourages speculation as speculatorsbought properties with the intention to flip for quick capitalgains. The DIBS is a mechanism that facilitates 'no moneydown' on the purchaser and hence, a speculator can havemultiple bookings with little capital. Obviously, speculatorsare more than happy to use the DIBS scheme to fuelspeculation. The so called 'property gurus' also encourage'no money down' as a ‘creative property financing’ method.Speculations are facilitated by the DIBS as it encouragesspeculators to make as many booking as possible. Suchbookings create a false impression that there is high demandfor properties in DIBS projects.However, the consequence is detrimental to the propertymarket as the DIBS artificially inflates capital values. Theseartificial high prices become the reference prices in settingthe selling prices <strong>of</strong> new units or phases. New launches willbenchmark their selling prices to projects with the DIBS thathad shown high sales rate indicating high demand. As aconsequence, the subsequent new launches will reflect theinflated high prices. Thus, the increase in capital values is notdue to demand and supply, but due to the costs andinterests that have been built into the selling pricesincorporating the element <strong>of</strong> speculations.When this happens over a period <strong>of</strong> time, it will give theimpression that house prices have indeed increased, coupledwith developer’s claims that the development costs haveincreased, thus creating an artificially high market pricingenvironment. The common people will be deceived thatpricing for housing are indeed high and are forced to acceptsuch pricing. "Affordability" for these common people wouldmean taking more borrowing based on husband and wife'sdual income and through other means to generate additionalincome such as part-time jobs.The second impact is on the residential development landmarket. Development land suitable for housing will be pricedbased on the high property prices. Hence, land owners willsell their land at higher land prices than before. Developers50


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Current Issuewithout land banks will buy these landswith the perception that the propertiesthat they develop can be sold at the highprices. Property market studies undertakenwill indicate that there is demand forhighly priced properties and financialfeasibility studies will show that housingdevelopment on such land is financiallyviable and pr<strong>of</strong>itable.Therefore, the artificial high prices due tothe DIBS are propagated from the primaryhousing market to the development landmarket and translated back into higherproperty prices <strong>of</strong> the primary propertymarket. The developers can now claim thatland prices are high and therefore, houseprices have to be set at high level to makepr<strong>of</strong>it.Thus from this analysis, we can say thatthe DIBS is a root cause initiated by thedevelopers themselves! In fact, fordevelopers who have land banks, theirland costs are low and the high sellingprices <strong>of</strong> properties will generate abnormalreturns and huge pr<strong>of</strong>its to them.In the final analysis, the DIBS started bydevelopers has encourage speculationsthereby created an artificial high demand"Affordability" for these common peoplewould mean taking more borrowing based onhusband and wife's dual income and throughother means to generate additional incomesuch as part-time jobs.which propagate high development landprices that later translate into highproperty prices. An environment <strong>of</strong> highhousing price is created and sustaineduntil the next downturn <strong>of</strong> the propertycycle where these excessive prices areadjusted.The parties who gain in the process areclearly the developers, speculators andland owners. True property buyers sufferand the society at large will also beaffected as more debts are to be borne byhouseholds.As a conclusion, a ban on the DIBS byBank Negara is a welcome move as it willremove one <strong>of</strong> the root causes <strong>of</strong> highproperty prices today. l51


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Managing Stress byDeveloping a PersonalisedStress Prevention PlanWan Hussin W.M.A.PhD, MBA, BSc (Hons), Dip.LSurv, FRISM, MSP, MAALS, CPULLicensed Land Surveyor under Act 458 (Revised 1991)Universiti Sains <strong>Malaysia</strong>We all go on with ourdaily lives and occasionallyget overloaded. We allknow what it feels like to beoverwhelmed by stress. Butunderstanding the basics <strong>of</strong>managing stress is invaluable aspulling out a stress management orrelaxation technique, adoptingsimple steps to sort things outbefore it goes beyond control, caneffectively reduce high levels <strong>of</strong>stress to a more manageablelevel and thus, avoiding negativehealth consequences. The bestway to manage severe stressis, <strong>of</strong> course, to managestress on a daily basis as itcomes or to manage it whileit is still at low manageablelevels and preventing it frombecoming severe.Managing stress using personal andpositive approaches that work welland using it to gain some relief is allit takes to develop a personalisedstress prevention plan. Stressprevention can't work if it is pursuedin such a reactive manner. Effectivestress prevention strategies requirepeople to make important changesto their lifestyles so that they takeproactive steps to avoid or to reducestress and enhance their well-being.To perform effective stressmanagement techniques requiresdaily commitment in order for it tobe sustainable.52


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>Lifestyle changeChanging lifestyle is not an easy thing to do, even whenit is performed with the best interest in mind. Whentrying to create the desired changes, the tendency bymany is to jump into the deep end and try to hold on toa rigid set <strong>of</strong> new lifestyle rules that are sometimesuncomfortable as many aren’t prepared for theunforeseen circumstances. There are some who manageto make it work effectively for a short while throughstrong willpower. But ultimately something tends to slipthrough due to poor concentration, wrong or ineffectivestrategies. When these happen, people tend to revertback to their old approaches or repeat past habits thatmay give short term comfort without realising that theyare harmful in the long run.Taking a more deliberate, gradualapproach towards lifestyle changecan make the differencebetween success and failure.A gradual approach tochange allows for peopleto develop theirmotivation and toprepare effectively forfailures and relapses.This can reduce thechance <strong>of</strong> side-trackfrom the changeprocess, thus creatinglasting lifestyle change.This will better help aperson to think through andstrategise the change process.MotivationCritical to the change process ismotivation as it serves as a strong foundationand provides continuous synergy. It is the basis uponwhich people set their change efforts on, and also theenergy that propels them forward through the stages <strong>of</strong>change. All change efforts start with motivation, which isdriven by unexpected challenging events that maysometimes upset their comfort, luxury and even statusquo. Effective motivation can make them become aware<strong>of</strong> problems that are to come. Before there is awareness<strong>of</strong> a problem and content with daily events, there is nomotivation to change.Effective motivation may start with pondering on a fewpast key stressful events that have challenged you, madeyou aware <strong>of</strong> life problems and learning some effectivestress management plans. For instance, perhaps youwere overwhelmed about making a presentation for anew task? Perhaps you found yourself repeatedly arguingwith your staff about below average performance andpoor outcome. Perhaps you were told by the doctor thatthe back pain that you have been experiencing lately iscaused by long hours <strong>of</strong> driving. Perhaps you are nowrealising that the tiredness you are facing is due to theangioplasty that was done many years ago but continueto have the same old diet and lifestyle. These are some<strong>of</strong> the innumerable ways that you can becomechallenged, but these could have motivated you topursue effective lifestyle changes.AwarenessEffective motivation maystart with pondering on afew past key stressfulevents that havechallenged you, made youaware <strong>of</strong> life problems andlearning some effectivestress management plansStrong commitment to change requires the extension <strong>of</strong>awareness <strong>of</strong> the problems faced and how to handlethem. To reach the stage <strong>of</strong> change is actually having theawareness <strong>of</strong> the issues or problems at hand and to seekout information or steps about how to manage them.This could be through self-learning from various sourceson the impact <strong>of</strong> stress on health and performance orfruitful advices from close friends. The awareness stage<strong>of</strong> change is very important as it strengthens thefoundation for future change efforts.Learning more about how the bodyand mind reacts to stress and whatcan be done to correct theseproblems can lead to moreeffective planning andcarrying out the process <strong>of</strong>stress management andchange.Self-prepared forchangeStarting to organise howto handle those problemsusing a personalised planfrom lessons learnt is in facta change process. Byselecting appropriate methodsfor reducing your stress, you maycome up with a list <strong>of</strong> possibleapproaches that you believe will workfor you but with different strengths,weaknesses, priorities and preferences. Anythingthat you need to accomplish in order to fulfil your stressmanagement plan occurs during this stage. Actualbehavioural change starts for the first time during thisstage. At this point, the commitment to change is made,your plan <strong>of</strong> action set and your preparation is complete.It is now time for you to implement your plan. If properplanning is made, this should be a relatively simplematter <strong>of</strong> doing the things you've said you would do,such as improving your capacity building, timemanagement, healthy eating, regularexercise, anger management,etc.This is followed byclosely monitoringthe progress,making notes onvarious optionsavailable, andbalancingbetween theavailable choicesManaging Stress53


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013and potential consequences. This is charting the dailypractice by monitoring the progress and finding ways t<strong>of</strong>urther improve should hiccups arise. It teaches us toaccommodate and visualise the progress to help us stayon track. The experience teaches us to interact with thefuture circumstances and what to do should similarincidents repeat in the future. This is in fact theorganisational element <strong>of</strong> managing stress using thepersonalised stress prevention plan and supported bythe motivational factor to make it works effectively.Maintenance for continuityEffective stress management means effectiveapproaches and techniques that are followed bypositive changes and outcomes. At this stage <strong>of</strong> change,stress management techniques have been incorporatedinto daily life and the goal changes fromimplementation to maintenance. If necessary, revisitearlier stages so to alter the current routine to respondto life changes. For instance, if you have to gooutstation for a month or so to complete a task, youmay need to alter the normal daily routine <strong>of</strong> perhapsspending time at the kopitiam withyour friends or the weekendexercises. You schedule maybe too tight for you tospend time on otherroutines and thesituation requires youto alter the types <strong>of</strong>stress managementtechniques youpractice.Maintaining apositive perspectivewith regards to yourbusy and tight schedulethrough the practice <strong>of</strong>cognitive restructuringapproaches may become ahigher and more realistic prioritythan making time for a hang out session with yourfriends or planning for a family vacation.The task now is to move from a general understanding<strong>of</strong> the various stages <strong>of</strong> lifestyle change namelymotivation, awareness, commitment for change andmaintenance to an approach that will help propel youinto a healthier and less stressed lifestyle you want toachieve. In order to best do this, think about developinga personalised stress prevention plan for how you canadd regular stress prevention approaches to your lifeand then, executing this plan to make it an effectivereality.Selecting methods that suit youThe best prescription for reducing stress is one createdbased on knowledge <strong>of</strong> the stresses you face as well asan appreciation <strong>of</strong> the strengths, weaknesses,opportunities (options) and threats (hiccups). But itEffective stressmanagement meanseffective approaches andtechniques that arefollowed by positivechanges and outcomesmust be effective enough to be accomplished shouldthe goals and plans set are clear and simple, practicaland manageable. It is not an issue <strong>of</strong> high or lowgoals being set but practical approaches that cancome up with effective workable outcomes; andit may not necessarily get to the finish line allat once but something that may be changedand expanded or modified at a later suitabletime as and when it is necessary to achievecounter-productive goals.It may sound complicated as problems arealready at hand but try to choose goals thatyou think you will enjoy performing asopposed to the ones you anticipate will beaversive. Make sure to keep the goals concreteand highly practical with fewer complications.When the goals are phrased in practical and concreteterms, they are easier to accomplish and the rates <strong>of</strong>success are easily measured. Making honest selfpromiseswork in most circumstances, but it must bepractical and concrete such as:• I will not repeat my faulty thinking patterns butcorrect them by practicing cognitive restructuringapproaches.• I will find time to have my 45 minutes <strong>of</strong> briskwalking every Sunday morning, come rain or shine.• I will recite my doa to God after every prayer, nomatter how busy l am.• I will wash my car and vacuum it at least once aweek and that is an exercise routine.• I will examine my time management strategies andalter them so that they better fit my values.The list could go on and on, but it is pointless to trymany things all at once. Rather, it is effective to be54


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>selective and to prioritise thelist, and concentrate on the fewgoals that are helpful. But it mustcome with commitment to carry itout. Making a commitment is easy,but keeping these commitmentswhen they make you uncomfortableis the difficult part. You may formaliseyour goals by writing it down anddisplayed at locations you can seeit over and over again, or throughcompassion with someone youtrust. Such a contract may comewith a specific time frame forachievement or frequency toreduce ambiguity. Any changesmade to the contract must come up with a revisedversion that must be practical and better than theprevious one to avoid further and repetitive loopholes.Reading through your contract on a regular basis will alsohelp you keep your commitment on track andensure that the goals are realistic andmanageable.TrackingTracking methodology may beone that is simple withjotting down importantcomprehensive points thatinvolves keeping anelaborative record <strong>of</strong>entries before and aftereach action was taken,what and when an actionwas taken, what goal wastrying to meet byengaging in that activity,details <strong>of</strong> the feeling beforeand after each action wastaken, noticeable stress levelschange as a result <strong>of</strong> actionstaken, and visible pattern changesthat can help to maintain motivation.This is a new level <strong>of</strong> practicalcognitive restructuring exercise usingthe negative thoughts you may have beenrecording, directly or indirectly, as aresult <strong>of</strong> facing those stressfulepisodes, as the sourcematerials for future referencing.Another effective way <strong>of</strong> lateis the use <strong>of</strong> digitalassistance such assmartphones to remind us<strong>of</strong> the regular scheduledstress management andprevention activities, and toschedule regular remindersto do things you might otherwiseconveniently forget by integrating thosestress programmes and reminders intothe calendar system. As stress is a neverendinglife process with dynamic stressmanagement goals, one may wonderat some point in time how to get astress management and preventionprogramme in place, how to findeffective ways to keep it going, andhow to adapt it to the changingcircumstances in life? As consistency <strong>of</strong>practice is critical to success in the action stage <strong>of</strong>change, flexibility and adaptability maintenance stage <strong>of</strong>change certainly brings significant effect. The ability to beaware and sensitive to how change is faced is always thekey element.The plan should workIn everything that we do,the key to success is not topush too hard at any givenmoment. Effective stressmanagement is an areawhere trying harder will<strong>of</strong>ten only make thingsworse and at the expense<strong>of</strong> other comfortIn everything that we do, the key to success is not topush too hard at any given moment. Effectivestress management is an area wheretrying harder will <strong>of</strong>ten only makethings worse and at the expense<strong>of</strong> other comfort. Rather,taking things easy and donot rush but enjoy everymoment <strong>of</strong> it. Slowingdown is always the keyto a better practice anda happier experience.Even if you are <strong>of</strong>f-trackfor any reason, simplyget back on track assoon as possible. It’s ablessing to realise thatyou are <strong>of</strong>f-track than toignore it completely.Managing stress is never acompetition; instead, nurtureand cultivate the stressmanagement skills as part <strong>of</strong> aliving process. Working towardsimplementing these practices into thedaily routines can go a long way towardsreducing stress in life. Ultimately, reward yourself for theprogress you make, and in no time, these new practiceswill become old habits.And that personalised stress prevention plan shouldwork. lW.M.A. Wan Hussin is a Pr<strong>of</strong>essor at the School <strong>of</strong> Civil Engineering, UniversitiSains <strong>Malaysia</strong>. He conducts several courses on stress management anddelivers public lectures and brain storming sessions on management issues forvarious organisations. He is currently a Licensed Land Surveyor, Member <strong>of</strong> theAssociation <strong>of</strong> Authorised Land <strong>Surveyors</strong> (MAALS) <strong>Malaysia</strong>, Fellow <strong>of</strong> the<strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong> (FRISM), a <strong>Malaysia</strong>n SpeakingPr<strong>of</strong>essional (MSP) <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Malaysia</strong>n Association <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Speakers, aCertified Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Utility Locator (CPUL) and can be reached atwmabwh@gmail.com.Managing Stress55


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Whether PriorExperience IsNecessary ForInnovationBy Dr. Arshad Husain Ph.DI wish to start with a quotationfrom Thomas Edison theinventor <strong>of</strong> the electric bulbwho said, and I quote, “I haveinvented one more way <strong>of</strong> howNOT to make a light bulb; thereare still infinite ways to go.”Iwill now proceed with the provision <strong>of</strong> adefinition <strong>of</strong> innovation by Denning and I quote ‘innovationis a transformation <strong>of</strong> practice in a community’. Thisstatement carries with it the concept that a successfulinnovation is one that is taken up by a community with anaccompanying adjustment to expected work methods and/orpractices. There is an important distinction between themeaning <strong>of</strong> ‘invention’ and ‘innovation’. Carayannis, Alexander,and Mason state that: ‘Invention is the development <strong>of</strong> a newidea that has useful application. Innovation is a more complexterm, referring to how an invention is brought into commercialusage’.Colonel Eli Lilly founded the global pharmaceutical companynamed after him in 1876 in an old dilapidated warehousebuilding with only three workers. Today, they have 41,000employees handling an ever flourishing business across theglobe in 138 countries. They have an annual budget <strong>of</strong> 2.3billion dollars spent on Research and Development alone inconsideration <strong>of</strong> the progressive manufacture <strong>of</strong> New Productsthrough a process <strong>of</strong> new ideas and innovation.The list can go on…the founding <strong>of</strong> KFC……McDonalds etc.Therefore, the answer is an emphatic NO to the question <strong>of</strong>whether prior experience is necessary for Innovation. In otherwords, innovation commences without prior experience.There is an important distinctionbetween the meaning <strong>of</strong>‘invention’ and ‘innovation’. …Invention is the development <strong>of</strong> anew idea that has usefulapplication. Innovation is a morecomplex term, referring to howan invention is brought intocommercial usage’56


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>The process <strong>of</strong> adoptingany new tool involves alearning curve forindividuals. Thisdescribes the need forlearners to be creativein their approaches tolearning in a rapidlychanging environment.The founding fathers <strong>of</strong> such global giantorganisations <strong>of</strong> today required noexperience that led to the innovativeproducts that they finally produced and areprogressively manufactured today.Broadly speaking in the early phases, news<strong>of</strong> an innovation spreads through a range <strong>of</strong>communication channels, including face-t<strong>of</strong>ace,email (one-to-one or one-to-many) ortelephone. These initial contacts are likely tobe with trusted colleagues and a highdegree <strong>of</strong> control over the informationimparted is assured. As the introduction <strong>of</strong>the innovation progresses, other forms <strong>of</strong>dissemination are introduced. This might bevia a website or newsletter, through focusgroups, at committees or departmental staffmeetings. These approaches exploit existingcommunication channels and peoplenetworks, although they may also involvethe creation <strong>of</strong> new networks specific to theinnovation. As communications spreadoutwards, the originators <strong>of</strong> the initiative areless able to control which individualsreceive information, and the content <strong>of</strong> thecorrespondence. There is also a greaterpotential for sceptics to be encountered.Despite this, awareness <strong>of</strong> the initiativegrows, is diffused across campus, andclusters <strong>of</strong> individuals with greaterawareness appear.The process <strong>of</strong> adopting any new toolinvolves a learning curve for individuals. Thisdescribes the need for learners to becreative in their approaches to learning in arapidly changing environment. Anorganisation that is devoted to change is the mostlikely environment for a culture <strong>of</strong> learning to flourish.This in turn enables learners to share experiences thusenhancing the learning process. Positive experiencewith technology inclines an individual towardsadoption <strong>of</strong> other technologies.Therefore, potential adopters <strong>of</strong> innovation evaluatethe possible ‘value’ that the innovation has to them.This value can be measured in terms <strong>of</strong> ‘cost’ and‘benefit’, with the value being determined by thebalance <strong>of</strong> these two factors. Another necessary factoris the importance <strong>of</strong> ‘resources’ and ‘communication’.Thus, personal and institutional factors combine todetermine adoption <strong>of</strong> an initiative. Such factors are:Personal factors• Costs• Effort to acquire new skills• Time• Resources• Necessary skills• Prior experience with similar innovation• Risks <strong>of</strong> failure• Loss <strong>of</strong> self-esteem• Loss <strong>of</strong> social approvalAn organisation that is devoted to change is themost likely environment for a culture <strong>of</strong> learningto flourish. This in turn enables learners to shareexperiences thus enhancing the learning process.Management57


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013Another necessary factor is the importance <strong>of</strong> ‘resources’ and‘communication’. Thus, personal and institutional factorscombine to determine adoption <strong>of</strong> an initiative.<strong>Institution</strong>al factors• Resources• Equipment• Finances• TrainingIt could be argued that some <strong>of</strong> the factors that are classifiedas ‘personal’ are equally applicable to institutions. Forexample, the risk <strong>of</strong> failure is a consideration for a universitycommittee that is approached to support a scheme. Thecosts in respect <strong>of</strong> time and effort are also validconsiderations for the institution as a whole.Additional factors to be considered include:• The nature <strong>of</strong> the initiative – whether it is a local,national, collaborative, or a distributed venture.• The aspects <strong>of</strong> institutional activity that are set to gainfrom the innovation – these may be related to teachingand learning, research, administrative functions or acombination <strong>of</strong> these.Both personal and organisational processes influence aculture <strong>of</strong> innovation. These organisational processes are:“management values, rewards, prohibitions, andencouragement <strong>of</strong> new ideas, encouragement <strong>of</strong> risk-taking,and the like.”To this list we can add services, support, and communicationchannels and staff networks. An institution with these keycomponents in place is better placed to ensure thatinnovations are facilitated, encouraged, accepted anddiffused across its campus.Thus, the institutional environment shapes the development<strong>of</strong> the initiative, its adoption and implementation. Culturealso affects the success or failure <strong>of</strong> a new innovation.Basically, in a culture <strong>of</strong> innovation, people will have a habit<strong>of</strong> constantly looking for ways to improve things.Organisational culture is understood as the “values andbeliefs shared by personnel in an organisation.” Thesecultural beliefs translate into “communication and mutualunderstanding” and they influence the beliefs andbehaviours <strong>of</strong> individuals. Organisations use differentresources and processes to guide behaviour and change. Thisemphasises the importance <strong>of</strong> the pervading culture withinan organisation in relation to the degree <strong>of</strong> acceptance <strong>of</strong> anew innovation.The influence <strong>of</strong> organisational culture on creativity andinnovation are viewed as the main determinants leading out<strong>of</strong>: strategy, structure, support mechanisms, behaviours thatencourage innovation, and communication. This highlightsthe requirement for institutions to encourage: flexibility,autonomy and co-operation at the ‘structure’ level; reward,recognition and resources at the ‘support mechanism’ level;support for risk taking, change, learning and conflict handlingas the behaviours that encourage innovation; and finallyopen communication.Two important determinants are ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors.<strong>Institution</strong>al push factors might be rewards <strong>of</strong>fered by aninstitution to encourage the adoption and use <strong>of</strong> a newinnovation, or mandate to enforce adoption. Personal pullfactors include the perceived need for the resource and thebenefits to be gained by using it.The institutional framework is bounded by externalinfluences, which in turn influence decisions taken atinstitutional, faculty, department, and project level. Thestrength <strong>of</strong> the boundaries between faculties anddepartments, or the existence <strong>of</strong> cross-disciplinarycollaborations can affect diffusion <strong>of</strong> innovations across aninstitution.In today’s world <strong>of</strong> marketing, it is important to learn howdeveloping the creative ideas that lead to innovativeproducts are a discipline by itself. It is important to learntechniques that can lead to products that will have lastingcompetitive advantage in the marketplace. In addition togoing out to speak to customers, it would be <strong>of</strong> furtheradvantage to discover the other research techniques that canlead to insights that will ensure the development <strong>of</strong> productsthat create significantly more value for the customer. lDr. Arshad Husain is an acclaimed Pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong> Psychology, Human ResourceManagement, Marketing and Management. He is a well-known author and writer. Heis presently the Chairman <strong>of</strong> an International and recognised Institute – The Institute<strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Studies (UK), where he teaches from anything up to 34 subjects atuniversity level based on both research and experience. He has written various booksand provided numerous research based papers and articles more specially, onwww.articlesbase.com. He has taught at many world renowned universities followinga successful pr<strong>of</strong>essional career where he rose to the position <strong>of</strong> becoming aneffective CEO <strong>of</strong> a Global Multinational company for a number <strong>of</strong> years. He isextremely well educated from the very best universities in the world having done anextensive Ph.D. and receiving a Doctorate in both Human Resource Management andPsychology. He did his MBA in Marketing. He is approached by students, pr<strong>of</strong>essorsand executives from all over the world who wish to seek a mature conclusion to alltheir personal and pr<strong>of</strong>essional problems. His email address ishusainster@gmail.com.…the institutional environmentshapes the development <strong>of</strong> theinitiative, its adoption andimplementation. Culture alsoaffects the success or failure <strong>of</strong>a new innovation.58


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>LIST OF NEW MEMBERS February – April 2013QUANTITY SURVEYINGFELLOWSr Ahamd Suhaimi Abdul MajidAS2 Consult S/B, KLSr Amnah bt Mohammed SallehCIC QS Services S/B, SelSr Ang Fuey LinTaylor's University Lakeside CampusSr Roziyah IsmailJKR, CKUB, KLAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sabaria HassanUiTM Shah AlamSr Shamshul Ariffin b Abdul AzizJUB Ikatan Sepakat S/B, SelSr Yeap Soon KiatBaharuddin Ali & Low S/B, KLAssoc. Pr<strong>of</strong>. Sr Dr Zakaria b Mohd Yus<strong>of</strong>UTM SkudaiMEMBERSr Anita IbrahimJKRSr Fadziah YahyaJKRSr Khairil Nisaak OsmanJKRSr Lau Wei LeongJK Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong>, PJSr Lee Lei YeeCKP Associates, KLSr Lee Shiau MeiTrilink Pyramid S/B,Sr Michael James McIverPlus Three Consultants (M) S/B, KLSr Chua Shiu YeePerunding NFL, KLSr Hanawati Hashim @ NordinJKR Selangor, Shah AlamSr Mohd Izwan b IbrahimAT Associates, KLSr Tay Ying SeeLangdon & Seah S/B, SelSr Thalasiah Mohd SaadJPSDato' Sr Wan Zakariah b Wan MudaAhmad Zaki Resources S/B, KLSr Zulkifli b YaacobJurukur Bahan Perdana S/B, SelGRADUATEAbdul Manaf b Ahmad SirajQS Focus S/B, SelAfeezah Nor bt OthmanPKNS, Shah AlamAhmad Fauzi ZulkifliSyarikat Prasarana Negara Bhd, KLAmyradha a/p MunusamyLangdon & Seah S/B, SelAnderson Yap Chun HenLangdon & Seah S/B, SelAzlan Abdul RafarPerunding DMA S/B, KLAzmi b AhmadJB BergabungChe Zaki Che MatSyarikat Prasarana Negara Bhd, KLChen Yoon LeeQuanticonsult S/B, SelChoo Kong BingQuanticonsult S/B, SelChristine Teresa NettoATC QS Konsult, Kota KinabaluDarren Chai Teck LiangPerunding WCH, KuchingDavis Chee Tzun ShengProlosman Consultant, Kota KinabaluDerek Hooi Yew FattTOFFCO S/B, KLHaifaa Ahmad HashimAT Associates, KLHaryati IsmailPoliteknik Kota Kinabalu, SabahIntan Suhaila MohamedPerunding NFL S/B, KLIntan Suraya HusinKA Associates, KLKhuzaimah Mohd JunaidiPakatan Ukur Bahan S/B, TerengganuLai Voon YauJurukur Bahan L & T, SelLawrence Yap Sie KiongLangdon & Seah S/B, JBLee Lay HoonJurukur Bahan YSK, SarawakLee Yian NeeSarawak Energy Bhd, KuchingLester Tan Sheng HuanNorthcr<strong>of</strong>t Lim Perunding S/B, SelLiew Khang ShengCSL QS Consult, SabahLim Meng WahNorthcr<strong>of</strong>t Lim Perunding S/B, SelLim Teck KhangVeritas Contracts S/B, KLLiong Li FongQuanticonsult S/B, SelMah Sin WeiQuanticonsult S/B, SelMohamad Akram b Mohamed KarimKump. Ukur Bahan SarawakMohamed Ismail b Mohamed OmarAT Associates, KLMohd Idris b Mohamad PiahAzzuman Business Services, IpohMohd Khairin Akmal Mohamad JidonSyarikat Prasarana Negara Bhd, KLMohd Muzamil Mohd RosliAT Associates, KLMuhamad Afiq b ZainalJUB Central S/B, KLMuhamad Azlan b SulaimanJurukur Bahan PBE, KLMuhamad Haziq b RuslanPerunding DMA S/B, KLMuhammad Ammar b JamadiJY Cost Plan Consultants, JBNazirah ZainiPerunding SHS S/B, KLNik Mohd Dhiyahullah b Nik DinKSK Associates S/B, SelNoor Azizah MajidJKRNoor Fazura Abu SamaanJKR Negeri SembilanNurulain RaizamKA Associates, KLNursyahidatul Syafiqah MaliJUB Central S/B, KLNurul Zawani RusliKSK Associates S/B, SelRonald Song Ing HuiJurukur Bahan YSK, SarawakSamer Shahedza KhairuddinBasar & Harun Sdn, SelSimon Chung Ka MingMOQS Consultant S/B, SabahSiti Aishah AmranWAW Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong>, KelantanSiti Hajar OthmanUniversiti Teknikal MelakaSiti Nahdatul Syima RumlanPerunding DMA S/B, KLSiti Sarah AmranBasar & Harun Sdn, SelSiti Syafarah Abdul RahmanJKR KedahTan Ban CheeJurukur Bahan FPS S/B, KLTan Wan YinLangdon Seah S/B, SelTan Yuan CuiNorthcr<strong>of</strong>t Lim Perunding S/B, SelTang Mun WaiLangdon Seah S/B, SelTeh Sin ChongTurner & Townsend S/B, UKTeo Xian QinYong & Mohd Faiz S/B, PJTina Ilyani Jus<strong>of</strong>H& A QS Consultants, KLYeo Hui ChinJurukur Bahan YSK, SarawakYeo Shou PinPerunding Kos T & K S/B, KLYvonne Runya RimanHLA Quantity <strong>Surveyors</strong> S/B, SarawakZakirin bt ZakariaNAZ Progressive Consultant & Services S/B, SelPROBATIONERCheong Sue WeiJurukur Bahan PFS S/B, KLDavid Yii Yang HeeGamuda Engineering S/B, SelDouglas Johann GhaniYong & Mohd Faiz (Sabah)Goh Chia HoongNorthcr<strong>of</strong>t Lim Perunding S/B, SelGun Chiu YeePCM Kos Perunding S/B, KLMak Jye ShenInt. Ltd, JeddahTeh Phoay KeatPelana Tenggara S/B, PenangOng Yee FeiY & G Corporation Bhd, SelTey Jium ShyaaLangdon & Seah S/B, SelTiu Gie OngJurukur Bahan L & T, SelSTUDENTHasanah Mohd GhausLau Kah MengMohd Shamsudin b HussainYang Wai YeePROPERTY MANAGEMENT, VALUATION AND ESTATE AGENCYSURVEYINGFELLOWSr Khaidir Abd RasipIRDA, JohorSr Norlina Ra'eeSarawak Land & Survey Dept.Member Updates59


THE MALAYSIAN SURVEYOR | Vol.48 | No.2 | 2013LIST OF NEW MEMBERS February – April 2013MEMBERSr Abdul Halim HussainPelaburan Hartanah Bumiputra Bhd, KLSr Azizierul b RamliJPPH PerakSr Chia Zi JinJS Valuers Property Consultant (Johor) S/BSr Chiang Woon LinSuruhanjaya Sekuriti <strong>Malaysia</strong>, KLSr Johari b IsmailJPPH PerakSr Khairul Anaz b MuratJPPH KedahSr Kholim b SahrayUiTM Shah AlamSr Lo Kin WengCH Williams Talhar & Wong, JBSr Loo Choo BengPakatan Ukur Bahan S/B, TerengganuSr Mahathir A RahmanHenry Butcher <strong>Malaysia</strong>, SarawakSr Dr Mohamad Sukeri KhalidUUM KedahSr Mohd Asraf b Mat YajidJPPH PerakSr Mohd Nasruddin Mat NorProjek Lintasan Kota Holding S/B, KLSr Mohd Noor Azeni NordinAzmi & Co S/B, SelSr Norlizawati SidekJPPH PerakSr Norrushidah bt ZakariaCH Williams Talhar & Wong S/B, KedahSr Siti Sarah bt FuadJPPH PerakSr Tiong Chee Yen JoyceCH Williams Talhar & Wong S/B, KLSr Zulkefli b AhmadIPC Island Property Consultants S/B, SelGRADUATELoh Phoi PeiNilLoo Shih BoonPPC International S/B, KLNur Diyana bt KamarudinMacReal International S/B, PenangRohizad b AznanIM Global Property Consultants Sdn Bhd,KLTan Zao YeeRahim & Co (Johor) S/BVictor Wong Zhi WenNilYeow Tze TeBurgess Rawson, SerembanPROBATIONERAhmad Shah b RazaliKK Property Mgmnt S/B, KLBong San SanMetro Homes S/B, SabahCheah Siew MunFKH Holdings S/B, SelChooi Lee ChenTA Properties, KLChua Kee KitKnight Frank, KLLee Chan HoeHartamas Real Estate (M) S/BLim Teck FungNilLua Chiyar LockNovartis CorporationMohd Shaiful b Mohd ShaffiaiJuruukur Sinarsuria, BangiPhoon Kin KheongEminent Ace S/B, SelPoh Chee SengTay & Associates, JohorTeow Wei XinNilWah Kheng WuNilWoo Zi YaangNilASSOCIATE MEMBERAlex Chong Hock KeeFirst Appraisal P/L, SingaporeAgustinus P TambaKJPP Dwi Haryantono Agustinus TambaAnne Loh Mei FunStrata AMC P/L, SingaporeMaisarah Mat NoorMohamad Amin Abd LatifMohammad Shazli b AzlanMohd Firdaus Ali Khan b HafidMuhammad Faris b NordinMuhammad Firdaus b ShabliMuhammad Idham b ZulkifliMuhammad Taufik b Mohd AliNabila Mohammed AsriNadzirah Md PadziNeo Sau MeiNooraisyilah MurniNor Ryana AbdullahNur Baizah MohamedNur Hidayah IbrahimNur Nabiha YahyaNur Syafiqah SaparudinNur Syazwani Eliza ZahidanNurul Akmar MustaffaNurul Shafiqah AhmadPang Zi WeiPhung Kah MinBernard Chen Ki YuenStrata AMC P/L, SingaporeTjondro PrasetyoKJPP Dwi Haryantono Agustinus TambaRabi'atul 'Adawiyah RahimRazlin b MansorRosenia Chung Nah NahSTUDENTAsmawi b BorhanSafira Nabilla Muhammad MuhirAdi Wazien Fikri b ZulkifliSharina Khalida SazeliAdibah Mohd RazaliSiti Fadzilah AyobAnis MusaSiti Nadirah Mohd NohAtikah ArifinSiti Noor 'Adilah Mohd HasbullahBadrul Hisham b Mohd RidzaSiti Nor Aqillah Mat NaserChew Kar YoungSiti Nor Jawahir Mohd NawawiChia Sin YinSiti Nur Hidayah Ab HalimChong Woon KehChu Chia ManEllen Tay JoelynnFatin Nabila Khairul AnuarFong Kar MunHeng Hwa MeiHew Li ChyiJuwairiah MustafaSuhana IsmailSyafika Adila SafieTan Lay BoonTay Yi YingThen Phei ChengTiong Chai PingToh Pei XuanIrene Tan Hui LingWan Fikriah Wan HarunIylia Atira RoslanYap Poy PoyIzyan Ayuni IsmailIzzah binti Shamsol KaharKhairun Najihah Abdul HalimKu Meei ShyenGEOMATIC AND LAND SURVEYINGFELLOWSr Ahmad Rustami RamleyJurukur Abadi, JBPr<strong>of</strong> Sr Dr Alias Abdul RahmanUTM SkudaiLeow Chee KuanLim Bee VeunSr Choy Ming SweeUkurarah Consultants, KedahLin Shi FueiSr Jalal b JohariJalal Johari Consultants, KL60


The Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Royal</strong> <strong>Institution</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Surveyors</strong> <strong>Malaysia</strong>LIST OF NEW MEMBERS February – April 2013AP Sr Dr Kamaluddin Hj TalibUiTM Shah AlamSr Mohamad Kamali b AdiminJUPEM KLSr Hj Mohd Fadzli HashimNaluri Ukur, KelantanSr Nik Mohd Wafi Nik Mohamed DaudJUPEM KelantanSr N<strong>of</strong>ariza ZainalUiTM PerlisSr Noraini bt ZulkipliPetronas Carigali S/B, KLBUILDING SURVEYINGFELLOWAP Sr Dr Syahrul Nizam KamaruzzamanUniversiti MalayaMEMBERSr Mohammad Anuar b SafianPoliteknik Sultan Azlan Shah, BehrangSr Siew Siew WengSeni Ukur Consult, SelSr Norshahrizan b Mohd HashimUiTM ArauSr Norizan MahmudJKRSr Dr Zainal A MajeedJUPEM KelantanSr Rabiulkhair b Mohd NorJUPEM KLSr Shahrullail b SulaimanStructural Repair (M) S/BMEMBERSr Afiq b Juazer RizalPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Ahmad Azan b Abdul RashidPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Alwi b Mohd NoorJUPEM HQSr Ashnita RahimUiTM PerlisSr Awang Ahmad Awang BasriJabatan Tanah & Survei SarawakSr Awangku Mohamad Zulhaji Awangku AhmadPutra Geomatics Survey, SarawakSr Chai Tuh EngNilSr Chee Shui YongUiTM PerlisSr Farawahida Mohd MonilPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Fariza Muhamad FaizPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Julaihie b RosliPutra Geomatics Survey, SarawakSr Khairul Zafuan Hj KhalidSO Survey Consultants, KuantanSr Lau Wei SengPerunding Ukur Tekun, SelSr Lee Ai ThengJurukur Noble, KLSr Masayu NormanUiTM PerlisSr Mat Akhir b Md WazirUiTM Shah AlamSr Mimi Diana GhazaliUiTM PerlisSr Mohamad Pauzi Mat ZamPoliteknik Tuanku Sultanah Bahiyah, KedahSr Mohamad Nazri MasnanPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Mohd Amaruddin AzmanPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Mohd Faiz Mohd RamliPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Mohd Hafizul b IbrahimJurukur Sejati, SelSr Mohd Khairi Izwan b MisronJurukur Sejati, SelSr Mohd Nazri b MasromPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Mohd Zahran SaadPerunding Ukur Al-Asr & Services, KedahSr Mustaffa b ShahimJUPEM KLSr Neogh Siak HooiJurukur Perintis S/B, KLSr Rozwan Hakin LongJUPEM KelantanSr Siti Hajar NayanJurukur Mutiara, KLSr Siti Zaleha bt MisnanPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Syed Omar Syed HamidSO Survey Consultants, KuantanSr Wan Mohd Zaed b Mamat @ Wan Ab HamidJurukur Makhtar, PerakSr Woo Seng KwongNilGRADUATEHafizunisa BorhanJurukur Nizam Ali, JBKamarul Akram KamarudinJurukur Kemuncak, KLMd Azlan Shah b SaidNilMohd Ali Shah Bana b MohamadJurukur Kinetik, SelMuhamad Afandi Mohd SukriJurukur Aras, KelantanMuhammad Khairi b IdrusJurukur Express S/B, KLNabila Omar BakiJurukur Nizam Ali, JBNik Ahmad Aiman b Nik MazlanMidlands Surveys Consultants, KLSiti Nor Fatihah Mohd NoorMidlands Surveys Consultants, KLWan Qamarul Hazimin b Wan DeramanJurukur Aras, KelantanSTUDENTAdilah bin Ahmad RustamiAfiqah binti HamdanAhmad Fadhirul b Ahmad ShukriMohamad Najib b SulaimanMohammad Romzi b Mohamad NorMohd Hanif b RomliMuhammad Amzar b AzmeMuhammad Shafiq b Abdul KarimNordiana bt RamlanNurul Athirah NawawiASSOCIATE MEMBERDian NurdianaPetronas Carigali S/B, KLI Gusti Ngurah Bagus NirwanaPetronas Carigali S/B, KLKristiawan Tri NugrohoPetronas Carigali S/B, KLSr Suhana JoharUKMGRADUATEAslida bt OmarUiTMMohamad Sanusi MustafaKolej Komuniti JasinMohammad Redzduan b KamaruddinGemilang Maintenance Services S/B, KLMohd Khazli Aswad b KhalidAdvance Maintenance Precision Mgmt S/B, SelMohd Redzwan b MusaKimlun S/B, JBNor Diana bt AzizFocus Facilities Mgmnt. S/B, PuchongMohd Safrin b Mohamad RasdiUiTM Shah AlamNahdatul Arm bt Abd RaniNilNik Affifi b Nik RamliCanaan Building Inspection S/B, PJNor Islahiah bt HashimJKR PahangSTUDENTAfiq b MohammadAhmad Zulfadzly b Anwar ZainiAisyah bt ArshadAnis Farhana bt AliminArnold Ricci LatimbunEzwan Fadzli b Che OmMior Fazrul Azdan b Mior AmranMior Wahidun Asuat b M SabriMohamad Rashdan b IsaMohd Norbahiyuddin b Mohd NawaiMohd Zainul Abidin b AriffinMuhammad Izwan b OthmanMuhammad Ruslan b IsmailNabilah RoslanNor Azmira BunyaminNurshafarina bt JasmeRobiatun Adawiyah bt AliSiti Umairah bt Sai'inTengku Muhammad Eqbal b Ku JayaZahlini Ab WahabMember Updates61


INVITATION FORARTICLE CONTRIBUTIONThe <strong>Malaysia</strong>n Surveyor Journal ISSN: 2232-1292 (On-line)The <strong>Malaysia</strong>n Surveyor is a high quality peerreview journal published quarterly online. Thepublication aims at bringing together researchers,academicians, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals, practitioners andstudents to impart and share knowledge in theform <strong>of</strong> empirical and theoretical articles andresearch papers. It provides an international forumfor the dissemination <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional knowledgeand practices, original research results, new ideas,practical experience <strong>of</strong> the surveying pr<strong>of</strong>ession,advancements and innovation in the surveyingtechnology and surveyors’ contribution toward theproperty market and building industry. Wewelcome original article contribution to The<strong>Malaysia</strong>n Surveyor.Peer Review ProcessManuscripts are subject to review by the Editorial Board andreviewers.General Guidelines for SubmissionsArticle submissions should not exceed 10 pages, including allfigures and tables (excludes the references). Abstract shouldbe no more than 500 words. Articles in Bahasa <strong>Malaysia</strong> needto include an abstract in English.Kindly email article to:editor@rism.org.myFor more information, visit the <strong>of</strong>ficial website <strong>of</strong> the journalat http://www.rism.org.my/ContentPages/Journal.aspxROYAL INSTITUTION OF SURVEYORS MALAYSIA3rd Floor, Bangunan Juruukur, 64 – 66, Jalan 52/4, 46200 Petaling Jaya, Selangor, <strong>Malaysia</strong>Tel: 603-7954 8358 / 7955 1773 / 7956 9728 Fax: 603-7955 0253Website: www.rism.org.my E-mail: secretariat@rism.org.my, editor@rism.org.my

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!