STF na MÃdia - MyClipp
STF na MÃdia - MyClipp
STF na MÃdia - MyClipp
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Reuters: You've described these laws as part of a<br />
policy of "self-deportation." What do you mean?<br />
Kobach: There's a false dichotomy that constantly<br />
emerges when you see politicians talking about<br />
immigration. They'll say you can't round up 11 million<br />
people and enforce the law 100 percent, so amnesty is<br />
the only ratio<strong>na</strong>l way to move forward. But no serious<br />
thinker would say those are the only two approaches<br />
to a law enforcement problem. The ratio<strong>na</strong>l solution is<br />
to ratchet up the level of enforcement. Then illegal<br />
aliens will self-deport because the cost-benefit<br />
calculation changes.<br />
Reuters: A study by the Center for Business &<br />
Economic Research at the University of Alabama<br />
found that Alabama's new immigration law will shrink<br />
the state economy by $2.3 billion and cost the state<br />
70,000 jobs. What do you think about the economic<br />
impact of the new immigration laws?<br />
Kobach: The Alabama study did not consider the huge<br />
fiscal burden illegal immigration is placing on Alabama<br />
taxpayers. The other factor that needs to be<br />
considered is the benefit of removing Americans from<br />
welfare rolls and allowing them to work. Once illegal<br />
aliens are removed from the labor market, wages will<br />
inevitably come up.<br />
Reuters: What's your own immigration story?<br />
Kobach: My great grandparents came from Norway<br />
and Germany and settled in Wisconsin. They were<br />
farmers for the most part. I'm a fourth-generation<br />
American.<br />
Reuters: How did you become interested in<br />
Reuters General/ - Article, Seg, 16 de Abril de 2012<br />
CLIPPING INTERNACIONAL (Supreme Court)<br />
immigration reform?<br />
Kobach: One of the biggest epiphanies for me was the<br />
9/11 hijackings. I was working at the Justice<br />
Department for Attorney General John Ashcroft. All<br />
hijackers had come into the states legally, but five of<br />
the 19 became unlawfully present during their stays.<br />
Four of those five were apprehended by state and<br />
local police for traffic violations while they were in the<br />
country illegally. In none of those cases did the state or<br />
local officer have the information available to make an<br />
arrest and potentially foil the 9/11 plot. That realization<br />
was essential to my understanding of how critical<br />
federal and state cooperation is in this area.<br />
Reuters: What's the most influential law review article<br />
you've written?<br />
Kobach: In 2008, I published an article in the<br />
Georgetown Immigration Law Review, "Reinforcing the<br />
Rule of Law: What States Can and Should Do to<br />
Reduce Illegal Immigration." Arizo<strong>na</strong>'s SB 1070<br />
manifests many of the concepts that I prescribed in<br />
that article.<br />
Reuters: Has anything surprised you about how these<br />
laws have played out?<br />
Kobach: I didn't anticipate these state laws would<br />
become <strong>na</strong>tio<strong>na</strong>l issues in the way they have. I also<br />
never imaged the Justice Department would sue a<br />
state for trying to help the federal government enforce<br />
the law. That's never happened in American history<br />
before.<br />
(Reporting by Terry Baynes)<br />
158