Product News & ReviewsReview: Scenic Details, Awnings MSRP $9.50, Sidewalks MSRP $8.75Frenchman River Model Works, HC1 Box 185A, Stratton, NE69043 ● www.frenchmanriver.<strong>com</strong>reviewed by Brian ScaceFrenchman River Model Works has been making a line ofHO scenic items for a while, now, and is now entering the O<strong>Scale</strong> market with several interesting items.First off is a kit for window awnings, consisting of foursheets of striped-pattern awning material and the wire supportsneeded for mounting these awnings to your structureof choice. These are helpful for folks modeling the steam era,especially, as window awnings were more than decorationback in the pre-air conditioning era.While perusing their website, I also saw some sidewalkcastings that have some promise, too. Although marketedas an HO item, the #004 “Big City Sidewalk” scales outnicely (about four feet wide) for our use. The curb height isabout four scale inches, and the castings are nice and crisp.Included are a couple corners with storm drains, a sectionwith a vehicle ramp over the curbing, and a section with anHO-sized manhole cover cast in. Quick work with a drill andan O <strong>Scale</strong> manhole cover will take care of the li’l HO one,making all the pieces useful. I’d love to see them offer a baglot with a whole bunch of just the corner/storm drain pieces,which are certainly the hardest of the bunch to scratchbuildconvincingly. They’re certainly worth a good look.Frenchman is <strong>com</strong>ing to market with a kit for a woodenrowboat (with an outboard motor), in keeping with theshoreside themes evident in their HO line. If you are lookingfor some nifty scenic detail castings and detailing kits, visitthem on their website to see what they’re up to.Review: Chicago Burlington & Quincy 28’ CabooseO <strong>Scale</strong> Kit # 403009 MSRP: $120.00Mullet River Model Works, 118 Huson Ct., Plymouth, WI53073 920-892-8159 ● www.mulletrivermodelworks.<strong>com</strong>reviewed by Martin BrechbielMullet River Model Works has been advertising theircabooses for quite a while in these pages. As it turns out,they actually offer 11 caboose kits, a flat car, and a gondola,as well as some structures (see OST, Jan/Feb ’07 page 54 fora review of their Wisconsin Central/ Soo Line Depot). Theseare all laser-cut kits of plywood construction with workingside windows and cupola windows, an etched brass underframe,and brass ladders. Having been more than mildlyintrigued, I was unable to resist an opportunity to check oneover first hand. These were older cars on the CB&Q that hadbeen remodeled with a steel underframe and using the samecupola as the 30’ cars. Window spacing varied on the 28’cars, since there were many classes of them. This model representsthe NE1 and NE4 cars.I’ll confess that I had not handled a modern-era craftsmankit (or any kit for that matter) for many years, so a smallamount of trepidation began to counterbalance my excitementpending actually opening the box and seeing whatbargain I had entered into with our Mephistophelian Editor.There were several very tidy plastic bags very neatly organizedwith laser-cut <strong>com</strong>ponents cut from thin plywood.Included in the one bag was also laser-cut window glazingand decals. In yet another separate bag was a sheet of etchedbrass underbody framing parts, steps to be assembled, ladders,and even tissue paper for the roofing. There were fivepages of instructions and another five pages of exploded<strong>com</strong>ponent construction views, interior <strong>com</strong>ponent views,and views of the etched brass <strong>com</strong>ponents and their ultimaterespective locations.Assembly began with the lamination of the sides and ends.There are three layers of laser-cut plywood, and carpenters’or white glue is re<strong>com</strong>mended along with weighting theseassemblies to keep them both flat and aligned. Everythingseparated nicely using a scalpel blade (whatever you prefer,invest in a new blade for this!) and, despite not liking usingwater based glues due to warping issues, I acquired a bottleof stainable carpenters’ glue. Everything went togethersmoothly and, between a bag of clothespins and leadweights, nice and flat as well. One critical issue to laser-cutkits with slot-and-tab construction – you really, really haveto keep all of the slots clear of glue. After I got the sides andends together, I made my first mistake. The next heading onPage 1 was “Assemble cupola <strong>com</strong>ponents”, followed by alot of instructions on assembling the interior. Page 3 is wherethe cupola instruction really are (I knew that, did it anyway…really!).No real harm done but something to correct,and I was able to “adjust” the cupola sashes to be acceptableto me. Assembling the interior could be improved a bit withan exploded-view drawing of identified parts. Otherwise, it’sa puzzle that’s solvable on the basis of a limited number ofparts that simply have to go together a certain way. Gluingtogether the obvious and dry fitting the rest until you have a<strong>com</strong>pleted sub-assembly, then gluing that into place, works.There was one slot in the right interior wall that is incorrectlypositioned that required removing one tab to install the interiorfor that side. Fortunately, it’s not noticeable. The bracingparts under the bunks all have tabs, but there are no slots for54 • O <strong>Scale</strong> <strong>Trains</strong> - Mar/Apr ’07
Product News & Reviewsthem in the walls. I never did find the interiorladder rungs to the cupola. I don’t think that theyare needed anyway, and I’m going to put somelead weighting under the bunks as well.I’ll confess that there is something very satisfying about takingan entire interior sub-assembly and having multiple tabsaudibly snap into place. I may grow to like laser cut kits!Assembling the sides and ends together went smoothlyafter I went back and removed every scrap of excess glue atthe overlapping edges. The tolerances on the corner lap jointsfitting the sides and ends together was really nice and tight,and contributes to strong construction. The only real issue Ihad here was the section that goes under the door sill. This isa very, very delicate part of the ends that is attached by twovery small slivers of wood. After I broke one off three times, Ijust took both off and glued them into place later after the floorwas installed.Now I was supposed to assemble the cupola, anotherthree-layer lamination exercise that went very smoothly. Thelap fitting assembly really makes it next to foolproof to get thissquare, and the assembled cupola dropped right into its restingplace between the two sides of the assembled body; anotherprecision fit!Painting the sashes and door pieces was next. The glazingfor the door is the full size of the door, and gets sandwichedbetween two layers to make the panels in the lower sectionsand “glass” for the upper part. I could not locate any informationin the kit pertaining to color schemes and not being aCB&Q expert, I won’t even take a guessThe roof is designed to be removable, and there are 14 roofribs on one end and three on the other side of the cupola.They all have to fit into their respective slots on the wall sidesfor this to work, along with the cupola. I pre-curled both roofsections, sanded them slightly to align the slots in the roofwith those in the walls, and installed the ribs (two at time asre<strong>com</strong>mended), finding it increasingly difficult to snap theroof into place. By the time I got all of the ribs installed theroof snapped nicely into place. Ultimately, both roof sectionsjoined up nicely with the cupola as a single removable unit.The glazed sashes were installed along with the doors anddoor trim. The adjustable side sashes actually drop down intoa gap in the wall left by virtue of the lamination construction.Assembling the etched brass underbody was more troublesome.A few alignment or soldering tabs for the center sill boxwould have been useful. The bolster crossmembers also do notseem to be wide enough to either form the bolster and to alsoset down onto the underbody floor. After some consideration,were these parts not foldedon the fold lines as instructed,they may actually be correctlydimensioned. Everything elseseemed to fit as designed correctlyinto the wood bracing.The final finishing touchesare really left to the modeler;grab irons, creating the endrailings (supplying a templatefor that would be nice!), locationfor a smoke jack, brake<strong>com</strong>ponent(s) and their locations,etc. Overall, a fun kit tobuild with a bit of a challengeto it. Though perhaps not akit for a beginning kit builder,it’s definitely one for a moreexperience builder, particularlyso if you have any interest inthe road names that are offered or if you’d just like a reallyneat wooden caboose for your own private line. The neatnessand precision cutting of the <strong>com</strong>ponents was quite a novelty,as <strong>com</strong>pared to having to cut every stick, and the neatnessof fit was quite gratifying. So there were a few glitches, and acouple of errors by both kit and builder; nothing that would beconsidered <strong>com</strong>promising.Mar/Apr ’07 - O <strong>Scale</strong> <strong>Trains</strong> • 55