13.07.2015 Views

Post Natal Depression and Post Traumatic Stress Babywearing ...

Post Natal Depression and Post Traumatic Stress Babywearing ...

Post Natal Depression and Post Traumatic Stress Babywearing ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Editorial 2Alba’s birth 4Ela’s birth 5<strong>Post</strong> <strong>Natal</strong> <strong>Depression</strong>:Jane’s story 8Leslie’s story 9A personal view 10Fiona’s story 10Aftershocks 12Wounded mothers 12PTSD 14Double Take 15Breastfeeding: 17Feeding twins 17<strong>Babywearing</strong> 18Book reviews 21Thanks <strong>and</strong> acknowledgements 25Timetable (week-at-a-glance) 26Notice board <strong>and</strong> contacts 27Activity listings 28Editorial Team:Nadine EdwardsDaisy DinwoodieKim BradieAndrea BalzariniEditorialIf time flies for you, as it does for us,you may not have noticed that there hasnot been an issue of Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyondfor some time. This is because Birth <strong>and</strong>Beyond is planned, collected, edited,proofread, <strong>and</strong> produced on an entirelyvoluntary basis. But, it is of great importanceto us that it continues to be producedon a regular basis. We receiveexcellent feedback that it is a source ofvaluable knowledge <strong>and</strong> contains arange of views <strong>and</strong> experiences thatdeepens our underst<strong>and</strong>ings about pregnancy,birth <strong>and</strong> parenting. It providesfeedback to health practitioners <strong>and</strong>commissioners of maternity servicesabout what local women <strong>and</strong> families findsupportive <strong>and</strong> unhelpful during childbearing.Our editorial team has had to focus onother aspects of the Birth ResourceCentre, but we have been joined by Kim,Vroni, Daisy <strong>and</strong> Molly, <strong>and</strong> thank themfor their help in finally getting this issueto press. Sadly for us, Molly left for herhome country soon after her daughter'sbirth, but we wish her well. We are sureshe will enjoy <strong>and</strong> appreciate the supportof her family <strong>and</strong> friends back home inthe States.We continue to be appreciative <strong>and</strong>honoured that women <strong>and</strong> their familiesmake time to continue to support theBRC in so many different ways . TheBirth Resource Centre could not functionas it does without the practical support<strong>and</strong> goodwill that it enjoys (see page 25).And equally, we appreciate <strong>and</strong> feelhonoured that women continue to contributeto Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond, sharing theirstories, suggesting resources, <strong>and</strong> writingso passionately, honestly <strong>and</strong> articulately.Thank you. Even when stories area joy to write, we know how busy yourlives are. When stories are distressing ittakes courage to retell them.As ever, we receive your birth storieswith delight. Many women tell us howhelpful it is to hear reflective stories whichcontain within them the many ways thatwomen meet the challneges of theirlabours. As Raquel <strong>and</strong> Yifat tell us,preparing in ways that make sense toyou can dispel fear, inspire confidence,increase inner strength <strong>and</strong> provide practicalsupport for journeying throughlabour <strong>and</strong> birth: that movement,mantras, focusing, breathing <strong>and</strong> havingtrusted companions who know yourhopes <strong>and</strong> concerns, can all be invaluable.We thank you for your deeply moving<strong>and</strong> insightful accounts <strong>and</strong> agreethat Ina May's Guide to Childbirth(reviewed in a previous Issue) is particularlyinspiring.This issue of Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond focuseson two themes: depression <strong>and</strong> trauma,<strong>and</strong> breastfeeding. It is of course byno means exhaustive or definitive aboutthese. But we hope that the informationwill be helpful <strong>and</strong> that the insightful personalexperiences will provide support<strong>and</strong> reassurance. As Fiona Armstrongsuggests in both her personal article <strong>and</strong>her book review, hearing others' stories<strong>and</strong> knowing that we are not alone arecrucial in beginning to heal, when whatwe experience is not what we expect,<strong>and</strong> can be deeply undermining<strong>and</strong> frightening. As Fiona's, Alison's,Sophia's, Jane's <strong>and</strong> our anonymouswriter's stories tell us, finding someonewho listens, someone who does notjudge, or someone who has been therebefore is invaluable, no matter what weare experiencing. This may be an NHSpractitioner, a friend, a counsellor, someoneat the BRC: the list is potentially endless,but finding that supportive, listeningperson, with the knowledge <strong>and</strong> skills tohelp sensitively is, for many of us, crucialto begin healing <strong>and</strong> crucial to achievingour ideals. And sometimes, as our otheranaonymous write tells us, time is a healer.One of the issues we hope to shedlight on is that antenatal <strong>and</strong> postnataldepression, <strong>and</strong> postnatal trauma mayarise for different reasons, may feel different,<strong>and</strong> will need different kinds of support.Michelle's short article may helpwith this. <strong>Depression</strong> <strong>and</strong> trauma are verydifficult issues, but we hope you willagree that talking about them may helpboth those who experience them <strong>and</strong>those who might be in a position to help.They are also very complex, which Benigaddresses when she suggests that experiencesof birth may awaken <strong>and</strong> collidewith previous life experiences. At theBRC we are very concerned about how2 birth&beyond


Alba's birthIt was 1.30am. It was still three weeks before my due date.Andy <strong>and</strong> I had been out for a big dinner in our favourite Italianrestaurant, Vittoria’s, <strong>and</strong> we were both very stuffed <strong>and</strong> tired. Iwoke up with a wet patch, <strong>and</strong> I said to Andy, “Look, do you thinkthis could be the waters?”. “Oh, no!” said Andy, “you must havepeed yourself, you know, baby pressing on your bladder”. So Iconvinced myself baby wasn’t coming yet!Well, after that I couldn't go back to sleep. I had a bit of a soretummy <strong>and</strong> thought it was a combination of indigestion <strong>and</strong> theexcitement of the nextday as it would be my lastday at work! So, I justwent to the living room,had some tea, read mySpanish novel, dozed on<strong>and</strong> off…Then at 6:30 in themorning I had a show <strong>and</strong>the contractions started. Istill didn't quite believe Iwas in labour as I hadlately had lots of ‘BraxtonHicks’<strong>and</strong> the first contractionswere very mild.When I finally woke Andyup he believed me thistime, <strong>and</strong> after cuddling infor a while he encouragedme to phone the hospitalfor advice. I phoned my Little Alba, happy to be in the world at 3 days old.Mum <strong>and</strong> Dad first <strong>and</strong>described the pain, <strong>and</strong>discovered that both I <strong>and</strong> my brother were born around 20 daysbefore the due date!My mum told me that she had gone with mild contractionsthrough the whole day <strong>and</strong> so I should try to move around <strong>and</strong>live a normal day. At this point I was still convinced I would manageto go to work for my “surprise” leaving party!Then I phoned the hospital <strong>and</strong> they asked me how far apartthe contractions were. I just said every seven minutes withoutreally knowing! They told me to phone again when I had themevery three to five minutes.At this point Andy started faffing around wanting to find a stopwatch, then wanting to plot a chart to monitor the contractions,then wanting to record a tape of thumb piano music for me torelax in the labour ward... meanwhile I was throwing up with pain,dancing, pacing up <strong>and</strong> down, staring at a c<strong>and</strong>le, crouching onall fours... <strong>and</strong> so on.Anyway, it went very quickly <strong>and</strong> by 9:45am we thought weshould leave as the traffic was now calmer; then it dawned onme that I had to sit in the car for 45 min! Oh, no! I couldn't faceit! So at this point Andy was very helpful <strong>and</strong> sweet: he reassuredme a lot, put big cushions on the back seat <strong>and</strong> gave me my eyemask to help me be in darkness <strong>and</strong> focus. He also remindedme to concentrate on slow breathing. So I travelled on all-foursin the back seat, hugging the big cushions! During the journey Istarted to feel the urge to push! Imagine! “Only 20 more minutesto go!” said Andy.During the car journey I felt I wasn’t there; I was totallyimmersed inside myself. It was at this point that I really felt somuch in touch with my baby <strong>and</strong> my own body.When we finally arrived at St. Johns Hospital, they did the routinecheck up to monitor the heartbeat of the baby <strong>and</strong> so on...only they couldn't find the heartbeat! They asked, "Has the babybeen moving?”A comment like that would have put me off in early labour, butat this point I knew the baby was arriving <strong>and</strong> it was all fine,except that the midwives hadn’t realised this yet.They said they had to put something on the baby's head tohear the heart, meanwhile I was having massive contractions <strong>and</strong>the urge to push. They then saw that the head was coming! Ahead of hair!So, we quickly went to thelabour room <strong>and</strong> that wasit! Before encouraging meto push, the midwives hadto go through the procedureof asking if I wantedan injection for expellingthe placenta. I said thatI’d rather do it naturally.They replied by sayingthat it can take up to twohours of more pushing…Then I looked at Andy as Iwas in too much pain totake decisions <strong>and</strong> heasked: “Is it necessary?”,“No” they said,”but it isfaster”. So Andy said“well, it is not race, wewould rather not have it!”I was happy we had talkeda lot about the birth <strong>and</strong>Andy knew exactly what my feelings were.They didn't have time to run the water pool for the birth as Ihad wished, but it was beautiful anyway as I didn’t need any painrelief drugs <strong>and</strong> I was able to choose the position I wanted forthe pushing stage. When I was pushing, what really helped mewas Andy massaging my face with a wet cloth <strong>and</strong> also myMum’s comment which I used as a mantra, “One of these pushesis going to be the last, <strong>and</strong> baby will be here!”I arrived at the hospital at 10:30am <strong>and</strong> Alba was born at11:40am. It was amazing to be totally there, mind, body <strong>and</strong>spirit, pushing my baby out into the world, as we say in Spanish“Dar a luz” - “Giving the Light”.I had skin-to-skin contact for a long time, as I was waiting toexpel the placenta naturally. Alba started to feed from my breastthere <strong>and</strong> then 10 minutes after been born - it was very beautiful.It really made me feel at one with Nature!After a while of cuddling Alba, I suggested that I changed positionto go on all fours to see if gravity would help me push theplacenta out, but the midwife seemed to think that this wouldn’thelp. Then after one hour the midwife went to check with thedoctor <strong>and</strong> came back to say that if I didn’t mind he was goingto put in a catheter. “Why, <strong>and</strong> what’s that?” I asked. Sheexplained that it was a little tube to go into my bladder as thedoctor thought maybe my bladder was full <strong>and</strong> that was the reasonwhy the placenta wouldn’t come out. I said I would like totry one more time, <strong>and</strong> I asked her to hold Alba whilst I went onall fours. So as the doctor was coming down the corridor withthe “little tube” I had the placenta out in one push. It was mucheasier than the pushes to get the baby out. “How did the doctorknow what I needed if he hadn’t even seen me?” I thought.4 birth&beyond


love to leave her be as long as she wanted to stay inside, but itwas really getting dangerous for both of us because of the pressureon us. If we wanted to have an amazing birth together, itwould be worth for her to start making a move.That was the introduction, now for the story itself…Tuesday evening the contractions started. I only felt them inmy lower back. We went for a walk, I had a rest, communicatedwith my baby, told her how I was feeling <strong>and</strong> how proud I was ofher dealing so bravely with the situation <strong>and</strong> doing her part in ourshared “project”. A few hours later the contractions became moreregular – about every 10 minutes. One or two hours later again Ihad diarrhoea <strong>and</strong> the time between contractions came down toabout 4 to 6 minutes. Excitement kicked in, but I wanted to savemy strength for the birth. The back pain never stopped. I couldnot sit or lie down, only st<strong>and</strong> up. I stood in the shower <strong>and</strong> duringeach contraction Eric pressed on my pelvis. Knowing that thecontractions would be harder to deal with later on, I wanted Ericat least to get some sleep. I managed alone for 3 or 4 hours, thenwoke him up as the contractions got stronger. We decided it wastime to call our two birth companions. They arrived at ours <strong>and</strong>straight away the world looked much rosier. I felt all wrapped upin love – maternal, feminine <strong>and</strong> masculine. Those three were justincredible. I felt like the most beautiful, beloved <strong>and</strong> sanctifiedwoman in the world. I should probably mention our birth companionshad a lot of first-h<strong>and</strong> home birth experience. One is afriend with knowledge about using homoeopathy during pregnancy,labour <strong>and</strong> post-natally<strong>and</strong> the other my yoga teacher <strong>and</strong> a big supporter ofwomen’s right to give birth as they choose. Both went out of theirway to support me during the pregnancy <strong>and</strong> birth, after I askedthem. For me they are angels <strong>and</strong> I will always be thankful tothem.Dealing with the contractions was much easier than I thought.The only difficulty was the back pain, which remained throughout<strong>and</strong> made it impossible for me to relax between contractions,even for a second. I could not sit or lie down. I wanted to be onall fours in the birth pool, but also wanted to hold off until I wasdilated enough to prevent any risk of the pool slowing thingsdown. My waters broke <strong>and</strong> there was some meconium staining,as we had been told there probably would be. However, this waslight staining from old meconium (the community midwives laterconfirmed this), so we did not worry about it. Soon after that Ericcalled the community midwives. Two midwives arrived. Theychecked the baby’s pulse, which was fine. Everything looked fine,except that it was getting harder to deal with my back pain <strong>and</strong>exhaustion as I could not get even the shortest of breaks. Laterthe contractions got very close together. The midwives examinedme <strong>and</strong> told me I was fully dilated, so I got into the pool.My birth companions <strong>and</strong> Eric took turns pressing on mypelvis; I could not st<strong>and</strong> any interruption of this, even for a second.While one person was pressing on my pelvis, the secondwould be in the kitchen talking to the midwives <strong>and</strong> the third infront of me, encouraging me, breathing with me <strong>and</strong> giving me todrink. The fact that they took turns was good because it helpedme keep a sense of time, <strong>and</strong> because I could get a different kindof support <strong>and</strong> attention each time. During the contractions I didn’tthink about anything, I just let things happen <strong>and</strong> went withthe flow. I felt close to myself <strong>and</strong> to my baby. I never thought“when will it stop” or “how far dilated am I” – I just enjoyed thesupport, breathed <strong>and</strong> roared like an animal. Nadine’s suggestionto say “oooooopen” over <strong>and</strong> over again in a low voice reallyhelped me (Eric says: low voice – hmmm – sounded more likescreaming the house down to me J). I felt myself opening – a feelingof sanctity, of being close to God, to a higher force. I am allwoman, nothing else. I was born, <strong>and</strong> now I am giving birth.At some point I felt my body starting to push the baby out. Fora while I pushed hard, then my yoga teacher asked me if I feltsomething coming down <strong>and</strong> going back up. I didn’t, eventhough I pushed as hard as I could, without fighting it <strong>and</strong> withoutworrying about releasing any “solids” into the pool in front ofthe others. I felt that something was wrong. One of the midwiveschecked me again <strong>and</strong> told me that the baby’s head was tiltedbackwards <strong>and</strong> that’s what caused the back pain. She also said Iwas only 9cm dilated after all, <strong>and</strong> that the cervix was swollenaround the baby’s head. I had to hold back until I was fully dilated.I got into the knees-chest position to fight the urge to push,relieving the pressure of the baby’s head until I was ready. After awhile I couldn’t hold back <strong>and</strong> be in that position anymore. Thatwas the only thing I could not manage. Throughout the labour Iwas able to remain in tune with myself <strong>and</strong> with all of creation, tolisten to my body <strong>and</strong> do as it told me to, but now suddenly I hadto do the exact opposite! I just couldn’t do it. This was my weakpoint.The baby’s pulse was still fine, but the midwives talked more<strong>and</strong> more about transferring to hospital. (Eric says: I had a talkwith the midwives in the kitchen. They told me a part of the cervixwas still there, swelling <strong>and</strong> getting stretched out but not movingout of the way. They said it was possible to move it out of theway, but that they could not do this at home as the risk of serioushaemorrhage was too high. I asked what would happen ifwe stayed put with no medical intervention, <strong>and</strong> they answeredthat Yifat would probably get totally exhausted, or in the worstcase, end up with a ruptured uterus. That’s when I said fine, let’sgo back into the room <strong>and</strong> talk about transferring.) They lost theirconfidence <strong>and</strong> could no longer give me what I most needed –optimism. I was able to suppress 6 or 7 out of every 10 contractions,but the others got through. I became scared of hurtingmyself or my baby. The midwives said that an epidural wouldrelieve the urge to push. They called an ambulance <strong>and</strong> we wentinto hospital. Arriving there was horrible. Suddenly I was theguest, <strong>and</strong> they could decide who could be with me <strong>and</strong> whocouldn’t. Everyone talked about me being overdue, whichannoyed me <strong>and</strong> made it harder to fight the urge to push. I triedto ignore everything around me <strong>and</strong> visualise my baby. Ericseemed very worried <strong>and</strong> helpless. He held my h<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> tried toencourage me. They did not let our birth companions come intothe hospital room for about an hour. An interminable half hour later(or one hour after the decision to go to hospital) the anaesthesistarrived. After a lot of talk <strong>and</strong> jabbing around for veins in bothmy h<strong>and</strong>s to insert a drip, I got the epidural. An obstetricianchecked <strong>and</strong> confirmed that I was fully dilated <strong>and</strong> pushed mybaby’s head back. They put the monitor belts on <strong>and</strong> each time acontraction came they told me (I could not feel the contractionsafter the epidural) <strong>and</strong> I pushed as I had learned to before. After afew times my baby’s pulse started dipping <strong>and</strong> some amnioticfluid came out, stained with thick fresh meconium. At that pointthey gave up on the idea of a natural delivery <strong>and</strong> insisted onusing the forceps. They also stopped telling me when I had contractions.We went to the operating theatre. Only Eric was allowed tocome in with me. On the way to the theatre, Lyssa suggestedthat I talk to my baby <strong>and</strong> explain to her what was going on. Thathelped me a lot. I did not feel the actual delivery at all <strong>and</strong> thatwas quite sad for me.When the baby was born, they held her up for me to see for asecond <strong>and</strong> then took her off to resuscitation straight away. Ericwent with her, <strong>and</strong> the hospital staff agreed that Lyssa couldcome into the theatre now to be with me. That was absolutelyessential as I cannot possibly imagine staying behind alone insuch a situation. I had a feeling that everything was going to bealright, but I could hardly wait to hold my baby. Lyssa gave methe warmth <strong>and</strong> protection that I needed. After a while Eric6 birth&beyond


eturned with the baby on his arm, tears in his eyes <strong>and</strong> a bigsmile. He laid her down on me <strong>and</strong> was very excited each timeshe gave a cry. She looked around with curiosity. We went in toanother room <strong>and</strong> within a few minutes she started to feed – agreat joy for both of us to be re-united.Although it did not go exactly as we had wished, I now knowthat I can deal with labour without any drugs, <strong>and</strong> even enjoy it,given the right kind of environment <strong>and</strong> support. I know I did itdespite not getting even a second’srest for twenty hours. Iknow the different kinds of contractions<strong>and</strong> I know that nexttime around I will be able toexperience what I imagine to bethe most amazing part of all:pushing my baby out into thisworld. This experience hasstrengthened me a lot <strong>and</strong> gaveme more confidence <strong>and</strong> pridein myself, my baby <strong>and</strong> my husb<strong>and</strong>.I am planning to have mynext baby at home (<strong>and</strong> makesure that the midwives in attendancewill be more skilled). Ericsays: Other dads probably saythe same but you really can’timagine how proud I am of Yifat<strong>and</strong> our little baby daughter forhaving mastered this difficult situationso well. No really, youcan’t. I’ve always known thatYifat has a lot of strength in herEla southing herself.but in the event it still surprised me when it came out to the surface– especially once we got to the hospital <strong>and</strong> it became clearthat things were not going to go quite as we had hoped for. I alsocannot thank Lyssa <strong>and</strong> Nadine enough for all the support theygave us – that was just as important for me as for Yifat.More than a week past the NHS due date, I felt that Yifat wasgetting upset from the pressure to induce, so I decided to workfrom home until the birth. All that stress just because of somenumber on a piece of paper! We saw a number of different communitymidwives, two of which were much more supportive <strong>and</strong>underst<strong>and</strong>ing than the rest. Let’s give credit where credit isdue: Alison McWalter <strong>and</strong> Patricia Bell. You two are brilliant,thanks for everything.At the weekend we went to watch the fireworks that mark theend of the Festival, hoping that our baby would not be able toresist such a spectacular welcome – but she clearly had otherplans. When Yifat’s contractions did start it felt like somethingvery delicate, to be shielded <strong>and</strong> protected. We had unpluggedour phone <strong>and</strong> switched off our mobiles the day before <strong>and</strong> keptit that way, except for calling Lyssa <strong>and</strong> Nadine, <strong>and</strong> (deliberatelymuch later) the community midwives. The entire time we were athome was very comfortable <strong>and</strong> felt like a kind of celebration.Yifat was very alert. When she was in the pool, after st<strong>and</strong>ing upfor many hours <strong>and</strong> not having got much sleep, the midwiveswere holding a mirror into the water to check if they could see ahead coming out. They did not tell Yifat what they were doing,thinking she would not know what was going on behind her.What a mistake! “What do you see? Tell me!”, she said.Hospital was a different world. First we lost Lyssa <strong>and</strong> Nadinefor more than an hour. That meant it was no longer possible totake turns pressing on her back – the hospital midwives did notsee this as part of their job. Then there was the long wait for theepidural that was supposedly “ready for us” <strong>and</strong> going to solveour problems straight away. Ela’s heartbeat was fine throughout,but once the epidural was in, she became distressed <strong>and</strong> ourhopes for a “nearly natural” birth faded quickly. It was a series ofsetbacks. At the end all we wanted was just to avoid a caesarean.Yifat stopped being scared <strong>and</strong> became calm <strong>and</strong> collectedas she pushed Ela out, while the obstetrician turned her headaround with the forceps.When they carried Ela off to resuscitation, her body wasn’tblue, but her limbs were completely limp <strong>and</strong> she was not breathingat all. They put an oxygen mask onher <strong>and</strong> suctioned her airways. Someof the mucus was difficult to get outbecause it was so gooey. Once I wasallowed to touch her, I put my h<strong>and</strong>her stomach <strong>and</strong> started talking to herto encourage her. I think I was bawling<strong>and</strong> blabbering away like crazy. Ihave no idea how long we were inthere for <strong>and</strong> how much danger shewas actually in, but it seemed a longtime until she started breathing, <strong>and</strong>even she still needed extra oxygen forquite a while. Every little noise <strong>and</strong>movement she made was a hugerelief. Whenever she cries now, I’mhappy beyond words that she canscream so nice <strong>and</strong> strong! In casesomeone up there is listening: it wouldbe nice if I did not have to go throughanything like that again in my life.Having said that, being there was stillmuch better than being outside, notknowing what’s going on. Once Elahad started breathing, I asked one of the hospital midwives to letYifat know, <strong>and</strong> she told me she had already done it. That’s oneof the most thoughtful <strong>and</strong> considerate things any NHS persondid for us. I don’t remember this midwife’s name but she is very,very nice <strong>and</strong> I would like to thank her.After Ela had had her first feed they wanted to keep her in theneo-natal unit for observation. After some lengthy conversations,<strong>and</strong> with Ela looking increasingly healthy, we were able to keepher with us. However, soon after that they wanted to transferYifat to a shared room with three other mums where dads arenot allowed overnight. Yifat threatened to go home, with hercatheter still attached <strong>and</strong> all, unless they found a way for me tostay with her. We got some spiel about how there was a shortageof one-woman rooms, which was sadly lacking in truth – Iwent for a walk along the corridor <strong>and</strong> saw lots of empty rooms.In the end, someone probably bent some hospital rules <strong>and</strong> wegot a room to ourselves. Lyssa <strong>and</strong> Nadine left us to get somewell-deserved rest. Yifat was exhausted but she noticed straightaway that they had taken away the blue folder with our casenotes, which had been with us throughout the pregnancy <strong>and</strong>birth. We found out that the hospital keeps these <strong>and</strong> we’d haveto go through a whole complicated process just to get a copy.Why do people put up with this? As I write this, we still haven’treceived it <strong>and</strong> as a result there are a few details of the birth thatwe’re still not quite sure about.The night turned out to be a sleepless one for me as I keptchecking that Ela was breathing (<strong>and</strong> probably annoying her quitea bit in the process). Next day was one long struggle to get thecatheter taken out early, get all the checkups over with, get Elato feed, <strong>and</strong> generally get out of the hospital as soon as possible.I think we got home around 7 pm. What a relief!Ela is now nine weeks old <strong>and</strong> I still haven’t writtendown everything I wanted to say about her birth, so I guess Ibetter leave it here.Yifatbirth&beyond 7


<strong>Post</strong> <strong>Natal</strong> <strong>Depression</strong>4 women’s experiences: Jane’s storyThe following is an exerpt from SaraWickham's 2006 book, Midwifery:BestPractice, Volume 4 published byElsevier. The Best Practice series bringstogether some of the best publishedarticles from midwives <strong>and</strong> others fromthe midwifery journal, PractisingMidwife, along with some original work,including a chapter written by some ofthe women who run <strong>and</strong> who have usedthe centre entitled The Birth ResourceCentre: a Community of Women. SaraWickham’s site can be viewed atwww.withwoman.co.uk.For many years I suffered from severemental illness. I was suicidal <strong>and</strong> wouldregularly self-harm. I was offered beds inpsychiatric wards in three different healthauthorities as we travelled about the country;offers we never accepted.We wanted a child, so, contrary toadvice from the medical profession, weaccepted the so-called risks <strong>and</strong> decidedto start trying. I was approaching 35 yearsold <strong>and</strong> we felt we had wasted too muchtime simply waiting for me to get better. Icontinued to take medication for my illness,although we knew it was potentiallydangerous, but I think neither my husb<strong>and</strong>nor I believed I would ever become pregnant.It happened surprisingly quickly. I immediatelystopped taking the tablets, <strong>and</strong>wanted to know if taking medication for thefirst 3 weeks of my pregnancy could havecaused any problems. Nobody seemed toknow (or care).As I entered the second trimester, mymood began to sink lower <strong>and</strong> lower.Severe antenatal depression set in. I wasseeing a succession of different people formy antenatal appointments <strong>and</strong> care wasbased around the physical aspects ofpregnancy. How could I begin to unpackmy mental health history to a completestranger?Things became so bad that the GP <strong>and</strong>psychiatrist recommended that I go backon the medication. They believed my mentalstate was more threatening to myself<strong>and</strong> the baby than the risks of abnormalityfrom the drugs. With support from my husb<strong>and</strong>,I refused, although every day felt likea lifetime <strong>and</strong> I just wanted to escape frommy own mind.During this time I began attending NHSparenting classes. I will never forget thetone of the first class. It went like this: birthhurts, really hurts, this is what we can doabout it … drugs leaflet h<strong>and</strong>ed round.Someone asked about natural childbirth<strong>and</strong> was informed that only hardy, stalwartindividuals did that. At the end of the sessionI spoke to one of the midwives <strong>and</strong>explained a little of my situation. She suggestedI opt for a nice easy birth with anepidural, as traumatic birth has beenshown to increase the risk of postnataldepression. This made sense to me <strong>and</strong> Idecided to take the advice.I did discover at these sessions thathealth visitors were available to supportwomen antenatally. No one had offered meanything other than drugs before. This wasto be my turning point. My health visitorhad previously worked as a midwife <strong>and</strong>gave me a whole afternoon of her timeevery two weeks. When I was 26 weekspregnant, she brought me a flyer for theBirth Resource Centre. “I think you shoulddo some classes here,” she said. “Theyoga would be good for you, I think itwould help.”Nervously, I called the number <strong>and</strong>began to attend class every Wednesdaymorning. At each class we began byintroducing ourselves, then we performedgentle yoga-based exercises <strong>and</strong> relaxation,as our facilitator gently told us to listento our bodies, do what felt right, <strong>and</strong>tune in to our babies. After this, we had tea<strong>and</strong> talk. Someone in the class usually hada question, an issue to discuss or a parentingbook they had read, <strong>and</strong> we learnedfrom each other while the facilitator skilfully<strong>and</strong> imperceptibly deepened knowledge ordispelled myths. Women who had givenbirth returned to show off their babies <strong>and</strong>tell their stories. They were eagerly questioned<strong>and</strong> their experiences added to ourknowledge.Gradually I realised that I was relaxed<strong>and</strong> happy during these classes. I wasParenting?Pregnant?In the everyday course of events, we get on with life without needingprofessional assistance, however, things come up which can de-spiritor disorientate us, resulting in feelings of helplessness or hopelessness<strong>and</strong> we can “get stuck” or feel trapped.Sometimes the changes women experience around the time ofpregnancy or while parenting can be unexpected <strong>and</strong>/or frightening.From my experience as a mother, midwife <strong>and</strong> counsellor I have foundthat talking to someone who underst<strong>and</strong>s can help.I have been meeting women at the centre since January last year .My approach is based on Personal Construct Psychology (PCP),a practical <strong>and</strong> optimistic psychology which involves finding out howpeople make sense of their personal world. I work to build up apicture of each person <strong>and</strong> how life is from where they are st<strong>and</strong>ing.From there we can work together to see how things might beimproved.I welcome anyone who is experiencing distress of any kind at thistime. Those who come to see me may have as many or as fewsessions as seems apppropriate, there is no need to commit to comingfor a fixed number of sessions.For more information,please call Jo or Jenny on 229 36 67or Jenny can be contacted by email tocounselling@birthresourcecentre.org.uk8 birth&beyond


eginning to trust my body <strong>and</strong> my baby,<strong>and</strong> it was then that I realised that anepidural as first resort would not be rightfor me. I had learned of the risks associatedwith epidurals: how could I spendmonths trying to protect my baby to thenexpose him to unnecessary intervention?With this revelation came the need tobirth in an environment where natural birthwas supported <strong>and</strong> valued. Our maternityhospital had a normal delivery unit staffedonly by midwives. I spoke to my GP <strong>and</strong>said I wanted to be booked there. I wasinformed I was too old <strong>and</strong> I could have anormal delivery on the main labour ward.With my newfound confidence I phonedthe normal delivery unit myself. I spoke toa midwife who said she would be delightedto book me there. With my husb<strong>and</strong>’sfull support <strong>and</strong> belief in my ability to birthmy baby, I began to feel calmer <strong>and</strong>, asforty weeks approached, I felt serene,powerful <strong>and</strong> whole.My labour was calm <strong>and</strong> beautiful. Icouldn’t stop smiling as I welcomed eachcontraction. We were really going to havea baby. We drove to the hospital <strong>and</strong>, inthe normal delivery unit, with soft lights <strong>and</strong>a single midwife, I travelled to my innermostbeing <strong>and</strong> birthed our first baby inconsciousness <strong>and</strong> strength.And the power of this glorious birth hasachieved what no doctor could. I now havethree beautiful children <strong>and</strong> have neversince taken any medication for mental illness.The BRC was crucial, in that I would nothave had that birth without the BRC, <strong>and</strong>without it it’s impossible to predict whatwould have happened. I feel that I’ve gotmy whole family to thank the BRC for. Thesupport I had from the BRC compared tothe support I had from the system washuge. It helped my relationship with mybaby, with my husb<strong>and</strong>, with my whole life.This community of women has alwaysbeen there for me, validating me <strong>and</strong>valuing me.Jane CreweLeslie’s story (not her real name)My second child was born onto my bedroom floor in her bagof waters. We stared in disbelief for a few precious moments -below the silvery skin of the amniotic sac a little face smiledserenely, buddha like. The midwife pierced the membranes <strong>and</strong>passed me my baby - a daughter. Suddenly the calm vanished asour little one roared her first roar <strong>and</strong> my sister entered the room,jaw dropping in complete shock that a baby had arrived <strong>and</strong> droppingan armful of equipment - that was never needed - to the floorwith a clatter.After such a swift <strong>and</strong> easy labour <strong>and</strong> peaceful birth whocould have predicted what followed? The days following the birthwere as any new mum would experience; highs <strong>and</strong> lows,although looking back I see some subtle differences to my firstpostpartum experience. The day after the night she was born Ispent resting, but after that I refused to stay in bed <strong>and</strong> I rememberfeeling irritated to the point of distraction by the clutter <strong>and</strong>mess that built up around me. I was furious at those around mefor not seeing the dust <strong>and</strong> dirt. I was angry <strong>and</strong> dismissivetowards those who suggested I might forget about the houseworkas I had just given birth. I had expected a boy <strong>and</strong> althoughI was thrilled to have a little girl I cried bitterly for the boy I felt Ihad somehow lost. I didn't want any visitors, <strong>and</strong> I resented thepresence of anyone who had "just popped in" or any arrangementsthat were made to have people in.Breastfeeding was the first really big low. I had breastfed myfirst child for 10 months but I had experienced incredibly sore,cracked <strong>and</strong> bleeding nipples for the first 8 weeks....... it graduallybecame apparent that this time would be no different. My angerengulfed me. had been so sure that feeding would go smoothlythis time <strong>and</strong> I just couldn't underst<strong>and</strong> it. I searched the faces ofthose I knew loved me <strong>and</strong> begged the midwives for answers butnobody could tell me what was going wrong. I ploughed on, <strong>and</strong>felt as if I was wrestling some terrible beast to be able to bondwith my child. love flowed easily when I held <strong>and</strong> cuddled her<strong>and</strong> the connection was deep when I looked into her eyes butevery time she cried for a feed my body tensed up, I cried in anticipationof the pain <strong>and</strong> I had to resist a mild feeling of resentment.Whilst feeding became established <strong>and</strong> I accepted the difficultieswould go in time, at about 3 weeks postpartum I realised thatmy anxiety levels were shooting through the roof <strong>and</strong> that I wasincreasingly feeling more sensitive about certain issues. My eldestwas reacting badly to the arrival of a sibling <strong>and</strong> I was convincedthat this was my fault. I hadn't prepared my child for this; I was abad mother. I wasn't h<strong>and</strong>ling the situation well; I was a badmother. I resented my eldest child for making it difficult to havespace <strong>and</strong> time with my baby <strong>and</strong> I resented my baby for changingmy relationship with my firstborn forever;I was a bad mother.For around six months I hid my terrible thoughts from thosearound me, <strong>and</strong> I became very insular. It was a dark grey place. Ilost touch with friends <strong>and</strong> aquaintances <strong>and</strong> stopped going out.I was less anxious about life if I felt I was in my own environment<strong>and</strong> so it became unusual for me to venture very far. So we all buthibernated;myself, my toddler <strong>and</strong> my baby. Everyday my heartsank as my partner left for work <strong>and</strong> I knew I another day layahead of trying to keep a lid on my feelings of anxiety <strong>and</strong> depression.I was plagued by tension headaches.Then one day, it was like I saw myself from the outside, <strong>and</strong> Icried all day at what I saw. I realised how low I had become <strong>and</strong> Ihated myself for it, the final layer of anxiety was an over-ridingfeeling of guilt at the damage I might be doing to my children.I recognised many of the symptoms of depression, but I wasinitially unable to admit that what I was suffering had anything todo with the postnatal period. I visited my GP with my own diagnosis- a thyroid condition. She agreed to test my thyroid levelsbut gently floated the idea that I might have postnatal depression.When the results came back they were borderline, she asked meto return in 6 months for another test but said nothing more onany other subject. One month later I went to my health vistor totell her I wasn't sure I was coping <strong>and</strong> might be depressed. Shereassured me that I was a great mum <strong>and</strong> I was doing fine. Shedidn't listen. She offered me fortnightly visits which I declined as Icouldn't see how that would help.Around this time I began to have very vivid dreams <strong>and</strong> daydreamswhich were so real, almost like hallucinations. I saw myselfbeing hurt <strong>and</strong> dying <strong>and</strong> one particular image which stays withme to this day was me swinging from the ceiling. I didn't reallywant to hurt myself or die but on some subconcious level thesedreams <strong>and</strong> images existed <strong>and</strong> were terrifying. I began to searchfor help.It was in an issue of Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond that I found the numberfor the <strong>Post</strong>natal <strong>Depression</strong> Project, I had no idea what to expectbut I rang up <strong>and</strong> asked for some information. What came in thepost was a breakthrough - a leaflet listing the symptoms for PND.I was astounded, relieved <strong>and</strong> pretty horrifed to be ticking everybirth&beyond 9


ox on that list. I called the number for my nearest centre (theyhave 3) the next day <strong>and</strong> made an arrangement to come along<strong>and</strong> chat to someone.9 months after the birth of my daughter I was finally able totalk to somebody who understood my feelings <strong>and</strong> experiences.It was like the floodgates had opened <strong>and</strong> I cried with relief <strong>and</strong>gratitude - some of the feelings of lonliness <strong>and</strong> isolation <strong>and</strong>much of my paranoia began to unfold <strong>and</strong> recede almost immediatlelywhen I realised that 1 in 10 women struggle with PND. Afteran initial assessment it was suggested I have one to one counsellingonce a week, my children would be cared for by the crecheprovided by the project. One of the most important things I wantto get across is that you can self refer to the project as I did. Nohealth professional offered me details of the fact that thisresource existed <strong>and</strong> I can't help but wonder why <strong>and</strong> feel slightlyaggrieved. How many women are ignored, offered antidepressantsor become seriously ill without being given the informationor help that could change their lives?It took a long time for me to feel completely better, almost ayear, but I will be forever deeply grateful to the wonderful womanwho listened <strong>and</strong> helped me work through my illness. The<strong>Post</strong>natal <strong>Depression</strong> Project saved my life.LeslieA personal viewOf late I've noticed these drug advertisementsthat pop up on Yahoo. There's apicture of a woman looking sadly off intothe distance, silhouetted against a darkbackground. Who suffers from depression?I think the ad asks, <strong>and</strong> as you readthis, her children giving her a worried lookfade into the background. That's me, lostin a circle of worries, sadnesses, until myolder child brings me round with a start,repeating the question he's asked <strong>and</strong>looking at me with that particular look ofworry that I don't want to settle on hisshoulders.It's funny, friends every now <strong>and</strong> then,when I've confided I am going to art therapysessions, sidle into the conversationtheir curiosity. In one way or another theywant to know what the symptoms are.How do you I qualify to be postnatallydepressed? I wish it were as tangible aspurple spots. That way I could definitelychart my progress. Instead of definitelyfeeling better, definitely feeling my bounceback, telling friends confidently so, findingthe coincidence of a few stressful factorsbrings that confidence crashing downaround my ears. It's worrying, the implausibility,the unbelievability of this fragility.I'm filling out job applications now <strong>and</strong>wonder if I'm lying when I fail to acknowledgethe status of my mental health problem.I don't know how, but oddly it is gettingbetter. The one year anniversary of B'sbirth <strong>and</strong> I did feel a mile marker, like I hadmore of my brain back, was more solidlyknitted together. Watching him st<strong>and</strong> at adistance from me, having walked there byhimself, some of me I've been straining togive him recedes back into myself, rests,becomes part of my reserves again. Iguess the one metaphor I have is that of aflower. When you give birth you open uplike the flowers of a petal. But flowersdon't have to pull themselves back intobuds. It's as if all the extended petals didn'tfold back in properly, some got bentout the wrong way <strong>and</strong> were left exposed,the others crumpled badly <strong>and</strong> don'tst<strong>and</strong> together properly.When I'm sad, it's not purely aboutthis. All the past wounds <strong>and</strong> hurts, theyare what I dwell on, what I wear day in dayout, what I can't see beyond, what I can'tbelieve myself beyond.But it is getting better. I've painted <strong>and</strong>scratched <strong>and</strong> scribbled some anger,some hurt, some opening out <strong>and</strong> closingin, drawing concentric circles until theyseem real, seem like they will hold. Andspring has happened. I've taken somerisks <strong>and</strong> been rewarded, done somework <strong>and</strong> been acknowledged, watchedmy children playing together, playing taground <strong>and</strong> round <strong>and</strong> round me sitting inthe middle smiling, glad to be able just towatch.I would never want my children to readthis <strong>and</strong> know I'd written it. How differentthan most of the birth stories I've read inthese newsletters! But there may besomeone else out there who will read thisdisjointedness <strong>and</strong> recognise it, feel recognisedwithin. If it helps lift just one layer ofa shadow, lessens the feeling of beingalone by one degree, then it's worth it.When I told my health visitor howdeflated I'd felt by some of the mum <strong>and</strong>baby groups I'd been to – how better kittedout <strong>and</strong> able to cope all the othermums seemed to be, she told me, butthey'll be feeling just the same inside. Iwonder .....AnonFiona’s story:A personal account <strong>and</strong> what helpedI suffered from postnatal depression (PND) after the birth of myfirst child in 2000. She was a much wanted child, <strong>and</strong> my pregnancywas the most exciting <strong>and</strong> special time of my life, yet soonafter her birth, I began to experience a whole raft of unpleasantfeelings. I often felt low <strong>and</strong> exhausted, I felt I was a bad motheras my baby cried a lot, I desperately wanted to run away <strong>and</strong> Ifound it hard to be alone with her. It worsened at 6 months as Istopped breastfeeding, when insomnia kicked in <strong>and</strong> I foundmyself increasingly unable to cope. I was put on Prozac, <strong>and</strong> whileit helped with my sleeping, it made me worse in many ways, asmy anxiety levels soared <strong>and</strong> my mind wheeled from one terriblescenario to the next.While my GP was good in many ways, I found her unhelpful inher impatience at my difficulty in coming to terms with the label ofmental illness <strong>and</strong> my slow road out of denial about it. It had takena huge amount of courage to start taking antidepressants <strong>and</strong>I needed more underst<strong>and</strong>ing as I struggled to cope with what itmeant for me. Looking back, she also failed to realise that while10 birth&beyond


the medication helped with my most difficult symptom, inability tosleep, it had heightened my anxieties, <strong>and</strong> overall my mental statewas not really improving.I have no doubt that this is a problem with the system ratherthan the individual doctor, as my depression was being dealt within a 10 minute appointment once a month in the middle of a busysurgery. This time constraint means that the pressure is to simplywrite a prescription for the most likely looking drug, <strong>and</strong> there isno time to explore the issues or to go deeper with someone whois putting a brave face on things.I reached crisis point one lunchtime when my daughter wastwo, when I considered methods of suicide <strong>and</strong> had reached apoint of near collapse. Amongst it all, my mind was functioningon two separate levels. While it seemed that my mind was fragmenting,there was a core of clear thinking which made me pickup the phone, <strong>and</strong> call for help. My husb<strong>and</strong> came home, a differentGP came out to see me at home <strong>and</strong> at last the mechanismsfor real help were activated.I was put on a different drug, Venlafaxine. Use of this is nowrestricted as there is a concern about heart disease, but I think itsaved my life. I was given a community psychiatric nurse (CPN),given sources to find counselling, <strong>and</strong> referred for cognitivebehaviour therapy. At this time my daughter started a part- timenursery place, <strong>and</strong> this gave me space for myself which I had nothad in 2 years, <strong>and</strong> also gave me the time to go to counselling,which I did every week for a year.Life changed its course at this point. I had had the unerringsupport of my husb<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> of friends. The constant help <strong>and</strong>support of one close friend in particular I will never forget; shehelped me through the darkest days when I was exhaustedbeyond belief <strong>and</strong> could not be alone. However, I was at a pointwhere I needed professional help, <strong>and</strong> this at last I received.My health visitor came round several times, <strong>and</strong> though shewas a kind lady <strong>and</strong> tried to help, she was much better at talkingthan listening, <strong>and</strong> overall I found her visits exhausting.My CPN, on the other h<strong>and</strong>, was a great help. He visited meevery week to begin with, then fortnightly, <strong>and</strong> seemed happy tolisten to whatever I wanted to talk about, as well as making mefeel that what was happening to me was really very ordinary. Thismatter-of-factness, compared to the hushed, concerned tones ofsome other people, helped me to feel normal, <strong>and</strong> his sense ofhumour was a relief.My counsellor, at Wellspring in Leith, was wonderful, giving mea weekly space to cry, to rail at the world, to talk. She helped meexplore all the issues that were seething below the surface forme, utterly non-judgemental <strong>and</strong> sensitive, but once I had madeprogress, firm in her refusal to let me slip backwards again. I knewit was time to stop when I simply ran out of things I wanted to talkto her about.This counselling is not available on the NHS, <strong>and</strong> cost £35 perweek, though Wellspring is a charity <strong>and</strong> offers reduced rates forthose needing them. I needed therapy then, <strong>and</strong> not 6 monthslater, which is when my NHS referral for cognitive behaviour therapycame through. I decided not to have it then as I had a goodongoing relationship with my counsellor, but have had some at alater date. It was helpful in dealing with specific issues, but what Ineeded back in 2002 was some in-depth counselling, <strong>and</strong> that iswhat Wellspring offered me.Antidepressants are a very useful part of the overall picture,but there is a tendency to use them in isolation for so manywomen with PND, as resources are so stretched, <strong>and</strong> drugs areeasy <strong>and</strong> cheap compared to hours of talking therapy. However,it strikes me as sad that it is necessary for a crisis to be reachedbefore there is even a mention that there is more help possiblethat just taking the tablets. PND is part of a health visitor’s remit,but how good they are seems so variable, <strong>and</strong> I wonder just howmuch training they receive in this sensitive area. There is no substitutefor skilled psychiatric specialists <strong>and</strong> counsellors, <strong>and</strong> thereis a real need for these to be more widely available.Fiona ArmstrongBoth Wellspring <strong>and</strong> the Birth Resource Centre offer affordablecounselling. Wellspring can be contacted on 0131 553 6660 orhttp://www.wellspring-scotl<strong>and</strong>.co.uk/Contact Jo or Jenny at the Birth Resource Centre 0131 229 3667or If you would prefer to contact Jenny directly, you can e mail herat counselling@birthresourcecentre.org.uk.Independent Midwivesin Lothian/BordersNatasha McDonald<strong>and</strong> Carrie McIntoshProviding holistic, one-to-one midwifery carethroughout the ante-natal period, birth <strong>and</strong>postnatal up to six weeks.We provide continuity of care for women <strong>and</strong>their families wishing to birth at home <strong>and</strong> arehappy to facilitate water birth.Please contact us to dicscuss your needs:We Natasha: 01875 818858/ 07812155248Carrie: 07890 842514,www.mcmidwives.co.ukBirth ConsultancyDoula Preparation~ embracing the spirituality of childbirth ~pregnancy nurtureconscious birthpositive parentingAdela Stocktonwww.birthconsultancy.orgadela@birthconsultancy.org01387-740356birth&beyond 11


Copyright www.caesarean.org.ukAftershocksDebbie Chippington Derrick, who had a HWBA3C (home water birthafter 3 caesareans), shares the emotions that hit her after the birth ofher niece. This article first appeared in AIMS Journal Volume 19 No 1 2007.Yesterday my brother’s partner gave birthto their daughter in their own home, <strong>and</strong>my brother texted me from his bed lyingnext to his sleeping daughter. I shouldhave been able to receive this news withpure joy, but I am finding it impossible toaccess that joy through the tears <strong>and</strong>anguish that I have been left with from myown births.I cycled to school with my beautifulHWBA3C son, his long hair streamingbehind him on this beautiful windy morning,but my view of this was hazy as thetears streamed down my face, not thetears of joy for the new baby that hasarrived in our family, but my tears of sorrow,my own self pity; self pity that I trulyresent.It is nearly 21 years ago that mydaughter, my first baby, was born; whatshould have been a purely joyous event,but has been permanently marred by theinept <strong>and</strong> over medical mess that is ourmaternity service. My two eldest son’sbirths were hideous, when they couldhave been beautiful. Even my triumph of aHWBA3C, over 11 years ago, a reallygood birth, certainly in comparison tomost births, was not what it should havebeen because of the impact of medicineon birth. I want to scream out for whatshould have been.This morning I have been brought backto wanting to go <strong>and</strong> see every personthat was involved with causing me thistrauma; the midwife that would not supportthe home birth I wanted with mydaughter all those years ago; those thatlied to me <strong>and</strong> told me I could not have ahomebirth after a section; that I wouldhave a better chance of a VBAC if I wasinduced when I went more than 10 dayspast 40 weeks; <strong>and</strong> the stream of peoplewho physically interfered with me in thename of medicine. I want these people<strong>and</strong> others to know the impact of whatthey do to women during pregnancy <strong>and</strong>birth, these effects last a lifetime, they arenot something that I will get over, this issomething that will continue to come backto haunt me.I am left to think what a mess I wouldbe now if I had not given birth to my thirdson, my fourth baby, if I had been connedinto further totally unnecessary surgery. Istruggle to contemplate how I would havecoped with never having given birth, neverhaving pushed a baby from my body,the way I should have done all four times.There is a lot of talk about treating birthtrauma, but that only helps you to live withthat trauma, for it not to dominate yourlife; it does not take it away. The wrongsthat have been done to me can’t be putright. Yes, helping those who have sufferedbirth trauma is crucial, so that peoplelike me can put their lives back together,perhaps not the way that they shouldhave been, but in a way that they are happywith most of the time. However, theonly way to fully address birth trauma isto stop it happening in the first place.<strong>Post</strong>script: I am lucky that I havelearned how to defuse these emotionswhen they hit me. I know that writingabout what I felt was therapeutic <strong>and</strong> I amprivileged to have the support of manyother women that underst<strong>and</strong> what I havebeen through; sadly many of them underst<strong>and</strong>because they have experienced thesame trauma. I am also fortunate to havefamily that have taken the time to underst<strong>and</strong>,which has not been easy for themeither. I was able to access support <strong>and</strong>pour out my emotions, this allowed me topull myself out of this emotional pit withinhours, something that I know I could nothave done alone.Debbie’s account of her three caesareans <strong>and</strong>her HWBA3C, Perseverance Pays,was published in the AIMS JOURNAL,VOL 8,NO 1, SPRING 1996.Benig Mauger discusses healing <strong>and</strong> loss of soul in childbirthWounded MothersA difficult birth often resultsin emotional wounding inboth mother <strong>and</strong> baby.Such ‘soul’ wounds are oftenoverlooked.‘The contractions suddenly came non-stop <strong>and</strong> I had no chanceto catch up <strong>and</strong> adjust to the excruciating waves of pain. I panicked<strong>and</strong> just could not stop screaming, <strong>and</strong> then when the babygot stuck I heard them say, “Get the forceps,cut her!” It felt like an attack.Afterwards, there was blood everywhereas if a murder had taken place.’Having a baby can be experiencedas a deep trauma as the words ofthis mother testify. She felt violated,demeaned <strong>and</strong> disempowered. It wasn’tthat giving birth was the problem; itwas rather that she felt traumatised byhow she was treated during her childbirth experience. My bookSongs from the Womb tells many women’s birth stories; theymake harrowing reading. Following such a birth, Emma had flashbacks<strong>and</strong> nightmares. When no one listened, she gradually withdrewinto a world of her own. She gained a child, but she suffereda devastating soul wound.A difficult birth often results in emotionalwounding in both mother <strong>and</strong> baby.Such ‘soul’ wounds are often overlookedbecause we have been taughtthat having a baby is a potentially hazardousphysical experience to be managedby medical professionals. If weemerge from the experience, relativelyphysically intact, with a healthy baby,then we have no cause to complain. Butmany of us do. Soul wounds can take years to heal. In our modernbirthing practice, preoccupation with the physical aspects ofchildbirth can mean overlooking the emotional, particularly the12 birth&beyond


negative psychological effects of highly medicalised births. Theinevitable focus is on making sure that a healthy baby is deliveredof a healthy mother. The medicalised management of childbirth<strong>and</strong> our technological advances are designed to make our liveseasier, but is there a cost?I believe there is. Technology, last time I looked, has no soul.Neither does the medical institution, which is based on the divisionof mind <strong>and</strong> body <strong>and</strong> has turned birth form a natural eventinto a technological feat. And since, as human beings, we aremade up of body <strong>and</strong> soul, mind <strong>and</strong> matter, <strong>and</strong> so much more,how can technology or medicine ever even come near to underst<strong>and</strong>ingthe mystery of modern life?Soul wounds are part of life <strong>and</strong> can propel us into healingpainful experiences necessary to our spiritual growth. Indeed thisis often what happens when a birth wound is activated. Theexperience of childbirth in this way can be a catalyst for healing.However, in an age where the same technological advances haveshown us that the unborn baby is a conscious, feeling being, anunderst<strong>and</strong>ing of this does not lessen each person’s responsibilityin ensuring the incoming soul of a warm, loving welcome. Thepsychological impact not only of birth but also prenatal life is welldocumented by now. From research <strong>and</strong> studies in ante <strong>and</strong> perinatalpsychology we know that not only what happens in thewomb <strong>and</strong> at birth, but also at conception, is grafted into the psycheof the child, creating patterns that are carried into later life (1).And if the mother feels wounded, so does her child. No doubtbeing catapulted into life at 32 weeks in a traumatic way hadsome part to play in leading me to study psychology <strong>and</strong> writemy first book Songs from the womb. This experience informedme so that as a mother, antenatal teacher <strong>and</strong> later as a therapist,I was acutely aware of women’s disillusionment with themedical management of childbirth. Knowing the unborn <strong>and</strong>newborn baby’s exquisite sensitivity meant questioning some ofthe practices that have become the norm in hospitals.People ask me, “Why is it so vital that women experience agood birth?” The answer is simple. Birth is a child’s initiation intolife <strong>and</strong> giving birth is every woman’s birthright. The desire to havea good birth experience is so basic as to be archetypal, whichmeans it is in our nature. So that when this doesn’t happen, itcan have devastating consequences, with both the mother <strong>and</strong>her baby bearing long lasting psychological scars.At the same time that I was involved in childbirth, I discoveredthe work of Swiss psychologist Carl Jung. He talked about ‘lossof soul’ <strong>and</strong> described it as a spiritual malaise afflicting modernman. He believed that in many ways we have become alienatedfrom our archetypal natures. Archetypal patterns possess a numinousenergy that exercises a strong influence on our lives. Denialof the archetypal dimension puts us off -kilter. Giving birth <strong>and</strong>being born are archetypal experiences of great spiritual <strong>and</strong> emotionalsignificance. However, modern medicine strips nature of itsspiritual dimension, dismissing soul <strong>and</strong> wounding mothers <strong>and</strong>babies. When a birth is experiences in this way, it can propelwomen into trying again in an effort to ‘get it right this time’.Birth is a soul experience that for many of us is potentially profoundlyhealing <strong>and</strong> transformative. Most women want to experiencethe birth of their child as a fulfilling, joyous <strong>and</strong> creative act.Again, this is archetypal <strong>and</strong> universal. All too often this is deniedthem, since the psychological <strong>and</strong> spiritual dimensions of the birthprocess are largely unacknowledged.In my therapy room I see bruised, depressed <strong>and</strong> traumatisedwomen, battling to come to terms with an experience that falls farshort of what birthing their babies should have been. Thesewomen are wounded mothers. Often the hurt they experienceduring the birth of their child touches on other hurts from the past,which formerly lay hidden in their unconscious, or in the darkestcorners of their hearts. They are wounded because instead ofexperiencing joy in the birth of new life, they feel pain. Depressed,they may find it hard to feel love for their child or others close tothem. Or they may feel love, but it will be tinged with pain.Healing birth wounds is essential to recover a sense of innerwholeness <strong>and</strong> most particularly to create fulfilling <strong>and</strong> empoweringbirth experiences in the future.How can we heal birth wounds?We should remember that there is a collective as well as a personaldimension to human experience so that in healing the personalwe also heal the collective. We should also remember thateach person’s experience is unique to them <strong>and</strong> that each healingprocess is different. In the personal section (below), I have outlinedmy therapeutic approach, which most women have foundeffective in helping them heal from such birth wounds.On the collective level:We must empower pregnant women <strong>and</strong> return birth to parentswhere it belongs. Pregnant women, taught that birth is a technologicalfeat to be managed by professionals, are often disempowered<strong>and</strong> alienated from their innate, instinctive ability to give birth.We must restore full choices in childbirth so that women cangive birth according to the dictates of their bodies. We need tofree the instinctive feminine.Healing the collective mother wound means reclaiming thefeminine in our culture so that childbirth is perceived <strong>and</strong> manageddifferently. It means reinstating the neglected <strong>and</strong> woundedmother archetype.On a personal level:Healing means listening to the lost voice of your soul. Be preparedto listen to your soul needs. Working therapeutically meansgiving voice <strong>and</strong> form to the unconscious by writing, recording ofdreams, painting, movement, telling your story to others, <strong>and</strong> havingit heard (therapy).Take responsibility for your healing process. Take your health<strong>and</strong> well-being into your own h<strong>and</strong>s. Although anger towardsthose who you consider to be the perpetrators is appropriate,remaining a victim to it will imprison you.Remember that what you don’t feel you can’t heal. Your willingnessto suffer <strong>and</strong> endure the wound will bring you, in time, tohealing. Try <strong>and</strong> clear a previous birth wound before giving birthagain. If pregnant, dialogue with your baby; remember <strong>and</strong> holdto your heart the amazing resilience of the human spirit in the faceof adversity. Keep your heart open <strong>and</strong> trust that your soul knowsthe way.When you come to give birth again, trust your inner wisdom<strong>and</strong> choose your place of birth carefully.When we underst<strong>and</strong> our birthing challenges as spiritual tasksof empowerment, it both heals <strong>and</strong> frees us. Healing will happenwhen there is an awareness of the emotional <strong>and</strong> spiritual significanceof the birth experience. When birth attendants realise <strong>and</strong>honour both the exquisite sensitivity of the unborn <strong>and</strong> the sacreddimension of giving birth, <strong>and</strong> combine technology with soul, wewill have a new model of birth, empowered yet vulnerable.This Article first appeared in AIMS Journal Vol.19 No.1, 2007Reference1. Raphael-Leff, Psychological Processes of Childbearing in Mauger, B.,Healing the Wounded Mother P.70.Benig Mauger is a Jungian Psychotherapist, writer, lecturer <strong>and</strong> pioneerin ante <strong>and</strong> perinatal psychology. She has a private practice, teaches <strong>and</strong>runs workshops internationally. Benig is also author of Songs from theWomb – Healing the Wounded Mother <strong>and</strong> Reclaiming Father –The Search for Wholeness in Men, Women <strong>and</strong> Children.For more information, please view: www.soul-connections.combirth&beyond 13


My Experience of <strong>Post</strong> <strong>Traumatic</strong> <strong>Stress</strong> Disorder (PTSD) after ChildbirthMichelle Barnes<strong>Post</strong> <strong>Traumatic</strong> <strong>Stress</strong> (PTS) is a set of normal reactions to atraumatic experience. Reactions such as dizziness, feeling faint,elevated blood pressure, feeling numb or dreamlike, fear, denial,irritability, anxiety, intense anger with self or others, poor decisionmaking, panic attacks, intrusive thoughts, flashbacks, tearfulness/emotionaloutbursts, sleep problems, <strong>and</strong> reluctance to talkabout the event or wanting to talk about it all the time etc.Sometimes stress reactions appear immediately after theevent, sometimes days, months or even years later. Only if thesesymptoms persist for more than a month is it referred to as a disorder<strong>and</strong> called PTSD. The Birth Trauma Association(www.birthtraumaassociation.org.uk) provides support <strong>and</strong> adviceto women with PTSD after child birth. With underst<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>and</strong>support stress reactions have been found to pass more quickly.After the birth of my son in September 2003 at times it felt likeI was going mad. I have since discovered that PTSD is a psychologicalphenomenon, <strong>and</strong> an emotional condition, from which it ispossible to make a full <strong>and</strong> complete recovery. I was not goingmad but I did require specialised help.Unfortunately, giving birth turned into an event that shatteredmy deeply held beliefs about hospitals being safe <strong>and</strong> benevolent.The months that followed were the worst of my life whenthey should have been the best.Following a traumatic, potentially life threatening event thebody is in chaos. It takes some time for the brain to accept thatthe danger has passed. It took months for me to accept that myson wasn’t going to die <strong>and</strong> over 2 years to discover that he wasnever in danger in the first place. It was like a dark cloud washanging over me <strong>and</strong> I was worried <strong>and</strong> anxious about everything.I heard fireworks outside <strong>and</strong> it filled me with dread, I couldn’teven watch television <strong>and</strong> had to keep turning the sound down.I was obsessed with good hygiene <strong>and</strong> became tense <strong>and</strong> onedge if visitors came <strong>and</strong> wanted to hold him. Even though I wantedto protect him I was unable to bond with him because myemotions were numb. I lost my appetite <strong>and</strong> people even commentnow on how quickly I lost weight. Everyday it felt like I wastaking one step forward <strong>and</strong> two steps back, the smallest taskwas a struggle.By the time the Health Visitors came I was too scared to sayanything because I felt that bad I truly believed I might have to goback into hospital, or that they might try to take my baby awayfrom me.Luckily <strong>and</strong> not uncommonly the severe symptoms spontaneouslysubsided after a couple of months. I have sincecherished every moment with my precious little boy <strong>and</strong> the bondwe have is truly amazing. Luckily I found AIMS <strong>and</strong> through themthe Vaginal Birth after Caesarean E-Group http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/ukvbachbac/. Both have given me the muchneeded information, emotional support <strong>and</strong> encouragement tohave another baby.I am currently working with a local Maternity Forum Group <strong>and</strong>Sheffield Maternity Services Liaison Committee. I <strong>and</strong> another ladywho suffered PTSD are lobbying to get the Trust to provide PTSDpsychological support. We hope that if the Trust is made to payto repair the damage they’ve caused they might start to look attrauma prevention as a more cost effective solution. I am also inthe process of writing a book about PTSD after child birth. I amhoping to raise awareness of this serious condition of anxiety, <strong>and</strong>ensure women get the immediate help they so desperately needafter a traumatic birth. For further information or to make a contributionplease email: mmmbarnes@blueyonder.co.ukFor further information, support <strong>and</strong> self-help in surviving traumavisit www.traumatic-stress.freeserve.co.uk.AIMS Journals available from www.aims.org.ukJournal Vol 19,No 1 - Birth TraumaIn this Journal - Guest EditorsMichelle Barnes <strong>and</strong> SarahStenson introduce this issue,Jean Robinson asks 'Where dowe go from here?', Michelle talksabout her PTSD after childbirth<strong>and</strong> her emotionally healing secondbirth, <strong>and</strong> Sarah tells us why'disappointment' trivialises theimpact of traumatic birth whilstMavis Kirkham in 'TraumatisedMidwives' discusses why mothersare not the only casualties ofthe system£3.00Journal Vol 18,No 2 - BreastfeedingIn this Journal - BeverleyBeech reviews the uphill battle tobreastfeed in a modern society,we report on Nestlé exit from thePerrier Award for Comedy, <strong>and</strong>their involvement with Body shop<strong>and</strong> Jean Walker questionswhether our society undermineswomen's ability to breastfeed bypromoting early weaning, additionalfeeding with artificial milk<strong>and</strong> over emphasises weight.£3.0014 birth&beyond


Vroni HolzmannDouble TakeThe Double Take programme enables mothers to meet other newmums <strong>and</strong> share their problems, as well as the chance to receivea professional portrait of their baby. There is also the opportunityto learn about photography <strong>and</strong> by the end of the sessions theparticipants will skillfully take photographs of their own children."What is my future?", an exhibition shown at the OceanTerminal in Leith, featured photographs by Edinburgh-based artistVroni Holzmann, as well as statements about motherhood fromthe participants themselves. Vroni is a photographer, musician<strong>and</strong> mum of one, <strong>and</strong> specialises in baby <strong>and</strong> child portraiture.Double Take has been short-listed for a Social EnterpriseDevelopment Award from Scotl<strong>and</strong> Unltd. The photography forthis exhibition took place at the Birth Resource Centre.Vroni is keen to repeat the success of the Double Take project,<strong>and</strong>would like to hear from women with babies or small childrenwho feel vulnerable for any reason. Participants may be incircumstantial difficulties e.g. very young mothers, single mothers,housed in deprived areas, medical difficulties or mothers whostruggle for personal reasons. Please call or email Vroni to noteyour interest if you would like to take part, or if you would like tosponsor a place in the project.Contact details:e-mail: doubletake@babyphotographie.comor call 0131 228 4373birth&beyond 15


BreastfeedingBreastfeeding for me felt like it started when I was pregnant.After an antenatal class I had a vivid dream where I was breastfeedinga cat (perhaps this was a sign of things to come)! When Iwoke up I had made some sort of connection <strong>and</strong> knew I wantedto breastfeed my baby.After a very long <strong>and</strong> difficult labour my baby was born byemergency caesarean section. I did not get to hold him straightaway. We had skin-to-skin contact in the recovery room but Iwas exhausted <strong>and</strong> emotionally detached. Soon after we weretaken to the post natal ward. It was upsetting <strong>and</strong> frustrating tohear him cry but have to wait on someone responding to a buzzerbefore I could touch him. The midwifery staff told me it wasimportant to change his nappy before I fed him. Although I askedthem not to do this, it was what they did, <strong>and</strong> so Luke was distressedby the time I got him in my arms. I fed him lying down<strong>and</strong> a bond began to form between us, it was such a warm feelingto watch my newborn relax at my breast. I knew little aboutbreastfeeding but instinctively felt we were doing okay <strong>and</strong> werelearning together.Two days postpartum, <strong>and</strong> having only just begun being ableto move on the bed myself, a member of staff came up to me <strong>and</strong>told me I was “doing it wrong”. She told me to sit up properly<strong>and</strong> then demonstrated how to hold my baby. My disability didnot allow me to hold Luke the way she proposed <strong>and</strong> so she saidit could not work <strong>and</strong> someone would have to latch him on forme. Having no experience or confidence <strong>and</strong> struggling to copewith the birth, I did not question this. I let her position my babyon me <strong>and</strong> from that point on asked the nurses or my husb<strong>and</strong> toposition Luke whenever he was hungry. Very quickly I began tofeel sore <strong>and</strong> each feed became a distressing <strong>and</strong> painful experiencefor both of us. My nipples cracked <strong>and</strong> I cried as he tried tosuckle. I felt useless <strong>and</strong> humiliated. Not only had I 'failed' thebirth but I wasn't even able to feed this baby myself. By 6 dayspostpartum, feeding felt like torture <strong>and</strong> one of the midwivescalled the infant feeding specialist. Karla came to watch us feed<strong>and</strong> was very encouraging. She showed my husb<strong>and</strong> how toposition Luke better but it was still agony. She left me her numberbut I didn't think I'd call her.Two days later the women in the ward who had arrived after mehad all gone home <strong>and</strong> the midwives started to ask if I thought Iwas ready. I didn't but realised that this was not working, <strong>and</strong> evenif they did not believe me capable, I had to try to feed Luke myself.I was able to walk about now <strong>and</strong> so next time he looked for thebreast I lay down like I had done in the beginning. It was sore, asevery feed now was, but was no worse than when the midwivespositioned him on me. Each time after that we practiced together<strong>and</strong> late that afternoon we were discharged from the hospital.Back home things didn't improve, Luke was feeding often, thepain remained acute, my nipples didn't get any chance to heal ...<strong>and</strong> then I started feeling unwell. I had developed mastitis (whichI'd never heard of). The number I thought I'd never use, I calledoften. Karla was very supportive <strong>and</strong> began to try to work withme to find ways that I could manage feeding on my own. Sheoffered advice on how to deal with the problems that were ongoing.She lent me a pump <strong>and</strong>, with that <strong>and</strong> medication, my nipplesbegan to heal <strong>and</strong> the mastitis cleared. However blockedducts <strong>and</strong> mastitis was something that I seemed to have a tendencytoward <strong>and</strong> although the pain lessened it did not go awaycompletely. I started to look on the Internet <strong>and</strong> read the booksshe lent me. One day the pain became much worse again, socrying I got back on the phone to say that it was useless, that thepain was worse <strong>and</strong> as much as I wanted to breastfeed Luke itjust seemed it wasn't to be. I went to the breastfeeding clinic atthe hospital <strong>and</strong> when Karla saw Luke <strong>and</strong> me she said shethought this new problem was thrush. We were both prescribedmedication but the pain did not improve. I spent time on thephone to Karla, <strong>and</strong>, increasingly time on the Internet looking foradvice. While my GP believed thrush could exist in a baby'smouth she did not believe that this could cause them problemsfeeding <strong>and</strong> she said there was no evidence to prove nipplethrush even existed. Fortunately between Karla's advice <strong>and</strong> acouple of informative websites I trusted that this could improve.My GP prescribed All Purpose Nipple Ointment (the ingredientsfor this I found in one of Jack Newman's online h<strong>and</strong>outs) <strong>and</strong>Fluconazole for both Luke <strong>and</strong> I on the request of my consultant.After weeks of pain, this medication started to work <strong>and</strong> thingsbegan to mprove.Luke was 8 weeks old before we felt we were really getting thehang of breastfeeding <strong>and</strong> managing to control the pain. Duringthe first 6 months I had repeat occurrences of blocked ducts <strong>and</strong>one more occurrence of both mastitis <strong>and</strong> thrush. The frequencyof my contact with Karla reduced but I continued to use theInternet <strong>and</strong> seek advice from a breastfeeding peer supportgroup. After 6 months there were many 'stages' to get through(distracted baby, introducing solids, biting etc) but on the whole ithas been an enjoyable <strong>and</strong> rewarding experience. It has givenLuke <strong>and</strong> me an attachment I don't believe we would have foundany other way, <strong>and</strong> provided an important connection during mypost natal depression. It also proved invaluable when he endedup very ill in hospital. It also got us through me returning to work,<strong>and</strong> many other situations.The next main challenge to our breastfeeding relationship happenedwhen I became pregnant when he was 17 months old. Iwas ill with hyperemesis gravidarum <strong>and</strong> was worried about continuingto feed my toddler while pregnant. I went back to theInternet sites I'd found useful before <strong>and</strong> found a couple of newones. I also called Karla again for the first time in many months<strong>and</strong> was reassured. My new baby is due soon <strong>and</strong> my toddleronly feeds once a day now. I have no idea what will happen toour breastfeeding relationship when the baby comes, nor whatthe new one between my new baby & me will be like. This timethough I will trust my instincts more <strong>and</strong> will look for help from theplaces I trust as soon as any problems arise. I have no doubtthat persevering with that initial bad advice caused many of theproblems that then took weeks to resolve.Being part of a breastfeeding support group has helped at allstages of breastfeeding. Initially for 'technical' advice then foremotional support for choosing to continue feeding my babywhen others had stopped (around 4 to 6 months among mothersI know). More recently being able to support other womenthrough their own experiences has been incredibly rewarding.I have also spent a lot of time reading <strong>and</strong> looking at various websites.Unfortunately I found it impossible to find a support groupfor disabled mothers choosing to breastfeed, this would havebeen most useful in the early days. The resources I found mostuseful <strong>and</strong> have returned to are.Alison McDonaldWebsites:www.breastfeedingonline.com/newman.shtml, www.lalecheleague.orgwww.askdrsears.com, www.kellymom.comBooks:Womanly Art of Breastfeeding, La Leche League InternationalUltimate Breastfeeding Book of Answers, Jack Newman Md.Mothering Your Nursing Toddler, Norma Jane BumgarnerAdventures in T<strong>and</strong>em Nursing, Hilary Flower16 birth&beyond


Breastfeeding Supportat the Birth Resource CentreThe Birth Resource Centre <strong>and</strong> La Leche League are workingtogether to offer information <strong>and</strong> support to breastfeeding mothersby hosting regular support group meetings. A trained breastfeedingcounsellor facilitates meetings on the second <strong>and</strong> fourthFriday of each month.On the second Friday, mothers meet from 1030 – 1230 for discussionson a range of topics like how breastfeeding helps mothersto meet their baby’s needs, how to overcome challenges, <strong>and</strong>starting solids. Mothers with all ages of breastfeeding babies arewelcome. Come <strong>and</strong> bring your questions!Mothers with older breastfeeding babies often have differentquestions –, for instance what benefit does breastfeeding give mybaby now that she’s older? Or, how do I deal with criticism fromothers? On the fourth Friday each month, mothers with olderbreastfeeding babies meet from 1030 – 1230 to discuss their particularquestions <strong>and</strong> concerns.And if it’s a fourth Friday <strong>and</strong> you need help feeding your br<strong>and</strong>new baby, come along – you’ll be in the company of a host ofexperienced mothers who will be happy to help!Karla NapierFeeding Twins“How are you feeling?” she asked as I wentinto the scan room. “Pretty tired this time,”I replied, “but I suspect that’s because thistime I’m running around after a 14 monthold toddler”.Little did I know. Five minutes later <strong>and</strong>she turned to me again with “well we cansee now why you’re quite so tired – you’recarrying twins”.With that my world completely changed…. realising that life would never be thesame, three children under 2, would thepregnancy <strong>and</strong> birth be over-medicalised?How was I supposed to care for three childrenin nappies? What about the practicalthings – new car, double buggies …. thelist was endless.And since I was still feeding Phoebe atthe time, how did you manage to breastfeedtwins?Thankfully nowadays you have sixmonths from that scan to get used to theidea of twins <strong>and</strong> to read as much as youcan – while coping with an extraordinarilyheavy <strong>and</strong> tiring pregnancy. And so atnearly 39 weeks, I gave birth to Rhona <strong>and</strong>Freya at 9lbs <strong>and</strong> 8lbs 1oz! Rhona’s birthwas swift <strong>and</strong> wonderful, Freya got stuck<strong>and</strong> I needed a section. Three days later Iwas home, very anaemic, weak from thesection, with a 21 month old who didn’tknow what had hit her <strong>and</strong> two verydem<strong>and</strong>ing, but thankfully healthily largebabies.Having fed Phoebe to 16 months, I wasdetermined to make a good stab at feeding.The midwives in the hospital werewonderful at encouraging me, trying toteach me how to do both at once, but alsodoing all they could to help me express<strong>and</strong> therefore increase my supply swiftly.Rhona <strong>and</strong> Freya enjoying Mum’s milk.Rhona was plethoric (had too many redblood cells) so we had to get a lot of milkdown her very quickly, <strong>and</strong> despite the predictionsof the junior doctor I was determinedshe was going to get through thefirst week with no formula. So right fromthe start we were expressing like mad <strong>and</strong>feeding with a syringe. It was hard work<strong>and</strong> the first night out of hospital I nearlygave up (to the point that I sent my husb<strong>and</strong>out to get some cartons of formulathe next day – we’ve thrown two away costhey’re now past their sell-by date <strong>and</strong> theothers are still on the shelf!).Teaching two babies to breastfeed isdifficult – you don’t spend nearly as muchtime with them, cuddled up, relaxing <strong>and</strong>getting to know each other. Your time isspent simply surviving. The sheer exhaustionof the operation after the heavy pregnancy,the dem<strong>and</strong>s of the toddler <strong>and</strong> thefeeding dem<strong>and</strong>s of two took everythingout of me <strong>and</strong> I spent most of the time onthe sofa feeding one <strong>and</strong> then the otherthroughout the day. Each day was abonus, <strong>and</strong> each day I thought I’d be givingup before too long. If I hadn’t fedPhoebe I would have given up, the pain,the exhaustion, the feeling of being completelytied to the babies – but I knew itwould get better. The first six weekspassed with many tears, many frustrations<strong>and</strong> many dark times, but then I began toget the hang of feeding both at once (<strong>and</strong>birth&beyond 17


eating for Scotl<strong>and</strong> – you need a phenomenalamount of food for feeding twins),although when I was very tired, which wasmost of the time, feeding two at once wasuncomfortable on my legs – you’re muchmore fixed with two attached at once. Youfeed them, they fall asleep <strong>and</strong> you’retrapped on the sofa cos you’ve got thiscushion attached around you, <strong>and</strong> if youtry to move one, you’re going to drop theother! You don’t get time for the relaxingfeeds – as soon as you’ve finished one,you have to put them down <strong>and</strong> deal withthe other (<strong>and</strong> then work out what to dowith your toddler!)How did I get through it? I gave myselfshort targets – at first I wanted to getthrough to six weeks, then I thought threemonths would be good, <strong>and</strong> then by thenI had been in contact with an old universityfriend who was still feeding her twins at12 months (with two other children) – thatinspired me, it could clearly be done … ifshe could do it, I could! That’s what I neededto keep me going.Soon after three months, I realised I hadgot to the point of dreading the introductionof bottles, everyone assumed we’d goonto formula at some point, as did I, butnow the idea of sterilising, mixing <strong>and</strong>working out what you did with formulafilled me with panic – there’s enough to doin the day of a mother of twins withoutadding to it. And so it was easier to continuefeeding. The horrendous times, withtwo going through growth spurts at thesame time, or both screaming hungry butrefusing to feed, faded in my memory.Now nearly seven months, Rhona <strong>and</strong>Freya have still not had formula, they arenow getting too distracted to feed at thesame time, but have worked out how tofeed swiftly <strong>and</strong> efficiently. We haven’t hadso many of those wonderful times youhave with one baby when she feeds untilshe falls asleep in your arms, but lookingdown <strong>and</strong> seeing four identical eyes lookingup at you as they feed is an amazingexperience.And we’ve carried on expressingthroughout. My compromise to the twinswas to give them expressed milk at night– I hoped that this way they wouldn’t associatecomfort with night feeds, but primarilyit meant that my husb<strong>and</strong> could feedone <strong>and</strong> I could feed the other – it was asociable way of doing the night feeds <strong>and</strong>it meant that no-one fell asleep till the end– feeding twins is very soporific! The constantexpressing has meant that my supplyalways outstripped dem<strong>and</strong> which hasbeen a great comfort especially throughgrowth spurts.Breastfeeding twins is possible, itrequires even more food, drink <strong>and</strong> sleepthan breastfeeding one, it requires a firmcommitment <strong>and</strong> a lot of support frompeople around you – I would not have continuedif my husb<strong>and</strong> hadn’t been so preparedto do everything to help, <strong>and</strong> friendswho told me I could do it. But in the longrun it is easier <strong>and</strong> nicer, <strong>and</strong> of course, somuch better for babies <strong>and</strong> mother. Twinshave so little mother-time compared totheir single counterparts, that I felt this wasa good way to ensure that they at leasthad some time to bond properly with me.Sophia MarriageGillian Baxendine<strong>Babywearing</strong>I sometimes think that what a newmother expects of her baby is driven bythe objects she is encouraged to buy him:a cot for sleeping in; a bouncy chair for sittingin; a pram <strong>and</strong> a car seat for travellingin. It can be frustrating when she finds outthat her baby hasn’t read the samebrochure; when she discovers just howmuch of the time her new baby wants tospend in her bed or in her arms. She maywonder how on earth she can get anythingdone. Part of the answer for me was tolearn the age-old practice of babywearing(the other part was to learn to get lessdone, but that’s a different article!).I have heard many descriptions of thisintense in-arms phase. Some people talkabout the “fourth trimester”, others of “ninemonths in, nine months out”. In Bali,babies were carried exclusively for the firstsix months of life <strong>and</strong> their six-month birthdaymarked with a “ground touching” ceremony.In Yucatan, Mexico, carrying wasso much part of baby care that there wasa special ceremony to mark the transitionfrom cradle carry to a hip carry when theinfant can sit by himself. What is beyonddoubt is that, until a baby is crawling <strong>and</strong>freer to choose for himself where he goes,most babies will try to insist on being withtheir mothers or another beloved carer asmuch as possible. Few of us have the luxury- or patience - to spend more than afew days sitting in chairs with our babieswhile others maintain our homes <strong>and</strong> fetchus food <strong>and</strong> drink. But getting things donecan be very hard <strong>and</strong> the immediate reactionmay be to train baby to sleep <strong>and</strong> playalone as much as possible. There is acompromise to be struck between whatbaby wants <strong>and</strong> what you want, butSome people talk aboutthe “fourth trimester”,others of “nine monthsin, nine months out”focussing too hard on freeing your armsfrom your baby may backfire later on. Ababy who leaves your arms in his own timemay well be more independent <strong>and</strong> secureas a toddler than one who was pushed outahead of his own schedule.Think of the baby’s behaviour in thecontext of his experience. Inside his mothersounds from outside are muted, heardagainst the reassuring background of herheartbeat, breath <strong>and</strong> digestion. There islittle or no variation in temperature, light,smells or tastes <strong>and</strong> he need not worryabout eating or breathing – all that is takencare of. There is plenty of movementthough, as his mother sits, st<strong>and</strong>s, rollsover, swims, dances. Even when she issleeping, he can still feel the rise <strong>and</strong> fall ofher diaphragm (perhaps this is why somany newborns love to sleep lying on aparent’s chest).Then he is born <strong>and</strong> suddenly the worldis full of bright <strong>and</strong> dark, loud or strangenoises, hot <strong>and</strong> cold, new smells <strong>and</strong>tastes. He has to learn to breathe, to eat,to see, to move his h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> a hundredother new things. Above all, suddenly, hismother can go places without him <strong>and</strong> hecan experience being uncomfortable, hungry<strong>and</strong> lonely. In time, he will learn that hecan have an influence on his experience;that his calls, smiles <strong>and</strong> movements willget results but especially in the earlymonths, he needs a lot of reassurance thatthe world out here is a manageable place.So what does a sling offer this newbaby? Something as close to the womb ashe can get. He is warm <strong>and</strong> secure, initiallywith his vulnerable chest <strong>and</strong> stomachturned in to his mother. The sounds <strong>and</strong>sights of the world reach him through the18 birth&beyond


safe surroundings of his mother’s smell,breath, voice <strong>and</strong> movement. When it getstoo much, he can fall easily <strong>and</strong> peacefullyasleep, knowing that he will not wake upalone. As he gets older, he can begin toexplore the world outside from the samesafe place – <strong>and</strong> more or less from hismother’s point of view so that he is intimatelyinvolved in her activities <strong>and</strong> conversations.There are less obvious benefits too.Dr Sears reports research which suggeststhat:• Close mother-baby attachment stimulatesthe baby’s adrenal hormones,which promote night sleeping <strong>and</strong> daywaking;• Close contact with mother’s voice regulatesbaby’s limb movements, teachinghim to move more purposefully as hesynchronises limb movements with theinflections of her voice;• <strong>Babywearing</strong> helps to develop thebaby’s sense of balance (the “vestibularsystem”) by constantly stimulating himwith forward/back, up/down <strong>and</strong> side toside movement.In short, babies seem to have been bornexpecting this kind of close contact <strong>and</strong> todevelop optimally when they get it.And what does the sling offer to baby’sparents – apart from a happy, secure baby,a significant benefit in itself? First of all, itvirtually eliminates the frustrating <strong>and</strong> timewasting effort of getting reluctant babies totake naps – <strong>and</strong> it can be used to get arestless or fussy baby to go to sleep atnight as well. You can take a nap yourselfwith a sleeping baby snuggled in a sling onyour chest. A baby in a sling will drift offwhile you are clearing up the kitchen, goingshopping, or just taking a relaxing walk inthe sunshine (or even the rain!). Once theyare asleep, you can usually carry on with asitting activity for some time before theystir (this article is being written with asleeping baby slung on my front). Thechances are they will sleep longer than in abasket, rather than coming wide awakethe first time they stir. With practice, it issurprising just how much you can get donewhile carrying a baby, although I continueto insist to my partner that washing up isjust too difficult… And at the risk ofappearing superficial, carrying a 4 or 5 kiloweight for a few hours every day can helpsignificantly with post-pregnancy weightloss <strong>and</strong> deliver a very well-toned pair oflegs!For fathers in particular it can be difficultto find their role with a new baby, especiallya breastfed baby. Mother appears tohave all the advantages – baby is alreadyfamiliar with the pace of her walk <strong>and</strong> herbreathing <strong>and</strong> quickly identifies her as thesource of food <strong>and</strong> comfort. It is notunusual for babies to cry, apparently inconsolably,whenever they are passed awayfrom mother. However, most fathers findthat a fed <strong>and</strong> changed baby will settlequickly <strong>and</strong> happily in a sling for an hour ortwo. While a pram or car seat may alsokeep a baby calm, the advantage of a slingis that the baby is getting used to the feel<strong>and</strong> smell of his father <strong>and</strong> beginning toassociate his body with an alternativesource of comfort; <strong>and</strong> the father is gettinga much more intimate grounding in thebaby’s patterns of napping <strong>and</strong> chattering.The same advantages apply to other carers– gr<strong>and</strong>parents or babysitters may allfind that a sling is a wonderful solution fora sad or tired baby.Happy Mum <strong>and</strong> Baby with a Sling.As I know from my own experience, inthe first weeks particularly, baby wearingcan seem like very hard work - especiallyif you are used to a fairly sedentary life.You have to be realistic about what youcan achieve, or expect a fair few aches<strong>and</strong> pains. Ideally, you would share thecarrying with other people although thatis not always easy in our rather isolatedsocial set-ups. More likely, you will sharethe load between a sling <strong>and</strong> a pram.Many mothers take both on an outing,with the sling as an infallible safety net ifbaby gets fed up of the pram. JeanLiedloff suggests taking a sling to carrythe baby <strong>and</strong> a pram for the groceries!The good news is that a baby does notneed to be carried all the time to benefit.In a 1986 study in Montreal, researchersfound that babies who were carried for atleast three hours a day, <strong>and</strong> who were carriedas a matter of course <strong>and</strong> not just inresponse to their fussing, cried significantlyless (43% less to be precise) than a lesscarriedcontrol group. Dr Sears suggestsAs he gets older,he can begin to explorethe world outside.that this happens because the motion ofbeing carried reminds the baby of thewomb: “The familiar overcomes the unfamiliarto which he is now exposed” <strong>and</strong> hisanxiety reduces; he can relax.Let’s say you are now persuaded of thebenefits of babywearing: which carrier touse? There is quite a range, <strong>and</strong> differentpeople adore different ones. The simplestto use – <strong>and</strong> also the easiest to buy instores – are front carriers with lots of clips<strong>and</strong> straps. These have the advantage offeeling very secure <strong>and</strong> being easy to learnbut they are the least flexible: for example,they cannot be used to carry a toddler onyour hip, to cradle a breastfeeding babyor to carry an older baby on your back.The most flexible carriers – in effect, a longstrong scarf which you wrap round you –have the steepest learning curve <strong>and</strong> canbe hard to use with confidence unless yousee someone else using them first. Andthere are a myriad of rings, wraps <strong>and</strong>pouches in between.Gillian BaxendineBecause this can all be rather confusing, wehave set up a “sling library” at the BirthResource Centre, where you can try out differentcarriers before you decide what tobuy for yourself – with help <strong>and</strong> demonstrationsfrom other mothers who are more expe -rienced babywearers. A range of slings will beavailable to try at the centre on Fridaymornings at the same time as the breastfeedinggroup meets. You don’t need to bebreastfeeding your baby to come along <strong>and</strong> tryslings – all mothers, including those withtoddlers, are welcome. And if anyone hasa sling they would like to loan or donate to thelibrary, it would be very welcome too.Contact us for details aboutour upcoming sling days at the BRC.birth&beyond 19


THE BIRTH RESOURCE CENTREBirth PoolsThe BRC hires oval <strong>and</strong> hexagonal birth pools for use at home <strong>and</strong>sometimes in hospital. The pools are strong, easy to set up, can be hiredfor a month <strong>and</strong> are very affordable.The Birth Resource Centre aims to make pools available to all,irrespective of income.Contact Iizi on 0131 553 6532 or the BRC on 0131 229 3667'20 birth&beyond


Book ReviewImpact of Birthing Practiceson Breastfeeding: Protectingthe Mother <strong>and</strong> BabyContinuumBy Mary Kroeger with Linda SmithPublished by Jones <strong>and</strong> BartlettPublishers, 2004Price: £25.99ISBN: 0-7637-2481-5Ruth Bowman (reviewer)On reading this book, I had to ask myselfwhat was new. Does it simply confirm whatmany of us have suspected for years – thatafter a complicated birth it is harder toestablish breastfeeding? There is of coursemuch more to it than that. Mary Kroeger<strong>and</strong> her co-author Linda Smith, respectivelyan experienced midwife <strong>and</strong> a lactationconsultant, suggest a clear linkbetween the difficulties so many newmothers encounter in establishing breastfeeding<strong>and</strong> the inappropriate use of interventionsduring labour, birth <strong>and</strong> the periodimmediately afterwards. In particular,they highlight the effect many of thoseinterventions have on the baby’s behaviourfor several weeks after the birth, <strong>and</strong> theycriticise the lack of ‘joined up thinking’ ofcertain contemporary health care policieswhich fail to support the vital mother-childdyad by not acknowledging the effect ofbirth interventions on both parties.This book sets childbirth <strong>and</strong> breastfeedingin a historical <strong>and</strong> cultural context,discussing the range between birthaccompanied by supportive family <strong>and</strong>birth in large impersonal hospitals, <strong>and</strong>highlights what we in the technology-dominatedWest can learn from birthing practicesin different cultures.The authors argue the need for solidscientific evidence to support a returnto practices that encourage straightforwardbirth. They examine the evidencebase for many current childbirth practices<strong>and</strong> acknowledge where there is aresearch gap.Chapter by chapter, there is detailedexamination of the evidence associatedwith childbirth practices, including emotional<strong>and</strong> practical support in labour,maternal position, eating <strong>and</strong> drinking,pain medication, surgical interventions inbirth, <strong>and</strong> immediate skin-to-skin contactbetween mother <strong>and</strong> baby. The effect ofthose practices in either hindering or fosteringthe mother-child dyad which isessential to a happy <strong>and</strong> confident breastfeedingrelationship is discussed. Forexample, they detail the growing evidencethat an infant whose mother has usedepidural pain relief in labour will be lessalert <strong>and</strong> his motor behaviour significantlyaltered for several days after birth, <strong>and</strong> thatthis effect can continue for up to a month,the period during which mother <strong>and</strong> babyare learning to breastfeed.In a chapter entitled ‘Physics, Forces<strong>and</strong> Mechanical Effects of Birth onBreastfeeding’ Linda Smith examines theeffect of birth interventions on the baby’sphysiology. She describes in detail how‘disorganized feeding’ can result from acaesarean or instrumental birth becausethe nerves <strong>and</strong> muscles involved in sucking,swallowing <strong>and</strong> breathing have beeninterfered with.If women <strong>and</strong> babies are to overcomethe additional obstacles to establishingbreastfeeding after a complicated birth,then their caregivers need to be aware ofthese issues too, <strong>and</strong> to take these problemsvery seriously. The authors challengehealth care practitioners to empathisemore with both mothers <strong>and</strong> infants, <strong>and</strong>to spend time imagining how it must feelto be on the receiving end of so manyinvasive procedures.The authors are to be commended fordrawing attention to an issue which hasbeen too long overlooked. While thisbook should be essential reading forall professionals involved in caring forwomen <strong>and</strong> their newborn infants, itwould also be an informative read for anyinterested lay person.Breastfeeding in Hospital:Mothers, Midwives <strong>and</strong> theProduction LineBy Fiona DykesPublished by Routledge, 2006Price: £20.99ISBN: 0415395763Reviewed by Clare BartosFirst published in AIMS QuarterlyJournal, Vol 18 No 2 2006available from www.aims.org.uk.This research-based book tackles the theory<strong>and</strong> practice of both mother’s <strong>and</strong> midwive’sexperiences of breastfeeding in hos-POSTNATAL DOULA SUPPORTHelping a mother to have the space,time <strong>and</strong> confidenceto more fully enjoy early motherhood.For more information please go towww.mothertomother.co.ukor call Clare on 0131 445 4445birth&beyond 21


pital. Fiona Dykes starts by taking thereader through a lot of academic theory inorder to create an underst<strong>and</strong>ing in thereader of why the parallel experiences ofmothers <strong>and</strong> midwives are as they are.She then relates these theories to the evidencegained during her research <strong>and</strong> indoing so conveys to the reader the realityof breastfeeding in a post-natal ward in2006. The picture is a sad one. Despitethe promotion of ‘breast is best ‘, mothers<strong>and</strong> midwives struggle in a climate where‘productivity’ is paramount, time is scarce<strong>and</strong> seen as the enemy <strong>and</strong> caring foranother is perceived as plainly dem<strong>and</strong>ing.The result is overworked, stressed midwiveswho operate in a ‘factory-like’ environment<strong>and</strong> unsupported, confusedmothers who often experience motherhoodin a detached way. Her final chapterconsiders the possibilities for the provisionBreastfeeding inHospital: Mothers,Midwives <strong>and</strong> theProduction Line.Price: £20.99ISBN:0415395763has been rhetoric for too long. The publicationof this book will hopefully open upthe much needed debate on these matters.What could be more important?Clare Bartos (reviewer) qualified as a midwife in1997 but following time at home with her childrennow works as a post-natal doula <strong>and</strong> istraining to be a breastfeeding supporter.Birth CrisisBy Sheila KitzingerPublished by Routledge, 2006Price: £65ISBN: 0415372658Reviewer: Jenny Newl<strong>and</strong>Journal, Vol 18 No 2 2006 availablefrom www.aims.org.uk.“I will never have any more children,I will not subject myself to that again . . .I remember exactly what was done <strong>and</strong>said <strong>and</strong> by whom. I have the relentlesstorture of re-living this experience daily,especially at night . . .The videotape isalways going on in my head.” SheilaKitzinger's most recent book exploresthe crisis of emotional suffering whichcan occur following childbirth whenwomen feel out of control, not listened to<strong>and</strong> not respected during birth.that everyone should read, but probablymost of those who will are women who arealready more than familiar with the issuesraised. For those women who have had abad experience with maternity services inthe past, there is plenty of validation forthose experiences as well as informationabout how they might approach <strong>and</strong> pl<strong>and</strong>ifferently in the future.I think many pregnant women will notbe drawn to this book because there is avery underst<strong>and</strong>able wish to trust that theservices are good <strong>and</strong> that 'they will beOK', <strong>and</strong> some of this book could beexperienced as rather frightening. Thisreminds me that it can be a very difficultline to draw between giving informationthat could be frightening <strong>and</strong> informationthat is useful. Culturally, I think that thebad experiences that many women haveare hidden from women who are pregnantfor the first time in order not to frightenthem, <strong>and</strong> as a midwife, I have heardwomen report back in different ways aboutthis – “the information I was given wasfrightening <strong>and</strong> actually, I don't know whatall the fuss was about”, <strong>and</strong> “if only I hadbeen told, I could have been prepared”.Personally I fall in to the second category,but I know that not everyone does.of post-natal care in a supportive, caringculture where relationships matter morethan productivity. This is important as shesuggests that the relationships betweenmidwives <strong>and</strong> mothers are reflected in therelationship between mother <strong>and</strong> baby.Possibilities suggested include moving thefocus from promotion to support of breastfeeding,more community-based postnatalcare, <strong>and</strong> within the hospital settingin particular, more peer <strong>and</strong> voluntarybreastfeeding support. Fiona commentson the contrast in peer <strong>and</strong> voluntarybreastfeeding supporters’ approaches <strong>and</strong>attitudes to those of midwives <strong>and</strong> suggeststhat midwives have much to learnfrom the voluntary organisations.Although a fairly dem<strong>and</strong>ing academic<strong>and</strong> theoretical read, this book will appealto many who have an interest in midwifery,women <strong>and</strong> child health, social <strong>and</strong> politicalpolicy <strong>and</strong> of course breastfeeding!The reference to research is refreshingamidst the background theory <strong>and</strong> clearlyreveals the need for change in the provisionof post-natal care. The importance ofpost-natal care <strong>and</strong> breastfeeding supportTopics include:· increasing intervention in pregnancy· the change in emphasis from relatioshipsto technology in childbirth· how family, friends <strong>and</strong> professionalcaregivers can respond to the needs oftraumatized mothers· why those working in the maternity systemshould promote changeUsing quotes from women throughout, sheprovides a clear, comprehensive <strong>and</strong> easyto read exploration of all aspects of disempowerment,how it comes about <strong>and</strong> theemotional trauma that can be experiencedas a result.Birth CrisisPrice: £65ISBN:0415372658In a way, I think this is probably a book thatwon't be read by those who should read it.By that, I mean that it is one of those booksEyes Without Sparkle –a journey through postnatalillnessBy Elaine A. HanzakPublished by Radcliffe 2005Price: 185775655XISBN: £16.99Reviewed by: Fiona ArmstrongElaine Hanzak suffered severe postnataldepression (PND), including an acuteepisode of puerperal psychosis, the illness’smost serious form, following thebirth of her son in 1996. Eyes WithoutSparkle is her first h<strong>and</strong> account of herexperiences <strong>and</strong> recovery.Following a rather difficult birth (readingbetween the lines, at least part of the problemseems to be that she was required topush her baby out by hospital staff longbefore she was ready or feeling any urgeto push), Elaine brought her much wantedfirst baby home from hospital, <strong>and</strong> verysoon began to slide slowly into depression.Feelings of exhaustion <strong>and</strong> inadequacywere followed by self harm, suicidal feelings,<strong>and</strong> a breakdown requiring months ofin-patient care in a psychiatric hospital.The book then charts her recovery, rebuildingof her relationship with her son <strong>and</strong>eventual return to work as a teacher.This book is aimed at least in part athealth professionals, <strong>and</strong> she tries to drawout in her story the impact upon her of22 birth&beyond


the approach of the various professionalsshe came into contact with antenatally, duringthe birth <strong>and</strong> during her depressive illness.She par- tially succe-eds in this, butthere are a number of ar-eas where thereEyes WithoutSparkle –a journeythrough postnatalillnessPrice:ISBN:could have been a much clearer underst<strong>and</strong>ing<strong>and</strong> discussion of this vital topic.I found her writing style initially difficult, asshe uses clichés constantly <strong>and</strong> peppers herprose with exclamation marks, but in someways this flaw represents one of the book’sstrengths as it is a personal account writtenin her own words. The book gets verybogged down in the first 60 or so pages withendless details of shopping trips, giftsreceived, <strong>and</strong> other things which could onlybe of interest to her friends <strong>and</strong> family.Similarly the account of her recovery seemsto deal largely with visits to Ikea <strong>and</strong> Marks& Spencer. It would have been better tochoose one or two of these as examples ofhow she was doing at any given period,rather than writing at such length about matterswhich give us little insight into what postnatal depression really feels like.The book is not without its merits.There is some mention of the triggers ofPND, suggesting the complex interactionbetween hormones, the physical <strong>and</strong>emotional changes of pregnancy <strong>and</strong>having a baby, exhaustion, <strong>and</strong> socialpressures <strong>and</strong> expectations, as well asself-imposed pressures to fit an ideal ofnew baby bliss. She illustrates well whatkinds of emotional support <strong>and</strong> empathycan be most helpful, as well as thereverse. She describes “competitivemothering” at mother <strong>and</strong> baby groups,where it seems she is the only one whohas found new motherhood hard. Thestrain on her worsens as she wonderswhy everyone else appears to havebabies who sleep all night <strong>and</strong> can effortlesslyjuggle motherhood with all of life’sother tasks – <strong>and</strong> these are groups ofwomen whose babies are only a matterof weeks old. She writes poignantly ofhow it would have helped her to hear ofother women’s difficulties too.The profound problem with this bookis, I feel, its writer’s lack of insight. There isa lot to be learned about PND in this book,but readers must largely find it out forthemselves as Elaine Hanzak does notalways seem to have realised it herself. Shenever questions the raft of assumptions shehas about what parenthood is about, norher ideas about “perfect mothers <strong>and</strong> goodbabies” which seem at the root of some ofwhat went wrong for her. I do not by thismean to imply that there is any element offault, but what I do mean is that depression<strong>and</strong> the recovery from it can be a tool forself-discovery <strong>and</strong> a greater underst<strong>and</strong>ingof what we feel <strong>and</strong> think <strong>and</strong> why, <strong>and</strong> thisis singularly absent from this book. It maybe that she did not receive the counsellingor therapy which would have helped her tounderst<strong>and</strong> more about what happened toher <strong>and</strong> why, as she does not go into anydetail about what she talked about to herdoctor or psychiatric nurse. Somehow a lotof this book seems very superficial, which Ifind astonishing as it deals with such a profoundmental illness. I am reminded of oneof the best books on depression I haveread, called “Sunbathing in the Rain” byGwyneth Lewis, which says that if you donot learn the lessons your depression is tryingto teach you, it will come back <strong>and</strong> hityou again until you do.This book might interest a mother experiencingPND who may find reassurance inrecognising similarities between her ownsymptoms <strong>and</strong> those of Elaine Hanzak,<strong>and</strong> it also contains some points of use toa health professional wishing to underst<strong>and</strong>better the experience from thepatient’s viewpoint. However, for a muchmore insightful, moving <strong>and</strong> better writtenaccount of PND, I would recommendBrooke Shields’ 2005 account “DownCame the Rain” over this.The Mother to Mother<strong>Post</strong>partum <strong>Depression</strong>Support Book - Real Storiesfrom Women who LivedThrough It <strong>and</strong> RecoveredBy S<strong>and</strong>ra PoulinPublished by Berkley, 2006Price: £6.99ISBN: 0425208087Reviewed by: Fiona ArmstrongThe aim of this book is to provide supportto women experiencing postnataldepression by offering a collection of personalaccounts from women who havegone through it <strong>and</strong> come out the otherside. The message is that whatever youare feeling you are not alone.There is a wide range of stories grouped intochapters with common themes. Topics coveredinclude women who have had difficultbirths or breastfeeding problems, motherswith various symptoms like insomnia or anxiety,single mothers, women with twins ormore <strong>and</strong> women who have experiencedpostnatal psychosis. There is an interestingchapter on fantasies <strong>and</strong> expectations ofmotherhood <strong>and</strong> the relationship betweenthis <strong>and</strong> depression, looking at the “mothermyth” <strong>and</strong> expectations upon oneself <strong>and</strong>from others about “perfection”.The way the stories are grouped allowsthe reader to home in on the stories whichmay be closest to her own situation whileallowing each individual mother’s story to beheard. There is no editorial comment exceptin the introduction <strong>and</strong> conclusion, which isgood as it leaves each experience to speakfor itself. All accounts are quite short whichis helpful as the book can be dipped intoeasily, <strong>and</strong> a reader can find something relevanteven if she has little time available.Most of the accounts are from the USA,though there are some from Britain, Australia<strong>and</strong> New Zeal<strong>and</strong>. The style is quiteAmerican, with lots of talk about “mommies”etc, <strong>and</strong> there is a slightly cheerleading feelingabout recovery: each account ends withThe Mother to Mother<strong>Post</strong>partum <strong>Depression</strong>Support Book - RealStories from Womenwho Lived Through It<strong>and</strong> RecoveredPrice: £6.99ISBN: 0425208087a section called “Now that I’ve recovered” or“Thoughts for a better day”. While overallthe positive message of the book is excellent,I wonder whether in the depths ofdepression, someone might find all thisactually made them feel worse by comparison.Also, there are frequent references toGod, <strong>and</strong> quotations from the bible in littleboxes on the page, which might be off-puttingto some people.This book is quite unique in that it iswomen’s own voices talking about how theyfeel. There are a few personal experiencebooks around about postnatal depression,but they tend to be of one woman’s ownexperience, where this one is a collection ofmany different perspectives <strong>and</strong> is all thericher for that. Even a mother who isn’t necessarilysuffering depression but is findingsome aspects of new motherhood challenging,or is feeling isolated in any way,would find a lot of comfort <strong>and</strong> recognitionamongst these pages.birth&beyond 23


Home BirthSupport GroupThe focus of the group is to offer support <strong>and</strong> information to anyone who might beinterested in the many choices surrounding place of birth,to provide a meeting point for those who may be considering (or those who have previouslychosen) a home birth, <strong>and</strong> reassurance that home birth is a realistic,reasonable, <strong>and</strong> most importantly, safe option for mother, baby <strong>and</strong> midwife.1st Sun of each month11am – 1pmwww.homebirthsupport.org.ukIntroduction toHomoeopathyCome <strong>and</strong> join an afternoon workshopon this fascinating subject. Learn about the principlesof homoeopathic philosophy, basic information<strong>and</strong> some home self-help ideas.29th March 2008, 10.30am - 1pmat the Birth Resource CentrePlease call or e-mail for further information(£15 incl. refreshments, concessions available)THANK YOUVolunteersThanks to everyone who contributed to our fantasticfoundraiser event on November 3rd.It was a very successful event, we had a great time<strong>and</strong> we are planning the next one.THANK YOU TO YOU ALL.GIFT VOUCHERS……are now available to buy from the Birth Resource Centre.A thoughtful <strong>and</strong> original present to buy your friend or relative which will be much appreciated.Buy a block of classes, or part of a block, to celebrate a birthday, Christmas or the birth of a baby.H<strong>and</strong>-made vouchers make this a special gift <strong>and</strong> classes include Yoga for Pregnancy,Baby Shiatsu or massage, Parent <strong>and</strong> Baby Yoga or baby music.For further information, please call or write to Joor Jenny at the Birth Resource Centre.24 birth&beyond


From us to you...Thanks<strong>and</strong> acknowledgementsWe thank Rivka Owen for stepping in like a breath of fresh air, toassist Jo last term. She was a pleasure to work with, <strong>and</strong> wewish her well on her journey to become a midwife.Our co-ordinators are a crucial part of the organisation, <strong>and</strong> manageto juggle the many different tasks expertly <strong>and</strong> with exceptionallygood humour <strong>and</strong> ability.Previous facilitatorsMany women support our classes, as facilitators.We were sorry that Lee Seekings Norman was unable to continuefacilitating one of our yoga for pregnancy classes. Lee hasbeen very involved with the Centre over many years, she is still aDirector, <strong>and</strong> we look forward to welcoming her back soon.We were sad to lose S<strong>and</strong>ra Farmer, who led some of the yogafor pregnancy sessions <strong>and</strong> the birth preparation workshops,coming all the way from Glasgow each week, to do this. We verymuch appreciate your commitment to the Centre <strong>and</strong> wish youwell with your classes in Glasgow.Photo: Vroni HolzmannThank you from the BRC DirectorsVolunteersWe would like to extend our heartfelt thanks to all those who doso much to support the BRC. No task is too small or unappreciated.We have many volunteers who generously help us by offeringtime, skills or both. Fiona Armstrong, particularly, continues toprovide us with much needed background support of all kinds.Thank you Fiona for your continued involvement. We very muchappreciate knowing that you are there. Thank you to all.Co-ordinatorsWe would particularly like to acknowledge the huge contributionsthat Jenny Newl<strong>and</strong> has made over a number of years to theBRC, as our previous main co-ordinator. We would not be wherewe are now without her. We welcome her back as our counsellor,administrative co-ordinator <strong>and</strong> co-ordinator of our perinatal mentalhealth group.We were sorry to lose Jo Harknett as one of our very activeDirectors, <strong>and</strong> thank her for all she did during that time, but weare delighted to welcome her as our current co-ordinator.Michelle Gow <strong>and</strong> Eva Bofias have been instrumental in keepingthe breastfeeding support groups going for many months, afterour previous La Leche League leader left us to take up full timework. We so appreciate your reliable, support on a completley voluntarybasis. The groups could not have continued without you.Claire Bruce ran our popular baby music groups before leaving tohave her second baby, <strong>and</strong> was a great support to the Centre.We thank you, <strong>and</strong> hope you might come back some day Claire,<strong>and</strong> meantime wish you well looking after your girls.Yifat Haber started our wonderful International Group last year<strong>and</strong> Anna Neubert has been co-ordinating it over the last months.We would like to say thank you to all those women who havemade this group such a success <strong>and</strong> have offered your supportto other women who have recently arrived in Scotl<strong>and</strong>, or whoare far away from their countries <strong>and</strong> families.New facilitatorsWe welcome Julie Mason. We are delighted that Julie has comeback to facilitate the Thursday evening yoga for pregnancy sessions<strong>and</strong> is now running many of the birth preparation days.We are delighted that Jackie was able to come back from hermaternity leave to lead our baby music classes, as Claire wasleaving. Welcome back Jackie, <strong>and</strong> thank you for putting on extraclasses to try <strong>and</strong> meet the dem<strong>and</strong>..We also welcome Daisy Dinwoodie <strong>and</strong> Karen Haggis. They areour new Directors. Both Daisy <strong>and</strong> Karen have already contributeda huge amount to the Centre, working among otherthings on Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond (Daisy) <strong>and</strong> on our fundraising day<strong>and</strong> evening in November (both) <strong>and</strong> co-ordinating our Directorsmeetings (Karen).Finally we welcome Karla Napier. We are delighted that Karla hasrecently started facilitating our La Leache League Group twice amonth. It is much needed <strong>and</strong> we know that it will grow fromstrength to strength. (see page 17)birth&beyond 25


Timetable of BRC ClassesWeek-at-a-glanceMonday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sundayam09.45 – 11.00Baby Music11.15 – 12.30Toddler MusicJACKIE10 – 12Yoga forPregnancyNADINE10.30 – 12.00Parent Baby YogaANDREA10.00 – 11.15Toddler Music11.30 – 12.45Baby MusicJACKIE10.30 – 12.00LLL GroupBreastfeedingsupport2nd <strong>and</strong> 4th Fridayeach monthKARLA NAPIER10.00 – 4.00Birth PreparationWorkshops17th February16th March20th April17th May15th June11.00 – 1.00Home BirthSupport Group1st Sunday of eachmonthpmeve.1.00pm – 2.15Baby Music2.30pm– 4.00drop in sessionfree <strong>and</strong> open to all7.15pm – 9.15Yoga forPregnancy1.00pm – 2.15Baby MassageLINDA6.30pm – 8.30Yoga forPregnancy12.30pm – 2.00<strong>Post</strong> <strong>Natal</strong>Parent <strong>and</strong> BabyyogaANDREA1.15pm – 2.30Baby ShiatsuTAMSIN7.00pm – 9.00Yoga forPregnancy2.30pm – 4.301st <strong>and</strong> 3rdFriday of themonthInternational groupsupport groupfor international parents<strong>and</strong> childrenNADINE, JULIEOR KIMNADINENADINEJULIEFIRST AID AND LIFE-SAVING SKILLSAre you interested in learning some basic firstaid <strong>and</strong> life-saving skillswith a focus on children <strong>and</strong> babies?The Birth Resource Centre offers brief classes toparents <strong>and</strong> parents-to-be covering manyaspects of first aid including choking, seizures,burns, broken bones <strong>and</strong> fever.The half-day session is facilitated by adoctor who works in paediatrics<strong>and</strong> who is a mother of two small children.Please call the Birth Resource Centrefor availability <strong>and</strong> prices.26 birth&beyond


Notice BoardWaiting Lists / Class CancellationsWhen classes are full we keep a waiting list <strong>and</strong> will contact you when aplace becomes available. Please could you let us know if you move houseor change phone number so our records are up to date <strong>and</strong> we can letyou know when a place is available. Also very rarely a class might be cancelleddue to illness, again we'd like to be sure we can contact you <strong>and</strong>let you know in good time.Breastfeeding Support GroupWe are delighted that Karla Napier is facilitating La Leche League Supportgroups for breastfeeding on the 2nd <strong>and</strong> 4th Friday of each month. Youcan read more about this information on page 17.Useful ContactsLa Leche League (LLL)LLL provides support <strong>and</strong> information on all aspects of breastfeeding.Local contacts for information <strong>and</strong> breastfeeding support: Caron Howden01506 414010 (or email:caron@cbahowden.icuklive.co.uk)Ingrid 01383 731644 (or email: lll_fife@yahoo.co.uk)24 hour Helpline: connects you through a local advisor 0845 120 2918.Birth Resource Center (BRC)Classes / mail / meetings;18 St Peter's Place, Edinburgh. EH3 9PH(Reg Office ; 40 Leamington Terrace, Edinburgh EH10 4JL)Tel: 0131 229 3667, www.birthresourcecentre.org.ukSara Wickam Midwifewww.withwoman.co.uk<strong>Post</strong> <strong>Natal</strong> <strong>Depression</strong> ProjectProvides advice, counselling <strong>and</strong> information on post-natal depression.Phone: 0131 538 7288 for further details. Drop-in centres;8A Palmerston Place, West End, Tel: 0131 220 3547Brunstane Road North, Joppa, Tel: 0131 657 9844Natural Nurturing Network (NNN)Bi-monthly newsletter, summer camps <strong>and</strong>contact network 0116 288 0844.NNN, PO Box 5622, Wigston, Leicester, LE 18 2ZAwww.naturalnurturing.org.ukBook ReviewsIf you come across an interesting book, journal or other publication let usknow the details <strong>and</strong> we can contact the publisher for a review copy – thisis a great way to spread information <strong>and</strong> we put the books in the libraryafter review.If you would like to review a particular book for Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond pleasedo get in touch with Daisy 0131 333 07 88.Birth Resource CentreVolunteers Wanted! As you probably know we are a charity <strong>and</strong> arealways looking for volunteers or people to do fundraising.If you are interested in becoming involved, please contact Jo onvolunteers@birthresourcecentre.org.ukBirth Pool HireThe BRC has three pools for hire (two oval <strong>and</strong> one octagonal) for use athome or in hospital. The pools are strong, easy to set up, hired for a month<strong>and</strong> very affordable. If you are interessted in hiring a pool, please phonethe BRC or e-mail: izilove@gmail.com for availability <strong>and</strong> more information.Association for Improvements in Maternity Services (AIMS)The Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services (AIMS) providesa range of informative, readable booklets on the second <strong>and</strong> thirdstages of labour, home birth, water birth, VBAC, induction, breech birth<strong>and</strong> other topics as well as a lively Quarterly Journal.For a free Publications List please phone 0131 229 6259.National Childbirth Trust (NCT)Breastfeeding Support Line: 0870 444 8708.General enquiry Line: 0870 444 8707.For information on local activities, phone the NCT Edinburgh Centre on0131 668 3257 or visit the website www.nct-edinburgh.freeserve.co.ukNCT Centre, University Health Service, 5th Floor, 6 Bristo Square, EH8 9AL.Bumps & Babies Group meets Wednesdays 10.15am-11.45amat Blackhall Library, Hillhouse Road (on Queensferry Road)Buses Lothian 41 & 32, SMT 43.For expectant parents <strong>and</strong> babies up to 6 months.Hire of Valley Cushions(to ease post-birth discomfort when sitting), Liz Goudie 339 3454.Egnell Breast Pump HireLaura Joffe 0131 476 9228, Barbara Smith 0131 449 5734.BallsThe BRC always carries a small stock of the large green birthing balls.Women find these comfortable to sit on in pregnancy, kneel over in labour,<strong>and</strong> sit <strong>and</strong> rock their babies on post-natally. We like to make these availableat a reasonable cost <strong>and</strong> therefore only provide a local service. Thismeans that the balls can be sold to BRC users for £18 <strong>and</strong> others for £20,(cheaper than other sources). Please contact our co-ordinator or any ofour group facilitators for details.Letters PageHas anything in this issue sparked your interest, raised issues or questionsyou would like to comment on or discuss. We have a letters pageas a place for your thoughts <strong>and</strong> as a forum for discussion. Letters canbe sent to BRC, 40 Leamington Terrace, Edinburgh EH10 4JL markedFAO Birth <strong>and</strong> Beyond or by email to nadine@nadineedwards.org.uk.HomoeopathyThere is an Introduction to a homeopathy event on 9th March at theBRC. See page 24 for more information.First AidHave you wanted to know more about First Aid so that you can dealwith accidents or emergencies? You are lucky. We have courses comingup. Call us for more information.birth&beyond 27


Birth Resource CentreActivity Listings 2008What When Description Facilitator & CostYoga for Pregnancywith discussion <strong>and</strong>relaxationMondays: 7.15 – 9.15pmTuesdays: 10.00am – 12.00noon6.30pm – 8.30pmThursdays:7.00pm – 9.00pmA time to 'be' with yourself <strong>and</strong>your baby, to stretch, release <strong>and</strong>relax with gentle yoga, followed byan informal discussion of pregnancy<strong>and</strong> birth related issues.Led by Nadine Edwards orJulie Mason.£40 (£20 concession)for a 5 week blockBirth Preparation Workshopsfor women <strong>and</strong> theirbirth partnersSaturdays: 10.00am – 4.00pmNext workshop dates: Pleasephone or email.Extra workshops are run ondem<strong>and</strong>. Please contact us if youwould like to come but cannotmake the above dateOne day workshops which focuson support during labour,positions, massage <strong>and</strong> naturalbirth aids. Please enquire aboutadditional dates.Led by Nadine Edwardsor Julie Mason.£70 (£35 concession) for eachcouple; £85 (£42 concession) forwoman <strong>and</strong> two birth partners.Parent <strong>and</strong> Baby YogaWednesdays:10.30am – 12.00noon(4 mths to crawling)12.30pm – 2.00pm (under 4 mths)Fun, flexibility, ease <strong>and</strong> calmfor both parent & baby!Suitable for babies from newbornto crawling.Led by Andrea St Clair.£35 (£17.50 concession) fora 5 week blockBaby Massage Tuesdays : 1.00pm – 2.15pm Nurture your baby by learning thestrokes for baby massage.Baby Shiatsu Thursdays: 1.15pm – 2.30 pm Applying some Shiatsuprinciples to working with babies,using oil to gently stroke themeridian channels.Techniques <strong>and</strong> acupressurepoints for dealing with colic etc willalso be taught.Led by Linda Bendle or JulieOwenson.£30 (£15) per 5 week course.Led by Tamsin Grainger£30 (£15) per 5 week course.Baby MusicMondays:9.45am – 11.00am (Babies)11.15am – 12.30pm (Toddler)1.00pm – 2.15pm (Babies)Thursday:10.00am – 11.15am (older Babies)11.30am – 12.45pm (Babies)Songs, music <strong>and</strong> fun for babies.These classes are very popular, soplease phone before booking.Led by Jackie Macdonald£30 (£15 concession) for a 5 weekblockHomebirth Support GroupBreastfeedingSupport <strong>and</strong> Information1st Sunday of each month11.00 am – 1.00pm10.30am – 12.30pm2nd Friday La Leche League babygroup4th Friday of the month La LecheLeague older baby <strong>and</strong> toddlerAn Informal meeting place forexpectant parents consideringhomebirth to get together. Alsoan opportunity to ask any questionsyou may have <strong>and</strong> meetsome other parents who have hada homebirth.An informal get together for mums<strong>and</strong> a chance to get to know others<strong>and</strong> share breastfeeding successes<strong>and</strong> challenges.Led by Nicola Goodall <strong>and</strong>Kim BradieDonation £2/£1for tea <strong>and</strong> biscuitsLed by Karla NapierDonation £2/£1for tea <strong>and</strong> biscuitsInternational get together1st <strong>and</strong> 3rd Friday of the month2.30pm-4.30pmAre you pregnant or a mother<strong>and</strong> far from home?We aim to provide emotional support,an opportunity to meet otherwomen <strong>and</strong> make friends,exchange information about birth,pregnancy <strong>and</strong> local maternityservices.Donation £2/£1for tea <strong>and</strong> biscuitsPLEASE contact Jenny or Jo by phone 0131 229 3667 or emailbefore attending a class – details may change <strong>and</strong> someclasses may be fully booked.We offer concessionary rates on all classes.28 birth&beyond

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!