Beyond Greening - Tourism Watch
Beyond Greening - Tourism Watch
Beyond Greening - Tourism Watch
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Beyond</strong> <strong>Greening</strong>: Reflections on <strong>Tourism</strong> in the Rio-Process | PositioningpaperUN agency acts more as a tourism industry lobby than as a facilitator for sustainabledevelopment – in contravention to the principles of good governance.At grassroots level, the participation of local communities is a necessary condition forsustainable development. Participation is about much more than jobs and income; it is aboveall about people’s ownership and control of decision-making in matters that affect their lives.Where tourism is deemed an acceptable development option, participation ideally occurs inthe form of community-driven tourism. Community-driven initiatives benefit greatly fromthe exchange of experiences with other communities, from the involvement in civil societynetworks and from the support of NGOs. This applies particularly to coastal communitiesfacing similar threats across the globe, such as land grabbing by tourism enterprises,displacement, destruction of coastal ecosystems, industrial fishing, and rising sea levels. It alsoapplies to forest communities who in many parts of the world are displaced to make way fornational parks, in the name of conservation and “eco-tourism.” Alternative models, such asthe Brazilian concept of extractive reserves (RESEX), help local communities protect theirland and manage their resources sustainably.The way forwardWe have only a few decades left to deal intelligently with climate change, water stress and thedevastation of the last remaining essential ecosystems. In light of the current world situation,we are at a crossroads as a civilisation: the crisis of turbo-capitalism may lead to greaterinequality, misery and conflict, but it could also be an opportunity to begin to make peacewith the planet, provide possibilities for human development for the impoverished majority,and increase levels of real democracy.The mass tourism industry represents a serious obstacle to the task of creating a sustainableworld with a future where communities count and democracy is real. <strong>Tourism</strong> has a hugedirect and indirect influence on the global economy. It fuels expectations of indefinite growthon an environmentally precarious planet. It suffers from the hegemony of transnationalcorporations and their synergy with a financial capitalism focussed on by quick private profits,and it plays a role in our failure to improve human development in the countries concerned.It is very important to divorce the sustainable tourism concept from the idea of economicgrowth and GDP-centric development. <strong>Tourism</strong> is not a viable option for the poor and shouldnot be promoted as such. It is counter-productive to make poor nations dependent on anindustry like tourism that is highly vulnerable to many external factors.Agencies like UNWTO and UNEP should work out stringent regulatory mechanisms whichcan control unsustainable tourism practices instead of pushing for more market-basedsolutions. They should seriously take into account the concerns of global civil society andaffected populations. People's participation at various levels of governance is a key issue in anydiscussion related to sustainable development.Civil society organisations across the world engaged in challenging the harmful impacts oftourism and offering a critical perspective on this massive global industry need to link up andorganise themselves more effectively. There is immense potential for a global civil societynetwork to draw strength from its diversity while being unified under a call for just, equitable,democratic, people-centred and environmentally sustainable tourism – including the right ofcommunities to say no to the development of tourism in their homes.13