Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare (2008) - The Black Vault
Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare (2008) - The Black Vault Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare (2008) - The Black Vault
Incapacitating Agentsconditions and when administered in the open airunder simulated field conditions, showed it to be approximately60% as effective as when given orally orparenterally. When breathing is regulated at 1 L perbreath, 15 breaths per minute (the typical volume ofrespiration for a moderately active soldier), approximately80% of 1-µm aerosol particles (the optimal diameter)is retained by the lungs. Of this quantity about75% is actually absorbed; the remainder is inactivatedwithin the lung or bronchial lining. 93,94Most absorbed BZ is excreted via the urine afterhepatic metabolic processing. Edgewood chemist AlbertKondritzer studied the brain distribution of BZand found it to be eliminated in three stages, roughlyin parallel with the clinical phases of BZ symptoms. 95It appears to be most persistent in the hippocampusand other regions that control memory and cognitivefunctions.BZ produces anticholinergic drug effects similarto those produced by atropine and scopolamine, asdo many related synthetic belladonnoids. To makequantitative comparisons of the growing number ofrelated compounds subjected to testing, it becamenecessary to establish operational definitions of suchparameters as the minimal effective dose and the incapacitatingdose, as well as onset time, duration, andother important attributes. After much discussion, thefollowing definitions were adopted:• Minimal effective dose: dose required toproduce mild cognitive impairment in 50%of the exposed population. The thresholdfor a minimal effect is two successive scoresbelow 75% of baseline performance on the NFtest. 39• Incapacitating dose (ID 50): dose required toproduce two successive scores below 10%of baseline (at which point incapacitation isclinically obvious). 93• Onset time: time of first NF score below 25%of baseline, which for BZ is approximately 4hours.• Partial recovery time: time at which twosuccessive scores return to 25% or higher insubjects exposed to the ID 50. 94• Duration: number of hours between onsettime and partial recovery time in subjectsexposed to the ID 50.• Peripheral potency: dose required to elevateheart rate to a maximum of at least 100 beatsper minute. This heart rate was found to bethe most reliable indicator of a significantperipheral anticholinergic effect, regardlessof baseline heart rate. 94• Relative central potency: ratio of peripheralpotency to ID 50. This ratio was found to be usefulin estimating the median lethal dose (LD 50)of the belladonnoids, because peripheralpotency (manifested by heart rate increase)at the incapacitating dose is a predictor ofbelladonnoid lethality. 96Other operational definitions include full recoverytime (the percentage of patients returning to above75% of baseline for cognitive testing using the NF test),prolongation time (increase in duration at double theID 50), and dose-onset factor (degree to which onsettime is shortened as a function of dose).Features of BZ-Induced Delirium. Delirium is anonspecific syndrome. 90 Before the systematic study ofanticholinergic delirium, however, the clinical featuresof delirium had not been correlated with performanceof cognitive and other tasks under controlled conditions.In the following discussion, aspects of deliriumproduced by anticholinergic agents will be describedin relation to associated impairment in cognitiveperformance as measured by the facility test alreadydescribed.Following the administration of BZ at the minimumeffective dose, delirium appears in its mildestform, represented by a drowsy state, with occasionallapses of attention and slight difficulty followingcomplex instructions. Recovery is usually completeby 24 hours.Moderate delirium generally is manifested bysomnolence or mild stupor, indistinct speech, poorcoordination, and a generalized slowing of thoughtprocesses, along with some confusion and perplexity.Although sluggish, the subject remains in contact withthe environment most of the time, with occasional illusionsbut rarely true hallucinations. NF test scoresdecline by about 50%. Recovery occurs within 48 hours,and amnesia is minimal.Individuals receiving the ID 50or higher usuallydevelop the full syndrome of delirium. There is verylittle variation from person to person in their responseto BZ (or other belladonnoids), perhaps because thesedrugs operate more directly on the “hardware” of thebrain—neuronal systems where all-or-none activityis more characteristic. Drugs such as LSD, in contrast,act directly at specific serotonin and glutamate receptorsand indirectly on others, including dopamine,norepinephrine, and opioid µ-receptors, with effectsthat vary in relation to the prevailing mood, arousal,and motivational state of the subject.During the first few hours, subjects show increasingconfusion but remain oriented. When delirium ispresent in its full-blown state, however, the individual423
Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfareseems to be in a “waking dream,” staring and muttering,sometimes shouting, as simple items in theenvironment are variably perceived as structures, animals,or people. These hallucinations may arise fromsome trivial aspect of the surroundings: a strip of floormolding has been called a strip of bacon; a bulky objectled one subject to yell for help for an injured woman;and another described a Lilliputian baseball game onthe rubber padding, evidently stimulated by unevenpatches or shadows. A total lack of insight generallysurrounds these misperceptions.A striking characteristic of delirium is its fluctuationfrom moment to moment, with occasional lucidintervals during which appropriate answers are unexpectedlygiven to questions. Sometimes the correctanswer gets temporarily shunted aside. An example ofthis unusual phenomenon was a subject who spoutedgibberish when asked “who wrote Hamlet?” Whenasked where he lived a short time later, he answered,“Shakespeare.” Phantom behaviors, such as pluckingor picking at the air or at garments, are also characteristic.This behavior was termed “carphologia” in the 19thcentury. Sometimes two delirious individuals play offeach other’s imaginings. In one study one subject wasobserved to mumble, “Gotta cigarette?” and when hiscompanion held out a nonexistent pack, he followedwith, “S’okay, don’t wanna take your last one.”Recovery from drug-induced delirium is gradual,the duration presumably paralleling the pharmacokineticpersistence of the causative agent. The morespectacular and florid hallucinations are graduallyreplaced by more modest distortions in perception.For example, illusions of large animals are replacedby those of smaller animals. As awareness of thetime and place and recognition of people graduallyreturns, the subject enters a transitional phase duringwhich he recognizes that his mental faculties are notwhat they should be, but suspects that somethingelse is wrong. This may produce temporary paranoiddelusions and withdrawal (or occasionally an attemptto escape from the room). A psychiatrist might bereminded of similar states observed in some schizophrenicpatients.During the period from onset of maximum effectsuntil partial recovery at between 24 and 48 hours, thevolunteers are completely unable to perform any taskrequiring comprehension and problem-solving. Duringthis time and even during their gradual recovery,they are generally docile. Aggressive or assaultivebehavior does not occur, except in the form of momentsof irritability, sometimes punctuated by an attemptedpunch or other expression of annoyance. “Berserk”behavior or attack with an object is absent, contraryto some descriptions by those unfamiliar with the BZdelirious syndrome. Confusion may give way to panicin a few subjects as they near recovery, but this is alwaysmotivated by fear of imagined harm, and neverby a desire to inflict severe bodily injury. Not once inseveral hundred drug-induced delirious states duringthe BZ studies was significant injury inflicted on theattending staff.A period of restorative sleep generally precedes thereturn to normal cognitive function, accompanied bycheerful emotions. Many of the BZ subjects describeda feeling of well-being following recovery. Initially, asreflected in their posttest write-ups, those who hadbeen delirious can recall some events, but, as withdreams, their recollection soon fades. Thereafter, thesefleeting memories are forgotten, in keeping with theclinical adage that delirium of all types is followedby amnesia.Other glycolates. At least a dozen synthetic glycolateswere provided to Edgewood Arsenal for testing involunteer subjects. John Biel, at Lakeside Laboratories,Milwaukee, Wisconsin, prepared many of these compounds,making it possible to compare belladonnoidstructures that differed only quantitatively in suchparameters as potency, duration, speed of onset, andrelative central potency. 96 His colleague, Leo Abood,was an early pioneer in the study of many of thesecompounds and formulated useful structure/activityrelationships showing that duration and potency,for example, could be predicted from the position ofparticular features of the structure, such as the locationof a hydroxyl moiety. Testing in volunteers validatedmany of these observations about structure. Abood’schapter in a National Academy of Sciences publicationon chemical agents also contains a useful compilationof the number of volunteers tested at Edgewood Arsenalwith each belladonnoid and a summary of theobserved effects. 97Abood adds his personal knowledge of three graduatestudents who surreptitiously ingested up to 10mg of BZ and were hospitalized. All three studentshad been in academic difficulty and had considereddropping out of school; however, after their recovery,their academic performance improved dramatically,and all went on to obtain PhDs and continue in gainfulemployment. In addition, several independentobservers thought the students seemed happier andbetter adjusted. These unexpected changes tend to corroborateprevious claims of psychiatric benefits frombelladonna-induced coma therapy. 98–100Many synthetic belladonnoids were tested in thevolunteers. Some of these were found to be more potentwith fewer side effects, such as no significant increasein heart rate. 101–105 Testing continued to find syntheticbelladonnoids with much shorter duration and withfull recovery occurring within 1 to 2 days, making aconvenient agent against which to test antidotes. 106–111424
- Page 395 and 396: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 397 and 398: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 399 and 400: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 401 and 402: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 403 and 404: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 405 and 406: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 407 and 408: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 409 and 410: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 411 and 412: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 413 and 414: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 415 and 416: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 417 and 418: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 419 and 420: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 421 and 422: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 423 and 424: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 425 and 426: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 427 and 428: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 429 and 430: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 431 and 432: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 433 and 434: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 435 and 436: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 437 and 438: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 439 and 440: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 441 and 442: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 443 and 444: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 445: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 449 and 450: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 451 and 452: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 453 and 454: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 455 and 456: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 457 and 458: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 459 and 460: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 461 and 462: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 463 and 464: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 465 and 466: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 467 and 468: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 469 and 470: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 471 and 472: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 473 and 474: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 475 and 476: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 477 and 478: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 479 and 480: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 481 and 482: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 483 and 484: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 485 and 486: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 487 and 488: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 489 and 490: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 491 and 492: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 493 and 494: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
- Page 495 and 496: Medical Aspects of Chemical Warfare
<strong>Medical</strong> <strong>Aspects</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Chemical</strong> <strong>Warfare</strong>seems to be in a “waking dream,” staring and muttering,sometimes shouting, as simple items in theenvironment are variably perceived as structures, animals,or people. <strong>The</strong>se hallucinations may arise fromsome trivial aspect <strong>of</strong> the surroundings: a strip <strong>of</strong> floormolding has been called a strip <strong>of</strong> bacon; a bulky objectled one subject to yell for help for an injured woman;and another described a Lilliputian baseball game onthe rubber padding, evidently stimulated by unevenpatches or shadows. A total lack <strong>of</strong> insight generallysurrounds these misperceptions.A striking characteristic <strong>of</strong> delirium is its fluctuationfrom moment to moment, with occasional lucidintervals during which appropriate answers are unexpectedlygiven to questions. Sometimes the correctanswer gets temporarily shunted aside. An example <strong>of</strong>this unusual phenomenon was a subject who spoutedgibberish when asked “who wrote Hamlet?” Whenasked where he lived a short time later, he answered,“Shakespeare.” Phantom behaviors, such as pluckingor picking at the air or at garments, are also characteristic.This behavior was termed “carphologia” in the 19thcentury. Sometimes two delirious individuals play <strong>of</strong>feach other’s imaginings. In one study one subject wasobserved to mumble, “Gotta cigarette?” and when hiscompanion held out a nonexistent pack, he followedwith, “S’okay, don’t wanna take your last one.”Recovery from drug-induced delirium is gradual,the duration presumably paralleling the pharmacokineticpersistence <strong>of</strong> the causative agent. <strong>The</strong> morespectacular and florid hallucinations are graduallyreplaced by more modest distortions in perception.For example, illusions <strong>of</strong> large animals are replacedby those <strong>of</strong> smaller animals. As awareness <strong>of</strong> thetime and place and recognition <strong>of</strong> people graduallyreturns, the subject enters a transitional phase duringwhich he recognizes that his mental faculties are notwhat they should be, but suspects that somethingelse is wrong. This may produce temporary paranoiddelusions and withdrawal (or occasionally an attemptto escape from the room). A psychiatrist might bereminded <strong>of</strong> similar states observed in some schizophrenicpatients.During the period from onset <strong>of</strong> maximum effectsuntil partial recovery at between 24 and 48 hours, thevolunteers are completely unable to perform any taskrequiring comprehension and problem-solving. Duringthis time and even during their gradual recovery,they are generally docile. Aggressive or assaultivebehavior does not occur, except in the form <strong>of</strong> moments<strong>of</strong> irritability, sometimes punctuated by an attemptedpunch or other expression <strong>of</strong> annoyance. “Berserk”behavior or attack with an object is absent, contraryto some descriptions by those unfamiliar with the BZdelirious syndrome. Confusion may give way to panicin a few subjects as they near recovery, but this is alwaysmotivated by fear <strong>of</strong> imagined harm, and neverby a desire to inflict severe bodily injury. Not once inseveral hundred drug-induced delirious states duringthe BZ studies was significant injury inflicted on theattending staff.A period <strong>of</strong> restorative sleep generally precedes thereturn to normal cognitive function, accompanied bycheerful emotions. Many <strong>of</strong> the BZ subjects describeda feeling <strong>of</strong> well-being following recovery. Initially, asreflected in their posttest write-ups, those who hadbeen delirious can recall some events, but, as withdreams, their recollection soon fades. <strong>The</strong>reafter, thesefleeting memories are forgotten, in keeping with theclinical adage that delirium <strong>of</strong> all types is followedby amnesia.Other glycolates. At least a dozen synthetic glycolateswere provided to Edgewood Arsenal for testing involunteer subjects. John Biel, at Lakeside Laboratories,Milwaukee, Wisconsin, prepared many <strong>of</strong> these compounds,making it possible to compare belladonnoidstructures that differed only quantitatively in suchparameters as potency, duration, speed <strong>of</strong> onset, andrelative central potency. 96 His colleague, Leo Abood,was an early pioneer in the study <strong>of</strong> many <strong>of</strong> thesecompounds and formulated useful structure/activityrelationships showing that duration and potency,for example, could be predicted from the position <strong>of</strong>particular features <strong>of</strong> the structure, such as the location<strong>of</strong> a hydroxyl moiety. Testing in volunteers validatedmany <strong>of</strong> these observations about structure. Abood’schapter in a National Academy <strong>of</strong> Sciences publicationon chemical agents also contains a useful compilation<strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> volunteers tested at Edgewood Arsenalwith each belladonnoid and a summary <strong>of</strong> theobserved effects. 97Abood adds his personal knowledge <strong>of</strong> three graduatestudents who surreptitiously ingested up to 10mg <strong>of</strong> BZ and were hospitalized. All three studentshad been in academic difficulty and had considereddropping out <strong>of</strong> school; however, after their recovery,their academic performance improved dramatically,and all went on to obtain PhDs and continue in gainfulemployment. In addition, several independentobservers thought the students seemed happier andbetter adjusted. <strong>The</strong>se unexpected changes tend to corroborateprevious claims <strong>of</strong> psychiatric benefits frombelladonna-induced coma therapy. 98–100Many synthetic belladonnoids were tested in thevolunteers. Some <strong>of</strong> these were found to be more potentwith fewer side effects, such as no significant increasein heart rate. 101–105 Testing continued to find syntheticbelladonnoids with much shorter duration and withfull recovery occurring within 1 to 2 days, making aconvenient agent against which to test antidotes. 106–111424