12.07.2015 Views

James Phillips Introduction For those of you not famil

James Phillips Introduction For those of you not famil

James Phillips Introduction For those of you not famil

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

22extreme retaliation. And as was <strong>not</strong>ed above, he was appropriately aggrieved that the judgedeprived him <strong>of</strong> the personal autonomy to represent himself, even after he had been found by thegovernment psychiatrist to be competent. In this situation his worst nightmare had come true -the machinery <strong>of</strong> government depriving him <strong>of</strong> what, legally, should have been his legal right todefend himself.In this discussion <strong>of</strong> how the theme <strong>of</strong> personal freedom is interwoven in the personaland ideological life <strong>of</strong> Kaczynski, we should <strong>not</strong>e that it is quite commonplace in any kind <strong>of</strong>intellectual, artistic, or political enterprise that the creative individual will engage the largeractivity to work through personal issues. Indeed, we expect that; it is what provides much <strong>of</strong> theenergy for the larger project. Freud termed this process sublimation, and his word has becomepart <strong>of</strong> public language.In trying to understand Kaczynski’s attitude toward freedom, what is striking is the wayin which he has turned everything on its head. This is <strong>not</strong> sublimation as we ordinarilyunderstand it. <strong>For</strong> Freud it represented the effort to contain primitive impulse by channeling itinto creative, intellectual activity. <strong>For</strong> Kaczynski, however, the primitive impulse to hate and killis <strong>not</strong> converted into creative activity - as it might well have been if he had been satisfied withpublishing his critique <strong>of</strong> modern technology. Rather, the critique takes on a<strong>not</strong>her role. Ratherthan functioning merely as a sublimation <strong>of</strong> the primitive drive, it becomes the rationale foracting out the drive.We can move the discussion onto a philosophical plain and find the same upending <strong>of</strong>expected relationships. The philosopher who most strongly argued for personal autonomy wasKant. But for Kant such autonomy was associated with our ability to act as moral agents, both inthe sense <strong>of</strong> determining on our own our moral obligations and in the sense <strong>of</strong> being able to

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!