<strong>Innovation</strong> <strong>Canada</strong>: A <strong>Call</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Action</strong>Box 7.3 Germany’s Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft aThe Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft (F-G) organization operates 60 Fraunhofer institutes inGermany. These cus<strong>to</strong>mer-oriented, applied research institutes strive <strong>to</strong> transform scientificfindings in<strong>to</strong> useful innovations. The institutes’ focus on application-oriented research issituated within the broader spectrum of the German research system — a spectrum thatincludes, at one end, the publicly funded, basic research-oriented Max Planck Society and, atthe other end, privately funded industrial research.The F-G’s threefold mission is (i) <strong>to</strong> promote and undertake research in an internationalcontext of direct utility <strong>to</strong> private and public enterprise and of wide benefit <strong>to</strong> society as awhole, (ii) <strong>to</strong> reinforce the competitive strength of the economy by developingtechnological innovations and novel systems solutions for their cus<strong>to</strong>mers and (iii) <strong>to</strong>provide a platform that enables staff <strong>to</strong> develop the necessary professional and personalskills <strong>to</strong> assume positions of responsibility within their institute, in industry and in otherscientific domains. As institutes are encouraged <strong>to</strong> work with industry, only about a third ofbase funding comes from government. Institutes must secure the remaining revenue fromother sources, which typically comes in roughly equal proportions from industry and publiccontracts and project funding.The Fraunhofer institutes provide highly specialized expertise that may be <strong>to</strong>o expensive forany mid-sized company <strong>to</strong> build up and may also be beyond the scope of consultingcompanies. By connecting with universities and technical institutes/universities of appliedscience, and by applying for competitive research grants, the F-G institutes retain an edge inscience and technology. Indeed, the grants are used for advanced work that is well ahead ofthe marketplace but has been identified as potentially important <strong>to</strong> client companies in theyears <strong>to</strong> come.In summary, the Fraunhofer institutes are characterized by (i) professional R&D services <strong>to</strong>industry, (ii) demand-driven research combined with scientific excellence, (iii) strongintegration with academia and (iv) au<strong>to</strong>nomy combined with simple corporate rules and astrong brand.a Information drawn from the Fraunhofer website at: www.fraunhofer.de; and Panel consultations.<strong>Canada</strong>’s large-scale research collaboration gapby evolving the majority of its current institutesin<strong>to</strong> a national network of institutes focussed onlarge-scale collaborative research motivated byindustrial needs. To achieve this vision, greatcare will be needed <strong>to</strong> establish a process that,over time and in dialogue with partners, enablesthe NRC <strong>to</strong> focus on this opportunity withoutlosing the value for <strong>Canada</strong> from its otheractivities.The Panel’s consultations elicited statements ofstrong support for IRAP’s role in supporting R&Dand innovation by SMEs but, notably, there wasnot comparable testimony regarding therelevance and role of the NRC’s institutes. This,<strong>to</strong>gether with the other considerations outlinedabove, suggests that there is both the need andopportunity <strong>to</strong> focus and reorganize the NRC’snational assets <strong>to</strong> more effectively andstrategically support innovation in <strong>Canada</strong>. ThePanel endorses the plans currently under way <strong>to</strong>reorient certain NRC institutes <strong>to</strong> place greater7-8
Filling the GapsBox 7.4 Institutes of the National Research Council withinthe ReviewTotal appropriations for the 17 NRC institutes within this review averaged almost$290 million annually over the four fiscal years, 2007–08 through 2010–11. The institutesreferred <strong>to</strong> the Panel are:Biotechnology Research InstituteCanadian Hydraulics CentreCentre for Surface TransportationTechnologyIndustrial Materials InstituteInstitute for Aerospace ResearchInstitute for BiodiagnosticsInstitute for Biological SciencesInstitute for Chemical Process andEnvironmental TechnologyInstitute for Fuel Cell <strong>Innovation</strong>Institute for Information TechnologyInstitute for Marine BiosciencesInstitute for Microstructural SciencesInstitute for Ocean TechnologyInstitute for Research in ConstructionNational Institute for NanotechnologyPlant Biotechnology InstituteSteacie Institute for Molecular Sciencesemphasis on industry priorities andcollaboration, but believes that an evenmore comprehensive reform is needed.Recommendation 4Transform the institutes of theNational Research Council (NRC)in<strong>to</strong> a constellation of large-scale,sec<strong>to</strong>ral collaborative R&D centresinvolving business, the universitysec<strong>to</strong>r and the provinces, whiletransferring NRC public policyrelatedresearch activity <strong>to</strong> theappropriate federal agencies.The Vision of the Panel<strong>Canada</strong> needs a fundamentally new approach<strong>to</strong> building public–private researchcollaborations in areas of strategic importanceand opportunity for the economy. Over the nextfive years, several of the NRC institutes mustevolve <strong>to</strong> become a core constellation ofresearch and technology centres, mandated <strong>to</strong>collaborate closely with business in key sec<strong>to</strong>rsand focussed on achieving measurable progressin this mission. Individual institutes shouldbecome focal points for the development ofR&D and innovation strategies for key sec<strong>to</strong>rs,for major enabling technologies and for regionalclusters.Getting ThereTo realize this vision, the Panel recommends thefollowing.4.1 Evolution of the NRC — Charge the NRC<strong>to</strong> develop a plan for each of its existinginstitutes and major business units thatwould require their evolution over the nextfive years in<strong>to</strong> one of the following:(a) an industry-oriented non-profit researchorganization mandated <strong>to</strong> undertakecollaborative R&D and commercialization7-9