Report and Recommendations - Scottish Government
Report and Recommendations - Scottish Government Report and Recommendations - Scottish Government
Annex ESubgroup & individual meetingsDate Attendees Issues discussed13 thDecember2010John Dunn• Police questioning• Detention and arrest and charge• Law, practice and culture in England15 thDecember201016 thDecember201016 thDecember201017 thDecember201025 th January201126 th January2011David StrangPeter DuffIan BryceGerry MoynihanJohn ScottShelagh McCallJohn DunnIan BryceGerry MoynihanJohn Scott• Timing of charge• Arrest, detention and charge• Reform of the detention model• Police questioning• Police powers• Time period of detention• PACE• Evidence• The approach in France and the role of theexamining magistrate• When the right to legal advice arises• Police charge• The requirement of fairness• Arrest, caution and charge• Period of detention and custody• Police questioning• Rights pre- and post-charge• Police charge• The right to silence• Victims and the general public• Disclosure of evidence• Admissibility of evidence• The emergency legislation• Limits placed on liberty• The rights of victims and of suspects• Convention compliance• Section 14 detention• Police questioning• Police charge• Right against self-incrimination• Vulnerable people• Police charge• Prompt appearance at court• Judicial control over detention and questioning• Police bail• The nature of police questioning• Questioning after appearance in court• Provision of information prior to interview• Provision of legal assistance in practice• Legal aid• The right of access to a lawyer• Prompt appearance at court394
Annex ESubgroup & individual meetings – continued31 st January201131 st January20111 st February20113 rd February20113 rd February201123 February20113 rd March2011Liz Munro• Detention and Arrest• Fairness• Police Charge• Prompt Appearance at Court• Police Bail• CorroborationShelagh McCall • Right of access to a lawyer• Nature of police questioning• Prompt appearance at court• Other Convention ArticlesDavid Strang • Investigation of crime• Interdependencies of the criminal justice system• Adverse inference from silence• Demand for legal advice• The purpose of arrest• Liberation by the police• Questioning a child or vulnerable adult• Role of the responsible or appropriate adult• Disclosure of evidence• Police questioningLindsay Montgomery • The provision of legal advice• Jurisprudence from the UK Supreme Court andECtHR• The duty solicitor scheme – call centre• Vulnerable adults and children• The need for guidance to solicitors• Waiver• Other agencies with interrogative powersPeter Duff• The right of access to a lawyer• Other European jurisdictions• Admissibility of evidence• Questioning of child or vulnerable suspects• Sufficiency of evidence• Admissibility of statementsLindsay Montgomery • The provision of legal advice• Jurisprudence from the UK Supreme Court andECtHR• The duty solicitor scheme – call centre• Vulnerable adults and children• The need for guidance to solicitors• Waiver• Other agencies with interrogative powersShelagh McCall • Corroboration• Sufficiency of evidence• Admissions by children and vulnerable suspects• The role of the SCCRC and Appeal Court• Appeals procedure• Carloway Review roadshows395
- Page 346 and 347: ConsiderationSolemn Appeals8.1.23 T
- Page 348 and 349: why the application is late 66 . Fu
- Page 350 and 351: case may be, by advocation against
- Page 352 and 353: e achieved by amendment of section
- Page 354 and 355: power ought to be retained on the b
- Page 356 and 357: 354
- Page 358 and 359: Thus, where there is a change of la
- Page 360 and 361: have his/her case referred back to
- Page 362 and 363: 8.2.9 It was perceived that there w
- Page 364 and 365: interests of justice, should be con
- Page 366 and 367: conviction be quashed. This applies
- Page 368 and 369: for undermining the important role
- Page 370 and 371: References to the High Court8.2.25
- Page 372 and 373: 370
- Page 374 and 375: 372Annex A
- Page 376 and 377: Annex AFiscal) to assess these case
- Page 378 and 379: Annex Aconviction, were the rule of
- Page 380 and 381: 378Annex A
- Page 382 and 383: Annex BRight of access to a lawyer
- Page 384 and 385: Annex BRight of access to a lawyer
- Page 386 and 387: Annex BPolice questioning after cha
- Page 388 and 389: 386Annex C
- Page 390 and 391: 388Annex D
- Page 392 and 393: Annex ELondon - 18 th -19 th May 20
- Page 394 and 395: Annex EConsultative Meetings - cont
- Page 398 and 399: Annex ESubgroup & individual meetin
- Page 400 and 401: Annex EConferences/SeminarsLord Car
- Page 402 and 403: Annex FTable 2 - Organisations that
- Page 404 and 405: Annex GUnited Kingdom Parliament -
- Page 406 and 407: Annex GCases referred to in this Re
- Page 408 and 409: Annex GGordon v HM Advocate 2010 SC
- Page 410 and 411: Annex GParker v The Queen [2007] NT
- Page 412 and 413: Annex GBooks (continued)Title Autho
- Page 414: Annex GArticles (continued)Title Au
Annex ESubgroup & individual meetings – continued31 st January201131 st January20111 st February20113 rd February20113 rd February201123 February20113 rd March2011Liz Munro• Detention <strong>and</strong> Arrest• Fairness• Police Charge• Prompt Appearance at Court• Police Bail• CorroborationShelagh McCall • Right of access to a lawyer• Nature of police questioning• Prompt appearance at court• Other Convention ArticlesDavid Strang • Investigation of crime• Interdependencies of the criminal justice system• Adverse inference from silence• Dem<strong>and</strong> for legal advice• The purpose of arrest• Liberation by the police• Questioning a child or vulnerable adult• Role of the responsible or appropriate adult• Disclosure of evidence• Police questioningLindsay Montgomery • The provision of legal advice• Jurisprudence from the UK Supreme Court <strong>and</strong>ECtHR• The duty solicitor scheme – call centre• Vulnerable adults <strong>and</strong> children• The need for guidance to solicitors• Waiver• Other agencies with interrogative powersPeter Duff• The right of access to a lawyer• Other European jurisdictions• Admissibility of evidence• Questioning of child or vulnerable suspects• Sufficiency of evidence• Admissibility of statementsLindsay Montgomery • The provision of legal advice• Jurisprudence from the UK Supreme Court <strong>and</strong>ECtHR• The duty solicitor scheme – call centre• Vulnerable adults <strong>and</strong> children• The need for guidance to solicitors• Waiver• Other agencies with interrogative powersShelagh McCall • Corroboration• Sufficiency of evidence• Admissions by children <strong>and</strong> vulnerable suspects• The role of the SCCRC <strong>and</strong> Appeal Court• Appeals procedure• Carloway Review roadshows395