Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ... - Social Watch

Saving Visayas:Issues, Initiatives and Innovationsin Environmental ManagementBy Jessica Dator-Bercilla, Prof. Carlos Magtolis, Joseph Raymond, PROCESS-Bohol and Green Forum*73Saving VisayasThe Visayas group of islands located at the heart of thePhilippines, was defined by political geography in threeclusters: Eastern Visayas with the provinces of Biliran,Eastern Samar, Northern Leyte, Northern Samar,Southern Leyte, Western Samar; Central Visayascomposed of Bohol, Cebu, Negros Oriental and Siquijor;and Western Visayas which includes Aklan, Antique,Capiz, Guimaras, Iloilo and Negros Occidental. Theseprovinces are located in the islands of Samar, Negros,Panay, Leyte, Cebu, Bohol, Siquijor, Guimaras.Though some of these islands are among thelargest in the Philippines, the Visayan islands aretechnically small islands — many with access tocoastal and lowland resources but with minimal highmountain peaks. The highest peaks of these groupof islands can be located in Panay (the Baloy-Madiaas Mountain Range) and Canlaon in Negros.Cebu has mountains no higher than 2000 ft, Samarhas irregular mounds of hills, while Bohol andGuimaras are basically hilly in some parts. Visayasboasts of centers for trade and industry (e.g. Cebu,Iloilo, Negros Occidental) and rich coastal resources(e.g. Visayan and Bohol seas), world-class beachresorts (e.g. Boracay and Panglao islands) andecotourism areas (e.g. Bohol, Dumaguete, Guimarasand Aklan in Panay island) Except for Cebu, many ofthe smaller islands depend on coastal resourceswhile the larger islands (e.g. Negros and Panay)lead in agricultural production.Monitoring the state of the environmentPressure on Fisheries ResourcesThe foremost challenge in assessing the state ofthe environment is the access to official governmentdata needed to establish upland, lowland and fisheriesenvironmental trends within the 1990-2004 timeframe. The fisheries sector has the most comprehensivedata based on fisheries production, but the dataset does not provide an analysis vis a vis supply.Alternative data sources indicate that as populationgrowth soars, attempts at increasing fisheries productiondrive fisheries resources to a rapid decline.The waters surrounding the Visayas hostabundant marine resources—but droves of smalland commercial fishers are threatening thesustainability of sea resources owing to over-andirresponsible fishing. Even at the present state ofexploitation and open access fishing, the Visayasseas are among those with highest fish yields. TheBureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources tables 1on the next page show this.Assessment in 2002 put Regions VI and VIIIamong the top three in municipal fisheries productionand Region VI among the highest in commercialfisheries production. Yet, the productive yields1Department of Agriculture BFAR, Commercial and Municipal Fisheriesby Major Fishing Grounds, www.bfar.da.gov.ph accessed on 28January 2005* Jessica Dator-Bercilla is a faculty member of the Division of Social Sciences, University of the Philippines in the Visayas, Miag-ao, Iloilo; Prof. CarlosMagtolis is the Dean of College of Arts and Sciences at Silliman University, Dumaguete City; Joseph Raymond is a professor of History and PoliticalScience at Silliman University, Dumaguete City; PROCESS-Bohol is an NGO which has a comprehensive Integrated Coastal Resource Management(ICRM) program using participatory approach working closely with LGUs for the coastal communities; Green Forum is an NGO based in Iloilo workingon issues affecting indigenous people in upland communities.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

74Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementFigure 1. Volume of Fish Production,By Sector 1993- 20024.0Figure 2. Philippine Fisheries Decline804,000,0003.570(in metric ton)3,500,0003,000,0002,500,0002,000,0001,500,0001,000,000AquacultureMunicipalCommercialTotal(CPUE/t/hp)3.02.52.01.51.0Catch per unit effort for smallpelagic municipal fisheries6050403020Population (million)500,0000.51001993 199419951996 1997 1998 1999Year20002001200201950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000Year0Source: Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources 2 Source: FISH Project 3Table 1. Average percentage shareof Marine Municipal FisheriesProduction by Major Fishing Grounds,1992-1995 (in MT)Fishing Ground Total % to Total1. Visayan Sea 92,885 11.502. Bohol Sea 84,305 10.443. East Sulu Sea 78, 491 9.724. Moro Gulf 74,765 9.265. Guimaras Strait 55,106 6.826. South Sulu Sea 44,000 5.457.West Palawan Waters 38,4444 4.768. Lamon Bay 37.138 4.609. Leyte Gulf 36,587 4.5310. Samar Sea 35,622 4.4111. Davao Gulf 28,365 3.5112. Cuyo Pass 27,253 3.3713. Tayabas Bay 22,500 2.7914. Others 152,063 18.83Total 807,524 100.00Table 2. Average percentage shareof total commercial fishProduction by Major Fishing Grounds,1992-1995 (in MT)Fishing Ground Total % to Total1.West Palawan Waters 158,220 18.712. South Sulu Sea 149,243 17.653.Visayan Sea 137,942 16.324. Moro Gulf 98,050 11.605. Lamon Bay 41,901 4.966. Bohol Sea 34,263 4.057. East Sulu Sea 29,071 3.448. International Waters 25,558 3.029. Leyte Gulf Samar Sea 23,385 2.7710.Guimaras Strait 23,382 2.7711. Manila Bay 21,899 2.5912. Tayabas Bay 19,826 2.3513. Sibuyan Bay 15,434 1.8314. Others 67,272 7.96Total 845,446 100.0Table 3. Total Fish Production (Metric Tons) 5Region 1997 1998 1999 2000 20012002(Jan-Mar)2003(Jan-Mar)VI 320,961 309,174 337,070 356,998.2 357,596 81,385.3 81,255.6VII 153,970 152,332 159,243 164,545 191,531 51,853.3 51,080.9VIII 73,707 72,312 76,200 78,728 91,318 24,126.7 28,698.3cannot hide the issues confronting the seas ofVisayas and its coastal communities. Many of theislands are in the list of priorty areas for marinebiodiversity conservation 4 because of threats to thediverse marine resources. Among these sites arethe Apo. Sumilon, Panglao-Balicasag, Pamilacan,Bais, Mactan, Olango Islands in Central Visayas;Taklong Island in Western Visayas; and Guiuan,Rapurapu and Polilio in Eastern Visayas.A study on the status and trends of fisheries inCentral Visayas 6 puts a different light on the produc-2BFAR (2004), Fisheries Profile, Department of Agriculture: Bureau ofFisheries and Aquatic Resources from www.bfar.gov.ph .3Dalzell P., P. Corpuz, R. Ganaden and D. Pauly, 1987. Estimation ofMaximum Sustainable Yield and Maximum Economic Rent from thePhilippine Small Pelagic Fisheries: BFAR Tech Pap. Ser. 10(3): 23 p.4Alino and Uychiaoco 1995 in Uychiaoco, Arceo, Alino, Cheung, et. al.in Marine Protected Areas in Southeast Asia: Philippines, www.arbc.org.ph/BISS/MarinePA/ph1.htm accessed on 5 February 2005.5Bureau of Agricultural Statistics, Fisheries Statistics of the Philippines(1997-2001), Philippines: Department of Agriculture, 2003.6Green, S., Flores, J., Dizon-Corales, J., Martinez, R., Nunal D. R.,Armada, N., White, A. (2004). The Fisheries of Central Visayas,Philippines: Status and Trends. Cebu City: Coastal ResourceManagement Project of the Department of Environment and NaturalResources and the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources of theDepartment of Agriculture, 159p.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management75tion rates from the area. Over the last four decades,the catch per unit effort decreased among municipalfishers across time while commercial fishersaccount for about 60 percent of all landed fish in theregion. This is viewed as an indication of weakcoastal law enforcement in municipal waters.Overfishing (e.g. economic, ecological, growth,recruitment) has been identified since the 1980s.Ecosystem change is manifested by a shift in thequality of fish catch (from demersals to coastalpelagics and from shrimp-dominant to squiddominantcatch) in the region. The absence of clearpolitical boundaries, illegal fishing in municipalwaters, over efficient fishing gear and degradedhabitat were cited as worsening the state of thefishery ecosystem in Central Visayas.Extent of deforestationAccessing upland data set was difficult. Onlyforestry data for 1960s-1989 and 2003 were availablein the regional offices of the Visayas. The 2003data are still under validation. Thus, any data fromthe time frame of interest are but projections.Attempts at extracting data from the national databaseon forestry were limited by current changes indata management in DENR’s forestry website.The extent of forest destruction in the Philippinesin general is alarming as the table belowshows. However, the 1988 Haribon-generated image(based on NAMRIA, 1988 references) and theTREES-generated image of the deforestation rate inthe Philippines presented below, will highlight theextent of deforestation in the Visayas. The area,thus, is an identified site of endangered speciesbecause of its threatened ecosystem.Table 4. Trail of Forest Destruction in the Philippines 7YearRemaining forest cover (Millionsof hectares)1575 27.51920 18.71934 171967 10.41972 10.11980 17.41987 6.71995 5.4Figure 4. Extent of Deforestation in the PhilippinesSource: Haribon,2005 8Figure 5. Forest Cover Map of the PhilippinesAgricultural productivityand biodiversity lossThe drive for agricultural productivity in thePhilippines came with poverty alleviation measuresto ensure food security through modernization.Among the major producers of palay in the countryare from Western Visayas. The yield in that regionis indicated below.The high yields, however, mask the biodiversityloss, raised by civil society organizations and7Bantayan, Nathaniel, Geomatics-Assisted Impact Assessment ofLand-use Change on the Biodiversity of Mt. Makiling, Philippines,paper presented at the 22nd Asian Conference on Remote Sensing,Singapore, 2001.8Generated from NAMRIA, 1988 references accessed from HaribonFoundation for the Conservation of Natural Resources, 2005,www.haribon.org.ph .9Stibig, H.J., Beuchle , R. and Javier, P. 2002.TREES PublicationSeries, D:N:3, EUR 20123 EN European Commission, LuxembourgSource: Stibig, et. al., 2002 9SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

76Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementTable 5. Production(in Metric Tons) Region VI 101990 1995 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002Palay 886,732 1,291,275 1,044,462 1,531,728 1,608,337 1,589,531 1,732,602Irrigated 450,499 747,646 630,250 922,355 976,772 945,759 990,945Rainfed 436,233 543,629 414,212 609,373 631,565 643,772 741,657Corn 34,353 57,600 77,619 68,510 80,340 75,540 87,065White 8,027 18,547 28,429 27,512 36,042 31,765 34,588Yellow 26,326 39,053 49,190 40,998 44,298 43,775 52,477farming communities. Identified as a primary threatis the government program promoting a limited setof crop varieties (e.g. hybrid rice, Btcorn) to promoteagricultural productivity. Disaggregated dataon land area planted to crop varieties, however,have yet to be comprehensively generated.This paper attempts to give readers snapshotsof the current environmental state of the Visayasand the initiatives to secure its natural resources.Below are case studies of coastal, lowland andupland areas.Threatened Fishery Ecosystemand Coastal Resource ManagementInitiatives at securing the coastal and fisheryresources have been a long struggle for manycommunities, local government units and concernedsectors. Issues and attempts at coastal resourcemanagement in the Visayan waters and islands arefound below.The Visayan SeaAngel Alcala, former secretary of the Departmentof Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)and well-respected academic, has aptly summarizedthe problem of one of the largest fishinggrounds of the Visayas, the Visayan sea (enclosedby Panay, Negros, Cebu and Masbate islands). In hisresearch on Negros and Northeastern Panay in2004, Mr. Alcala notes : “The Visayan Sea was oncea very fishery-productive inland sea of the Philippines.But 50-60 years ago, the sea was heavilyfished by trawlers with the approval of the BFAR.The Visayan Sea also hosts some of the terrestrialspecies endemic to central Philippines, indicating itsevolutionary importance… The overexploited morevaluable fish species have been replaced by the lessnutritious species of squids and cuttlefish, followingthe known trend in other similar depleted areas inthe Philippines. There are no visible conservationmeasures, except for the 30,000-hectare Maka Reefcomplex off Sagay City, where reef and seagrassspecies are protected from fishing. Destructivefishing methods such as blast-fishing and compressor-fishingplus cyanide, are still used by fishers.The provisions of the law governing the extent ofthe fished area for noncommercial fishers are notimplemented, in effect allowing commercial fishersaccess to areas reserved for poor, small-scalefishers. Complaints of non-commercial fishers havenot been given attention by local authorities.” Henotes that a challenge to the fishery colleges anduniversities in Negros and Iloilo is information andeducation on fishery conservation. Furthermore,“the coastal areas of these islands are teeming withpeople, apparently with a high birth rate to judgefrom the number of children. Most of the people,with the possible exception of the fish traders, arepoor and live a hand-to-mouth existence. This highpopulation of permanent and temporary residentshas probably more than doubled during the last 10-15 years. Lastly, local governments have failed torealize the potential for tourism of some of theunique geological features of certain islands (examplecaves) and have failed to implement measuresto conserve them.” 11Multiple Attempts at Coastal Resource Managementin the Visayan SeaIn 2002, there was an initiative to address theissues of depleted resources, habitat degradation,unsustainable resource use patterns and resourceuse conflict and poverty among the people in theVisayan Sea areas. The initiative includes Masbateof Region V, Iloilo and Negros Occidental of RegionVI and Cebu and Negros Oriental of Region VII.Among those involved in this foreign-funded undertakingare local government units, BFAR’s WesternVisayas office, and the academe. The 8-year projecthas and will continue to provide alternative incomegeneratingopportunities, encourage and facilitatenetworking among stakeholders, implement animproved Coastal Resources Management andMonitoring project, facilitate the formulation of aJoint Management Plan (JMP), and set up aninformation base for resource management and10Bureau of Agricultural Statistics, Region VI.11Angel Alcala, Visayan Sea, Malaya: Environment, Philippines, 15May 2004, www.malaya.com.ph/may15/envi1.htm accessed on 20January 2005.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management77monitoring. 12 There have already been initiatives bythe local government units and concerned sectors atmanaging coastal resources. An example of these isthe NIACDEV or the Northern Iloilo Alliance forCoastal Development is an attempt at inter-municipalgovernance of municipal waters in sevenmunicipalities in Northeastern Panay.Bohol SeaBohol Sea is also a primary fishery resourcearea for many Visayans. At 29,000 square kilometers,it stretches from Sulu Sea to the PacificOcean and is surrounded by southeast Mindanao,Negros, Bohol and Leyte. It is one of the highestyielding for municipal and commercial fisheries inthe Philippines.Knowing the value of the sea has led concernedsectors to work towards a more sustainedvolume and diversity of fish catch in the area. Aprimary strategy was the protection of marinereserves or no-take zones for marine exploitation.According to data gathered by the Silliman UniversityAngelo King Center for Environment andManagement, there are approximately 30 marinereserves in the area, eight of which are in theVisayas. Of these, the Apo Island Marine Reserve isthe oldest. These protected areas were products ofjoint collaboration among local government units,academe, line agencies like BFAR, non-governmentorganizations, organized fish wardens and peoples’organizations. 13Multiple Attempts at Coastal ResourceManagement in the Bohol SeaThough the success of these protected areasis debatable, the experiences of Apo Island inNegros Oriental and Selinog Island in Dapitanindicate an increase in fishery yield and biodiversityin marine resources in the area, which also enhancesthe fishery catch in adjacent nonreserveareas. Effective partnerships among stakeholdersand the strong involvement of communities are citedas success factors. Lack of enforcement facilitiesand weak political will and lack of support from localgovernment officials were primary reasons forfailure of law enforcement in the marine reserves.To address the problems, an association of marineprotected area managers was organized in 2003known as the name Hugpong Tagdumala saSangtuaryo sang Kadagatan sa Bohol(HUTASAKAB). 14Other attempts at conservation in the areainclude the coastal resource management andwildlife protection/conservation at Tahong-tahongislet in Talibon, Bohol; the sustainable coastal areadevelopment (SCAD) in Barili, Cebu; the creationof resource management councils in Samar;Fishery Integrated Resource Management forEconomic Development (FIRMED) in Daram Island,Samar; the Fishery Sector Program in Carigara,Leyte. These are but a few of the many initiativesin the area. Following are specific examples ofthese initiatives.Bohol: PROCESS-Bohol CBCRM ExperienceThe island province of Bohol is located in theheart of Central Visayas, approximately 556 nauticalmiles south of Manila and about 40 nautical milessoutheast of Mactan Island of Cebu Province. Boholis the tenth largest province, with a total land areaof 411,726 hectares – 78 percent of which isclassified as alienable and disposable (A&D) lands.It has 48 municipalities, 30 of them coastal; the restare interior towns.Based on the 2000 NSO survey, Bohol had atotal population of 1.137 million, making it amongtop 20 most populous provinces. The populationincreased by almost 3 percent annually.Bohol has a total of 314 coastal barangays, 45of which are urbanized. The coastal barangaysconstitute roughly 25 percent of Bohol’s population.The island province was also endorsed by variousentities as one of the best tourist destinations. In2003, the Department of Tourism and the PhilippineTravel Tour Association recognized Bohol as theleading tourism destination, citing its ecology,culture, heritage and agriculture as major attrac-12GTZ, Visayan Coastal Resources and Fisheries Management Project,www2.gtz.de/Philippines/projects/VisSea.html, accessed on 30January 2005.13Indab and Suarez-Aspilla 2004, Community-based Protected Areas inthe Bohol (Mindanao) Sea, Philippines, NAGA Worldfish CenterQuarterly, Vol 27 No. 1 and 2 Jan-Jun 2004.14Ibid.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

78Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Managementtions. Department of Tourism data show touristarrivals increasing by 16 percent in 2001 and 2002.Domestic tourists accounted for more than 80percent arrivals.1. Challenges to Coastal ResourcesIn year 2000, the provincial coastal databank 15recorded a total of 5,127 registered municipalfishers among the coastal towns’ combined populationof 258,017. A total of 6,404 fishing boats wereregistered by Municipal LGU (MLGUs) – approximatelyhalf of them are motorized.One major problem in the island was theproliferation of illegal fishing and extraction ofmarine resources. Rampant illegal fishing in themunicipal waters of Bohol destroyed the marinehabitat and shrank aquatic resources. With coastalpopulation rising, more and more people turned tothe sea for their food requirements and livelihood.To have enough catch to bring to market,some marginal fishers resort to prohibited methodsof fishing and gleaning despite their life-threateningand life-long effects. Illegal fishing through the useof cyanide and other noxious substances waswidespread in the northern part of the province,specifically in the municipal waters of Getafe andTalibon. The fish aggregation devices were widelyused off the shores of western Bohol, specificallywithin the stretch of Loon to Inabanga. Use of finemesh nets, coral extraction, commercial fishing andother banned methods were uncontrollable. Illegalsand extraction was also rampant in various coastalareas. 16The absence of other livelihood options leftlocal communities with no choice but go on withtheir illegal fishing and marine resource extractionjust to earn a meager amount for livelihood.Undelineated municipal waters, not standardizednor harmonized CRM ordinances; and, lack ofpolitical will of local chief executives to resolve theexisting coastal environment issues, all contributedto the failure of the LGUs’ initiatives on marineecosystem conservation.Large commercial fishers from neighboringislands, particularly from Misamis Occidental,Dumaguete and Cebu, infiltrated the Bohol municipalwaters and harvested Bohol’s fishes and othermarine resources. The capture and slaughter ofmarine mammals and manta rays were onceordinary activities in Pamilacan Island.The significant and distressing result of allthese damaging activities: the daily fish catch of amarginal fisher of approximately 8 kilos per day in1970 decreased to a meager 2 kilos per day in year2000. 17 If unresolved, fish supply is expected tocontinuously decline until none is left even for afamily’s own consumption.2. Attempts at Community-Based Coastal ResourceManagement2.1 Learning to work together: Exploring the MultistakeholderApproachThree years after the environmental summit,all coastal stakeholders pooled their resources fora province-wide Coastal Law Enforcement Summit.In May 2000, the local chief executives, membersof legislative bodies, judiciary, law enforcementagencies, peoples organizations (POs), businesssector and academe; and representatives of thenational, provincial and nongovernment organizations,convened with the objective of resolving therampant problem of illegal fishing in the municipalwaters of Bohol. Mapping of illegal fishing andother related issues were made. Consequently,stakeholders found out that a single strategic planis inappropriate and ineffective to other coastalareas owing to variations in existing species ofmarine resources, types of illegal fishing activitiesin the area, and other factors. The summit alsoresulted in the organization of three congressionaldistrict Coastal Law Enforcement Councils (CLECs).For each council, a multi-sectoral Composite LawEnforcement Team (CLET) was formed to conductseaborne patrol operations in their areas ofjurisdiction.To support the lower LGUs, barangay fishwardens were re-organized, organized or strengthened.Municipal coastal database recorded 899deputized municipal fish wardens in 1999. The15Bohol Island: Its Coastal Environment Profile16BEMO, Municipal Coastal Database 200017Bohol Island: Its Coastal Environment ProfileSOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management79number increased by 11 percent during the initialyear of coastal law enforcement intensification, butdecreased by 27 percent by year 2002 (Table 6).Table 6. Population of Fish Warden at CoastalMunicipalitiesNumber of Fish WardensPercentage ofincrease/ decrease1999 8992000 1015 +112002 665 -272.2 Attempts at Environmental Protection andBiodiversity ConservationFrom year 1995 to 2001, at least 102 fishsanctuaries and marine protected areas (MPAs)were recorded, although there was no clear recordas to whether they were still operational as of thelast MCD update in year 2000. Of the total number,approximately 50 percent were located off coast ofrural barangays.The Fishery Development Program (FDP) ofPROCESS-Bohol started assisting the LGUs insetting up MPAs in 2002. Technical assistance wasextended - from the initial consultation phase tothe periodic monitoring and evaluation of aquaticresources. Eleven MPAs are now operational, 10of which undergo periodic monitoring of PRO-CESS-Bohol, Inc. and the Committee on Monitoring& Evaluation (M & E) of the local MPA ManagementCouncils. The remainder was just newlyinstalled.2.3 Municipal Water DelineationIn 2003, the NAMRIA held mapping workshopswith the chief executives of Bohol’s 47 coastal townsand one city to clearly delineate the municipalwaters of adjoining municipalities. Majority of theboundaries were clarified and legally settled withinthe LGU level while five towns remained in dispute.To settle the disputes, the NAMRIA scheduled sitevisits to the areas to show the concerned LGUs theirexact municipal water boundaries using the GlobalPositioning System (GPS) and, at the same time,check the authenticity of the documents presentedby LGU claimants as proof of their jurisdiction.2.4 Strengthening Fisheries and Aquatic ResourceManagement Councils (FARMCs)Pursuant to Chapter 3 of the ImplementingRules and Regulations of Republic Act 8550, otherwiseknown as the Philippine Fisheries Code of1998, the Fisheries and Aquatic Resource ManagementCouncils (FARMCs) at the provincial, municipaland barangay (optional) levels should have beenorganized. PROCESS-Bohol, Inc. in coordinationwith concerned LGUs, strengthened the MFARMCsof its eight assisted MLGUs and their componentBFARMCs through the conduct of training, workshopsseminars and meetings.2.5 Crafting a Coastal Resource Management PlanCRM planning is a participatory process ofplanning, implementing, and monitoring sustainableuses of coastal resources through collective actionand sound decision-making. The CRM planning issupposed to generate a Municipal CRM Plan. Themunicipalities of Albur, Anda, Buenavista, Calape,Candijay, Clarin, Dimiao, Garcia-Hernandez,Guindulman, Getafe, Inabanga, Jagna, Loay, Loon,Mabini, Maribojoc, Pres. Garcia, Talibon, Tubigon,Ubay, Valencia and Tagbilaran City in Bohol havealready formulated, adopted and implemented theirrespective CRM Plans.Provincial and Regional Validation Teams ofCRM projects monitor compliance with the plans. Assoon as the validation complete, the coastal town isawarded with a CRM Certification. Once an area isCRM–certified, more prospective developmentpartners are projected to invest. The towns of Jetafeand Inabanga are now already CRM-Certified; Albur,Maribojoc and Guindulman are still under validation.2.6 Community OrganizingFrom 1999 to 2002, 54 CRM organizationswere organized in the entire province of Bohol–this31 percent rural communities along the coast. 18These CRM organizations were organized andmanaged by POs and NGOs with assistance fromthe DENR, BFAR, other line agencies and othernongovernment agencies.NGOs, like PROCESS-Bohol, facilitated thelinks between the assisted POs and the microlendingproject of the Department of Social Welfareand Development (DSWD)’s Self-EmploymentAssistance Program. Likewise, organizations wereassisted in the installation of fish cages, encouragedto adopt the more economical and environmentfriendlymethod of swine raising, and were providedtechnical assistance on the management of theirrespective finances, bookkeeping and programmonitoring and evaluation.2.7 Community-Based Sustainable TourismThe “Community Life Tour” offered by threePROCESS-assisted POs features breathtaking18BEMO, Municipal Coastal Database 2000SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

80Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Managementviews and diverse natural resources of the province,especially those found along the coasts andother bodies of water, the unique traditions andskills of the Boholanos, and, their culinary expertisein preparing fresh seafood recipes. All locatedwithin Maribojoc Bay area, the three POs–SAVIMA,UBCA and DEA–accept guests interested to be part ofa local community and experience a simple Boholanoday. The tour includes homestay, boardwalk journey,river cruise, bird watching and other sidelights likehands-on lessons in handicraft making. Local andforeign visitors may take part in the province’sreforestation project by purchasing mangroveseedlings from nurseries and avail themselves of theCommunity Life Tour package for minimal fees.Negros Oriental: seeing the fruits of andissues in marine resource managementMajor coastal areas of Negros Oriental canbe found in the municipalities of Manjuyod, Tanjay,Amlan, San Jose, Sibulan, Bacong, Dawin and thecities of Bais and Dumaguete. Negros Oriental is,likewise, a coastal area teeming with abundantresources under pressure from economic andpopulation demands. Stretched in a 300-kilometercoastline, Negros Oriental has 186 kilometers ofcoral area. Its major fishing grounds, the NorthernSulu Sea and Tanon Strait, yield, skipjack, yellowfintuna, mackerel, scud, slipmouth and anchoviesyear-round. However, the reefs of Negros Orientalsuffer from overfishing. 19 Major issues common tomost of these areas include “overfishing, beachand shoreline erosion, siltation, mangrove overharvesting,encroachment by fishers of othermunicipalities, lack of security of tenure on landand/or home lot” lack of alternative livelihood andimproper waste management. 20 Innovations inmarine resource management by the academe andlocal government units prevented the rapid depletionof fishery resources in their waters.1. Apo IslandSince the formalization of the marine reservein 1985 spearheaded by Silliman University, Apohas grown as a model for community-basedresource management, not only in the Philippines,but throughout Southeast Asia. It is also consideredthe oldest marine reserve in the Philippines.Several factors contributed to the development of19Ablong and Waltemath, Establishment of Marine Reserves in NegrosOriental, Phil:CVRP20Coastal Resources of Negros Oriental in http://oneocean.org/download/20010825/negros_profil/chapter2b.pdf accessed on 2February 2005.Apo island (i.e. political support from the municipality,the small human population). Highly commendableis the leadership of the community thathas taken responsibility in managing its marineresources.The Marine Management Committee (MMC)remains an active and strong people’s organization.It is very effective in enforcing the provisions of thereserve and maintaining the sanctuary. The user’sfees collected for the island are used for the upkeepof the sanctuary, education, medicine, and emergencyneeds of the community. The provisions ofthe reserve are enforced by the MMC, Banty Dagat,and the Barangay Officials with full support from thecommunity. The plan to regulate tourism activitiesand financial support must be implemented tocontinue the training of the community on alternativelivelihood (e.g. basket and hat weaving, t-shirtprinting, etc..)2. Bais BayBais Bay is the richest fishery area in NegrosOriental. It has about 200 hectares of mangrovearea and high yields of rabbitfish, shellfish, shrimpsand crabs. Siltation from soil erosion of baremountains surrounding the bay, overexploitation offishery resource, mangrove degradation, andpollution from agricultural and milling activitiesaround the Bay are among the main issues incoastal resource management.Coastal resource management (CRM) in BaisBay was initiated by the Silliman University MarineLaboratory. Management areas consist of theMangrove Wildlife Sanctuary and the proposed fishsanctuaries. Offshore guardhouses and patrolbancas are among the available facilities. Replantedmangrove trees, occupying a few hundredsof square meters, are now bearing fruit. Since1995, the mayors of the Municipality of Manjuyodand Bais City have been active in the protection ofmarine resources. However, a land dispute betweenthe two mayors over Campuyo reef and itsvicinities and disagreement among the communitieson the size of the fish sanctuary at Tagay pointhave led to the suspension of the legal establishmentof the fish sanctuaries in the two sites. It iscrucial to define the marine-protected area boundariesand install marker bouys and to enactordinances to legalize the establishment of themarine-protected area.PanayPanay, surrounded by waters (e.g. VisayanSea, Panay Gulf, Iloilo Strait, Batan Bay, Sapian Bay)SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management81was once abundant in fishery resource untilirresponsible fishing methods, encroachment ofcommercial fishing vessels in inshore seas,overfishing, pollution of the sea resulting fromindustrial and household waste, along with thedisposal of waste and oil residues from shipsand the failure to properly manage abundantfishery resource, threatened the main source oflivelihood for many. Siltation due to erosion fromdenuded uplands as well as wastes from expandingfishponds for aquaculture had adverseeffects on coastal resources. Fisherfolk observedthat catch as well as variety and average size offish caught were decreasing. 21 Such observation,though drawn from 22 coastal communities inSouthern Iloilo, reflects of the state of coastalcommunities in many parts of the island. Thus,like the islands of Bohol and Negros, concernedsectors have made attempts to secure thesustainability of the coastal and fishery resources.1. Community-based resource managementThe experience of the Southeast AsiaFisheries Development Council in Malalisonisland in Antique in the island of Panay is one ofthe most CBCRM experience in the Visayas. Inthe said CBRM initiative “the people of Malalisonwere able to organize themselves to assign andprotect a marine reserve in their area. This wasin answer to their desire to implement a territorialuse rights ordinance that they worked out tobe passed by the local government and villagecouncils. In addition, this move supported aprevious deployment by Aquaculture Departmentof the Southeast Asian Fisheries Development(SEAFDEC/AQD) researchers of concrete artificialreef habitats in the area. To date, a total ban onfishing of any kind has been successfully enforcedin the reserve.” 22 Currently, “SEAFDEC/AQD researchers are carrying out a communitybasedcoastal fishery resources managementand mangrove-friendly aquaculture project incollaboration with the local governments ofIbajay municipality and its adjacent Tangalantown, in Aklan province in the Philippines. Twonongovernment organizations, Process Foundationand USWAG, are also helping SEAFDEC/AQDin the community organizing aspect of theproject.” 23 An FRMP (Fisheries Resource ManagementProject) is being undertaken in Sapian Bayinvolving the municipalities of Ivisan and Sapianof Capiz and Batan of Aklan province, the BFARRegion VI and the UPV Foundation, Inc.2. Saving BoracayBoracay Island, in the municipality of Malay inthe province of Aklan, is a prime tourist destination,drawing tourists to its four-kilometer white beach.There are 1,259 business establishments, one golfcourse and several inland resorts on the island. 24Intensive pressure on the coastal resources of theislands and pollution from various tourism andhousehold activities contributed to the degradationof the island’s waters. The Western Visayas officeof the DENR noted that the island receives touristsand building structures beyond its carrying capacity.A massive algae bloom during the peak touristseason led to the revival of DENR’s monthly monitoringof Boracay’s water quality. A DENR study alsomonitors the effectiveness of the environmentalmanagement programs and the centralized wastetreatment facility in operation in Boracay. 25The Lowlands of VisayasChallenges in Biodiversity Conservation in theLowlands of VisayasThe lowlands of Panay and Negros have beena major source of agricultural products in theVisayas. Western Visayas a main contributor to the6.1 metric tons of rice produced in 2004. 26 The21Tietze, U. 2000. Socioeconomic and Occupational Characteristics ofCoastal Fishing Communities in Tietze U., Groenewold, Marcoux A.,2000. Demographic Change in Coastal Fishing Communities and ItsImplications for the Coastal Environment, FAO Fisheries TechnicalPaper 403, (Rome: FAO).22SEAFDEC, SEAFDEC/AQD bares research findings on socialtechnologies for sustainable coastal resource management,www.seafdec.org.ph/study2.html , accessed on 3 February 2005.23Ibid.24DOT VI, Boracay Island List of Establishments, Iloilo City: DOT %,2003.25DENR VI Environment Management Bureau, Coastal WaterMonitoring: Boracay Island Coastal Waters in the State of the BrownEnvironment Report, (Iloilo City: DENR), pp. 22-26.26Department of Agriculture Bureau of Agricultural Statistics, July 2004.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

82Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementPhilippine government launched a Hybrid RiceCommercialization Program (HRCP) aimed atincreasing productivity in rice farming, self-sufficiencyand facilitate poverty alleviation. The programcomponents are “seed production, procurementand distribution, seed subsidy to farmers,intensive promotions, training, and technicalassistance to both hybrid seed and commercial ricegrowers”. 27Iloilo in Panay was a target area for hybridrice production under the Ginintuang MasaganangAni program of the government. Though Iloilorecorded one of the highest rice yields in thePhilippines, the hybrid rice program cannot entirelyclaim credit for it (see Table 9 28 .) However, thediversity of rice and corn traditionally planted hasbeen threatened in Iloilo and across the Visayaswith the government’s intensive campaign andsupport services for the use of hybrid rice varietiesfor the planting of Bt corn. The program, thus,entices farmers to hybrid rice and Bt corn productionwhile relegating the diverse rice and cornvarieties into nonuse.Table 9. Hybrid Rice Commercialization ProgramAssistance Provided in Region VI CY 2003ProvinceNo. of BagsDistributedAreaPlanted(ha.)No. ofFarmersServedAklan 158 71 71Antique 377 228 228Capiz 301 239 239Guimaras 141 134 134Iloilo 2,133 2,024 2,024Negros Occ. 414 346 346TOTAL 3,524 3,041 3,041Source: GMA Rice ProgramNongovernment organizations have launchedbiodiversity conservation initiatives for rice andcorn in Bohol, Cebu, Negros and Iloilo. SEARICE(the Southeast Asia Initiatives of CommunityEmpowerment), for instance, encouraged farmersto breed the seeds they plant (through participatoryplant breeding), established seed banks,encouraged a community seed registry system,and facilitated seed exchange among farmers–allin the hope of enabling the continued use ofdiverse rice and corn varieties for this and succeedinggenerations. Bohol Network for FarmersRights (BNFR) argued for biosafety and sought aban on products with genetically modified organisms(GMOs) and secure Bohol crops from GMOcontamination.kg per haFigure 6. Yield Performance of Hybridand Inbred Rice Across Locations WS 2002800070006000500040003000200010000HybridNueva EcijaInbredIsabelaIloiloDavao delSurDavao delNorteThere is, however, a much severe threat inbiodiversity conservation these days: The provinceof Iloilo, for instance, recorded a declining plantationin irrigated agricultural lands since 1998.Massive migration to, population increase andurbanization in Iloilo led to the rapid conversion ofagricultural lands into residential and commercialuse. Though there have been policies to preventthese, there is a growing real estate development inIloilo that now clears, encroaches and changes thelandscape of agricultural areas of rurban areas onthe fringes of Jaro and Mandurriao and the municipalitiesof Leganes, Zarraga, Dumangas, and Oton,among others.Urbanization and environmentalmanagement in CebuCebu City, is a major industrial and urbanlocation. It has a land area of 5,000 square kilometerswith a 330-square kilometer city area housingmost of its population (about 88 percent) near thecoastal area.The heavy influx of intra-provincial migrants,rise of informal settlements and growthin the informal economy along with land conversion,land reclamation, infrastructure development29 and the passage of City Ordinance 1780declaring a 200-meter commercial strip zone atboth sides of the highway have presented CebuCity with numerous environmental challenges. 3027Bordey, et.al.. 2004. Socioeconomic Evaluation of Hybrid RiceProduction in the Philippines presented at the 4th International Crop28Bordey, et. al 2004. Socioeconomic Evaluation of Hybrid RiceProduction in the Philippines, 4th International Science Crop Congress.29Etimadi, Felisa, 2000. Civil Society Participation in City Governancein Cebu City, Environment and Urbanization, Volume 12 No. 1, April2000 p. 58.30Cebu United for Sustainable Water, Metro Cebu EnvironmentManagement Board, DENR and the Soil and Water ConservationFoundation reference material on Not for Sale: Lands in ProtectedAreasSOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management83The latter will deprive Cebuanos of forest coverit needs to secure water supply and preventlandslides.Cebu City water demand is approximately234,000 per day supporting a population of about1.3 million and a rising number of industries.Domestic and industrial consumption of water isdependent on groundwater from the coastallimestone aquifer and alluvial water-bearingformation in Cebu’s river delta of five rivers:Kotkot, Butuanon, Cansaga, Mananga, andPangdan. The Cities of Cebu and Madaue havepoor water quality due to domestic and industrialpollutants. 31 Most common of the latter is thedischarge of industrial waste into rivers andchannels (e.g. the FMC Marine Colloids’ wastedischarge into Mactan Channel). 32The growing population of Metro Cebu citieshas also resulted in large amounts of waste whichthe local government units found difficult todispose of. Cebu City produces 500-520 tons ofwaste daily. 33 In 2004, the Integrated Bar of thePhilippines and DENR VII threatened to sue theMetro Cebu cities for failing to comply with theSolid Waste Management Act of 2001 by burninggarbage in open dump sites and for failing tosegregate garbage. The cost of managing solidwaste has always been an issue, an impedimentaggressively working towards a cleaner environment.34Initiatives have been undertaken by stakeholdersincluding local government units, nongovernmentorganizations, academic communities,and community stakeholders in partnership donoragencies to correct the degradation of Cebu’senvironment. A common treatment facility forwaste water from small and medium-rangeindustries is being initiated through the establishmentof the Cebu Central Treatment Facility, Inc.—a private enterprise with most clients as stockholders.An attempt to save one of its rivers frompollution and degradation is awaiting its implementationthrough the Butuanon River WatershedManagement Project. But while there may beconstraints in waste and water management forthe local government units, nongovernmentorganizations like CLEAR in Cebu City have beeninitiating river water quality monitoring, a massiveriver clean-up in Metro Cebu areas, and helpedintroduce clean production techniques to Cebu’sindustries. Cebu City also has an EnvironmentalQuality Control Council for Metro Cebu. It is amultisectoral organization aimed at protectingCebu from industrial pollution.The uplands of VisayasMany of the Visayan islands are characterizedby lowlying and hilly areas. But two islands, Panayand Negros, have mountain peaks that havesheltered diverse flaura and fauna and indigenouspeoples. The following case studies present challengesfaced by the mountains of Negros Island andPanay.Deforestation in Negros OrientalThe onset of American colonial rule usheredin further industrial growth. The grant of loggingconcessions in Negros was a direct result of theindustrial activity in the island that in turn led to thegrowth of the population with the onset of development.Development came in the form of infrastructureprojects – schools, hospitals, clinics and otherbusiness establishments, especially the expansionof plantations supported by subsidies from the USgovernment. After World War II (WWII), logging onthe island increased under combined foreign andFilipino ownership. By 1970, the population hadrisen to 2 million and stood over 3 million by 1998.Figure 7 . Map of Negros Island31PCEEM Project Inception Report 1998 in Metro Cebu EnvironmentalImprovement Project.2003.32Gaylican, Christine, 2003. US Firm’s Subsidiary Defies DENR onWaste Discharge, CebuDaily News, 20 June 2003.33Gadin, Benilda. NGO Activities in the Improvement of River Qualityand Environmental Education. Proceedings of the KitakyushuInitiative Seminar on Public Participation, Kitakyushy, Japan, 21-21January 2004.34Versoza, R. and Campana, G, 2004. IBP, DENR may sue MetroCebu citiesSOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

84Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementThis result in a density of 220 per square kilometer,twice that of France and nearly eight times that ofthe US in that year (1998).As a result of colonial administration andpopulation growth, old-growth forest cover declinedfrom 90 percent in the 1700’s to 60 percentby the end of WWII. The last remnants of the oldgrowthforests below 3,000 feet were cleared bythe middle of 1970. By that year it had declined toaround 8 percent, 6 percent by 1984, and less than4 percent by in 1992. In Oriental Negros, the totalforestland is believed to be only 5 percent (27,011ha.) of the total land area of the province (540,230ha.)These forests are now reduced to smallpatches of montane and mossy rain forest near themountain tops; an old-growth lowland forest existsonly as a few thin ribbons between forests andcleared lowlands. These patches and ribbons offorest now serve as diminutive islands of naturalrain-forest habitat delimited by a throng of impoverishedmasses. Illegal logging is a threat. FromJanuary to December 2004 a total of 27.71 cubicmeters of forests products such as wooden logsand timber were confiscated by Provincial Environmentaland Natural Resources Office (PENRO)officials. The catch amounted to P352,556.40.The areas of Amlan, Pamplona, Mabinay,Sibulan, Bacong, Sta. Catalina, Bayawan City,Tanjay City and Dumaguete City are identified withrecorded illegal logging. The province coveredaround 80 percent of the natural forests in the early1900’s and at present it has alarmingly dropped to5-6 percent. Officials warn a possible repeat of thescenario in the Quezon and Aurora provinces if suchissues are not addressed. The current thrust toaddress this problem is to enforce existing laws tothe fullest with the cooperation from both theprivate and public sectors.1. Securing the Forest ReserveThe Mount Talinis Twin Lakes Forest Reservehas been recognized as an important but endangeredecosystem. The reserve is within the confinesof the 133,000-hectare Philippine National OilCompany (PNOC) geothermal reserve. The TwinLakes area is home to two watersheds, Mt. Talinisand Lake Balinsasayao, which help supply Negroswith water. It is also the largest contiguous forest insouthern Negros Oriental (1,692 hectares) with highbiodiversity 36 and endemism ratings 37 and richmineral deposits. The latter is a major reason totarget the area for mining.In year 2000, Proclamation 414 declaredFigure 8. Deforestation in Negros 1875-1992 358,000 hectares of the Twin Lakes area as protected.It is now called the Balinsasayao TwinLakes Natural Park. The declaration does notinclude the Mt. Talinis area. In 2004 House Bill1462 attempted to further reduce the protectedarea to 3,749 hectares. Although the proposed billdid not prosper because of resistance from civilsociety sectors in Negros Oriental, the threat to theforest reserve still looms.Concerned sectors in Negros Oriental arecalling for the creation of a multistakeholderProtected Area Management Board. Attempts tocurb kaingin and small-scale illegal logging havealso been initiated by partners of the Foundation forPhilippine Environment (FPE), CenTrop and TMF inNegros Oriental, through environment-friendlyalternative livelihood projects (e.g. sustainableagriculture, organic fertilizer production and duckand vegetable-raising. People’s Organizations (POs)linked with the CenTrop and TMF have beenlearning wildlife biomonitoring skills and haveparticipated in ethnobiological survey and monitoringof the Twin Lakes area. In the process, membersof the POs begin to appreciate the value ofwildlife protection.Cebu: protected areas needing protectionCebu has five protected areas: ManangaWatershed Forest Reserve, Kot-kot Lusaran36Heideman, P.D., L.R. Heaney, R.L. Thomas and K.R. Erickson. 1987.Patterns of faunal diversity and species abundance of non-volantmammals on Negros Island, Philippines. Journal of Mammalogy68:884-888.37Heaney, L.R., P.D. Heideman, and K.M. Mudar. 1981. Ecologicalnotes on mammals in the Lake Balinsasayao region, Negros Oriental,Philippines. Silliman Journal 28:122-131.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management85Figure 9. Map of PanayWatershed, Central Cebu National Park, SudlonNational Park, and Buhisan Watershed forestreserve. All of these protected areas cut acrossCebu City. The passage of City Ordinance 1780declaring a 200-meter commercial strip zone onboth sides of the highway has given rise to landacquisition and land speculation in The uplandsof Cebu. Because there are claimants – carryingtax declarations and even titles as proof ofownership – to portions of the protected area,the forests are under threat of being transformedinto housing, commercial and industrialproject sites. While protected areas are not tobe sold, donated, exchanged or inherited, manyof the claimants assert prior rights to the propertywhich is recognized by law — a major causeof concern for those seeking to secure theprotected areas. 38The uplands of Panay:issues of utilization and resistancePanay island (see map 39 ) has an area approximately11,520 square kilometers and lies betweenlatuttude 11° 55’ and 10° 24’ N and longitude 121°24’ and 123° 9’ E. It is bounded on the north by theSibuyan Sea, on the west by Cuyo East Pass and onthe south by the Sulu Sea. Panay is the sixth largestisland in the Philippine archipelago and is home tofour provinces of Region VI, namely, Iloilo, Capiz,Aklan and Antique.1. Forest Cover and WildlifePanay retains approximately 9% of theoriginal, primary forest covering as much as103,000 hectares on two mountain landscapes. Arare, low-elevation forest tract on ca. 7,000 hectares,much of which is rugged, karst topography, isin the Northwest Panay peninsula; it is a mixture ofprimary, secondary and selectively logged forestwith identifiable pockets and corridors suitable forecological restoration. The remaining 95,000hectares of primary forest is largely montaine andis contained within the Central Panay Mountains atelevations above 1,000 meters, although fingers ofquality forest survive at lower elevations in valleysand recent field surveys have identified limestoneforest at a lower elevation in the northern reachesof the range. Primary forest in Central Panay isfragmented into separate tracts, some or all ofwhich a suitable for corridor developments.Panay is part of the West-Central Visayas, orthe Greater Negros-Panay biogeographic region,and ranks among the highest conservation prioritiesin the world when considering levels of faunal-floralendemism and degree of threat. 40 Panay wildlifeincludes 189 species of birds, 42 species of mammals,and 39 species of herpetofauna. Changes inand intensification of upland use put the wildlifeunder intense pressure. among the affected ones,the Writhed-billed or Visayan wrinkled hornbill(Aceros waldeni), the Visayan warty pig (Suscebifrons), and the Visayan spotted deer (Cervusalfredi).The rapid denudation of forest cover andrising upland use is alarming. Iloilo, for instance38Cebu United for Sustainable Water, Metro Cebu EnvironmentManagement Board, DENR and the Soil and Water ConservationFoundation reference material on Not for Sale: Lands in ProtectedAreas39RandMcNally Map of the Visayan Islands,www.isis.csuhayward.edu/cesmith/vittmus/Philippines/Islands/VisayasTopo.htm, accessed on 28 January 2005.40Oliver and Heaney (1997)SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

86Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementProvinceTable 10. Land Use Cover of Forest Land by Province in Region VI (in hectares) 41TotalForestlandMossyVirgin/OldGrowthResidual Brushland MangroveOtherLand UseAklan 74,994.00 6,378.00 2,851.00 18,981.00 25,733.00 417.00 20,634.00Antique 11,8635.00 13,199.50 1,650.00 14,131.08 30,274.79 532.00 58,847.63Capiz 103,951.00 1,525.00 1,892.00 10,678.00 49,241.50 26.00 40,588.50Iloilo 114,083.00 3,790.88 7,016.00 5,225.80 25,819.60 700.44 71,530.28Guimaras 2,836.11 0 0 449.58 1,307.04 0 1,079.49Negros Occidental 25,2221.38 0 10,885.50 23,210.00 64,061.56 1,761.37 152,302.95TOTAL 666,720.49 24,893.38 24,294.5 72,675.46 19,6437.49 3,436.81 344,982.85Source: LEP-FMS, DENR Region VIonly has a 7 percent forest cover although it mayclaim about 18379 hectares of upland reforestedarea. 42 Trends in land use of Iloilo province indicateincreasing illegal extraction of sand and gravel anddeclining plantation of once-irrigated land andincrease in cultivation in non-irrigated lands. Whilethe province has yet to ascertain the cause of thistrend, it is apparent that rapid and extensive landconversion for residential use in once productiveagricultural plains have pushed many farmers tocultivate uplands, clearing areas covered with treesfor cash crop cultivation. This unabated trend ofillegal logging, agricultural intensification in andmigration to, and continued unregulated access toand use of minor forest products have a severeimpact on biodiversity and the communities dependenton upland resources.2. Water Resources from the UplandsA major concern for many stakeholderslooking into development changes in the uplands isthe access, use and control of water resources.Water resources from the uplands do not onlyprovide for the basic survival needs of humans, butare essential for agriculture and industrial processingand production. The latter two have increasedconsumption levels of water twice as fast as thepopulation rate. Thus, there is a recognized need tomanage water systems in Panay.It has been found that water from the uplandsalso carries domestic waste and run-off fromagricultural fields, and affects not only lowlandusers of water resources but also the coastalresources. Panay River — a major river in Panay –for instance, originates from the mountain ranges ofMt. Igabon and Mt. Binilangan and cuts across thebasin in a northeasterly direction traversing severalmunicipalities of Capiz. DENR VI reports that theriver receives domestic waste, piggery waste andagricultural run-off coming from the populated areait traverses. And this same river is the source ofRoxas City’s drinking water supply managed by theRoxas City Water District. 433. Mineral Resources, Infrastructure Developmentand Upland CommunitiesThe current conditions for the upland communitiesare far from stable, aggressive modes ofdevelopment initiatives are threatening to displaceor overwhelm untenured communities. There aremining claims cover large sections of the mountainrange in Central Panay, the entire Buruanga Peninsulaand Northeastern Panay. An assessment of themineral resources of Iloilo in 2003, for instance,yielded a range of metallic and nonmetallic mineralcommodities that can be tapped. Among these aremanganese, clay (e.g. ball, white, red-burning),guano, limestone, phosphate rock and basalt/lavaflow. 44 In Iloilo alone in 2004, the province received143 applications. Of these, 103 permits have beenissued. 45 Moreover, in Central Panay, proposedinfrastructures in the form of roads and militaryinstallations either adjacent to or overlapping withboth indigenous peoples (IP’s) ancestral domainsand primary forest, each and collectively representmajor threats to the stability and integrity of theuplands in human and environmental terms.A population of approximately 25,000 indigenouspeoples (IPs) resides in the uplands of theCentral Panay Mountains. Under the broad culturaland ethnic titling of Bukidnon, these people haveundergone some diversification and tribal factionalismamong the group, which now occupy differentareas across the range. Nevertheless, as a whole,Bukidnon possesses distinct cultural orientations,41Based on Land Evaluation Party data as of January 2000 and drawnfrom DENR VI on January 2005.42Provincial Planning and Development Office, 2004. AnnualDevelopment Plan CY 2004 Province of Iloilo. (Iloilo: ProvincialGovernment of Iloilo), p. iv and p. 10.43Environmental Management Bureau DENR-VI, 2003. State of theBrown Environment Report, (Iloilo City: DENR VI), Chapter 3 p. 15.44MGB-DENR 6, 2003. Mineral Resources CY 2003. (Iloilo City: DENRVI).45Monitoring and Evaluation Section, Provincial Planning andDevelopment Office, 2004. 2003 Annual Accomplishment Report,(Iloilo: Province of Iloilo), p.16.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

Saving Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental Management87rituals and worldviews that indicate a commonidentity and lineage, qualities that separate themfrom the upland communities deriving from thelowlands during the past century. One feature of theBukidnon society is a worldview that obligates Manto co-exist with nature rather than to dominate it.Such views, which are characteristic of many IP’s,are favorable to biodiversity conservation and theconcepts of sustainable development and could beincorporated into the strategic environmentalmanagement of the Central Panay mountains.The demand for resources to support lowlanddevelopment, migration into the uplands and thepresence of settled communities on the periphery ofancestral lands/primary forest have severe consequenceson biodiversity and accelerate the erosionof cultural values inherent in Bukidnon societies.4. Power and Upland ResourcesNew threats to the use of freshwater resourceshave also proven to be a challenge to watermanagement. In Panay, the putting up of coal-firedpower plants in Northern Iloilo has been perceivedto heavily impact on upland resources. “The islandsof Panay and Guimaras make up the Panay grid thatconnects Negros, Cebu and Leyte grids to form theVisayas power grid. These main grids have varyinggeneration capacities and power consumptionneeds. The biggest excess energy generated comesfrom the island of Leyte.” The excess makes up forthe “deficiency in all other islands combined.” 46 Thegrid allows for power sharing that channels excesspower generated from Leyte to Cebu, that of Cebuchanneled to Negros while the latter’s excess ischanneled to Panay. A scenario of power shortageraised by the Department of Energy (DOE) led to theassertive lobbying for the approval of proposals toput up independent power projects. Among theseare proposals to build a 100-MW coal-fired powerplant in the region. 47 Among the target zones aremunicipalities in Northern Iloilo.It is perceived by some members of nongovernmentcoalitions (e.g. Responsible Ilonggos forSustainable Energy, RISE) perceived the increasingpressure to push for the coal-fired power projectsis not meant to address power shortage in theregion —since there is none to speak of. TheVisayas Grid has a 457-MW surplus of dependablecapacities. (See Table of Power Sector Situation) 48Instead, the assertive stance of putting up the coal–fired power plant may be closely related to theperceived power needs of mining operations thatmay soon be under way in the in target areas ofPanay. The coal-fired power plants are to be put upin Northern Iloilo where most of the mining applicationshave targeted.Furthermore, RISE asserts that the coal-firedpower plants are not compatible with the approvedland-use plans. The target sites have been “zonifiedas agricultural, tourism and ecologically-protectedareas”. Moreover, the process required to run theplant demands quarrying of massive quantities oflimestone which may damage watersheds andendanger the livelihood of affected communities. Itis also perceived that the power plants will “competewith local communities in the use of freshwaterresources which is estimated at 1000m per dayper 100-MW plant”. 495. Attempts at Upland Resource ManagementConcerns, such as those mentioned above,have led to attempts by government, non governmentand people’s organizations to initiate variousattempts at managing of upland resources. Community-basedattempts stir from the traditionalreforestation programs. The government, throughDENR, has pursued a community-based forestrymanagement program. The summary of CBFMA46Suruelo, Ian. Pany –at the tail – end: Issues truggles and campaignson the power sector in the Island of Panay, Philippines in South Asia-Pacific and the Freedom from Debt Coalition-Philippines (2004).Peoples’ Resistance and Alternatives to Privatization of Water andPower Services, (Quzon city:Jubilee South and Freedom from DebtCoalition), p. 180.47Ibid., p. 182.48Responsible Ilonggos for Sustainable Energy (RISE), (2005). P. 6.49Ibid., pp 7-9.50Ibid., p 6.Table 11. Power Sector Situation per Transmission Grid in 2004 50Power TransmissionGridsInstalled Capacity(MW)Depend.Capacity(MW)Peak Demand(MW)Unutilized Electricity(Dep.-Peak)Luzon 12377 11086 6728 4358Visayas 1721 1520 1063 457Mindanao 1665 1402 1278 124Total 15763 14008 9060 4939Source: DOE Visayas Power Development Plan 2005 to 2014SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES

88Saving the Visayas: Issues, Initiatives and Innovations in Environmental ManagementProvinceCBFMPotentialArea (has)Table 12. Summary of CBFMA Issuance, Region VI (CY 2004) 51No. ofPotentialPOSTotal No. ofBeneficiariesNo.CBFMA AwardedArea(has)No. ofBeneficiariesTotal No. of Tenured PO’sAssociation/CooperativesFederationTotal%UtilizationAKLAN 10,915.31 60 2,704 23 5,816.44 2019 25 2 27 52ANTIQUE 15,593.96 102 2,398 15 3,744.55 844 15 0 15 24CAPIZ 11,373.00 67 1,399 9 1,063.55 679 9 1 10 18ILOILO 25,287.11 163 4,453 19 8,582.90 2829 32 3 35 34GUIMARAS 1,130.31 23 530 17 763.45 530 17 1 18 68NEGROSOCCIDENTAL52,200.16 107 2656 21 19,654.95 1995 22 1 23 38Total 116,499.85 522 14,140 104 39,625.84 8,896 120 8 128 35Source: DENR Region VIissuances for the region in 2004 is on Table 12.A multistakeholder approach to the managementof the Magapa-Suage River in Central Iloilohas also been initiated by the Panay Rural DevelopmentCenter, Inc. (PRDCI). What started as anattempt to manage watershed resources with acatchment area of about 9,000 hectares 52 evolvedinto a water resource-management initiative fromthe uplands to the communities and municipalitieswhere the river runs through. Together withpeople’s organizations in eight municipalities andlocal government units, organizations of farmers,women and youth have worked together to ensurenot only a multistakeholder approach but also anintergenerational and gender-sensitive one to thecommunal-management, access and utilization ofresources from the Magapa-Suage River area.Among their specific initiatives are curriculumdevelopment, reforestation, river clean-up, andsustainable agriculture.Moreover, groups like Green Forum-WesternVisayas have been enabling the indigenous peoplesto map out their resources and help them in theirstruggle to claim their rights to land, environmentand culture. Using skills in computer technology andmapping techniques, participatory processes ofmapping out upland landscape and resources havebeen utilized to help the IP’s in their claim over theirancestral domain, specifically, for on-grounddelineation of ancestral domains for tenurialprocessing.On the other hand, in the attempt to addressclean energy options for sustainable development,Responsible Ilonggos for Sustainable Energy (RISE),a coalition of more than 50 groups in Panay,opposed the application for coal-fired power plantsin Northern Iloilo, lobbied against the approval ofthe proposals in target local government units, heldcommunity meetings to raise awareness on theimpact of coal-fired power plants, and called for acongressional investigation on the proposals to putup these plants. Among RISE’s major concerns arethe impact of the coal-fired power plants on theresource base of Northern Iloilo and its health andenvironment impact on host communities.ConclusionThe snapshots of the state of the environmentin the Visayas reveal the fragile state of its ecosystemsdue to overuse and the demands of a growingpopulation, abuse, unregulated human activities inall ecosystems, lack of concern for the environment,and weak political will of local and national governmentofficials, among others. Environmentalprograms of local and national government unitsand agencies and even NGOs and academe dependmostly on external funding. Yet, noteworthy are theunrelenting initiatives from people’s organizations,civil society organizations, academe and some localgovernment units to explore innovative explorationsinto coastal resource management that draw fromthe social capital, passion and local resources ofcommunities. Without doubt, the Visayas islands,though productive, will drive their resources to thepoint of degradation if unregulated and unchecked.Yet, there is hope in the resistance of many to giveup their rights to a sustainable environment.51DENR Region 6 (2004), Summary of CBFMA Issuance, p1.52Villano, Pestano, Reynaldo, Gascon (1997). An Assessment of theUpper Suage River Watershed for a Community-Led ResourceManagement, (Iloilo City: Panay Rural Development Center, Inc.SOCIAL WATCH PHILIPPINES