PDF - Wallace Online

PDF - Wallace Online PDF - Wallace Online

wallace.online.org
from wallace.online.org More from this publisher
12.07.2015 Views

116 NATURAL SELECTION v'Parsons Pond,' in Newfoundland, which is separated fromthe sea only by a high pebbly beach. Within the periodabove stated high tides and heavy seas have shifted the courseof the brook flowing from the lake into the sea, and caused agreater, and consequently a more rapid fall of fresh water,which has so shallowed that part of the lake where the gullswere in the habit of breeding that it was no longer safe tobuild on rocks easily accessible to their common enemy, thefox. They therefore betook themselves to some neighbouringspruce and balsam firs not much over a hundred yards distantfrom their old breeding station." Audubon also notes asimilar change of habit, some herring-gulls building their nestsin spruce-trees on an island in the Bay of Fundy, where theyhad formerly built on the ground.A curious example of a recent change of habits has occurredin Jamaica. Previous to 1854 the palm swift(Tachornis phoenicobea) inhabited exclusively the palm treesin a few districts in the island. A colony then establishedthemselves in two cocoa-nut palms in Spanish Town, andremained there till 1857, when one tree was blown down andthe other stripped of its foliage. Instead of now seeking outother palm trees the swifts drove out the swallows who builtin the piazza of the House of Assembly, and took possessionof it, building their nests on the tops of the end walls and atthe angles formed by the beams and joists, a place which theycontinue to occupy in considerable numbers. It is remarkedthat here they form their nest with much less elaboration thanwhen built in the palms, probably from being less exposed.But perfection of structure and adaptation to purpose arenot universal characteristics of birds' nests, since there aredecided imperfections in the nesting of many birds which arequite compatible with our present theory, but are hardly sowith that of instinct, which is supposed to be infallible. Thepassenger pigeon of America often crowds the branches withits nests tillthey break, and the isground strewn withshattered nests, eggs, and young birds. Books' nests areoften so imperfect that during high winds the eggs fall out ;but the window-swallow is the most unfortunate in this respect,for White, of Selborne, informs us that he has seen thembuild, year after year, in places where their nests are liable

thev THE PHILOSOPHY OF BIRDS' NESTS 117to be washed away by a heavy rain and their young onesdestroyed.ConclusionA fair consideration of all these facts will, I think, fullysupport the statement with which I commenced, and showthat the chief mental faculties exhibited by birds in constructionof their nests are the same in kind as those manifestedby mankind in the formation of their dwellings..Theseare, essentially, imitation, and a slow and partial adaptationto new conditions. To compare the work of birds with thehighest manifestations of human art and science is totallybeside the question. I do not maintain that birds are giftedwith reasoning faculties at all approaching in variety andextent to those of man. I simply hold that the phenomenapresented by their mode of building their nests, when fairlycompared with those exhibited by the great mass of mankindin building their houses, indicate no essential difference in thekind or nature of the mental faculties employed. If instinctmeans anything, it means the capacity to perform some complexact without teaching or experience. It implies not onlyinnate ideas but innate knowledge of a very definite kind, and,if established, would overthrow Mr. Mill's sensationalism andall the modern philosophy of experience. That the existenceof true instinct may be established in other cases is notimpossible but in the;particular instance of birds' nests, whichis usually considered one of its strongholds, I cannot find aparticle of evidence to show the existence of anything beyondthose lower reasoning and imitative powers which animalsare universally admitted to possess.

116 NATURAL SELECTION v'Parsons Pond,' in Newfoundland, which is separated fromthe sea only by a high pebbly beach. Within the periodabove stated high tides and heavy seas have shifted the courseof the brook flowing from the lake into the sea, and caused agreater, and consequently a more rapid fall of fresh water,which has so shallowed that part of the lake where the gullswere in the habit of breeding that it was no longer safe tobuild on rocks easily accessible to their common enemy, thefox. They therefore betook themselves to some neighbouringspruce and balsam firs not much over a hundred yards distantfrom their old breeding station." Audubon also notes asimilar change of habit, some herring-gulls building their nestsin spruce-trees on an island in the Bay of Fundy, where theyhad formerly built on the ground.A curious example of a recent change of habits has occurredin Jamaica. Previous to 1854 the palm swift(Tachornis phoenicobea) inhabited exclusively the palm treesin a few districts in the island. A colony then establishedthemselves in two cocoa-nut palms in Spanish Town, andremained there till 1857, when one tree was blown down andthe other stripped of its foliage. Instead of now seeking outother palm trees the swifts drove out the swallows who builtin the piazza of the House of Assembly, and took possessionof it, building their nests on the tops of the end walls and atthe angles formed by the beams and joists, a place which theycontinue to occupy in considerable numbers. It is remarkedthat here they form their nest with much less elaboration thanwhen built in the palms, probably from being less exposed.But perfection of structure and adaptation to purpose arenot universal characteristics of birds' nests, since there aredecided imperfections in the nesting of many birds which arequite compatible with our present theory, but are hardly sowith that of instinct, which is supposed to be infallible. Thepassenger pigeon of America often crowds the branches withits nests tillthey break, and the isground strewn withshattered nests, eggs, and young birds. Books' nests areoften so imperfect that during high winds the eggs fall out ;but the window-swallow is the most unfortunate in this respect,for White, of Selborne, informs us that he has seen thembuild, year after year, in places where their nests are liable

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!