12.07.2015 Views

Kite Lines - Vol.2 No. 4 - KiteLife

Kite Lines - Vol.2 No. 4 - KiteLife

Kite Lines - Vol.2 No. 4 - KiteLife

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS
  • No tags were found...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Weight Watching Japan's GiantsA. PETE IANUZZI, POCKET CALCULATOR IN HAND, QUESTIONSTHE WEIGHT CLAIMED FOR JAPAN'S LEGENDARY MAMMOTH KITES .There is a story that has beenhanded down from book to bookabout a giant kite which was builtin Japan some time ago . The datevaries depending on which bookyou read, some putting the dateas early as 1909, others as late as1936. Apparently the kite wasflown for several years in successionand may have been the samekite rebuilt each year . A goodguess is that it was a new kiteeach year built using some of theparts from the previous year's kite .A kite that big would almostcertainly be badly damaged onlanding .This great kite was known as thewan-wan or the wan-wan-dako andit was designed and built in thecity of Naruto on Shikoku island,probably by the master kite makerNagajima Gempei. There is someagreement from the varioussources that this monster was anoval-shaped kite, 60 to 65 feet indiameter . One source puts it at 90feet in diameter, but that sizeseems highly unlikely .I make this last statement on thebasis of a photograph of anotherkite, the Hoshubana o-dako, whichappears in several places . This pictureshows a nearly unbelievablerectangular kite propped up on itsside, with its flying team of 5 3 menand a Shinto priest standing infront of the kite . The caption statesthat the kite is 36 by 48 feet . Ifthe kite is that size, the men are711011 tall-a possibility forWatusis but a bit tall for Orientals .Assuming the men are 511011tall, the size of the kite scales outas 24 by 35 feet . A kite 90 feet indiameter would have about seventimes the area of the monster inthe picture! Even if we accept thefigure of 65 feet in diameter, thewan-wan would still be about fourtimes the size of the kite in thephotograph .The size of this kite is very interesting,but I am puzzled by thefact that so many sources reportthe weight of the wan-wan withoutgiving any thought to the impliedresults . The weight is given as aminimum of 1700 pounds and amaximum of eight tons, with severalreports at about 8000 pounds .The Guinness Book of World Recordsgoes further, to nine and ahalf tons. I just don't believe it .I have built a large, heavy kite .It is rectangular and 6x8 ft. i nsize, giving an area of 48 squarefeet . A wind of about eight milesper hour is required to fly it andit weighs 5 .24 pounds, which isabout 1 .7 ounces per square footof area. Also for comparison, mostkitefliers know the Peter Powellstunter kite . It is a heavy plastickite which flies best in strongwinds, as at the seashore . It weighsabout 1 .9 ounces per square foot .<strong>No</strong>w let us consider the wan-wan .If it is 65 feet in diameter, it willhave an area of 3 318 square feet .(I am not quibbling about the lossof area for the oval .) If this kiteweighs 8000 pounds, it will weigh38 .6 ounces per square foot, whichis ridiculous . If we take the lowestfigure quoted, 1700 pounds, theweight works out at 8 .2 ouncesper square foot, still not veryreasonable .To get some idea of what one ofthese kites might actually weigh,let us assume a monster-typeweight of 3 .0 ounces per squarefoot . Then the wan-wan wouldweigh about 622 pounds . That, asfar as I am concerned, is an absoluteupper limit . My educatedguess for the actual weight of a65-foot wan-wan would be 250 to350 pounds, or a surface load of1 .2 to 1 .7 ounces per square foot .Anything from 800 pounds up issheer nonsense .That photographed big rectangularkite mentioned with its 53-man flying team would be 16.3ounces per square foot if itweighed 800 kilograms . At a reasonableloading of three ouncesper square foot, it would weigh324 pounds . However, if it were35 by 24 feet, which seems morelikely, it would probably weighabout 160 pounds. That is still apretty husky kite .I have prepared the accompanyingchart of large kite sizes andweights from two sources : (1)available published information,from which I have taken averagevalues for the sizes and weights ofthese large kites, since there isconsiderable variation from bookto book (the exact values are notvery important ; after all, what is1000 pounds more or less whenyou are discussing a kite thatweighs 8000 pounds?), and (2)actual measurements and weightsof large kites which I have flownor know have been flown recently .As you can see, none of the kitesin the second group goes abovetwo ounces per square foot andthese are not low-wind kites.TAL STREETER REPLIESI cannot believe that the Japaneseare mistaken or exaggeratingthe weight of their giant kites .This seems improbable as manyof us have raised the question tothe Japanese on many occasionsand have been reassured that theweights are correct . <strong>No</strong> doubtPete Ianuzzi's question will serveto urge the Japanese kite expertsto settle the matter to everyone'ssatisfaction .The improbability of the giantkite's flight is in itself a keystoneof its appeal over the centuries .As long as we don't quite believeit, it's a heck of a lot more interesting-don'tyou think?

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!