wherein all the reason and philosophy of atheism is confuted, and

wherein all the reason and philosophy of atheism is confuted, and wherein all the reason and philosophy of atheism is confuted, and

cch.kcl.ac.uk
from cch.kcl.ac.uk More from this publisher
12.07.2015 Views

thatjiA The great Djffe?'efice hetwlxt the B o o k I.hence, that not only all animals and the fouls of men, but alio if therewere any gods, which fome of thofe Materialifts would not ftick, at leadverbally, to acknowledge, ( meaning thereby certain underftanding beingsfuperiour to men) thefe likewife muil needs have been all generated, andconfequently be corruptible. Now to fay, that there is no other God, thanfiich as was made and generated, and which may be again unmade, corruptedand die, or that there was once no God at all till he was madeout of the matter, and that there may be none again, this is all one as todeny the thing itfelf. For a native and mortal God is a pure contradicj.ih.14. c. 6. tion. Therefore whereas Arijiotk, in his Metaphyficks, tells us of certain[i'-47''] Theoloo'ers, ol ex vu>c1o? wavrai •yinmrs;, fucb as did generate all things (eventhe crods themfelves) out of Night and Chaos, we mud needs pronounce offuch Theologers as thefe, who were Theogonifts, and generated all thegods (without exception) out of fenfelefs and ftupid matter, that they werebut a kind of atheiftical Theologers, or theological Atheifts. For thoughthey did admit of certain beings, to which they attributed the name of gods,yet according to the true notion of God, they really acknowledged none atall, [i. e. no underftanding nature as the original of things; but Night andChaos, fenfelefs and ftupid matter, fortuitoully moved, was to them thehigheft of all Numens. So that this theology of theirs was a thing whollyfounded in atheiftical nonfenfe.XIV. And now we think it feafonable here to obferve, how vaft a differencethere was betwixt thefe old Materialifts in AriJlotL\ and thofe otherphilofophers, mentioned before in the firft chapter, who determined, «'JbvSi ylyviBxi m i?>0£.'p.=(9«i Tujv ovTxr That no real entity at all -was generated orcorrupted, for this reafon, becaufe nothing could be made out of nothing.Thefe were chiefly the philofophers of the Italick or Pythagorick fucceffion-, and their defign in it was not, as /Iriftotle was plcafed fomewhereto affirm, avfAsn/ sry.Ty.v ttv ysvinv, to contradift common fenfi and experience,in denying ail natural generations and alterations ; but only to interpretnature righdy in them, and that in way of oppofition to thofe atheiftickMaterialifts, after this manner •, in all the mutations of nature,generations and alterations, there was neither any new fubftance made, whichwas not before, nor any entity really diftinft from the pre-evifting fubftarces,but only that fubftance which was before, diveilly modified ; and fonothing produced in generations, but new modifications, mixtures, andfeparations of pre-exiftent fubftances.Now this docirine of theirs drove at thefe two things ; firft, the takingaway of fuch qualities and forms of body, as were vulgarly conceived to bethings really diftinft from the fubftance of extended bulk, and all its modificationsof more or lefs magnitude, figure, fitc, motion or reft. Beeaufe, ifthere were any fuch things as thefe, p.-oduced in the natural generations andalterations of bodies, there would then be fome real entity made sV. y.r,^s

theyChap. III. Pythagorlch^ andthe Old Materiahjls. 115fore they concludcxl, that thefe fuppofcd forms and qualities of bodi'-s werereally nothing elfc, h'.'t only the diiferent modificacions of pve-cxident matter,in refpe(fl of magritude, iigure, fite and modon, or relt ; or dilfjrcnt concretionsand fecretions, which are no cntitits really diftinft from t^e fubftance,but only c.iufe difR-rent plufai-ita, fancies and apparitions in us. oThe fecord thing, which this doftrine aimed at, was the cfcablifliing theincorporcity and ingencrahility of all I'ouls. For fince life, cogitation, fenfeand undiTfi.inding, could not be refolvcd into thofe modifications of matter,magnitude, figure, fite and motion, orintomcch-inifm and fancy, but mufbneeds be entities really ditUndt from extended bulk, or dead and ftupidmatter -, conclixLd, that therefore fouls could not be generated out ofmatter, bccaufe this would be the produftion of fome real endty out of nothinginexiftingor j^re-exifting but that they muil needs be another kind of•,fubftance incorporeal, which could no more be generated or corrupted, thanthe fubRance of matter itfclf ; and therefore muft either prc-cxift in nature,before generations, or q\{^ be divinely created and infufed in them.It hath been already proved in the firfl: chapter, that the upfliot of thatPythagorick doftrine, that nothing could be generated out of nothing preexifting,amounted to thofe two things mendoned, viz. the aflTerting of theincorporcity and ingcnerability of fouls, and the rejecting of thofe fantalfickentities of forms and real qualities of bodies, and rcfolving all corporeal phjEnomenairtto figures or atoms, and the difi'erent apparitions or fancies caufedby them. But the latter of thefe may be further confirmed from this paflTageoi yhijlotkh, where, after he had declared, that Z)««o(rr//z/j and Leucippusmade the foul and fire to confift of round atoms or figures, like thofe h tucJepi fuVji/.sjTis, thofe ramenta that appear in the air when the fun-beams are tranfmittedthrough crannies ; he adds eoixe h\ v.x\ tl ko.^'I tuk n-j^xyof^iuv Xiyojj.cvo'j, A'-ta yfufiflx.rriv a.\jT/iJ t^Cii J'utioiai', i(px(!-c.v yy^Tivig ai'Tuv, ^/\i^m livca roi h tm a/pi j^va-fAocleCj ol^J. ?• C i "^^ii, 70 TOMToi xi'.Tv. And that zvhicb is /aid amon^Jl the Pythagoreans feems to have arniftake foi*the fame fenfe, for fome of them affirm, that the foul is thofe very ^uViuaTa, the paflTage isramenta or atoms; but others of them, that it is that which 'moves //^j^w; ; Lib. i. de a-v/hich latter doubtlefs were the genuine Pythagoreans. However, it is plain"'"^^.'"P- j[-from hence, that the old Pythagoreans phyfiologizcd by goVjuaTa, as well asQ.t^^ °"'" 'Democritus 5 that is, figures and atoms, and not qualities and forms.But Ariflotle\ Materialifts, on the contrary, taking it for granted, thatmatter, or extended bulk, is the only liibftance, and that the qualities andforms of bodies are entities really diftinft from thofe modifications of magnitude,figure, fite, motion or reft ; and finding alfo by experience, thatthefc were continually generated and corrupted, as likewife that life,fenfe and underftanding were produced in the bodies of fuch animals, whereit had not been before, and again extinguifhed at the death or corruptionof them, concluded, that the fouls of all animals, as well as thofe other qualitiesand forms of bodies, were generated out of the matter, and corruptedagain into it ; and confequcntly, that every thing that is in the whole world,befidci

<strong>the</strong>yChap. III. Pythagorlch^ <strong>and</strong><strong>the</strong> Old Materiahjls. 115fore <strong>the</strong>y concludcxl, that <strong>the</strong>fe fupp<strong>of</strong>cd forms <strong>and</strong> qualities <strong>of</strong> bodi'-s werere<strong>all</strong>y nothing elfc, h'.'t only <strong>the</strong> diiferent modificacions <strong>of</strong> pve-cxident matter,in refpe(fl <strong>of</strong> magritude, iigure, fite <strong>and</strong> modon, or relt ; or dilfjrcnt concretions<strong>and</strong> fecretions, which are no cntitits re<strong>all</strong>y diftinft from t^e fubftance,but only c.iufe difR-rent plufai-ita, fancies <strong>and</strong> apparitions in us. oThe fecord thing, which th<strong>is</strong> d<strong>of</strong>trine aimed at, was <strong>the</strong> cfcablifliing <strong>the</strong>incorporcity <strong>and</strong> ingencrahility <strong>of</strong> <strong>all</strong> I'ouls. For fince life, cogitation, fenfe<strong>and</strong> undiTfi.inding, could not be refolvcd into th<strong>of</strong>e modifications <strong>of</strong> matter,magnitude, figure, fite <strong>and</strong> motion, orintomcch-inifm <strong>and</strong> fancy, but mufbneeds be entities re<strong>all</strong>y ditUndt from extended bulk, or dead <strong>and</strong> ftupidmatter -, conclixLd, that <strong>the</strong>refore fouls could not be generated out <strong>of</strong>matter, bccaufe th<strong>is</strong> would be <strong>the</strong> produftion <strong>of</strong> fome real endty out <strong>of</strong> nothinginexiftingor j^re-exifting but that <strong>the</strong>y muil needs be ano<strong>the</strong>r kind <strong>of</strong>•,fubftance incorporeal, which could no more be generated or corrupted, than<strong>the</strong> fubRance <strong>of</strong> matter itfclf ; <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong>refore muft ei<strong>the</strong>r prc-cxift in nature,before generations, or q\{^ be divinely created <strong>and</strong> infufed in <strong>the</strong>m.It hath been already proved in <strong>the</strong> firfl: chapter, that <strong>the</strong> upfliot <strong>of</strong> thatPythagorick d<strong>of</strong>trine, that nothing could be generated out <strong>of</strong> nothing preexifting,amounted to th<strong>of</strong>e two things mendoned, viz. <strong>the</strong> aflTerting <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong>incorporcity <strong>and</strong> ingcnerability <strong>of</strong> fouls, <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> rejecting <strong>of</strong> th<strong>of</strong>e fantalfickentities <strong>of</strong> forms <strong>and</strong> real qualities <strong>of</strong> bodies, <strong>and</strong> rcfolving <strong>all</strong> corporeal phjEnomenairtto figures or atoms, <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> difi'erent apparitions or fancies caufedby <strong>the</strong>m. But <strong>the</strong> latter <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong>fe may be fur<strong>the</strong>r confirmed from th<strong>is</strong> paflTageoi yhijlotkh, where, after he had declared, that Z)««o(rr//z/j <strong>and</strong> Leucippusmade <strong>the</strong> foul <strong>and</strong> fire to confift <strong>of</strong> round atoms or figures, like th<strong>of</strong>e h tucJepi fuVji/.sjT<strong>is</strong>, th<strong>of</strong>e ramenta that appear in <strong>the</strong> air when <strong>the</strong> fun-beams are tranfmittedthrough crannies ; he adds eoixe h\ v.x\ tl ko.^'I tuk n-j^xy<strong>of</strong>^iuv Xiyojj.cvo'j, A'-ta yfufiflx.rriv a.\jT/iJ t^Cii J'utioiai', i(px(!-c.v yy^Tivig ai'Tuv, ^/\i^m livca roi h tm a/pi j^va-fAocleCj ol^J. ?• C i "^^ii, 70 TOMToi xi'.Tv. And that zvhicb <strong>is</strong> /aid amon^Jl <strong>the</strong> Pythagoreans feems to have arniftake foi*<strong>the</strong> fame fenfe, for fome <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong>m affirm, that <strong>the</strong> foul <strong>is</strong> th<strong>of</strong>e very ^uViuaTa, <strong>the</strong> paflTage <strong>is</strong>ramenta or atoms; but o<strong>the</strong>rs <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong>m, that it <strong>is</strong> that which 'moves //^j^w; ; Lib. i. de a-v/hich latter doubtlefs were <strong>the</strong> genuine Pythagoreans. However, it <strong>is</strong> plain"'"^^.'"P- j[-from hence, that <strong>the</strong> old Pythagoreans phyfiologizcd by goVjuaTa, as well asQ.t^^ °"'" 'Democritus 5 that <strong>is</strong>, figures <strong>and</strong> atoms, <strong>and</strong> not qualities <strong>and</strong> forms.But Ariflotle\ Materialifts, on <strong>the</strong> contrary, taking it for granted, thatmatter, or extended bulk, <strong>is</strong> <strong>the</strong> only liibftance, <strong>and</strong> that <strong>the</strong> qualities <strong>and</strong>forms <strong>of</strong> bodies are entities re<strong>all</strong>y diftinft from th<strong>of</strong>e modifications <strong>of</strong> magnitude,figure, fite, motion or reft ; <strong>and</strong> finding alfo by experience, that<strong>the</strong>fc were continu<strong>all</strong>y generated <strong>and</strong> corrupted, as likewife that life,fenfe <strong>and</strong> underft<strong>and</strong>ing were produced in <strong>the</strong> bodies <strong>of</strong> fuch animals, whereit had not been before, <strong>and</strong> again extinguifhed at <strong>the</strong> death or corruption<strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong>m, concluded, that <strong>the</strong> fouls <strong>of</strong> <strong>all</strong> animals, as well as th<strong>of</strong>e o<strong>the</strong>r qualities<strong>and</strong> forms <strong>of</strong> bodies, were generated out <strong>of</strong> <strong>the</strong> matter, <strong>and</strong> corruptedagain into it ; <strong>and</strong> confequcntly, that every thing that <strong>is</strong> in <strong>the</strong> whole world,befidci

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!