52 3. <strong>Calibration</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Terrestrial</strong> <strong>Laser</strong> <strong>Scanner</strong>nersystem, a coordinate transformation can be applied using the coordinates <strong>of</strong> the control pointsTheresiduals <strong>of</strong> the local scannerorigin define the eccentricity <strong>of</strong> the scan centerThe results <strong>of</strong> several independent <strong>and</strong> different setups show that there is no significant eccentricityin thescan center The residuals <strong>of</strong> the transformed local origin, defining the scan center, to the coordinate system<strong>of</strong> the control points are less than 1 mm for the horizontal positionThus, the eccentricityis below the accu¬racy <strong>of</strong> the distance measurement system <strong>and</strong> the angle measurement system, respectively Furthermore, avertical <strong>of</strong>fset was identified with a value <strong>of</strong> 0 222 m ± 1 mm depending on the screws <strong>of</strong> the tnbrachs3.4.2 Wobble <strong>of</strong> Vertical axisThe wobble <strong>of</strong> an axis is an instrumental error, which is caused by variations in the axis during rotationTheideal case is that the axis remains at a constant orientation during rotation, but inpractice, motion <strong>of</strong> the axisleads to deviations from the ideal positionCauses for the wobble are either manufacturing imperfectionsresulting from mechanical deficiencies, eg defective mould <strong>of</strong> the bearing, or the mechanical components<strong>of</strong> the axisThe bearing can especially cause systematic effects <strong>and</strong> result in changesin the orientation <strong>of</strong>the axis, cf [Matthias, 1961] <strong>and</strong> [Gerstbach, 1976]Variations in the vertical axis are investigated by measuring the inclination <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis Developingvalues for the orientation, l e the inclination <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis, allows conclusions to be drawn regardingthe behaviour <strong>of</strong> the vertical axisThe raw data provided by the inclination sensor have to be pre-processedbecause these data include somesystematic effects First, possible systematic effects caused by the inclina¬tion sensor itself have to be identified [L<strong>of</strong>fier et al, 2002] additive constant, linearity error14, long-termstability, temperature influences etc Second, systematic effects caused by the rotation <strong>of</strong> the laser scannerare <strong>of</strong> importance the influence <strong>of</strong> the levelling error, properties <strong>of</strong> the bearing, etcThe inclination sensor used is the Nivel 20 <strong>of</strong> Leica GeosystemsThe mam characteristics <strong>of</strong> this sensor are[Leica Geosystems, 1988]• inclination resolution 0 001 mrad (measuring range ±2 mrad)• linearity error ± [0 005 mrad + 0 5% <strong>of</strong> inclination value]For acquiring the inclination data during rotation, the Nivel 20 is mounted ontop <strong>of</strong> the laser scanner, nearlycentrallyin the vertical axismeasuring range during the rotation AThe laser scanner has to be levelled so that the inclination sensor is within thebe performed due to imperfectness in the levelling procedurebe eliminated mathematicallyor LRViewer15levelling error is present because absolute precise levelling cannotHowever, the levelling error produced canThe laser scanner is then controlled via the operating s<strong>of</strong>tware LRCServerWithin this s<strong>of</strong>tware, the laser scanner can be rotated to discrete horizontal directions basedon the local scanner orientationThe inclination <strong>of</strong> the actual vertical axis, in two perpendicular directionsx <strong>and</strong> y, can be read by the inclination sensor, as controlled by NivelPlane16The goal <strong>of</strong> the wobble analysis <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis is to analyze whether there are systematiceffects thatcan describe the wobble mathematically or whether there are no systematic effects <strong>and</strong> consequently, thevertical axis has no wobble The assumption is that the wobble results in harmonic oscillations, which canbe approximated by sine terms Therefore, a Fourier analysis is appliedon the inclination data to derivethe frequency, or period, the amplitude, <strong>and</strong> the phase angle <strong>of</strong> a possible significant frequency causing thewobble <strong>of</strong> the vertical axisThe sampling theorem has to be taken into account when the Fourier analysis14 An inclination displayed by the inclination sensor should be proportional to the real inclination The deviation between displayed<strong>and</strong> real inclination is defined as a linearityerror <strong>of</strong> the sensor15LRCServer <strong>and</strong> LRViewer are s<strong>of</strong>tware for operating <strong>and</strong> controlling the laser scanner, both provided by Zoller+Frohlich GmbH16NivelPlane is a s<strong>of</strong>tware tool for controlling the Nivel20 provided by Leica Geosystems
Analysisvalueseffects, beforeh<strong>and</strong>throughTheseprocedure<strong>of</strong> the sensor, ThisNivel applicationFourier systematicareinclinatione.g. error,Data vertical 20 includes which analysis.abalance alevellingpart two-face-measurements.always Series havepresentaxiseliminatedlaseracquisitionusingscanner. producedapplied todata easily after acalibration3.4 Instrumental Errors 53is applied to a data series [Taubenheim, 1969]. The Nyquist frequency /nyq defines the maximum frequencybased on the sampling interval At, which can be detected byf=2At-(3'8)This means the real signal can only be detected if at least two samples fall within a full period<strong>of</strong> thewavelength. All frequencies higher than the Nyquist frequency cannot be detected <strong>and</strong> lead to aliasingeffects thereby, defining the aliasing frequencies that superpose the frequency / [Taubenheim, 1969]:/, 2fnyq±f, 4fnyq±f,...(3.9)An example <strong>of</strong> aliasing is given in Figure 3.27. It can be seen that based on the samplesmore than onesine curve fits to the data. All frequencies higher than the Nyquist frequencyto aliasing effects.remain undetected <strong>and</strong> leadMore information concerning Fourier analysis, Nyquist frequency, aliasing,found in [Taubenheim, 1969] <strong>and</strong> [Welsch et al., 2000].etc. can ber«.jèX" i \iff \ l\ / \ / \1 \J'JlA f„1 10,I P p,IJ \I \j'J1I \ I \ / "\ f/- \ ( \1 \{ / \ dr",--f /"ft. 1uI\ i~^£.7Figure 3.27: Aliasing effects based on sampling: More than one sine curve fits to the samplings.The comprehensive investigations <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis wobble include several different experimental setups:(1) The laser scanner was mounted on a tribrach <strong>and</strong> then installed on a tripod <strong>and</strong> on an observationpillar.(2) The laser scanner was mounted on a granite table directly without using a tribrach.During the investigation a counter weight was attached on one side <strong>of</strong> the laser scanner to balance the mass<strong>of</strong> the laser scanner (approx. 5 kg). The advantage is better symmetry in mass, but the disadvantage isthat the counter weight increases the mass <strong>of</strong> the laser scanner considerably. The assumptionis the balanceweight influences the wobble <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis in a positive way. All different data series have two thingsin common: the sampling interval At varies between 5 ° to 30 ° <strong>and</strong> the sampling rangethree to four full rotations according to 1080° <strong>and</strong> 1440°. Thus,a reasonable acquisitionvaries between<strong>of</strong> data series isguaranteed assuming that the wobble causes harmonic oscillations with periods <strong>of</strong> 720 ° or shorter. Themathematical description <strong>of</strong> a possible wobble <strong>of</strong> the vertical axis requires both repeatability <strong>and</strong> repro¬ducibility <strong>of</strong> the parameters characterizing the wobble: amplitude, frequency <strong>and</strong> phase angle. Comparingdata series acquired by the same setup, one also finds that the levelling errors correspondwith each other.