WSDOT Moving TowardsPerformance-Based<strong>Concrete</strong> SpecificationsAlthough the concrete has performedwell overall, future projects similarto this will use performance-basedconcrete specifications. This willallow WSDOT to include additionalperformance requirements such asshrinkage and scaling resistance. Somepotential improvements that couldbe made to this mix include reducingcementitious materials content, addingshrinkage-reducing or corrosioninhibitingadmixtures, or perhapsmoving to self-consolidating concrete.Shifting to performance specificationswill allow contractors to develop mixesthat meet performance requirementsyet are tailored to the forming,placement, consolidation, and the formremoval methods they prefer.<strong>The</strong> WSDOT is currently consideringuse of the performance-basedspecifications for the next floatingbridge project, which will likely bethe State Route 520 floating bridgereplacement across Lake Washington.This project is currently in the designphase, with pontoon constructionexpected to start late 2009. Pontoonconstruction on this project sharesmany similarities with the Hood Canalproject. <strong>The</strong> WSDOT is incorporatingvaluable experiences from Hood Canalinto the design of the State Route 520<strong>Bridge</strong> to further improve performanceand constructability, and reduceconstruction costs.materials and tight constructiontolerances are required. Wideningand improving the bridge’s west halfwas completed in 2005, Since then,the Washington State Departmentof Transportation (WSDOT) has beenconstructing a new east half, which willbe moved into place in May-June 2009,and further upgrading the west half.<strong>The</strong> work is underway at multiplec o n s t r u c t i o n s i t e s i n w e s t e r nWashington. Since early 2006,construction pro g ress includessuccessfully building and floating 12 ofthe 14 new east-half pontoons, joiningthe draw span pontoons together, andrehabilitating three 1980 pontoons.<strong>The</strong> original elevated roadways wereremoved from these pontoons, andwider roadways with a new profile gradewere constructed in their place. Also, 20gravity anchors have been constructedand were placed on the canal floor insummer 2007. Other large operationsin various stages of construction includefabrication of the transition spans andspecialized supports, lift spans, largespherical and cylindrical bearings,major mechanical components, andoutfitting of the draw span assemblywith buildings, access ramps, and thehydraulic, mechanical, and electricalsystems.All of these elements of work set thestage for the closure of the bridge inMay-June 2009, when the east half ofthe bridge and the west transition spanwill be replaced. <strong>The</strong> bridge will be opento traffic while new anchor cables areinstalled and west half mechanical andelectrical upgrades are made.Pontoon Construction<strong>The</strong> prestressed high-performanceconcrete (HPC) pontoons are beingconstructed in four separate cycles at<strong>Concrete</strong> Technology Corporation’sgraving dock in Tacoma, Wash. <strong>The</strong>largest of the cellular box structures is60 ft wide, 18 ft tall and 360 ft long.<strong>The</strong> pontoons are heavily reinforcedwith both conventional epoxy-coatedreinforcing steel and longitudinal,transverse, and vertical post-tensioningtendons.<strong>The</strong> HPC used for the pontoons wasoriginally developed in the 1990s forthe I-90 Lacey V. Murrow (LVM) floatingbridge across Lake Washington andincludes the following components:Type I/II cement: 625 lb/yd 3Class F fly ash: 100 lb/yd 3Silica fume: 50 lb/yd 3Aggregates: 1/2-in. maximum size<strong>The</strong> approximately 31,000 yd 3 ofpontoon concrete have a minimumspecified 28-day compressive strengthof 6500 psi, and a maximum 56-daychloride permeability of 1000 coulombs.<strong>The</strong> actual 28-day compressive strengthshave been approximately 11,000 psiand the 56-day permeability less than800 coulombs. Early in the project, thecontractor realized that the LVM concreteplacement in the pontoon walls wouldbe challenging because the walls are upto 21 ft tall; 6 in., 8 in., and 10 in. thick;and heavily congested with reinforcingsteel and post-tensioning ducts. Toimprove concrete placement andconsolidation, the contractor requestedapproval to exceed the maximum 9-in.slump that was allowed by the contract.This was achieved by using additionalhigh-range water-reducing admixturewithin manufacturer’s allowances. After<strong>The</strong> elevated roadway was constructed atTerminal 91 at the Port of Seattle on threeexisting pontoons. <strong>The</strong>se three pontoonswere used temporarily in the west drawspan until 1982 to open the Hood Canal<strong>Bridge</strong> quickly after the 1979 storm sunkthe west half. <strong>The</strong>se pontoons weresuccessfully rehabilitated in 2007 after25 years of storage in the Puget Soundand are used in the new east half.
<strong>The</strong> final set of 10 anchors was towed to the Hood Canal and set accurately on the channel floorusing GPS, tilt meters, and gyroscopes. <strong>The</strong> anchor cables will be attached between the anchorsand pontoons in 2009.A concrete floating bridge providesa cost-effective solution.Pontoons are assembled together withspliced post-tensioning tendons beforebeing towed to the Hood Canal <strong>Bridge</strong> toreplace the old pontoons.conducting a series of qualification testsand constructing a mock-up pontoonwall, the contractor successfullydemonstrated that this “new” mixcould be placed without segregation.Testing and acceptance of this concretewas accomplished using the flow testthat is common with self-consolidatingconcrete (SCC).Another innovation implemented was toprecast portions of two pontoons thatmake up the moveable draw pontoons.<strong>The</strong>se pontoons have heavy mechanicalcomponents cast into the walls 21 ftoverhead. <strong>The</strong> precasting operationimproved overall safety in supportingthese massive guides and facilitated thetight alignment tolerances needed forthe mechanical draw span operations.<strong>The</strong> precast elements consisted ofportions of the exterior walls with allnecessary reinforcement and posttensioningto tie into the top andbottom slabs. Once the precast pieceswere set into place, reinforcement andpost-tensioning was tied into the baseslab and the wall closure regions. <strong>The</strong>base slab, wall closures, and top slabwere then constructed with cast-inplaceconcrete. By precasting portionsof these pontoons, construction timewas reduced. Precasting also allowedmuch of the work to be shifted off-siteand away from the heavily congestedgraving dock facility.Elevated RoadwayConstructionTo withstand the regular pounding ofsaltwater waves that crash over thebridge during the storm season fromOctober through April, the elevatedroadway built atop the pontoonsis constructed primarily of reinforcedand precast, prestressed concrete.With project activities since early 2006focusing on constructing pontoonsand anchors and assembling the drawspan section, the elevated roadwayremains a main element of work to beaccomplished.<strong>The</strong> elevated roadway on a floatingstructure compels the designer to selectan optimal span length to minimizethe dead loads and to evenly distributecolumn loads to the pontoon structure,which behaves like a beam on elasticfoundation from water buoyancy. Forthe Hood Canal <strong>Bridge</strong>, this equates toshallow I-girders with 60-ft span lengths.Built on two-column piers, the two-spancontinuous units have a hinge diaphragmat the center pier. <strong>The</strong> floating structure isisolated from seismic events with specialconnections to the fixed structures, so thefloating bridge is governed by dynamicloads from wind, waves, and currentsinstead of seismic loads.<strong>The</strong> prestressed concrete I-girders aretypical WSDOT 32-in.- and 42-in.-deepsections, but all reinforcement and0.5-in.-diameter prestressing strands areepoxy coated and the bottom flangeconcrete clear cover is 1-1/4 in. <strong>The</strong>7-1/2-in.-thick roadway deck consistsof 4 in. of reinforced concrete cast on3-1/2 in.-thick, stay-in-place precast,prestressed concrete deck panels.Using stay-in-place panels significantlydecreased the time required to constructthe deck and increased safety whenworking over water.<strong>ASPIRE</strong>, <strong>Summer</strong> 20<strong>08</strong> | 19