e x e c u t i v e i n t e r v i e wBrainwashing part of CAL’s safety blitz – page 34CAL: the‘Comeback Kid’After a year of ups and downs, China Airlines is back in the moneyBy Barry Grindrodin TaipeiResponsibility appears to rest easily onthe broad shoulders of China Airlines’(CAL) chief Sandy K. Y. Liu. It needs to.Historically, to be president of Taiwan’s nationalcarrier, with all the political baggage it carries,albeit through no fault of its own, has neverbeen easy.In more recent times demises like the Asianrecession and the tragic September earthquakein Taiwan, have tested CAL to the full.And if all that was not enough, a poorsafety record, very much the responsibility ofthe airline, has brought CAL extra governmental,operational and financial pressures.Mr Liu’s first year in office – he was confirmedas president in mid-1999 after fivemonths as acting president – has been nothingshort of extraordinary. A whole range of eventsfrom the good, the bad and downright uglyended in December when CAL announced itwas increasing its pre-tax profit forecast by39%.In August, CAL placed the largest aircraftorder in Taiwan’s aviation history and the biggestin the region for four years. Within 24 hoursit signed purchase agreements for 13 BoeingB747-400 freighters, valued at US$2.5 billion,with four options, and seven Airbus A340-300s with options for an additional A340 andfour A330-300s. The Airbus order was worthUS$1.8 billion.A few days later CAL’s safety record was inthe spotlight again, but for the worst reasonswhen one of its MD-11s flipped over on landingat Hong Kong’s Chek Lap Kok airport andcaught fire. Three people died and more than200 passengers and crew were injured.Although he was limited in what he couldsay about the accident at the time of thisinterview, Mr Liu said an ongoing investigationChina Airlines’ president Sandy K. Y. Liu: an extraordinary first year in officehas revealed, to his “relief”, that the cockpitcrew, contrary to early reports, acted properlyin the circumstances and pilot error was nota factor in the crash (see elsewhere in thisstory).The airline’s woes mounted in lateSeptember, however, when Taiwan was hit bya massive earthquake that killed an estimated2,000 people.Load factors slumped by 9% in October, butafter six weeks passenger and cargo traffic hadexceeded 1998 levels, with 73% and 85% loadfactors respectively in November!On September 30, CAL was forced to ceaseservices to the Philippines after Manila pulledthe plug on the air services agreement betweenthe two countries. The Philippines Governmentclaimed CAL and EVA Air were poaching sixthfreedom traffic on the route between Taiwanand its country and that they were hurtingPhilippine Airlines.Add these circumstances together and itmakes the profit forecast announcement bythe CAL board at the beginning of Decemberall the more remarkable.Consider the figures:Pre-tax profit forecast to increase to NT$2.8billion from NT$1.725 billion.In the first three quarters of the year passengerand cargo revenue rose 22.8% over thesame period in 1998. Pre-tax profit totalledNT$2.5 billion. This performance resulted in a6.2% reduction in unit cost, a 6.6% yield increaseand a 7.8% improvement in productivity.CAL predicts its revenue for 1999 willbe NT$61.2 bullion, up 18% on 1998. Net30 | <strong>Orient</strong> <strong>Aviation</strong> | February 2000
e x e c u t i v e i n t e r v i e woperating profit is expected to reach NT$1.6billion, compared to a loss of NT$3.9 billionlast year.Not for the first time, CAL has proved to bethe region’s leading ‘comeback kid’.And fifty-one-year-old Mr Liu has seen itall before. A 30-year stalwart of the nationalcarrier, CAL has been his life. He has workedin just about every division of the airline as heclimbed the management ladder. His father isa former chairman of CAL.Before he agreed to take on the hottestof hot seats following the crash of anotherCAL airliner in 1998, he thought long and hardbefore accepting what he describes as “a greatchallenge”.At the time, CAL staff were still recoveringfrom the crash of the A300-600 jet as itapproached Taipei’s Chiang Kai Shek airportwhich killed 201 people. Four years earlier,another A300-600 crash killed 264 passengersand crew in Nagoya, Japan.An extensive safety programme coveringall of the airline’s operations was already inplace when Mr Liu took over the reins, butsafety has continued to be his priority. No onecan accuse CAL of not addressing the problem(see separate story).Company sources say Mr Liu is a toughtaskmaster. “He has very high standards, buthe applies these standards equally to himselfas he does others,” said a source.Only time will tell if CAL has managedto exorcise its safety demons, but there is nodenying the contribution of the fiscal gurus tothe airline’s improved performance. Althoughthe turn around in the Asian economy hasplayed its part in the CAL recovery, cost controlhas been the underlying cause of the carrier’sperformance.But unlike many other airlines in theregion not one staff member has lost his orher job. “We guaranteed staff would not beasked to take furloughs or be laid off,” saidthe president.Staff cuts have been achieved throughnatural attrition, although some CAL employeeshave been retrained and moved to other areasof the company. In 1998 CAL had a payroll of9,200 staff. The budget for 1999 increased it to9,400. By mid-December, the figure had fallento 9,030.THE FUTURE:“The market is looking prosperous”, saidpresident Liu and CAL is honing its operations toexploit the improving economic situation.During 1999 CAL reduced the number of itsaircraft types from seven to five. It rid itself of itsremaining A300B4-200s and B747SPs. Between2000 and 2003 CAL will introduce new Boeingand Airbus aircraft to replace its B747-200s andthe MD-11s. By 2007, maybe earlier, CAL willhave just three aircraft types in its fleet; B747-400 passenger and freighter jets, B737-800s andAirbus A340/330s.Its fleet plan, said Mr Liu, is based onrenewal rather than expansion although itsaircraft options will allow it adapt to marketconditions. By 2007, CAL will have a minimumof 60 and maximum of 69 planes, dependingon market conditions.Mr Liu said CAL spent four years developingthe company “bible”, its strategy for the next 10years. At best it could make CAL hugely successful.At worst CAL could continue to be blightedby its poor safety record. One has to ask howmany more comebacks can a ‘kid’ make.Mr Liu will be hoping to ensure that comebacksare a thing of the past.Will an airline buy into CAL?China Airlines’ chief, Sandy K. Y. Liu,kept his cards close to his chest when hetalked to <strong>Orient</strong> <strong>Aviation</strong> about the saleof 35% of the stock in his airline.It was only days to the original dateplanned for the completion of the sale– the end of December. The decision hasnow been shelved until the end of February.The stock is half of governmentcontrolledChina <strong>Aviation</strong> DevelopmentFoundation’s 71% holding.“Yes, there has been a lot of interest,”he said. Banks? “Yes,” he replied.Airlines? “Yes,” he repeated. More thanone? Again: “Yes”.“You will know soon”, he said. Butalas the stock sale was delayed until theend of February.Analysts said the deferral was causedby CAL’s recent stock performance. ButMr Liu told <strong>Orient</strong> <strong>Aviation</strong> a delay wouldbe beneficial to CAL because prospectivebuyers would see the airline’s improvedposition unfold.And then, just possibly, a clue fromthe president’s tight lips about his plansfor CAL. Yes, China Airlines is investigatingthe benefits of alliances. “But we willwait for a result (of the sale) before wedecide on the way to go,” said Mr Liu.Could the buyer be a member of amajor alliance? Time will tell.MR LIU’SVIEWS ON...CAL’s MD-11 crashin Hong Kongased on all known facts this was to“Btally different to the Taipei andNagoya accidents. I spoke to Albert Lok, theHong Kong CAD director, and the investigatingcommittee and they said while there are manyareas where there are big questionmarksabout the crash, they confirmed that we cannotidentify this incident as pilot error related(on this basis Mr Liu said CAL had downgradedit from an accident to an incident).“The CRM between pilot and co-pilot,there is no question (they acted properly) ifyou read our aircraft CVR and FDR (transcripts)... I am not happy that we did not land the aircraftsafely, but I am somewhat relieved, basedon known facts, that all our efforts focused onflight safety related issues such as training andpilot discipline in the last year have proven weare serious about it.”Mr Liu said the investigators are concentratingtheir efforts on conditions at HongKong International Airport and the structureof the aircraft. He confirmed CAL is co-operatingwith Boeing, the U.S. National TransportationBoard (NTSB) and the Federal <strong>Aviation</strong>Administration (FAA) in studies into threesimilar accidents involving MD-11s.The Philippines airrights disputes the national carrier of Taiwan we”A have served this route for manyyears and likewise Philippine Airlines. Wehope the agreement can be re-instated,not just for the sake of the airlines, butalso for business and tourist customers.“As an international commercial airlinewe are selling the network. We are notselling the sector ... if any given route hasto miss out on fifth and sixth freedomtraffic that route has no future.“The Taipei-Seoul route has been suspendedfor seven years (a Governmentdecision when Korea opted to recogniseChina instead of Taiwan). It was an importantsector, but we have managed verywell without the services.“If the Manila situation is not resolvedwe will diversify to other areas.”32 | <strong>Orient</strong> <strong>Aviation</strong> | February 2000