and less secure, and its use, whether in the formof fuels or plastics, poses a very real danger tothe natural environment. It is the responsibilityof education to equip citizens with a degreeawareness of the physical realities of the worldin which we live, and with critical faculties andindependent thinking skills.The blame for our continuing to degrade theenvironment with chemical pollution, deforestation,extraction and so on has been said to lie atthe door of the over-specialisation of education.This view sidesteps both the role of economicsystems and matters of human psychology inthe despoliation of the Earth. It could be arguedthat educational curricula are fundamentallyshaped by the needs of the political economy,or that patterns of production simply meet thedemand of the majority of humans for comfortand status. But whether or not there is animplicit political agenda inherent in prevalentapproaches to education, the pigeon-holing oflearning into discreet subjects the world over,at all levels from primary to tertiary education,means that the way that things connect andinteract in the real world is largely neglected.Hence, for example, mainstream economistsdo not take into account in their calculations ofannual agricultural profits the long-term damagedone to soil or water quality or to biodiversity bythe massive use of agro-chemicals. Indeed, sucheffects may be hard to quantify in conventionalterms; but ultimately we ignore them at ourperil. This is not to say, however, that specialistsare not important. The complexity of naturaland human systems and effects demands a veryhigh level of expertise to penetrate and understandthem, and well-honed skills of enquiry,analysis and interpretation. We need to continueto train individuals in specialised areas, butdelving deep into subjects without also lookingaround at what is going on elsewhere producesdangerous tunnel vision.An important aspect of education for sustainability,then, is the contextualisation of knowledge,the consideration of the bigger picture. Theexercise of joined-up thinking – a practice atwhich politicians are often found to fail – shouldbecome an aim of the educational process.Education for sustainability needs both to beecological in itself and to include the specificstudy of ecology.Educating the whole personThe idea of the ‘educated’ person as a wellroundedindividual with an appreciation ofhuman history and culture and a grounding inscience, who is equipped to take an active andresponsible role in the world, is but a distant,dream-like memory. Contemporary educationaldiscourse, at least at policy level, if not ownedby teachers themselves, is all about testing,‘driving up standards’ and increasing employability,about academic attainment and vocationallearning. It serves the agenda of economicgrowth, ‘wealth creation’ and the maximising ofindividual incomes. Yet it is this economic enginethat is propelling environmental devastation.Education for sustainability, then, must involvethe education of the human heart, mind andspirit, not merely the training of the potentialemployee, earner and spender. In order to sustainhuman life, and at a level of existence that makeslife a pleasure, we need to learn to consume agreat deal less of material goods and energy, andto focus a great deal more on the non-materialriches that life well lived has to offer.In fostering these different objectives, educationwould wield enormous power to challenge thevalue system that puts profit for its own sake first,regards the human spirit as an optional extra, andin the end effectively threatens environmentalviability. There is currently an emphasis insecondary and tertiary education on ‘transferrableskills’, clearly useful skills like delegatingresponsibility, presenting material, organisingevents, and using particular computer software.However, if we are going to take sustainabilityseriously we need to learn and to teach other skillstoo – not just horticulture and all kinds of practicalmaking and mending skills but personal skillssuch as imagination and creativity, reflectiveness,self-restraint, co-operation and problem-solving.Music-making, appreciation of literature andother enriching activities that require virtually nomaterial consumption are other thoroughly usefulskills for living both sustainably and enjoyably.Experiential learningThe best and most enduring kind of learningis that which engages the learner affectively asEducation for the good society | 31
well as cognitively. Real understanding is mostlikely to be absorbed from active involvement,from doing, questioning or reflecting and thusdiscovering, rather than from acquiescing aspassive recipient in an intended process ofinformation transfer. Playing on a swing in thepark will convey far more effectively than beinginstructed in the classroom, if less consciously,the fact that a body needs the input of energy toremain in motion. Attempting to grow a planton the windowsill or in the school garden will begreatly more productive in nurturing a sense ofexactly how much water and shelter are neededfor successful cultivation than any textbook orteacher. Experiential learning trumps abstractlearning in most contexts. It creates the fertile soilin which intellectual concepts can grow.Given the crucial and urgent importance ofdeveloping sustainable ways of living, every effortshould be made to find practical means of bringinghome the relevant issues at different stages ofeducation. Hands-off learning, de-contextualisedparcels of information taken on trust from ascreen, book or teacher, which do not exist inreal time or space can, of course, be usefullyemployed to support practical exercises that haverelevance to issues pertaining to sustainability,but are not sufficient in themselves to build aproper understanding.New ways of living and localenvironmentOne way in which to increase awareness of theconditions obtaining in the natural and builtenvironment of a particular area and of howthese change over time would be to incorporatelocal studies into the curriculum so that allpupils learn about the history of their own areaand effectively conduct longitudinal researchinto it throughout the course of their schooling,considering different aspects of the localityduring their school career. Not only would thisdevelop in them a sense of identity and place, butit would also sensitise them to the significance ofchanges to other environments.Beyond the classroom and the lecturetheatre, part of the educative role of educationalinstitutions can be exercised through leadingby practical, explicitly explained example.Schools, colleges and universities should embodysustainability as a priority in their material policiesand practices, and create high expectations oflearners’ compliance with certain principlesof sustainability. Measures could include, forexample, the maximum use of local, minimallypackaged and fairly traded food, the provisionof drinking water fountains and the banning ofbottled water, strict rules for procurement andwaste disposal that fully incorporate the precept of‘reduce, re-use, recycle’, and active minimisationof the use of car journeys and air travel bystudents and staff. The growing of food on siteand the involvement of students and the localcommunity in this fundamental survival activitywould be of great benefit wherever feasible. Theaim should be social cohesion through maximumcommunal self-sufficiency.Building a relationship with thenatural worldIf children are to grow up with a desire to protectthe natural world, as well as an understandingof the importance of doing so, they must, at thevery least, have some familiarity with that world.But to develop the motivation to live in such away as not to damage it they need more thanacquaintance: they need to love it, and to respectits power, both as a provider and as a potentialdestroyer.There is only one way an affection for and trueknowledge of places, plants and creatures canbe engendered, and that is being among them,being part of the natural environment; it cannotbe inculcated by books, teachers in classroomsor anything a screen can provide. Abundantresearch evidence demonstrates this. Earlychildhood contact with nature really matters;it leaves a lasting mark. There is simply nosubstitute for going out into the woods, onto thebeach, into the fields and hills, feeling the wind,the rain and the sun, seeing the sights, smellingthe smells, hearing the sounds of birds, animals,insects, trees and plants. Not only does interactionwith nature foster a personal relationship withthe natural environment, but it benefits wellbeingand cognitive functioning too. Lack of suchexperience constitutes real deprivation, far greaterthan the lack of money to buy the latest fashion32 | www.compassonline.org.uk
- Page 1 and 2: Educationfor theGoodSocietyThe valu
- Page 3 and 4: Acknowledgements:Compass would like
- Page 5 and 6: ContributorsLisa Nandy is Labour MP
- Page 7 and 8: IntroductionEducation for the Good
- Page 9 and 10: 1 This article has been developedou
- Page 11 and 12: 8 See Ann Hodgson, Ken Spoursand Ma
- Page 13 and 14: 13 The most comprehensiverecent res
- Page 15 and 16: 1 See for example B. Simon, ‘Cane
- Page 17 and 18: 10 J. Martin, Making Socialists: Ma
- Page 19 and 20: the poorest homes (as measured by e
- Page 21 and 22: 1 In 2008, 15 per cent ofacademies
- Page 23 and 24: 1 Angela McRobbie, The Aftermathof
- Page 25 and 26: 8 Christine Skelton, Schooling theB
- Page 27 and 28: 1 See www.education.gov.uk/b0065507
- Page 29 and 30: 13 Barbara Fredrickson, ‘Therole
- Page 31: 6. Education forsustainabilityTeres
- Page 35 and 36: 7. Schools fordemocracyMichael Fiel
- Page 37 and 38: and joyful relations between person
- Page 39 and 40: 8 Wilfred Carr and AnthonyHartnett,
- Page 41 and 42: 1 Winston Churchill, quoted inNIACE
- Page 43 and 44: 9 See http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/ed
- Page 45 and 46: 1 The Learning Age: A Renaissancefo
- Page 47 and 48: nities, and not have the public-pri
- Page 49 and 50: 4 Engineering flexibility: a system
- Page 51 and 52: other countries to require their re
- Page 53 and 54: 6. Remember that many of the outcom
- Page 55 and 56: 2 Adrian Elliott, State SchoolsSinc
- Page 57 and 58: 4 Peter Hyman, ‘Fear on the front
- Page 59 and 60: 12. Rethinking thecomprehensive ide
- Page 61 and 62: training, be part of a local system
- Page 64: About CompassCompass is the democra