summary of decisions requested by persons making submissions

SUMMARY OF DECISIONS REQUESTED BYPERSONS MAKING SUBMISSIONSPROPOSED PLAN CHANGE 9MINOR DISTRICT PLAN MAP AMENDMENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTSSection 1:Guide to making further submissionsSection 2:Submitter’s names and addresses for service (by submitternumber)Section 3:Summary of Decisions Requested by Persons MakingSubmissions on Proposed Plan Change 9 – Minor District PlanMap AmendmentsPrepared by the Far North District Council – August2011

Section 1Guide to making further submissions1. Further SubmissionsAll the submissions received to date have been summarised and entered into adatabase. This database allows the Council to prepare a summary.The Summary of Decisions Requested by Persons Making Submissions, along withcopies of submissions is now available to the public so that everyone can find outwhat issues have been raised.The public is invited to make Further Submissions. These Further Submissions mayonly be in support or opposition to submissions already made. They can not extendthe scope of the original Submission and can only seek allowance or disallowancein whole or part of the original submission.Only certain persons may make a further submission, namely:(a) any person representing a relevant aspect of the public interest; or(b) any person that has an interest in the proposed plan change that is greaterthan the interest that the general public has; or(c) the local authority for the relevant area.Your further submission must be in the prescribed form. A standard form called“Further Submission on Proposed Plan Change 9 – Minor District Plan MapAmendments is available from Council Service Centres and can be downloadedfrom our website: www.fndc.govt.nzPlease complete a separate further submission for each original submission youwish to comment on.IMPORTANT PLEASE NOTE:Within five working days of sending your further submission to Council, youMUST send a copy of that further submission to the person who made theoriginal submission on which you are commenting. Further submissionsmust be received at a Council Office by 5.00PM ON THURSDAY 1SEPTEMBER 2011.

2. Notice of HearingIf you have made a submission (or a further submission) you have the right to beheard or to be represented at a hearing on the Proposed Plan change 9 - MinorDistrict Plan Map Amendments, as long as you have stated on yoursubmission that you wish to be heard.You will be informed in writing of the date, time and place at which your submissionwill be heard at least 10 working days before the hearing.3. Notification of DecisionsCouncil will notify decisions to the submitters and a copy of the decision will be sentto all submitters.4. AppealsIf a submitter disagrees with the Council’s decision, they may appeal to theEnvironment Court to review the decision. The Court will hear the appeals and mayagree or disagree with the Council’s decision. It may direct the Council to amendthe Plan if it supports the appeal.5. Plan Change ApprovalWhen all submissions and appeals have been resolved, Proposed Plan Change 9 –Minor District Plan Map Amendments is approved by Council. It is publiclyadvertised as being approved.If you have any queries or would like further information about the Far NorthDistrict Plan please contact Council on 0800 920 029

Section 2List of Submitters# Submitter Address1 Gozewina (Connie) van P.O Box 731, Kerikeri 0245Bruchem2 Peter McQuinn 1376 Pipiwai Road, RD6, Whangarei 01763 David Manning and Karen P.O Box 275, Kerikeri 0245Manning4 Robert John Almond 8 Taylor Place, RD2, Golden Springs, Reporoa 30835 Russell Bruce Cox and JaneElizabeth HodgsonCable Bay Store, 384 State Highway 10, Cable Bay,Mangonui 04206 Justin May and Rhonda May 1766A Wainui Road, Te Ngaere Bay, RD1, Kaeo 04787 John Harrison Gibson 40 Whiting Grove, West Harbour, Auckland 06188 Donna Washbrook 59 Waiotemarama Gorge Road, Pakanae, RD3, Kaikohe04739 Robert Iehu Moetara 47 Waitemarama Road, Pakanae, RD3, Kaikohe 047310 John Kildare Upperton PO Box 272, Kaikohe 044011 Leonard Dissanayake 9 Campbell Lane, Kerikeri 023012 John Bayly and JocelynBaylyC/- Bay of islands Planning Limited, PO Box 795,Kerikeri 024513 Far North Holdings Limited C/- Bay of islands Planning Limited, PO Box 795,Kerikeri 024514 Samuel Davis on behalf of 611 Karetu Road, Karetu, Kawakawa 0283Karetu Marae, Te Hapu ONgati Manu15 John Goulter and Elaine 66 School Road, Paihia, Bay of Islands 0247Goulter16 Robert Willoughby 23 Pomare Road, Russell, Bay of Islands 020217 David Peter King PO Box 3, Kohukohu 045318 John Wigglesworth PO Box 7, Kohukohu 045319 Director-General ofConservation (Department ofConservator Northland, Department of Conservation,PO Box 842, Whangarei 0140Conservation)20 Adam Turner 128 Rakautapu Road, Kohukohu 045321 Lois Elliott Russell Ratepayers and Citizens Association Inc, POBox 57, Russell 020222 Albert Burgoyne PO Box 274, Mangonui 044223 Simon Peter Creighton PO Box 689, Kerikeri 0245

Section 3 – Summary of Decisions RequestedSubmitter Specific Provision Oppose / Decision RequestedSupport1/1Lot 4 DP 113937 Removal of Support Removal of the Outstanding Landscape.Gozewina van Bruchem Outstanding LandscapeOverlay2/1Proposed Plan Change 9 Support Not Stated.Peter McQuinn3/1David Manning andKaren Manning3/2David Manning andKaren Manning3/3David Manning andKaren Manning4/1Robert John Almond4/2Robert John Almond5/1Russell Bruce Cox andElizabeth Jane Hodgson6/1Justin May and RhondaMay6/2Justin May and RhondaMay6/3Justin May and RhondaMay7/1John Harrison Gibson7/2John Harrison Gibson7/3John Harrison GibsonMap 17 – Lot 9 DP 61577(Removal of OutstandingLandscape Overlay)Support inPartRemoval of the Outstanding Landscape.Map 17 – Lot 2 DP 48077 Submitter queries a refund for the fees for the Resource Consent required asa result of the Outstanding Landscape Overlay.Map 17 – Lot 2 DP 48077Support inPartThat the removal of the Outstanding Landscape overlay does not include therecreation reserve.Lot 7 DP 26373 – Awanui Support The rezoning of Lot 7 DP 26373 from Conservation to Commercial.87 State Highway 1 Support 87 State Highway 1, Awanui be included in the plan change (Lot 1 DP 91522)to rezone from Rural Living to Residential.(Submitter requests the inclusion of a site not in the Plan Change)Map 15/61 – Lot 2 DP 66078 Support The submitter supports the rezoning of Lot 2 DP 66078 from Residential toCommercial.Removal of OutstandingLandscape OverlayRemoval of OutstandingLandscape OverlayRemoval of OutstandingLandscape OverlayRemoval of OutstandingLandscape OverlayMap 17 – Lot 2 DP 48077(Recreation Reserve)Removal of OutstandingLandscape OverlaySupport inPartSupport inPartSupport inPartSupport inPartRemoval of the Outstanding Landscape Overlay from properties zonedCoastal Residential.Do not support the removal of the overlay from the Te Ngaere Bay reserveand esplanade.Submitter queries a refund for the fees for the Resource Consent required asa result of the Outstanding Landscape Overlay.Remove the Outstanding Landscape zone from Residential properties at TeNgaere Bay.Require the overlay on Coastal Residential to remain on the Te Ngaere BayReserve.Submitter queries a refund for the fees for the Resource Consent required asa result of the Outstanding Landscape Overlay.

Submitter Specific Provision Oppose / Decision RequestedSupport8/1Donna WashbrookMaps 44, 107, 111 Oppose That the requesting party be amended to the correct entity (MS11-04, MA11-11, MS11-28 and MA11-36 – Sites of Cultural Significance to Maori inAppendix 1F).8/2Maps 44, 107, 111 Oppose That a review of the District plan be made.Donna Washbrook8/3Donna Washbrook8/4Donna Washbrook8/5Donna Washbrook8/6Donna Washbrook9/1Robert Iehu Moetara9/2Robert Iehu Moetara9/3Robert Iehu Moetara9/4Robert Iehu Moetara9/5Robert Iehu Moetara9/6Robert Iehu Moetara(Submitter has not identified specifics)Maps 44, 107, 111 Oppose That until the Environmental Plan has been amended that it be the propertyof Rate Payers held under Pakanae Resource Management Committeebecause of their money being used to put together the plan (MS11-04, MA11-11, MS11-28 and MA11-36 – Sites of Cultural Significance to Maori inAppendix 1F).Map 44 DP 400762 Oppose Consultation be undertaken regarding the Wahi Tapu site (MA11-36) and ifnecessary be removed.Map 39/107 Lot 23 DP 116161 Oppose Consultation be undertaken with those of ahi kaa/Tangata Kaitiangi.Cabbage TreeMap 111 Omapere DP 404030 Oppose Consultation be undertaken with those that hold ahi kaa/Tangata Kaitiaki.Te Pure Waahi Tapu MS11-01Map 44, Kauwhare Pt HokiangaMA11-04 Map 36, Kaikai BeachTe Pure Waahi Tapu MS11-01Map 44Te Pure Waahi Tapu MS11-01Map 44, Kauwhare Pt HokiangaMA11-04 Map 36, Kaikai BeachTe Pure Waahi Tapu MS11-01Map 44Mahena Island MS11-05 Map39, Koutu MS11-06 Map 36,Pakanae MS11-07 Map 39.Mahena Island MS11-05 Map39, Koutu MS11-06 Map 36,Pakanae MS11-07 Map 39.Opononi MS11-08 Map 39-44,Opononi MS11-09 Map 44,Opononi-Omapere MA11-10Map 39-44.Opononi MS11-08 Map 39-44,Opononi MS11-09 Map 44,Opononi-Omapere MA11-10Map 39-44.OpposeOpposeOpposeOpposeOpposeOpposeThat Pakanae Resource Committee name be removed from this District Plan.(It is assumed that the submitter is referring to sites listed)That all significant sites be removed until a recognised person with the rightcredentials for doing this work takes the right GPS readings, is qualified, andCouncil sits down with the people who are directly involved in thesubmissions, submitters who do hold Ahi-Ka-Whenua Ngati Korokoro Hapu.That Pakanae Resource Committee name be removed from this District Plan.(It is assumed that the submitter is referring to sites listed)That all significant sites be removed until a recognised person with the rightcredentials for doing this work takes the right GPS readings, is qualified, andCouncil sits down with the people who are directly involved in thesubmissions, submitters who do hold Ahi-Ka-Whenua Ngati Korokoro Hapu.That Pakanae Resource Committee name be removed from this District Plan.(It is assumed that the submitter is referring to sites listed)That all significant sites be removed until a recognised person with the rightcredentials for doing this work takes the right GPS readings, is qualified, andCouncil sits down with the people who are directly involved in thesubmissions, submitters who do hold Ahi-Ka-Whenua Ngati Korokoro Hapu.

Submitter Specific Provision Oppose /Support18/2The Waterline Café at 1389 Support inJohn Wigglesworth Kohukohu RoadPart19/1Director-General ofConservation(Department ofConservation)19/2Director-General ofConservation(Department ofConservation)20/1Adam Turner20/2Adam Turner21/1Lois Elliott22/1Albert Burgoyne22/2Albert Burgoyne22/3Albert Burgoyne22/4Albert Burgoyne22/5Albert Burgoyne22/6Albert Burgoyne22/7Albert Burgoyne5681 State Highway 1, NorthAupouri. Legal Description Lot 1DP 190746 (Zone Map 6)205 Kerikeri Road, Kerikeri.Legal Description Lot 3 DP319869 (Zone Map 83)Hokianga Herald Office at 1368Kohukohu RoadThe Waterline Café at 1389Kohukohu RoadReserve Block identified onLongbeach Road, Russell(MS10-49)Map 6 – Land under claimWaitangi Tribunal Claim 292Support inPartSupport inPartOpposeDecision RequestedThe proposal should be amended to include the rezoning of this propertyfrom Coastal Residential to Commercial (1389 Kohukohu Road).(Submitter requests the inclusion of a site not in the Plan Change)To retain Lot 1 DP 190746 as Rural Production.To rezone Lot 3 DP 319869 as Coastal Living.(Submitter requests the inclusion of a site not in the Plan Change)Amendment to Plan Change 9 to list this property (Hokianga Herald Office at1368 Kohukohu Road) and change of zoning from 'Coastal Residential' to'Commercial'.(Submitter requests the inclusion of a site not in the Plan Change)Amendment to Plan Change 9 to list this property (The Waterline Café at1389 Kohukohu Road) and change of zoning from 'Coastal Residential' to'Commercial'.(Submitter requests the inclusion of a site not in the Plan Change)Amend the anomalies/inconsistencies with the Reserve Block identified onLongbeach Road, Russell (map HP4) and delete "(Marae purposes)".Lot 1 DP 190749-190746 is Maori Land to be left Rural Production.Map 6 – Lot 2 DP 190746 Oppose Lot 2 DP 190746 Northern Aupouri to be left Rural Production.Lot 2 State Highway 1 NorthernAupouriOppose Northern Aupouri Lot 3 DP 190746 – Object to change Maori land toconservation – to be left Rural.Northern Aupouri Oppose TC17 and ME66 left as Maori Land. High School Maori land - oppose anychange to current zone.Property at Cable BayOppose Property at Cable Bay inconsistency be addressed – Under claim.inconsistency1297 State Highway 1 Oppose Section 10 SO 365322 Map 13 – left Rural zone.Map 15, 60, 61 and HP5 These areas are under claim – Waitangi Tribunal Claim #2/77. Department ofConservation never owned land, land on the coast.(Submitter to provide details regarding specific sites).

Summary of Decisions Requested – Late SubmissionsSubmitter Specific Provision Oppose /Support23/1Lot 1 DP 168752 and Lot 1DPPeter Creighton 30626Decision Requested9 and 11 Routley Ave (Lot 1 DP 168752 and Lot 1DP 30626) be no longerzoned Conservation and returned to a Residential zoning.