Classical Islamic Paradigms of Deterrence and their Expression in ...

In the mind of radicalized perceivers, "divine reward" can be replaced with "divine punishment." Thisdisturbs, unsettles and raises questions among jihadis. Most importantly, it has the potential to deter thempsychologically.Understanding jihadi group culture, its psychic triggers and propaganda processes opens possible venues toapply such a concept. If the process of terrorist "belief" (i.e. here jihadi ideology) can be disrupted, thewhole construct of jihad loses validity. The vastness of the concept "jihad" in Islam must not beunderestimated. One only has to think about Sufi mystic and Sunni approaches. The Persian Sufi mysticMuhammad al-Ghazali (1058-1111), until today one of the most influential religious thinkers of Islam,wrote on jihad al-nafs (fighting one’s ego): "The strong one is not the one who overcomes people, thestrong one is he who overcomes his ego (ghalaba nafsahu)." 138 salafi-jihadis are essentially open to mysticconcepts. They use them constantly in the marketing of martyrs and in the construction of ideology (forexample, "karamat" (wonders), "'alamat al-shuhada' (signs of the martyrs such as smiles on their faces, thesmell of musk, the "invulnerability of jihadis").Islamic movements which foster non-violent interpretations of jihad should be supported. This might havefrightening effects on terrorists: They have been ordered to blow themselves up, but already doubt thatthey will gain a divine reward from it, because of theological interpretations that deny this reward. Onegoal is to create a "jihad"-discourse [sic] that rejects violence. A devaluation of terrorist jihad should first ofall focus on controversial justifications to kill civilians, and then on constructions of jihad in war scenarios(Iraq, Afghanistan, Israel/Palestine, Chechnya, Libya).In parallel and according to point 3.b, a massive media-based re-branding of Islam is required. Key message:"Islam and Muslims are welcome, good and excellent partners." The ideal case would be to convince animmensely popular Muslim preacher, such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi, to deconstruct jihadi salvation myths. Butone can also start on a more basic level. Western media-depictions of "moderate political Islam" and"moderate Muslims" should be loaded up with positive representations and connotations. This might helpto influence Muslims to support policies against terrorist Islam. Muslims would eventually overtake thiswork and devaluate terrorist interpretations by themselves. However, catastrophic military policies andpublic relations failures should be avoided at all costs such as further occupations of Muslim countries, orprison and torture scandals (Abu Ghuraib 2004), or U.S.-Marines urinating on dead Afghan Muslims(January 2012). Similarly, the publication of anti-Muslim ads such as upcoming advertisements in NewYork’s subway stations should be avoided. One of the ads in the campaign that has been initiated by U.S.anti-Islam activist Pamela Geller reads: "In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support thecivilized man. Support Israel. Defeat jihad." 139 The statement contains an implicit syllogism, which - in themind of a Muslim perceiver - compares Islam to savagery. It is counter-productive for "deterrenceconciliation"approaches that should address jihadis and mainstream Muslims in parallel.138Muhammad al-Ghazali, "'Ihya' `Ulum al-Din'" ["The Revival of the Religious Sciences"], (Accessed January 8, 2012) -http://sunnah.org/tasawwuf/jihad002.html139 Paul Harris, "Civil rights group condemn anti-Muslim New York subway ads," The Guardian, September 20, 2012,http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/sep/20/new-york-anti-muslim-subway-ads. Accessed September 24, 2012.43